Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 23 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning coming in slowly welcome all the guests we have a by Mary dambi and um we're going out of order a little bit but Bo we have two live places in Flatbush the usual B meas of manich and in Jackson Jackson you're from Jackson oh yes you know this place what is this I don't know what this is Tom's River enjoy some pizza oh it's at somebody's house AR arov okay I received this email in Hebrew it's pretty emotional my name is Aon CER I'm a Yesa and I want to share you my story with you when I was iner I'm going to skip through it basically he says he's a pretty smart guy but he never made it in Yesa he never had goodas is always bad for him but one day his brother told him why don't you try to finish sh before you get married he thought he's m and uh he started doing the sh with us and he started and he he finished in one year he finished for and it really changed his life and he asked me to come to his so I'm like I'm thinking like wow this is it's a big I'll come to his and then I took a look at the invitation and it says that it's this email came in 3 months ago and I got it yesterday somehow so I have to ask him a and then his mom pipes in here I know she wants oh get her his mother sent me an email also cuz I read it last night so his mother sent me an email she says you should know you saved my son's life and you saved my life that's what she says I don't know exactly she says um okay so galic beautiful um this is also very emotional to me this isn't a mat by shimm [Music] BR on the wall there two does not [Music] stay so he he he wrote he wrote he wrote to me today this guy he says that he has a hard time uh I think he's a more of a Bela and he has a hard time with the reading and he's he's working on his reading and Rashi and kit so he's staging stagging away as he's uh it doesn't get any more than that you start off you don't have to the entire second he's also thinks he's thinking learning everything's um here's another one I got so many emails yesterday in Hebrew very very emotional emails this one with a translation this individual started giving thei when he was 24 years old and today he's about 40 and he's also a rebi in Yesa inana which means a high school here in Isel um in recent weeks he discovered the shear and he was captivated by it comes from the heart he always for years he felt this passion to call out to every Y come learn to transform your life and your wife's life your family's life just like it transformed mine how could you live without learning to suddenly you hear you saying the same thing with enthusiasm your message is so important [Music] uh your emphasis that it's not about the da it's about the Yi your insistence insistence that you not make up the da later that you may you make it up to later but you learn today it's truly so he says one lesson he learned from me as a because it's hard if anybody ever tried to give a Shear you'll see I think I actually advise every single person including you Dr Epstein try to one day you should just as a take it upon yourself as um how do you say as a challenge as a everybody here Donnie here as a challenge give a one time just one time prepare for hey look who's behind you D look who's behind you so try it try it prepare for a few hours a few days maybe and give a sheer you'll have a different appreciation so here's the guy that gives it every day and he's like be a person of Ms without gimmicks of pretenses don't be ashamed try to laugh and cry be sensitive he says what he learned the big is that yeah when I was in when I was in Utah the were not so and get prepared it's going to happen again soon have to go back to Utah because the snow I don't know if I'll go skiing I don't know if that's I have to go visit my daughter and uh the the yeah I have to sacrifice SLE War they Under Pressure but sometimes you have to say to yourself you know the kids have to go skiing the family comes first he gives me a whole whole thing here fine and he loves the charts you have to say sh sh what's your name Ari what you're the famous Ari Greenwald RAB boai Ari Greenwald was in Gaza for months months and he always did the GRE he's a shy guy Mike he's shy wow yeah no get over could I can I give you a hug I I need to give you a hug anybody want to come here and give him a hug also thank you so much for everything you've done loves you hey tell us about the D we able to do the do every day yeah I have uh in my we're like 35 guys we have uh around eight guys that are doing the do eight guys eight guys yeah every day uh in Gaza in Gaza onear gamar going around you need gamar we have some extra gamar here we just got now we got the now that you left you got the we just got wow so when tell me tell me the hardest time you did A D like you were like about to fall asleep 2 in the morning any good gakis uh just finished uh killing a bunch of terorist for a while and then uh we got moved to do a mission so during cona so it was a tough time because we didn't really have a lot of time there so stunk in some learning 5 minutes five minutes there or you able to do the whole off in a shot that was like half half like one unbelievable your inspiration thank you so much all right Mike you should be very proud I am very proud and you're Happy's home now huh all righta we got to go there's a lot of lot of emails here and a lot ofak stuff theor from his grateful family the sponsor for sponsored started learning at age 70 and 32 years sponsor for the unity of the people and tremendous be making learning making learningj remember Elliot Haggler in honor of completing my fifth cycle of The Da and my cats who just started the da he's five Cycles behind but'll catch up soon by his children y side is the ninth of Tav from RBS I said already twice the of and the whole MD staff to continue to makeus Joy so many and the Art of the in honor of y k and markazi for all the work they do Bo was starting a brand new peric per there's a concept called you might have heard of it and that is if you have it inra you pick one ding the other guy picks one D in and together you pick a third D in that Za so that's what we're going to get to but when we start the mishna we could learn the mishna differently and that's what gar is all about really it's not a it's not going to say oh Z straight out and tell you the masc it's going to go through all the steps to see how we got there how do we know this concept Z of each person choosing one we have a mishna from the mishna it's not so clear shom you look familiar you you were here before yeah many times yeah you've been here for two years every day no no not really oh wow what's your name again okay great oh I have to show you this this uh this is a famous painting by rembrand is a is that that's how you pronounce it you see you see on the now we know what it says on the wall there's a hand coming out and writing on the wall so now it's finally understood to us nobody else understands it but okay we get it he misspelled it you read it he did Oh you mean the guy writing it David Fisher from tin New Jersey okay David somebody else some I'm not comes over to me yesterday goes there's a famous painting there's some women in it and is like that's M like what what are you talking about and then I get it from a guy from tin and that then I understood thei from last night okay in the original Rembrant he painted other women's faces as well no this is the original I didn't do anything no I didn't put those white circles there D mom and his says when you have it three how do you do it says rash that if we want to start with the G and understanding G so we understand it with the hav mean of the G and that is that the ru and shim have a fight the guy on the right and the guy on the left so Ru picks a bezan and shim picks a bant so total of six [Music] together they pick a third be that's if you want to say hav that's the we going to say that's not like that it's one each person picks one and then for a total of three but that's typical you have to we have to go through the steps and see why this doesn't work maybe this maybe this is what the mishna meant no it's not what the Mish I'll prove to you that this is not what the mishna meant yesterday we had a g today we don't have a g that's how it goes one day like this one day like that don't drop out of the sh because it's not a g today we'll have a God the next day so that's it works like this according to the each person chooses a bezden from the bezden one dying from here and here they choose a third so total we have three but who chose the third not the two B not but rather that's just says each guy the guy on the right the guy on the left ruin and shim have the the the ability to say we don't want this dying we don't like him you want to say who says he could do something like that can't just another can't say oh I don't like the way his beard looks you have to say this you have a good reason he's a relative he's posle he's a EV okay good reason it's important to remember this word here the wording of the mishna if they were ker or we're talking about professional d then you cannot say he's no good the is going to use the these words later say look we're talking about a professional the want to say for a second it's not a professional say well maybe we don't really meet a professional we mean somebody that the made him a professional he's not a real professional this is very hard to understand on the surface what I could just say that those witnesses that came to testify against me I don't like them every single time this Witnesses in court I say oh I don't like them they're not good people bring bring other Witnesses but there aren't other Witnesses why should I why should I have that ability and the going to say no that's not what he meant no you have the ability to say you don't like those Witnesses if you could prove that they're relatives or that they're Apostle but if they're good Witnesses you don't have the ability to make them possible okay so now let's dig into this Mission and see what we just read everything on the surface seems is very difficult by the way yesterday I forgot just to show you this um Yoshi worked on it really hard and for sometimes I just so I'm scheduling for tomorrow again at 1 there's a king every day he needs a haircut so he's scheduling scheduling is here with mdy thing no the beard you don't touch but the the hair is very very short I don't if it's a zero if it's a one but each hair touches the root of the other we kids are basically he's bald and he's getting scheduling a haircut for tomorrow says mean so we're going to talk about the hav that what each person picks chooses entire bz and together they choose another Bez question you don't need nine three people is enough if each person has a fight and that happens a lot I don't like that bzen they're they're too M I don't like this bzen whatever it's not my style they're to they're too Lish I don't know what so together they decide to choose another bzen so we're going to knock the two on the right and the left we're going to knock them out of the picture and we're going to be left with what with one bzen what does the borrow have the right to decide what B he wants to go to so we have and the says that somebody has the ability to say I only want to go to we live here in I don't like I want to go to the the big I want to go there I want to go to the real Court who has the ability to say it says Razer holds it's only one out of the two it's the lender the lender has the ability to force the borrower to travel all the way to Y in those days it could be quite a trip today it takes uh 25 minutes 30 minutes by car going uh 70 M hour can imagine with all the mountains and by by foot maybe a few days I don't know how long it took them I could force you to go all the way to and that's from Imagine you lived inat or something the has no say if the wants to force the the malva to go all the way through says no I lent you money it's enough that I lent you money now you're going to SLE me all the way over there says you borrower you considered a a slave here something like this if you borrow money you're m to the Mala not the other way around not so nice but it's it's it's I know it's not nice but it's to it's to Vis you get it in terms of meni doesn't like not approved by meni so now we have to have a new thing we have ASI approved men do not approved I'll never get approval I'll get a not approval what she does no what what happens me no you're not to borrow money I borrow money I have a lot of now but I'm a I'm a evid to to my to my [Music] lender the only way to make money is to borrow money these days that's right you shouldn't feel that way but you have to know you are that way unfortunately you don't decide you don't dictate what bu you go to he dictates okay I'm getting it off the thing the screen for you if Thea wants to go to another city you say no no no you stay here in this city that I let you the money in so says [Music] the when does the have a right to to protest in so everybody here in the room thinks right away what does means a non-jewish bz no it's a New Concept they have it even today where three businessmen people that are intellectuals they get together and and people use them to for advice in even in law even in you have Aus you go you have a little problem with your neighbor you go to you don't have to go to a bz you go to three people that are that are smart and they're understanding it they're not the biggest they they make a lot of mistakes in in they don't know all the but they're very good at at these kind of they can figure things out so that's the that were in Syria today we're talking about Syria this you know taking over Syria a little bit we're not taking over it's ours we had it back in the day and it's ours today too Shu so the could say you know what this not it's not a true bezin it's a make believe bz that people accept it upon themselves I don't accept it that he has a right as much as he has the right just like is going to say this idea later so we're going to use this idea now that what that the has the right to deny such a you Mal want to bring me to to your three neighbors who are geniuses the big businessmen each one owns a business and the understand this stuff no I don't want to go there but if he wants tole you to a Bez of professionals a real you don't have the right to deny talking about a of professionals we're talking about regular we have which is a ra really and the could say I want to go to ra I don't want to go to ra I had a bad experience once with ra I want to go Toda and that's okay why it's not a big deal big deal so you're going to go you go to the the other B it's not a big so of he asked one of his do me a favor and on condition that it's not too hard for you it's not a it's not a th said Okay a few days later he said no did you do did you do what I asked you to do he said no the re said if it's not a t i do what the Reb said and it happens to be it was a t it was going to take me a bunch of hours and uh that's a I'm not that the said I shouldn't do so he said no no no if you look in tus in says but wait a minute how could have next to so that they were three par away from each other so says that three par away from each other that's quite a that'll take back and forth it will take two-thirds of a day to get there based on the whole calculation oh so you see that two3 of a day is not a it says it's not a so up to two-thirds of a day working for the re that's not a yeah you say full day that's fine that that I believe is a but not two3 it says in our that the two get together and they pick a third now we're still trying to prove what we know we come here we're all we know means you pick one I pick one and together we pick a third but where do how do we get there gar is to teach us all the steps that took to to to reach that that conclusion if we're talking about that this one picked the whole bz and this one picked the whole Bez and together they pick the Third queening here you pick the B on the top right you picked the bz on the top left and I said I don't like that bz the two you say you don't like that Bish so two di from the b one b one di from the right one B from the left they got together and they chose a third bz for you does that make any sense I said I don't like that b so he said okay we're not going to use that you said you don't like that we're not going to use that so you're going to take two people from two but that we don't like together we don't like them and they're going to decide for us who we're going to use that makes absolutely no sense so it doesn't make sense that we're talking about a full bz in here is this a must in every single I must go ahead and and and and start what what if you chose everything for me and everything's on a silver platter he said just show up to bezan yeah I'm sure people had that situation here the guy says hey let's go to he's a great D he's a great bet let's go over there he said okay let's go no the mission says no I have to choose and you have to choose and we have to do a whole situation and we should both argue that I don't like this Bez and together we're going to come up with a third Bez and if you don't go through that whole process no good oh so now finally we're here this is Za you pick one Di and I pick one Di and together we pick a third they say in English you could pick your friends and you can pick your nose but you can't pick your friend's nose you could pick your dying but and your friend could pick his is dying but you can't pick your friend's dying oh no you can pick your dying and together you can pick the third dying but you can't pick your friend's dying okay it's not going to work not going to work not going to work okay it's a big M you can't pick your friend's nose say you can't pick your friends nose all right who knows no I'm going to change it it's not called meni not approved it's we have to like no no let's go oh no sorry I missed two words why do you have to do it this way if we do it this way that you pick a and I pick a together we pick the third this is how we're going to achieve a real why says Rashi because everybody's going to listen now the the guy that became that was found guilty it's my fault it's not my fault I actually brought this Dy and if he goes against me obviously it's right and if he would be able to find something it's not look the D has to be 100% glat but he thinks himself look I brought the guy that's my style everything is great if you could have found something you would have found it and the together they want to they want to come together and find the for everybody room each one tries to yesterday the story keeps on getting better and better sitting here in chak yesterday and uh a guy was going around collecting money with our with our push was helping you know you go during as so he's a little bit of a let and he went to a guy sitting next to him he says no no and he says so and so no where's your why don't you give some money you want to give a donation and the guy says you know and then he goes over zet on his back and he says something to him and at that time I was like wow the guy that he just did it to he brought one of his good friends that was never here first time he was here and I felt bad kind of like it looked like the guy was being like he's making him look like a stingy person he doesn't want to give now a lot of people don't give you know middle of daving and this and that so happen to be that I saw that guy that didn't give I saw him like looking in his packets before he actually did give a few of the people that came for but he ran out so I was just thinking to myself wow then I said then I thought another thought I said whoa Benny rodnik came to me the night before which was less than 12 hours before and told me that that guy that didn't give anything he gave $1,000 to mdy Anonymous and his name is going to be anonymous from RBS that's what he told me anytime you see anous from RBS that's this guy so I said over to SM last night at this year like you have to be you see a guy you think to yourself maybe he or maybe doesn't have money I don't know what but not only didn't give a shekele but he gave 3,700 shekele 3,700 more than you thought more cuz if he would have given a shekele the guy would have been very happy that's all he cares about sheele for each guy 3,700 so the guy tells me after the shear he says here here's what's even more interesting that my credit card charge went through at 838 he showed me on his phone 8:38 that's the exact minute that that guy knocked him on the shoulder and asked him for the so the story keeps on getting better after this year we're going to have another anyway fine but you should always be down you see the guy going like this he might like this I don't know no no no he just gave 10 hours ago or that minute different and later on in 100 years from now when they say over the there going to be did he give the night before did he give that minute but whatever nothing left to put in the push we said that each person he goes and gets a d and they get another D you got to be careful when you sign AAR they say about the stier when he uh when he would if they came to him with like one of these K you know you have to go to here you have to vote I don't know what he took a look at it if signed in it boom he signed right he didn't ask any questions you have to know who your company is because if they knock one of them everybody gets knocked if we take if we could pass a one a All Day become posle if we pass one ding all the Day become so I need to know who the other people are huh let's see let's see why because it's btle the whole thing doesn't hold of this in other words we have choose the third or not have to here we're talking about have to know who the third di is everybody holds that a d needs to know who his other D you need that should agree to the third do we need the agreement of the the two the two people Ruben and that the have to agree that way everybody agrees so everybody agrees that a d and a d have to agree on the third D I don't want to sit on on a bz where the third ding is here he did a picture gets like who is this guy I don't want to sit with him he might not be the best ding but do the B do the have to agree to each other to the third that's by the way I I need to stop here for a second before I forget is there people in the last week a few people came over to me people like I didn't believe it doesn't matter it doesn't go by looks you can look like a big you look like a people told me it's the first time in my life I'm doing MRA I made it through Braes so it's a great time to to push it again to if if you didn't start here is coming up now get on the bandwagon it's another thing once you get this habit a great habit of if you just started Sanhedrin you should know by the end of Sanhedrin if you can stick it out to the end of Sanhedrin through all these kind of do everything you will acquire a habit for life and once you acquire that habit you could add other habits you could start doing exercise you can start doing MRA do all sorts of G stuff so says the gar I just saw somebody I didn't recognize you all the way in the corner you're new yeah do you have anything to do with building this building well Robert Lings is here for huh 50 for still you you're not did you take a little see if it Stills the 50 from ah he speaks English Robert I just want to tell you something that when we were sitting down those days uh planning this B Med most of the people in the B said that I'm crazy if for trying to build such a large B Med they said you remember I always tell every on the story we had the old room in people said you think my brother going to get a bit bigger maybe we should a for 50 people maximum that's what I said that's what said no no no we did 80 80 75 you said oh here that's more like it I said 75 I never said 50 because we already had in we had days we had over 40 people 45 here rber will be made 45 okay you got to you got to think big and big sometimes is not 80 big is like we had literally four or five times this week since month of shabas the two mon shabas in Hebrew zero seats people standing we had one day like almost 10 people were standing it's not enough and then they're going to start saying oh you have to expand I don't think so then they're going to take that video that I said I don't think so he said look here is after the expansion he said I don't think so okay cuz no in the in the scene they just said I I said I'm not going to do Hebrew I don't think so never going to happen where gets wi the pureed people of this is what they would do check this out I know that this irks you a lot you thisa with a black beard he's about 29 years old and a long Frack walks into a into the Sim and he looks around and he doesn't want to sit on this table then he doesn't want to sit in that table and finally he finds all the the guys the white beard the and he he makes sure he get what's going on and it bothers you I know it bothers you like what is he he's he's he says that a of a guy should not be sitting with and he doesn't want to sit with the the the common folk he's don't look at him like that here here's the right here we're going to learn it right here as I was walking up the steps a big from the you know many I told him this Gar so he told me that he once invited one of the Rab in the city he says I'll only come if tell me exactly who's sitting on the table I need to know cuz the guy's he won't come if on the table he's going to sit next time such we have we have people that know and they wouldn't the person wouldn't sign unless he knew him he knew him and they wouldn't sit in unless they knew oh this is good this is good take take listen to this they wouldn't go into they need to know they need to call before make sure that the table full of for them it's to sit with and he says even in thez you go to you go to see whatever you go to you cannot you cannot sit and then he sticks in the it's very interesting but if you're there for to raise money you had some sort of dinner and this is going to help you raise can with those that's okay he says now I got to preface this I just had us uh I have these these conversations they they they drive me crazy I'm talking to a guy his the brim of his hat was much bigger than mine was stained and everything he's a yes Gish but the guy admits to me hasn't opened up a sa for in 30 years but he's you know these guys that they they in inside for whatever reason they trick themselves they think they're more they're more than you they look down at you you're not as you're not as as them you don't have the same hat the same this you not on all these that they're but he's a garnished he hasn't opened up a safer he doesn't know how to read he hasn't opened up anything he looks down at you so that being said I want you I want to show you this beautiful uh video they did here don't judge the book by its cover David schniter you can sit over here I one of the Nikas of I don't sit next to just anyone I heard that okay let's talk at learning and see if I'm Anar what would you like to talk about uh would you like to talk about leure calculations what is it or maybe how something becomes or maybe you probably won't like the picture of the on the ship who keeps scaring away my customers huh another one that hasn't opened the gamar for 30 years because he only learns bean and he calls himself DAV what are you learning in middle of my video what you got to see it you got to enjoy anyway I hope it wasn't too Stark but I I didn't I didn't I didn't stick in the piece of the E thing but you get the point the point is there's a lot of people that live in Dreamland because they learned in Yesa 20 years ago so they think they're more and no just sit down and learn after a few years of you sitting down and learning you should know half of the that you look down at so says [Music] the I didn't want to say this they forced me to say and then they left I said okay fine the saw a guy passing in by himself he said you know what you're doing is so the guy said no I'm here actually with three it's me my so the said yeah yeah that's very good but it says in the gar that you have to know the two people that are with with you and also a little bit of AUD of mus not mus gak there was a guy who they tried to bring him to the meas to learn he said n it's not for me I don't understand most of it I actually had one of these emails today that I wanted to read a guy says I don't I just started 23 days into it I barely get what's going on but I feel good I get one little nuda slowly slowly I'm getting better so he ran away and he went to he sat in a bar and when he's in the bar the kazaks came in there and they they started beating everybody up including him so he said but I'm not part of the kab you know I'm a Jewish he said no no no anybody here is part of their group so he came back to the be and he said you know even if I don't know how to learn but I'm part of the I want to be part of the the learning group so I don't understand everything I'm part of the group sometimes I sleep during shears I don't understand all but I'm part of the group may make other people walk why they don't want with him says it says in the that each person could say the other Dy is no good How Could You D and this is where comes up with his V that we're talking about three Jews that get together in Syria and they asking for people but they're not the real deal but if the professionals you cannot them let's read the the says when you bring a that they are and relatives great but if they were're real them but they argue is talking about professionals as well that you could make them possible if you want to say they become like and that would mean even says rash the worst of the worst the lady the gay from the corner the guy that sits on the corner and smokes all day he could be a if you decide he's a you take him upon yourself that he should make it sorry even a guy like that if you accept him yourself you can't was talking him a similar to here in there's two ways that you can become a I'm just thinking about mayi who was here last night and today's like literally word for word came out I'm thinking what happened to all those seats over there they all got up and left that's crazy one day like this one like that so no no in order to be a city Rabbi so either you have to go through the raban which is a very very tedious process of tremendous amount of tests or if you happen to be a rabbi in a show for a while then they they could give you a salary so that's what this is this is when the the seabird takes upon himself they say this guy didn't test him but he's our Rabbi okay we learned like this as well the guy the defendant could say no I don't like him I don't like him until once he's a he's a professional you cannot Accord to okay great so all on second said but what about ad people that are testifying did anybody ever go to school to testify no you are a aid and you saw it and you are considered a professional Aid you don't you don't take test to be Aid you're you're Aid you see you don't have to be a professional even Aid you can passle without saying anything now the whole thing doesn't make sense two people come in and testify against you you're going to say no I don't like them we explained it already REM with the Holy mouth he'll say such a silly thing impossible you cannot them what could you do singular one and the is going to explain what does it mean one Aid he asked right over here in this a guy if a May has a holy mouth so he's not going to make a mistake what what's what's the connection PES the God he'll say something like that but what's pesh he says yes when a person is not to talk any from his mouth and only talk has special helps him that what comes out of his mouth is pure and without mistakes mistake free because he has a doesn't make sense that may would say something like that when two a come and testify against you you could say no no I don't want you guys I don't like you of course you're going to say I don't everybody going to say that one a yes but where we're talking about a monetary dispute where's the T saying that you're not all here better than that one is no good then the says don't even show up here what are you doing if he came that somebody he is believed like to he came for M but the says one guy is no good for m I could accept the upon myself one guy like two I say you bring one witness I'll accept him like two I accepted it the problem is that we already said this such a situation when you have one guy that's equal to two according to her mayor he could he could take it back he could retract no no you know what I thought you're not going to find anybody now that they saw you found this guy I don't like him what's when it comes to be a judge I trust my own father he's good judge he's a judge in in Tel Aviv I accept him now between me and you I'll accept him no or your father your father is a great judge I heard he has a good name I accept him that's a big thing we're only arguing over $500 you know what I take your father Shepherds they don't know anything about you could do that but at the last second you can retract so we already have this that you can retract again the case is where I accept upon myself a judge we have two judges and the third one is my father your father or a Shepherd so I already have two cases so if I say I accept one person as a witness I could retract just like I could retract if I accept upon myself one judge says the big difference maybe between a judge and a witness the of I accept upon myself your father and my father as a judge said I cannot retract I was I was very surprised when I saw this I was thinking the exact opposite of the but I'm wrong I thought that a father is mle CRA is Craven and aid is great just he's one says the exact opposite a a is nothing one a is nothing a father is a great judge he's been doing this his whole life he's doing his whole life he judges people just what he's biased and that he's so I would think since he's great for the whole world he's a real judge so maybe you can use him here and I cannot [Music] retract but one person now you accepted him like to them great but in nowhere in the world does it work one equals two maybe would agree that he can retract cannot retract even by one and we just said this case of one Aid I accepted by myself one Aid to be like two says in this case that you could retract why cuz nowhere else in the world is one Aid equal to a but in the case of a father who's a great judge he has good Common Sense he knows inside out the whole world uses him maybe will agree that you cannot retract you could retract I need both cases the means one Dy in singular now you can't make excuses before we were saying you know what the word a dove plural doesn't mean two it means one I accept it one as two no no no no when you have in the same sentence is in the same mishna it says singular and then all of a sudden it goes to plural now the mishna is being serious the first case is one Aid one Di and the second case is two a you can't you can't start telling me that it means one the mishna is saying straight out to a do where a second before that it says which is singular so you see the mishna is you want cuz people used to memorize things right and everything has to be it has to flow well so if you saying singular and singular okay plural and plural makes sense but to start start switching aan in a sentence and say singular and then plural that means we we mean business we mean this is singular and this is plural he's not coming to push off Theos what happened was this Bal is not saying oh I don't like this Aid he's coming to testify with another person against the aid oh that's different what happened how could you do something like that how could you testify against aam to ad come and say you owe a million dollars and you say oh you know I think that you're a m I think you're a of course you're going to say that they're testifying against you that you owe a million dollars so I've never seen a more thing in my life you're going to testify against that Aid that he's POS I'm not saying that in this case he's wrong I'm saying he his whole character is off how does that help exactly we'll see I'm saying this guy's always POS what happened a guy who steals guy who steals is puzle this everywhere what's a good example of guy that steals oh we have mamish you know my my pet peeve shopping carts or the guy that walks out of the be SM with cups and hold on here he is he's a box of oh just to give some people a a box of pizza no I took a few cups and some coffee I'm going to Ste and learning yeah my pet peeve no a guy when when I was doing the Thursday night youum people took from my kitchen they went into my kitchen I I saw this my own eyes they took full boxes of cakes like like closed cakes they took the whole thing home the she is over he doesn't need a m he needs it for shabas who said I almost had a close down the she I'll just say this real quick I to close down the she my wife there was like a sh Z somewhere or whatever bris so my wife made this giant thing with cake and everything with you know the the wrapper and a nice bow and she Salan and she left it on in the kitchen so guy gets up from the table goes to my kitchen opens it up and takes the cookies out she said you know I can't do the shear anymore you can't you can't have these people these what are these behas no they just thought everything is theirs there was like a open a take whatever you want yeah the guy steals from the what do you mean but he's still biased you're claiming the guy is a slave I didn't say that he's a slave I said his father's a slave you're testifying about his father but at the end of the day it turns out that he's a slave also and and and it's ruining the the testimony and therefore you're going to come out not o the guy a million dollars so this is a beautiful but it's new we actually had this at the end of so it might be familiar to you when a guy claims I have four that saw this you know sometimes people exaggerate a little say I have four you know you think this is what everybody saw it how many people four when you say four did you just mess yourself up in other words you have to now produce four you said four bring all four oh and it's counterintuitive because if I said all four it actually helps me out cuz now I said all four I'll have to bring four but two of them I can testify against them I'll say that they're slaves why because it's not biased yeah they're slaves and we'll get rid of them but now since I have to bring all four so bring the other two and they're two good a them I'll have two good so that's means you have to produce what you say if you say there six bring six you say there's 100 bring 100 you don't bring a 100 get out of here says if there's only two then you cannot say that one of them is or something what if there's only one in other words there only two way which doesn't make any sense as asks immediately you just said what this two people you cannot make a no no no this is what I meant to ask I say this for so I could go to town against two I could say oh he's EV he's he's a terrible person he's okay and I said it's okay so now what am I left with these two let's do like this I go I say these guys are a and I have to bring these two okay so I could talk about these guys because I have two more guys so I bring these guys to bzen turns out that these two guys in bzen they are also no good now do can I go back over here and say we don't accept your testimony against them cuz I need to come on to these what's once we make them pule you can't undo it you can't retract that you read the same answer but with a different name unfortunately I think we might have to stop here wow have a wonderful day