Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 35 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good [Music] morning I don't hear from this side over here I hear a lot of talking I'm going to have to do it again no okay this is a beautiful thing a very very dear friend of mine who've been convincing to do the DA for a good few years sends me this picture he says okay he's ready to do the da send me a gamar say I send a gamar mayor my still in Florida and here he is in a lounge doing it his mom is stagging away a lot of pictures today on Planes Trains people are traveling D sent me this picture of his father on a bus to a lot what's the big father never did years old I know but he started what he started like four or five years ago yeah but then he dropped off 80 years old and he just started doing the da basically he's relatively new to the D yeah life I want to again it was the night before we started H wow the night before we started s HED whoever didn't he it was uh his 80th birthday says I feel like I'm missing something I want to start the da again and he restarted and here he is going strong wa lot the famous schom Rand has a very popular status and I say that all the statuses put together all what he accomplished unless he accomplished for and for doesn't not even a 1% to what this one status I haven't opened up a gar in pretty much 20 years this is on sh ran status even in my Yesa days I barely learned except for a couple of years I never thought I'd learn again after watching a rebellion on your status Shalom Rand on your status over the last year and a half I guess it seeped in like long advertising that it may not be terrible so sometimes it doesn't work on the first shot you try again you try again for some reason I can't fully explain I started the die from beginning of San hedin now that I'm in a month in I can say I started for the first time in my life I went a month straight of learning all because of your status shom did we show this yesterday this guy learning in [Music] Mexico did we show this Yi [Music] wasman how about this one I used to watch a sheer for a while and I enjoyed it this past Thursday I was on a fly from Newark to Fort Lauderdale and I saw something I had to another wonderful yid who was learning the D while watching yesir I didn't get his name but I did get a picture of him for the she keep spreading to to all our brothers what do you do hello I'm taking picture it's not posed at all right he's learning the da gal is on the way to Fort Lauderdale they're on the way to Miami now Yesa weekid sh Corman good morning RAB Bo said listen to this all the way from Melbourne Australia my father y Corman learning the D after work sitting next to him is my 2-year-old son yane [Music] Corman from his grateful family started learning that at age 70 and for 32 years until he was for the unity of the Jewish people Glen esterson with love and gratitude from Wilmington North Carolina shim on Zoom how's doing how many people are in Zoom today it's like I think it's made up because it's the same it's every day it's the same number that's usually 70 okay uh so again thank you surge Gman and family memory of my father Blackbird recruiting with like to wish David wanu wanu wuu wanu a belated happy birthday happy birthday of the month forell and the staff to to make T So enjoyable for so many and in honor of Kazi for all the work that they do we're holding 12 lines from the bottom of question for the to think about we learned that you cannot started inra for neas for capital punishment on a Friday because you can't kill the guy on sh we'll get into [Music] it could you started doesn't say in the Mish but could you start a for on chabas it's learning it's uh it's necessary to get rid of this could you start on not it's but it's a Mitzvah feels like no feels like no why no you can't just say no it's not a yes or no you have to know what you're saying no no no it's aah to do this it's not it is no right not say there you might carry the guy the dead guy so the answer is car that's the that's the reason no it's the same it's the same idea you're going to come to do something which is us to do okay we're not going to win the problem is you're not allowed to write that is the problem says you have to write down the positions you're not allowed to write but if you're allowed to write if you if you don't have to write the tell you allowed to do it if you don't have to write are you allowed to do it so so you're saying something else say something it's the writing it's not the the it's the writing part says the gar yesterday we learned compares the the azden that gathers for M for monetary things he learns out from teras that what they cannot do a at night you have to do the during the day so yeah 12 lines from the bottom it says in the it has to be during the day but what do it why does he need this POS we learn it from refering to during the daytime you you give the you don't give night so the simple meaning is hard to understand so only somebody that dies during the day he could give a his kids and whoever dies at night says give during the day not during the night so if the guy dies at night it's all over it's hard to understand the other day I saw somebody sent a a thing that in New York since the tolls on these Bridges I don't know $18 $25 who knows what they are today I haven't been there a while like the Lincoln Tunnel so people line up on the side by by Lincoln Tunnel you know like waiting to go to the airport so they line up on the side cuz when the clock you know when it turns like 7 8:00 at night then the the price drops they want people to travel at night so when you get to the bridge 5 minutes before the time what are you going to pay the so you wait on the side over there no I was just thinking M you have to like wait you tell the guy the guy's about to die it's still night time wait wait a half hour you start CPR a little bit you know you get the guy to go a little you have to wait according to this it's it's it's between $10 million and zero either you get TOA you don't get to yusha they uh they did a study that 1999 is the year that the least people died there a lot of old people were like waiting they were waiting for the the Millennium for 2000 they wanted to make it to 2000 you have something to look for also there's another study I saw no ta ah yusha laws but you see people could if you're waiting for something important if you have nothing to wait for a lot of people they retire they find that they don't C the next ah no it's a doesn't it's ker yeah the bottom line is if you wait for something positive that's why they also they did a study who's they I'll tell you a second when you hear the study you'll know exactly who it is that the good of America did a study that anybody that learns lives longer you're always waiting for the next you're waiting for the next you're doing something important this called The Royal next this is approved by everybody says so an interesting Lo here maybe what you mean to say is that if a person writes during the day you don't have to worry about anything you don't have to go to bz it's perfect during the day if you write a at night that's what the is saying that if you wrote the during the day you don't need a b at night you do need a [Music] b so this is a talking is trying to explain him says [Music] the it's a in other words it's it's it's it's a finished product it's done a three people come in to to visit a sick person they have the ability to either be and a all a DI will make a on the spot and say okay ruin gets half of this and shim gets the department in Miami blah blah blah or they could be aen aen they're more than aen but you know TR they could act as aen what do Witnesses do they they write down what they heard they heard the guy say XYZ but it's not a d it's not it's not final a guy Ora goes to visit a very wealthy Miser guy never gave a dime in his life to to any M or anything knocks on his door comes to visit him so the guy says what are you doing here you know I don't give money toas he says no I came to be look at me he says no any Miser is a it's a type of a disease it's a money disease there are people that have diseases when it comes to money they can't they can't give her anything they give her di I'm this okay good you could leave he says yeah but it says whoever takes 160th of the disease for if it's only two people that came to visit they they're they can't act as as a bz because B is at least three so they have to write down what they heard and they cannot do a three he did like this here two are just a and these are at night oh at night what's oh they're only I think they're supposed to be they do have they do have oh here yeah at night they're only they cannot be says is that what you meant to say this is what you meant that a at night you come to visit a guy that that's that's sick that he's a he's a aid and not a dying that's exactly what I meant to say when it comes to killing somebody capital punishment you could only do during the day there's no night time we know when did they did it's a terrible it's relieving oneself in front of so they die it says in the you should hang them how do you know that the word means to hang so that's is going to prove from the next but it says when it's sunny outside in other words it's daytime capital punishment is by day rash says over there very interesting thing I like to say the interesting stuff says how did how did know who who did who didn't cover opened up miraculously and the sun shined in cuz it was a cover it was a protection from the Sun from everything from all elements it shined in it like a like a flashlight a night on the people that that did that you were able to see if you had a thing of son on your head he's over Spotlight how do you know that the word means to hang what happened over there was we know the famous story of killed out all the of and the who lived right there they were the ones who lied and said that they were from they came from a far away but it turns out they weren't then they made them water carriers and Wood Choppers but now they they were out of work so sha destroyed their perasa they were starving so now they're very upset at sha so they come to and say we want a little Revenge sweet revenge give us some of sha Sha's descendants so and he agreed to give him some kiss and it says they wanted to they wanted to to hang them woman she sat there next to the bodies for six months she made sure that the the animals the birds they don't touch the bodies and D heard about this and then D married her it says that they were hung says the it happens to be that Raji brings what andang but typically speaking Yeah typically speaking not not regular so typically speaking when you hang someone you have to you don't let the body stay overnight so rash says over here very interesting so he says problem of you're not allow to let the the body hang overnight how do these bodies hang for six months so he says it's better to not listen to that and this should be in public these are the kids of what are they doing hang on the tree said they he took away the paros of and this is what happens when you when when you do something like that and that's for we could be something the you should you should kill all the heads of the the nation but that's the general public they're the ones that did why you killing the heads you have to divide the POS into two it's that first you have to divide the r you have to divide make up many don't use one Bon to try everybody's case why perhaps you'll say you're not allow to kill two people in one day that's when they get two different death penalties but when it to one death penalty one B can take care of two people so as how come the says you can't you can't judge them in one day so it says because over there we're talking about the daughter of a and she actually has a different than the so now it's understood when there's two different types of Mis then it's two different days but if all these people a thousand people did one than so if it's one B than that's it why why divide them up into many many the the P I thought it's I was I sometimes I laugh out loud when I read the P says why not why not why not he says because it's a mitvah to kill somebody that deserves you shouldn't and then I'm thinking to myself wow it's it's a nce like some of these organizations that do thear they didn't take on they didn't take the S it's another Mitzvah a very rear Mitzvah to kill a murderer and now they're going to start selling like you know Parts in that Mitzvah huh don't take don't make any okay incredible check out this rashash is going to Cal down how it's unbelievable rash when hem sees that people care about him we're not just one b and will take care of the business every the whole CL is busy with this there's a bz on this street there's a bz in this in the basement over here everybody is trying to restore hashem's honor that's when hasem comes down and we could learn for for usse as well when people go out and recruit people for the shear loves it even though if you're not you know I'm serious I just thought about last night during she Mark ashkanazi tried and tried never got a single guy to join the sh when he came to he got two Israelis you gotta keep on trying gotta keep on [Music] trying how many seven Israelis ah seven Israeli soldiers Gary how many did you get the kid that came I here Ash got three didn't m so continues you cannot you cannot be of him that day when it comes to monetary stuff you come in and out of BZ that same day you get a Potter whatever it is not when it comes to if it's po that day you have to wait a day so okay fine you heard a lot about uh bring people to seriously if a person is just to be in it I'm sure it gives a lot of there's so much sire going on so many people don't have so be in it at least make a phone call show that's the idea to show that you care over here is learn there's two ways to learn this y by y y means to sleep it overnight by y you come toed you have to sleep on it you have to have one night go home and then come back to B the next day but now you're killing why cuz you're not waiting overnight you're doing it too fast like in the Arab death penalty they here for five minutes yeah boom [Music] dead what does that mean like praiseworthy it's to delay to to you wait 18 minutes and it becomes praiseworthy is a d who delays the takes some time he doesn't just say that day the next day he waits it overnight you should give praise to the one to the victim and not to the the one that caused the problem what does that mean so Rashi says beautiful do you know this brings this I personally didn't remember it even though we just learned it you go to somebody say you owe me $1,000 what's the first thing the guy says he doesn't Deni he says yeah I owe you $1,000 but you know what you also owe me because you broke my car this this uh you took a Mas you have my mashin right you destroyed my mashin says the to you admit that there's a a loan pay the loan pay the loan then come and claim your claim on the don't do oh this equals that and we're we're even if you admit that you owe money pay ah you say that he broke your masin okay come to the we we'll talk about it afterwards first pay up no first pay up you could use it in a lot of different you agree so first pay now we'll talk about the second thing second this doesn't want to pay I'll tell you why I have a great excuse because I gave you my watch and now the watch is not the same it got ruined got lost First We Take Care we worry about the not whatever the is First We Take Care of the the victim the one that that that's owed money first he has money in his hand afterwards great it says in the go first will deal with the victim and then afterwards the whatever you want to call him he already has a so what does he do with the ofed that we said if you if you sleep it over you sleep you sleep on it you get a lot of people learned this right it's the first five a lot of people got there says that the I forgot the something like that that the the main part of aus is the you give it's not the fasting that you do it's the that you give so especially in the time of the a that at the end of the ESS they give a lot of they give so imagine a person is in the time of the has nothing to eat zero he's just fasted a whole day with his an but he's looking forward to after right after my he's going to get nice amount of food and he's going to fill up his stomach and even that doesn't come so he goes home hungry what does he do so you killed him you P killed him first he made him fast the whole day and then you didn't even give him food that's what the p is saying that what call Call you don't pay you don't give you that you you you let him sleep without meaning without the you killed him says that's only if you're going to give him readymade food like a date like a piece of bread if anyway you're going to give him money and then he has to go to the store which the store is closed you're going to give him some weed then he has to grind it and do all the the production of the bread that we're not talking about that so obviously this guy already has a meal ready to go for mulus you're not killing him so you gave him something they has to work on okay so do tomorrow sorry less that's not a big deal so you waited until the next morning you're not you're not a killer for that says so therefore says you don't do it on my we said this already in the mishna and here it is in the how you going to do it Friday if you're going to try to try him on a Friday and finish up the case on Friday that's great if you found him not guilty but what if you found him guilty and we know they have to sleep on it okay so sleep on it so if you slept on it and now you started on Friday you cannot kill an individual on chabas even though it's a Mitzvah that Mitzvah doesn't push off chabas so because of what we're saying here that so now the is going to give us a beautiful a couple of beautiful because of that because we have this what does mean to kill him in doesn't mean to kill means that we are killing him interesting I just realized somebody sent me a whole not a hole but a little email maybe they didn't like the the word I was using in she the difference between murder and killing so it seems like the gamar is saying different than him it's murder we are killing him saying killing means this means that the murderer and killing one is on purpose one is okay whatever it is putting to that but over here is is calling the the okay we're not going to get into that that differentiation but what's a problem started in on Friday and then sleep on it on Friday night and then you don't kill him on chabas because it's andabas bring to bed kill himas see have everything on it has to be during the daytime and you cannot kill him on at night at what's the problem judge him on Friday do the on CH the over here doesn't say it's a problem to do it on chabas it's not over you allow to continue doing the and they'll kill him on Sunday that's a problem the guy is waiting to get off the hook and now that he gets the now he's waiting to die I I still I forgot to look into it it bothers me like we say that if a guy is on machines you shouldn't take him off the the machines because every minute he lives is is who knows what and the amount the person could accomplish in one minute and you're if you take off the machine and over here we're trying to get rid of his life as quickly as possible so he shouldn't be B everybody that's dying a lot of cancer patients you know at the last stages of Life they're dying they know they're going to die but they want to live another day they want to spend another minute with their family I don't know okay but over here it says it's man it's full torture what he's guilty no no if he's guilty only if he's if he's not guilty it's fine if he's guilty now we have to wait a whole day to kill him you have to wait you can't kill him on you don't know it's going either way you're delaying it either you don't do the din on Friday you do it on Sunday then you start on Friday don't know no if a guy if you don't know the guy question is we don't start on Friday because we might to kill right no but after everything till Sunday anyway don't start the process the process you start the process on Sunday you find out that he's that and you don't know you say he's guilty now you have to sleep on it Sun Monday morning you wake up you you you do again another you deliberate again everybody says guilty take him out right away and kill him that day he never has to wait a night but if you find out on shabas if you find out on chabas that he's guilty now you have to wait until Sunday to kill him you can't kill him on Chavis so now he has a whole night to think about it and he's going to be he's going to torture himself to death say oh so now says say listen to this so start off the process on Friday and and and and do the G on Sunday why can't we start it inra on Friday what's the problem started inra on Friday you don't tell him if he's you don't tell him if he's guilty or not guilty so he's not suffering and then on Sunday morning you get together you skip shabas you skip shabas and Sunday morning he decide guilty not guilty and kill him on Sunday why can't we start the process on Friday people are going to forget the reasoning they had behind it but we said that the two writers two guys what do you call them stenographers are sitting on the right the left and they write down what people say what did say so how are they going to forget the're writing their words that come out of their mouth two different words the heart of a man he forgets in means to forget in other words he might have spluttered it out something oh he's because a he didn't explain himself he didn't say what what his reason is the the logic behind it there's a lot going on in man's brain and that he's going to forget because somebody's going to say what do you mean it's this oh I forgot I went through it like the famous story guy comes to later on in his years he says I have a question on the says I don't understand it so said you know it's a good question but I'll tell you what when I was doing the m and he worked in it for 22 years when I was r m I know that I that wasn't that wasn't a question for me I went through it at at that point today I don't know what the answer is but he could rely on what it says in the Miss people forget even after one day so says the gamar he that's why you should not started in on a [Music] Friday what no no overnight is fine a whole day a whole 24h hour period they forget plus is deliberations says so let me show you this I think Yoshi did a phenomenal job this was actually's idea the idea the concept and then we worked on it we what could be I don't remember yesterday one day goes by I forget so thear says like this the that's a shabas candle and that's aen if the Cen and chabas have have a arm wrestle the is going to win the beats chavas in other words we talk about it if he's if it's a question we bring a carbon on Chavis right what Caron do we bring in shavas that so that means a beats shavas a is stronger than chavas what else do we have a dead man is stronger than chavas now we had a sh me and Yoshi like a dead man doesn't have any muscle how could he win so with rubber bands he could attach a muscle it's not a problem he attached some did some okay but a Mitzvah pushes off shavas a mitz pushes off a t he sure is tummy that's the whole thing Mitzvah pushes off a the wining there yeah yeah don't get into that it's hard to manipulate shabas pushes off killing that that's what we just said killing somebody in chabas that's our Su that's why we talk about it you don't kill this guy I don't know why a yeah yeah whatever the shabish pushes off misz so shabas wins in this case over here misz pushes off he wins what else do we have M say bz pushes off chabas okay you get the idea now check this out here it goes let's just take these two things wow hold on oh this didn't update H okay let me just see yeah yeah it did okay awesome check this out it's very very simple everybody can come to the same conclusion by themselves here if you have one and two we'll understand what three is if a a beats Shas andv so certainly Mitzvah beat what Shas if is stronger than chabas is stronger than so certainly is stronger than chabas very nice and here we goz should beas that's the that's the whole thing that's and we can finish it until we turn the page I want to come out to the conclusion three that beats that what that if you find a dead man in middle of nowhere and nobody's there to bury him you could push off shabas you could take a shov dig be over all the of and bury [Music] him number one pushes off shabas how do I know pushes off shabas because it says in the we say we bring on shabas I have to say the ver I say it every so often it's one of the best vers from Charlie Harari one of our first speeches of mdy like when we did uh theab we had 500 locations something M was unbelievable and Charlie said this V very famous V is a galart to repeat it every so often that brings a m that no no one actually located the M he says that there's three that had a argument if you have to encapsu the entire one what would it be so one says other one says first comes and the other T says that and the question is what's the connection and that is the site of and now actually in the last half a year or so it even came for me clear and clear how why this is such a big the creat creation of a habit of a hero of every single day day in day out learning T not stopping for a moment that is and that's the the of carbon of bringing a carbon every single day of the year no matter what you shabas and every single day and that elevates a person to another M so anyways we see that a carb which is pushes off so that's step one pushes off nowah pushes off the working if there's only one in the world left and he's in the and there's a m Mitzvah he has to bury the ma and he has to become T so certainly then Mitzvah shabas CU if mitzvah certain that's the whole thing but we're just going to go on a tangent a little bit to explain this line over here so here here's the it's referring to was the only I would know that azer who says I'm going to abstain from wine and anything to do with wine and he's going to grow his here and he's not going to become Tom he's not become Tom to anyone so why does the following P say and even to his father and his mother and his brother and his sister these are all extra words and rash brings us what each word comes to say we're going to focus on the word what do come to tell you the man was walking now so says Rashi we're talking about even even the most severe case called a who happens to be azer and he's walking and he happens upon a dead person but he's walking to bring a to and to do to do another and he heard that somebody let's say his own sister died perhaps he should become no way no maybe he should not even bury the only to sister okay just quick story about the also a classic but it explains what M Mitzvah is there was a man in be that was having interesting dreams he wasn't religious and he told his wife that his father keeps on appearing in his dream says become and his wife told him he's crazy he's dreaming you know and uh he had enough at one point and he went to the r of B and the r of B wrote a safer and he writes this the story in a safer go to this years ago you're talking about 60 70 70 years ago goes to he says I have these dreams says the r b I have no idea I have no clue what a dream I'm not a dream kind of guy but there is a person in his name is the Kish he he's known he could deal with's dreams go to him so he goes to the Kish and the Kish looks at this guy and the K says before the guy opens his mouth he says you're the guy that that your father keeps on coming in dreams he says yes so K said tell me how do you why do you think you're such a thing he said because I once did this and I gave somebody and I helped that guy says no no no no I need a something juicier finally he says when he was like 12 years old the Nazis killed a bunch of people in town and his father said take their bodies and bury them and he he said he was disgusted dead people and it was heavy and they had to go through some places where he could have got caught and killed he was and he buried the says oh that now it makes sense and then the story of course he becamea n months later whatever [Music] so so we know that shabas gets pushed off to bring the carbon certainly step three certainly push off shabas if pushes off Shas P certainly Shas says the no not a good that you don't do on chabas but yet I have a case there's no proof If something pushes off why because pushes off what happened a is about to perform a he didn't start yet says rash because if he started we don't stop him but he's about to perform the and he's the last alive and last we pluck him out of the and we judge him on on on on whatever he did for or whatever it P we just established an you don't kill a guy onas but yet that same thing push says but maybe I should kill somebody we just he's a murderer and the B came to the conclusion kill him on why not what's the so let's do this inside here we go very simple sorry if pushes off shabas you bring a carbon on shabas out you say no you don't do the bring him to the court so certainly which is stronger than sayz should break chabas you should kill him on chabas you should even though he's the only Co in the the world take him off to die you go judge him and that you bring a carb and all the other you bring on chabas certainly should push off you're right but I have a the T says here let's do this real quickly what does it say in the we say this in we say this you're not allowed to do any any of the so then why does the say they you not to make a fire on chabas oh let me show you this video first we'll try it first and then here we go mro what are you doing today is shabas lighting a fire on chabas is cus Scala dad I remember something from what I learned in hea don't try to fool me lighting a fire on shabas may be forbidden but there's no cus or Scala first of all that is only according to rosi but according to reasen it is like all shis prohibitions second of all any OFA is very serious you never know what will happen if you violate a Prohibition from the Torah what could possibly happen oh no [Music] all right why does the talk D about doesn't talk about any other other um doesn't talk about all these other talks don't make a fire in it's unbelievable you're not over you don't get a you don't they don't bring you to b and a guy drives a car if it's of of you don't you don't doesn't get he gets malus that's why I said all these in a car wouldn't get what by the way I think I'm throwing this out it is the it's but if a person had to be should drive an electric car I'm just throwing this out there there's not even any fire I'm just huh Alexis no Alexis you know even during the week not say you can that's what I'm saying it Tesla self Drive yeah that's why people get self Drive these days a guy told me he came to the shear here and he said he's going to send me an email he says every single day he commutes with his Tesla he has a long drive and self driving he says he watches the shear 100% on the screen you just you just have to touch the sering whe he doesn't look at the road nothing he's watching the she focused on the share what no but it's a Tesla self drive it's very trust me ask no if you were ever I was in Los Angeles this car is self not they drive around no less accidents Than People trust me not all people the certain people if I was the Pres United States I was sign into maybe I should watch what I'm about to say sign certain people for certain classes they could get a license but they can only drive in self-driving cars especially in Reverse no you would think that if a person does all he opens Up's and he starts going through okay let me let me do let me do let me be over all how many how many or how many let's he doesn't know let's he was in Hawaii like my daughter she didn't she didn't at then your shabas you don't know what day shabas is in Hawaii is it Sunday so you're confused and you do a bunch of how many you have to bring you didn't realize you thought a wise part of America so what happens so says each one how do I know from this because the brings it out it's different each one is an individual so you have to bring if you did all 39 39 if you he did 39 Times fire 39 fires in one chabas without knowing thatw then you only bring one unbeliev says this is great for you says what's the difference between why fire different than all why not if a guy reaps his fruit on chabas he should only be over on and not me so why fire say guess what the first shabas in the World there wasn't even fire there's only 38 malas fire only existed on so it's weaker than everything else says so still going with this I have a special why does the you shouldn't light a fire and Everywhere You live living has to do with only certain mitzvas where you live if you live in you have these MIT you live you have this shabas has nothing to do with the country you live in shabas is you yourself your own body is in everywhere if a person deserves to die maybe perhaps you should kill him even on chabas it says all the in the world Butz has the right to kill perhaps maybe you shouldn't kill on there is to kill somebody onas and when the Torah says go kill him it means six days out of the week not seven I don't know I'm confused maybe it means even on why because I have that we just brought so you should be able to kill no we have a special that says do not kill how do I know it says the word the same word so that's called when it's talking about M where do you do m in AZ so when it says is referring to where even in you don't have the right just because you're doesn't mean you're allow to end of the story so that's his Source where you see that you do not kill somebody onas now that you already established that we B doesn't kill somebody on chabas so says finally the last one here beats MZ we just established you don't kill somebody shabas and beat shabas you bring carbon you bring the carbas so therefore a which beats shabas and chabas which beat bz certainly should beat the so uh so therefore what if a who needs to perform the and we think he's guilty of murder you should let him stay there to perform the it says you should take him off to kill him no that's not an irregular that which is for the the carb that you leave him that's referring to when an individual has a carbon that he wants to bring on his own nothing to do with theor that and the wants to perform that VA and we think he's guilty of murder remove him from the have a wonderful day for