Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 10 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning R welcome back everybody thanks for being here ah I missed you it was unbelievable how was it when I was gone did come to the merish yeah the food every day not so good okay galic um you know if you weren't there I don't want to make you jealous or anything all I can say is start saving up money for next year it was so kada it was the best money spent the best ,000 that you spent it was Unreal every moment every [Music] second you were only part of the sh for month and a half you made it there so whoever is there still lost has a lost voice there's no shot you can't by the way I got to I got to tell you uh you strug I said this um last night he came over to me he said listen I want to every everybody had their part their person that they met the story that they heard maybe make the volume a little lower he's not used to the thing yet um he said one thing that really got him was on chabas morning was singing and I I asked like I I stopped I said listen could everybody everybody in the room join we had 850 people in the room uh there were a bunch of women also so I don't know how many men maybe let's say 650 men or whatever but the room was so large that didn't want to speak in the room he was supposed to speak Friday night he didn't want to speak he said it's impossible it really is impossible to speak to such a large room so many people and uh when you get up to speak everybody in the side couldn't hear uh was speaking it hard said okay let's uh let's sing but everybody together let's do something that no you know nobody in this room has ever done and we sang I think we should sing at least one thing you ready but with heart I'm telling you it's the words the words people are crying on shabas it's aesome right right H I don't even know how to do it all [Music] it was beautiful beautiful endless stories we'll have a whole year full of stories ask people that were there every minute every speech every piece of food did nothing went wrong it was m and enjoyment from the moment you walked in every the I never said this every single person k out that walked into the hotel got a hug from y kin sat there at the door for three hours [Music] but's on the way to some by the way does anybody know what is the bombs the bombs did anybody hear these bombs no but what is going on these are louder than ever what is going on huh no no no no this morning there were a bunch at 5:30 last night what is going on here they're they're demolishing Gaza what are they doing what but but it's louder than always is everybody in the bomb shelter 3: in the morning 3:30 3:30 doka 3:30 what happened I leave for a week and this what you guys do what's going on here welcome back Michael how's the ankle replacement ankle replacement okay we have a bunch of gu let me just say real quickly who's next to you what's your name sh you yeah Feldman why are you so [Music] familiar what's your name I'm an offenheim so I know you're from somewhere yes we met in Five Towns Five Towns okay youal who else you you're Newber kber you're next hold on a second from we might have to open up a Bas marage over there there's so many people what's your name ah so you're first really you should have been first uhuh very what you slept him or you slept you really that's what you look familiar was it galic did you come over to me they say hello to you very busy one minute there was a guy on my flight that came over to me last night he was talking about you yes what a small world did he know you're here and just roll comes over me he says my good friend was at the shabat and he loved it but he didn't come over to say hello to you so I'm coming over to say hello to you so was you were you shy or just it was too many people I made a I made a calculation if I had to say hello to 850 people that's 850 minutes no no it's just not enough time said okay whatever I feel bad how you're making beautiful you wrote me an email I'm not exaggerating I have 200 emails in the last two days since shabas over 200 emails I physically couldn't read them I'm I read every single email over I don't even know where to start just breakfast today sponsored by [Music] rabber do we want to know more no no okay I don't know if I showed this in English or not did I show this yet with without sound right let's see if the sound today shragi rubo is his name that's first of all to the person who made this by call my ofie most fny jokes mean jokes makes everyone laugh and most of all enjoy the okay so the rest you'll listen to yesterday I know I know I could have posted this message so many times since last week as I think the scene was just one day ago two days ago three days ago Etc now I just think to myself that this time last week I was on a plane about to land soon for the shaton experience there are few people that I really try to get to come last last year was Mark ashkanazi I sat on the phone with him for 20 30 minutes because of the whole War mat he decided he doesn't want to come it's not appropriate and I convinced him to come he's thanked me dozens of times since then for convincing him and here's another person that I really wanted him to come Dove Harris and here he's admit I really wanted Leon Welter to come but he let me down it's not the first time Leon it's the last time the next year you're going to be there well next year in we all know that the same that no words all beond the wild factor of every aspect the fact I can truly only use this group to post and share this series he didn't write this to me he put this on the group no one would really understand it no one would really understand it's true nobody really understand it thank you all the one thing that I was worried and every everybody I know that was there last year were're a little not worried concerned knowing that this year is not going to be as good as last year it's impossible the the the emotions that we had last year it's just the beginning of the war and nobody knew what's flying what's going to be and a lot of people backed out of it because it's not appropriate to be there said we could do it just we can't play Le music only this kind of music remember this and all the speeches were a little heavy on on the mat and people were crying and laughing how you going to outdo that and I think we outdid it I really do I think everybody that was there in almost every aspect it was outdone and uh that that was the amazing thing of it this group thank you all wouldn't be I wouldn't be honest if I didn't admit to having feelings going into the shabas and starting with cabal shabas that I it won't be like last week we need to take the best and the highest we had and reflect them on the rest of clel can't wait to share the third Bish with you with no doubt last has helped us speed up it's coming one of the biggest things that I heard over and over is people saying what what the the the variety of there and everybody getting along together everybody sitting on the same tables dancing together and I heard from women usually you go on a PES program go to hotel it's very nerve-wracking what are you going to wear and you have to have an outfit for every meal was none of this no nothing just pus you come you enjoy the Rus women didn't care about anything how you look and how you dress and who you are it was not none of that it was M like a bunch of people told me that it was not about the Joneses it's about just coming here and enjoying and I think hopefully we can get that message out to the women because many men couldn't come because of their wives women naturally like who am I speak to who I don't know anybody there I don't want to come and that that was the thing you know what I'm talking about and if we could overcome that and they it's not funny it's um can't wait to sh good all and please please reach out directly for anything you ever need particularly be it mdy related maybe I shouldn't read this out loud here Dove Harris London I have to say um Rafi Katan owns a a service called royal airport concierge he didn't ask me to say this obviously but he went out of his way and he picked me up from the airport and picked me up here and with a beautiful brand new very shiny professional driver slips your luggage does the whole thing took me through the all the airports here all the airports in America every stop and I had a lot and I'll tell yesterday I told the Israelis this is how it goes like the shum are difficult and Shi the guys said you know maybe we should do it a little differently start them and a week later do a shabat cuz we had 6,000 new people and here they come and like some of the wor who said yes painful sh thank you Elvis I appreciate I can always count on you yeah on Wednesday morning I had to get up let's just say I have to prepare a she right I didn't even see the do at 6:00 I was giving the shear so whatever hour I got up I'm not going to tell you what hour I got up but I got up really early 6:00 I'm giving the shear I'm done with the shear my wife says the taxi waiting outside it's still dark outside it's before thein it's a 2hour difference Utah and New York so we have a flight let's say it's 9:00 flight we get there that means it's 11:00 in New York by the time we landed in New York it was after in New York that's my day I get to New York to my brother light candles sit down and give a Shear in English I'm not done with the shear in English my wife is already in she's opening the door she taxi outside you got to go to the airport get to the airport to JFK yeah sit there in the people that's that flight is delayed a little bit get on the flight a whole 10 hours get on Thursday night after at 8:30 9:00 I had to give she here that is the life on the road it's not easy it's not fun and the Sho are not very good so um uh you stay in Israel real quickly I just want to read this email a very interesting story another day and how I got this guy was in mdy during a trip toik in Vienna Hotel not being able to fall asleep cuz the AC in the hotel room was not operating and my roommate was watching rebelli the entire night on a very low volume with assumption I don't hear this a guy not doing the shiria it was days before the started Bas kept giving the Ty message with classic reasons of why to join the after hearing this over and over all night long I decided I'll give it a shing ever since I'm enjoying the most amazing sh by belly even though it still not changed my life as of yet and still have lots more to improve but that gave me the most amazing gift of hoping to continue to grow and be able to share soon more life-changing things I've taken on I've been doing the cycles for a few years they even G gave a Shear in the D 5 days a week in Fridays and shabas we skipped as was not practical for the group we all needed to do it on our private time needless to say that did not really happen well what's tbhs what's TB to be honest this is the very first time thanks I did it each and every day without missing a single D and was to make listen to this my very first real see in 56 years here's a picture of the guy I'll show you in a second my very first real see in 56 years cuz he didn't miss a single da I made it a habit and just didn't go to sleep before the da is done oh no matter the time or circumstance that's that's the thing to make it a habit if you make it a real habit and he becomes part of you thanks to the most amazing sh I love the emails he loves the emails jokes and all the M that gets confused I find myself repeating so many quotes to friends in Gatherings also was and belly personally on my very first time of this year see the big event Shas had extremely uplifting experience from the entire made up of all walks of life United one family work behind the scenes Around the Clock give the most amazing gift here he is I guess he's the one sitting down the 56y old this is what's his name zon he came this is the first time in 3 years that he left his house the one on the right he really really difficult for him to communicate and everything thing um oh and he said at the end of his email thank you for coming over to no it must be on the bottom of this thing hold on if I could get out of it okay I forgot it's it's on the bottom of that email says his name and everything as you know uh real quickly my son AKA and Aon started doing the DA they only got one got $12,000 to do it the other one got 20,000 we're not talking about the money part they're doing the da so my son AA send us this video he has a cat it looks like the cat is very very into the do now very check this out it oh and now finally I gotta preface this I used to be a decent snowboarder I used to play basketball during co uh everything I because I didn't play ball in a year when I went back on the court I I couldn't move I couldn't do anything the next day and I gave I I had to give it up last year I had a big knee injury I couldn't even walk I was literally on crutches Ben used to pick me up twice a day and bring me back this that the whole thing I was I thought I needed surgery I still need surgery I need a knee replac then my knee started growing this way it's a mess so uh with with the r brought me a device I said I want to practice I want to I want to have a goal I want to be able to do a 180 back on on the snowboard to do a 180 it's most people don't do it it's like it's so I worked I wor my goal I had a workout every day to work out my knee and this and that to do the 180 I got there I couldn't do it first I was like I can't just after all that I thought I could do it and not but this is this is it at the finally second day after falling a few times hitting my head on the snow um it's not the great snowboard come very good it's not the greatest I'm not I'm not showing off I'm just saying for getting me that device that workout thing here it is [Music] good hold on it's not that great okay [Music] it's fun it's galic there's no snow to my masle you know when it snowed on the way to the airport started snowing all the out of 350 Trails or something only 20 of them were open so everybody was and this is mdy ah I love this license plate this is a great picture boys you're going to love this one it's such a great picture ah look at them they're m a guy on the left guy on the right okay V let's go oh this right have to to the the Ma sorry Mr and who what else I know there people there we got to learn some let's go we're holding the last last words an amazing oh if anybody knows of an editor or you're an editor this is how we found our great editor Kobe Kobe GID the the Hebrew editor we need editor for Hebrew we need editor fore English we're looking for editors people that with experience doesn't have to be the crazi experience we still teach you on the job and everything but we will okay so a great riddle here m is great yoseph man yesterday pretty much he was able to get it on his own how's it possible that a person gets killed for being over on ishish but the woman he was with is still mutter to husband now we know that aen iser to to be with his wife even if was so how is it possible that the co is still moted to his wife but we kill the guy so y started saying yesterday that maybe the husband testified against his own wife and therefore we have a concept of it's very good was a very nice guess that's why I said I don't believe he saw and knew about this I told him he's wrong because you're right we do but when the husband himself says that my wife was M that's called so he'll be AER anyways because he made it isra on his wife but if we take that idea we go a little bit differently the KV her own brother let's say testifies about her that she was misana with so him we kill together with another Aid so we have two Aid and one a is a brother one a is not a brother we kill the guy because they both testify he was misana we cannot kill her or do anything to her or even make her user on her own husband even though her husband is a Cen because he's a relative and we don't trust him when it comes to her we only trust him when it comes to him it's a Thing If just for that it was worth coming to the sh we could close the gar now but there's a little bit more fun stuff here alreadying two two words in the bottom if you want to do those two words inside so here's the mus called so and so was with my wife a man could go with another guy and be St come together to be a to kill the even though it involves his own wife we don't kill her what's the that you do you cut his statement in half you use one part the pl was a was a what what happened I didn't get there even oh wow we're not getting anywhere [Music] today from his great family that's another spor for is the best sponsor of all time third sponsor Larry member of started learning at age 70 and contined for 32 years until he was n you know what I'm thinking to myself now first time I never thought about it he was to live to 103 because he started learning Tyra imagine he wouldn't learn Tyra maybe what would he be doing s the retired guy sitting on his looking around guys that's why you wanted the sponsors he wants to say hello to his father for the fourth sponsor for the unity of the Jewish people the pares of the month we have five of them for f and complete [Music] we have two sponsors of the day and by Shalom K happy belated birthday to y k who listens to your every day ma and the Art of the month we have two of them now for Rebellion the whole MD staff to continue to make to so enjoyable for so many and in honor of Y kin and Mar askanazi for all the work they do says you split up a sentence that's exactly the same case as we had yesterday that a person testifies that so and so he had relations with me and I was willing I was a willing participant we kill that guy and we don't trust you about you we we divide the sentence in half I'll tell you this story there was once a rebba who you know the gab they get a little physical sometimes push people around you know if you're not so a gab went and he wasn't happy with somebody the way somebody was acting smacked him right in the face okay you're not going to do itaba gab half hour later the gab announ okay the re looks around and he says but there's no minion he says there is here look Aion he says no there's no is if you smack somebody not until you have to go ask you are pule for a minion so asks if a guy says so and so smack me can that guy be a it's also for him to be a if he smack somebody so do we do a he goes into it interesting St like how it applies the same we learned yesterday when a guy says so and so had relations with me so it's understood that you yourself you cannot testify by yourself that you're a bad guy there uh Manuel Feldman from Atlanta when he made alah I said the story before what's he comes to the what is it what's the office called when you come here the m whatever it is they say okay how do we know you're Jewish he says I'm a rabbi in Atlanta for 40 years what Jewish he says no we need a letter from a rabbi that you are Jewish he says look at your list I'm one of those rabbis that's that that that that writes letters for everybody else I decided that 5,000 people are Jewish what you telling me he said no but you need another Rabbi ain't person I don't know they didn't say that the guy that's what he meant it is it's em he writes in his book he writes in his own book it's a it happened to it didn't listen if talks abouto doesn't mean didn't happen to he's saying over about what he said it about himself he said it about himself okay great so good so we have back up to these already they these are m [Music] say so I would think that a person cannot testify himself that makes a lot of sense but he could testify about his wife person is not that close to his wife you are close to your wife no matter what you think about your wife and all these things that you do your wife you think she's this and this that and it's you're you're like you're like one so you can't testify about your wife and this is I'm talking about in the worst situation he Mish hates his wife now because he's he's accusing her of all sorts of stuff right talking about this is a terrible story you have a Niro between the age of 12 and 12 and a [Music] half she's engaged engaged means she's a AIS in the time of the she's however if they were testifying about the girl and the guy then both of them would be but they never mentioned who the girl is they want to protect her let's say they just say this guy is a bad guy who's over with who we're not saying who we don't know we don't know her name what's so you kill them oh did I miss a word sorry right they accused this this man of being they want to kill him then we find out that they're Liars they were on the cruise you cannot you cannot testify so what whatever they want to do you do to them they wanted to kill the woman so we kill them now they don't have to pay why would they have to pay well typically if they would kill the woman they make her lose theba the say M she loses but since they're not saying who the woman is so they're not trying to hurt anybody they're not nobody's losing so they don't they don't have to pay and what's the of course you can't make them pay for something they didn't want to do you can make them pay if they try to make somebody lose a then you you could you could be them but they didn't want to make her lose they never mention anybody's name they never mention a woman the answer is even if we find that lady later who this woman is they they still don't they still didn't try to hurt her they never mentioned her so now how much of a Cuba how much Cuba should they pay let's say they made her lose theba how much should they pay oh so like everybody said there's no there's no here let's say for instance let's say somebody uh hits a woman leeno and she dies did he make her lose auba well in a way had she gotten divorced later on she would have lost had her husband died she would have lost but her husband didn't die and her husband didn't divorce so what did she lose she lost something called how much is worth today you're looking at a young couple he's 25 she's 23 how much is Hera worth today the chances that he'll die in the next 50 years are very very slim chance that he'll divorce her maybe today it's getting worse and worse you know these divorces one after another the young couples but how much what it's a very bad option how much is this option worth on the market it's a 200 monba it's a it's a MBA how much is it worth it's worth maybe five out of the 200 I don't know how much it's worth I'm not paying more than five the chances so if these aen try to make her lose the but that's all they have to pay is five they didn't make her lose 200 she not getting divorced anytime soon anyway that's rash talks about it's not important to the Su go so that's in a case that we don't know she who she is but if they mention her name now they want to kill the man and the woman and we find out that the are liars they were they have to do both they have to pay and they have to they die and they have to pay ah we said we have famous concept called that if you die you don't pay so now we said already yesterday that's only if it's in one case in one situation but if it's in two different places two different goof over here they want to kill the woman and who do they want to make lose theba the father why the father because she's 12 between 12 and 12 and a half he's entitled Toba question that I had is isn't every Kim R chabas we I saw this the chart day a guy shoots an arrow it goes doas and it rips a shirt so you're and on the shirt you Potter why because it's you don't die and pay I it's two different the has nothing to do with the shirt the shirt is owned by Ru and the me is me so T talks about it okay [Music] fine I had it was very I'll tell you I was I was learning with my I didn't learn with him the whole week yesterday on the way back from the airport I called him said I'm here let's learn so I asked him this question so he tells me it's tus so he said he said he said my wife and my children heard that was a he says you know it wasn't always like this when you started learning with me but now every time you ask me a question it's usually he said but you used to ask me dumb questions kind of like that's what that's what he meant to say anyway it's good so they heard I said you heard that you heard stopped you heard yeah okay good I don't think my wife sh okay fine anyway shoots on shabas and he's over for the shooting yeah did he didn't kill the guy no no no no no no no it's it's that's don't worry about it that's it's a different so but it's carrying it's throwing object for will get in chabas B you're over on chabas in addition by during being over in chabas you also ripped the guy's shirt what you're saying is another story you could say that as well you killed somebody and you tore a shirt you're not you don't have to pay for the shirt the bullet that went through the shirt we had a guy in Chicago my my brother-in-law my okay somebody know from Chicago's father was shot I believe was shot by a anti-semite and it went through his his jacket and it didn't hit him went through his shoulder he has he has a a garment that has a bullet whatever so you kill a guy you ruin a suit also you ruin his life and a suit so he only pay for the life not for the suit to kills breaks at the same time that is when yeah it happens at the same time k let's go it's not the so it says it's two different people you pay for your life you pay for the money again another very similar story so and so had relations with an ax so he's for that but he doesn't say which ax and they die but they don't have to pay for the axe because we don't know which Axe it is they never made anybody lose an axe even though later on we might have found out who the ax is but if they say we they they they say this is the axe in that case they die for because they want to they kill the person they want to kill the person and they have to pay for the axe the axx is owned by somebody else completely this exact same case we just said before the same thing with it's the to the Father the the she's dying it's two different people we had a question what if a person testifies about his own person we said he can't testify about himself but he testify about his dog why not maybe a person is very into his own money here's a guy in China who's very into his own money he loved loved his car so he decided he wants to be buried with his car him and his car are inseparable even in death it's a beautiful car also I mean I can understand why we want to be buried with such a beautiful car people are M okay we you got the idea so he loved it so much so nobody else could drive it his family shouldn't be able to sell it for for any Prophet The Man loved this C anyway you think that listen but I a car is one thing what about a dog a pet right oh I said the story but because at the shabbaton this this guy that used to be a priest in Colombia and he became a g Yol gold was there was unbelievable Yol gold was UN phenomenal speaker if you we knew that he's a good video you know he does his he's a great speaker so anyways this Yol go did a whole story about him he brought back I think 600 people but he has 2,000 followers he brought back G when he became a g himself so he was there at the shabat one of the stories that's on your Gold's video that I saw that Mish moved me was that a guy got they're very very poor over there and they wanted to write a sa they don't have a sa what could I what could I give to the sa what can I give and he looks at his wife says you know maybe we just sell the dog it moved me a lot because anybody that I had a dog my son was he's still alive this dog Mando is in Los Angeles now to sell a pet people get so attached to their pet it's like it's like another family it's hard to understand when you don't have one but when you have one you understand and he went ahead and he sold it it's like selling your child for some people he went ahead and sold the dog to to make a few bucks to say donate to the sa anyway so says the gar all these are looking and watching it's like no no fast forward fast forward [Music] okay fine let's keep on moving this never happened so where are we holding I don't know oh got to pull this out the question they answered a person could testify that his bull had relation with another human being you kill the bull you killed the guy how do you know that when you give somebody malus with this something like this it hurts trust me so here's the you see the understand this is a regarding malus and it says it's plural two people two judges you can never have a even number so now we know it's three continue the next word next word in the POS and they shall be M that's another two another two so that's a total of six you have to make it seven you're saying it's the same words and those two I knew you're going to ask this I could have told you that you're going to ask this which I did once before it was unbelievable do you guys want to hear the story we in me middle and I showed him the it said like this ask this and this and this and that it said in my in myar I wrote it down I gave it to him I I know we know each other for so many years I know all this K I can tell you I knew he's going to and this is a different St that that K was um what is it called that when you already know something then uh no no no when the M says no so says the unbelievable thing not like no is actually changing it is is talking about the is talking about the the it's not even talking about the what how do I see aint in what do you mean where's the hint how do I know that gets malus we know that if a person is he wants to kill somebody he says false testimony about somebody to that that person should die you kill him he says money but sometimes you give him malus what is the case that we're even talking about says rash here's Rashi can look at the chart if you want sometimes he cannot do at all when when somebody says you testify this is not a good he's the son of a he's a so now what do you do to the guy if he's is of course he can't do anything but even if the Witnesses are and they're trying to get another out of his Kun they don't become benas they don't become why says you could only give to a person not his generations and what you're doing now is you're making all the generations you can't do that so what do you do what do you do to a guy like that giveus how do you know that in the hold on hold on a second you make make because he made a guy that's why this guy should be get I get it he's is great but what's why do you getus for that you getus for that check this out here we go here you have a and they say he's a rash okay so two come in and they toss these guys out why and now they they say he's not a Russ he's a that's what it [Music] means there's two sets of a the second set makes the original sadic aad he was a sadic two guys come in and say that he's a rash but those two guys were on a cruise ship on a cruise ship so the the the original guy remains a sadic he's not a Ros anymore so how do I know that I give the guys that were thrown out the window I give them malus that's what it means that we're talking about there's another set of so we're not talking about so now we go back to this you're asking me from this POS it seems like that there's six judges no the two judges talking about the that sometimes they getus where does it say does it say nobody together all the Israelis knew this and you guys don't where does it say we all know that as we just proved so it says you say falsehood if you say falsehood you get a whip it's a but it's a they didn't they didn't take action they didn't eat why is it a big Mas that we don't get CU every single one of us get malus every single day for talking sh let's say every day spend down boom boom boom it would be a big [Music] mess3 we just learn from the death penalty death penalty capital punishment is in a peas of 23 so to say the word 23 is instead of the death penalty says you have to remember this rash for the rest of your life I forgot to show to this yesterday for the Hebrew she I was in a different world I had this already was ready listen to this you're not going to believe this a lot of people say oh it's it's a little harsh no if if I light a fire I drive a car and sh I deserve it that's but I don't think what kind of business is this it's a little harsh the Torah is I don't know says rash the and as boo you do against your Bo your creator you went against your Creator first you have to realize he's your creator you go against his word he told you to do something you go against it it's not a little harsh you deserve to die and listen to what says it's like one of the four death [Music] penalties a fifth one it's called malus it's one of the five death penalties it's it's instead of it's in death why Hashem said don't say a lie don't testify falsely you testify falsely death penalty don't ask any questions because so why do you always have to look at a guy and say could he uh take the 39 malus not who cares give him the the 39 be let him die it's one of the penalties it's one of the five you never said oh if we Stone him he might die yeah he dies that's part of the thing there's a special word here called my brother you could you only could hit somebody that's alive that he's going to live there's a guy I just want to say this throw it out there not son but middle shabon by shabas a guy started having a heart issue he looks at ay and he tells ay my heart and he was in a wheelchair he wasn't so healthy so says okay and all the all guys come they take him out and uh they tell him okay we're going to the hospital he says I'm not going to the hospital I paid for the shabbaton I'm staying right here so he said so Mar says forget the money I'll give I'm refunding you the money you could go he says it's not the money I want to be at the shat he almost got a heart attack from the beautiful the the choir at K Shas my son also almost got a heart [Laughter] attack guy he certainly stayed I don't know if this is what I'm trying I'm trying to this reminded me I don't know if he's alive I don't know what happened over there said' rather be the first guy to die at the shat go to the hospital you rather be the first person to die the shabat and go to the hospital we have a whole and we have minus four minutes we're learning when it comes to malus the only way you can give malus is like this 7 plus 7 plus 7 you give 14 on the on the back seven on the front a total 21 if you could only give a guy six on the back uh six on the front and 14 on the back you can't give him you can't do that so you have to drop it down to how much let's say you know that if you give him 21 he's going to die you can't give him you can't give him 20 because it's not divisible by three so you have to be divisible by three so you go down to 18 as the gamar what's the big deal give him 21 and if he dies he dies why start hitting him give him 21 and if he dies that 21 let him die you said the whole problem is he's here he's a li he was when you gave it him and it's all good he has to be your brother after you done he can't die after you done he has to be alive when you're done okay unbelievable we're doing this great here great with minus time but that's how it works sometimes official a great girl if anybody has a I met her she's actually great plus all the of elite is reality welcome all the new standing with you on your journey to finishing sh together so it's very very simple we're not going to go into the deep things it's m simple we know there's a lunar year that's 254 days we know there's a solar year 365 days what did I say 354 and a bit and then 6 there's a solar year that's also a little off great the the the non-jews they go with the solar year the Arabs go with the lunar year the Jews go with both we use the lunar year fores and we use the solar year for and everything like that for the full year and we want to we like to line up the the lunar with the solar so we have the seasons it has to be it has to be a certain season you can't so the problem is that a typical lunar month is 29 29 days 12 hours and which means 44 minutes so you you can't just add a day and a this cuz it doesn't really add up have the 12 and you can't do months with half days so every once in a while we do a month of 30 days and a month of 29 rash says you cannot do more than eight 30 days per year because then you'll have a situation where the mot is 3 days after it will be a difference of three days and people say bz are no good that's not important to the what's important is that we do something called are months that are 29 and there are months that are 30 that we all know right great so say the it says in the just to see the list again why not this number 12 is you need three what does mean what does the word mean we know what it means what is you interviewed the ad that testified that they saw the moon and the says we know means they have to calculate what does mean means the 30th day the 30th day is part of the previous month that's Eber Eber like pregnancy like it's a little bit extended it's not 29 days it's 30 days the 30th Days part of the previous month on the 31st month but what do what do you have three guys doing what three what are they doing exactly it doesn't say that they're they're they're calculating whether you should do it or not which is actually one of the in the that's exactly what it means okay and it doesn't say that they're saying that they they interrogated the and that they they said so what do you need three they shouldn't make the 30th day they if they do the 31st day then it would the 30th day would become the would become Uber would become by itself all you need to do is on the 31st day and what happens the 30th day became part of the previous month on its own you don't need any intervention so says the so we have a bunch of the I just want to show you what I did this morning just to Benny you're here okay yesterday we didn't have this we have three she really when do you do says you can do on the 30 or the 31st says you never do that's when you do for you don't do anything when it comes to and then you have says 30 says 31 says 30 and 31 says zero so you have four sheas here [Music] really you have to take a word out of the mishna and replace it instead of the word you take it and you make it into I'll prove it to you it says you need three people for says Rashi we have to see this Rashi I know that we're Mish late I apologize Mish I don't have the rash here so we'll just see inside make a mistake sometimes he forgets he misses a word he'll never make a mistake in a word in a completely different mus inish so says the the on the day we have to add words he add you could add add you could but not not replace a word with a different word when you do the ibra on the 30 day is by the way real quickly the thei says and everybody knows this that when decide that a certain month is is on the 31st day not the 30th then a physical change happens in the [Music] world a three-year-old if a three-year-old depending on when is let's say she was n right before or right after in a one day difference her will come back physically according to the G so says the G by the way we're talking about that's one of the things the wanted to I forgot to say everybody one of the things want to get rid of is this idea right sorry we ready did that on the 31st day so look at this chart again is the one that says that you do only on day 30 not on day 31 what's I again Iber Means Day 30 so day 31 if you don't see the moon on its time you don't have to do on 31st day why 31 did it on day 31 like you see in the chart you do a k so is the one that say day 30 he says 31 so he says the same thing like but on a different day on 31 on day 30 you don't do on day 31 you do and that's you don't need to be according to there's no such thing as just should so on day 30 you don't need1 do need and fin it actually says it really means in the mishna the word ior means calculation sit down should we do it should we not do it sometimes it should be but they say it's not why because it doesn't fit in with will be a two whatever it is they decide and what does the word mean now why would the M use such a funny language so if you take a look at this chart 12 and 13 they say one says one says that's an hour so because 13 is so also on 12 it's really what the M wanted to say is it's just the same word it's easier to remember you could calculate you never say that's the on the left on the 30th day the 31st day never said this you could sanctify say this year the 50th year is but not a month have a wonderful day at regular whatever that is [Music] 8:30 thank you for coming I'm still horse for