Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 83 by R' Eli Stefansky

A good inner face of voice I ah unbelievable we're sitting here it's 3:00 in the afternoon right before Leila Seder to shirim the oilum is staggering away we have people here in the room and we have people online and the it's the shmaya that all the shirim that I had to give gave this is pay gimel this is already for uh you know chol hamoed basically or in Eretz Yisrael chol hamoed and in America whatever but we're ahead baruch Hashem we're ahead of the game we're going to do a short shiur so I can give both shirim and still make it to the hotel I want to remind the oilum to say sfiras haomer if you're staying if you're today don't say sfiras haomer but if you're somewhere else sfiras haomer I will do let me just do the the sponsorships real quickly the official edition MDY shas sponsored by the Iranian Levy families per Eli Dickman Eliyahu Zusia ben Dvir Razla chol hamoed official edition shas daf pay gimel Moses Markovich in honor of our children and grandchildren a lot of health and success in everything and also sponsored by David Solomon dedicated in memory of Reb Meir Reb Shmuel Boruch ben Reb Chaim Shimon Zichrono Joel Gedalis was my father Jack Gedalis and also sponsored by the family of Jonathan and Shmuel ben Reb Palchik Eliyahu anonymous for Reb Moshe ben Yisrael anonymous for Reb and Reb Shimon ben Reb ben Reb Malkiel ben Reb ben Reb Yisrael ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb Ari Simon is a monthly sponsor for Reb ben Reb Meir ben Reb Meir ben Reb Meir weekly sponsor in honor of Mark Ashkenazi I have to say again you should thank Mark hopefully I remember to say in the middle of the shiur you should thank Mark for doing four shirim two days in a row and today erev Yom Tov it's already 4:00 4:10 in New York he's about to go to shul in about two hours and he's doing two shirim right now you should thank Mark you should thank all the editors you should thank the to the artists we had five artists working till 1:00 2:00 in the morning to get these shirim out so we have art for the pay beis and pay gimel and managed to the last minute right before they were working thank you for your constant generosity in giving of your time particularly on erev Yom Tov your efforts are greatly appreciated by all who watch and share the consortium MDY art month for Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb ben Reb here we go we're holding on the bottom of pay beis amud beis the Gemara asks the question how does Rebbi Akiva learn that anything that's a chov if he must bring it and what's beautiful Rebbi Akiva what's beautiful we're here literally during the hours of shechting the korban Pesach and we're discussing about shechting the korban Pesach that's today's sugia crazy how do you know that a korban Pesach that you must shecht you have to you don't have a choice you cannot buy it with maaser sheni money you must buy it with your own money so Gemara brings this whole pasuk I'll remind the oilum just I'm not going to show you the whole thing but just uh that's the pasuk the famous pasuk that we're going to sing tomorrow in shul so the Gemara says this pasuk this pasuk teaches us every word la toida v'la oila u'lamincha hatoida sorry what's the words la oila u'lamincha chotas v'asham u'lamincha every word comes to teach you something and we're going to see that Rebbi Akiva finally it's a very long answer but meanwhile we'll go through very easy stuff we're going to get all the way at the end in about 20 lines from now we're going to see where Rebbi Akiva learns this yesod mincha so now we're holding at the word mincha what do we learn from mincha three lines from the bottom mamincha ein lo ne'echeles ela z'charei kehuna a mincha can only be eaten by male kohanim this is in the pasuk kol zachar bivnei Aharon yochalenu it's talking about a mincha only a zachar Aharon from a kohen af kol in a cholim ela z'charei kehuna so to all the other things only a kohen and a zachar now what does that mean with the are we know there are many korbanos that women can eat that Yisraelim can eat non-kohanim mayi you heard that noise you didn't even hear it but me as someone who lives in Eretz Yisrael I heard a and immediately my my whole body like I go into it's crazy in Eretz Yisrael once when there's um a motorcycle they revved the engine everybody you like catch your breath okay you don't you don't even know what I'm talking about baruch Hashem you don't know mincha mamincha ein lo ne'echeles ela af kol in a cholim mayi what korban are we talking about chotas v'asham we're talking about a regular chotas and asham beheidi ksei where in this week's parsha you know a lot of uh here Vayikra perek vov which is the parsha we just read kol zachar bakohanim yochal oiso again it's talking about a chotas we know that a chotas which is kodshei kodashim that a woman can't eat a Yisrael can't eat this is my first in the pasuk eizei zivchei tzibur what's the zivchei tzibur zivchei tzibur are the two korbanos that we bring on Shavuos the shlamim that we bring on Shavuos together with the two bread merubbei dikraos that we learn from a limud the what this is in the pasuk bakodesh hakodashim tochalenu kol zachar yochal oiso me made a zivchei tzibur she'eino cholim teaches us the zivchei tzibur is only eaten by ela z'charei kehuna so where it says uh why why do I need a pasuk mincha to teach us this I'm really learning it from other psukim chotas asham other psukim so the Gemara writes tanoi this is a machlokes tanoim what pasuk to learn from eika demayisra l'machah some people learn from this pasuk that we just said from the kodshei kodashim chotas uh yeah the pasuk we just read kodshei kodashim eika demayisra l'machah and some people learn from our pasuk from the mincha great chotas we continue with this pasuk v'lachotas v'laasham u'lamincha chotas what do you do with the word chotas it's extra why is it extra no no I'll just go repeat because with every korban the Torah says zo'is Torahs achotas zo'is Torahs asham zo'is Torahs amincha so then why does the Torah take a whole pasuk and and talk about all the korbanos each one comes to teach us a new chiddush chotas machotas mikatzei bivlu'a there's a special halacha interesting halacha I don't think people know this and it's kedai that you came just for this halacha you know what take one halacha out of it today if a chotas the meat after you shecht it korban chotas somebody was over on chol hamoed bishogeg so he brings a korban chotas shechts the animal takes the meat and that meat touches a shlamim in the Beis Hamikdash it's like uh it's like fleishig and milchig it's like tamei and tahor it's like tum'ah if a piece of meat is tamei and it touches another piece of meat boom comes tamei if chotas touches another piece of meat the other piece of meat becomes like a chotas in other words typically speaking a shlamim you could eat for two days now you can only eat it for one day cuz the chotas is if the chotas is tamei it passes that one also becomes whatever the chotas is it transfers its halachos into the other piece of meat chiddush gadol you knew this probably not so here we learn from here machotas mikatzei bivlu'a it absorbs af kol mikatzei bivlu'a becomes kodshei through absorbing asham what do we learn with the word asham maasham ein shofar v'shilyah kodshei beis a asham is a male so just like the the fetus of the male of the asham doesn't become kodshei why doesn't the male's fetus become kodshei cuz it's impossible can't have a fetus I was going to say something cuz I'm in America but I'm going to control myself right now a male cannot have children so therefore its fetus and its amniotic sac the the the article calls it the shil the the shofar the shilyah they don't have kedusha why because they don't exist and the Gemara is going to say so if it's impossible how are you going to teach something else to a female that's possible so that's called what we had the other day donam efshar mishei efshar it's impossible it's just a technical difficulty af kol so we learn from here ein shofar v'shilyah kodshei beis everything else the the the the fetus doesn't have kedusha now we have to understand cuz we know that fetuses usually are like the mother they do have kedusha why cuz blood is kodashim b'yomam v'einam kodashim number one he holds that a fetus doesn't become kodshei in the mother's stomach at all when does it become kodshei when it's born bedonam efshar mishei efshar we can learn other korbanos from a asham that's impossible for a asham to become pregnant nevertheless hey the asham's baby its fetus never has kedusha why okay cuz it's impossible but all my stuff, its baby can become its fetus can become so to all other carbons its fetus cannot become carbon. End of that sugar. New sugar. We're doing like bunny slopes here, no? Mammoth greens. Miluim. What do we do with the word miluim? Just to remind the island miluim is the seven days of inauguration which brought carbons. This is this is another. Yeah, but I think the continuation is miluim. He moves away the naseem brought only for seven days is one time thing. My miluim is any meat [clears throat] in the any meat that's left over must be burned. The ain bala my famous let's say they brought extra carbon as a backup as a you don't burn that live animal. I've called my anytime you bring in a you bring extra animal as a backup. Or let's say we had the other day that a fetus that was born is considered moisture is considered extra considered addition. So if there's meat you burn the ain bala my famous let's say sorry I've called my famous my famous if it's alive you don't burn. You know before I said it during the emails but maybe somebody skipped the emails. I want to say it again. I want to say a tremendous to Mark Nazem for being there every single day of my trip. It's about a 30-day trip. So every single day. And the last few days four a day which is four hours of him just sitting there and watching the computer. He's on the computer right now. Every of a couple of hours before on the computer doing two tremendous tremendous our entire staff from Ariel Shimmy, Kobe, the editors and we have Dave Sharphman and Avrahami and Gary and who else? Oh, our artists. So I don't know there's a bunch of new guys. Menachem the new guy, Uriel the new guy the old guy, Yoshi obviously. Yossi Shachar I'm missing one. The sixth one. Okay, but anyways these these artists worked crazy hours. They they worked overtime way into the hour 2:00 3:00 in the morning Yoshi was texting me last night after the comments he came right back to the office and continued working. We got to finish this year. it says in the in the the word what do I do with the word By the way, we're still in the middle of the question. What's the question? Where did know that a carbon you must pay with your own cash. You can't use my money. We're getting there. what I do with the word My in fact is We know the people means that when a the checks the animal and he thinks to himself I'm going to eat this instead of two days I'm going to eat it for three days from now, four days from now, a month from now that makes it people. And if he in fact eats it he's if he doesn't eat it he's who that causes the wine. We know that and come with wine and they come with flour. You can be the wine. I'm sorry, no cup today? I've called my made a burger before. The mission of Akiva so too every other carbon you can do when the people it also makes the wine before we go, right? Cuz there's a because the thing about this animal he's not thinking about the he's thinking about this and not about this the wine. Oh, no I have real wine. The wine. But when I have a cup on this I'm going to eat this in three days from now instead of in two days from now this becomes also also. That's the great. I've called my the mission of finally. They say in the name of Akiva. Zois Hatorah. The same possible using the same possible. But we learned from something else before. What do we learn from we start off the share? That it has to be cool enough. He's learning something else. About the baby he's doing the the baby thing that all absorbs from another from another another carbon. So whatever that carbon is it becomes so do other carbons also absorb. If they touch each other they become carbon like the other one you limit the days etc. The tumor This is the this is the mission after teaching in two places. Carbons and because of the mission mission Bala a mission the flower is soft it absorbs. I will maybe meat tough meat before you before you make it a steak it's tough maybe it shouldn't absorb. And it shouldn't have that of the other things because of carbons the other the showing carbon maybe if I can't meat has it's oily so that's why it absorbs it goes in deep. I will maybe flower not three honey buttons. Carbons. And finally after learning yesterday and after learning a bunch of minutes today 15 minutes into the share here we get to the point. This line right over here. What I do with the word carbons my carbons ain't no ball element of just like a carbon you can only purchase it from your own money and not from my money. And that's it. So that's it. Now I know that a carbon I must purchase with your own private money. That's it. This is where we learn it. The continues and in the carbons you can only during the day not at night. I am you have to use your right hand not your left. I've called every other carbon you can only buy other carbons like a carbon you have to buy it with your own personal money you be and you during the day you be not. The carbons how do I know that a carbon you can't use my money. It has to be his own and not from my money. As the you're telling me that you learn from here that you have to carbon during the day you be there's another possible that teaches that you have to learn you have to do it during the day. Says you're right indeed so. I just said it for the fun of it. For no good reason. The real source that you have to carbon during the day is from the voice. The threw it in. You know we have a whole thing here. You have to buy with your own money. You have to do it during the day with your right hand. In in fact the right hand is also for fun. I don't learn from this possible you have to use your right hand. Come up at anytime the says the word or in we had a whole discussion over there. That's all etc. But have another possible source that you have to do with your right hand. You be we the over here just threw it in the but it's not the real source by us. The real source is over there that it says that's all. Also what I do with the word also now we continue. My my my the bones of the the carbon which is very similar to the carbons which is carbon. carbon The bones are you allowed to I've called my you allowed to use bones of other carbons. Now the says the other learns from that you must purchase the carbon I can't believe that we're talking about a carbon carbon at 3:00 in the afternoon where in the is doing the carbon we're talking about a carbon in the I mean. I'm telling you it's very real. Trust me. It's real. You can be learning you be learning right now. You can be learning even whatever we learn that I did every day. Whatever we were doing last year. Marcus. Doing Marcus. Doesn't talk about carbon there I don't think so. What? Really? You got to go back. It's incredible but we're talking about every day you have to how to buy it. You have to buy it from your own money. But anyways what is doing with the possible we learned that you have to buy with your own money when he learns it already from the word carbons. I will let says the big room days. Let me just do the sponsor. Turning off the extra cross border payments. Shout out to please read the day cuz every show that happened was first read. I don't know what this says but we just said before so show it. It says um that he holds that when a an animal gives birth that's when the goes on to the baby not before. Not when it's in in you bro. Okay, let's see. The carbons. Are you sure you're hack dash? Sure. Sorry, I don't see any Kadusha here. >> [music] >> Congratulations. You've just had hekdesh. Before I was born, I never saw this one. Before I was born, I almost didn't show it. Before I was born, it was still my Russia. Was smoking in Europe. It was had it had a earring. Nobody but the moment the moment I was born, became hekdesh. worthy So, what do you do with this possible that they learn that you have to buy a carbon Pesach from your own money? What do I do with leftover carbon Pesach? Now, there's three types of leftover carbon Pesach. There's a carbon Pesach that's like a year after Pesach. You missed Pesach and the animal just became 2 years old. It had a 2-year-old birthday. So, it has two things going against it. So, what do you do with it? It becomes a shlamim. There's another one. It's after Pesach, but the animal is still a year old. It's within its first year. So, you can use it as a carbon Pesach technically if it was Pesach. That's also shlamim. And then there's another one. It's 2 days before Pesach and you shacht your carbon Pesach. What happens to it? It's not a carbon Pesach. It's too early. So, it also becomes a shlamim. So, we're going to see three psukim here. And that's it, pretty much. Yeah. How do I know that let's say but this is something else. Let's say you brought a second carbon Pesach. You're nervous that something's going to happen to your first one. So, or 15 people on YouTube. They're on YouTube. Or maybe during like they're broiling this raya and they're watching. They give out it. The case is as follows. Your carbon Pesach ran away and you got another carbon Pesach. And then the other one showed up. So, now you have an extra one. It's moiser. It's the extra one. How do you know how do you know that you could shacht it as a shlamim? So, that we saw in in Psachim and throughout Chass, you see the idea that a carbon Pesach transfers into a shlamim eventually if you don't use it. That's what Rebbe Akiva does with this pasuk. I learn that it turns into what's tzo boker? We discussed this yesterday. By the way, in Pesach shlamim comes from sheep and goats. A carbon Pesach only comes from sheep and goats. Hello, it's coming to teach us why it says boker, cattle. Hello, moiser l'dover avo min hatzo umin haboker. It should become it should become something that could have come from sheep and cattle, which is a shlamim. Ask the Gemara, but I have another source for that. I don't need this pasuk that you're telling me "V'zavachta et ha'Pesach l'Hashem Elokecha." I have two other sources. Learn from Shmuel's father. The city. V'min hatzon umin habonim lezaveach shlamim. The word lezaveach shlamim is completely extra cuz we're talking about a shlamim. The carbon Pesach that comes from sheep should become a shlamim. I have another source, a third source. What's the second source? The tsan o keves l'rabos et ha'Pesach l'alyo. What do you do, raboisai? What do you do with the with the tail of the carbon Pesach? Do you eat it? It's delicious. What do you do? So, the famous story, very famous story where there was a that came over to Rebbe Yehuda and said, "Ah, I eat carbon Pesach every year with the Jews." So, Rebbe Yehuda didn't like that because he was pretending to be Jewish and he thought maybe he was spying, whatever the So, he told him, "Did they give you from the good gishmak fatty tail?" They don't. Do they? No. He says, "You better ask him for the tail. Tail is the best and they're not giving it to you cuz they know you they know you're a goy." So, the next the next year he comes there. I'm just throwing that in. As he comes, he says, "I want from the tail." So, they looked into it and they realized that he's a non-Jew. And that's the famous saying, "You, Rebbe Yehuda, you sit in the tzevin and your net is prusa b'Yerushalayim. You're your chachma caught this this imposter." So, in other words, what do you see from this whole story? The bottom line from the story. Tail is not eaten. The tail of the carbon Pesach goes on the mizbeach. How do I know this? The Rabbis says Pesach l'alyo that the carbon Pesach the the tail goes on the mizbeach. How do I know? Sorry. So, Nachman, keves. These two words im keves are both extra. So, the word keves teaches us that the tail goes on the mizbeach. Kishoy omer im keves, the word im l'havi Pesach she'avar shnosav. So, now we have a third source that the carbon Pesach that is no longer a year old, carbon Pesach has to be within a year of its life, 365 days from when it was born. 367, no good. Pesach she'avar shnosav. So, let's just see. I saw that there was a video here which I didn't see yet. Here we go. I'm going to watch together with you guys. This is a carbon Pesach that is too old. Sure, sure. A young and fresh sheep. [music] Are you sure? He looks a bit old. >> I haven't been this sure since I was born. >> [music] >> A little shot, everything is fine. What is this? Who are you? Oh man, you scared me. It's Botox. I am 48. [music] >> [laughter] >> Okay, not bad. That's from a real. I can tell it's a real. I don't know from his music. Da da da dum dum dum. He he does the he redoes the music in AI. Anyway, I Yerushalayim. Yerushalayim. Botox, 48. So, Pesach she'avar shnosav is too old. Ushlamim habaim machmas Pesach l'chomitz shalom. So, I used to ask this question. You know, I used to I go around asking bachurim all these different questions. What kind of aveira is it to hit somebody? What's tmura? What's trumas ma'aser? Back in the day I used to ask this. When you come to Eretz Yisrael, when you come to the Beis Hamikdash on Pesach, Erev Pesach, how many animals are you bringing with you? And the answer is a lot of times five. A lot of people don't know. Here we go. It's shlamim she'avar Pesach now. Pesach Olas re'iyah cuz you're seeing Hakadosh Baruch Hu in a long time. You haven't been to the Beis Hamikdash. So, you bring a special olah called olas re'iyah. Chagiga Yud Daled, which we're talking about. This is unreal. I'm I'm serious. It's crazy. I'm I'm emotional about this. We're talking about chagiga Yud Daled. The It's a chagiga carbon chagiga you bring to only today. It's the only time in the year. It's called chagiga Yud Daled. And there's one tomorrow. Chagiga Yud Daled. That's what it says over here in the Gemara. The Gemara The Gemara says it. Ushlamim habaim machmas ha'Pesach machmas Pesach. The shlamim, in other words, the chagiga that comes together with the carbon Pesach l'chomitz shalom. It gets all the the halachos of shlamim. That That what? She to'ano smicho, you got to lean on it with all your might. Unusachim, you have to bring wine. Utnuvas chozeh v'shok, you have to wave the breast and the thigh like you do the back and forth. Kishoy omer im ez inyan. And then it says in the pasuk im ez, it stops. L'meidan she'eino t'ru'ah. You should know that a goat you don't have to throw the tail of the goat onto This is a I never want to see what the Sorry. These are the tails of the sheep, the real tails. Sheep usually should have this. That's the aliyah they're referring to. Okay. Now, this is the goat. Let's see. I've never seen this one. >> [laughter] >> Funny. [snorts] Okay. Ah, gishmaka shirah. You see, they worked hard on this. L'meidan she'eino t'ru'ah. So, the Gemara says it's Nachman. So, the Gemara's question is why you tell me that Rebbe Akiva learns from the pasuk that if you have extra leftover carbon Pesach that it turns into a shlamim. Here I I just brought you two more sources that it turns into a shlamim. Says the Gemara, "Pasuk ra'ikhi da'as." Actually, three. You're right. Why only three? Chad l'over shnosav one comes to tell you in a situation where it's after Pesach. The time of shchitah is tonight. You know, 3-4 hours from now. It's over too late. You can't check that anymore. It already needs Botox. It's already too old. The other one that everything is going wrong for it. It's after Pesach and it's already 2 years old. The other one too late to check this year's Pesach but it's not 2 years old. It's only a half a year old. The other one is talking about 3 days before Pesach. It's not even the time to do it. What do you need all three Why? Let me just make sure I'm not missing any. This guy does not belong here. Okay, beautiful. I need all three. The other one is already past the worst of the worst. It's already past Pesach and the guy is already 2 years old. This animal is completely pushed off. The other one is but if the Pesach went by but he's still the right age. The could use this carbon maybe on the second Pesach. A month after Pesach. This is the second Pesach for those who couldn't bring a carbon. Maybe you should not turn into a remain a carbon. What about a case? The other one is already The other one is already The other one is already pushed off a little bit from the first Pesach not from the second. The other one is already but in a situation that he's before Pesach and he's not even 2 years old. He's available for this Pesach. So maybe he shouldn't turn into if you check that into early. The other one you shouldn't turn into three That's why I need all three sources. The other one is already The other one is already The other one is already The other one is already The other Merit the source of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a share today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor.mdydaft.com