Daf Yomi Makkos Daf 7 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] me and unbelievable. We made it all the before like a few thousand views of shurim downloaded all those. So it was it was kadai to do those uh I put on at least seven pounds over the first few days stuff. Uh just want to show you a few pictures here and then we jump into the shar for all the guys especially the guys in holding down the fort. We have 81 people live right now. 81 people live to everybody to remind that is it's why you should try not to go to work not to work you should try to wear big day shabas as much as it's annoying oh I'm sitting here in front of somebody that's in his exercise clothes I got to mind. Today is two days and uh if try not to go shopping. Try not to do all that non yantive stuff. Things that you don't do on y don't do is y just with a few relaxations but just a few. remember that a bunch of people wrote to me that because of when we're learning discussed it many times he stopped going to work to shut down their business here's a guy I I don't remember who I think this is he's related to I got doing the daf 40 minutes to shabas while hosting 20 people boy said here you go I don't I don't know why it's not working. Here we go. It is working. 20 minutes before Javas or 40 minutes is Javas 20. The deaf comes first. What the Oh, birodimson got to the hotel from for Yant maybe last night. My 12-year-old had downloaded Makistaf, his MDY tablet. But when we got into the car, it wouldn't play for some reason. We got to the hotel and he really wanted to get to his room. I go check on him after a little bit and this is what I found. How you have changed my family. Thank you. I have to say that um on the middle of my son, my gave me tremendous top three nas moments of my son. got up in front of the whole hotel and made a sem on Sanhedrin. Big summ was a lot of tears were shed. I'm not I'm not going to talk about myself, but my wife was crying like a little baby. A few other people were crying. It was a very emotional thing. Uh to my son Aron, thank you for all those who supported him and put money into the into the account for him to you all. for encouraging him at the Shabbaton. We did a whole thing to get him to go and to get get him to do it and he did it every single day with the emails with everything and it was because of a bunch of people at the Shabbaton. They got together and put together a nice amount of money and now he's starting without any incentive. I've written before. I'm a 10th grader in Diabir. I was driving on Central yesterday and what a perfect day to see what I saw. I just want to thank Rebi for all that he taught me. It's unbelievable what Rebi is doing. You have a great y number one daff join mdy and their voice is sponsored by anonymous churns in honor of family memory of their uncle the whole sponsor anonymous may our learning bring us closer to one another and to hashem We have four sponsors, monthly sponsors. That's all about weekly sponsor anonymous in my first completed. I wish I know who this I wish I knew who this person is. In honor of my first complete finish, I guess. And that's unbelievable sponsor for the month. Thank you to Rebelly's wife and kids for the great sacrifice they make to the masses. Thank you of the month in honor of Yosi Klein and Marinazi for all the work they do. We are here four lines from the bottom. When we when the Torah says that you should hear you should hear from the mouth of two. So the Misha says that the Sanhedrin shouldn't hear the testimony from a translator. So I promised every I'm gonna say over one of my favorite jokes. It's not my favorite joke. I hope I so much build up this joke that it's not that funny. I love this joke. There was a Mexican guy who stole a ton of money and the sheriff caught him and the sheriff started uh torturing him and it was apparent that the uh the Mexican guy couldn't speak any English. So he brought in a translator. And uh the translator comes in and he tells the guy, "Tell the sheriff where is where do you hide the money?" So the guy said, "I'm not going to tell where I hid the money." So the sheriff pulls out a gun and says, "Listen, you tell the guy that if he doesn't tell me where the money is, I'm going to shoot him right now." So he tells the guy, the sheriff said that if you don't tell him where the money is, he's going to shoot you right now. So the guy says, "Okay, I hid it under the tree, right by the bridge, on the left side of the tree, 3 feet down under the ground." So the translator turns over to the sheriff. He says, "The man says he's not afraid to die." And the sheriff went I love the joke. The man says he's not afraid to die. Yeah. Why I like it that much, I don't know. It just is. says the says these people that spoke in other words they spoke a different language translator use a translator you can't use a translator says like me in I understand everything but to to speak is much more difficult little but nothing I can speak better than that but there's there's a level of understanding a language completely and then the level of speaking it so Rob understood everything but he needed a translator to repeat over what is saying to them. He understood them. So there wasn't a problem of they don't understand says there's two people and they were the witnesses on a loan but they were relatives of the guarantor. The loan had a mala a borrower and a lender. But a third guy was the guarantor that if the borrower doesn't pay back then the guarantor is going to step it. They were related to him. [Music] This has nothing to do with you know but just once we mention you know different things that areas want to say that since the the these two people and are not related to the main suspects over here the main characters the so it's okay no if Thea can't afford he can't pay back the loan. So of course the mal is going to go and chase after the ar the guarantor and since these guys are related to him therefore it's considered kva to the actual people in the case and therefore it's no good says the [Music] memarino somebody had a and they said okay you have uh whatever the the said this guy should die for whatever he did and he ran away. You know it just reminds me I have to say this over because very powerful there are people that sometimes when doctors give up on them and they say there's nothing to do for their for the disease. So the rabb will say this gula is this is goolah to go to go to. So it's based on this over here on this Mishna as we'll see because has special we're going to see. So just have to share this. There's a a person in the sh I'm very close to and he said I know that it's and I know you can't speak to anybody. I know you're doing shurim and I was I was busy with my three shur and I I didn't have the head for anybody. He says but I need to speak to you. I realize that it's important. So I called him up and we spoke for seven eight minutes and basically said he told me like this. He said he has yan, he has cancer and he's going through treatments and the insurance drapped him. Insurance drapped him and he tried to get new insurance and he just couldn't. It was it wasn't working out. So he told his wife, he said, "Listen, I think it's a sign from Hashem that I have to leave this world. Then I'm done. I did my did his his treatments and now it is what it is. and he says that there's a a guy from MDY that heard about this and the guy started putting a lot of pressure on him that he should let him get him insurance. He's like he's the he's very proud person. He says no I don't want to take from somebody else. He says you have to take it. I'm going to pay for it. You have to take it. And finally the other guy got him the insurance. Paid for it in full even though he has a pre-existing condition and it was very expensive. He got him insurance and he called me to tell me he says listen I know you give I know but you should know that behind the scenes there's such such and somebody went ahead and saved my life I'm here now because of that person he told me the name of the person I know the person very well as well so for letting me know this for the other who got him the insurance it was a start because I got all these messages and it's very emotional. I was emotional as this because of the but great messages from from Benny Rdnik and Mark Ashkenazi and this guy and it was very nice somebody had a the verdict was given and he ran away and he comes back to the same gave the verdict okay I'm giving myself up you don't start all over [Music] again. But if two people show up and say, "Listen, we could testify that there was a verdict in them." And these are the witnesses that could testify to that. You could kill somebody based on their testimony. says the Sanhedrin Sanhedrin of 23 Sanhedrin means 23. The bez of 23 applies also of 2. Today we don't have one because you need the real the real Sanhedrin of 71 in the mdash for this to apply. If you have there was Sanhedrin of 71 in you have 23 all over the world. There was a guy that refused to give his wife a get and he went to this best and that best and he was all over the place and I believe he went to four different finally he was in Lakewood and Lakewood they said listen go to Rabies and Carellis he kept I think it was like 15 years he wouldn't get his wife again for a very very long time so he said okay fine we'll go to Carellis he went to Carellis he told Carellis his whole story and The wife said her whole story and Carellis looked at him and said, "Listen, what you're saying is 100% true. You don't have to give her a G. You don't have to give her a G." And of course, her family that was there was furious. What do you mean you don't have to give a cat? What? She's She's already for 15 years. What now? Another 15 years. You don't have to give her a G. He says, "Listen, if you want to be a mench, you're not going to be married to her anyways and she's you don't have a marriage. Be a match." you give her a get, but you're 100% right. You don't have to what you're saying is 100% right. And uh after like two, three months, this guy gave a get and they said understood what this guy needed to hear. He needed to hear that he's right. So he said it. So he the family is all upset and everything, but at the end of the day, that's what that's what the guy needed to hear and that was the way to get him to give a get otherwise he would never give again. I hope the guy's not listening to the sh now. Now he knows that church. Okay, whatever. We said if this 23 best kills one person every seven years when there's when there's like some sort of you know bag by a bus stop and uh nobody knows what it is. You bring in the kablan a destroyer. You bring in a robot comes. I've seen it a few times where the robot actually has a gun like everybody backs up hundreds of feet and goes all the way over to the back. It's usually just some kid that forgot his knapsack by the bus stop and then he has a nice little bullet through the knapsack. You probably never give it back to him. So if you kill somebody every seven years, once every seven years, you're a terrible, you're a destroyer. We had him by once every 70 years. So the is going to say is one every 70 years bad or it's good. say also we had them in the sed if we were in the Sanhedrin we have a way that nobody would die. We asking questions that nobody can answer and therefore the are no [Music] good. What kind of is it to say oh nobody ever died. The whole point of capital punishment is to put fear into people so they shouldn't kill. If nobody's going to die in so nobody would be fearful and then people will kill. So you're actually increasing murderers [Music] says in front of that if the guy ran away and he comes back to the original you don't redo the if you come back to a different then you do break you you redo the if you go to another if show up and say this is the verdict in such and such and those two are the he dies there's a difference between and out of the a person runs away from to outside of you don't redo the den but if somebody runs away from America let's say to you redo the people run away from their problems. They run away. Depends where you run away too. If you run away from it's not going to help you. If you run run away from there's a special that they can redo your D and maybe find favor in San How do you know that the Sanhedrin applies also in everywhere? Let's see. The Torah says And that you have to see the end of the see here. I'll show you. You can see over here in all your all your dwelling places all your we we people live all over the world. So the Sanhedrin of 23 all over the world is another oops wrong one. This one means in your in your gateways in your in there is there's a difference between when you're in you put a 23 in every province and province in every city and city put in every province but you don't need a in every single city that's why the says so the said that said once in 70 what did he mean if the that kills once every years is considered a destroying perhaps that's good once every seven days normal I don't know how to say we don't [Music] know say if we were there nobody would die what would they ask the the best I'm sorry what would they ask what would the best ask the in in order to avoid killing the not the what's the word I'm looking for the perpetrator the the the [Music] accused they would ask him did you check the body afterwards to see that the the guy that died wasn't a tra because if he was a tra if something was inherently wrong with the guy that he would die within 12 months then we can't kill It's also to kill, but we don't we wouldn't give me. Did you check? Did you open him up and do an autopsy? Of course, he didn't. So, get out of here. And even if he says, "Yeah, he's he's perfect. He's not a maybe the the point where the sword went into the heart, the guy already had a pre-existing hole and the sword went right into that hole. So you couldn't tell that he was actually a tra beforehand. So me every criminal could get every get out of it. And if somebody came to testify that he saw somebody being how what kind of question would they ask that would get him off the hook? This is a lash that means like a woman's makeup has her eyelashes whatever they have like it has a brush that goes into a small canister. So this lash did you see with your own eyes? Do you see the actual mess? Obviously not. You saw something that you know whatever you saw around and around you didn't see the actual thing. They get off the hook. So there's a fascinating Tyus here. Just gives us a little insight. Look at Tyus over here. Oops. Sorry. So Tyus says that's a question. What about So he says uh five lines down You hear what says in the time of the was a lot more it was more common for a person to kill than to find somebody that was mal shabas from all the Jews people were not shabas and they weren't it's not common I just thought it's it's fascinating Okay. Says, "How could you how could you say they would get somebody off the hook when it came to and what would do? How would they make him be? How how could somebody be made that he saw when it comes to people that are not necessary to seek him they have to see something that looks like looks like but from the side whatever do but they don't have to see literally that we finish The first parag which really means that we just finished about a third of says the radic. This is the list of people and this is the things that you have to do in order to go to gullis. These are the people that go to gullus. So again a person who kills somebody by mistake in certain situations must go to a special city which the mission the parag is going to discuss. He has to leave his family, go to the special place. Otherwise, a family member the could come and kill this person even though he killed by mistake. That's how does it work. somebody that kills somebody by accident they say I don't know it's a little bit of a joke I guess that they they constantly have to go to that's their gullus why because perhaps they killed a bak yes by putting a bak down and destroying his life whatever they have to go they they told this to said that because he's a public figure he must have insulted a baker in public unnecessarily and that means that he's he killed it. It's very very sad thing for me to hear because I must have done it also when you have a microphone and you have a lot of people and you know things come out uh the filter is not the best so it's very sad very very sad have to do a lot of cha so the mission says So this is what I found. This is all right. The way it worked is let's just say this is the device right over here. Something like this. They had a roller. So says in the time of the Gumar they had flat roofs. In his time they were more like pointy roofs. They say in there's a few signs. If you want to see if a house is an Arab house or a Jewish house, usually you go by, you're not sure, hey, am I going through an Arab village? If it's flat roofs, it's Arab villages. If they have these black water tanks on the roofs, those are Arab villages usually and giant satellites and a few. So they would make the roof slightly tilted. It was flat but with a little bit of a tilt. And when this guy is pushing the roller away from him, that's a downward motion. Why? Because he's he's on the slant. He's standing over here and he's pushing it towards the bottom. He's going downwards. And then let's say it comes loose from his hand and falls down and kills somebody. That's in a downward motion. Then he's potter. Here we have a picture. So he's on a uh some sort of roller and I'm going to push this button. Okay. I don't know how many are on on total, but I see 60 people just on YouTube. 69. It's growing a minute ago. 60. Okay. I shouldn't say because it's still so heer. He was lowering a barrel down. So was on a downward motion and it fell on somebody and it killed him. He was going down on a Oh, here we can do this. Let's see what's going on here. Oops, wrong one. No. Okay, that doesn't have motion. He was lowering down some sort of uh heavy thing like a like a barrel or a bunch of bricks. This is not even good. That's not a good picture. That's exactly what happened to Rashea. Wow. That's what happened to the Rashiva Randman from originally from Chicago. That's literally what happened to his son. He was walking by and one of these pallets full of bricks hit him less than a half a year ago and he was uh in a coma for a long time. I think he's doing much better now but uh it was very very bad. Um all these three things you go to go. So Tyus says over here interesting he says that this is more like au let me just here I'll show to you over here he says why are the three cases because each one is worse than the next the guy with the roller he's gulos why wasn't he careful he's on a rooftop he should have put like different uh demarcations telling people don't go there. But even a guy that's lowering down a barrel, he's more careful. He doesn't want his barrel to break if it fell and kill somebody's. But of course, certainly when he's lowering his own body down, he's even more careful. So it's it goes in it goes in levels. the the the one that he's most careful is when a person puts himself down, comes down a ladder, he's super super careful. Nevertheless, if he kills somebody, when he comes down, he's what if he was pulling the roller to towards himself? It was in an upward motion and then it killed somebody or he lifted a barrel upwards and and the rope broke and it fell and it killed somebody um when I was about 15 16 years old. We had a suka in uh on East Fourth Street in Kensington and I was lowering down these giant pieces of wood back back in the day. It wasn't we made a suk out of plywood. It wasn't like today the thin little, you know, real, we'll call it uh the the quarter inch. What is it called? I already forgot. Half inch, quarter inch. It was thick. The kids was thick and I was lowering it down like an idiot. I didn't know. I was lowering it down with a rope. And once it came off the porch on the third floor, it fell down and it ripped my hand. It like ripped all my skit my skit. And um not the Luon stuff. No, the the the real. It was real thick stuff. It ripped my skin and it just fell down. Imagine if somebody was walking down there. The plywood thing would would kill him. Yeah, definitely plywood. All right. So now he was upwards walking up a ladder and it killed and he fell and killed somebody here like this. Let's show this one. Hold on, Mark. Let's just do this guy first. So he's on he's going up the L he's working on the ladder but there we showed already but you know so over here he's just work so the why is that not part of the mission because he wasn't going up and he wasn't going down he just fell so that's different okay oh this part is the best that has to go to Okay. Oh, I have to do sponsors. But we have to finish the mission to do sponsors. Anything that's on the downward motion, you go to and if it's not on the downward motion, you're not going. We're going to have a fascinating example coming up. How do you know it has to be on a downward motion? Oh, no. Let's do the thing here. Turning of the DA sponsored by D Global onestop shop for all your financial needs by Kovations LC in honor of our sons Ko and I wish I can meet them. Kinovations LLC in honor of Calo who's 129 for learning San with her belly in globalations true role models of how to support the and learning says it has to be it says it has to be in a downward motion amazing here in this it says somebody who killed by mistake says what does it mean come to exclude probably it doesn't like it comes to clude somebody did it on purpose now we have the Next and this is in without an awareness comes concludes somebody that did it on purpose the first one. What do I need to say? Somebody did it on purpose. He's a he's a killer. A killer dies. Doesn't go to gulos. What do you think? If somebody thinks that it's to kill what what category would you put him in? Is he Is he amazed? Is he a shik? What is he? He doesn't know. He's 25 years old. He doesn't know that it's it's ushered to kill somebody. He thought you're allowed to kill people. You say he's shouldn't he should you know they say that if you if you don't tell a cop, I didn't know you're not allowed to go through a red light. What what does the cap tell you? Ignorance of the law is the forgot the law. When you're ignorant of a law, it's just as bad as knowing the law and not listening to it. You have to know laws. Don't drive if you don't know the law. Don't be in society if you don't know. You're not allowed to kill. So, we're going to have a little you might be right according to soar. So okay tell Yoshi thank you says he thought it's he didn't know guy know you're not allowed to kill so we A new concept in chassis. Oops. Let me show put it over here. What does that mean? He's a shy, but it's very very close to being amazed. How did he not know? How does a person live in society not know you're not allowed to kill? It's also common sense. You're taking a guy's life away. You can't have children anymore. You can't have a family. D. It's a bad thing. There's also something called I just want to point it out. It's called something like a guy that's driving a car and kill somebody. He could be a car. He could be very close to being, you know, negligent and amazing. And it could be he's a complete a guy ran right in front of the car and he had no way to to see him or to stop. It could be a a guy's on his uh cell phone and he's texting and he kills somebody. It might be without awareness. This comes to exclude somebody that is is doing it intentional. If somebody's intentional, kill somebody intentionally. He had intent to kill, but he wanted to kill an animal like the vice president. What was his name again? Who shot an shot? Shot no went through this already. He shot someone with a gun, but it turned out he thought it was a deer, but it was somebody's his friend. Uh Mark will tell me soon. Uh that older guy. Okay. Um Lusi, he's trying to kill, let's say, uh ignorance of the law. Vice President Dick Cheney. That's exactly what Dick Cheney shot his friend in the face because he thought he was an animal. What was the other one? The other one was ignorance of the law where it is okay it doesn't matter he tried to kill let's say idol worshiper kusi is he would be from he kusi but he killed is leel he tried to kill a young uh like a a kid that's not going to survive but he ended up killing a kid that will survive. Ignorance of the law is no excuse. No, there's something better. The end is okay. Says in the if suddenly without any hatred he pushed him or he threw on him any kind of vessel deal without ambushing him. So let's see the pausing. Every word here tells us something. Pratt Laren's office. Imagine. Oh, I want to put that in. Okay. We had in um Babakama. Maybe you could ask Yoshi. Mark, maybe send a message to Yoshi if he's not diving yet or whatever. We had in Babakama uh somebody coming at the corner. It's not the same thing, but he was with the pole and he was with the remember the battle. Okay. So, there's a there's a corner. This guy's coming with a knife. And this guy's just walking and gets killed with a knife. So that the understand there's different ways to learn it. I'm learning that it's which is there's no way for him to know that somebody's going to come at the corner without any agent. If you kill an enemy, you can't claim after. Oh, it was a mistake. There's no mistake that you meant to kill him. He pushed the reminds me very sad. Reminds me a little bit of the Miron tragedy. People um got crushed there. So perhaps you could say over there. I'm not even going into it. People don't get upset at me. I'm just giving as an as an example. Might might be a bad example, but maybe people there killed other people with a complete with their body. They crushed other people. So we said that the only way to kill to be is if you're going downward. What if I went up in order to go down? I want to get some momentum. So I went like that. Like this. That's up in order to go down. So this upward motion, am I or not? We're going to talk a lot about it. Um they say by the way in a lot of times you do you don't do it on purpose but a lot of people they have downs and that down that is in order to come back up. A lot of people let's say are you know on drugs they have some sort of uh some sort of an addiction and they won't get out of their addiction until they hit rock bottom. You need to hit that bottom that urida in order to come back up. Mind you, I got to say, "Oh, here it is. How'd you get it so fast?" Beautiful. Let's go. Hit play. Very nice. 8 minute battle. I don't know what just happened. It's crazy. There's 80 people on YouTube. Uh, this is not the corner. Okay, but you get the idea. Fine. Different time. This is the corner one. I believe there's something coming out of the corner. Yeah, definitely. We have something in the corner above. We got to move um without ambushing. Oh, this Mark put in here for me. This is he tried to throw the ball, the bowling ball this way and by mistake it went the other way. Here we go. Okay, get the idea. That's a complete read that one now. And this which he didn't ambush. This is also part of why he tried to throw something two feet and it went four feet and killed the guy. You came and you found your friend in a forest. The sharest is for everyone to go in the damn merger and the damn both of them the the person that died and the person that killed they both had the right to go in there. A person was going up a ladder and the rung came down. So you hear the sh Listen to the questions. Give all the good question. The guy is going up. He's climbing up a ladder. So we said that in order to be of gull, you have to be going down. So he's going up, but the rung, the step that he stood on went downwards. So which one is it? Is it an upward motion or a downward motion? Let's see. Here's the corner. Uh, okay. Back in the day, Evaldi. So, here the Shiloh. He's going up the ladder, but the rung of the ladder went downwards. Is that considered a downward motion or upward motion? Is it considered upwards? Is it downwards? Upper leg. You already touched upon the question of go uh going up in order to come down. You're going up the ladder, but it's it's literally like taking going like this. You're going up because you want to go down. So you're going up the ladder in order to push the rung down. And we said for that you go to gull. We have a question. Anything that's on the downward motion, you go you go to go upward motion. What does it come to include going upwards? What does it come? Aren't we coming to to say our case? He's going up the ladder and the wrong one downwards. Okay. So, he's saying that comes to include something. So, the next statement also comes to include something. Anything that's downwards new, what is it? Everything call comes to include something. Comes to include a butcher. I bought this. I I I sent somebody to the store and I'm very grateful he bought me this. In the picture it looked like it's much wider, much bigger, but okay. It's going to do the job. There's a cat. There's a cleaver. I'm going to show you a beautiful thing that that Yoshi did. It's going to explain the whole sir beautifully. Um, a butcher that was chopping the meat. Listen to this. We have three different here. One says that if it's in front of him in back of him, the exact opposite of potter. If in front of him is but in back and the other it says in front and back what do we do it's not it's not a listen to this boy amazing I guess I'll just show you Yoshi's and here we go Check this out. It's beautiful. Here, here's the butcher. I just want to maybe I'll show it to you first. The butcher in order to get momentum, he goes downwards to start. So, this is motion number one down. He comes up, up, up, up, up. This is up. That's up. Now, it comes behind his back. That is down. This is up and down. So we have five motions here. It's it's starting point right over here. Down. Up is two. Up up up up up up up up up up up up up up up up up up up up up up until this point. Now we start going downwards. Three down four up. Five down. Okay, now we're going to see it in Yi. Here we go. down is alf the it was very fast. In other words, this alf no here I used to work in construction. If you have like a what is that a 5B hammer or 10 lb hammer, you never start over here. You always go from all the way down and then you you come back up. You start from the lowest point. So I'm saying this is a fast mo motion. But the point is he's not cutting here now. He's just trying to get momentum to do bay. Boom. Bes. That's up. That's down. This is up again. And watch this. The final thing is cutting the meat down. So now let's just now let's do it inside. It's very very simple. All the downs, how many downs are there? There are three. Three downs. This is one down, one up, second down, two up, third down. There's three downs. All the downs, you're all the ups your And that's the gumar. The gumar is answering that when it says, it means you're on a down. when he says up and you just have to it's just very simple here. So let's see here. That's one. Boom. your potter. This one is talking about that he went that way down up. Great elephant giml in this chart. You're and B and you are potter. Why? Because you're on an upward swing upward. You're potter. End the story. Yaldic worked out great. Maybe I didn't have to buy this. Let me cover this before I hurt somebody. Okay, next person was climbing ladder and the rung fell down. So perhaps the question that you asked me before about the rung of the ladder falling downwards here we see perhaps that's exactly when you go your body is going up but the step goes down is considered a your body's going upwards it's considered but when it comes to being you you cause damage let's say you're going up a ladder and a rung fell out and broke somebody's car. Of course you because when it comes to being it doesn't matter if you're sleeping if you're up if you're or you're always but we're talking about killing somebody by mistaking going to go it's only in a downwards motion or perhaps no everything's talking about when the rung is wormy we have two answers that saying the same thing when the rung is wormy so when you step on it actually goes down when you step it there's a little give a little give and then it pops. So you didn't go up, you went down. You push downward. The ma you have to go to it's considered a downward motion. You have to go to gullos. But if it's not wormy, so it's very strong and you're going upwards and then it fell then you are because it's upward motion. It's not wormying. It's very very strong in the latter. So therefore there's no give and therefore it's only upward motion. Mahadik or it wasn't the second the second Bryce is talking about where it's not very in there strong. So therefore there's a give. It's the same thing as warming. There's a give and therefore it's a downward motion and therefore goes says he he was using an axe and like let's let's do this thing right over here. He's using his axe and the and the metal flew out of the ax. Okay. So we have that's not what the is referring to. So you don't go to go. That's exactly what the PK is saying is but what does Rebi say? Rebi says the P meant to say that when he's chopping wood and a piece of wood that he's chopping flew out and killed somebody that you go to Golos. No, that's not in the posi. Does it say that the the the the um the piece of metal came out of the wood? came flying out minates. So Rebi is saying, "Look, you see from the ping, that's a piece of wood that went flying, not the metal." Here, look at this right over here. It says the word eight in the beginning of the line. It says the word eight at the end of the line. Now, what's what's he trying to do? It says he's trying to cut a tree. He's trying to cut a tree. We're not talking about here. This is let's say let's call this an axe. Okay, here's the handle and here's the metal. So he's saying look the first part of the P is saying that he's trying to chop wood. He's not talking about the wood handles. Talk about the wood that he's chopping. 99 people on Zoom on on YouTube. That's incredible. We've never seen such a high number. Unbelievable. Let's see if we get to 100. That'll be cool. Uh are you able to see that? I'm trust me it's 100 on there. People are on there if I was lying say no it's not a 99 went down to 96. People with dafa you know they go off. Uh what about the word eight in the beginning of the P and and and three words later says eight is referring to the same wood the wood of the tree that killed somebody not the wood handle or the the metal that flew off the wood handle. That's not what we're talking about. They both learned from this right over here that's on the screen. It says the word it says but it doesn't have so I could read it different ways means it costs something to go flying which is the wood that is chopping. No, you have to you have to read it the way we read it, not the way it's written. When flying, what does Rebi really say that we read it based on how it's written now? How we read it? Right? There's two ways to do it. We have a we have a word. Is it the way we read it, which is or is the way that it could be read, the way it was written? Rebi always says that we go by based on how we read it. Everybody holds schools the way you read it. Even that's why he needed two reasons. He says, look at this has the word eight over here and eight over there. Forget about the word. Let's go by the words. Have a good we'll see you tomorrow. Thank you for being here. [Music]