Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 50 by R' Eli Stefansky

[singing] >> Good morning Rabbi VOICE OUT. THE news must be more serious than we thought. Live from Beit Shemesh. I have a big kiddush today. I know that Mendy screamer scree- scream screamer. What about you Reb Nachman? You did? Reb voice out, we're here we're here in Beit Shemesh. So just a few minutes ago we came out of the mamad. The sirens, exactly when shul was supposed to start, sirens. And they're saying that shrapnel from the missiles landed either on this building or the building next to us. We didn't go check yet, but literally pieces on this block right over here. Yesterday as you all know was a very very sad day. A very not good day for people in Beit Shemesh and all of Klal Yisrael. Nine Nine people were nifter, nine. Nine is a large number and many injured. Um we saw yesterday there was videos, there was uh also in Ashdod and six people were injured at night. And there are a lot of videos going around of yeshiva guys taking videos of these missiles and and I even saw a guy here today on the porch, you know, as these things are coming the the boom, like the shrapnel here on building bam! It's there's a guy on this porch that refused to go in. We have to be more careful with our voice. We have to be more careful. I'm talking to myself also because I'm also a little bit more relaxed this time around. Last time, you know, what are the chances? What are the chances of a missile direct and the mice uh the chances are are, you know, it happens. And the people got hurt because they were outside. Uh it happens to be in the chemist, they were in a macula. So, nothing you can do about a direct hit. But, people got injured from not being in a macula. So, we have to be careful and I want to also remind them today is Remus Einstein's yard side of that is Lavaya as a 13-year-old. I believe it was about there. So, must have been 40 years ago. Wow. 40 years ago. Um Yeah, it was a tough day. Tough day. Um MDY in general, we're in a we're in a sad situation. Everybody that knows our very very good hobby, Yossi Klein, is going through it. So, it's a it's a it's a it's a very hard thing to go through. Um knowing that this should be a hassle in this week and uh the chances are very very slim that they'll be a hassle. The hassle is in America, Carla and Israel. And even if they get together, just there's no What do you make a hassle now? The halls are not open. And even if there is a hall even if you can do it in your house, you can be running to the to the mama every 22 minutes. Not a good massive. And uh a lot of a lot of monetary loss, a lot of a lot of Tsar. So, MDY is is with Yossi. And then we know colleague of the table has a plan. And uh we should have stories. One, you know, there's always it's always good to have some humor and I I took a lot of a lot of was on a comma slash humor shaking my head where I'm going to say I'm going to say this there's going to be people I'm going to get I think Donald Trump is going to go down as the greatest president that America has ever seen, especially for the youth and he did a lot more than Reagan and and all that. He's going to go down Although he has a lot of enemies and people he's going to go down. He's only 1 year into his job and look what he did. But he wrote he said yesterday he said, "We sunk nine Iranian ships." But other than that their navy's doing very well. I I took I >> [laughter] >> Thanks for the attention to this matter. Other than that they're doing very well. I think they only have like 10 ships total. Nine of them are in the bottom of the ocean. Other than that their navy's doing very well. And other than that their air force is doing very well. They they the two planes that they had left over were were in smithereens right now. So Can you have the each one of them is a sham put another guy in charge and they'll get eliminate him. Um Shpitzer Huge shout out to David Solomon for hosting me this week at the MDY satellite location Miami Beach, Florida. His positive energy and enthusiasm is electric. Packed room every night. Unbelievable food. I came for the daf and stayed for the second helpings. An incredible true MDY style. All types of Jews united around Thank you David Best, Naftali Palchik. Ah, he's one of the He's the Palchik family. I got it. L'chaim Tiarlo. Luzzy Longer, I have an idea. So this guy I really enjoyed this idea. It's a simple idea and I think we could incorporate somehow Gary. So the first one is that he's like if you go to another location you want to know where the satellite location is. So we actually have it on the bot. You put in where you are. It tells you where Maybe he's talking about more with directions and all that stuff. But that for that you have Waze. If you go anywhere, it'll tell you where the the closest location to you. All right, Dave? If you It knows where you are. You just write in Miami, it'll tell you where the location is. You need to write where you are. You send your location and the bot will tell you where it is. Just get the bot. But his second his second idea was very cool. It's a simple idea and those are the best. And he's saying that you know, sometimes I have the roll up of the base of migdash and I put it next to me. So, why do you need a roll up? Today everything's digital. You take a nice screen, you put it right next to you. It's there next to you the whole time. One of the things that people used to complain is like, I used to hold charts and used to point and they said it's very hands-on. Now you can do both. You put a screen, maybe it's on wheels even. You could it could you enlarge the screen that you could touch. We did? No, no, but right next to me and I go like this. I could show on the screen the chart that we have. The one that everybody has over there, I can actually next to me. So, the base You never have to do a roll out. You don't have to pull it out. And you're okay, today we need the base of migdash. Boop, it goes on and I can go like this. Right. Okay, but right. It's It is a touch screen. We're going to do a touch screen. It's a touch screen. Kids, uh, we can do it. It has to have be on wheels I think and it has to be secured somewhere in the base of migdash over there. So, that's uh, lazy longer. The Yeah, yeah, that that's coming soon. That's why we're going to have to Everybody asked me, what are you going to do when the cycle is like, every month it changes. If you look at shiyurim just from last year, it's different. The AI and everything. So, like the weather. Exactly. The weather people do it. I don't know what you're talking about, but yes, yeah. Right. No, but something like that. We don't need a green screen cuz it's No, no, no. But over here, you don't need a green screen cuz it's on here. They do it because of other reasons cuz Now you see He writes like this. This guy I'm reading this just for one reason. Yakov Rubin writes, "Last night I was here the Shabbos was unbelievable with Shwekey, the whole thing." And then it hit me like a ton of bricks. What am I saying? Yakov Shwekey flew to Eretz Yisrael for one reason. His concert was cancelled last night. So So tacos, why did you come here? He came here to be with MDY, to give tzitzit to MDY, [clears throat] and bring people to Torah. And now he's here, he's stuck here, and Be'ezrat Hashem we'll get him to join the shiur. It'll be like a win-win-win. That's the reason. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's the reason. Um we had this uh this rov Rav Schachter Schachter from the Tephillin Awareness Project or something. So he keeps on sending me these emails and they're very cool. I want to share with you. He went to yeshiva in Miami. Listen to them the boys in Miami. And here's a film that he found. A guy has a sticker on the bottom of his tephillin. Tzitzit. Here's a kesher that some kid made by himself, homemade kesher. Here's a kesher that's like uh 2 in away from the bayis. Mamash no no good. But one minute, there's one here I want to show you. Oh, this one I skipped. Look closely, you'll see that one of the white strings here in the corner, the gid is is not there. It's gone. The tzir is out. Now if you look closely in the next picture on the uh This just means that more stuff is coming into Eretz Yisrael from Iran. It just we don't know where. So if we have to pause, so first of all, the good news is we did the emails. >> [laughter] >> And if we have to pause, we'll come back Be'ezrat Hashem. Black this guy has his tzitzit in his pants. Yeah. This guy has his tzitzit in his pants. And these are uh also from Florida. The part of the Rivkah Hebrew Academy annual campaign trip skip. This guy is very excited to be in this room. All right. Um I don't know. It looks long, this one, so we'll put it in a different day. Wow. It's a new one. All right. The message is sponsored by David Solomon, dedicated in memory of Rabbi Shmuel Boruch ben Chaim Tzvi Dovid Zichrono l'vracha. The message is sponsored by Jack Dallas and his father Jack Dallas anonymously and the Paluchik family. Here he is. This one? The Paluchik family foundation of Rabbi Gordon Paluchik, the mission to Eretz Yisrael. The message is sponsored anonymously by Moshe ben Nissan. Anonymous for complete dedication to Eretz Yisrael by Yisrael Malki ben Malkiel Zev Kessel. We're so proud of you, Yakov Mordechai Keep Staging. That noise, I don't know if you're if the camera's able to pick it up. So, right over there next to the shamash on that side, you can actually see the F-15s, not F-16s. F-15s means they hold a a heavier load payload of bombs. And you can see them just one after another, like five, 10 in a row, just go before they they get out of the they're coming off the runway. And that means that's a good thing. It's like they're going Tzeischa l'Shalom. You can see them right over here. Tzeischa l'Shalom. Send the Grossman family, Canvey Island. Just explain to the oilam, cuz they're in America, they don't know. So, we went to the I might have said it, but you're sitting in there and all of a sudden very, very loud sounds of explosions next to your window. And then they're saying that a shrapnel actually hit this this block and maybe even this building. But it's one after another and it's it's nerve-racking. But yesterday's sound, everybody agrees that that was the loudest sound by far, probably two three times louder than anything we ever heard. And unfortunately, that means it was a direct hit. And people will lift their from it. Send the girls and family Canvey Island, UK in honor of Reb Elie, you changed my meaning of life. Elie Yossi Mark and Benny and all those in the White House Michelle Obama I already signed on for my Miriam Jimmy Azulay Esther Bas Luna Anonymous for the merit of Ben Sarah and Bas Sarah blessing in all areas of life. Anonymous for the merit of for all of needs of Layma. So fishing fisher in honor of putting putting on filling Send us the down the sea board anywhere worldwide and Sean Basala. Weekly sponsors Axelrod families for 14 years take for Baso and hire. Fishing division and the wife by the Iranian Levy families Perik anonymous of Ben Yossi and Roco. Lama Ramos Toshin Bay What is this? Oh, that was the Perik. The Dof Dove Eisenberger. Thank you for everything that is in my world and being. The Haim to MDY. I guess he knew that and that was Earth Purim. Sitting here Tinus Esther Mom it's unbelievable. Persia Tinus Esther Purim and the Iranians hopefully we don't cave in but they're asking to talk, they're begging to talk and to do something. Daily sponsors Yakov Segal in memory of my father Ben Yossi Levy on his first yard side. And Abba Elie Tarlow 200 since I met Reb Elie by his daughter's house in Park City and he hugged me. I know. And the and the snow snow the film the snowman was by him also, yeah. What was that? I just skipped something. Innovations LLC has this quest to keep all of us safe and to be to be able to see Klein. And in my heart month before Jonathan before Ben Esther. The first I yelled at Voice I here we are. Daf noon on the 11th. And we have a guest all the way from America who got stuck here. What's your name? Yehuda Kupfer. Yehuda Kupfer from Brooklyn. Brooklyn. You you here by yourself? Uh yes. Not with your family, with your >> on a mission with Cross River Bank. Yeah. Everyone else left Thursday night as scheduled and I wanted to save Shabbos but I couldn't find Nachman. >> [laughter] >> Sometimes sometimes I could just borrow who pays the scar or the English after many years. Sometimes it's immediate. You don't say what's wrong with you? No, I'm just kidding. Yeah, I know. Who? Who's that? Oh, Dr. is here. How you doing, doc? Wow. And it's like across the river. Wow. Says the holy Torah. Like you will Kevis my boy. Kevis my boy. Kev I want to show you what the camera show you the misbah misbah hello to you all the time. So is the one that says that if you don't bring the in the morning and you're supposed to bring in the afternoon. But not only the of the afternoon, you bring it all, you bring the morning Thursday afternoon Thursday, you bring it all together one shot. Whereas when it comes to the carbon as if you don't bring the carbon coming in the morning, and it's afternoon time, you don't bring the morning one. Says the Gamara, >> [laughter] >> that the Mishnah goes on to say that the way you're mechanech the Mizbeach Hazahav, [clears throat] this is the Mizbeach Hazahav, right? To remind the oilam, it's beautiful. I don't even know if I showed this in the Hebrew part or not. But I don't know. The moment I mentioned so. >> [music] >> But the Mizbeach Hazahav was in the Heichal, that's the one that you put the ketores on twice a day, in the morning and the evening. The chinuch, meaning the first, the very, very first time that it became kodesh, it became a chinuch. Yeah, but wait a minute. That's not Hold on. It's outside? It's outside. So, Rebbi says, "We're going to convene." We'll be back, Rebbi says. We'll be back. So, Rebbi says, "We are back." Uh uneventful uh occasion. We heard a small boom. Those of us who are zocheh. We are back. Okay, thanks for sticking with us. Rebbi says, "We're holding chinuch manda kashmei." The Mishnah, when discussing the ketores, Reb Shimon says, "Oh, you know, when they first inaugurated chinuch, the inauguration of the Mizbeach Hazahav happened in the evening with the ketores. The menorah happened in the evening with all the neiros. The Mizbeach HaChitzon happened in the morning when they brought the But who's talking about inauguration?" Chinuch manda kashmei. I just like these words, chinuch manda kashmei. It just means like who knows anything about chinuch? Like who >> [laughter] >> Who's talking about even? Now, what does mean? means to What's the mean? What's the mean? Means to to teach a child to teach someone how to act in the future. Right? So for instance, the famous which I'm not 100% you know, I'm not with it. I don't get it 100% but they say about the of that his son was running around. He's jumping around on a table. So somebody said the how come the didn't tell how come the was not him? He says is for the future. I don't think if he's 30 years old, he's going to be jumping on a table. I hear some people took it to the other extreme. You know, the kids do all sorts of interesting things and in the future they won't but maybe in the future they do. Who knows? But one thing's for sure that if you're sitting next to your kid and a lot of these Israelis they they they they they understood this. When you're sitting next to your child in but you don't want the the people next to you to see that you him. So you give him a nice pinch under the table and his thigh, you know, like Look in the there. Mhm, you know. That's not though. Cuz that's not teaching your kid how to act in the future. That's teaching your kid to hate it. Oh, my gosh for me. I called my my gosh for me. Says the history and you're right. We forgot to explain there's a few words missing from the Once you get these words, you'll understand why it fits into the there. If and we're going to see in a second was it on purpose not on purpose but they didn't bring the carbon in the morning. Like you were This is what boys said this is it. The the of that feeling. A man of my word. When is it the halacha that if you don't bring the the carbon tamid in the morning, you don't bring it in the evening? When they never started with love, it was day number one. Why? Because the pasuk, the very very famous pasuk, the pasuk of daf yomi. Let's call the pasuk of daf yomi. especially our shear. We have a shear in the morning, shear in the evening. When could you bring the keves as a keves as a sheini tasivinarbaim? When you have a as a keves as a sheini boker? First First you need to do the morning. You have the morning, you do the evening. I'm not going to say anything to retire about daf yomi that because daf yomi doesn't work like that. You don't do the morning, you do the evening. But here the pasuk says you can't do the evening unless you have the morning. But that's the first day on the Oh, it does work with daf yomi. On the first day. But from then on, it's not like that. On the chanochas hamizbeiach, once the mizbeiach is operating, you kariv uvin arbaim. So if you didn't do the the one in the morning, you do the one in the evening. This is only in a situation when the kohen was a ones. It was a mistake. I'm mazidim, if you did it deliberately If you did it deliberately, then we punish him. We say, since you didn't do it in the morning, you can't do it in in the evening. But when it comes to ketores, it's different. Like you ketores baboker, you ketores uvin arbaim. There's no punishment when it comes to ketores. It's First of all, where's uh picture of the oilam in the uh stairwell. There's not enough room in my mamad. Where we're m'funikdig uh Americans. We need our da da amos. Just go into the moment. [music] I'm okay. Thank Mhm? What's that? There isn't a clock. I was never really the being one during the >> [sighs and gasps] >> What is a clock? I don't need a clock there. Who needs a clock over there? >> [sighs] >> 1 second before you can bring the afternoon tamid, you'll have to let me know why you missed this morning. Okay. So, it's not coming. If it was the maze, it they don't get to bring it again. But, if it was the show, you get yes, but not immediately. How do you know that the the hinukh of the mizbe'ah only happen in the morning. The tan bonam ve sa keves ha sheini ta'aseh ben arbayim. Oh. So, Noam, you have a mesifta. What what what What does it mean? Well, tell me pshat. Anybody can tell me pshat. Who knows pshat over there? The tan bonam ve sa keves ha sheini ta'aseh ben arbayim. What do you see from the possuk? Can't call you can't call the second one. >> What? No. What are you saying? Is there an interception right now? Is [snorts] there an interception happening now in our show, but not in our neighborhood? We don't have a siren. What? It's in Beersheba. Okay. So, again, we're trying to find out that where do you see that the Mizbeach happened only in the morning? What does he say? Right. If you don't have So, So, I just want Rashi says right So, I'm just want to point out. Rashi says that we're using another possuk. This is not the possuk that we used before. He says this is a possuk that doesn't have the Rishon. He says The possuk doesn't even discuss the Rishon. And then you see from here that without without the uh without the I don't know why. For some reason uh we're not using the first one. It's it's without the Rishon you don't have a Shiny. It it goes directly to the Shiny. It's the Shiny in the morning. Shiny in the morning and in the morning. You see that the possuk never mentioned Rishon. If the possuk would have mentioned Rishon, maybe it would be in the in the beginning. No. Shiny in the morning and in the morning. What do you say? It's not This is a regular day. Right. Okay. On a regular day on a regular So, now what's going on immediately here? So, why don't you use the first possible? They already used the first one. No. This is a shiny. Look, look where the olive is. But, that is the schmaltz one. Oh, no, no. So, you're right. You're right. No, no, it's my bad. My bad. This is schmaltz. Turn it on. Sorry. Sorry. Sorry. Bad. Bad. Bad. Bad. Erase. We can start We can manage to erase and go this the sheer. But, not immediately. This is the first possible. You're right, 100%. I even wrote it in my Gamora. Doesn't help. Here, this possible. Bad. Schmaltz. Schmaltz of this. Okay, very good. So, you need You only bring the second one not the first one. That's if there's no bear. I was kind of bear with her by him. But, if there was if this is already operating, do we learn this before maybe? No. I was kind of bear with her by him. But, if there was if the if the is operational, then you can do and you didn't and you missed the first one, then you can bring the first one in the afternoon. And that's where he brings the second possible. Let's see. Okay, why does the second possible help us? This is without You don't need the first one. Uh-huh. In this possible, you don't need the first one. You hear? This possible starts just talks about the second one. So, we don't need the first one. The first one is not market. So, if you already got to the to the bring you could you could bring the first one. There's no equal. If it if the possible would have said the the first one and then there's the second one. So, he's first you have to do one, then you get the two. Over here we jump straight to two, meaning that if you forgot the first one, you could bring the first one in the afternoon. I thought we did this. Ah, we Yeah, we did do it. It's the same words. Same words. Yeah, yeah, same words. Okay. You cannot bring the second the the one that you missed but when tires is different. Now the Gamora goes into why is tires different than a carbon? Just because one mushugana a Russia he does something against the halacha and he doesn't bring a carbon in the morning. So that's why class has to suffer and there's not going to be a carbon coming that day. Now there's a cohen who's a bad guy who didn't bring the carbon. So he is not going to bring the carbon in the afternoon, but others will. But it doesn't say who. Look at the What does hain mean? Oh. >> [snorts] >> The same mishmar. The entire mishmar is punished. Collective punishment. The whole class gets punished if one kid does something wrong? But not not all cohanim. You go to the next mishmar and they could bring the carbon that was missed. Actually we have to rush a little bit because it's my krias shema, you know? Yesterday we even had a problem with my krias shema. Huh? >> [snorts] >> Oh, the guy doesn't know. No, we had it 55. Ah, it's not a problem, yeah. Yeah, we're only on the minute. Look at it. the Mishmar. I think it's the Kohanim who are supposed to be involved in the Tamid. The The The word Mishmar was mentioned in the Rashba. The Rashba says The Rashba was somebody else. But they had a raffle anyway. What was that? >> Put it in the Mishmar. You heard that bomb? What was that? Maybe it was somebody who kicked the table. The The Rashba says >> [clears throat and snorts] >> It could be It could be It could be Mishmar. It could be from the same Mishmar. The Safek. Safek Safek Which is difficult to bring the raffle. Okay. Let's go to what Boyce says. Like Tiyuk Tiyuk Tiyuk Tiyuk Ben Arba'im. If you didn't bring the Tiyuk in the morning, bring it in the afternoon. The Kivan Dilishkhiho Tiyuk is not Shkhiho. So one of the Psukim in Rashi is he brings the Gemara in Yuma. Gemara in Yuma says an amazing thing. That a Kohen never brought Tiyuk twice in his lifetime. A A Kohen could only bring it once in his entire life. So it's very very not common. He's not going to mess it up. Or And also, this is what everybody knows. Umei'atrah. And it makes you wealthy. Khaviv Uvelei Pashie. So people like it. Ah, money. It's a Segulah. So they're not going to And when when people don't do don't they when people There's no concern that people are going to be Poshe'a. There's no There's no There's no reason to make a Kinas. I can't I can't show it cuz people try to try to take it and >> [laughter] >> Lehavai She. Ah. Omer Reb Shimon Ben Kulai Sakrevin Arba'im. You could take both portions of Tiyuk and put it on on the Mizbe'akh Hazahav in the afternoon. Shem Khatam is Mizbe'akh Hazahav. Oh, let me show you this Pasuk. Says in the Pasuk and everybody knows this Psukim. It says a Brakha. Yisimuktar Ba'pekha. The Tiyuk is Ba'pekha, you know. Borekh Hashem Kheiloh. And right after is the next Pasuk. Hashem will give you a Brakha. I think that maybe that's why people read the Parsha of Tiyuk. No, don't they read Tyrus? Oh, love this. Cuz it's good as that she is. But what did Rabbi Miller would say? He said a good vart that the Spiegelman He said it's not about saying it's about saying with kavana so I don't know. Okay. Zog the Gemara. All right, we'll go to the Gemara and we'll come back to this later because the Gemara is right. >> [laughter] >> There's a video here, but you you guys don't want to see it, right? Forget it. We have too many videos today. But Tanya because of the Shacharis So when when the Mishnah says it was done in the afternoon, that [snorts] the inauguration of the Shacharis happened in the afternoon. As the Gemara says it was done in the Shacharis, happened in the morning. So now it's actually when the inauguration happened. Did it happen in the morning or the evening? Omar it happened in the afternoon. Victorious Shacharis in the morning. It seems like it happened in the evening. The Shacharis The morning and the morning and the evening and the evening and the evening and the evening and the evening and the evening. That Hold on. I need to show you this two Gemaras. Very very important. To understand the Ooh. How come I don't Okay. No. Oh, here it is. >> [laughter] >> It says like this. Victorious Shacharis. I'm talking about Shacharis. The morning and the morning in the morning. The evening and the evening and the evening. So when did he From this posuk it almost seems like that it happened in the morning. Victorious Shacharis. The morning and the morning and the evening. The evening means when you clean out the menorah. So where it says like this When you clean out the menorah, you love the way it looks in the morning. Why why are you cleaning out the menorah in the morning? It must mean that you lit it at night. You love the way it looks in the morning. I told you we're talking about the evening. Okay, so once I get that piece, Piece number one is to know that the Torah, the lighting of the menorah is at night because you clean it out in the morning. Now we go to the next possible possible test. Possible test says says "I always wanted to have neighbors been our buying yacht to Reno." Torah is telling me to finish them. In other words, so like two pieces there. I'm not exactly sure why we need both pieces, but in this possible it says that the Torah happened when you light the menorah and we figured out that we light the menorah in the evening because when you clean it out in the morning. It says in the first of this possible sort of "I always wanted to have neighbors been our buying So maybe "I always wanted to have neighbors I wasn't sure that it means to light it." I know for sure that it means to light it because you have to clean it out in the morning. If you clean it out in the morning, that means you lit it at night. And in this possible it says you have to ready to do the Torah at the same time "I always wanted to have neighbors" which means at night. In May law. Oh. So that's the inauguration of the Torah is happened in the evening, not in the morning. What about the Torah is happened in the morning? And what about the argues it says the inauguration happened in the morning? Possible sign of test. Yeah. Yeah, but what I need possible sign. I always wanted to have neighbors been our buying yacht to Reno. You do Torah. But But the Torah is the Torah even says he loved over that law. The Torah goes into whole thing. What? What it says he loved over that law not for the fact. It goes to this whole I always wanted to have neighbors been our buying yacht to Reno. I always wanted to have neighbors been our buying yacht to Reno. I always wanted to have neighbors been our buying yacht to Reno. When it comes to the of the the outside of the we bring all the that happened in the morning, the first comment. So too the Torah is happened in the morning. Next. How do you inaugurate the shulchan with the lechem apanim? We don't have a picture of the shulchan. No, not today. Hello. So, the Gemara is medayek. Elo Let me just say about that. How else could you be mechanech the shulchan? How can you be mechanech the shulchan? You have a table You have a table. How does it become kodesh? How? It has to be lechem apanim. So, don't they go hand in hand? In other words, mashma that the chinuch of the It became It became kodesh on Shabbos through the bread. Elo be cholo chinuch How can you say mikadesh? It seems like that you could be mikadesh the bread on the weekday. That you could put the bread into the shulchan on the weekday. Otherwise, why in the world is the Mishnah saying that the chinuch happens on Shabbos? It's obvious. When's If the only day of the week that you could put the bread onto the shulchan is Shabbos, so that's the only day that it became chinuch through the bread. If I knew that the only day you could light a menorah is on Chanukah, let's say. So, I don't need the Mishnah to tell me that the only time to be mechanech the menorah is on Chanukah. I know that The only time you Obviously, you can't light the menorah on Purim. If the only time to put the bread into the shulchan is on a Shabbos, so the only time you can be mechanech is on Shabbos. The only time you could be mikadesh is on Shabbos. He gufa kamashma. That's exactly what we want to tell you. The chinuch The kodesh of the shulchan is Shabbos. That the way it became mechanech is through the bread. And the lechem apanim could only be on Shabbos. And may I say, it goes hand in hand. Eila kanami, that's what we want to tell you. You cannot put the the the the lechem apanim I don't like calling it bread. The lechem apanim you can't put in Hebrew lechem means bread, but it doesn't sound, you know, good enough. The upon him doesn't go into the corn in a weekday because if it did go on the weekday, then it could be on a weekday. The reason why the could only become on a could only be on a because the only goes in the on a job. You thought he said That's what we also learn in makes this thing. The is no other time to light the only in the evening. So what else could it be? The is telling us that they goes hand in hand. When you light the candles, that's when it comes when you put the bread in, then it becomes good. And it's on a and for the in the evening. So I don't know. >> [clears throat and cough] >> So it's also the says it's a interesting one. It's a statement, one of these riddles. There was at one time in history where the was brought not on the where we always bring it in the hole. Rather on the you bring the and the and all the other ones. One time somebody brought on that there. But it was a very special thing. It was a It was a an exception to the rule. When was it? I don't know. I don't know see him. So it's interesting. We find that when we put the Israel eight on in there. So I don't know. There's certain things that you do by you can break the rules. It doesn't explain by um what's the over there? I don't know what you mean. And sure sure, right? I don't know what you mean. Ate the whole honeycomb with the honey. What's that? Because the the honeycomb became so sweet so to speak that I ate it together with the honey. This is when when is it's out of love. The clients stroll that they built them a Mishkan and there's that everything becomes relaxed. You like also you're eating honeycomb. You're you're there's no Yom Kippur, there's no there's no turns on the side. Break rules out of love. So So we have a we have a a thing. One time in history an individual brought tires on the which means the each one individually brought the tires as a gift on the side. So the guy you have to have the lawyer on the side being mocked. It's like a one-time thing that he brought it which is actually strange. They brought it on the giant What? No. What was the only exception to the rule? Wasn't the What do you mean? Cuz you got to but that was on the side. Inside the side. No. Oh, they they were burning it between the two poles over there. Well, that's that's not an individual. That's part of the We're talking about We're talking about an individual bringing tires as a gift to him. Nothing to do with the side. I am people that says in the to bring tires. What we are saying an individual, you. Are you saying you want to bring tires Look how you can bring tires. It was a one-time thing in the Russia. You can't do it. But are you saying you bring tires on the regular of tires? The of tires you can bring. The side on the side of the car. Well, that was the exception to the rule that they brought it on the outside is better but on the inside better maybe Yachid could bring. And then you can make another deal with the Suam Mizbeach Achitzah Yochid Lo Yochil Otziv U'mikarev. Perhaps the tzibur could bring K'tarus as a communal gift to Hakadosh Baruchu on the Mizbeach Achitzah. But that can't be. So the Gemara just brings a braisa that that's assur for Yachid and a tzibur. But at the end of the day we have a diuk from here that he could. It says the one time it was a one time thing on the outside one mashma that the inside one a Yachid could bring. So what do we do? But Daniel says you can't. Yochil Yochid Lo Yochil Meivi K'yotzei B'no Davar Acharei Acharei Acharei Yochid Yochid Meivi Davar Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei And I'm going to say the pasuk that when you make a shvuah you're going to bring a gift you have to keep it. Lo L'ma'aseh L'chulu Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei You're not going to bring on the davar of k'tarus. Only what the Torah tells you. Yochil Lo Yochil Yochil Maybe Maybe okay individual can't bring a private uh k'tarus. Shemay BeChayav Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei in the Torah that a Yachid could do that. Aval Tzibur Ya'aleh Maybe but maybe uh a whole community could bring k'tarus as a gift to Hashem. Shemay BeChayav Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei because you see that the tzibur does bring every single day k'tarus. Aval L'ma'aseh L'chulu It's L'shem Rabim You're the the the the community cannot bring k'tarus. Yochil Ya'alu Mizbeach Maybe Aval Ya'alu Mizbeach Achitzah Perhaps the Lo Ya'alu L'chulu means on the inner Mizbeach the one the normal Mizbeach for k'tarus. Aval Ya'alu Mizbeach Achitzah Perhaps the community could bring it on the outer Mizbeach. Aval Lo Ya'alu Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei Acharei K'chol Asher Tzevichu Ya'asu exactly the way I told commanded you. Don't do anything extra. Einoch L'ma'aseh She'omer B'inyan You could only do what I commanded you to do them is to bring twice a day k'tarus. Don't bring any more even if you're the community. Turning of the daf, a daf global, have your clients all year, not just this month. mishadag.com, please read a shidduch today. Huh? Zog to you more. Omrim by Rabah by a kama. Ah, so we have a diuk that a yachid could bring in the inner mizbe'ach and the tzibbur could bring on the outer mizbe'ach, what do we do? Even though we just learned that he can. Omrim by Rabah by a kama. The way you daik it is spot-on. Omrim by a tzibbur mizbe'ach chitzon lo yashka. Of course the community cannot bring extra ketores. We learned by a yachid mizbe'ach pnim lo yashka. We never found anywhere that an individual could bring ketores like a kohen does on a daily basis. Ela afi lu yachid mizbe'ach chitzon lo yashka min ha nesi'im. Perhaps you want to mimic what the nesi'im did. The nesi'im brought ketores on the outer mizbe'ach, so you too, in 2026, you're going to decide, "Oh, I'm like a nasi, I'm going to bring ketores on the outer mizbe'ach." And you want to know that we say, "No, hora'ah she'hi asur impossible. It's not going to work." Oh, easy stuff now. I got it though. Chavivi kohen gadol lehavdil bayom ha tzo'im. There's a rule that the kohen gadol brings a mincha every single day, half in the morning, half in the evening. He brings an issaron of flour from home and he divides it every single day, twice a day, one in the morning, one in the evening. But it has to be lehavdil bayom ha tzo'im. You cannot go home and bring half. You have to bring the whole shiur of an issaron and divide it. So let me ask you a question. Let's say we know that 300 kohanim gedolim died in the second bayis. In 400 years, for something for 20, 300 died. In other words, it's very possible that a kohen gadol brought his mincha in the morning and then he died. So the kohen gadol that takes over that day, what is he supposed to do? How many what does he bring? A half? Two halves? Zero? What does he bring? Does he bring because we just said that the coin God will cannot bring a half a sheer from home. Does he bring the whole sheer? Now, half was already given. So, now what does he do? So, that's what the mission is going to discuss. But, this is a solid rule. We're not going to break this rule. The rule is you cannot bring halves from home. Bring the whole. It's heavy. Weighs 5 lb. If you have to carry 5 lb for 2 mi, it's very heavy. It's a lot easier to carry 2 and 1/2 lb and go back home and come back again. No. And maybe sorry and shall we cut say you. You can bring a full amount. You have to bring a full amount and you chop it in half. Half in the morning, half in the evening. He makes six breads out of it each time. And he throws the breads onto the back. I'll show you a video in a second. If he's a coin that brought a half in the morning then he dies. They appointed a second coin God instead of him. Do not bring a half of you sorry from your house. And the half of you sorry of the first one. And then maybe sorry and shall we cut say you. He has to bring a whole you sorry. And he And he And he divides it. He only He only You You only puts half of it on the back and the other half goes five. You have to burn it. The first half of the coin God that was nifter has to be burned. The second half of the The new coin God has to be burned. So, two halves are brought. Two halves are burned. Here's the video. Yeah, the the the the coin of that says he has to bring it from himself. He can't use somebody else's carbon. >> [music] >> This is how you make a the middle of the video. >> [music] [music] >> Half an hour. >> [music] [snorts] >> Who is it over [music] here sir? Licho, it's Licho. Maricho. Now, what is this called? Jalito. Cuz he puts it in water. It's like a bagel, a good bagel from the old days. >> [music] >> Good bagel from the bagel factory they said. You got your style [music] on there. Questions after. >> [music] >> If you see this five area, you'll see four subwoofers. >> [music] >> Yeah, right there is six. That's in the morning. And in [music] the evening. You got all the Okay, now. There's another one. I did? But here, this I didn't show. There's a kind of God that has his oxygen tank. Put it down there. He's weak. My kind of God [music] is solid. I'll be double. That is so embarrassing. >> [music] >> We mean we have to talk to him. There's a lot of questions here. Do they wear And also the the big day cooler I'm not so sure yet. >> [music] >> How do you say shiny? How do you say shiny? You say shiny. You take those two? Yeah, not that big. Who says it wasn't going to go? It looked different. I don't want to get dirty. Turn it over. Is he going to mine now? So we have to move. It's always repetitive. So bring half of your home. And then he goes home and he brings another half. From it. The half from it. So that's you have to start off with a whole. Okay, it's that. Maybe it's you bring the entire amount and you divide it. Have in the morning, have in the evening. What if the second half becomes Tommy? Now what do you do? Maybe you should go home and bring a half. You always have the full amount and you divide it. So you have to go home, bring the full amount, divide it. And he bring and he's making with the second half that he wasn't making with yet. But now he's left over with the whole half of that, you have to burn it. Nim some craving or even them comes out that he he was macro of the right amount and two halves are lost. One became to me and the second half that he went home and brought the whole amount, that second half also has to be burnt. Coin God sugar makes the remains. Coin God all dies. Point somebody else instead of you have to send it to be shown. Maybe she use the original coin God all's half That's what I'm showing you maybe macro of you have to bring a whole amount. He's macro of half. Okay, so maybe some shall we tell you. He divides it. Who macro of and he and he's macro of it over and half goes to waste. This is what I'm waving them craving. No addition here, right? Has a lot. Time to come in the bathroom. Next to me two bits of this is right for. As we saw in the video you take both halves and you put them in the fire. All my mission is shining my trouble. I understand that the first coin God all he brought two halves. One he when he put on his back, the second one he's about to put on his back, then he died. So since it was right to be put on the back so now it became possible cuz he's dead. So now it's possible. You can't bring it on it's possible. So I understand why something that's possible you have to burn. I will show you what you saw. Because I leave it out. Actually maybe not. Maybe the first one is asking no. The first one is not possible. Why is it possible? It was right to go on the back. It's not possible. The second one the second coin when he brings a whole amount and he knows to begin with that half is not going to be good. That's possible. You already have it. So I don't need to wait for Selena. Yeah. It's possible right now. So if it's possible right now, why do you have to leave it overnight? Leave it out. Who said that you need to leave it over? Turn to the very That's his shita, Rabo. So he says even if you have the bad carbon, you made a certain carbon possible, you have to you have to wait overnight to put on the mizbeach. So you see that even if something is possible, you have to wait overnight. So too by ya, what? I said What I said? I said you put on No, no, no, no. You have to wait overnight in order to burn it, not to put on the mizbeach. Hashem, did I really say that? For real? Wow. I would not even Even though I said it and you tell me I said it, I don't have any recollection of it. Wow. You wild it. Maybe I'm maybe I'm Yeah, maybe I'm running on maybe 60, 70, who knows? Wow. You could say something, you don't even know you said it. So I can't even argue with you guys that I said it. No, yesterday somebody said you didn't say these words. I said 100% I said Let's go to the video. Then I remember saying it cuz that I remember. Okay. So anyways, somebody made pigel. Pigel. Pigel is a terrible soul. You could die for if you eat it the whole of the whole. So you think it's possible. It's possible. Burn it right now. No, you can't burn it right now on the basis of you have to wait overnight and burn it. So the same thing with our flower. It might be possible. We have to wait overnight. Flower is certainly not as possible as pigel. Pigel is much more homer. Okay. You could say that it goes according to Rabona the pigel. You don't have to wait overnight. You could burn it immediately on the basis of rafa. When the coin the second coin goes the his flower in half, he has a choice. He can use the one on the right, the one on the left. So since they're both available to be put on the they don't have a it doesn't have so in order to burn it you have to wait overnight and then get it more. We could keep on going. I don't know how much time. The truth is we only started about an hour ago minus the the break we took. So we have we have a few minutes here actually. It more. How do you make? In other words, let me explain the question. The question is that in the possible there seems to be a contradiction. First it says means you bake it. Means that you put it in water. Put in water. And then it says means we're going to say that it's somewhat in oil. Here, let me just show you in the pictures it would look something like this. Is the one on top left corner which is in the oven. You're you're baking it. We're better than the Vienna. Means water. So a little bit of oil. So how do we get around all these things? So we know they have to do all these processes. But which one comes first? Is first and then to finish? Oil or is it the opposite? So I have a actually have a three-way like this. How could it be three-way like this? It's either you bake it and then oil or you deep fry it or you deep fry it and then bake it. And what's the third option? Bake, fry, bake. You I saw you also knew it. Bake, fry, bake. It more. First you bake, then you fry. Deep fry, then bake. How do you remember that, Reuben, from the video or from the the sheer? Cuz there's a video that that highlights it. I I learned before. Ah, you learned it before. So the sheer yesterday was like the khazar, and this is like the triple khazar. Says that I'm right. The what? First you bake, then you deep fry. Tufina, look at the word tufina, which is super interesting word. Tefina, no. In other words, if you were to deep fry first, it'd get a very dark color, not a nice color. So what do you do? First you bake it. You take the baked good, you There's nothing to It's like a It's like a donut. Taking your donut, putting into the First you have to bake it [clears throat] a little bit, then you throw it into a bunch of oil. There it goes like a schmack. I don't know if they do it like that, but it sounds good. They don't do it like that. Some places do. >> [laughter] >> So Rashi says, "No, first you deep fry. Why? Tufina tefina no. That once when you bake it, it should already be slightly How do you call it? It's like you finish. No. It's the finish off like Sometimes they sell you stuff that's like half done, and you throw it in. Here, it should be deep fried sort of, and then you throw it into the oven, and you bake it. It's a machlokes tanoyim. Here we go all through all three shitos. Tufina tefina no. You should first deep fry it a little bit, so that when you bake it, it should be um rare. Not rare. Rebbe Yochanan says raw. Not raw 100% but rare. Rebbe Yochanan says tefina you should make it nice not not rare rare not ah pretty nice So how do you make it nice? First you bake it then you deep fry it this mom is beautiful. And finally the 30 that we didn't see yet so he rather You should bake it twice. In other words bake deep fry bake. It's like not it's like not like this. You you first you bake it. So when you sorry You bake it first you're going to have not. It's going to be nice when you put it into deep fry. You're also going to it's also going to be where you going? Oh. And you also thought you stopped sharing. And also it's going to be uh slightly cooked undercooked before you put it into the oven for the second time. So here we have a little bit of uh Those who know know. If you know you know. There are people that live for this stuff. Welcome back viewers. Today we're tackling the Minhas Rav Itan challenge. Let's see what our contestant whipped up for us. Yonatan get over here. >> [applause] >> Here you go. Mhm that crunch back. You can really tell that he baked it first and then fried it in oil holding like Rabbi Yohanan. No way. The oil totally penetrated the inner layers of the dough. He definitely fried it first and then baked it just like Rabbi Hanina. Okay so we have a split decision on the judging panel. Are either of them right? What does our contestant say? Wrong you amateurs. I baked it tossed it in the fryer and then shoved it right back in the oven. Going with the shita of Rabbi Yossi. Boom. I hope you guys in Lakewood don't watch this one. Okay. Good. Not awesome. We got another We have a minute or two? Not awesome. Everything you do with the with this mincha of the Cohen Gadol whether you're kneading it or braiding it or baking it, everything has to take place in the Azara. Here's the big chiddush. So, that's the sugia we're going to go do a little bit today, most of it and the rest tomorrow. It's You can do this on Shabbos. You can bake it on Shabbos. You know what I mean? How do I know that you can push it off? Shabbos is pushed off. You don't have to bake it on Friday. You have to It has to be a nice bread. You have In Eretz Yisrael, there's a big no-no here in Eretz Yisrael. You can never have second day old bread. It doesn't work. Always the fresh bread. Why? Because if you bake it a day earlier in Eretz Yisrael, it could blow up a little bit. It's not It's not kashrus. So, it's masculine. So, in those days, I guess they had They had their little ways of keeping things fresh. They would put it in some vegetables. I don't know what. Kavush almost seems like to pickle it. Pickle it in in in You pickle bread. Pickle bread. Preserve. Preserve is the right word. Preserve it in the vegetables. So, somebody said yesterday, he says by us in He's Satmar. He says we we wrap the bread in lettuce and we put it in the refrigerator and mamish, you don't know. Mamish, it's mamish fresh out of the oven. And then uh If if anybody's Okay, I'm not going to say who did this, but just yesterday, somebody took a bunch of fresh fresh bread, put it in the freezer. I suppose if you take it out if you put it in when it's fresh, you take it out, boom, comes out And he says, "Yeah." The last night the day also said, "Yeah." But fresh. >> [laughter] >> Mom is the same way? Wow. Like a fly. You take a fly. It's not not momish. You lose a little bit of the flavor. A little bit. You put the fly in the freezer, it comes out 2 months later, you take it out, you defrost it, and it starts flying. The baby will be small tuna. No, there's a positive that says, "You should you shall do it." How? Even on Shabbos. You also have a feeling of tumor even if there's tumor. Have a wonderful day and a Have a wonderful day and a and a meaningful fast. And you should make it purim. Merit the schutz of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shear today. mdysponsor.com or [email protected].