Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 3 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning. Live from Park City, Utah. She is available for anybody in the Utah Park City area skiing in Shiva week. Um I saw a few videos of people doing sum. There are people on the slopes. So, just know that we are here at the Jewish Collective Center. Look it up. And uh tomorrow, Shir is going to be at 8:30 p.m. local time. So, that is Wednesday, 8:30 p.m. That's the English year. Yesterday, I was in Toronto with the I didn't go alone. A Remy Coenfluent Special, Mark Ashkanazi, Yosi Klene, Benny Rodnik. Who else? I know I'm missing somebody. Oh, Mullandi just to be Mazak just to come along. Benny Rdnik who Bim is going to be working full-time for MDY. Uh extended his ticket, a whole thing just to be able to make it. Why did we choose Toronto? Beautiful crowd showed up there. We have a very long standing relationship with Toronto starting uh 7 years ago with Mayor Planka and Ary Blau. I did some sort of summ there. I think it was a sim. Yeah, I don't remember the but like it was four years ago at AJ's house and uh it was a beautiful beautiful uh I got to see the tremendous tremendous he stayed through the whole she which [snorts] was very humbling because you know he's a big he has other things to do and he sat throughout the sh um in Toronto they're powerhouses over there. You have Pinszel now and Jamie Auli pushing the satellite location idea because we have to get it in anywhere in we have different locations but we need to get stronger larger and push them said don't forget we just started it's not too late to bring your friends it's not too late to get on your statuses um Shalom brought brought I think 90 people 90 new people to the DAFF through a status pinsel brought 70 plus people to the DAFF through a status um Shimmy J what's the name of his status also he started bringing people in anybody has a status you don't have to have 50 to 100,000 people in your status you have a thousand people on your status 200 people in your status people will join if you just post your own message and put it to status. It's not a lot of work and it's this are everlasting. So, we have a few thousand people that join us from and I hope they uh they don't mind the fact that I'm taking a tour through the United States. We're in Toronto. Now, I'm in Park City. I'm going to be here for a few days back to the New York tri-state area. Maybe even Miami. We have to see about Miami because it is yeshiva week and it's up in the air. Tom's River. Look at this. The amount of people here, beautiful, beautiful. They have a a very, very strong satellite location going. Bakazakam Williamsburg. Look at this. I love this. So, we're having here a little uh get together and one of our Williamsburg participants >> [clears throat] >> uh he has like a promotional item company. So, this is what he did. A nice notebook. MDY. It's not about what you learn, it's the effort. Keep climbing. Beautiful. A notebook and uh [clears throat] >> kettle sort of >> the MDY logo there. Gald >> MDY. We're here live in Wburg. Hollywood, Florida. So that's the place I was going to go have to see. Oh, man. Is that Toer? No, that looks like Kobe actually. I don't know who that is. Baltimore. Very nice. They sent me in the Chicago picture also. Chicago made a Los Angeles not of Englander. Dear Rebell, it's currently 2:25 a.m. and I'm on my way to Tel Aiv from Tel Aiv to Jerusaleam. I'm listening to you mentioned about someone who's one can right away and complete shabas. I just sat next to non-religious told me that he wears to every day. However, he keep however to keep shabas. He said that's too much. I notic that he felt bad about it. told that I believe told I received the email not that it's okay the will take credit forb the will say told me that but the point is that the same told me that used to smoke on shabas that if you cut down just on one cigarette per shabas is itself keeping a part of shabas somebody asked the cash but you see that if you're fasting you break the fast it's not considered at I was saying that there's something called the tightness of rivet that you just leave over one piece of food on your plate. You see I'm not going to eat the entire plate that itself is considered some sort of tinus the tightness of the rivet. So if you keep one part of shabas I'm not saying that uh it's a shabas I mean I'm not promoting breaking shabas and not being I'm saying if a person has that struggle doesn't mean that you should continue breaking shabas and continue struggling that's all I said as much as you keep you'll get whatever that is will give you for that amount that you keep and then I began listening and said the exact same thing. Wow, keeping thank you Jacob England Larry Jaffy. Dear Shabelli, I'm home from the Shabat for a few days now and I'm still riding the high. It was the most amazing experience. I was listening to all the stories and I realized that if it were not for MDY, I would probably never have opened up a Gumarra. Now here I am 2,200 daff and looking forward to completing shots with you. What aus. So this individual Larry Jaffy only has 511 daff left. Mdy has enriched my life in so many ways. He's never stopped being I guess is that what everybody has left? I guess that's the nas. Yeah, makes sense. 500 days is more than a year. Yeah. And has enriched my life in so many ways. Please never stop being our cheer. May Hashem bless you and all you do. Ephraim Jaffy and cats. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to be at the but after seeing all the pictures and videos. I'm already planning to be there next year. I was thinking about the two pillars of MDY, Mark and Yasi. Mark Ashkenazi who's on the computer right now behind the scenes always when I'm on the road and Yasi Klein our CEO and how their partnership represents something so rare and beautiful. You don't even have to attend this year. I actually saw a picture today, the two of them, and I was thinking the same thing. Mark with his type of yarmaka and Kle with his yamaka and his pis and beard. You don't even have to attend the sh to feel the when was the last time you saw a safari. I don't know. I hope he's not talking about marshazi because he's not spari. He's he's um yucky and aonovicher working side by side with such harmony. It's truly unbelievable and inspiring. If I may add one small request, is it possible to start sending out the share by email as well? I think we do send it out in email. I don't hear a lot about it, but I know we used to. Not everyone has WhatsApp and this could help even more people connect and join the share. Thank you for everything you do. You're [clears throat] doing you're ch you're changing lives, saving lives, building lives. Don't know where I would be without you. Thank you Cats. I love this picture because it's a candid picture. Um The father is watching one of the AI videos and all his kids are clamoring around him to watch. And finally, Kosha Delux, good afternoon Rebellux, how can I help you? Sitting with this guy from Switzerland asked him if he does the DA. He said he does other learning programs like to which I responded, I also do and yet I still find time to do the DA of the rebell. See, that's great because a lot of people they tell me they do. It kind of gets me. I'm like, okay, if you're doing have nothing more to say, you're learning to every day and that's great. That's all I care about. You're doing another program. But he's saying, "No, I also do." He has the right to say it. I don't have the right to say it. I do, but I find the time to also do a day and get more. sent him the link and told him I'll follow up with him in a week. Wanted to hear the belly thought thoughts on following up with your new recruiters recruits 100% a thousand%. I actually reached out to a few people today that told me that they uh you know shran got 90 people. I told Shalom I gave him a whole long schmoo how it's very very important to get new people but it's even more important to get them in a um what's it called to make them accountable and in a nice way in a way just you know send out a a survey who did the daf who could you know write done just one word done get the into it get the guys into it one after another and the idea is to get them going for the first month, two months until they build the real habit, which takes 60 days, 90 days. Once they're in a habit, then you could let them loose. But in the beginning, you don't want to be a nudge, but in a nice way. Looking forward to for the first time in my life. Keep the AI videos coming. Family chat loves them and the kids. Stay tuned for a new stand to be put up in the restaurant Paris and offering free fries or drink for anyone that signs up. Um, Avict Weiss, I'm not telling you what to do with your money, but my feeling is just a gut feeling that fries is not going to cut it. You want to get a guy to learn Tyra, you want him to commit to something that's in the beginning difficult. one thing of French fries or free drink, think you're gonna have to up up your game a little bit. Now, again, it's not my money, so I can't really tell you, but just my gut tells me that somebody's not going to commit to a lifelong dafi thing for a couple of French fries for $150 worth of French fries. Now, you want to give him a free meal. You want to give him a free I don't know what you serve over there. Now, we're talking something else. You want to give him $30. Okay. Hit French fries with the lots of aava avdar wise kosher deluxe Midtown New York. Clifton listen I don't know maybe fries in Midtown New York cost $30. Clifton New Jersey daffing since Yumo 87 but I do appreciate I appreciate the the thought just maybe up it a little bit. Yeah, a boy in Hollywood. We're doing a Hebrew shar. It's live at 2:00 p.m. New York time Miami time at 8:00 at night. Wow. And on Shabas at 1:00 Shabas 9:00. Okay. New sheer watch in Queens, New York. Cool. Very cool. Like it. Oh, I wrote to myself two notes. It wasn't really for the but it's on the screen. Uh, it's a good thing I wrote it because I completely forgot. I was interviewed by the famous world famous Jakob Langanger. He has I think like two million subscribers or something, something crazy. Over a million subscribers. Um, it's close to two, my son said. So, I was interviewed by him for a long time. I um it was a decent interview. I liked it actually. It was good. I was very, very tired. Jet just came off a plane, so I'm a little bit more subdued, a little bit more serious than usual, but I think it was a good interview. And I people are starting to join the share because of that interview. So, it's good as long as it brings people to Taro. Go check it out on Living. It's on YouTube. I don't know where else. living. All right. What else do we have? Oh, we have sponsors. A lot of new sponsors. Let's get used to the sponsor. Wait a minute. Uh, we're missing Oh, how a businessman became a Torb 50,000 Jews. But rai, that's one problem I have. Yakov, it's Reveli. It's not Raveli. Um, I didn't tell him that, but whatever. Call him out in live. Where's uh David Solomon? Mark, we got to throw in David Solomon. He got lost somewhere. So, these are all sponsors. $9,000 per one of these to all of them. Send the gross and family candy cami island UK in honor of Rebelli who changed my meaning of life. Thank you anonymous for complete. We're so proud of you. Mark and Benny and all. is this pli spent $9,000. I love plenty ali. He's the ply. We're very similar in a lot of different ways and all the sponsor David Salman dedicated memory of it was beautiful that David Solomon who said he's not coming to the shabatan and he told me again he's not coming and he wasn't going to come and at the last minute he came with his two sons and he says next year he's coming with his homish and his wife and I'll stay even for Miriam Jamie. Thank you Jamie. He hosted us. He got a cater to come to his house. Phenomenal caterer. Great food in Toronto last night. Esther Walking Maz. My husband Natan walking on his 40th birthday. A hidden generation. Anonymous in memory of Mazel Ba and his anonymous a verdict that is good and open and revealed way of weekly sponsors memory of our beloved raud upon his fifth fifth yard site anonymous as a for successful fertility treatment among other things. A bunch of people came to me and asked me and I feel very uncomfortable every single time but they asked me for fertility and it's thing it's a thing that a lot of people struggle and it's a very very difficult struggle thing giving a my birthday should give you and the to continue with your hashem I'm still an emotional wreck what he means says the emotion that we went through, the emotions that we went through on Shabas were so overwhelming that it literally causes pain to the brain. It's like it drains your it drains your whole brain. It's that itself makes you weak. Um, yeah. To see Israel Goldstein with his camera taking pictures and all of a sudden the camera just drops and he's crying, falling, falling from emotion. Here we go. We are in the second day of today we have a easy daff the most of the daff is going to be discussing this idea that we learned yesterday that according to and rabb explains that goes with time of the let me look into the reasoning behind what the says and when you could tell that what a person is doing is false. It's we ignore what he's saying and doing. When a person is saying that he's he's bringing a flat, but in fact, he's bringing a very thick soft one. So, we just ignore him. We say, "Okay, he said it, but but he didn't mean it." And therefore, it doesn't ruin it. Whereas when you're doing a carbon, you can't tell because every looks the same and every looks the same, every looks the same. So when a person tells you that I had a mind to bring instead of that ruins the carba in a way but doesn't. So basically what we're going to be doing today is going through a lot of different cases. Let me throw an example. A carbon pes we know is a little sheep less than a year old. So if a person shows up to migdosh with a cow and he brings a carbon pes from a with a cow. So you said the guy is crazy. The guy he didn't mean it to be a carbon p. So it's it's it's a joke. Ignore him. You know what I'm saying? So when when it's when it's very when it's very clear that what the person is saying and doing are so different and they're opposites then his actions speak louder than words and therefore his actions are what count not the words. Does that hold true to everything? And that's why we're going to go through different cases. What if you bring an animal? Another example. What if I'm supposed to bring a one-year-old animal and I bring a 2-year-old animal? Are those actions that speak louder than words? Or perhaps people don't really know the difference between a what if I was supposed to bring a male because all are male and you brought a female. What if I brought I was supposed to bring a female because all are female most and I brought a male. It's that action that speaks louder than words. And that's that's today's like I said easier stuff today. And here's [sighs] Wow. All I could say is wow. An emotional mish emotional emotional shamas on all levels. Great picture. We're holding 10 lines from the bottom of B sim. Great. Now I have some tears in my eyes. These are all the different questions that we're going to bring on this idea of actions speak louder than words. Okay. So for this we need to explain a little bit and here it goes. There are two types of birds that we bring in the B mikdash a pigeon and a dove. We bring a and that's it. There's no there's no there's only two. There's no shita on a bird. Although today we sh not in the B mdash. For that we do malika. This is what malika would look like. It's the nail of the thumb goes from the back of the neck. And that's how we killed the bird. It's not a it's called a malik. Now what do you do? There's something called haha and something called miti. Hzah is when you take the bird and you shake it. You don't touch the misb. You throw the bird sort of a throwing motion with your right hand towards the misb and the blood from the neck goes flying onto the misb. That's hu is when you take the bird and you fetch it on the wall of the you squeeze it onto the wall. Let's see how that looks. That's me. Now notice the cayenne is standing above the red line. There's a red line on the back. That's called the he's standing above the red line. That indicates to us that this is an bird because an bird goes above the red line. There's only one other carbon that goes above the red line and that's a animal. Everything else goes below the red line. So if it's a bird will go below the red line. An oil bird all you do is mitas bird you do both do hah and then you do mit you sprinkle it and then you do here you do this let's see and you'll notice here he's standing below the red line and he throws he tosses the bird towards them the blood comes flying out and hits him back that's called what the is going to do now is say look from the fact that he's doing it above the red line indicates to me that he's doing an or from the fact that he's doing or let's say h is only for so that would indicate to me that he's doing a so if you say action speak louder than words so his action is showing us whether it's an or depending on where he's standing or what he's doing is it has or So I'll know whether it's or again there's only has which is the sprinkle and then which is the squeeze has both. So let's see inside. So now if you take an bird and you say it's a bird, but you're above the red line, the fact that you're standing in a place that only is reserved for an So that tells me that it's an the fact that you said that you're doing a means nothing to me. You made a mistake. You misspoke. your your action of being above the red line is louder than the words that you spoke and it should be a good bird. Why? The fact that you're standing above the red line proves to me that you're being bird because if it was bird, you would be standing like in this picture below the red line. says, "No, that's not what you can't perform the malik above the red line. We learned if you perform the malik with your thumb, you kill the bird with your thumb above the red line, even though it's kosher." So just the fact that he's standing above the red line doesn't tell me that's an as well. So now they ask the other question which I kind of prefaced. If you're doing an bird, but you did, which is squeezing above the red line and you said to yourself that you're doing it should be good. Why your actions prove what you're doing? It's I'm proving that you're doing an because if it was the bird, where do you do the do below the red line? So first of all, two problems here. First of all, be below the the red line. Second of all, you do the tossing, the throwing, not the squeezing. First, you do the throwing. So it says because people are going to say maybe what you just noticed was the squeezing of the neck of the bird after he already performed the in other words people from your your action is not conclusive because yes you squeeze the bird but is supposed to squeeze after you toss it first you do then you do so now I caught you doing mitsu above the red line it doesn't mean it's an perhaps and I'm doing the mit after Because we learned if you do anywhere above the red line as well, it's also why because the main part of the is the sprinkling not the so asking third question the shame. What about the rivers? You take a [snorts] bird and you say that it's an bird and you do. Now is reserved only for not for because I could prove to you that the fact that he did that it's a and not because if it was he would do it above the red line. That's number one. And number two, you wouldn't do you don't do for you only do. You only do the squeeze. Says the now thear gives in on this case. You're right. That case you took bird and you said it's an bird. He did. Sorry. He did a took bird. It's obvious that it's bird. But what what we were saying is that the you could see the actions speak louder the words by and not by animals but by birds. Yes, you could tell from the action of a bird. I apologize. drink from the battle says. Now another question. So here's the here's a picture of the Um, let's see if I can zoom in on the muzz here. This this guy right over there, that's now where the finishes, you can see the ramp of the that's the southern part of the and then you have this square on top. Let me see if I can get I don't know if this is going to work laser. Here we go. Yeah, it doesn't work when this area right over here and above this whole area is the northern part of the in other words this line right over here which is the end of and upwards is north from this area down over here that's south all kachikach now let's go to the list of kachikachin kachikach What else? They must be above the red line above in the northern part of not in the southern part. All can beed even in the south. It's hard to understand's question really is saying well from the fact that you did it in the south is the but no you could do in the north as well could also do in the south. So that's answer if you take an it. So here you can see you checked it in the green box but you have in mind that it should be a schlum. Let's say take an which belongs only in the green box. You say it's it's from your actions that you'reing why you in the south. So it seems from tis that typically speaking they would always these carbonas in the south if they had an emergency and there was not enough room then they would also shuck it in the north. So that that was that you could see from his action that it's a not a from the fact they shut it in the north not in the south the said you could check the column also in the south not only in the south so you could check in the green box as well the fact that you checked in the green box doesn't tell me that's kach and kachum lally this. Anyway, so now another question. What if I take my voice is still shot from shabas by the way? What if you take and you it in the south? Now it's impossible to say that there because for sure you cannot take an or in the south those are reserved only to the north but he said that he'sing it he takes a and he says but I'ming it for now we have a situation where his actions prove that it's not an because he wouldn't check an in the south Why? You can prove from his actions. It must be that he's really and he just misspoke and he said that if it was he would only in the north goes to something brand new. It's in fact And he was. Yes. He took an and he was. So now this opens up a box of worms so to speak. Why? Because once we go that route and we say, "Oh, a person could be." So actions don't speak louder than words. So you do you take an action and you're being so then the same thing would apply to the we spoke about yesterday. If he's trying to do a thick soft mah. So, so what if he said that it's a thin hard? Actions speak louder than words. But maybe no, maybe he's being so if a person makes a So here, let's see what a mas looks like. We have something new today. >> [snorts] >> This is mas. The top one is mahes. The bottom one is makas. It's thinner. But here, this is a little bit better. Maresh is on the right. Thicker, comes out softer. Same amount of ingredients, but a larger pot. And because it's a thinner frying pan, so to speak, so it becomes becomes thicker and harder. We should say the same thing. The fact that he said in his mind that it's the thicker wall he's been and he put it he wants to bring it in in in a frying pan since he said his nether was he's going to bring it once but once he changes it and he brings it in it turns We learned he says I want to bring a but he brought it in. He said I want to bring but the fact is that he brought it in a frying pan in it changes it physically. He has to rebring it once he says the word zoo. Similar to what we said yesterday then means he says zoo and he's saying this flower specifically. So now doesn't change you take out these words. He says, "I want this flower to be a but at the end of the day brought it in." So perhaps he said so says you're right according to however says that he is what you say with your mouth and saying oh I want it to be something else but the fact is you're doing you're you're doing A but you say you want it to be B. His mouth doesn't do anything. It doesn't matter what he says, what word he uses. Even if he uses the word zoo, it doesn't change anything. Says, so we're continuing. We're still probing. We're still pushing. And at the end of the day, we're going to see that are certain things that action speak louder than words. Even in If you take anah ana is supposed to be male and you say that it's a which is always female not always but it's supposed to be female. Why is always a male and is supposed to be female? Says since that the brings but that particular is a z. So it's it's not 100% that what you're bringing here the zah is because there is a that is a zah. Whether or not the Ni has to be there or not be there, it seems like from the fact that there is a possibility and somebody standing from the side would be confused. Then it's not an action that speaks louder than words. So now the keeps on going, keeps on pushing. But there is a that's guaranteed to be a female and you can't say you cannot say that it's a why because individual notes what are you going to say then what about the reverse what if you take which is a female and you said it should be is always a male so it can't be it must be your actions are speaking louder than words So you're going to tell me in that case it's a good talking about cheap and cheap traditionally unless they change it because in our generation they cut it off almost like a Doberman and pincher but a a true you know an original sheep look something like this. They have very very large tails and you cannot tell whether it's a male or a female. And that's considered like the fattiest part of the the sheep. Very very to eat. That's great. If you're bringing sheeps, you have this kind of excuse or reason to to not know the difference between what if you brought a goat? How would you know? You should know the difference. But to make to to differentiate between when you see a dog in a park and somebody asks you two minutes later, was it a a male or a female? Usually you don't really pay attention to that. It's not something that's on your mind. If you want, you could do this at a you say there's once a guy that wanted a brain transplant. He went to the doctor and the doctor said, "Look, I have uh I have two brains here that are available. One is a male and one is a female brain. So the guy says, "And what's the difference in price?" He says, "The female brain is is $200. The male brain is $100,000." So when you say that, you know, everybody, the women, they get very insulted. And then you just continue say because the female brain is very used, the male brain is unused. What do you have here? Oh, I forgot to show I wanted to show this rashy before. It's too late now. I like this Rashi. Rashi says, I'll just read it here. Get into it. Okay, it's already so we'll we'll just continue. [snorts] And then I had a little follow up on the rashy with the uh Okay, different time. that you flipped and that was the first of that on a carbon if you flip the designation from a carbon to any other carbon you toss that carbon in the garbage and you toss in the garbage other carbon you keep on bringing it the owner has to bring another carbon but it's not possible a carbon pay become it's very sensitive comes possible so if you said that's not a carbon pay what is a carbon aam Um, why throw it out? It's obvious that he meant to bring a Why? Because the age difference has to be less than a year old and asham has to be in the second year starting the second from the second year on. [snorts] If a person said he's going to refrain from drinking wine and grow his hair, not being a maze for 30 days typically and during those 30 days he touched the mace. So he has to bring in a nazer sorry that's a is a person who has saras bring a carbon now these are younger ones these are sheep that are a year So it's hard to tell. You're asking me if it's pes there's also asham that is a year old. What about he takes a pes and says this should be for swearing falsely on gazel. And if somebody's moy meaning he takes something from the bis mikdash and he uses it he has to pay 25% fine plus he has to bring uh of carbon it's 25 the says it's meaning 20% but that's in in in English it's called 25% plus a carbon He says it's a but he says I want to bring it for now it has to be a 2-year-old and it's obvious again I can tell from how old it is what kind of carbon I'm bringing for people don't realize ize the difference between sheep. How old they are? Oh, oh, yeah. This is a 2-year-old sheep. No, it's a one. You know, we're not such and sheep to differentiate and make a whole big deal about it. I want to tell you. So, here we have a beautiful uh video of how the different ages of sheep is not something that we pay attention to. Maybe sheep, even the sheep themselves sometimes think it's funny. is still there just smoking what I thought and now we're missing we're not going to have him anymore. Young boy, please stand up and give the seat to the man who is studying the daily Talmud page. >> I am not a man. I am a woman. >> Show some respect. I am not a young boy. I am an older man. I could be your grandfather. [laughter] I give out the stuff. Great says good. [snorts] Oh, sometimes you have a one-year-old that looks like that was my father's trick. I was 10 years old and he put me in high school because in I went to when I was like 10 and a half years old because I was very tall and he figured nobody will realize that I'm not baritzvah. The only thing is like I didn't have to fill in or anything. At least they weren't rapping says Mark Ashkenazi. So that guy that sent me that uh beautiful email about our last video and with the sheep rapping someone who's very upset about the whole rap rap is awesome. Okay, listen. Each to their own. I call upon him. Some kids look older than they are. Like, you know, and I know in Israel when they try to catch store owners selling cigarettes to minors, so they always bring like a 17-year-old that looks like he's 26 and they send him in and and the store owner doesn't ask for ID and they say, "Why don't you ask for ID?" He says, "Look, he's 26." No, he's only 17. And then they give him a huge fine. So, you you never know the two-year-olds looking like one year olds, one year old, like two year olds. It's not something that people readily uh differentiate. Now, just as a side note, there are young people, I guess it's normal for young people to think that they're older and older people to think that they're younger. So, both of those things are not the best. Like, when a young person thinks that he's older and it's too late or whatever, that kind of thing. It's very negative. But I was just discussing the other day and I said it in cheer. It it shocked me. I met an older fellow. He's in his 60s. he wasn't very healthy and he and he he was speaking as if he's you know 15 20 years old and that he has this tremendous life ahead of him and I like think to myself you got to be realistic you don't live forever especially you you didn't you're not taking care of yourself I don't know how long you're going to live why do you think that you're going to live so long we we're only here for a very very short amount of time as is and you're already in your 60s You got to get your life together. You got to you got to you got to produce. You got to start learning some tire, my friend. 10 minutes a day is not going to cut it. Another question. What about a goat that you for an aum? Now asham you need a a sheep asham is only a sheep. So if you bring a goat it's obvious that you didn't make you didn't you didn't bring it as ash says no you know maybe it's a sheep that's black. Interesting. In other words it's not a goat. People don't realize it's a goat. You'll think that maybe the sheep got a haircut, says Rashi. And therefore, it's black. So, what's do you mean you take a sheep, you give it a haircut, it turns black? Here, I have pasha for you. You want to see? This m is for this not for a joke. >> [clears throat] >> some Now could look like a goat after you get it. Here it go says Rashi. We got to pick up some pace here because we have the whole and we only have like uh 10 minutes. What if you brought a calf and a bull for everybody knows to be a sheep or a smaller animal, not a big giant animal? There is no such thing. You're right. You got me in that one. You got me what the Gmorra said is that in in a you could differentiate but not not in I didn't mean all most there is there's a an exception to the rule and that would be if somebody brought a bull for a B that would be obvious that he did not mean to bring it as a garment. Now we're going back to the question. We had a contradiction says on the one hand he says that if you bring a and you think that it's instead of that you are on the other hand he says you're not and we had this yesterday so we could even go quicker than usual. Where do we say that it's kosher? that that he said that the MVA should be he was doing it for the with in in withtle we thought that he's bringing a carba like he's saying that this is not a this bread over here is an bring it as a carb I think explains he starts There's a that says this is the Torah of all the so if I get confused between and it's okay I'm still kosher I'm still within I said the says they're all considered one but if I try to switch it off to a The car is not included over there says not because it says but because it's you could I could prove from the action explains that the word is really it's not it's he explains why it is but we could even read You could see from his from his action it's nicker. It is obvious what he meant. So that's why the Torah says what does it mean that you don't have this by the reason why it should be kosher. So even though there's one for every everyone and there's no concern that maybe people get confused and they'll say that you're allowed to mix things up this applies to a carbon another question a person will eat forbidden fats but he brought a carbon as if he he He He ate blood. This is kind of a gross video. So, if you don't like blood, I would not recommend watching. The men grab a strong young cow and tie a tourniquet around its neck [music] to find a vein. A special arrow is used, one to only make a small incision so not to permanently harm the cow. [music] A dried and smoked gourd called a calabash is used to collect the blood. [music] >> Then cowdong is rubbed [music] onto the cut to seal it. >> Oh my god. >> And then they drink it. Okay. So if a person drinks blood, he has to bring but he thought that he's bringing or the reverse or he brought thinking that take based on what you're telling me that if the says it you have one for for So there's no mixing. You're right. You would be right that if you mix up in that in that why is it there? own category of if you drink blood but the other other if you mix it up then it's possible why and the they bring other carbon with it and people are going to get confused they're going to think that you brought this for an all these that we just mentioned If you mix it up, why? Because it says in the it should be for that. You have to have in mind for the right. Now this contradiction that we have between the one hand he says that if you mix up the other hand says you're not from we had this yesterday. If you you say that it's a a frying pan instead of a deep dish, that's not a problem. But when you say that it's a a that's a problem. Sticking the word that ruins it. If you're just verbalizing what you're doing, not in terms of the in terms of the type of dish, that doesn't make a difference. You're doing a that's different. That's already a problem. says that you could see from the action. So once again we have the issue is it even though it all looks the same since you had a different thought in the actual carba that it that actual that actually passes it. Do I have to stop? It's already an hour. Let's just do a few more lines. If a person takes a dry without without oil and he did it with the intent. Here's a nice kit. So he did it with intent that it's bubble that it's has oil. Why is it? Because what he meant is that it's it's says he's saying it's like oh it's without without oil. Maybe when a person said I'm bringing this for he didn't mean maybe he meant peace peace with I'm making peace with no a carbon is called there is something called so when a person verbalizes the word he actually means so the calls So when you say that's what you meant but the is never called a mixed one with oil. It says in the that is mixed with oil but it's not called a by by itself is not called a if it has oil in it it's a with oil. Have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsored at mdy.com.