Daf Yomi Pesachim Daf 12 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabbi sai just starting to pile in how's them doing today's share is sponsored by a new member akiva fold in honor of his brother avigdor for convincing him to come to this year he's very appreciative also sponsored by schmucker gottman leading newsmaster above ram bin oyser all of us should continue learning with us and be part of our sheer shots together with all the new guys shia greenfield and yossi kline is for the delicious sushi dinner you sent me two nights ago by the way i don't eat ten rolls you could barely eat one but amazing this gives me a lot of simcha we know hilo kamianski is in los angeles on a business trip so what does he do when he goes to los angeles he goes to visit someone from the deaf who he's never met but he feels like he knows him this is harry shalom if you look closely of course there's the mdy magnet and if you look really closely through the window i'm not kidding you'll see ellie stefanski hosted bobblehead that raboisai is begeth zara i don't know that it's a it's problematically a quick email from schmuliweisfish we love schmule he's 12 years old he says mazato rebellion your 48th birthday i wish you that you should have many many more tell me them this one is from you the shuster i'm hooked i just started listening to you sharon aldaf a few days ago and love it by the way it's the only share on all that i think that has video i'm at home under quarantine and can't go to my regular sheer so i found yours maggot shear is in trouble it will now be hard for me to go back to the sheer and troll once i'm out of quarantine yehuda shuster this rabbis is from a real character you swallow shilitsky managed fine if you if you stay on zoom after you hear something yesterday he was talking about khalavi small als all sorts of stuff he says ellie this is from donald trump himself you're doing a wonderful job explaining gemara maybe when i leave office in four years i'll join the daf donald nobody wishes happy birthday better than me let's make daf yoimi great again and this is from yoshi schloss by the way i need to say a quick mazel tov to phil barone his son mati got engaged says i just want to say a huge thank you for your beautiful enthusiastic daily shurim and a massive thank you to my holy brother another brother thanking his brother menachem schloss if you live in rbs you know menachem is for introducing me to the sheer thank you to no ends for giving me real purpose in my daily life yasi shlosh tyra is keeping us alive you'll see now it's your chance or your job to get menachem to come to the chair he was here for a few a few uh weeks months i don't even remember all the way in the beginning all right it's always good tell the other guy to go this share you yourself you stay home get valdic zak the hello gemara all right so we're in middle of very interesting sugiyah you have two witnesses that witnessed a murder unfortunately and they're off in the way they say the time that they saw it at so yesterday we had we're gonna see six different possibilities here we have a macholic is between rabbi mei rabi huda and it's very interesting the way it works sorry mayor says what's going on is one aide said it happened at two o'clock the other eight said it happened at three o'clock upgraded the the chart today more colors nicer better so this is eight one eight two eight one eight two and this is when the actual murder happened this is how we're gonna have it in all six cases eight one a two and the actual story once at two o'clock once at three o'clock says abaya according to a mayor no one makes a mistake when it comes to time people are very punctual when they're testifying on a murder case they do their research they know exactly what time it is and there's no contradiction between the guy that's at two o'clock and three o'clock because when the guy says two o'clock in fact what he means is 2 59 and the guy says 3 o'clock he means 3 o'clock and we're talking about that the story happened right between 2 59 and 3 o'clock it's as it was leaving as it was leaving the second hour so they're actually talking about the same exact time 2 o'clock and 3 o'clock equals 259 and 59 seconds it's the same exact millisecond there's no stirrup review on the other hand says the first aide said three o'clock the second aide said five o'clock the story happened the murder happened at 4 30. so people could confuse they could be confused by a half hour according to this abaya in rib yehuda ramayana says they're not confused at all hold on half hour the story happened at 4 30. three o'clock equals 3 59 because you can go all the way to the end of 3 o'clock so between 3 59 and 4 30 you're talking about a half hour plus and the guy that said five o'clock he's at five o'clock so the difference between 4 30 and 5 o'clock is 30 minutes so they are not contradicting each other when he says three o'clock and he says five o'clock there's no contradiction we could accept their adults their testimony okay now we're holding on that viewed all of them base five lines from the bottom it's a new lotion in abaya quesadillas okay so he changes it literally by uh by a second before he was saying that you don't make a mistake even in the millisecond now he's saying it's possible to make a mistake on a macho in a second once again i'm not even going to change romero's chart from the first launch and the second last time because it's you're talking about a millisecond i can't even describe a millisecond in the chart story either happened at 2 59 or 3 o'clock difference of a second and once again one guy said three o'clock other guys at two o'clock he says 259 he might have been off by a second because it really happened that three o'clock is off by a second and a person can make a mistake in a second okay so that's pretty much the same here's the difference before we said a person makes a mistake a half hour in a month now you say no a person can mistake time by a full hour you're talking about a generation didn't have clocks didn't have phones didn't have anything so they made a mistake by an hour he saw the murder throws 11 o'clock and at 12 o'clock what happened the mice happened either this is where it becomes interesting we need to understand this better it happened in either two two times it's not a specific time it either happened at the end of the third hour 3 59 or at the beginning of the fifth hour again one eight says three o'clock one eight says the second date says five o'clock according to review that's the different aidos than what roommates are saying three o'clock and five o'clock and a person can make a mistake with a full hour so what's the worst com worst case over here when he said three o'clock he actually meant 359 the difference between 3 59 and 5 o'clock is an hour and a minute okay so a person can make a mistake in an hour in a mushroom what's the big question here but maybe it didn't mean 3 59. maybe he meant three o'clock he said three o'clock maybe that's what he meant why don't you ask him you're dealing with killing a person based on this testimony you're gonna kill a guy because maybe the witness when he said three o'clock you mean 359. that's how you kill somebody you have to you have to be really certain that the guy is a murderer okay so the kumar is going to deal with that so nakamura one guy said three o'clock the other guy said five o'clock the guy said three o'clock will will translate that to 3 59 the guys at five o'clock remains at five o'clock the story happened either at 3 59 or at five o'clock so this guy made a mistake at most either he's exactly right 359 equals 359 so he's perfect at most he's off by an hour and one minute 3 59 to 5 o'clock and that's okay that's all within in hebrew they say the tekken it's all within the standards it's okay it's okay to be off by an hour and one minute according to this shot and i buy let's see it inside the review the last line on your alif i'm based on players show natural person can make a mistake in an hour and a little bit myself and the mice and shahada the murder happened either at 359 or at one of them made a mistake with an hour as studies explains we're dealing with one guy making a mistake to say that two guys made a mistake a little bit more difficult it says the gemara ozal de ravi so ravuna the son of judah says this over to rava it says this following it's very nice for you to be down the cafes and say look these two witnesses are not liars maybe he made a mistake a mistake when he said three he meant 359 that's a beautiful thing but based on this limous cross you're gonna go mur kill somebody give somebody the death penalty based on this limous close that's not very nice omar and not only that maybe the guy that said five he's the guy that you have to change what he said and five means five five nine so in fact they're three hours almost apart from three o'clock to six o'clock or five five nine two hours and 59 minutes how can you kill somebody based on a testimony like that this is garbage testimony throw it out misfaker we're going to kill somebody because of the suffix to search deep and try to save this guy's life not give him the death penalty the way though it's supposed to save him hello you're right we're not going to translate his words and we're not going to say when he said three men 359 we're going to take it to the extreme okay what's the max the ba however we're changing it a little bit people mistake two hours adam taylor stay shy two hours i saw a joke today uh it could be it's a joke could be emma's but they said that somebody gave over a pill to deny the huda took him four hours when he was finished it was hard to believe that another user sit there for four hours another looks and he says you're not the that's not the this is the mayor's the guess is why he says because according to her mayor adam taylor stations according to you thought i'm tired you were taught of foreshadows anyway so but to remember the idea adam taylor stay choice other toys charlie choice a person can make a mistake two hours according to the mistake the time of the day by three hours so let's see it inside how does it work so the first date said it happened at two o'clock the second aid said it happened at three o'clock the mysore the actual murder happened either and this is hard to wrap your head around but the story actually happened it could be in two different times either two o'clock or 3 59 so if we stretch the two o'clock and we don't do anything to his testimony we don't say maybe he meant this maybe he meant that we take it at face value when he says two o'clock he meant two o'clock but what what's the worst that it went from that the murder actually happened at 3 59 let's call four o'clock so from two to four is two hours minus a minute and that's okay that's within the standards the person can make a mistake stay shy this guy that said three o'clock forget him he's less than two hours but the worst case scenario if we spread it apart as much as we can the most we can go is from two o'clock to 359 which is less than two hours and that's within the standard and therefore the testimony stands his eight this is two o'clock easy this is three o'clock it's what it's all within the standards the mayor of toyota a person can make a mistake a little less than two hours myself the story happened either at the end at the beginning of two two zero zero or at the end of three three fifty we're not talking about that nine made a mistake we're saying at most the most the most that he made a mistake here is two hours and that's within the standards what about review though a person makes a three-hour mistake for the last chart the final case the sixth case the mice happened either at three o'clock or five five nine almost at six o'clock the first date says three o'clock the second eight says five o'clock the difference between three o'clock and then when the mice happened is three hours minus a minute between three and six o'clock minus a minute 5 and that's within the standards according to review the review that says the person could mistake a three-hour difference he'll think it's three o'clock and in fact it's six o'clock that's okay and we can kill somebody based on that testimony tanaan okay i'm going into sugin in sanhedrin we learn from the psukim it's exercise that we ask the witnesses we cross examine them we interrogate them we ask them seven questions khakiras and then on top of that we ask them a bunch of the decoys what are the what's the difference means and this is now don't make a mistake here that it means a week it means what cycle of shemitah one which one of the seven cycles in the 49 year cycle of shmita is it did you see the murder 25 years ago yes okay so what cycle was it in we're not talking about a guy said he came to bed after the murder he was scared for his life the mafia threatened him now he wakes up he wants to do true he wants to testify so i need to know first of all what cycle of the shemitah now second question and it goes in order beisu'shana now what year was it of the cycle beijing month of the year become the baha'is and what month of the month was it what day of the month was it beijing what day of the week is it now texas asked a bomb question here why do i need to know what day of the week it is if i know what day of the month it is i just look at the calendar test above kiss slave falls out on the tuesday show mali israel why do i need it okay so it's a very sad cost of that we asking this thing or according to what we said yesterday that the two witnesses they were off on the day of the month once a test of once it has zion but they both said tuesday it's it's a good testimony why because they one guy made a mistake on the ibrahimovic says tyson's okay fine but i asked him these seven questions and what place okay so those are the seven questions that i ask that are the rights of questions there's no way out of them i must ask these seven questions now there are questions that are ridiculous i asked him do you recognize the guy what clothing was he wearing dark white what kind of gun did he have what did it look all these little questions what's the difference is the gemara mabi is the decoys if a person says i don't know what time of the day it is bottle a this is battle why because as the gemara is going to explain we'll just say there you eidos has to be a dos a testimony when it comes to capital cases you you want to kill somebody you want to give him misa's best in it has to be added means that another set of witnesses could come and say imanu those are the words in other words you reuven who are testifying that you saw the murder you're a liar you're with us in disney world when at this and this time now if the guy doesn't know what time it is what day it was then how could those guys do hazama and say you were with us in disney world when he doesn't even remember he'll try to wiggle his way out i was in visiting world at ten o'clock not at two o'clock and i don't remember what time of the day it was okay so says the gemara if one of the two witnesses says i don't know what time of the day it is or i don't know what day it was i don't know what week it was they do something taylor the decoys but if somebody says we don't remember what color clothing he was wearing it's a good testimony between the interrogation part of the torah of the sev once you wiggle your way out of one of the time periods now you can't say manu isa even the machine if you say it was in new york so now that adam can't say emanuise i'm in florida why because i never i said i don't remember where it was so you have to know where it was once you don't know where it was you don't know what time it is it's over masha'enke is either but if if they both say we don't remember what clothing it was that doesn't hurt the hazama another set of adam could still come and say imanua isam you're lying you're right you don't remember what color clothing it is but you're lying that day and time that you said that you witnessed a murder you're with us at a different place and therefore they will be killed those false witnesses will be killed hazama so it's a good as i'm a male 1 if people mistake two hours three hours khakir is there nami so if a person says i saw i witnessed the murder at 12 o'clock come made them and say but 12 o'clock you were with us and this and this place the way they ate them are going to wiggle their way out of it they have a leeway a two-hour leeway according to the mayor a three-hour leeway according to a buddha so it's not either a for three hours so they can't wiggle their way out or more let's see what does that mean later mayor yavin alohu mithrilla according to her mayor shari shawina right over here zero zero zero is day break so i go back two hours and i go all the way to the fifth hour why not now um says that you could be off by two hours so in other words i could go into the the eleventh hour because it's two full hours however i don't do that why elaborate because look it's dark it's i i this is a late chart so the the graphics aren't great but at least they put it in black it's dark no one is going to confuse night with day so i only give him two hours this way till zero o'clock till day break again he has three hours he goes all the way till the sixth hour uber dinner with the nights of lumi carrot fei now we're turning that food base on the base once again the same idea that people are not going to mistake the night with the day so i get until daybreak the natively committed faith i should give him three hours full hours so he should go all the way into here says the gemara allah when i'm talking about hazama killing these false witnesses witnesses said we we witness the murder come another set of witnesses and say imanoisem and i'm going to take you you were with me on vacation from daybreak all the way to six o'clock then we could kill these aiden because they have no leeway even if you say you could be off by three hours you have no leeway it explains rashid that's only for azama but akasha it's a terrible eidos you don't need you don't need the entire day like that to prove that they're wrong as long as they're they're hours don't overlap each other then it's not a good atheist so you could break their aedos we're talking about here killing them based on false testimony how do you kill them by proving that he monitors them from they break all the way through here now why can't why don't we give them till the sixth hour says the gemara because people don't make a mistake when the sun is it rises from the east and goes to the west so by that time it's already in the west so nobody's going to confuse them nobody's going to confuse the the sun they were very into the position of the sun that they're not going to be confused new so you time to wake up let's wake up the oil a little bit hold on for your i don't know if anybody saw that and he sent me a nice birthday that he made a grammy kind of thing who else donnie fine how are you long time no see where's your dad i don't see him here and hello you're still in you're still in los angeles beautiful picture you shaquille thank you really appreciate it does he really have that bobble head in his truck he just did it for the video he today oh yeah yeah yeah gotta do it turning it down the the new guys want to know what's this all about so there's there's a very hush of a guy a big balchester his name is official from official catering in baltimore and he wanted to raise more money for mdy and he started this thing called the turning of the daf we had a big mclaughs do you say turning of the page or turning into daf and the whole thing so what are you a bunch of fruit means you gotta say daff and what are you what are you a bunch of mizrahnics and madaranashi guys kids the whole fighter says official you know what if you pay for it you get to decide what it is so anyway so since then it was the turning of the deaf sponsored by leading us it's a thousand dollars to say this to have this host to say that it's a way to raise money for mdy and this money goes we have a coil of unbelievable delight that learned the daf over and over they do hazards they're taking a big faher now we have libby uh rabby david's uh son that's in the basement right now he watches it live on the screen because he doesn't have a device with another 10-15 people there but he's one of the guys in the car that they take these tests and they take a test from the beginning of shots from brachas all the way through him it's a crazy test so they're constantly learning even when they're not incredible they're learning at night they're learning their sleep they're learning on shabbos yoga in the bathroom sometimes even so it's a tremendous thing it says the gemara says it says the thing sponsored by leaders and sponsored by coming from the five towns leonardo's father the whole year the mendo ben simcha and the third one is i just mentioned his name donnie fine and his father sweetheart sponsored by the fine and pearl families in this house of refuse lima from in the elka bass edo she should have her for shleimo four lines from the top when exactly they have to stop eating comments so mayor you have to give it a one hour break and this has to do with the whole sugar that we just learned people confuse they confuse hours how many hours they get confused we said when it comes to testifying in a murder case they could be confused by two hours three hours what about comments comments officer mayor says one hour give a one hour break because at most will be confused by an hour but you have to give him a two-hour break so once again rabi huda is more concerned that people make mistakes in time but not as much as he said over there or it's only two hours before he said three hours okay they agree that it's the sixth hour that you burn says established we said in the beginning of today's share a by according to a mayor zero mistake zero not even a second people don't make mistakes when it comes to testifying nejokuloshis so why why take a break why give him a buffer of one hour that he might make a mistake a person is very very exact when it comes to time let him meet the entire sixth hour what about burning the comments okay so you give him a few extra minutes this time he says mclennan fine okay and what about then we went in the next sheet there was in abaya in remayer he'll make a mistake by a few seconds okay so give him give him a buffer of a few seconds why a few a full hour rabbi continue the question according to the shot that a person makes a mistake in a half hour so let him meet 6 30. why a full hour and if you make a mistake in an hour why is it that you have to stop eating the beginning of the fifth hour omar abbayo says about your biggest sight there's a big difference between a capital case mises besdon and muhammad aidos missouri's reason if i take the risk and i go to bed then knowing that they're going to interrogate me they're going to try to find every every inconsistency that i have so i'm going to be really careful i'm going to be medical and what time it was i'm going to be as sorry as i'm going to be extremely careful kham is like all master but when you give a rule to all of clyde's role you can't expect every single person in classroom is going to be exactly the second on comets can't be we're talking about individuals plucked out somebody witnessed the murder he's going to be extremely careful he's going to do his homework he's going to try to remember recall exactly what time it was [Music] now let's talk about rava don't rather if a person can make a two-hour mistake so the buffer should be two hours why is the buffer only one hour what if he mistakes the time of achilles comments he'll think instead of saying it's seven o'clock and it's also deep comments he'll think it's five o'clock he'll eat he makes a two-hour mistake he should have a bigger buffer nobody makes a mistake between five and seven seven the position of the sun i forgot to print it out i already had it there's an interesting picture in the article that shows you exactly in the next suggest but it already turns the curve it's already the sun is already heading west it's not in the in the eastern side of the sky it's already in the wet so people don't confuse the west and east so already made the turn says the gemara it's not true the sixth hour is where the east and the west meet exactly it's on the southernmost point between the east and the that's where it starts making its turn towards the west and the may law you can get really confused people don't know is it over here is it over here and it's confusing so therefore we added the sixth hour of leaving the view that all my other toys show the shoes oh there's a bigger problem well it's the same answer though if a person can confuse time by three hours his buffer should be three hours since it's awesome in the erase of the comments from the seventh hour so take the seventh hour back three hours to four and say nobody should touch comments for three hours what if he confuses it he's human being he's a human being adam tell your shoulders he can make a three hour mistake he shouldn't eat from the fourth hour says the gemara you heard that people make mistakes we're human we make mistakes to the point you could kill somebody it's unbelievable it's an interesting idea i could cause somebody's misa death based on my human error mistake because i'm human i'm allowed i'm allowed a two-hour mistake the dialogue hakeem reminisces we make mistakes you get up and go fighters so so when it came to five and seven we said people don't make mistakes so kolschkin certainly the sun is way more to the east so he's not going to confuse it with seven which the sun is in the west so let him eat in the fifth hour target of the ravages once again we have this idea that when it comes to testimony that's when people are really careful when it comes to muhammad people will confuse it you're talking about the entire population they're going to be a lot of mistakes therefore we give it an extra buffer so in fact there's no real difference between comets and misa it's just the fact that people are less the less careful they're not as exact when it comes to when it comes to misa they'll be more careful says no so is not talking about people making mistakes three hours two hours that's not what we're talking about time interview the elder of you though the omar eight comments we touched upon this when you burn comments review the holds you have to when you get rid of comments review the holes it has to be burnt physically with a fire there's a mitzvah in the fire so therefore you have a layer of you can't eat all the way to the last minute how is he going to find firewood we have to give him firewood to to to make the fire he has to have time to go collect the wood so may i give him a buffer this buffer is not because of a human error a mistake it's a buffer to give him time to find wood is very vanilla um when are you when they have a mix of the burnt comments with a fire stop a couple of hours before beer comments be but once that seventh hour heads hashball called over flush it down the toilet do whatever you need to do to get rid of it so what's going on so at the end of the day why am i giving him extra time to find wood let him not find wood and by the time the zeman beer comes along he'll have the right to burn it destroy it flush it down rip it up throw it in the in the wind whatever get rid of it give it to a dog el okay yeah you know what we're talking about confusing hours and people make mistakes with hours we're talking about a problem that it might be a cloudy day and a cloudy day people get confused they don't know what time it is and therefore i have to give him a buffer he won't know what time he doesn't have a watch he bases it on the sun no sun today he's going to eat hummus at the wrong time so then what do you gain so take it give him a buffer a six hour buffer why why'd after one hour two hour omara papa airbus mansoor locally no four o'clock four hours into the day right over here if this is daybreak so right over here this is where people eat all the all people the common folk this is where they eat mela when people are hungry they're not gonna get confused they're not gonna eat comments they know this is the time of eating we have to eat non comments this there's a good cinnamon and they know what it is they don't need the sun anymore every day they eat at four o'clock or whatever time that is into the day day break and mellow there's no need to give them a buffer before that says the gemara very interesting cannibals people that eat other humans says rashi they're freshers they what's their proud they're very hungry they constantly want to eat one day somebody came to visit them and they took a good look at him and they said wow this is geshemaka lunch and they ate him up and from that day on they started eating people by the way they have cannibals at the mse you know jeffrey dahmer a hindi guitar cannibal which by the way as a side sad note he actually one of his victims was a kid from a firm family in chicago so these people eaters they eat at daybreak why because there's such freshers that they're such foodies they they can't they can't take it they can't they can't sleep for one minute into the day they need to eat right away okay so it's one hour in st these are also raftanim fresors terrible guys that are into their food but the difference is says rashi they're up the whole night robbing people they rob people so now they need to take a good nap but they take a one-hour nap and they're ready to eat and fresh one hour into the day so they're in the second hour oh here comes the guy with the um no what is it called uh yeah yeah i should know this thing um [Music] the trust fund the trust fund kid so he never worked a day in his life so he just rolls out of bed he's not worried about pranasa he's not worried about making a living working for somebody he's not so he but he's he's not a professor he's not going to eat at one tour so three o'clock great what is that like eight o'clock in our time today right three hours after day break reveals and the fourth hour is when everybody eats the sorry the workers the workers but that's the problem here if we stop right here we said that everybody the common folk eat at four o'clock four hours it and we just said now ravis macha poylem workers people that are mashup to about a bus the guy tells him when to work how to work he gives a little break four hours into the day but it's not common folk hamish is they shouldn't be taking breaks to eat until they really have to at the last minute so they end in the fifth hour and then she says this is the problem says mafurish the sixth hour magical i'm not the fourth hour you're telling me that everybody sits down theater four o'clock four hours in and therefore you don't have to make a buffer at four o'clock but they don't they cut they eat at six o'clock six hours in you have to change this bryce around a little bit review is it's the fourth not the poi lim it's the macaque we're not going to do a complete switch pile him with kolatham but what we're going to do is we're going to move the the pyalim the workers to the fifth hour and insert in the fourth hour all people and we're going to move tamir over from five to six she is if you don't eat before the sixth hour after day break and then you start eating it's like taking a stone and throwing it in to some sort of jug that holds water it's going to make a nice splash but it's not going to do anything now i'm reminded we had a uh when i was a bucker i think it was yeah we had this russian guy staying by our house and i heard him telling my father he said let me explain to you how the stomach works he said basically the stomach grinds itself it grinds and what you need to do is you need to throw something in there so it stops grinding so it doesn't matter what you throw in there you can throw an apple you can throw a piece of bread then it stops grinding and you're good to go that that's how the stomach works that's how you explain it in other words not to have these steaks and it's just let's just stop grinding but if you eat after the sixth hour you don't stop the grinding it's gonna go all the way to the bottom you're gonna hear a big boom it's not gonna stop that's basically what the russian is saying that's only when he didn't eat taste anything safra if you tasted something you had a stickle cookie in the morning and then you went until the sixth hour then the food will work it will help you the same idea that we have by eidos testimony on a murder case and remember says two hours of view this is three hours whatever the machine says that same idea we have by comments that's exactly what we're trying to prove the whole sugya how come so all these answers that we said are real answers in other words we're going and we're not just saying oh the in fact there is a much like [Music] no we're going with it so but at the end of the day when it comes to comments we can't do the same hours as he dos why because we're giving it to everybody when it comes to a murder case there's reason and when it comes to comments they're not so careful we'll give it to everybody so yeah so the the hours are but in terms of what people confuse time people confuse time by two hours three hours according to the mayor for the buddha that remains the same um that's okay if a person makes a mistake he says 2 3 o'clock he says 5 o'clock but if they define a specific thing they're very specific one says before the sunrise the other one says after sunrise that's a liar these guys are liars you can't say oh but they're only off by five minutes sunrise is a five minute thing no when it comes to hours they can be off by three hours but it comes to a physical thing and say it was after sunrise the murder now you're a liar because the other guy said it was before sunrise says excuse me of course one didn't say after before one said before once it right as it started so maybe there's no such different it's not that different it doesn't betella we still say he made a slight mistake he saw some sort of hint of the sun the glow visa he just saw some radiance as the arts grow commercial i would think that at the end of the day they're saying the same exact thing they're saying it happened before why is this guy saying it started because he he saw something he thought is what he what he saw was was sunrise but in fact it was just some you know the cloud was reflecting whatever it was commercial no what they're saying is a lie you can't take their testimony have a wonderful day the [Music] who is that simon jacob shamalikum how are you thank you very much it's a pleasure to see you with the sparrow in the back it's a real background right it's not it's not uh it's not one of those virtuals how could you tell oh yeah very good yeah you gave me that subconscious thank you thanks yes don't forget tomorrow oh yeah okay you also will remind me i had no idea thanks for telling me so i should leave this up you're saying leave it up what does this suffic when you sniff [Music] there thing i said is that really a thing in manchester they make problems with it he told me the character says that when you say bear it's even worse than saying basically because then you're making it a whole set wow you should know so i was making to that that that was my makshaba actually you just say it and finish you go invite it to make a whole wow i had no idea i'm so happy you told me that that's beautiful beautiful so what is he saying that in manchester the not mock bit on it he went off the darker stick already but originally so they're not so magic so where they might but exactly this is in bar park there's a new york thing huh [Music] wow okay you know let's not discuss it until we get there please [Music] what happened cohen should be on the on the chat no so what are you saying hold on yeah what are you saying but i'm talking about 30 years ago 40 years ago actually so but you see so what do you see from this guidalia that you're supposed to move away from san francisco and go to new york joseph stark good morning good morning oh you have to read your email after you i have to read your email okay it's a good thing you remind me i have no idea where it is i have to search it's so awesome you have no idea it's one of the biggest dissorum