Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 34 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning yesterday we had a raffle for this end of a perck ironsky now five minutes after this raffle somebody here in this is a a membership to the zoo in the aquarium a full year for a full family and uh somebody 5 minutes later texted Benny that he has a uh computer store and he's donating a computer for the next per which is only a few days four or five days I think so that's the next one so very nice the is giving G shalom what's your name Aron Newman Aron Numa from Bal Baltimore special wow listen in the last week or two we had a few people from Baltimore I even had the uh SEL SEL he's from Baltimore he got you hooked he just sent me an email yesterday or something that he was in Singapore recruiting so my question is there so many people in Baltimore are doing this year how come you guys don't get together and makes a mat of [Music] we got to talk to fish you're going to go back and we're going to we got to get this off the ground once and for all well you look very familiar far no B you look familiar I'm not joking oh that's what it is okay you at the sh far what are you doing for ra stuff does the does stuff okay great um how excited was that when I received a friendly reminder from the city of New York that I'm a proud member of MD y Overland stand in isand new yorkis here it is a friendly reminder did I I didn't mention in the seum it's one magnet per family I on the website ah he bought it yeah he bought it on the website say check these Israeli kids out this is a guy he came to the se he says the whole family is is in complete they're in Rous and but these guys have a future doesn't have his choir anymore these guys are unbelievable they made their own [Music] they have a future they have a future oh here Steve I spent a wonderful shabas in the Philippines and spoke to people individually over shabas about MD this morning prior to D Shas uh 6 hours earlier oh about a minute of lighting candles during the bris and then there was a bris right there and there's not it's not very common to have a bris it's a very small community he showed the rabbi after daving about to to put the candles and he learned from the D and he promoted MD y like that Steve he doesn't stop promoting MD you changed my life says ABI Bernstein my name is AB from mon but I was born in Chicago I can't believe we're holding a DA L it's a dream come true that I thought would never happen one day at a time I work for and I'm fulltime drummer for weddings and one night during the box packing one of the volunteers Jerry Isaac from tin approached me and was telling me that San hedin starting a wig I must join the D shout out to Jerry I can't thank him enough you see this when you tell somebody about the D you convince them they can't thank you enough you have nothing to worry about they'll be indebted for life then I found out the markazi is involved a longtime close friend my is Mark askanazi how can Mark didn't get him okay then I was hooked done deal however busy my day in life The Da comes first it's only 35 days in and the Da comes first woke up early today bought a fight with my family to Orlando Yeshiva week I downloaded the da my son who lives in in Miami told me he's running away to Orlando for Yeshiva week next week and here they are they're going to Orlando I better War my son theys in Orlando also down he says just to get down you know cins it say 25 minutes download the die before I left and was the most enjoyable flight to Florida okay I need to email to end because he's in a basketball game and he's giving he's writing an email at a NBA game and his M saying what are you doing there's only a few minutes left to the game thank you so much for the Sher good energy the fact that a 55 years old there still hope to accomplish and learning 100% here he is ABI Bernstein here he is learning on the plane this is not a madeup email he's learning on the plane to Florida and the most enjoyable flight of his life learn with the Rebellion Mexico another person here with the cap thank look forward learning with you train to work from west hson to Brooklyn started learning with you in November 20 21 withus I haven't missed a day another email two emails like that today of people I haven't missed a day since Tinus in 2021 that's three years ago for week I'm imp Del K in Mexico made sure that I have internet access soone miss a day of learning the attach picture I'm learning D next kette jungle that day we embarked on all day walk and swim mayem Grant you strength to continue teaching the die for many years to come on M so that people can continue to be a positive influence on so many people so you can continue to be a positive influence so many people best regards Howard Apple West hson New York here he is doing the D in the jungle see watman attaches a picture of fellow mayor who's complet completely engrossed learning with the shear it's always great to find out about another mdy guy learning in the same B me as you keep on going mayor since I wanted to upon myself strength Rec actually Mouse is to the Past before sh that's why he's on your table for making of angels with and everything mayem Ben you and your team of angels H angel you're an angel he called you and everything you need to do New York from and have not missed a d that's 100 that's 200 D ago yeah 200 plus d wow 200 days straight is sponsored from his grateful family started learning 70 and for 32 years M for the unity of the Jewish people the MERS with love and gratitude from Wilmington in North Carolina thank you for enriching my life with our children and tremendous to all the guys on Zoom good morning or good night wherever you are there's still a lot of people in uh in America no it's like what time is it 12:1 I don't remember anymore 12 where is schz from from Manchester what time is it 12:15 in New York there's a couple people on is not the 125 the is that they're still on at one and thank you to love memory of a Roman David sponsored by his grandchildren sponsored by his grandchildren the for Bell and the whole MD staff to make t enjy so many in of the month in of Yi for all the work they do boy said just uh quick for releasing the hostages in every it's a great it's a great time for a lot of Yen out there with all the bad that comes with it we have to focus on the good it's a tremendous thing and there's a lot of very very happy families and friends and people should keep on releasing hostages and we should know no more we are holding the gim b six lines from the [Music] bottom yeah I I saw some new people but one was by the door now where is he you you're new what's your namey shonfeld okay you put you till this was perfect now I got yesu sheld who else do we have there was somebody else I saw sh you're not new I where did I just see you last year yeah really what's your name Mor Morty G sh I no I do remember I remember even the name bis I I didn't put the face in the name together not a joke there's somebody else I know there's some guy that walked in and was sitting by the door I don't no that's Taki Taki is here's here all year just leaves a few once in a while to America okay M the Miss tells us that when it comes to M to monetary dispute everybody could bring a riot for for the negative for the positive and then it we're we're really focusing now not on monetary we're focusing on on capital punishment anybody could come by and say I found the I could get this guy out of it but not for not everybody is entitled to have an opinion here when it comes to find the guy guilty says the mishna what means everyone and to include what you and I we're we're regular people so what's H call comes to include something special even the a who testify they can find a positive thing to pull the guy out of the shouldn't be is why it talks about a now we're talking about about killing somebody so the tanak says that the aid should not open his mouth even to find the the this murderer not not guilty so our go together that what that the aid this is the the one testifying G is just asking Dave if the camera is focused 100% doesn't look so focused to me I don't know is that a yes is that no you huh okay I might be off just maybe it's my l lenses so says no the aid the one testifying which is a big because he's biased if he finds something he he comes along says well listen I think this guy should get off the hook we listen to him not if he's trying to say something just say your testimony and leave don't don't try to find but say no our mishna is not referring to when the mishna says it's referring to and what do I gain by that says this doesn't have to be this could be anybody that AAL sitting there on the side a intern could bring proof to let him off the hook we did get his idea that a Aid could testify for when it comes to the when doesn't the a open his mouth when don't we listen to him when it comes to die only if it causes the the the individual the defendant to die then he can't speak but if it the opposite if it takes him out of his problem then we listen to say Aid can't say anything even he can't open his mouth for so what are they going to do with L not who the aid aid oh no no no no no this that's that's Papa that's that's Papa we're going back yeah we're going back good point who argue and they say you can never say anything we never listen to the aid so why does it say the word l so says that theot is what what's the what's the Rashi explains this what causes the adom to say the truth and keep straight and not not Dre a cup there something hanging over their head what is the there's one thing that threatens them if you come to Bez and saying that so and so killed somebody you better be saying the truth because we could find out that you were in a certain place we'll have witnesses that testify that at that point you were somewhere else and then they they'll kill you oh that's scary but what if a Aid has a way out the aid as he sees that the they're closing in on him he'll start looking for ways to get the the murder out of the murder charge so he's he's biased therefore we can't listen to anything that he has to say even because at the end of the day he's going to try to get out of his own death penalty by by coming up with with a positive thing and prove that the guy's not a murderer ver huh again that's why we don't listen to we never listen to this guy that it's Aid can never can never say he can never testify nothing zero cuz he's always biased but when the tah says the word and it's da for me we don't so who are we talking about over here we're talking about the tal the inter we don't listen to him to kill the defendant but we listen to him for so check this out he did a cool thing here the P has all these words in it the is going to do a very interesting thing here we learn two Li and each Li is going to use part of these words here first li is the first four his tape cannot say anything in any case because says Lam so we don't want to use that word Lamas because lamus is not good for us in this case lamus means only to cause his death no a Aid shuts his mouth for everything even to cause him to go free he's we said he's he's biased and then we use the next part of the P we we we dump the aid we don't listen we don't use the word Aid we just we read the brand new as if there's no posing before there certain people that cannot testify to cause this guy to die who that a Tal interesting way to learn the so that that we learn from the first four words witness can't testify anything how do you know that a intern cannot bring the negative to die but if he wants to testify yeah of course of course is we listen to so certainly yeah who says that he he does or you're saying okay so now we have a little bit of a su we discussed this in the mishna seems simple and here the talks about it what the mishna tells us if you just read the simple words in the mishna that when somebody comes to bezan one of the in bezan he's the the one he's on the team not guilty not guilty team so the Mish says he doesn't have the right to switch his his opinion he said not guilty it's not guilty stick with it but wait a minute he really believes now that he is guilty what do you mean stick with it so he said the is he has to stick with it all the way through the whole process all the deliberation and everything at the end when it comes to the to to the vote he's going to have to then he'll switch his his that's during the deliberation he cannot switch his opinion once you say not guilty you have to stick with it and you have to prove to everybody else that he's not guilty even though now you might have switched your own opinion to guilty once we're coming to to vote it's all the way at the end if a guy says he's not guilty and he he fights with all his friends he's trying to prove not guilty not guilty not and nobody listens to him at the end when it comes to the big vote they ask all the 23 day on him knew what he vote he's going to say guilty everybody look at him like he's crazy cuz he was fighting there just standing and fighting for the not guilty cause but he really is voting guilty but that's how it is the T says you have a we should try as hard as we can to find this guy not guilty now we found a good candidate here you started off saying not guilty so stick with it that's how far we're going to go with it you have to stick with it you can't be a Wishy Wash you can't say oh you start off guilty not guilty guilty no no once you say not guilty stick with it you're going to be have to be you're going have to be a defense lawyer defense lawyer all the way through but all the way to the end when the EMS comes when we say is he really not guilty no no no he really is guilty I know that he's guilty and I'm going to I'm going to vote for the guilty now the gar is going to ask a bunch of questions here in RAV is it true that that a dying who starts off because that's not the simple meaning in the Mish the mishna says that a d who says not guilty must stay with it all the way through all the way even through the that's your so let's see if it sticks this is next next peric in about six days the next morning they get up I'm sticking to my guns I said he's not guilty he's not guilty I say guilty I'm sticking myun and then the M says that the one who says guilty could switch and say not guilty but the one who says not guilty cannot switch to guilty you just said you could switch and proves it even more when can't he switch tomorrow it says they woke up the next day it's already it's already at the end and it says you're now all to you now all to switch your opinion and R said you could switch your opinion R doesn't back down R knows about this mishna R is a Tana he learned by rebi he knows this mishna what do you think they don't continue deliberating you don't think that they wake up the next morning and they start fighting all over again of course the deliberation what the Mish says over there that you cannot you can't switch your opinion from from not guilty to guilty is during the deliberations of the next morning I'm talking about by you could switch okay so he didn't get ra another question so we we deliberate back and forth and we try to get one of the parties who says guilty to switch his opinion to not guilty but it doesn't talk about what R says they could go from not guilty to guilty listen why is it not mentioned that we try to get one of the guys or we we try to get what it says we try to get one of the who said guilty to switch to not guilty why don't we say maybe one of the not guilties is going to switch to guilty so you see that you don't do that t is trying to talk in a nice proper way we want to get the guy off the hook we're not trying to to to kill somebody here didn't mention it but of course you could do it you could switch from not guilty to guilty just theana is not going to go into that another question very interesting one of the the viewers of the case one of the interns one of the decided he has a good reason to say that this guy is not guilty and then he dies now typically speaking will consider his opinion we said even a talet has the right to say his opinion and we we're going to count him in the vote but he died does his opinion stand or not here it goes quickly so what what it is is here's the talid and he takes over his position I don't know Yoshi I wasn't so sure if this 23 day plus is a 24 day on him Yoshi it's only 23 now like we kind of fits into somebody's okay that's sure about that could be this 24 if there's other tell me have to say so it's a bz of 27 I'm not sure we we we we have to come back to the 23 the point is he's as if he's alive his opinion counts it's a it's a it's a stronger question than even I even realized now I'm thinking to myself now if is like I'm just explaining what I'm thinking out my head if is like r that you should never switch your opinion if you say not guilty you don't switch your opinion until the but this individual never had a chance to switch his opinion by he died before the so how do you know that he wouldn't switch at the maybe he's just keeping what R said that you have to you have to keep quiet and say not guilty not guilty until the last minute but the says at the end of the day we heard from his mouth not guilty we're going to use that as one of the votes it's a little hard I get it I but but maybe he doesn't really believe it but maybe he doesn't really believe it maybe he's just saying it because the M told him he has to keep that that opinion says now you're trying to fit this that one of with ra it fits him beautifully because now at the end of the day he never got a chance to switch his opinion so we're going to keep his original opinion but the problem is means we take him out and it doesn't fit him withu is RA in other words and don't get along and we just said they do get along says you have to just stick in one word you should know that that was not what it was said what said is that he does get along with ra [Music] okay this literally in two days a mish you have this whole B than 23 and then you have the two guys that write down everything that's happening in the bz one is standing on the right one is standing on the left and they write everything that everybody's talking about the the claims you say that he's not guilty why what's his Source you have a POS okay we write it down you say what's your Source write it down they're not just writing down ruin said they're writing down the the proof this is a I don't think anybody knew this coming into the share today I can understand because there's a big here what's so says Rashi over unbelievable we know that when you say the guy's guilty if you say he's he's he's not guilty everybody goes home that day but if you say guilty what's you have to sleep on it you have to go home sleep on it check this out let's say you said guilty because it says in the the next day you come you say no no no he's guilty because it says a different so not same just different do you have to sleep on it again says rash you have to sleep on it again thear says it rash is just explaining bring it out says and if you come tomorrow and you give another reason for your same opinion guilty for the second opinion you need to sleep on it also oh so makes a lot of sense theer ofz needs to write down and they why do you say guilty ah great the next day we're going to remember oh you came up with a new oh go to sleep can't pass him today how do I know that that it's new cuz I wrote it down I have it in writing you said yesterday different POS now said this POS great so now I know why you have to write it but explain to me why do I need to write down why people say the reason in the there's no the whole point is that do we know we need to know do do you need sleep on it another night that's only when you say guilty but on a non-guilty verdict or opinion you don't sleep on it you never sleep on it even on even one night you don't sleep if everybody says not guilty not guilty go home that that day during the day you don't sleep with it so certainly if he comes up a second time he says not guilty but I have another source so certainly you're not going to sleep on it so what's the point of writing it Eli you want to make sure that uh he didn't switch his opinion okay so for that you write the words uh ruen Zak you don't have to write the reason behind it but what is the real reason you write it the real reason you're writing it is because maybe you made such a mistake of a baby that even a baby knows your mistake auki knows your mistake oh for that I get it but at the end of the day you see that you cannot take it back can't take it back so says the reason why I write it down is so this we see this three CH the t is perfect there's no extra word in the T and there certainly no extra in the T the T doesn't have twoim saying the same anywhere so if I say this guy's guilty because of PK a and you say this guy's guilty you agree with me that he's guilty but B so we have a problem which one is it so I could only count one out of the two so two people here now are counted as one dying cuz you're both saying guilty but you bring two sources you're both wrong not both wrong one of you is wrong I need to cancel one of you you hear what's going on if both of you say guilty and you bring the same so you count it as to you're saying the truth but if both of you say he's guilty and you're bringing two separate PUK one of you is lying cuz there's no two PUK in the T that saying the same thing so one of you I know for sure for a fact is off so I have to cancel one of you I'm not going to I'm not going to count to you as a guilty as a guilty verdict that's why I need to write it down or is a not guilty sorry as not guilty that's why we write down everything no no he's not guilty he's claim why are we writing not guilty he's not and you cannot be yeah no then you're saying the wrong thing you can't put a guy to death and you you say he's I'm putting him to death because he killed somebody and and and another say but at the end of the day that doesn't work like that you have to say he's guilty [Music] because they both said the same there's no contradiction they brought they brought two different two people count as one cuz one of them was a mistake how do you know you don't learn from spoke once from one learn I can learn two is not learn from from and now we go into whole I thought it's very interesting first of all I was told I didn't get there I don't even do Rashi now said so he said this twice in the H he said he looked it up this twice what so um Dr Epstein told me because I'll say this uh cuz people were telling me so so why don't you push Rashi last night I said it's in Rashi and I said I oh oh so so so Dr AB saidan I I you want to say it the enemy of good is better the enemy of good is better so guy and I said this in sh last night to the Israelis and a guy raised his hand what does it mean the enemy of good is better just be good just do M you want to do Rashi don't tell anybody about it but don't don't force yourself to do Rashi because what happened the guy he says I took it by myself to do Rashi and I'm not doing mik right now cuz that's the enemy of good you want to be even better than good just be good one thing at a time I want to learn six at the same time and then you just fall off the whole D also L lot yeah one day you'll get there yeah bet finish one cycle I'm not saying don't do it I'm just saying it's okay I'm bringing it up only because some guy scream out and Kobe C said at the uh screamed out forget it I'm in English and I'm in Hebrew and that's the way I'll remain that's we have don't ask it's it's a disaster so KOB said what don't go for too much the FAS the FAS do do the basics first and if that works out for you then you add to it don't jump in okay oh I want to do that for but also you know what let me do 16 Karas and let me do let me start from bras also and once I bro might as well do shabas so I'm going to do four day those things usually don't last ah that that's not important right now I'm not there yet I didn't even finish the next line two different yeah exactly exactly my point that's why I started saying and this is T you're bringing T to say the same thing great I pointed out last night and I was I'm getting there so the simple in the is this this is the simple in the here you have a a stone like a like a like a hammer breaks a stone but that's not what we're saying here really in fact what we're saying is that the psh itself the hammer breaks into pieces that's you know discuss it but that's that's how we're learning the hammer could break it when it tries to break a a diamond or whatever it break into a few pieces so to one could break into you could learn a few from one but not the opposite you can't learn two the same from give me a good example where two people are saying the same they learn from two sources so this is this is literally why we have gar Gar teaches us how every word is important and there's not ex and now we're going to go in a little bit of a tour it's unbelievable we're going into like him here a lot of people are not familiar but it's very very I can't wait I'm not I'm not joking unbelievable says like this so the guy that did the the props for um our shabbaton and he did an unbelievable job he did a a a mockup of at the staircase coming into mdy Mish you know was life size life size wiber Sly Weisberg he sent me this he gave me a gift at the this is not easy to make we had this during something like this during Yuma whatever I wanted $1,000 for it and then I offered him $1,000 I said no no decided I can't sell it it's too hard all right he made it out of wood this wood what we just need this for a few small things but it's kmak to have a nice prop this is the the red line some blood is sprinkled below the red line some above the the red line it goes like this um you bring a carbon you bring the stuff onto them the is if let's say you have a pel carbon for whatever reason the K had the wrong thought while he was doing the the meag in his mind he said I'm going to eat it outside of the time outside of the place don't put it on the on the on the on comes doesn't listen to or comes a and he he didn't know he takes the carbon puts it on top of the the carbon is good do not remove it leave it that's the so we're going to get to the in a second so [Music] this even if it's has the power to make it anything that's that could be that that's a that you could bring as a carbon yes like a carbon you put it on a fire the fire we're going to explain what that means in a second how where's something that goes on the fire in other words a carbon the same exact and what the both saying the same exact thing that if you have a carbon that's no good and somebody puts it on don't take it off but one learns from the word we're learning the same from two sources so that's a good example it's an example of learning two two the same from two sources but the says no that's not a good example in fact is there the blood here's a picture that's one of the real quickly there's four when you carbon the carbon slicing it throat then you have to receive the blood in that that vessel that the has that he you receive the blood that's then you walk to the and then you sprinkle it and that's the main part of the of the the end of it you sprinkle so but blood blood is not something you put over here where do you put blood so first of all I just want to like I showed you before first you sorry this corner right over here you sprinkle like this and it goes It goes on both and then right over here on this side now whatever is left over if you notice I don't know if you can see this there's two holes right over here right by my finger see these two holes there's also two holes right over here so that's where that's where you pour the wine on top over here you pour wine over here and the leftover blood over here and the blood but you don't put the wine on the fire and you don't put the the blood on the fire so it has to be it has to be something similar the only thing that the is something that you put on the fire but not wine says no anything that has to do with wine blood you put it up there don't take it down take it down because it's not something you put on so what's a good so so in other words there is then that's why they use two sources I understand now why there two sources are very similar same kind of almost identical call anything that touches becomes even something that's not acceptable to be we're going to say what that is in a second it has to be like sheep you cannot put on a deer you can't say oh I put a deer I'm not going to take it off deers don't go on you can't put in you can't put you can't put honey on the m so this comes to exclude honey has to be something that could I learned from a different word the same idea same exactly a different word so that's a good example of the same learned from two different just like so it has to be can't be a deer can't be honey both com to say that was you don't take it off they learn from two different words so you see this is a little bit of a problem to what we're saying that you don't learn the same no that's not a problem there is enough and since they're learning from two different words now what the the bird you when you sprinkle the blood you sprinkle it above the red line it's different than an animal animal he sprinkle below the red line on this corner the O bird above the red line over here so it's different it comes to exclude the bird only if you put a pule sheep or on top of the you don't take it off but if you put a posle bird on the M take it off immediately yeah let's just finish this okay so since we do have the two it makes sense that they learn from two different words turning family in honor of Champions Mr andless leader and chiefo by the members of the M fire department andon films strategic video [Music] production have another thing similar this is referring to there's something called a I love this picture from n this is a guy fancy house of and with the tennis court but he has atile m going on in the backyard he likes to uh I don't know why the the word bum okay yeah you're right that you add that to this it's interesting they're play the Tesla when flying off did anybody see the Tesla in the background it's like a runway for his private jet in times River you're right 's River if you have a b it's not good and if you an animal on that thing you're like he killed the he killed something he spilled Bloods this also comes to include not only theing action do on an animal but also pouring the blood on this bumer like so like this that's one of our artist this is another artist you get the point two different artists we we had a one is learning this is the learner this is our so here he's spilling the blood on a backyard B also this just reminds me of a story because the story itself is a story about remembering something else this just triggered my memory I I I figured I'll break up the sui a little bit with I thought it was a beautiful story simple story but beautiful there was a kid in in school here in AR Ro he comes home he sees his mother making this giant birthday cake so he says is there any way that you can make one for me I want to bring to I want to bring to school I want to show my my friends nice cake of course of course so she had the little leftover batter she made him a little tiny cake you know this big and she put it on the counter to her horror she wakes up in the morning she's going to bring this beautiful cake to her friend at work and there is no cake the kid switched the big one he thought the big one was for him he left her the little he takes the cake he takes the cake to school you know here and there to I just got an email actually from uh this just going from story to story email from a reaban here said that he he gives out one bottle of soda to at the end of the week to the best kid in the class and it's a whole thing you take the bottle you give to all your family he says he forgot the bottle he went to somebody from mdy went bought a bottle for this kid I'm thinking to myself in America a bottle of soda new like they make a hole it's a hole I get a bottle of soda from my re and B he this kid some guy he was just trying to show the the guy went out of his way okay this kid imagine coming to school the giant birthday cake with all the cream and all the stuff the whole the the rebi came into the the class the re called the principal and they made a whole Reco and all the kids were his friend the whole thing fine the mother decided she's not going to say a word it doesn't make sense he he made an honest mistake it wasn't he didn't do it on purpose nothing this kid at his V he gets up and he says I I want to thank my mother want to think my mother she saved my life says one day him and his friends decided that they're going off the D they're going off the DK they're going to fly to to another country and when they get to the next country they're going to call up the parents so the go to the airport and he sees a guy holding a giant cake and it triggered his memory and he said wow my I my mother did this for me and remember she stood up at night and the whole thing how could I do this to her got back in the taxi went back home Kam it has everything to do with the Su look inside here no sometimes uh things belong in different places the car no had the story to say okay no a guy came over to me after after she and he said you weren't sure uh you know how the story really fit in here so you should just know that just the other day I was thinking about going off a stickle and and he told me a whole thing how this year he he watches he comes here all the time this B I'm Ser she guy I'm not joking I think Benny even heard him say yeah were who was there somebody was there no no no this some this is this this thing a carbon belongs inside doesn't belong here whatever just trigger my memory okay they're learning the same that even when you you sprinkle the blood outside you're also but from different words they both coming to learn the same exact and both of them are learning it from the same the same but from different say no no no once again we're going to try to do this thing that what you think it's the same and the learning from two different sources no there is here and therefore they learn from two different sources the question is you know in shabas if a person has one awareness of shabas like he doesn't know what chabas he's in Hawaii he didn't realize in Hawaii shabas is also for two days whatever he he does over and over and over so he's only one carbon because he he wasn't aware that a chabas if somebody notified him in the middle of the day and said hey you know thatai over here chabas today and he continues to do then he's to so here also if he has it's one one of or one sprinkling is for the and the it's only one so that that's here it's one awareness he's one one one carbon he didn't know that the bums are over nobody notified him that there's no more they used to in the backyard used to sprinkle blood in the backyard anymore so at the end of day we have that's why it's two sources there is no and if there it's perfect here's a great example of two who say the same exact and they learn from two different sources that's what we don't like it's all one okay so we have a great source of what saying the same exact in all one and they learn from two different sources how do you know that M you right you you start off the the din during the day and you can finish it even at night you could do a judgment at any time you want even at night so why do you have to start the the the during the daytime it goes like as thetion it says you could judge at any time you want when it comes to which is M only during the day said how do we Rectify this you to start off a judgment the says has to be during the day and then we use the second POS when do you finish it off even at night anytime and this doesn't go like the says the word fight meaning a monetary dispute together with what's the connection you could you make a he and you learn all the from from and what when here it goes like this a person has an Affliction this is his hand and all of a sudden some White Spot comes on his hand and two haars so what does he do he go goes to the C he shows the C his it can only go to a single Cen and he shows him the thing and the says okay get out of here you have to leave you have to go into we put you away so there's a few alas here just like the Kind Checks it out only during the daytime you can't look you know there's no light at night how is he going to see only during the day and this is the question this is that that's why it doesn't go like if we stop right over here this is we have to stop not for this sh for thisor says that is only during the day and he doesn't explain what he means even even the second part is during the day only not like our M who says you finish at night another just like obviously the can't be a blind man has to be in front of his eyes so who sit on the in the they can't be blind just like when it comes to the oh now we go the opposite way we're learning from to just like you can't have be relative you can't be ative know how many I spoke to my son last night and that's the question I asked him I said uh how many how many people sit on a regular three how many sit on uh for 23 I wanted to make sure that he's not bluffing here I spoke to both my sons yesterday about the da we had a lot to uh to about I asked them do I make you cringe do I embarrass you and they both said no I was I was very surprised cuz as a son your father always makes you cringe uncomfortable my my oldest son said yeah there was one thing you said today but he didn't remember what it was and then ipped I I now they're thought they're actually listening I got to be careful you know like it wasn't it wasn't in my mind until then I don't get it how could one decide something and that's bodily harm you're causing this guy to go into who knows where he has to leave the the and everything it's a lot worse than judging him for $100 $100 you need three people how come judging his his one is enough that's because it's we don't ask questions one decides it it's a you're right without this I would say it's three because I would compare it to says you see from here even one says story there was a blind man now you must write with your pencil in here what kind of blind man he wasn't blind in two eyes obviously there only one eye has to to be he lived in the neighborh he didn't say a thing when you have a Mna without any names that's a RI that re wanted to Institute that as he said this is the I'm not even going to bring any names it's unanimous everybody agrees to this and what does it say this that everybody that could be a judge could be aesy but there is somebody thaty cannot be a judge that a blind man in one eye cannot judge so how did you let him judge says very good we have our Mish and he proved it from our M it's also that a blind man in one eye could judge the what it says let me ask you the question who could see better a regular human being that has two eyes and has great eyesight in middle of the night in the time of the gamar without LEDs and fluoresence at night or a man with one eye during the day who sees better one eye during the day for sure so it says you could you could finish it at night but at night you can't see well you definitely see less than a guy with one eye say interesting the SM in Simon he says that if you light a bunch of candles certainly this kind of stuff that we have today we don't have candles we have Crazy Light it's more than daytime light you could you could be down at night he says it's unbelievable that's the SM I don't know how we pass look it up so okay so he found the hour mishna but as thear you have two St mishas why did you pick our mishna over that mishna and that mishna seems like a one oneeyed man cannot judge over it says you could why is our better that is onlys is the you go with the this is a great one over there was brought down as a side point but over here we're talking what's the name of our this is the peric we're learning these are it's one after another these are so this is more than one what does do with the says you can judge all the time even at night how come you say you could only judge during the day a cloudy day this I would think that a cloudy day is no good you cannot look at a ter a cannot look early morning when the sun is not out 100% and during that by the way um I have to ask not to blow noses if you blow your nose you know but I got a bunch of complaints you hear it like a r there's ways if anybody needs to learn how to blow nose I'll talk talk them afterwards come on what about sing the sneezing in the sneezing there's ways to sneeze I'll teach you all how to sneeze but the sneeze that that that shakes up the guy poor guy's trying to sleep over the shear in New York and you wake him up with your sneeze laughing okay laughing is Gish it's approved and right seriously this has nothing do I didn't notice it I didn't notice but what I don't know people wrote in emails that that we got to do something about this I guess the the microphone picks it up or something it really bothers a bunch of people so says and not what a lot of people three people I'm not joking three people and and that's a lot they have time to take out for that this is it do not look at a tell me what this says over you're not going to believe this nearest chaos sometimes the bleakness is bright and sometimes the brightness is Bleak do whatever you want to do with this you say your own here because so the the light could affect you it has to be bright in order for to be Tom it has to be bright and some you have too much light it looks the dull sometimes dull looks bright um I don't know we have to stop here we're literally in the middle of a word maybe we could find okay let's just stop we'll start over there unfortunately have a wonderful day