0:00 / 0:00
Daf Yomi Review Sanhedrin Pages 75 to 81 at Bais Medrash Ohr Chaim
26 views
Video from the weekly Sunday morning Daf Yomi Chazarah class at Scheiner's Shul
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good morning everybody we're going
to pick up from the top
of try to get all the way to the end
of so let's jump right into it we're
starting from the mice on the
top there was a person he saw a woman he
got so upset he had obsession with
her got so sick from that Obsession and
they asked the r him what could they do
to heal
him the only way to K such a person
the with this
is it's better to do what it's better
that he shall die from his sickness and
not do Tash with her so what's the big
deal I got it do says no is a problem
but let her stand there aruma which will
help her at least calm him down and that
says of it's better that what
that he should die and not do such
a
okay maybe let them talk to each other
and that
says one wants to say she was M she
married
woman one wants to
say she was actually
a we can
understand we can understand why it's
better
what's the big deal let them get married
it's not such an issue forget about
marriage let
them there they're going to be
embarrassed even if she wants to be the
family is not going to
be don't want is and such a thing and
it's better to do and not have such a
okay let's
do let him get
married he's not going to calm
down we all know that stone waters are
sweet the breaded secrecy over here
we're talking
about is always secret you know him is
very pleasant
now we're going to a
new there the next we spoke about
it now we're jumping into who are the
people that
get is g to explain exactly what that
mean someone
who's his mother and mother mother and a
daughter we all know the tah says a
person that's get we all
know and and
then we're going to see nine
different the daughter his own daughter
his own granddaughter his son's daughter
one thing is
is
sorry his wife's daughter's wife's
granddaughter's wife's son daughter
another case
is his wife's grandmother his
mother-in-law's mother and his
father-in-law's
mother what's the case it should have
say very simple you marry someone who Bo
his mother-in-law rather it says
what you did both usually in a simple
case it's a
mother-in-law it sounds like very
clearly both the daughter and the mother
are both uses what's the case what's the
case the only case you could have it's a
mother law the AIM
and the mother-in-law's mother so we're
saying the daughter is not user rather
it's the mother-in-law and the mother's
mother-in-law the mother the
mother sounds like they're both written
in the the rest that we saw the other
nine
cases so we're going to see in a
moment when it says in the T if you look
at the says in brings
down means them so
it's what's it mean it sounds like you
what you're GNA what you're going to
burn your wife how in the world do you
understand that you're going to burn the
wife the wife did nothing so it doesn't
make sense of means Dam rather wants to
say over there we're going to see as
means one of them it's is one which is
the Mother-in-law however keep want say
no means two people but who are the two
people so wants to say means the
mother-in-law and the grandmother-in-law
we call it the mother-in-law's mother
however R wants to say means however
what referring to that when it's not
alive the mother gets burnt however not
g to get
however according
comes they both hold they get rather is
coming from a and is coming from
that
ACC that's coming from
the says what we're gonna
see to
read just means who his mother-in-law
that's all it means the mother that
after he married the
daughter we saying explicitly says
we have to mention the case of what
which is Mother we mention the
mother-in then we mentioning the mother
the grandmother-in-law
we mention the
what where do we know these n hey a
concept says in
the it says
however if you look in the very clearly
it clearly just says the mother and and
the mother and the daughter how do you
know the wife's daughter the
granddaughter our answer is since over
here
says we're going to see regarding the
end of the
of it says over there clearly explicitly
in the
grandchildren clearly
it
says we're GNA see in a moment
what gonna explain this in a moment
we're gonna go through
this again explain what mean
so we just quoted extensive now we're
going to break it up
slowly we
started so what's it
means what's that mean you going to tell
me means his own
children you want to tell me that what
the daughter the son's daughter is like
the daughter's daughter that's what it
means they're both clearly coming from
the from the
you're going to tell
me that the father-in-law's mother is
like the mother-in-law's mother has to
think about
it we never clearly we didn't find
clearly in the where you
get to start looking for the's mother
what's going
onwers this is what it's
saying means something
else we want to say own daughter and his
grandchildren we're talking about that
it's not his how do we know that has the
same that we saying the that it says in
both
places but if you look inside
the the
first clearly just
says look at
it's the famous that we made if you look
in the last word is and when you look at
it talks
about there it
says however in the third where it talks
about regarding a person who takes his
daughter a daughter and a mother it
says and over there it says also we're
making
the we're taking
the to
what once we
know we it up and therefore we know that
you
get so now we have to figure out what's
the either can mean two options either
means the we always find whatever come
first isalo or sometimes we have it that
over here we're GNA see it means your
wife is Lala and maybe your wife's
granddaughter is Lata or Etc or your
wife is going to be Lata and your wife's
grandmother would be let's go through
it so what's it
mean you're G to tell me means
means her son's daughter we
consider like we said earlier they both
comes you're going to tell me means why
Grand your wife's Mother's
grandmother that's what it means means
the
grandmother and means the wife that's
the other way
around no
it's means the grandmother is like the
wife answerers you have to read
it that your wife's grandmother is no is
the
same as the mother and the wife
where do you know to say the we have
your
wife number one to go down Generations
da number two and number three or to go
up is your mother and the
grandmother-in-law is going to consider
[Applause]
it clearly says
in and it says which weing by
regarding that
is this you read the
where do we know they make
what know such a
con and it
says we're making it what just
like that what her grand the
granddaughter is like so too you make
it you make it that the grandmother is
like the mother-in-law
however Rashi doesn't want to flip it he
doesn't want to flip the
whole that we have to read
it rather he says as
follows we're saying is not what we're
referring to which is
means and this is what it's saying where
do we know to make it that your
mother-in-law's mother and your
father-in-law's mother which is to make
it like which is like your mother-in
that and that we're saying from
the now if so his wife grandmother's
user the problem
is according to this it should be that
your own grandmother's and we all know
your
grandmother's a person can technically
marry his own grandmother the only
reason why
it's says over there no the reason why
your grandmother's
not says in
the let's slow down let's explain this
don't know know whenever you want to
make
aaz the question is do we do it
completely a double dip a double dip
over here would be that if you're
learning from for example you're
learning from a Isa which has courage
which has skila not just say the
punishment of
that it's us go go a second step and say
who the punishment itself whether you
going to say no we can learn from it but
the is going to be different you cannot
learn out the grandmothers Etc and the
wies let's go through
it just like you're G to say just like
you understand by the
wife let marry their wife's
grandmother you're going to want to say
so to your own grandmother should be
user why we know
just like your mother-in-law and your
grandmother-in-law
gets your own grandmother as own
grandmother should get
what you
hold person's his own mother-in-law the
explicitly says he
get how can you compare it to him we all
know a person who B his own mother
gets another issue
you're going to tell me let's see we
swallow that so it comes at your
mother's
B but your grandmother is B that makes
no sense she's further away than your
mother
[Applause]
we just like you understand by the
mother-in-law and the grandmother-in-law
there's no difference in the
punishment if you want to make a you got
to take it all the way if so it can't be
that your mother and your mother-in your
mother and your grandmother had
different punishment
from the last point that we said that
have different
punishments you can learn it
now what it mean means you don't follow
the
punishment just like your wife's
grandmother's AER so to your own
grandmother's AER
going to say no there by your
mother-in-law and your grand but you you
going have a
different you're going to get your own
grandmother you
get like your own
mother so
again I invol you can make
a we all know that regarding the wife's
mother different
punishments if you make EX has be
together just like your
wife there's no difference in the
punishment how could he make a
difference again from the last point
that we brought out do you have to take
it
completely if a person's own da we
know that's not true for example a wife
son which is your stepson's wife is
says so if you're making
the that says there's a reason why your
wife's your stepson's ex-wife is
not wants to
say so let's go through this
again we all
know we all
know your stepson's
wife
comp we know that is different regarding
who your own Mother's gets what
however you're going to tell me that
what that your daugh
get do we all know person
own and this is going if you think about
it who's much more to be bo a
daughter-in-law daughter is much
more the daughter in-law has a stronger
punishment just like regarding him
regarding mother
and that they're going to say that both
of them
get again from the last point because
whenever you make you got to do it
completely going to say the what
okay they're both however regarding own
daughter however regarding your wife's
daughter just like regarding person his
mother the
mother-in
with that his daughter gets
you can't have different
punishments how do you know if a person
does with they have a daughter and then
you how do you know
gets Now everywhere else it clearly says
rash
says however doesn't say your daughter
on that on that says on
you get your
granddaughter it's not considered it's
not
consider says is when a person says the
talks about a a sister from the mother
and a sister from the father how you no
complete sister and then we saying
however over here we're
saying it's not just
explaining as a granddaughter
itself the only way a granddaughter is
it's coming through the daughter
itself we're making that what that we
made earlier
of since we didn't
learn has to say we're gonna come for
the what's it say says as
follows if you look at
we all know it
says so come
out if a person is Bo his own daughter
why does he gets ra he's like the bo the
bo gets something else other
punishments the reason why she gets she
gets but he doesn't get
the he himself is doing
regarding a we understand that what she
get the is going to
have what do you want to
do over here what do you want to put us
where are you going to put the
punishment make her what make her
regular his own father has no choice but
to get the punishment so
where do you know the
from we
earlier that learns it from
the where does he learn from
says someone say a brother someone not a
brother
it's not really true it's not coming
to we need it for something
else if you think about it till now she
was able to eat Trum now they got
marrieds
what's his
what's one
is the other one if a person
does with his
daughter they're not coming
from his
da we're going to see why but the point
is that
cannot satisfy the wife with she's going
to end up
doing it's somebody that he doesn't want
the what he
gives there's no someone who we
explained that
once that what we mention so the
gives but you hold off to your daughter
you're keeping her as a mid you're not
a that we're
saying because he's poor he doesn't want
to give up his daughter he rathers use
her as a
maid you should be very
careful always be careful from who you
asking from advice make sure he doesn't
have his own agenda the second you
realize he's all about himself he's
really if himself you run
way all these
people all of
say whether the quench be attached to
the
Thirsty is not going to pardon he's not
going to forgive
him a person who loves his wife like
himself
and this is the pun underline this
words very clear close to the age
of says
clearly and you should not do clearly
not over anything so what are we talking
about we just said soone who makes such
a thing
as close enough in age Rashi says is
has no problem waiting in a half a year
till she's going to start getting from
her
husband he's she's realizing she's never
gonna get it and what is she gonna do
she's gonna
do what does it
say you cry
out will answer
you okay this is what we mentioned
earlier the
never going to go through it right
now because again there's no way we
could understand that a person does Tash
with his wife who's married to his wife
and he's B his mother you killed the
wife she did nothing B rather
say
two so one's coming from one's coming so
now here we have
the wants to say you know what they're
talking about
that just
means okay very that was we saw earlier
here's
the even though the on to the next case
of
her someone who murders we all know gets
killed someone who convince the whole
city what happens to the whole city they
get all get and and we burn
everything you have a murderer he hits
his friend with the stone or
metal he holds him down in
W or he puts him in the
flames you have to know somebody there's
a room on fire and you quickly hold the
door shut and he dies from smoke
inhalation sounds
like you push him into the water into a
pool and he could have easily took the
ladder and climbed out of the pool we're
gonna see even if he removes the
ladder leave from the fire
escape you let a a pitbull run out of
the cage and go and kill him or a
poisonous
snake you take the snake itself and you
put it on the arms then it's we're going
to see why the question is is the poison
Mish in the Fang of the snake or maybe
it's in the body and the and the snake
needs to do another action going to go
through with
any if you just take a little metal and
you throw it in a person's hand not
going to kill him the bar pies Pi rash
says either the the vest either the
lungs the brain somewhere where it's
very deadly
put him in water so we're saying the
says and the is going to
be what happens the guy is in a what
happens the guy walks into a room and
suddenly there's a fire all you did was
close the door and hold
a even though you push the guy into the
pool he could have easily used the
ladder to get out at the time that you
pushed
him how do you know when you hold
somebody
down says which
me to tell who confines
you now the says
was person took an animal his friend's
animal and put it in the sun
and it died from the heat we saw this a
little such a type of
thing only regarding
murder we know doesn't go to Etc however
when it comes to
damage we see the
his grandfather
was says in
the regarding the says what to
say to
us what happens you put a guy in a
prison room and you just lock the door
and throw out the key and he dies from
Hunger
you put a person in the Heat or in the
cold and he
dies
why oh so in such a case that's the
second
case you put a person for example it's
not yet hot yet it's not yet cold you
have to know maybe in the mountains in
the summer you tie a guy up and it's not
cold yet overnight he dies from the cold
because we're going to see it's Grandma
the whole point when you only when it's
m immediately that's when you
what if it's only going to happen later
then you
putter you put a person in front of a
lion why rash's M because there's no
hopes right you see what there a you see
the white beard say good night right
it's gone there's no chance he's going
to survive a lion however like little
bugs why cuz if he wouldn't have died if
he woulded have tied he would have rid
of the bug but eventually it gave him so
many bites that he
died he didn't die from the first bu
bugs eventually he came and killed him
whoever re wants to say you're because
just like by water you put a guy in the
river it's not the same water that
killed him rather it's other water same
thing with the bugs we look at as one
big
unit cuff all of gigas what happens you
take a barrel and you cover it and he
dies from the ear he dies from lack of
oxygen rash says from the h of the
barrel you have to know it's like a
garage and you turn on a car it'll die
from the it'll die from the
gas or you opened up the ma now he died
from the cold rash
says see
this wants to
say you tie a guy up and he died from
Hunger so you see clearly the reason is
because not immediately
B the person who puts a he puts his
friend in what in a marble chamber he
makes a candle then he dies again from
the candle from the from the
ear if he want to lit the candle he
wouldn't
be without the candle you would have the
sorry it would have happened immediately
the second you close off the barrel
there's ready no ear the person's going
to die it might take a few seconds but
just gets stronger and stronger and he's
eventually going to die from lack of
action or the
H
Sim whether it's a ladder a shield some
means medicine regarding a w we're going
to go through a four a bunch of little
things that ra is going to say regarding
the that we spoke about if it's not
immediately if you're able to save
yourself
immediately you're
not you throw a guy pit but there's a
ladder
there you quickly go you push him into
the pit if you hop the ladder You' get
up but you took away the
ladder even if you throw the guy into
the pit then you go and take the ladder
po the second you threw him
in he was able to go up therefore you
can't
you throw an arrow the guy has a shield
therefore the second you threw the it
wasn't you weren't going to kill
him you have to know how he got there in
time the second thing when you when you
sent it out the shield was able to
protect
Arrow you throw a thing and attack hit
him
now you throw it in a place he was able
to take a thing to plug up the
hole someone else took his medicine away
or the
bandages he took away the bandages part
the he was able to save
himself if so should come out that even
if he's able to go to the Shook and buy
himself bandages or you have to know
today if you're able to call it it's not
my
fault what is to make the case easier
comes and says we're willing to help you
and you'll survive but he says I'm not
interested and he dies what is do we
say since he was able to sell him since
he was able to save him or the other
side is when you shot the bullet there
was NOA here happens to be member passed
by that's the case that was
punked we're not going to be and the
reality is he Tako should have saved
himself by utilizing whatever it was
whether it was bandages members that's
not the point the point is he's able to
save
himself so what's that mean rashi's M in
those days they had an interesting
game today we call it racka ball pick a
ball one of those things or or hand ball
they take a ball they throw it against
the wall and the the cavana is to throw
it as hard as possible you throw it
against the wall while second you let
over you run as far as you can and the
point is it takes long enough for your
friend that's playing by time he catches
it you're gone that's how you win the
game it sounds like or you can't throw
it him something like that because we're
going to see that a person throws a very
heart so as
follows person throws a rock or a hard
B and it bounces back from his strength
and it kills
somebody this the ball that we're
talking about this game that you
played go
is what is the regarding but the point
is that if a person says you better be
careful you're playing in a very
dangerous area because it can kill
somebody the way we look at it we look
at
a and there say that the she that is
what is
it's a V when you're playing such a game
that it's going to bounce
back however
it's what's the
case if he's happy where the bull went
what's the
difference but if he wasn't happy it
went 100 feet to kill somebody
like we explained earlier when you throw
the ball the whole Cav of the game is to
throw with all your strength so there's
no to say less
than therefore
it's your Potter because he never he
doesn't want it to be the whole game is
it should be much
stronger such
AE it's m strength what are we saying
you threw the ball it bounced back
against the wall and a rich right it
bounce and hit somebody else so you want
to say that's
consider that you need to do
with theas so what do you see over there
even though
it's into the
Bas answer no no no no we know where
it's where dripped it went on its own
try to bring another
Right Touch the for
example now sitting on
and you poured water t in
it basally you have a needle it's on
shards and whether you poured it
directly or you poured it On A Shard and
it bounced off and
went bounced off as long as says needs
to be it should be should
be don't read it
SP you found it wet now you have another
option maybe it got wet not through
whether it dripped or something else
that's so got wet therefore it's still
possible person ties up his
friend so imagine you're sitting either
by a big large aquarium where he's
sitting by the seashore the point is you
tie him up so he can't run away and then
you smash the glass you smash a barrier
and all the water comes and drowns
him say it's considered not arrows
if for example three blocks over there's
an aquarium and you smash the aquar
three bucks over and only gets you later
that we considered a and
therefore you take a rock you throw it
very high or you shoot a bullet in the a
same type of concept it went
sideways what you going to say
why I don't understand if
go
up it should immediately fall that's
what happens when you throw something
without any energy it falls right down
the way we look at it
is the way we look when someone throws
something it go sideways the way we
understand that it's your it's your
energy but the way energy works it gets
lower weaker and weaker weaker and
eventually Falls however there's no shil
if you're on a rooftop and you take a
rock and you see somebody walking by and
you drop the Rock
and gravity goes and kills
him it's a very
famous you have 10 people they start
whacking a person with clubs with sticks
and he dies whether they do one two
three they all Whack
Him
however the last
one you might say the guy was about to
die either way doesn't make a
difference and therefore
they're both coming from one why it says
in the as
follows a person who what who Hur
somebody call that what that has to be
completely means any part of
the the only reason you is when you
completely kill
someone means any part of
the person a that what says whether he's
his brain dead or his lungs appear
pierced and he's not going to
live however if a person a he's M about
to die then he's
then you however
you
answers that's nature however you went
and went veered off nature once you veed
off nature we could want to be
regarding
a we're saying their organs what the
vital organs were caught but this was
not says in
the your person what he wounded him he
doesn't he's not going to kill him did
the final knockout
it's what have otherwise my answer is
no you you hurt the guy enough that he's
about to
[Applause]
die like we just
said they said any is good enough enough
we learned means
any now we're going to see four
different the says more or less till the
two dos
statement from is a person that kills a
he's
poter we're going to see
why however you're sitting in front of
the b and a tra comes starts killing
people he gets
killed to tell us he must destroy bad
and he's bad
since here we understand that what how
could he kill him because he's a TR that
what how could you kill me that's not a
therefore that's one
another
however
only
again
Tom what's the
difference the person who goes
and just like a person with a dead
body the reason
why the only reason is it's a dead body
it's cold there's no that's
why
regarding another
they were made a they got
busted you have to know how to give
maybe he became a TR you know maybe they
didn't know he was a TR because we just
said he don't
do like we said however want to
argue why
even the reason is still
even though
it's we want to
say they're not going to
get they're not going to get killed
however ra is going to argue ra wants to
say
since therefore he's going to get killed
of because
of not the final statement from as
follows what is you have a ax that's
going to die and he kill
somebody the is healthy but the person
himself is
a
says we all know this we learned this
many
times is a trade just like the B
wouldn't get killed so too you don't
kill
the raash
is we
saw according to
clearly you have to understand that the
way we look at a snake where's the
poison we saying the Poison's Mish in
his mouth so the second you take the
snake it's like no different than a
person taking a syringe full of poison
injecting with somebody
it's he's going to die the person who's
doing
his is no
different than aing
however wears it in his
body brings it the
body the is doing
it is poter why because it's only
Grandma I didn't do it the snake did it
I caused the snake maybe to trigger
reaction you got him upset but he pulled
out the poison from his
own person heard killed heard his friend
whether it's with stone or where his own
good old Knuckles they said you know
what this guy is not going to
survive you got to recovery back to
stable
condition
Bo next thing you know minutes later the
guy
passed you know what let's be real he
got into the stable condition suddenly
died maybe it was a different reason why
he died aners him heart attack but
nothing to do with the
beating says in the as follows he gets
up he goes outside either power or mean
on a cane but the point is he got
healthy
enough we're learning it means the guy
who hit him is cleaned he's absolved
he's done he's
to say you heard a guy then what
happened and he's walking around I got
it he's walking around with a cane cuz
you made him limp but you have going to
kill
him they said you know what the guy's
Dy then they said he's back to stable
condition and then we read it perod
then and then he suddenly
died why soon as you get up stable
condition you're
done we put him in prison until we
figure it out till we know 100% that
he's going to
survive we not arguing that you put him
in prison where would he know that
from he learns if we all know from the
when he was gathering it
says they clearly put him in a
prison why doesn't
learn answer there was
you just didn't know didn't know what to
kill him
with therefore you can't learn enough
from what from
the he learned from the there we didn't
know still
it say says
clear it was not clarified
what's says in
the sracing
follows what it mean
should have said as
follows a person waxs his friend whether
it's with the rock or his
knuckles why does it say two extra stuff
what does it say says why do you have to
say he didn't die number one and it
says why do you need these two things we
call them they're two extra Dres in
the we have and we have which is extra
to tell us two
points says even though they said he's
going to
die the cas you would have know
what this guy had zero chance of
survival you killed
him gave him back his life therefore
should got
killed like we said earlier top of since
he got into stable condition the second
he gets into stable condition he's po so
according to you have two two extra
things in
the to tell us even if it was a back his
life to tell us the second against the
stable condition you're
po however according
to why do you need both
okay we can understand
why answer
the the case is we ended up
dying they decided that there's no
reason why you're going to say he died
he
died you didn't need a to tell us that
if the Bas evaluated him and the doctor
said he's not going to die and then
suddenly dies that
you going to die he Live's
the moment we valuate right now how much
it's going to
cost you go after
the we don't just say oh
he rather what are we going to do you're
G to kill him
we
say
when
this that's the difference with
the person has to kill animal he's a
hunter next thing you know he killed a
person by mistake
all these
cases his growing area it would to kill
him ended up hitting his heart and it
killed
him you want to hit him in his
heart would killed him
if it would have hit him in his heart
okay the heart it would have killed him
but would have killed him his in his gr
would have died but he died for whatever
reason the guy was a big person you have
to know why it's so much tall in age
forget about it what about a big heavy
person that a punch wouldn't kill him Ed
up
again now we're say
was To Kill
A Punch like that went to kill the but
still kill
the you give a guy you want give a guy a
by his and it would have killed him so
powerful let's say bullet guy shoots a
bullet a CH he's gonna die his
heart same thing with a god you give him
a kna punch would kill the
god you miss to hit
the now we're going to see right away
the going to jump into what is talking
about where's the
case the last case for example the case
is what they want to
say the since it was powerful
what's it mean what's this whole
statement you're going to tell me what's
going back on the ra what do we start
the mission
with you want
to you
are therefore we want to say such a Cas
so why why we have to put why do we put
all end of the why don't we put at the
end of
the on that we wanted to say that don't
think in every case on even on the case
of in such a case if there was a
powerful to kill you
be
follow guy sees he's a hunter he sees
what if he says I don't care who I hit
whether it's he says I want to hit a
whether
it's he he killed
him what is in such a case do we say
it's considered wanted to kill the guy
or if you would have known aim you want
to kill
them the only time
want to
kill quickly jump on
him this one of the most famous they
bring
this gonna tell me the what he threw a
roack at the crowd there's
and this
one even
50 this we learning out from this is the
of is only when for example you shoot
something into the ear and the chances
are nine out of 10 people are going to
be yiden or even six we say R however if
it's stationary
it's we say even the we
say
is we know this says in
the two people are fighting and they
mistake hit a
woman they hit a pregnant woman by
mistake and it
says the is refering to somebody is's
trying to kill how do we know this we
know if he doesn't kill he just hurts
he's we
know so it's clearly
that if you didn't have to kill how
could you kill
him so according to the question is
according to what are you going to do
with such a case you hold
aners it
means
says it
says there means clearly
now we
have
ACC the case of
what however we're going to see that
according to not and you're
not what says
the just we know
we all know regarding only going down
you're not going
up regarding the
com GNA
read so according to
anything you weren't having you wanted
to kill somebody
else clearly
see
so it's clearly not like
that's it's not
like and it's not like RAB that's
you see this by lot when people run away
from the M they run into a crowd next
thing you know you can't find the guy
right so what is this guy's a he's a
murderer and he jumps into a room full
of people we're GNA see who are those
people what do he do now's gonna explain
who they are
everyone's everyone got to go into
prison going to
see is a death
sentence we starve you and then after
your stomach shrinks we give them barley
so their stomach
pops they get the easiest
one for example what happens you have a
room
everybody's but one jumps into the
room you have to get the
we wouldn't give it what do you
mean and we went through this back and
forth very extensively earlier in
the and we said over
there again the same type of thing who
we give him the so what is this who are
these people in the room we going to
tell a guy runs into the
room it's that he's part what do he want
it to
be why would he put the CH into prison
so we're going to
see bring it down then it means
that the Sim is for for the B sh is and
is
so let's say you have death row very
simple we're talking about a murder that
they didn't pass in yet it wasn't didn't
have so he runs into the death
row you have no choice because you don't
know who he
is therefore you can't kill
him let loose the
right and they end up dying in the keep
people we're not going to kill them
we're talking
about we're talking about moment we're
talking about
AC we put him in a
prison how do you understand this
even my father have to know how he said
he talk his father maybe said first even
my
father so how could he talk like
that whether you're talking
about he's a who cares who he is number
one and if you're talking about what is
the person
this is what it
means two people are
standing you turn around you see two
people now and to killed somebody it had
to come from one of
them even the standing there there's no
to
think because you can't prove
it however this is what it
say what do we say which are innocent
still we don't have to give them says
the reason is rather they die from
Hunger that died that
killed gave
bir if it gave birth
before however wants to die
not only that it got mixed up
twice we put them into the
prison says
me still we put him in prison which is
who
we we
say even
the reason why we say the is because the
way we look at it when you have a
pregnant ax it's not just ax it's also
the is part of it
so Amy you have to read
it after underline the word first
after me what
happens he's not part of the he wasn't
he didn't do anything and he's a and
this V is coming from the
father okay no problem
which is the came
from you have to read
it it became part of the mother that's
why
we said that you give him the if you're
not right
away so the question is has a what
is over here we should see the we have a
good good R
why you gave a guy SK he ended up going
and hiding with a bunch of people with
her how could you kill him when you give
you give for you automatically G
[Music]
however there there's no about it they
didn't even know what to kill he just
said he's going to
die and there you cannot learn out from
other d
we said you have a room five of the
people all deserves he deserves so we
give him what we give
him tells his
son so you have a full give
one his brother tells him R's brother
tells his father his brother why you
learning this
what is it you have a room think about
it we have a room everybody gets one guy
gets we're saying you get
why forget
about he
says see answer back how you going to
learn the safe for the next
case when the room is full of we say get
what
say and there the is what
he tells him how he learned and he
answer
back how you can
understand you have the exact same
question nothing to do with
according
to it's nothing to do with rather has do
with the reason why he give
him the reason why you're going to go
give
him in such a case that we're saying in
the
sa there was saying no and that's where
you should get
my smart one you never should have
talked like that to your
father you don't speak like that to your
father it's embarrassing
it this is what it
says just says XYZ and the father's
knows right away he's doing something
B okay we are the the
final you get for example going to
see it
get
now you're gonna
get you get the first zik we're going to
see if marries if someone marries so the
mother-in law is not an so now
you're and then she becomes an you get
but if you marry a typical girl
she's really we're going to see maybe
say first that's what zik zika usually
means the marriage that's
first you have a to say that what you
should not get the why do you have a to
think you should get the C why should
you
benefit the guy let's say was
they decide that they're going to kill
him and execute
him you have to know how you did maybe
ran away because we learned when you
execute him it's
immediately then he went was Bo his
mother-in-law you say the guy's ready
dead person you don't go over and bring
him back the best andash we're going to
slap you back and we're going to start
the procedure
over to give you the punishment
know says in the following in
the it's quite extensive it says this
follows someone who gives birth a
violent
son means
murder and then the
says the
mountains with someone's
wife he do
the person murders
gets so the
ready three different
punishments we always
know so clearly see that what he's three
different punishments
get I the whole and as
follows me doesn't mean someone who we
know about the gets killed because he's
going to
be us do
mean he should have said over
the why he pick
these he's coming to tell us when
there's three different punishments you
get skill
he doesn't need the that's what har
always means the you don't need them
because
[Applause]
he's whenever something is unlean
whenever you embarrass it's disgrace
it's definitely live
only if you do all these stuff that's
when you live otherwise not tells his
friend he says no says in the regarding
all these
of you're GNA tell regarding all
the can say one of
them one of them you're ready going to
be so what's
mean says the cas is for
example he
get why because the
concept
so okay I got
it your mother-in-law is now she's
could the rest of the world marry her
the answer is absolutely she's not user
that's good to you but now when she go
to marry somebody else comes
that's doesn't
apply
ansers betay you're not making sense
what are we talking about the only case
you have such a question is what a
mother-in-law that
became an aous is so what do you want to
do you're
what do you want to do give her you can
only give her one punishment you give
her
this gets
twice they put him in they give
him till his stomach
splits just because the person getus
twice gon kill
it what are we talking about
you deserve to die and it's going to
happen
however you're ready to bring it on
quicker we have no problem we'll finish
you
off when a person does it with one
specifics over and over that he's
it's very clear two is good
enough even three
[Applause]
times need three
times here you have three times what's
the third time the A and the a is what
is what is
you don't need the and therefore even is
going to
be
however is what you
need is what gives you the
is going to go
like is going to go like R
says therefore you already have three
you need another one for
the gives we all know you need to
validate and say
yes and you stay
quiet he nods his head but doesn't say
anything verbally
what bring
prison there we're clearly not talking
about so what would be the argument you
know what
say to put a guy in prison need
therefore that's the do you need three
or four times
everyone on the three therefore you put
in the even though he didn't have
regarding the however is going to hold
you need to have the what is that how
big is this
prison prison enough as long as his
height says but where do we know that
it's in
the the death of is
evil a person doesn't know when he's
going to die just
like they get stuck in evil
trap like a fishook a fishook it's small
and it's quick and next thing you know
they you catch the
fish we're going to see what that means
how be able to kill him if there's no
Witnesses we put prison what do we do we
give him very little
bread and very little water so simple
question if there's no how you going to
put him in
prison we're talking about very
specific two valid however the says they
both need to see each other if one is
from one window and doesn't see the
other window you can't kill him but
we're not going to argue B if the guy
has two Aid them so therefore we throw
you in
prison we can't kill you but we know
what
happened is man time or regarding and is
like what color was his
clothing we all know there was a murder
on the Fig Tree and they asked him how
big and how small were the
figs if you look at the top of theing
malus what does it say regarding the
prison we throw him in prison give him
barley he ends up his stomach splits
you first put him in prison you give him
very little food till his stomach
shrinks now that his stach shrinks what
he
do perfect time you give him
barley and they explain the first Miss
where it's Mal need to tell us you want
explicitly say that you're going to kill
him so you mentioned the barley where
it's clearly says he's going to die in
the next Mish we know you're going to
die we explain the first part of the
procedure okay let's see this final
Mish we're to see
like gives with Supernatural
Powers so we're talking about
all not the brothers bring
to and they kill
him
[Applause]
withs you don't do anything
it's
a says in
the it
says regarding the shelving tubes upon
him where they have little tubes that he
put in the rooll just like you see by
Bakery those tubes that you can put in
these long
baguettes they shouldn't see the
inserting of the whole why because they
might
die what he says
is I want my what I want my Supernatural
power to destroy to
hit
destroy kill the enemy
creat and their provider in such a case
he's going in such a case we all
know going to pick up with the very
famous of Bo har next week