Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 109 by R' Eli Stefansky

[singing] [music] [singing] >> Good morning Rabbi Yisrael. >> [singing] [singing] >> IT'S LIKE I got sent one of the best real estate brokers in Eretz Yisrael. Unreal. Unreal. I'm going to tell you in a middle of sheer. So, you're going to see him actually in a few minutes. Top. Top notch. Not only is he a top camera guy. He's been with us from the very early days. Every single day besides when he goes to Eilat, which by the way, we're opening up. Seriously. Opening up in Eilat. A satellite location. Starting cooling. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's real. Real. So, everybody say hi. As you know, uh I said the latest was with Mordechai. Reminder I'm going to send you a message about this voice. Lo imer or bo imer. And I want to show you a bunch of videos. A lot of came in. I can't show everything. Some of them are 2 minutes long. There is one that's about 2 minutes long, but I do want to show it. It's very important. This I'm not going to show cuz I did it already. This one I I don't know if it's in English or not. Yeah, it's in English. MDY? Hello, I need an ambulance urgently. What? Okay, we're on our way. Hang tight. >> [clears throat] >> Laughing gas. MDY laughing gas. >> [laughter] >> Thank you, Rabali, for healing me. Somebody invested a lot of time here. I'll grow a new Star Trek daf shiur now. This is Rabbi Kotz from here in Bet Shemesh. This is awesome. This kid is 10-year-old kid, he's doing the daf already for a year. For a year, for a year. >> [singing] >> The voice of God. Just a moment, Donald. Moshiach What do you say, Donald? When are we going to finish with the Iranians? These guys Okay. Uh Israelis are selling it in, packing it in. Um I'm writing you today for tomorrow's daf as well. I want to wait. Tomorrow will mark my 1,000th daf learned through Daf Yomi with MDY. 1,000. I am only 17 years old and I cannot believe it. Thank you so much, Rebbi Weisz, for you've done for me and all of Klal Yisrael. Words can't express the absolute gratitude I have. I love the daf so much and it's helped me in all aspects of life. I know I'm only 17 years old, but I truly feel that I can say the daf has changed my life. I started at Kiddushin Bais and never thought I could make it this far. And I wouldn't have if it wasn't for Rebbi Weisz and the whole MDY family. I've only gone up from the first daf of Kiddushin and I hope to just keep doing the same until my Siyum Hashas in a few years by Ezra Hashem. Throughout these few years where I've been learning the daf with MDY, my cousins have always teased me saying, "You're not actually learning, you're just watching a TV show." However, watching their faces go blank and then go silent after I respond to them and asking, "What is Temurah? What Temurah is? What's Bi'ur? What's Minchas Chinuch?" I show them what true learning is and make it all worth it. Thank you. Again, thank you so much and keep doing what you're doing. Your Talmud, AV. Oh, this Hold on. Reboy side, this is this is interesting. I got to tell you. This is super interesting. Where is it? This guy is a grave digger and he did one from digging a grave. All right, here's a special one for me. Avi Berg is doing the daf. What? Intense. Intense. Avi Berg. It's Rabbi Berg's brother who lives right over here and he's been [clears throat] with us for 5 years. He's a big meat guy. He gave us meat a bunch of times and and he's he's a shy person. He said he didn't want to do this but he feels like he has to do it for a cause of time. So here it goes. Hey, so if you're seeing this, it means I finally gave in and decided to record a video. Today marks exactly 5 years to the day since I started doing the daf yomi and honestly, that itself is a miracle. This is my sixth or seventh time trying to learn the daf. My previous record was two masachtos. I've been doing this now since towards the end of pesachim. Previously, I used to da- bounce back and forth between random shiurim. I had chavruses off and on. Um, I miss them a lot. Um, and honestly, I felt like an impostor ever since I left yeshiva. But MDY gave me something I never had. It gave me a hischayvus. It gave me a kvius. It gave me a responsibility to myself. Every day without fail, I know what I have to do. And it's not just what I have to do, but it's what I want to do. My commute used to be dealing with work calls, listening to meetings I missed, catching up on podcasts, listening to an ebook. Now, it's just about growing as a Jew. But, it's not just growing as a Jew, it's about the friendship and the laughter and the MDY crew in the morning and all the crazies that are there on Saturday night and everything in between. It's the way I get myself energized in the morning and it's the way I decompress on the ride home from work. My rebbe used to say that a ben Torah is someone who never stops pushing themselves to keep on growing and MDY helped me push my limits. The ripple effect is real. My three boys have watched me over the last 6 years and for many of them, they never miss a day. My three oldest do not miss a day of MDY. It changed me, it changed my friends, it changed my family and honestly, it's helped to change my community as well. Don't wait for the next big Siyum Hashas. Jump in right now. Join MDY today, you won't regret it. Beautiful. All right. Squaya Harvey, what? You know, I have to remember. I know I know you know you yeah. Yep, excellent. So, tonight tonight oh, yeah, going tomorrow in England I'm sorry. Tomorrow's sheer is going to be the last daf of mena Tonight, we're doing the big Siyum in Bnei Brak. There are few How many are left? Like 30, 40 tickets left? Um we already have I don't know how many. 600 maybe? 600 people already signed up. It's a beautiful amount. For tonight, it's going to be a big master we're going to do It's a show cuz something like this costs over 100 checkers just to watch, to go to Seidel and and see him do it. So, he's coming to us, showing us how to do stay alive him. Good food. It's a great deal. 100 shekel is a is It's a bargain. What is this? Oh, Eilat. Everybody say this is the one in Eilat. Check this out. It's crazy. It's happening in Eilat. Um this one is also I I said that this is a se'um, but this is in Montreal. There's going to be a live Hebrew shiur shidurchai 2:00 in Montreal. A night of achdus. I don't know. It says over there. Read the thing. Here, you want me to go back? Here, read it. Biknesses Shaarei Chaim Rachov Avraham Avinu 55. Um Toronto se'um a night of achdus sponsored by What? What was that? Two minutes in after we sponsored perek or daf in the wife's official edition. Maseches Chullin with all the beautiful pictures from Kallah Shanah and many other pictures. Only three programs still available. Haftada already sponsored. It's your time. My boys is for shalom bayis. The first one is my vision shlita. MDY Coffee Corner. Cover that field committee daf yomi made. Official edition of the wife's shas masechta by the Iranian Levy families. Perek Anonymous. L'iluy nishmas Nochum Tzvi ben Dovid Shulhof. Daf kuf tes. Anonymous with gratitude to Rebbe Nachman Sharf for sharing the joy of the daf with his family. Yashar koach. The masechta sponsored by David Solomon dedicated in memory of Rebbe Mordechai Joel Gedali nishmas my father Jack Gedali and Anonymous for shalom bayis and refuah ben Yisrael anonymous for complete refuah shleimah and arichas yamim to Leah bas Esther Yisrael Mordechai ben Dovid speaking of refuah shleimah we're so proud of you Mordechai keep staying in. Cindy Gross and family Canvey Island UK in honor of Rebbe who changed my meaning of life. Play it out you see Mark and Benny and all the masechta in the wife's official edition of shas by Simon. Is this monthly sponsored for shalom bayis and refuah of Baruch ben Miriam. MDY Kids Generation at the Sea. As a zchus of having fegel and rifka Yehuda bas Yaffa Chaya. Daily sponsors to the consortium. Marvin Toribio Wasihas Hulan thanks the alliance. Michael Fuchs and Mary Rochelle Mosha Ben Mayer and Hana Bas Mary Isaac. The Price family L'Nishmas Shai Gross. Al Hashalom Binyamin and Ilana Gross L'Refuah Shleimah. Who? Ah, L'Nishmas Shai Gross. Official Official Educator's son. But Is is the Yahrtzeit now? I don't think so. Maybe. L'Refuah Shleimah I thought has to do with Sukkos. No, that was something L'Refuah Shleimah Rav Chaim Yisrael Ben Chaya Rachel. Today's daf in memory of our son oh Shalom Yishaya. It is It is the Yahrtzeit. Today's daf in memory of our son Shalom Yishaya thanks to Reb Elie for saying Kaddish. On his Yahrtzeit during the COVID lockdown the original official. And the Yahrtzeit month. L'Refuah Shleimah Yonatan and Yonatan Ben Shimon Baruch. L'Refuah Shleimah Mordechai Ben Esther. L'Refuah Shleimah Daniel Ze'ev Ben Ayelet Esther. Reb Boaz I we have a little bit of a got it today. A lot of a got it today. A long story. Aleph Mem Bais. Easier Easier uh daf. And uh we're we're finishing off Maseches Menachos on the right foot. And in geshmack. I just want to mention before we get into it. We saw a lot of statuses. And I think a lot of people are complacent. They said, "Oh, there's a lot of statuses. They're bringing people in. So, I don't have to do anything." No. You have a cheilav of a Talmud Torah Yisrael. For every person that joins the daf now, there's a hundred that are not joining. A hundred. There are hundred people that have excuses. I see them every day. People that posha don't open up Seforim. Don't open Guys that learn in Yeshivas. Guys that work. You know who they are. You see them in shul. And you have a heel. Yes, you have a heel to give him a little nudge. Don't be too pushy, but a little just a reminder. We're starting chulin. Starting a brand new masechta. You're not going to have that opportunity for 140 days. 140. Here's your chance. I know they there's a lot of statuses. I know. But what did you do? What did you do to bring another guy to Torah? Don't forget. Make that call. Make that status. Even if it's a silly status compared to all these statuses. You just look at the phone and say, "Hey guys, we're starting chulin tomorrow. Join." That's it. 10 seconds. You You never know whose life you're going to change from 10 seconds. And that's all it costs you. It's nothing. Costs less than a phone call. Zoch day l'yom hamavet. Here's the question. The Mishnah we're holding by the Mishnah on daf kuf ches amud bet. You have it unfortunately. You have an Israeli guy that goes to Thailand to He becomes a Buddhist. I don't know what. He He did avodah zarah. Did avodah zarah. You have it all the time. Unfortunately, a younger A young guy trying out another religion. He comes back to Eretz Yisrael, does teshuvah, and he's a kohen. Could he do duchaning? Could he do nesias kapayim? Do you give him an aliyah? You give him an You could give him an aliyah, but does he get kohen? It's a question in the rishonim. It's something we're going to touch upon today. Because we're going to see that once you perform avodah zarah, Hakadosh Baruch Hu could be mochel you. That's his thing. But l'maaseh, you did damage, irreversible damage, that you can't get out of. It's like a chalal. You know, okay, "Never I want to do teshuvah." But that's it. You're chalal. So you can't be can't do certain can't perform certain things that a kohen performs. Hamer, eich anachnu foslin hekdesh v'eich anachnu mashvarim hekdesh. Otherwise, you think about it without the Mishnah. You said, "You have a whole ranch, thousands of animals." You said, "One of these animals is is hekdesh. Which one? Which one? So, we have a concept of it should be mivchar, it should be the the the top. So, omer echad, one mivchar of hekdesh v'echad mishvar or he says one of my bulls voilish shnayim and only had two, hagodol shebahem hekdesh. Mivchar d'dregalim, you got to get the best. So, now we take the same, we apply the same reasoning, you have three and he said the best, which one should it be? He didn't say the best, he said I want to give one of the bulls, it should be the best. What's the difference two and three? Says the Mishna shlosha, if he has three, beinoni shebahem hekdesh, the middle one. This doesn't fit into what we just said. So, the Gemara is going to explain, I'm just doing chazarah here. It means also the middle one. Of course, the top one cuz v'chol mivchar d'dregalim, you got to go to the top. Also, the middle. So, two of them are kodesh. So, now you have a problem. Two, how do you get out of two? The Gemara gives you an answer. Beinoni shebahem hekdesh. Pirashni v'lo yedama pirashti I I remember designating one, I don't remember what, o she'omar li avo v'lo yedama, my father died and as he was dying he said one of the bulls is hekdesh, hagodol shebahem hekdesh, let's take the number one, top one, the largest, heaviest, most kishmak, most expensive one, that's the one that goes, mivchar d'dregalim. Says Gemara, from the fact if there's two, you have to give the number one. Almo magdish b'ayin yafa magdish, a person always donates with a largeness, he has a good eye. Eima save us, then what do we do with the middle case? Beinoni shebahem hekdesh, if he donated one out of three, you give the middle one. How's that possible? It's the top, it's the number one. Almo magdish b'ayin ra'ah magdish. Omar Shmuel, choshesh shema lo beinoni, the pshat is no, it's not only the middle one, it's also the middle one. The top one for sure goes to the highest because Mivchar Nidrei Cham, you give the top. But also the middle one. The Lagabei Katan. Hold on a second. We're getting there. We're getting there. All if we finish the Sugya and you have a question then you will ask. Lagabei Katan, Aino Yochol Hu. Because compared to the the smallest one, he is Kodesh. As the Gemara Heychi Ovid, what should he do? He can't bring two animals to be some English. Each one is $5,000. Omer Reb Chiya bar Av. Huh? 100%. Mamtin Loy Ad Sheyuma. What you do is you wait until the middle guy gets a Mum, falls a Mum. You send him to Kaves land. U'macha leli Kedushasei ba'Gadol. Memona Sha. Either the Kedusha was on the top one and not on the middle one at all. And even if it was on the middle one and not on the top one, we're going to move the Kedusha, the owner is going to move the Kedusha as it has a Mum. I'm going to transfer. That's a better word. I'm going to transfer the Kedusha from the middle guy to the top guy and only one is Kodesh because in fact he only said one. Of course we're talking about we don't know what's going on. We we Takka have a If we know what's going on, great. But we don't. So we got to we got to make sure that we dot our eyes, cross our tees. If you're from Chicago all the bulls are Kodesh. Ah. They used to all be Kodesh. Omer Reb Nachman bar Rava bar Avuha, Leshono Elo Domar Achas mi'Shoro Hekdesh. If a person said one out of my all my axes, he could have meant the middle one. Aval Omer Shor bi'Shoro, he uses different loshon. The axe of all axes. So now the axe of all axes means number one. That's there's no question that a guy says uh axe of all my ax- axe Shor bi'Shoro, the axe of axes. And what if he says house of houses? There's a bunch of real estate. He says house of houses. Look what it means. The biggest nicest house. The nicest penthouse. Okay. There's no question that a guy uses such a lotion. The acts of all acts as he means the best. The best of the best. He meant the most kosher. Okay? In this context a lot of people love to to be kosher. This kind of kosher is is an axe. The most kosher is an axe. I have a bunch of houses. I'm selling you the house of houses. He shows him the attic. The attic in the time of the year wasn't very good. You have to walk up steps. It's hard to get to. It might be a little, you know, there might be a little slant in the roof. It's not kosher over there. So why is it when a person says the house of a houses, he shows him the alia? The mission degree of the moral is going to make a distinction like that soon. The mission degree isn't it because I'm showing you the worst, not the best? Look at the word alia means a been alia. Like somebody that who's who's growing. He's He's working his way up. Alia in fact means the best of the best. What does the best of the best mean? The penthouse. I'm giving you the best. Not the not not the attic that you're thinking. I'm giving you the best. Oh. So the outcome of this video happens to be that Gershon dabbles a little bit Gary dabbles a little bit in real estate on his status. You won't see any like join in the wire. Usually once in a while he does. But it's it's usually some penthouse or something in Ashkelon you know on the water. So I ain't sure if anybody wants to move to to the water. Talk to Gary. So we also we're starting to incorporate people from this year slowly. We have the famous Michael Ben Shitrit. He's one of our main guys in in Miami. He's been with us for a long time, Michael. So, we'll say But I want to tell you that practice Lately a bunch of different uh contractors or how do you say in English? Developers. Developers have approached me. They heard that I'm looking to do something together with MDY, you know, move to the building newer measures and a community. We're thinking about it. We're dabbling in it. Different meetings all the time. It's just one minute to the other. You know, this one offers that. I'll I'll build you this and you'll get that. The whole thing. Come to my place. So, yesterday I had a whole meeting with the guy. He's doing seven different projects. Big, big. I spoke to one of the top developers in Israel. You know, I'm talking about. So, just yesterday he sat in my in my living room. We sat for over an hour schmoozing about a development that it could be very, very good for MDY. The whole of So, here's I said to them some afterwards. I said, "Were you Were you referring to this?" I will say I think it's beautiful. >> [laughter and cheering] >> Now, also take a look at the even the enlarged has the stairs. The stairs will never go away. Here we go. The water fountain that is so beautiful. Just unbelievable. Look at the stairs. You see the stairs? >> [laughter] >> I'm going to show you something. Look at the granite in the floor. It's just unreal. It's unreal. This whole thing. Michael Ben Shitrit What do you mean bite BVT? I mean Aliyah. Aliyah. No, I didn't mean an attic. I meant the nicest luxury house. In the stairs, you have fish in the stairs. >> [laughter] >> Everybody said it continues in the next show you'll see something unbelievable. Ah, ah. So something about amazing we have a castle. If a person says The acts of axes. The acts of axes. And what does it say second later? The chain social like this. Yeah, let me just put them up on the screen together. You don't really need it, but One case is short before I want to show before I mean top of the top. What's the next one? Short should I decide it? Oi. I just realized something. Anybody have a Rabbi Willis' number? Haven't seen him in a few days. You got to call him up immediately. Seriously. Where is he? The one that stands in the back? Tell him what? Oh, that's what it is? Okay, I'm getting nervous here. Okay. Can't lose a guy like that. Big time of column. Okay. Short should I decide it? What's the next thing? Says in the safer. Everybody say, pay attention over here. It says the same. These two cases are identical. Short should I decide it? Meaning I have this is a bad case. And we talk we spoke about it in King's Ranch in Texas or whatever that that place is. The guy has 800,000 acres, right? The property is worth $9 billion property. It's owned privately. 35,000 cattle, at least. And I take one one sure, I want to get him good. Take one sure that's like this and throw him in there. He's a goner. All 35,000, what are you going to do? So they have the helicopters over there. They're trying to herd the things. It's like larger than Israel. 850,000, I don't even know. It might be like the size of Israel. Something crazy, mishuga. So you you could really mess a guy up with this case, right? The Cain social hechsher in Sarei B'heim. Hechsher got mixed up with others. Hechsher. What do you do? You take the largest one and you make it hechsher. In both of these cases, Reb Yisrael, even in the first case, Shor B'shor what? Cuz it says Shor B'shor and then the second line it says B'heim Shor Sarei. What do you do? Top one, top dog, the top sure goes to hechsher. But what do you do to rest? That's it, you're done. Mamish, looking shabbain. Ellie's he's ready he's singing out of his eye. Unbelievable. Day late. All of them must be sold because you don't know which one. Maybe one of them is is an oila. Each one has a safek kdushas haguf. It's not even kdushas damim, it's a massive kdusha over here. Each one in a let's say with mayim chulin. And then you take the money, give it to chulin. So it's a kasha. We said only the top one in case number one, Shor B'shor, only the top one. There's no mention of selling the rest. Terguma Shor shel hechsher in Sarei B'heim. That that halacha of of that you sell everything is only in that. Only in the second case of Shor Sarei. Ah, aval B'heim gomur dai, identical cases. Terguma agudo. There's two halachas. One is that you you give the top one to hechsher. That's tak on both. B'heim in Shor B'shor, Shor Sarei, both cases, you give the best one to hechsher. Now there's a second halacha that you have to sell the rest. That that second halacha only goes in the second case of shares in the house. May say question. By the way, base in here comes Gershon again. I'm selling you the house of houses. And one of the houses falls. Crumbles. He tells the buyer, "I'm sorry. Your investment is right here in the rubble." I have 100 slaves. I'm selling you a slave. One of them dies. He shows He shows him the dead one. This is what you bought from me. If you tell me he gets the top one, he means the top one. Let's see what fell. Let's see if it's the penthouse. Let's see if it's the bottom. What What fell exactly? What broke? Says the Marla Care Commerce, you bring me a Raya from a regular transaction between two human beings. The guy that has the the the star is he always loses out. The It's a time for me to to mention again. It doesn't matter if it's the deal over there. It doesn't matter if it's in your own family. It doesn't matter if it's your best friend. This guy that I met yesterday, he says, "Everybody knows about me. My handshake is ironclad." I don't think there's such thing. You know, you know, people wired me 100 million check up for this and that. There's no such thing. I don't care who who you are and what you are. I don't care if it's your father, if he's your brother, if he's your uncle, if it's your best friend, if it's your wife. Have everything in writing. Every single thing in writing. In a business deal, you don't trust anyone. Doesn't matter who. Cuz at the end, he forgot this and you forgot that and you think he said this. Everything in the world. A lawyer told me, "My sister Raya, there's a thing called huh?" The hazmat star. Yeah. But it doesn't say what. And that's what I'm saying here. This here This lawyer told me There's something in this world called a top of Mishawaka. People can't Real estate is so expensive, so younger couples are buying apartments together. They'll buy an apartment, they put a wall down the middle and this guy gets the right and this guy gets the left, but they if they own the apartment together. You don't understand how many issues later if they would only add another little safe, a another clause. One more clause. What happens when we want to sell? Could I force this guy to that? What happens if I I need to get a mortgage cuz the mortgage goes on both of them. I want another mortgage. I want to refinance. What I didn't think about everything and now there's fights. Now we don't talk. Everything should be written down. You result so somebody reached out to me today. Guy from the sheer is suffering a lot from a yerusha. He feels that his family is not there whatever. I- I- if the nifter would have written everything down exactly, this guy gets this this this this then there's no issues. So in wills also all just write everything down. Stop throwing it out there. Hashas is all the yad baal hashter d'achtina. Hamotzi mechavero l'raya, the one the the the buyer of this house loses. But when it comes to hekdesh, hekdesh doesn't lose. Hashas is lochi, so if so, now let's go back. A few little time al yad d'gria. So you could say when the guy when Gershon ben Moshe was selling this guy Michael ben Shitrit, he actually sold him an attic, not a penthouse. Over here aliya doesn't mean the best of the best like Gershon showed Michael that this gorgeous penthouse on top of the MDY Tower. He actually meant aliya sagga garnished, bad something bad. Why? Yad baal hashter d'achtina. Because at the end of the day the the one the purchaser that has the shter, he loses hamotzi mechavero l'raya. I'm showing you this even though in your mind chasha shalom, subconsciously you could say that this is MDY style. Even though we build top top top. But to make the gemara more yishmach, why not? You have to look at my facial expressions. Admission committee. I watch Rabbi Eli's lesson every day and I want to buy the most luxurious penthouse you have here. >> [laughter] >> Well, at least can we take a selfie? >> [laughter] >> Oh, it fell exactly on your house. >> It doesn't say here THAT IT'S MY HOUSE. TRUE. What difference does it make whether there is a home or not? The main thing is that on Friday you join to study Masachet Chulin. We just planted a terrible thing in people's minds. I don't want the Y or the boys. I'm buying but I want in the M, the M building, not the Y building. >> [laughter] >> Easy come, easy go. Yeah. Here starts that guy with the toe. Starting the doubt, we're starting that guy with the toe. You have to read about Mikdash. A person says to himself, I am I'm I'm donating an Olah. So, obviously, where do you bring an Olah? You bring to Beit Hamikdash. So, this is that guy with the toe. The guy is going to say the story twice. There was a crazy story in Klal Yisrael. Shimon HaTzaddik was a Kohen Gadol 40 years into the by Shani. When he was nifter, a lot of things changed as the mayor is going to tell us. They stopped saying Birkas Kohanim with the Shem Hamiforash with Shem Hashem. A lot of things happened. As he was dying, he said, "I want my second son to be the coin Godel, Chonyo." And his older brother, Shimi, was jealous. And yeah. Shimon and Shimi? Shimi. Yeah. And Shimi did some terrible things, as the mayor is going to describe. He wanted his brother dead. So, Chonyo runs away to Alexandria and builds a base Hamikdash. Something like this. But So, obviously, if you're going to bring a carbon in Mitzrayim, in Alexandria, you lay out some. Lay out some. Harei oil is actually going to base Chonyo. But, if a person says, "I'm bringing oil law and I'm going to be mac given base Chonyo, you have to give it to the migdash." Oil goes to base Hamikdash. You make revo base Chonyo. But, if you're mac given in Chonyo, you out some. We have to understand what this means. The mayor is going to discuss this. How in the world could you bring an oil law in a base Hamikdash is outside of Jerusalem and say that you you're right. Rebbe Shimon says I'm going to It's not a sad day. It's not Shimon Rebbe Shimon and so this is nothing. It's not a oil. It's a regular animal. You can sell it do whatever you want. You can write it. It doesn't matter. It's not oil. Now same thing similar case person says I'm going to be a you got to be he has to remove all this here in the just like this. Sorry. Sorry. Skip and if he shaved off his hair in the lie Yotzer. I'm going to do this. I'm going to shave my head in base Yotzer. He should originally shave his head in the other Yotzer. Again, we have to understand what's going on here. So we are going to say it's not a real Yotzer. You didn't really it's not a so that's why if you did it in in in in Alexandria Yotzer. It's not a Yotzer at all. Ask the Yotzer. How could a person be person says I'm going to bring it in base Yotzer. Yotzer. It's oil. It's oil. You're killing it outside of the Yotzer. If you did it outside of the you have to if you killed it outside of the you killed it. It's not a how you could be Yotzer. If you choked it you didn't check it. So you killed it. So you how could you be Yotzer? I don't know that's the real oil. I'm going to actually buy this. I'm talking about a case of a person case once a person says I'm bringing it in in base Yotzer. So what he's saying is is bringing an up any responsibility. If something happens to it, for fallen, I don't have to do anything. If I choke it to death, I'm not even if even if I myself kill it, I'm not anything. So, you have to tell me here what means I don't have to I don't have to bring another one. Doesn't mean I'm a see the of oil. It means I fulfill my obligation with this animal. This animal I don't have to take care of it anymore. I killed it, fine. Next. Continue your life. >> [clears throat] >> But let's say let's say you take this animal and you take an a sheet of knife and you shut it in base what happens to you? Chorus. Then you will be chorus cuz you shut it outside of the big dash. Let's talk about the next case in the mission. Aren't they identical? Save the money in the money you got the big dash. If he says I'm a then I'm going to take care of the here in base in Alexandria. You should do it in the money you got the big money you got but if you did it in the money you're okay. I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't I'm not taking responsibility on these animals. Great. The problem is I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't In order for another to start drinking wine and be and everything you have to bring these three of the money of oil. You have to take care of yourself. You can't say all these are without a crisis. Hello, I'm a Adam says you You got it wrong. You didn't bring an oil. He didn't say I'm going to take upon myself an oil. He's talking about a gift I have to send. Sounds like an oil. It's like an oil but it's not an oil. It's a way of [snorts] saying a gift. I'm bringing a gift to a share where in Chicago. So, there's no there's no big money you got over there. It's not even an oil. It's time an animal. I don't have any money. Like a like a gift not in the money you got the big money you got. I don't have any money I don't have any money I don't have any Obama. Like I'm I'm just giving a carbon to to Alexandria. I'm bringing something to Hashem. Like a like a like I'm making a kugel carbon Hashem. Carbon Shabbos kodesh carbon Hashem. Nothing to do with the with the base hamikdash. It's not an oila. What? He wasn't magdish it. It's not heqdesh. Yeah. We bought it's ki ilu the way the best way I can describe it is oila. It's not an oila. Okay. So then once you bring it to the base hamikdash then then you make it an oila at the time. Hello my rabba. Adam had a daughter in Skhavin. Omar. And he says to himself he saggi is chani to rachni if I could get there I'm very close. I live in Eilat. I'm right there by Egypt. I'll just bring it over there. I'm not going to bring it all the way to Yerushalayim. Tvei l'metzina l'sturei. More than that I don't want to trouble myself. Nazir ami. And the same case would be ben nazir ami gavi l'tzurei. And he shaves his hair and he's trying to he's trying to give himself sigufim mitzaer himself, you know, to get a kapara. But he didn't mean to bring a carbon to base hamikdash. He saggi is chani to rachni if I could get there and cut my hair off in Bnei Chani great. Tvei l'metzina l'sturei. More than that I don't So So if you're going to shecht an animal like that in Alexandria you're not you're not chayev kares in such a case. It wasn't heqdesh. Rav Nachman Amar. Lo nazir k'dei kammei. When we're referring to a nazir you're 100% right. Oila. Amar l'shayei chayev achrei zman. In other words it's two different dinim over here. There is the nazir. Nazir is he didn't mean at all to be a nazir. But [clears throat] by an oila oila is a true carbon. He did mean to make it a carbon. He just said I'm not going to have a kares. You ask me but the nazir should be the same case. No. Nazir is a different case. Two different cases. Nazir he didn't mean it for real. So therefore he could cut his hair off in Alexandria and not worry about any korbanos cuz he's not a real nazir. By oila it was a real oila. Just it's a type of oila that he would have means he ought to means that if he kills it he doesn't have to bring another one. Also holds like this Amar Rabba Rav Kahana Amar Rav Yochanan. >> Because it's a real It's a real carbon. He thought in his mind that the midbar still has dusha from the time of Moshe Rabbeinu. So he said, "Let me I want to I want to be magriv in the midbar." Cuz he designated as a real oila, he's karus. Yotza means there's no etc. I'm not absolving myself from any responsibilities. So if this animal dies, or even if I kill it myself, I don't have to bring another one. This is a voice I Listen to this, David. You have to know this. A cohen that performs avodah zara can never do the the avodah in the Beis Hamikdash. What about if he did avodah in the Beis Chonyo? If he worked he worshipped the Beis Chonyo. He helped Chonyo out. It's also for them to perform the avodah, but it's for a different reason. It's not a deraisah as much as it is a gzeirah. Ve'ein tzarich lomar and certainly and the Gemara is going to prove from here that Beis Chonyo is not avodah zara from here. Ve'ein tzarich lomar and certainly if you do avodah zara, you cannot perform avodah in the Beis Hamikdash. Achlu ya'alu bamah b'Yerushalayim. If you don't know what a bamah is, let's just I'll keep on talking over here while this is playing in the background. There's a There's a bamah Mizbach Hashem b'Yerushalayim kim achlu matzos b'kerev acheichem. If these Kohanim they they brought uh uh sacrifices on a bamah, it's it's Mizbach in somebody's backyard in Toms River or something. No, no, no. They They don't have tennis courts in England. Oh, the car The car's from England. Maskim. So yeah, it's in point. South Africa. All right, so that they have houses like this in South Okay. >> [clears throat] >> I don't see the gates. Fine. I'll go upon him. It says >> [snorts] >> it says a mission that this coin we we we treat him like a bum. They cannot be marked with a carbon, but they they split they they they cannot be marked with in the base of English, but they can eat. Almost like a bum. I'm going to have you the coin show up with the Tsar. If a coin before shita for the Tsar and does shuva all the cases here are cases that he did shuva. He can continue before me why? Micro where do you see this in the Yanni show you show the the key word is show show. That a coin who did He was he he performed in a void in the base of English the flame you lay him I'm sorry to the Tsar the whole of the mission of love him. It's a a stumbling avira. Okay and also by them. It's a terrible thing what they did that they were the Tsar. And then it says afterwards you cannot perform that in the base of English. So you used the word you all about in shita love shita show anybody that learns and even if you didn't learn you all know that a coin can perform the shita in the base of English. How can a coin perform the shita in the base of English? What is not what? Cuz shita. Oh, first first mission in shul. Usually the more like and we're going to even see more what? I can share I can share the shita because Ah, okay. It's not shita. Yeah, it's not shita. He's right. I'll go upon him. Almost the first I'll go upon him shita share a bizarre in the base of English. So you see it's not a share. The Torah's talking about a thing that's share. So the Gemara that By the way, Shacharis is in 12 minutes. Whoever's waiting for Shacharis. That was the same. Shchita doesn't share this rule. It's mar. What about the next thing? Zrika. So this I think will really hit you as a massive chiddush. Zrika is 100% and I don't know what it means. It's the number one avodah. It's the mechaper. So what about a kohen? You hear this save. A kohen who performs zrika by mistake. He thought that it's muttar to to do zrika in the Beis Hamikdash to avoid avodah zarah. Could he perform the avodah later on in the Beis Hamikdash? You'll be surprised to learn that there's a shitta that says it's assur for him to perform even though it was a complete mistake. >> [sighs] >> So shogeg b'zrika, he thought that it's muttar to do zrika to avoid avodah zarah. Rebbe Nachman bar Rebbe Nachman Rebbe Chiyah says it's no problem. Continue doing the avodah. Rebbe Shimon bar Yochai says ain't carbon Rebbe Nachman Rebbe Chiyah. He cannot. Rebbe Shimon bar Yochai says I don't know this the whole Beis Yisrael the mishol avon. It says two words, mishol stumble, avon an aveira. My love oy mishol oy avon. The Torah is talking about two different things. The mishol is a stumbling block. In other words, you didn't do it on purpose. An avon is that you did it deliberately. Oy mishol shogeg oy avon meizid. That that's the pashut Rebbe Nachman. Mishol de avon. You stumbled to do an aveira. So no, it's only meizid according to Rebbe Nachman. According to Rebbe Shimon it's both. A mishol and avon shogeg and meizid. Rebbe Nachman bar Rebbe Nachman Rebbe Chiyah says I don't know this the whole Beis Yisrael the mishol avon. It's referring to avodah zarah. It's referring to the possibility of avodah zarah. Melamed shekayam kaparah l'atzmo. A kohen can forgive himself. If a person does an aveira, he'll go A kohen himself will go to the Beis Hamikdash and do do a kaparah for himself b'mayim. What does it mean? How? Either b'shchita, that's not a chiddush. My ears are burning. a film amazing army. If a coin did the shita to have it done by mazid, he could continue. Why? Because it's not an avodah we said. And he can continue doing avodah in the base hamikdash. El al av, no but he's doing he does chuva. El al av bizrika. It must be that he did he performed a zrika bishogeg. Versheish al al av lelo meshita. Now, we're referring to shita ubemezid loyi and it's not true if a coin does a shita on purpose. He cannot perform avodah in the base hamikdash. Why? Nasa they stick in here koimer avodah zara. You're right. Shita is not an avodah. But, there's another problem. He becomes a koimer. A koimer becomes a priest avodah zara and a priest avodah zara has no place in our base hamikdash. V'al zu amay on each go according to their own reasoning in the itmar. Here is the meshita. If he did avodah zara and did chuva by shita, Rav Nachman over korban yireach nekhoyach continue performing the avodah Rav Sheishes Enkeba Rav Nachman he cannot perform the avodah. Rav Nachman over korban yireach nekhoyach. Lelo meshita he didn't perform an avodah. Rav Sheishes Enkeba Rav Nachman nasa koimer avodah zara. The the problem is a meshara avodah whatever it is you want to go with but the point is he becomes a priest avodah zara and that's why he cannot perform the avodah in the base hamikdash. Omer Rav Nachman sponsors and our global specialists in international financial services Chaim Milrad Refuah Shleima Mi Marasi Fradel Bas Chana Besoch Shaar Cholei Yisrael. Omer Rav Nachman Min al Min al av. How do I know this? The sign of a coin shav avodah zara v'shav. A coin a coin that performed avodah zara and did chuva korban yireach nekhoyach His korban is a beautiful thing as loves it but my but my even the shogeg if he did it if he if he didn't have a barrel by mistake but my what does it mean it did show it was a complete mistake it was an honest mistake I'll amazing he did it deliberately. Maybe Rico and if he did it by the throwing of the blood on the show my hobby who cares if he did all of his done and gone for the rest of his life. He performed and cannot perform Allah must be the we're talking about Shlita. We're just on my lock line of we're talking about that he did it by mistake. So he take twist the words a little bit and shove me if a person has never done to begin with the how is that possible he didn't have a complete thinking honest mistake he thought that's the throw blood to have a desire. What was he doing there? I don't know but he thought it was an honest mistake. But I really have to continue performing the love but if he did amazing ain't carbon equal. Great that's the end of that. What about a person bows down to have a desire didn't check anything he built a desire and he did carbon he could do from that it's not a it's not no he can't. I love the desire again and with words he said in the yacht he said Eliata. He talks to have a desire said said thank you to have a desire and he did [snorts] all we're not going to have a carbon we're not going to have a carbon again there's no since you need all these cases of Shlita hide all these things why easy stuff right? The only have to come I saw if it says only the part he did by But he come out all other day shares. At the end of the day, this guy performed on a voida that you do in the Beis Hamikdash, and that's why he says that he cannot do the voida anymore in the Beis Hamikdash. Ava Shchita shchita is mutar by a Yisrael. We said even a woman, right? In the Beis Hamikdash. So, it's not considered shares. Ema lav d'Nachman? Maybe you'd admit that this guy could perform in the Beis Hamikdash. Yeah, no, he can't. We ask min shchita mishum d'lav d'avoda he did a he did a ma'aseh. Ava hishtachava'ah d'leilav d'avoda, he didn't do any avoda. There's no There's no animal involved. There's no avoda. Ema lav maybe this not stop him from performing in the future avoda Beis Hamikdash tzaricha. We ask min hishtachava'ah d'leilav d'avoda mishum d'lav d'ma'aseh, but ma'aseh he bent down on his feet. He did something with his body. Ava avoda b'dibbur b'amma d'reilav shares, talking is not considered a ma'aseh. Ema lav maybe that shouldn't prevent him according to Rav Shasheis from doing that avoda tzaricha. Vein tzorech lomar d'lav d'avoda, achas is the mishna of certainly if a kohen performs avoda zara, certainly cannot do the avoda Beis Hamikdash. So, now we say the story. Here comes story time. Midei ko amar in tzorech lomar d'lav d'avoda, from the fact that the mishna says that Beis Chonyo has this halacha, but if he performed avoda in the Beis Hamikdash you performed avoda zara, you cannot do avoda Beis Hamikdash. Certainly he can't perform in the Beis Hamikdash. Michlal d'Beis Chonyo lav avoda zara if you're comparing avoda zara to Beis Chonyo you say certainly vein tzorech lomar. That means that avoda zara is worse than Beis Chonyo. That means Beis Chonyo is not avoda zara. Ka igum and amar Beis Chonyo lav avoda zara hu. Well, by the way, it's time as I'm throwing this out. Shimon HaTzaddik, a lot of people the minhag was unlike Binyamin they would go to do the halachas by Shimon HaTzaddik. People go to Shimon HaTzaddik. Like in they'll go to go to Shimon HaTzaddik. Shimon HaTzaddik, there was a famous ma'aseh that I'm just throwing this out there. This guy that there was a cave that a lot of people were going to. Shimon HaTzadik turns out that was a donkey buried there. The guy called his donkey Shimon HaTzadik. Maaseh Shaya, a famous story. What? You know the Anybody know the story? Where are the Where are the Where are our uh uh tour guides? Not here today? No? Who? But you heard about the story? It is it's a true story. You don't take people there, I'm assuming. It's not It's not on the itinerary. So, what happened? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. That year that Shimon HaTzadik died, he was he performed that way that I believe 40 years in the Baishani. He was from the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah. Omer lahem, "Shanah zu hu maaseh." He said about himself, "This is the last year of his life." Omer lahem, "I've been an old man. You look nice and healthy. How do you know you're going to die?" Every single year an old man wearing white comes to me. Venisado levanim. Venichnas imi, he goes with me into Kodesh HaKodashim and he comes out. Says Tosafos. Top Tosafos. Even a malach can't go in there. Perhaps, I can't say for certain, perhaps he saw the Ribono shel Olam himself kavyochol, in a in a form of human being. As an old man. Dressed in white. Shanah zu, but this year in his damim zakin achad lavush If it's like Tosafos says, Hakadosh Baruch Hu dressed in black as in over the screen? When he see me he also he didn't come out with me. Why not see me? Locker regal. Right after Sukkot. Call us to Yemen. The maze he's lifted up this tissue. The name of from that day on they stopped using the before us. You used to say you can walk okay in the house no more. The shots you also they felt there's no do there's nothing to save them. Shots you also and on his death bed he said the knee is almost after I want my son to be instead of me. The sky is so I thought about it. If you think about BB and everything he accomplished the hatred that people have to hatred that they say that he's worse than a terrorist. He should die right now. The hatred people have to Trump with all his success and everything. They hate just the pure hatred. I can say I'm I do have over the people from jealousy. Just from pure jealousy people say nasty remarks to you. They do nasty things to you. You know what I'm talking about. You there's nothing you can do about somebody is jealous. There's nothing. You can't talk any sense into them. They're they're vindictive. They're it's a terrible thing. And I could ask that that they shouldn't do it but they do it. They manage nasty stuff. Here's a person who has jealousy from his own brother. What does he do? Wants him dead. Dead his own brother. Because of jealousy. Pelep light. It's not a pele. Those who don't know show you going to manage to show them this. Good spot. He's 29 years old than me. He's going to be the kind of guy even though my father said that the young one should be let me teach you how it's done. Of course he knew how it's done. He saw his father doing it hundreds of times. But maybe he didn't know how it's done and the girl inauguration. You wear something special like the king that day. Something I'm going to tell you, my my dear brother, what you have to wear is woman's clothing. You have to take your your your wife's dress. He'll be sure he won't be some some sort of hide from of women and he put on a belt of women. A nice pink belt. He had me there and he put him there by himself. And then he runs and he tells unbelievable from Kinneret. He goes to the the other guy. Room another guy. To his beloved. Look what he promised his wife. I saw you just become a he promised her if I ever become a I'm going to wear your clothing. They want to they want to kill him. So he ran away from them and he ran after him. Halah Alexandria trying I'll just tell you a quick story and the mice the guys in front of them they told one of their friends they pulled a prank on him. They said listen, let's go to the Angel Bakery at 1:00 in the morning and let's let's wear pajamas. We'll all go in pajamas be funny. So they all went to the Angel and they're all wearing pajamas and in in Angel Bakery they ripped off their PJs and they had regular clothing underneath. But this guy didn't have regular clothing underneath and he's no more so they stripped him around he's wearing pajamas and they and then they made a big a big thing out of him. This is what they did to this guy. They uh They want to kill him. I'll go to Alexandria I'll show you the second video tonight or tomorrow. I'll show you the second video tonight or tomorrow. Or that's why he ran away. He was supposed to be the he had to run away to Alexandria and over here it says that he built it he did it which is and they said one more lie and this Shimmy should be he was never the prime minister of Israel but he had such jealousy if somebody that was hired law, somebody that was already there and is removed, a lot of jealousy is so great. We'll see you tonight in Ben Ish Chai. Have a wonderful day. >> [music] >> Merit the schutz of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shear today at mdyisponsor.com or [email protected]. >> [music]