Daf Yomi Meilah Daf 16 by R’ Eli Stefansky

we're continuing all right we're continuing with the theme of things that combine together for different chiron so the mission says only veiler so it's seen from the simple reading of the mishnah that all the veils even if you take a non-kosher animal you take a half a shear of a non-kosher animal let's say you say you take a half a kazaas of a non-kosher animal and have a cause is of a kosher animal you take a camel and a cow a half kazakus of each you combine them together for kazakhstan you eat it you're over on nevaeh but starve zoom zoo we're going to see what this means exactly so if you take a little bit of one share it's whatever the sheer is a kazais let's say or kadasha whatever the shear is and you combine them together their mitstar omarav that's the the main thing we don't really talk about shikatsum usually sharits we're talking about we're going to be discussing schweinsteim regular sim let's combined together says rav we're not talking about eating you cannot combine a cow and a pig but the toma of an availa that yes they can they could combine why what's the difference between two men ahila tuma they both have toma but nevaela rav holds they don't have novella a non-kosher animal doesn't have an israeli veil why because anes are a lizard the non-kosher animal was created as a tummy animal so he already has the issuer of pig then he dies you can't add to it another issue called novella it already has one is so you can't add another is on top of it so if you can't add another israel on top of it that doesn't have an available so now you're taking a half a kazais of pork which is not an availa and you try to combine it with the havoc as is of cow which is novella they don't go together there's nothing to go together but by tomorrow they both have toma is something else so half of his eyes of this tummy and half of his eyes of this tummy together you have one hulk his eyes of tomo and that's why your tommy the lady omar afidullah hilo named says levy now even when it comes to eating there's a issue of navella on a non-kosher animal why because lady's going to hold israel khalali so taisu says beautifully typically levi is going to hold ayna sukhalali sir he agrees to that concept but over here it's special this is special in this passage in other words the navel you shouldn't eat so over here the there's that there's the isr of nevada goes on top of the israel calif so once i say that neville is so powerful it can go on top of something else like caleb so go on top of tom as well it's a special tradition when it comes to navel that is according to levy what it applies to tommy tummy animal just like applies to caleb it can attach itself to height attach itself to atomic animal verb comes and says a little bit of uh we have to understand what he says how would you read it um okay again if you look at the beginning of the gemara is the same words basically he says that you cannot combine kosher animals with non-kosher animals when it comes to when it comes to aquila it comes to tomias says they are mr fatuma comes ravasi and says there's no syrup at all for anything just like he's going to hold here just like by food the name is and the mishnah the mission says call her in vegas with starfish what does that mean ravasi but the mission says they are menstruative so we need to explain says tyson's that the mission is talking about one species only kosher animals one a half a gaze of one cow has been starved with the half of according to the second shot rivassi holds that when it comes to tumor a non-kosher animal and a cultural animal armed starif and because the name itself just like rav says mace vestigmar casho it says in the bryce interesting bryce what does that mean if you have a dead cow and a live camel the cow is kosher the camel is they are not met styrofoam they get hypokasize to this one and i have a concise of the second one they're not meant tariff okay that's because one is alive and one is dead so what do you have here now it's dead no no but that's that's that's that's the suppose if the with we're going to get into that in a second what what happens if what happens if you have a full shear of kaze from an animal that's alive it's bosom in a high 100 according to a view if it's a if it's a kosher animal it's a hundred percent also the kula alma even though the animal is alive that's what basman is that's that's why it is maklakus review that says it works on a non-cultural animal and rabban and say it doesn't work it's not like we didn't learn this once before it might have been a week ago a year ago i don't remember but we did learn it somewhere in hulen probably homie in starfin so the gemara wants to make a deal it's it's a funny case of a live animal and a dead animal they don't combine together well you can make the simple duke but if they're both alive x or if they're both dead so the gemara goes okay let's be medic if they're both alive limits tariff sorry i'm sorry sir no i miss this part if they're both dead they are mistarif and what does ravasi say that when they're dead the namit star according to wamp shadow of asia did not starve at all not for tomorrow not for hilo so this is for sure according to other shot it's not fakilo but over here regardless it's very because we're talking about every minute so we're talking about here we're talking about eating obviously this bryce is talking about somebody eating and that's somebody touching because they're talking about the israel of basma so that would be where according to ravasi lokhara would be also according to rav who says that there is no issue goes into that reverse he was automatic rav and obviously if it's shivering him it's for him no there's no tomorrow on his avatar there's a whole sugar we had but no we don't know there's no toma umani uh no so we have a cashie rivassi says that a kosher animal and a non-kosher animal there's no sea roof at all you can't combine the two to make it israel for eating and over here it says that there is a sir if they're both dead there is an israel says no you made the wrong deal you went in the wrong direction the case was if one is alive one is dead so you want to make a duke oh but if they're both dead it's messiah no ish name and starving if they're both alive then they must tariff for what because one of them is kosher one of them is not kosher according to the kosher animal also has the israel and okay so you're going to tell me that the deok is that if they're both alive there's a issue but if they're both dead there's no way to laughing starving kane that can't be i think it might remains with this question my ear derivatives is part of a gumball so then why are you telling me an interesting case where one is alive and one is dead haphilumi let me start go all the way say much bigger even if they're both dead forget about one is alive even if they're both dead you cannot be tired of them according to rivassi they don't combine one is kosher one is not kosher void tanya it says in that price itself if one is alive one is dead that's what we just had before there's no two and then it continues but one half of his eyes of a cow and won't have his eyes of a of a non-kosher animal like a camel baby starfin so what's going on here on the one hand if you want to be if you want to read it simply you could say that if you have the the the brice says mamesh it seems like even if you have a half a kazyas of one and advocates to another one is alive and one is dead it doesn't matter if they're dead or alive or alive and dead they're almost tired obviously that can't be because there will be a complete stereotyration so we must say that what it means is they are both dead okay so let's explain they're both dead but it says mafurish if they're both dead they arm it's tariff so what are you giving me the yuki and from the ratio that if they're both dead the namin starve that's how you just finished off saying if they're both alive there's a museum with starve if they're both dead i'm going to be medic that did not make starve but it says i'm foolish to say for that they're both dead that they're they are midstarf not like so what are we going to do obviously we don't know we don't want to price him in shabbat stuff we don't know that's how we have to explain it from obviously have to say that they would start if for if they're both they're both dead they are my styrofoam and non-kosher and the crusher is starved and that will be a major problem taravasi it doesn't matter how you learn ravasi whether you learn him that they are not mitstarif only for akhila but the armaments are for tuma or certainly if you say that according to ravasi there's no syrup at all in any case even for tomah in any way it says over here that two dead animals a cow and a camel kosher now arm and starve so what do we do is sir this is a special tana the the price it doesn't hold like me you're right because that price just says it's but i don't hold it emma mello did not meet tariff [Applause] find new sought after zion on the base i don't know the sharits if you touch your share it's how much do you have to touch of a share it's in order to be tame kardashov why kardashian brings here apostolate over here that it says mahem from them and then it says in it sort of a contradiction in the passage so in order to explain the contradiction we have to say that what the torah meant is you have to touch a whole animal a whole share it i it says mayhem a little bit of a shares we're going to go to the smallest possible sheriffs in the world as it's born that's the heimet places brings i think it's like some a weasel it's born is this what when it's born i don't know how the size yeah you ever saw a mouse when it's born the size of your uh your nail okay fine let's say it's a snail it makes a lot more sense as a snail the kids are the size of a lentil that's how we get this lentil so if tuma the minimum size of toma is a lentil so it only makes sense logically that if you eat a chariz it would also be the size of a lentil says rav no it's not true akhilas rotsim like allah because ice there's a difference between tuma and eating when you eat all of a sudden you need a larger shear kazais my timer i don't even have to print it out it's all here five lines in a tiny little page it's unbelievable 25 what oh you mean i hear what you're saying but you know what everybody knows it's possible whatever the word is don't disgust yourself what's the proper english word the file now the file discuss is better well there's this actual but you can't write that if you are scrolling the file the file okay yeah that's what he said so what is this talking about how do you define yours how do you make yourself disgusted not by touching by eating we're talking about so the positive starts off as beautiful shot just like is a lentil so too lentil that'd be a big problem with what rav just said raf says that akhila is kazaas what's the answer so you have to make a distinction here vikas cashew cabin difference when it's i need this you see because i forgot which one is one when it's alive it's because it's when it's dead it's kadasho now it makes a lot of sense for boy son why because when it's alive like you pointed out a second ago there's no tumor when it's alive so if there's no tumor then i don't have the parsec what we just read there's no beginning of the positive end of the past like a heck is between tomina because you're eating something that's not tummy if you're eating something that has the that's possible to be tommy so then i can make that hackish and just like to misbehave but i'm eating a live animal i'm eating a piece right out of the carrots which by the way is really about the shaktsu so the since there's no tomo now i have to step it up to the shire of akhila like i have in the rest of the torah which is because i is here between since the posix starts off talking about aquila and ends off in tumor and to my know the shears because there's a special lee mode when it comes to eating something that has tumor but if i'm eating i take a bite right out of a rat then the shear is not a kadasha because there's no there that doesn't apply to it what does it apply to it the shear of akhila very tasty yeah yeah in china they they eat that yeah we will never no depends if the animal is alive or dead if the sheriff is alive or dead in shirazim there's an air look read this it's the sheriff's when it's alive then this series because ice when it's dead it's a i'm just explaining the reason why a dash applies to tumor and tumor is only when it's dead so whether this year applies to a dead animal barrilla over here when it's alive there's no tumor what yeah even for this forget about tumor let's say he put it in his mouth without touching it yes yes you're talking about uh ava ava versus not a your volume not your volume you know i tell you i have eight years of practice in chicago eight years now one time did they stop me when i skipped the line later on brings those words it costs rebirth and it has a cash on it so i jumped to the castle and in my gemara koi so what about he's doing here is look rap started out right right by the mishnah we have the mishnah calling on the basement and then right away rap says leishanu and he gives his first allah is talking about on the mishnah that is the difference between achill and tomah says abaya assumes himself it makes sense that this second allah said whatever he said before it was a continuation in the sheer he said one allah that there's a difference between being a tsar if a cow and a camel bene and then he says by the way shrads him you doesn't distinguish between a live show it's in the description making me a beautiful killing between a live one and a dead one but the mission doesn't say it i feel like even if the animal is dead it seems like raf said it is and over here it says says you're making funny assumptions make a taste of speaking about the mishnah he said one allah mishnah true he spoke about sea roof of a cow on a camel and then he said another nothing to do with the mishnah how much do you need to eat by sheriffs who told you that he's talking about the mishnah i think this is brings here that it's like a lotion of zillow it's your own shot gets shot out of here nobody else ever thought about your your assumption rash might say rav was just saying nothing to do with the mission you cannot be medic or cash from the mishnah unraveled because rav wasn't even talking about the mishnah oh and here's my mistake the the shot from the pasuk the positive starts off talking about ahila finishes it off with toma so to give us a hackish that just like to um when it comes to a limb there is no shear affirmative if you have a limb smaller than a lentil but it's a full limb since this is double khashov that's that's all you need by shari is to be metamo and by an availa a himself says it's a beautiful beautiful shot when it comes to a share it's all you need is a kadasha because the end of the process is talking about tomah and thomas beckhadasha or vasari is talking about so this third team shot the mirror how to read the gemara i'm sure the the mesifta says a little bit different i'm sure because i saw it inside the possuck that's that we just made the heck is from that starts off talking about akhila ends off in tuma and you made a hagers between thomas that's talking about mubadalam that's talking about the shmaina shirazim they are moved though they're different than everything else in the torah it's only talking about this said that you need a kazias he wasn't talking about schwarzenegger he was talking about an availa and now it all fits in reverend says you need a kazaas isn't it that possible is shiratsu so now here's the lotion everybody no matter how you learn like any shannon the three other tysons of the mafaaris these words are not mamish because we just said means a sheriff and now we're talking about a behemoth there's no in behind there's no categories in bama the only categories that are really kosher and not kosher so the kumar is asking that even a aver that's less than a kazias just like an avid that's less than a kazaas a full labor less than a kazai's in a behemoth yes it's because it's a flavor so if so as the gemara then you should if you eat it you should also be over why is there a minimum share of a khazais by an available if somebody eats a full limb he should also be over on availa just like by sheriff's we we took it we took this passage we said just like this sharing there's no difference between uh there's a we make a hackage between tuma and akhila and the sheer becomes the same it becomes one adasha so and there shouldn't be a difference between the the sheer and just like tumor the shear is a neighbor so so too bad this year it should be a neighbor if i eat a neighbor i should be over in a veil this hackish of that parsley that you loved so much about the shaktsu there's an issue of eating a chariots you either about the shaktsu you're the third never told us to make a hackish in shiurim that by a behemoth there should be an issue to eat and ever even if it's less than a sheer prairie only said that by behemoth this is israel have a beautiful wonderful day hold on hold on