Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 105 by R' Eli Stefansky

[music] >> Good morning Rabbi boys. See you in the next mincha. In I'm not going to be in Bene Brak. Tons of parking. >> [laughter] >> Kumsitz. Something special. We have something special worked up. Mamis you have all the comments join. Close to 1,000 people we were thinking. From all over Israel, English speakers, Hebrew speakers. There will be a sheer because it's a night, the sheer will be in Hebrew. And we're actually going to do the CM we rarely have that. That this is a full sheer and this is a CM at the end of the sheer. Like we're going to be Messiah in the sector right there at the CM. In Baltimore there's a CM. In Manchester there's a CM. Rabbi say I want to say a gracious to Mayor Bloomberg. Here's a a situation a case a case. I'll go back. A few years ago Noah and I had a stick of argument about the direction of MDY. I told him that we were daf. We're going to stick to the daf. And he's like yeah but you could do a little mish you could do this. You should be sure. So there's so much on the daf. We don't even know where and we still don't know where. There's so many different projects. For instance now the Gamara project. So here's a beautiful project that Mayor Bloomberg is working on. We've been talking about it for a very long time and he came to a lot of different dead ends but here's a um almost a final product that we want to it's not to get to us but when you see it you'll understand the potential. The potential in Yiddish. The potential in all sorts of languages, let me tell you how it how it works. There's a person who learns the daf well. He knows the daf well, and he speaks a perfect Spanish and Hebrew. And after he watches the sheer once, on the second time, he translates word for word in his voice. You can even hear that the havara of the words are in are in Sefardi havara, not Ashkenazi Yeshivish. And then it comes out a pretty decent product. I never saw it on large Let's see in on the This is a little faded. We have He has to get a better quality, but here it goes. Raboysai, It goes out of his mouth and And we send it to three different array here. As he said, it's perfect. It's everything is good. The sound is good. Everything is good. No. Oh, it's He takes all the words, every word, he says over everything I say, he says it in Spanish. And then they they translate his voice into AI. The only thing that that that that AI does is changes the voice to my voice. It doesn't do the words. The words are whatever he says. He can say 1 2 3 A B C halakha hava. It just changes into Stefansky's voice. It's And he's been working on it like like Mr. Sugar for months and this didn't go well and this this this technology this they finally came up with this and this has a ton of potential for Yiddish for all sorts of things. Yeah, so it's another another product. You struck me a blanco you score out. Send me regards doc. All right. For boys only. Um so these these things are starting to come in. >> [music and singing] >> From the whole green. >> [music] >> This is from the whole green. >> [singing] >> Okay. >> [music] >> I'm sorry. Dear Rebbi, I'm a 14-year-old boy who started this year and have a desire to base after being positively influenced by my friend Shimon Newman. This kid wrote yesterday. He said I was reading a series of a bunch of 12-year-old, 13-year-olds that have been doing the dots since the beginning of minoxidil which is 100 dots. So I got a bunch of emails from kids. And yesterday one of the kids he writes that the dots mom has changed my life. This guy next to me Rabbi Grossman's grandson started laughing his he could almost fell off his chair for 2 minutes straight. He's 13 years old and the dots mom has changed his life. >> [laughter] >> And then so then he had here Benjamin what's his name his last name the one that had a baby boy the Bornstein. He says you should know that my baby is a week and a half old. He's been listening to this year for over 4 months now since you know when my wife heard she listens loud and she she says right now she's listening to this year with the baby. So the guy screams out and the mom has changed his life already. The mom has changed his life. Dear Rebbi, I'm 40 years old. I don't know he told me to join for the sake of it yet I haven't missed the dots since. I'm proud to be making my fourth scene with you and hope to make many more. People should realize what a small suggestion can do. As she means influence has changed my life for the better. Here's another 14-year-old. Changed my life for the Why not? Even a 14-year-old can change his life for the better. I hope to see you in sheer live very soon. Thank you for changing my life. Yossi. Maybe it's the same guy writing the same email. I really want to thank you for changing my life. I'm only 13 years old. This is the one. I saw a real change in last 100 days. Baruch Hashem, since then I've never missed a day. And some days were really hard. Baruch Hashem. I brought somebody to the daf since then, but now for I'm working hard to bring people for So my friend >> [snorts] >> that I thought rather than the daf, he brought already two people for So this kid is 13 years old. He already has two in a clock. And Baruch Hashem, yesterday I sent an amazing powerful text messages on my 100 days from my flip phone. You don't need status. To many people and I'm inspiring them and working to bring them for You hear this? You can You can send something out on a flip phone also. I didn't know that. Baruch Hashem, some of them even have a camera. I heard it. I heard. I don't know if it's true. I heard it from Baruch Hashem, the feedback has been incredible and we're trying to bring as much people as possible in this But Baruch Hashem, the impact of my as a 13-year-old doing the daf everywhere has been crazy. Has been crazy. And I'm really not consistent. So this is huge for me. It's really helping in many areas of my life. Recently I went to the house of one of my friends to sleep there to be able to finish the daf I brought a laptop listening to my ear pods and he asked if he could please join I swear to me it's all they can't see someone learning Torah and not join him. Another example. Here's another This is another example. Finally, this is the end of the email. Another example, my mom was talking with a friend. Friend told her, "My son is not doing that well in learning." My mom told her, "My son does the daf and he loves it. Tell your son to try it." And Baruch Hashem, another guy for And plus many more that we're trying to give them to them. Also, I'm giving a lot of to my parents and my grandparents for all that I'm learning. I really was planning to go to the live share. The trip to Israel was canceled. Nosson Tzvi Sandler. Nosson Tzvi. This is a uh I'm just showing it to you guys. Remember the tie-dye? Yeah. That was from a Simchas Menachem. 7 and 1/2 years ago. And he's wearing and last night he came Yeshurin Price. He's giving out coffee. And here he is wearing that thing. Look at the hour base measure which is like this. Okay. Uh let's jump into it. Anonymous coffee corner. Kvoda Tefillah committee. Dial of name me at all made. I heard that since the head of the coffee committee, the Kvoda Tefillah committee is in America, dialem is very, very shvach and they're they're momish making coffee in the middle of davening and That's kach shamati. I don't know if it's true. We need him back immediately. Official edition of the Yiddish Shas. Chanukah bracha. Tie-dye. It's Chanukah party. Imprushim. Yeah. Imprushim. Imprushim. The mesechta by the Irani and Levi families. It was the last time we did a family seeyum kind of thing for all kids. It was a family by the Irani and Levi families. They said that the last time it was a family. These two guys. I have two haters here. He laughed at you like you had the best joke. You should be crying. I got it. If he's already doing this, maybe he should translate to Canadian also. Official edition of the Yiddish Shas. Mesechta by the Irani and Levi families. Perek Anonymous. L'ilui nishmas Nachum Tzvi ben Dovid Sholhoif. Daf Kuf Hey. L'ilui nishmas Immanuel Yekutiel. Akeida Nosson Tzvi ben Moshe ben Moshe Menachem ben Hershel Versatile. Dedicated by children and grandchildren. The neshama should have an aliyah. Sponsor David Solomon. Dedicated in memory of Avraham Meilech ben Shmuel Boruch ben Avraham Tzvi Dovid Zichrono Livracha. Jolene Dallas l'ilui nishmas my father Jack Dallas. Anonymous for Shmuel Boruch ben Yisrael Yitzchok. Apology found foundation of Zichron Yisroel ben Avraham Boruch ben Shmuel Apology Demitzeli. Anonymous for ben Moshe ben Zev Anonymous for complete refuah shleima of Aryeh ben Yisrael to Leah bas Send the girls and family can be on UK and Ireland rebellion. Who changed my meaning of life? Ari Simon is a monthly sponsor of first lamer and the white kids Anonymous Yeshua Shalom Baptist is a weekly sponsor and daily sponsors Liba Bas Yeshua Liba Bas Shimon Mordecai is a The Neil Barad for first lamer L'Oreal Bas Hana Malko and the white art for the month for first lamer Mordecai ben Esther Yael Esther Huh? I said I said. I said I said I said. Said it. I'm pretty sure I said it. Of course I did. Of course I said it. How do I know I said it cuz last night I said the wrong one and then this and the sleeping okay. We're holding a brand new parrot. Daf kuf dalet on the base. I really like sort of Yovi Yachad. This is no good at all. If a person uses a singular lotion I really like Yisaron. I take upon myself to bring one Yisaron. Yovi Yachad he should bring one. If he says plural it's really nice Yovi Shnayim. So this is a little bit more of a good dish. That he only brings two he doesn't bring more than two. Minimum of the plural is two and it's not more than two two. Pay attention. This case is going to be brought down twice in the Mishnah. I set aside I said I'm going to bring a Mincha, but I have no clue what I said. So [snorts] unfortunately for him The most a person can bring in one Mincha is 60 Issaron. So perhaps he said 60 Issaron, we don't know. Now what if he said 59 not 60? How can he bring 60? 59 is the Chiyuv. One is an Nedava. One 59 is for his obligation. Let's say he said 30. 30 is his obligation. The other is not his obligation and they're all in one Kli. So what do you do? You do the classic which is a Tnai. You say Whatever, if I if it was 30, so the 30 is my Chiyuv, the rest I'm giving in Nedava. Whatever my Chiyuv is, that's what I'm giving and whatever is in the Kli, the leftover, that will be you have to make a condition. Yes, you have to specify. No. Hareini Olai Mincha. What are you going to do? I don't see a second committee here. Hareini Olai Mincha. What if a person doesn't say what kind of Mincha? So there are five classics. And you would bring one of these five. You bring anyone you want. No no no no no no. One. There is the default. There's a default Mincha. If you don't specify what, so the default is a Minchas Soles, number one on the list. That's the most special, that's the default. In Hebrew I learned a new word I'll teach it to you. It's actually two words. Be me down. I lived there for 13 years and I don't know the word so well. You have to make me down default. It could be cuz a lot of people say default. Default. Okay. But if you want to be fancy be like me down. >> [cough] >> So if like it's couples over I need you down be like me down. You know like throwing like a lot of words. The mom is thinking that you're an American. So if a person says How much is that? Me one. Or he says I really like me coming home. He doesn't say me he says me. A type of which is one singular me is a singular. How many singular? So here are the two cases. I really like me coming home. Me coming home is one. It's it's singular. Me me guys is two. That's the next case. I really like me coming home or me me guys me me guys plural. You have a stein. That's in his lotion. His lotion is which means two so he brings two. The guy is just going to ask and actually make a whole thing out of it. What if he says gimel? I really like me coming home. Me me seems like two. Me seems like one. It's a contradiction in his words. So what do you do? What do you say? So how many? Two? Okay so you guys to go through the question and explain it nicely. Try to learn from the first case. Try to learn from the second case. Try [clears throat] to learn from a different case. Yeah, but maybe we could explain away his words. If it's a complete contradiction, you're right. But we could explain it. So let's see. We'll see the Gemara. I'm just throwing it out here cuz we just had two cases. I'm throwing out the third case. So you don't get all famished. Aleph and Bet is in the Mishnah that we just read. Min Mincha Min Menachos. The simplest of the simple. >> [clears throat] >> Pirashti Ve'eini Yodea Eizeh Min Pirashti. I said I'm going to bring one of these five. I might have said a Machvas. I might have said a Machshas. I have no clue what I said. Yavi Chamishim. So unfortunately, Nebech to you, you have to bring all five. Now, this seems very very similar to the first case of the Mishnah. It it might be the same. There's a Machlokes in the Gemara if it's different or not. Pirashti Mincha Shel Isronim. Ve'eini Yodea Kama Pirashti. I said it's going to be >> [snorts] >> at least one Isaron, maybe two Isronim, maybe five. Yavi Shishim Isaron. So because I don't know what I said, and the maximum is 60, I'll bring 60. Rebbi Omer Yavi Menachos Shel Isronos Me'echad Ve'ad Shishim. This is Rebbi. This is unbelievable. This guy messed up royally. Mamash messed up. Instead of him bringing three Isronim, he has to bring a Kli that has one Isaron in it cuz he might have said one. He has to bring another Kli that has two. He has to bring another Kli that has three. And another Kli that has four, five, six, 10, 31, another Kli that has 52, and clear that has 59 and finally a clear that has 60. Now I know R A Simon knows the answer. So how do you do the math? Very very simple. The sheet of bets is sheet of bets is has a whole look it up it's go like this like that. Mamish This is how we did in Ponovich math for dummies the easiest way mamish. There's a famous story in Germany Frederick what's the guy what's his name that the mathematician? The the teacher said how much is 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 up to 100 and in a few seconds he said the answer that and the way it goes like this let's say it's 1 to 100. 1 to 100 you add a 1. You always add the 1 so it's 101. And you take that number and divide it in half that's it that's the whole way that's how you do it. So what's half of 100? 50. 50 * 100 is how much? 5000. You take the number your total let's say I tell you to count I'm going to do it again. From 1 to 100 so 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 22 + 23 + 24 + 25 = You take the number you divide it in half that's 50. 50 times the total number 50 times 100 is 5000 but it's not just 5000 it's 5 it's 101 so I have to do 50 times 1. So I do 50 times 101 = 5050. That's the answer to the questions 5050. Now let's take it by us very very simple. We have 60 60. Our number is 60. So you take 60 divided in half that's 30. How much is 3 times 6 just for Ponovich people? 18. So it's 30 times 60 is how much? 1800. But there's one you have to add the one. So it's 30 + 1 is another 30. So, it's 1830. That's the number. That's the number of Ishtaranum that you need. 1830. No homo. No. >> [laughter] >> Oh, it can't be easier than this. It can't be easy. It cannot be easier. 59 and 1 is 60. 59 and 2 is 61. That's why that math works. >> That's why it works. I didn't explain why it works. Exactly. Cuz you have 30, you have 30 You have 30 pairs of 61. It's 60 + 1, 59 + 2, 58 + 3, whatever. That's why it works. So, why why make them a sugar? You take the number, divide it in half. So, it's 60. Divide in half is 30. 30 * 60. Then you take that half and divide it by the total number. 30 * 60 = 1800. But, there's one more number. It's It's 61. So, you take 30 * 1 is 30. So, the total number is You don't even need to know the numbers. It's super interesting that a guy messed up so much. Instead of bringing one Ishtaranum, he's going to bring 3 and 1/2 ton of flour to the base of English. He's going to bring a truckload of Frederick Gauss. You got to say it right. That's his name. Frederick Gauss. I don't I saw this video and you'll tell me if it's We'll We'll We'll decide if to show it or not. It could be insulting. Take it out. Okay. Take it out. Editors, take it out. >> [snorts] >> Masking. Fine. Zuk tzu gamor. You saw I did that, but I showed it to you. Take it out and show it to you. The rest of the world won't see it. >> [laughter] >> We don't insult anyone. But, no, this is a person has Alzheimer's. It's not insulting. I don't You might say they forget. They forget. What are you going to do? Now it's becoming insulting. >> [snorts] >> Listen. for me it's not insulting because but I don't know but I don't have Alzheimer's but I have something very close to it. Seriously, I don't have like in my my memory is like whatever. So tomorrow on the on the first line of the mission a person says how are you a kid in kindergarten knows that it means one. So you're right. It's the second case that's important. That's a little bit of a that's also possible. Hard to understand exactly back and forth here with that's one way to read it that that is a that not more than two. That the minimum of plural is two but not more than two. Okay. So just Where did here? You have case number one in the mission I said I I said I'm going to bring him in I have no idea. So the mission says you will be 60 in the mission. I I realized something very interesting last night. This time for the people here in the base of managers. All the screens are good. Besides mine the dollar and the all the way the second line from the bottom is missing. In other words something with the ratio is off on that on that screen. So maybe we need a new screen. What? We're going to get this just a test run. Now we're going to get screens over here. If somebody wants to donate the screens we're we're we're we're open for donations. Okay. So and then look at this thing it says it again. You will be 60 in the mission. It's the same words you should bring 60 but over here you have Rebbe you do one till 60 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 it's equals 1830. So what's the difference between the ration the safer? So the Montana the like a Rebbe or my Rebbe the like a Rebbe. The first the blue part on top is just one sheet the Yavi is not going according to Rebbe. The Rebbe Rebbe says before you should do 1 + 2 + 3. Rebbe and no no no no no no no it's two different cases. I feel the same Rebbe. The case is Rebbe the Rebbe and Rebbe Rebbe. The first case is I said I'm going to bring a certain amount of flour but I never said in how many vessels. The so what you have to do is you bring but just in 60 calum. So the you don't gain anything in terms of the vessels you have to put in 60 packs. But only each pack gets one for a total of 60. Worst comes to worst what? You said 39? So you take 39 bowls and you that's your that's your thing. You don't have to do in each bowl two and then the second bowl three and four and five you don't have to do that. Each bowl is just going to have one in it. Just make sure you you have 60 bowls and then you cover all your bases. My Rebbe and the Rebbe and the safer he said it was a certain amount and each amount was by itself in a bowl. So if each amount is by itself in a bowl so now I have a it's possible 39 in one bowl 52 in one bowl seven in one bowl. So now I have to go through one through 60 every bowl a different amount. If I didn't say that the bowl is important, then I could just bring one is on per bowl. That those are the two cases. Sorry. Let's do it again. I never said how many vessels. Then I could just bring 60 in 60 different vessels. We had review the argument on this and says no. If I say mincha, you can't bring any one of the five you want. There's a default. And the default is silas. Review says oh, it's shihime It's the it's the it's the most important one. Why? So maybe the pshat is we're starting off saying The the Torah the first mincha mentioned in the entire is mincha silas. Wait a minute. If what the Torah says first is the most important, so then every time a person says oila, I'm bringing oila, you must bring a cow, which is super expensive versus a sheep. If he says minat sayin yovi kevis, he he can't bring a a goat, he has to bring a a sheep. Why mention the first? Min oil, when he says that I'm going to bring a bird, yovi tiren, he should bring a tiren not a not a not a dove. Not a pigeon. Cuz that's first in the Torah. But the fact is the mishna versus oila, he could bring a sheep not a cow. According to what you're saying, it should be a cow cuz it's first in the Torah. He could bring whatever he wants. Review doesn't argue. So we have to say pshat what what he says in the mishna that the reason why you bring a silas is cuz it's muchedes, it's special. The last lay shame of eight. It doesn't have another name. Like if somebody says, "I'm doing the daf, I'm doing daf." What does daf mean? Daf means daf yomi. It doesn't mean any other kind of daf that there is you have in school, you have in a school, you have a daf kesher, you have a daf this, daf that. No, it's one thing. Um When you said daf daf Let's see I have cover homer. This is interesting. >> [music] >> What kind of sausages do you have to offer? Sir, we have a Hindi sausage, beef distilled in alpine rosemary and hand rolled in delicate Persian salt. Or perhaps you would prefer a veal sausage with smoked ebony seeds in a saffron and mountain honey glaze. And there is also a truffle sausage, black lamb seasoning wrapped in edible gold leaves and served on a bed of glass noodles. >> ENOUGH WITH THE NONSENSE. WHAT IS YOUR MOST ELITE SAUSAGE? AH, that's an easy one. Now, this is a real sausage. No explosive names, no distractions, just the best real thing itself. Oh. Oh. No similar value. Now we know what no similar value means. So oh, let me just show you the possuk. All these jokes and everything, but here the possuk. Check this out. Typical typical mincha in the possuk says it's called minchas machshos. How does the Torah call a soilus? It's not called minchas soilus. It's called mincha lashem. Soilus ya korban. It's not a minchas soilus. It's by itself. It has It doesn't say the word mincha. Soilus. It has nothing accompanying it. It's by itself. So when a fellow when a person says a mincha, he mean he means soilus. But the problem is what kind of You just said the reason is because it's the first in the possuk. How can you call it? Aizu mincha miyuchades minachos lashem levai. In other words, the main reason is because it doesn't have an accompanying name. That's the main thing. But how do I remember it? This is supposed to be It's the first one that the Torah starts off with. You tell me we're talking about Silas. This is where the boys are. It's a Hadash Baruch Have. How many people remember the simony gave 2 days ago? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. How? What did you say? Zedad. Zedad Yaha uh? Zedad Yahas. Get over here. These kids are better than the adults. >> [laughter] >> What's going on here? David, what's going on here? This is crazy. Well, your grandson is Where's Daddy Louie? What's your name? Yakovari, how old are you? >> [clears throat] >> You're 12? I thought you're only 11. A month ago. >> [snorts] >> Okay, it's not so good cuz you're already big. You're already I'm just kidding. I'm kidding. I'm kidding. So how do you remember you Zedad What is it again? Zedad Yahas. How How do you remember? Um we learn in school also and here. So what does what does Zedad stand for? How do you What do you do with the Zedad? Zedad is 7 44. 744. So what like 744 what? Of Meters? No. The kids are giving out the unbelievable. How do you You're the only one here that remember that. Unbelievable. Maybe you also You also remembered it? >> [applause] minutes, boys. Not you again, Ellis. minutes, boys. He's right. He's right. He's right. It's going to be a lot. No, I'm and I have no chance. We'll never be one No, I'll be I can say we'll be the best we can be. >> [laughter] >> Be the best we can be. Wow. Thanks, Mom. I didn't change this kid's life. He's changing my life. I don't know what you're talking about. This kid is just This kid's on a different level. Okay. So, you see them sitting here and they're like It's going in. It's going They're absorbing. They're absorbing. We guys we got to step up our game. We can't We can't be embarrassed by these 11-year-olds anymore. This is crazy. This is nuts. Okay. Yeah. This sheer is only for adults, by the way. Adults only. Go back to where you came from. Go back to Don't you have school now? 7:00 Or is it 7:00 in the morning? They get up at 6:30 to get here to sheer? What is going on with these kids? What is going on here? Okay. Remember what you read in the siddurs. I do more. I do more even though I'm in the middle of calling my Oh, sorry. Fighter. Okay. Mincha min min a mincha. So, here's the question again. So, let's just see it again. >> [clears throat] >> Here are the two No, sorry, not this one. These are the two cases in the Mishnah. Min mincha. Anybody knows Hebrew? Simple uh dictation. Min mincha is very very singular. It means one. Min mincha is It means two. Although you could Okay. Boy of papa. Mine a mincha mahu. What if he adds Case number three in the bottom, gimel. It says mine a mincha. So, on the one hand mine a means two. Mincha means one. So, what do you do? So, the explains the question. Given all my mine a Tired of going over it. Means two. Oh, my mincha. But but why do you say mincha? Seems like a contradiction and you should do the boor like he asked. No. The mincha is not a mincha at all. You You know, that's the lotion of the positive of Torah. You talk about all these and at the end the Torah calls it in the singular lotion. I have no idea who he is, he disappeared. He asked the question and ran. Okay. >> [snorts] >> Perhaps milk means one. Why did he say plural in the beginning? How do you from all the five types I want to bring one? Tushma. Huh? Okay. I got it. Tushma. So, basically all the is doing what's let's just leave this on the thing for a second. Take a look at case olive all the way on the top. It says mincha. So, and that's one. Let's just do the outside very simple. From case olive that if you change the wording a little bit and instead of saying men you mean a it should be two. Only olive means one, but anything different than olive should be two. So, what's the classic going to ask? But from case is my only is two, but if you change the wording to is going to be one. So, what is going to say you're right since I can't go from what? Something like that. Since it's a a little bit of a problem from from olive is my small that it's two from base is my small that it's one. So, we're not going to learn from our mission. So, from our mission it says how many case olive. How many but if I change it to case gimmel stein. Otherwise it would have said case gimmel in the mission. No, let's learn from the safer. How many case How many case are we like how many case In that [clears throat] case case base you have a stein the middle case you bring two. So, I could infer how many mincha if I change the wording around chada? Al lo ma ha le kol ma shmi no. I can't learn that from the ration of the seifa, so let's go by it. Tashma. But over here the only difference that changes now is that there's only one case in this braisa. I don't have two cases contradicting each other. So I'm going to do the same exact thing again. But I don't have Oh, it's mashma from the reisha like this and the seifa like that. Over here I just have a seifa. I have case base. It says in the braisa min menachos zalai yovi shtei menachos min menacha. You bring two. Or but if I change the wording around to minei mincha I'll only bring one. How many minei mincha chada? Says the Gemara, beautiful. You inferred well. But perhaps you should infer it slightly different and then I don't have a good outcome. That what? You're right. Case gimmel is going to be different than case base. What's the outcome of case base? That you bring two. So the Gemara wants to infer that case gimmel you bring one. No, maybe case gimmel you bring one two total two, but from different types. That's basically what gimmel was saying before. Minei mincha different types of menachos one from two different types. One marcheshes, one machvas. Whereas case base is going to be two from the same type. How many maybe shtei menachos shtei minei? So maybe I can't I can't infer. Vahalisa but we don't we don't we don't we don't learn like that in the braisa. It says min menachos zalai Where is that? Oh. This I had to do a little surgery myself. Did Does anybody see my surgery? It's a graft. It's a graft. This the case base I stuck in in middle. I cut and pasted cuz I couldn't Yochanan did it in a way and he's sleeping, so I had a Okay, but I hope you don't you might call me cuz I had to extend it also cuz it's there was a long nun. You see where it says number like case base in the middle. So the meaning is like kind of weird. >> [clears throat] >> I just took it from the bottom, placed it on top. Okay, so what do you have here? Let's do it together. >> [clears throat] >> Min minochis is a lie. Case number one on top, case aleph. Maybe sh'tei minochis min minochos. He has to bring two minochis but from one one type. Min minochis is a lie, case base. Min minochis maybe sh'tei minochis mish'tei minim. 1 * 2, one mincha from two minim, I wrote there. Ha, minei mincha chada. But our case, hareini minei mincha, should only bring one. Look. The two type cases is two, but I can infer that if I change the wording around a little bit it should be one. Says the Gemara, "D'mahu amar Rebbi Shimon ben Nos Maybe this goes like Rebbi Shimon d'Amar." Mitzvah chavas mitzvah d'kigin yavi. We had Rebbi Shimon many times in this mesechta. At least three. No, I think more. But we had him a bunch of times. The what? That if a person Has the voice. Oh, yeah. It's like dealing with many Rebbi Didi Kramers when they're 11 years old. You know, these kids, it's hard. I'm not going to recommend the fences. >> [snorts] >> So, the the the mincha, you have five minochis. Check out number four, number five. Number four and five, they go together. Rebbi Shimon actually says that you can mix and match. That's important for our sugia now, just to go back a little bit chazara. Chalis and rikikin. One, the Tanna Kamma holds no, if a person chalis, if he says mincha, he can only bring 10 chalis or 10 rikikin. Rebbi Shimon says no. In fact, you can bring five chalis and five rikikin. You can't do that with marcheshes and chalis or soilos and chalis, but chalis and rikikin you can mix and match. You can do six and four if you want, one and nine, whatever you want. Okay. So, um meila, the wording, this wording could go like Rebbi Shimon. The what? Hareini minei mincha. It it it it's different types in one mincha. A challah is a rakik and minae and it becomes one mincha. Or my minae mincha, mincha that is but three minae. It's two types in one mincha. A rabbonan mincha challah is a mincha rakik and rabbonan all you cannot mix and match. Maybe sh'tei menachos sh'tei minin they in fact hold it has to be two different types of minchos. If a person has no idea what mincha he said he might have said a side of him he might have said a machvas. He has to bring all five. This does not go like Rebbe Shimon. Super simple. Check this out. What do we have on the screen here? Five types of minchos. So if a guy doesn't know what he said he has to bring five. How many challahs will he bring? 10. How many rakikin does he bring? 10. The problem is what if he said what if he tried to mix the challahs and rakikin? Five of each. So he has to bring five challahs and five rakikin. So that's already six varieties. And what if he said six and four? So that's seven varieties. What? The combinations that are available to you are 14 total. Why? The five that we have on the screen but the bottom two, number four and five, rakikin and challahs you can mix and match. So only according to Rebbe Shimon here, you would have to typically bring 10 rakikin and 10 challahs. That's normal. But what if he said one rakik and nine challahs? So you have to bring one and nine. The guy could Is he allowed to say according to the mission, is he allowed to say one one rocket and nine challahs? He's allowed to. You're allowed to mix. So, he has to bring this. Maybe he said this. The guy who's a The guy says, "I I brought a mincha. I forgot what I said." Forget what he said. So, maybe you said one rocket and and nine challahs. So, bring one rocket and nine challahs. But, maybe he said two rocket and eight challahs. So, you have to bring that. That's another That's another variety. And another variety. How many total combinations are there, Rabbi Zave? Nine. Cuz it's nine and one, one and nine. So, there's only nine varieties. Plus, there's another two. 10. 10 and zero of rocket, 10 and zero of challahs. So, that's 11. Plus three more, which are Let's go back to the three more, the top ones. So, let's a total of 14. Is everybody with me? We have to do hazara. Huh? We're good? 14 permutations of how to bring the mincha. This What what what How many what? What's that word? Each permutation. Permutations. Only for interruption. Permutatia, yeah. I couldn't believe I was talking like a Sephardi. Shita ol hava, it was unbelievable. >> Spanish Sephardi. Yeah, with the resh. Very good. It's good Mom's good. So, I'm saying you do the same exact thing. You get a Hasidic The whole shiur is going to be in perfect Yiddish. A guy came A guy comes in A guy comes into the base medrish with a streimel, an old Yerushalmi guy, white beard. Maybe Dave [snorts] could find it. He Oh, a Remy. Uh okay. Dave, where's Dave? He all of a sudden he just blurts out from the back. He goes, "Can I give you a kiss?" And he comes running to the front and kisses my head. Last night, in the middle of the shear. And then uh so then uh this guy Mark this Yushani guy Mark he goes Wow, something I don't know what he said. He He says, "You wanted to do it." So I said I said in Yiddish I mom I said I messed it up I said Ed givolt und du hast getut. Something like that instead of getin. Get getut. My it's terrible terrible. And he said to my cousin that getin. Yeah, okay. He said that's why I don't give you saying Yiddish. He's going to have hundreds of these. So the guy this lets again says It's okay cuz the way you speak Hebrew is you just do it in the Yiddish also. It's fine. Yeah, he screamed it out. English is not not like to write home about. Yeah. Nothing to scream home about. Eat. Um Abayo Amar. I feel like they may have a shimon. No, it could go like a shimon. The what? Nachamol. We said that you could bring five five minachas in the mishnah you could bring all five. According to the shimon you have to bring 14 because there's another nine permit what? Who what? Um um Combinations. There's another nine combinations. So it can't be a shimon. Says no, it could be a shimon. Bring five. Rabois I bring five. 10 challahs, 10 rikikin and make it nice. Say if it was one from here and nine from here or two from here and nine from here. What's the problem? The reason my shimon asked me all you need to do is is make it a condition. The shimon I made a mockery of maybe I show him the way he might. So Baruch Hashem Rashi if Rashi does it short I'm also going to do it short. He doesn't go it's it's a it's a little bit of a complicated situation. This guy is having a terrible terrible day. He's not sure if he's a metzora like a muchlar or a muzgar. >> [clears throat] >> He's one or the other. And he's not sure if he's a nazir. He's completely confused. >> [laughter] >> No, no, no, no, no. He is he is both of these. He just doesn't know if he's a real nazir or fake nazir. In other words, he is time out. He's a 100% nazir, but he made of, like the woman on my flight who after the flight said, "What a crazy flight." She goes, "Like why?" I said, "It was a very good flight." I said, "Yeah, but the guy right next to you died." She said, "What? What are you talking about?" I said, "You didn't see He was like sitting next to you, and he's dead." She says, "I don't know what you're talking about." I said, "So, what did they do with him?" I said, "They put him in the kitchen." She goes, "Uh I went through the kitchen and there's a bag there I couldn't get through, so I stepped on it." I've said the story now. You've never heard the story? No, I didn't. I don't know who the woman was. I don't think I know. But anyway, I don't think So, so she she became tamei maybe misofek. I don't know. She doesn't know for sure exactly what So, this guy is a nazir. He's a 100% a nazir. Now, he doesn't know if he went to the when he was in the funeral, did he touch the body? Was he went to did they do oil? He doesn't know. So, what should he do? Think about it. If he knows for sure that he touched a dead body, what does he do? Gets a haircut, starts all over again, brings korbanos, starts all over. But he cannot do that. He You can't just take a haircut while you're a nazir. If you're a nazir and you take a haircut, you have a issue with the reisha. If you knew for sure, it would be okay. So, what does he do? Very simple. He waits till the end of the 30 days. This is typical nezirus is 30. Waits the 30, gets a haircut, cuz anyways he would have to get a haircut even if he was a nazir, and then he starts over again. So, he has a total 60 days. At the same time, he also doesn't know if he's a metzora, muchlar, or muzgar that can't put him in for for 2 weeks, 1 week. So, is he a complete metzora or not? Okay, the bottom line is you have a guy that's very confused here. And he's supposed to bring it says over here the machras after day 60 61 maybe a shalom you should bring a carbon asham like a nazir does with the oil that a nazir everybody knows nazir yeah? The famous videos that we have put put it on the on the finger on the this on this head Vayomer And he makes a condition here see Reb Shimon says he can make a condition now what? If it's a if I'm a metzora so I'm bringing my asham so I'm bringing my carbon asham. If not asham if not my asham is not a asham my asham is a is a shalom. Now let's think about it for a second. >> [laughter] [applause] >> Okay the take away fine next. >> [snorts] >> So Oh one minute one minute one minute time out. Let's think about it everybody knows the answer to this we're just going to do hazara. A asham is in what category? Kodesh kodashim kodashim kalim? Kodesh asham. Asham huh? Let's ask the 11 year old time out Ari what do you say? Kodesh kodashim what do you say? Okay kodesh kodashim I go with the kid. It's kodesh kodashim. What's shalom? Kalim. So we have a big problem because there's big differences between the two. You can't take a asham and say oh "Oh, be a shalom. So you have to be machmir in each one whatever chumra it has. For instance, asham ton shchitas hatzafon, akachi kachim, achatos and asham, and it shall be tzibur, you could only do shchita on the north part of the azara. A shlamim you could do in the south, but it doesn't matter. Let's just be machmir and say this animal, since it might be an asham, let's shlacht it only in the tzafon. And you go through the whole process of matana matan b'honos, and you put the the the the oil on its on its thumb and its big finger. Blood, the whole thing. U'smicha, now this is not for an asham. This is only for uh shlamim. So, you lean on it. U'nisachim, you bring wine. This is not for an asham. This is only for shlamim. Right? Every shlamim and every ola gets nisachim. U'tnufas chaze v'shok, this is only for shlamim that you lift up the chaze and the shok and the ear. You you do the whole nanuim. Now, this is for how how long could you eat kochi kachim for? Only for one day. How long could you eat shlamim for? Two days. So, what do you do? You only eat it for one day. What's the problem? What's the problem if you take something you could eat for two days and only eat it for one day? Let's see if the 11-year-old knows. Sha! Sha! Let's see if the This is a hard one. I don't know if he knows this one. No, if you could if you take something you could eat for two days and only eat it for one day, it's a problem. Why is it a problem? What is it called, the problem? It's graise noiser. So, what is it called? Base ap'sul. Exactly. Kodesh noiser ap'sul. Maybe ap'sul. So, Rava gave the comment mar b'shchitas kachim. This is gevaldik. I love this. What does it say? B'shchitas kachim. Meaning maseches z'vachim. It's another way in the time of the Gemara. They didn't call it maseches z'vachim. They called it b'shchitas kachim. I'm learning What maseches you learning? Shchitas kachim. That's the maseches. So, even though I'm going to go I'm going to go I'm going to do it. Even though we already took this apart in z'vachim. Eima d'Rabbah b'sheim Rabbi Yossi u'Maseches When did Reb Shimon say that you could do this all with that corner Gabriel? This is to help a human being that's in a big tsara. He's having a bad day. He's in tsara. He doesn't know what to do with himself and he'll never be able to catch him again in his life. So, we have we have a fix for him. I will be with Amazon. David you can't tell somebody >> [clears throat] >> make a tinai on your carbon when it doesn't really help anybody. Let's do the sponsor right here. Turning the dial by dial global specialist international financial services Heim Milrad Refuah Shlema Emi Marasi for the little bus of Shacharit Yisrael. So, this is the this is the answer. How to come When is it a big problem and you can only do when you're helping somebody out to fix his life? It's by because you took something a carbon. You have a 200 lb You have 200 lb of meat and you just said, "I'm limiting it. You can only eat the meat for one day." That's a big problem. The question is what is the soul? >> [snorts] >> The expiration date you shorten the expiration date. This is terrible. By the way, stama if you ever come to Israel and you you want to buy milk or cottage cheese, so it's a little different than in America. In America if you want to get something with a long expiration date you go to the back of the shelf. Here in Israel go to the front because they know that you're going to go to the back. So, they put it in the front. Now, we should just know this. I'm going to laugh at you. So, it has a short expiration date. >> [laughter] >> Why? Why? It also has to do with the guy is very lazy and doesn't want to put the Okay, fine. >> [clears throat and cough] >> So, if they call all stuff out, put the new stuff all in the back. Kids are Okay, fine. A little bit of MS a little bit of >> [snorts] >> I'm going to have to feel like I'm feeling a little bit of this, a little bit of this. I'm going to have to feel like I'm feeling but I'm going to have to do this all the same exact date. This this is They're all for one day. I'm going to have to do this all in one day. So I didn't mess anything up. I'm going to have to do this all in one day. I'm going to have to do So this video, believe it or not, as silly as it is, it's really going to explain this beautifully cuz I wanted to bring two bags of flour and I said, "You know what? I don't need to because this guy did a very good job here. Oh my Okay. Where was it? Here. Basically, think about it. For the I have to bring a bag of flour. For the I have to bring a bring a bag of flour. Where am I doing my from? I'm making a I'm making a tonight condition. But if I decided to bring half and half, half half this, so half should be another, half should be another. I have to make a condition. I'm bringing 10 loaves of 10 loaves of and I start making conditions. If I said eight and two, so the eight and two should be my real thing and the rest should be another. And if it's five and five, the five and five should be my real carbon. But I have two separate bags of I made I made my out of one bag of flour and I made my out of one bag of flour. How am I doing my How am I mixing it? Here, check this out. This might explain a little bit better than what I just explained. I need to bring a mincha for hova and a mincha for nedava. Okay, so we need an of solet and an of yoyins for each one. Half from here for chova and half for nedava and half from here for chova and half from here for nedava. You said one here is nedava and one is chova. How can you divide the cle of solet and the cle with the shamin like that? Oh. I hold like Rabbi Shimon. Okay. As the Gemara You bring one isaron from two. In other words, one from one isaron for each type. The one look for each type for one look for the rikikin one for the challahs. So the Gemara is not a problem. Yotza. The what in a completely different case. Listen to this. A person says I'm going to bring one isaron. He ends up bringing two in two separate vessels. But he took a half from here and a half from here. The charets shouldn't be good. You don't have one together. You have a half here and a half here. He says it's okay. So there also it's okay. As the Gemara very good, it's okay. Omeik matzei he comments. You don't have the choven you don't have everything together. You have a mixture of chova and nedava in one bowl and a mixture of chova and nedava. Where do you do your kemitsa from? The mastlin of all my makes a condition army. If I said I'm only going to bring challahs by themselves or the rikikin by themselves. The whatever I take kemitsa from the challah should be for the challah. The kemitsa of rikikin rikikin. But in if I made if what I promised was half and half or whatever combination or whatever kemitsa I it should be for the and the part of the nether part of my for the nether As the you need one should all be we said once I'll just we don't have to we don't have time here but you do something like this Titan right? You take the the color you break it up into pieces you take the thing and then once you have all the pieces of the house and the together in one bowl you do a like that but it should be one from everything mixed in. You should have one mixture not two different pieces. Have a wonderful day. >> [music] >> Spread Torah throughout the world sponsor a share today and do I sponsor.com with sponsor mdy.com. >> [music]