Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 84 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] We're live. Great job. I didn't just hear from other people, I I saw firsthand. No, in 22 minutes without you know. We're holding up paid dollar like eight lines down two four six eight nine lines down nine hustle. We learned over there in the mission over there in school and we learned So how does it work? On you're not allowed you're going to ask me what I said in a second. Okay, yeah. Here we go. It's not those those I have to put the oil on back into place. You guys who you thought you could just take advantage now it's it's over. Okay. We all know you can't plant. You can't do anything with the sudden. What happens? Every time you have a crop and we learned it a bunch of times sometimes things just grow spontaneously from the the seeds that fell off the previous years crop they grow. A guy walks by the field he sees the crop he says smack there's no fresh produce his fresh produce and it's after he goes in and takes it. But we need that's called speaken. We need some of this crop cuz we want to bring the owner. So how do we protect it from these people? Rashi says poor people it really means anybody even rich people are desperate for fresh crops. What do they do? They put a a watcher and who pays them? The pays them because it's for the for the owner. Says the mission watchers knows how to call. Special. It was right if it was for just your own benefit then fine but we need it for the we need it for the owner. It it says show me speak but show me. So what do you Not by owner it says it's forever for all the generations there's owner according to you once every seven years there's no owner going to get it from from a field but the field is only to eat and not to burn on his obviously the tire wasn't talking about the owner. The owner overrides this is of you you're supposed to owner every every meter. I will make I know but I will I didn't say just sit idle and not bring a owner on lay same in the stock. Bring it from the year the previous year. So bring it from storage you have you have a Now if you remember yesterday's morning here Yeah, let's see what the mission says. Turn your attention to that let's see the mission call it says not like you just said. Okay, it's a question. Being says the one being Carmel the liquor. This we had many times. It says in the Carmel what is Carmel mean? We take the cuff in the ratio we switch it and becomes it has to be soft and has to be that you you could fetch it with your finger. So below that's why I can't use last year's last year's crop. Look at real quickly the second to last places on the bottom it says table. Which we had yesterday on the top of the page. Where was it like three lines down it says owner owner owner. So as they say what's what's his question the cloud? Yes. You have a in so bring from what's the problem according to you can bring from even on owner there's no reason to battle once in the way to listen. So it says it doesn't go according to him. I will follow and see back in the morning. Yeah, what about what about all this stuff? Stuff that you could eat. Or stuff that was planted let's say before I don't know before before before came in before let's say. Anything you could eat. [Music] He's saying it should be because it's because everything's up. Okay. No comments no comments. Every day I told him that you could hear as clear as with me with my mic you hear him on a regular I'm serious when he talks it's unbelievable. Yeah. He's about ready to use this. Okay, so we have one shot Carmel you know Carmel probably the liquor. Okay. Now the owner it's my that the fact that the owner has to be from the new crop not from the old crop it's my owner. Carmel talk with So we have to remember these two sheets is not what we're going to say. We say amen. What happened to this whole bench over here? Come. Hello. Fine. The reason Carmel talk with It says in the that it should be rough. So it has to come from the new crop has to be and it cannot be from the ocean. The reason why It says in the it should be first reason don't bring from last year's last stock has to be the beginning of the new stock. So what are the two we have Carmel and we have races and it's going to ask him these two it seems like one of them is off. Most of them The reason why if you remember I once did a nice this I thought was probably the hardest at least to explain. The hardest line in the was this remember this chart? Here so you have and you plant it over here. And then you see the the the kids are Basically what I'm trying to say is that everything that we're learning now we had word for word This is the right here. It's it's a simple that we had. In fact we can make any ball. What do you do with the barley? Because we don't have to make any ball owner owner owner or you ain't ever going to keep them maybe it comes from wheat and that the owner brings three reasons that the owner comes from barley and not from wheat. Reason number one the reason why owner Never over the mystery. It says by borrowed it says of what does it say? The barley of it. Okay. And it says word of it for generations where by the owner just like the reason why because it says the reason why it says owner. And the reason why reason number one from reason number two Maybe this was interesting one we had the problem then also it's hard to understand this we can say just like we find by individual brings the typically brings the from wheat once in a while he brings it from where by a site. So it makes sense as we that they're similar. We should be not Why I don't know that's how we decided makes sense that maybe I am sorry. So therefore If you say that the comes from wheat then we don't have an option ever that the public brings the community brings a from barley. So obviously it has to be that the comes from barley and in the third shot in my it says in the third that has to be the first crop. Now if 49 days earlier by the owner you brought the first crop out of wheat. So, it's impossible to bring the first crop on Shavuot from wheat. Unless you say that that's that's considered different. That was the Sugya over there. That maybe it is possible to bring two Bikurims one after another, two first crop, because they were planted at different times. And that that commercial doesn't make sense because for the Mizbeach it has to be a first crop, not the first crop five. So, the Gemara says, what what does the Gemara bring all this? Because we had a Machlokes between Rebbi Akiva and Rebbi Eliezer. How do I know that I have to bring the Omer from the new crop and not from the old crop? Rebbi Akiva said the Pshat is Carmel, has to be soft. Rebbi Eliezer says it has to be from the new crop. Who does this sound like? This sounds like Rebbi Eliezer, the new crop. Doesn't mention anything over here about soft. This is the Gemara Teyuvta. See, you're right. That's a very good question. Tannaim also. Ein Mevi'in Bikurim Chutz Me Shiv'at HaMinim. Bikurim, the first fruit that you bring to the Beis HaMikdash only applies to the Sheva Shiv'at HaMinim. What are the Shiv'at HaMinim? Eretz Chittah Se'orah VeGafen Te'einah VeRimmon. Eretz Zeis Shemen U'Dvash. What's Dvash? Dates. I didn't know this until I started eating dates a couple many Machaneh Yehudah they have in the fridge these fat plump dates that are like literally like honey and they taste like honey. They're amazing. I used to hate dates. You know, the ones that you eat on on Rosh Hashanah for Simanim. No, this is a the different story. Anybody wants to try? You'll see what what? Exactly, the Medjool. I never heard of this Dvash and you give your kids a treat. Dvash, now I understand. It's It tastes like candy. What? I never tasted it. No, these these refrigerated stuff. Okay. Akol Panim. Now to get to our Sugya. I'm trying to stall. It's not good. We have 10 minutes left and Okay. Says the Gemara Mordechai Getz Chiddush. The Lo Listen to this Chiddush. It's crazy. The Bikurim applies to Shiv'at HaMinim, but not just not to all Shiv'at HaMinim. VeLo MeTmarim SheBeHarim. You cannot bring it from dates that are on the mountain. Why says Rashi? Because they're very sweet. They're too sweet. They're Medjool or whatever they're called. VeLo MePeiros SheBeAmakim. And not from wheat that's in the valley. What happens in the valley? There's no drainage over there. All rain gathers and it could it could ruin the crop. To the could spoil. But it says Meforash, I cannot bring Bikurim. If you bring it in the Chiyur, it's no good. So, it's unbelievable Chiddush. It's too sweet, no good. Amar Ulla, Im Heivi Lo Chiddush. And that's what Ulla says. And the Gemara is going to have a problem with this. If you bring dates from the mountains which are too sweet, you're not Yotzei. It's not It's not even Kodesh. What does not Kodesh mean? Anybody can eat it. It doesn't have any Kedushah. Korban Reishis. Shtei Reishis LeChol HaMenachos. Says by by the Shtei HaLachmim, it should be the first. [Music] The Shtei HaLachmim has to be the first. So, it has to be the first of everything. How do I know that the Omer which comes from Se'orim, we just established that the Omer comes from Se'orim. How do I know that it is also first? What does that mean first? So, you think just Pshat simple Pshat, just to be clear here. The Omer comes from barley has to be first. What? That you can't eat other barley stuff before this? You could eat other barley because the Omer came. So, what what the Pshat is it has to be before the other Minchah of of barley, which is Sotah. Fine. Ta'amu Lo Amar Chadash So, I printed it out. Could you see over there? Yeah. It It's so many It's very small. And what happened was I did buy a printer. I thought I was going to go to America and bring back a present. And what happened was I got to show you this. This is crazy. I got there the first day and this guy stole my printer right off my porch. Here's the printer. This is the guy. I'll send you the video. I have it on video. I have to share. They all look the same to me. Akol Panim. I got I got another printer. It's fine. [Applause] Oh. But it's a lot of words. Still very small. If it's a small Posuk, it comes out unbelievable. I tried it out. Akol Panim. What was this Psukim by Shtei HaLachmim? And in the Shtei HaLachmim, it says the word Chadashah. Chadashah Chadashah. VeChiyuv Chadashah and over here also Chadashah. Maybe Vayikra should be before Bamidbar. Lo Meshaneh. And over here it should be by itself. Next. See this paper? It's Gishmak. Feel this. So, it's American also. I brought this. American paper this. You see you can see the both ways. It's both ways the Israeli paper. This 32 lb. Akol Panim. So, what do you do when you have Chadashah Chadashah twice. It's Mamesh extra. What do you do? So, there's a Halachah there's a Segulah that says the concept. If you have a word you don't need you need an extra, you can use it for something else completely. That's a rule. So, I'm going to use it. If I can't use it for Shtei HaLachmim, what am I going to use it for? To the Omer. Gemara, it says Chadashah Chadashah. Im Ein Ein Chadashah Shel Chittim, May Ein Ein Chadashah Shel Se'orim. I go all the way from wheat to barley. So, therefore I have a I know So, I know that barley, meaning the Omer, has to be the first of its kind before it. U'Minayin? The Gemara is going to go through every step. The Gemara is going to say how I know that this has to be first of all first. U'Minayin? Kodemes to Bikurim. How do I know the Shtei HaLachmim? Going back to Shtei HaLachmim. Forget about Omer now. We're back to Shtei HaLachmim. How do I know the Shtei HaLachmim is before Bikurim? Now, what's the Gemara's Kashya? It's very deep the Gemara's Kashya. Because Bikurim has the same exact words as Shtei HaLachmim. It says Chadashah and it says Reishis by Bikurim. So, maybe Bikurim should be first? No. Before you bring any fruit to Hakadosh Baruch Hu from off your tree, first you have to bring the Shtei HaLachmim. Ta'amu Lo Amar VeChag HaShavuos. So, the Gemara is learning VeChag HaShavuos means what's what's Negayah to Shavuos, meaning the two breads. Taseh Lecha and then only Bikurei Chittim. After you do the Shtei HaLachmim, then I bring the Bikurim. So, I know the Bikurim of Bikurim. What's Bikurim? From the Shiv'at HaMinim. So, in the Shiv'at HaMinim I have wheat. So, maybe this the Shtei HaLachmim comes before the wheat of the Bikurim. What about other parts of the Bikurim? Bikurei Where am I? How do I know Bikurim that are come from barley? How do I know the Shtei HaLachmim is before that? Ta'amu Lo Amar VeChag HaKatzir which is talking about Shavuos. Bikurei Who is the two the Shtei HaLachmim? Mas Asher Tizra BaSadeh. Asher Tizra is referring to other stuff. Ein Ein Asher Tizra. Amar Rebbi Nechemia Meleila Minayin? Says Meforash that you planted. How do you know like we were talking about the Sefichin that come back themselves? How do I know that the Shtei HaLachmim comes before them? Ta'amu Lo Amar BaSadeh. Anything in the field. Ein Ein Asher BaSadeh. Minayin Rabbosai? Oh. VeRabbosai SheBeGag VeSheBeChurvah. What if I don't I don't know that I have to bring this Shtei HaLachmim before the Bikurim that grew on my rooftop or that grew on the Churvah VeSheBeAtzis, in a flower pot. VeSheBeSefinah, that grew on a boat. How do I know that I can't bring Bikurim before the Shtei HaLachmim? Ta'amu Lo Amar Bikurei Kol Asher BaArtzam. Everything. Kol Asher. Everything BaArtzam in their land. Everything including on the rooftop. Including on the including the boat. Minayin Shtei Kodemes LeMasah. How do I know the Shtei HaLachmim comes before the wine? U' What kind of fruit are we talking about? The dates, the Medjools, and the and the olives? Cuz the wheat and the barley we discussed already. How do I know it comes even before the other Shiv'at HaMinim? Ne'emar Kan Bikurei Oh, so for this I have a nice chart. This is interesting. He thought he's walking away with a $7,000 mission. Why why is the possible that if it's not Dr. Lerman or if it says it's even speaking or anything like that? I don't know. Don't know. It's exactly the opposite. Also, another But here's what's very interesting about this possible. You see the red? The red is talking about Sukkot. And the black is talking about Shavuot. It's very interesting. The higher quality of the circle. It's a good thing I can read from the other side. I share Israel by soda. Now, my circle You see it says the word my circle. And over here it says the word my circle. So it's a show between the beginning of the possible which is talking about Shavuot. The Aussie is talking about Sukkot. Now, the moral assumes that in Sukkot everything is already done. Everything grew already. So on Sukkot you already have wine. You already have grapes. You have You have olives. So if you already have olives, so you take the my circle from over here having olives and grapes and you learn it to over here that by Shavuot is also referring to grapes. That you made an onion? No, it's not This is my very show. My circle my Is the moral taste different or the coffee? No, the coffee. It's different. Very different. Yeah. What is that? It's like the moral. Never can be cool in my circle. What's calm? In the beginning of the possible the name of the alone later on at the end of the possible My alone is so very silly. Don't just like in Sukkot. You already have everything. All the fruit is grown. I can only do this in Sukkot and very silly. So now the moral comes to this question. It says like cool from the rooftop. So how now going to the top line of the page it says I don't take I don't take Ulan Ulan said it's not even college. If I take the cool from from a date that grew on a mountain. Forget about on a roof. Forget about on a boat. On a mountain. It was a little high. It's not even be cool. You know what it says before I take the cool from a boat top. But maybe the quality is better. I know, but you're going to tell me the quality of a boat is good. It's a It's not good. And the moral doesn't hold like the moral says you're right. You can't take the cool from a rooftop and you can't take So why does it you take the cool from a rooftop? Says the moral possible not even talking about the cool. It's talking about It's the cool of course you can't take. It wouldn't be college. Must give the moral about how it's talking about the moral It's kind of It says before the possible go to the circle So anybody can eat it including your wife. The cool of the circle only the male can eat my circle. I'm going to try to break the CD. See the higher referring to the only you the males It's going to be a circle. The higher contradiction everybody can eat it including your wife. Okay, so come be cool in the Everybody can eat the cool. Come be my circle in the first part of the is referring to the iron. The ratio cool my circle No, it's all referring to my circle not be cool. We say for the cross my There is a call my the bread that you have to bring all your friends to eat. That they can eat. Says the moral. They going back to this date that grew on a mountain. Says the moral is my for maybe like says like Ulan. If he brought it there's nothing. No cool. There is cool. Now so why and he explains it's as if the cool in the Just like I'm supposed to bring a nice fat animal. What if I brought a skinny disgusting animal? It's a no no, but it's a car. So if you're also weak, but still be cool. So we're talking about the time he said a very good reason. What is his reason? All my loser. I saw him in And if I saw him in my dream Listen, I mean I know for a fact that because of this cool I saw him not only did I see such a good like but I saw the person we're talking about. The person we're looking for a reason and I know I'm going to come up with something good. Oh my god. My rations. It said by the It says my rations. The light In other words, my rations meaning it should come from the cool should come from my rations. And not everything else. My is an exclusion below my rations. Not all your land meaning and not from a mountain. What's going on? Everybody's all giggling. It's a It's a good sign. It's a good sign. Why not? Listen, trust me. If you came to they ask you about the question So what tell me you go Oh my god. I can't believe it. I just dreamed of him last night. It makes it like it Now it falls together. It all came together. It's not like he dreamed Not like they had a question and then he dreamed. He had a dream and then he dreamed. Then he Then they asked him a question. Makes sense. If you came What if your name was a loser? Maybe he wanted everybody to remember so that's why he see it at the end. Talking about the real deal here. Look at this. Okay, we're talking about We're talking about doesn't need to come on this. We're talking about the way What does he do with the word circle? He doesn't need to come on this. Draw sure. We're going to decide your by Rabbi Omer. Never can hear it by the cool. Whenever it is done by the by talking about it says my alone It's like I can't hear it. So also by the cool we're talking about the beauty of What's so beautiful about What's the What's a mile of the meaning? We are mayor of I It says mayor I have two drawers over there from the men. We are mayor of my circle doesn't learn from the men. 20 of them. Now we have a contradiction in the braces. One brace it says maybe it's also you know Maybe the it's fine to bring the cool from there and read. In other words, it's the real deal. It's the real So maybe the cool. The brace says if you brought it don't don't read the cool. It's not real be cool. We're talking about the show. Gaga gaga show. Now we have to go through all four things. You have the the gag Aussie you know what else the cool. So the two types of gag says the moral the moral hug the gag device. It's the rooftop of a cave. But what's a cave made out of? It's made out of dirt. So it's a real It's a real car. So there's no problem over here. Cool like I can't see the cool cool cool cool. called a cool cool a house can't act out but they cool planting. Aussie I can't see the cool cool cool. I'm not exactly sure. You have a a that a clay or fell down and they started planting. They They They cultivated it. It's a cool that they they they planted on it. So it's no different than any ground. You might prepare the ground properly if it's in the field. Exactly. So he's What he's asking is then it's a field. Then it's a field. No, no, no. It's in the house. It's in the house. Not in the house. It's Oh, you mean walls and everything. Clean out the house. It's He's saying it's one of those sun rooms. It's one of those What do you call it? A cool means it's a house that's it's very rickety racket. It's It's still up. So but they cultivated the ground inside the cool. Fine. Maybe it has less sun. Maybe it has No, the floor is dirt, but it has these walls around it. So maybe It's a sun room. Aussie Aussie That's obvious. You know what I'm saying? If it has holes in the bottom then it's unique from the ground. So it's as if it's on the ground. Sweet I can't see I love this one. I can't see the I can't see the house. Don't try this at home. You have a sweet made out of earth You hear a like the Titanic. He's right to the point where it's talking about it's actually touching the ground. You have to say that this one this this we know Yeah, yeah. It's a house boat. Fine. It's You don't You don't take it across the Atlantic because if you hit a iceberg or something it's finished. If you hit a fish it's finished. It could float. They don't They don't use it for flotation. They use it to put in the ground. Whatever. Over here Over here for sure it's talking about it's touching the ground. If it's in the If it's in the water it's far from the ground. So then even though it's made out of you don't have a connection to the ground. And you shouldn't say this. I didn't see the show. No. So I don't understand. Cuz it's touching. It's touching. It's touching. That's exactly the chat. That's why I would say it's touching. I I knock off even without touching if it has a hole, then it's Yonic. Over here, the fact that it's touching does not so it's brown. Brown and brown is fine. 10 minutes and we're on the bottom. Can we finish the Now, Hello, there beautiful According to doesn't matter what we're going to say. We could say this is a knock off. Any knock off it's on a house says you can never bring the corn from it. It's inferior quality. Quality you can't bring the corn from it. How is he going to answer this? So you write you can't answer but we have a contradiction between the prices. I know you the sign you should be gone should be maybe the corn. Should be also anyway we call you don't bring it out at all unless they one one last line. What? If you bring it, why not? Yeah? You don't bring it and if you bring it all the you have the best quality flower called this. I'm going to I'm going to let you know I'm going to let you know so these two told me I don't know. What are you doing so much what are you doing in Nissan in front of us? Bring vegetables. I want to show you I'm going to bring it to you. Where we what is this now? 8:15? I was you you could you could leave this I'm I'm keeping it up. The last time you left was No, two I need a little bit of time to to to print stuff out to to this. We do it what time is over? Is this all by the way? is over 5:30. So could it be 7:00? But it's going to be too complicated. We should just We did every single 9:15 so why is 7:30 too late? 7:00 7:00 7:00 7:00 we always say. I wouldn't feel this feel this paper. You got to feel this.