Daf Yomi Kesubos Daf 33 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] as you're watching this i am probably somewhere between ethiopia and johannesburg so this year is right now uh 7 15 in the morning so just this is pre-recorded so that you have this year on time and i asked thailand last time i went to switzerland it was a little rough and [Music] i got a lot of emails what's going on the shirt doesn't have the same quality caught me a little slack just a little slack we're going to try to have this your room on time but then you have to realize that sometimes it's not 100 well now we get this out of the way usually we have a lot of people that take sedum away okay so with that being said bazer hashem we're gonna try i do plan on being in the jungle in the safari where the internet is very very weak and hopefully we'll be able to upload this year in proper time but if not be mindful and be understanding we have here an email from justin ivory please consider leaving the beard on for a few extra days the lions and hasidim and i will certainly appreciate the gesture i'm so glad the hydra's bottom of mvy is back wow hope he stays around for a bit longer this time a thousand days vertifos wow he says some interesting things here about guillermo and a thousand straight knights besouros toybiz hashem safe travels thank you over here we have akiva sulkowitz i believe the island is playing baseball the secret seas in the mountains i could actually smell the mountains just by looking at these pictures of brings back unbelievable memories the baseball mound and he's wearing the mdy shirt of course and i think even the mdy cap as well boys i i forgot who this is from but he claims this might be the youngest good morning or boise of all time [Music] okay you got the laugh i hear you guys googling [Music] and here we go from your fans tell me them if you should tell me them at camp nagila midwest good morning voice like hi belly this is from yankee p thanks to you since joining your shirt from zappos mcgill i'm still keeping up with the daf i have around six block to doing obama's beautiful that's unbelievable halaway everybody can say the same thing that they're only missing six stopping obama's many many people are missing tons of definitely those and that's okay we go on i don't listen to all you sure now but i do listen to your cheerful good morning and email segment every day and i go to your share when i feel that i need your amazing charts i'll be understanding that when i'm stuck i didn't attend the semen bell works but i did watch it i was so happy to see that your son keep was at the ceo i try to have him in mind by davening i don't know his full name so i have in mind elise stefanski son akiva simcha ben fago i am writing to you now because due to the magnitude of your shear i felt the passing of the gaivet of you shall i am saying should get some mention so in fact we didn't mention i think twice once when i found out during this year i didn't but this is a good thing that he's reminding the guy that goddard battalion godel in our generation was nifter this week and she gets a mention i apologize in vance if he did mention it and i happen to have missed it yankee families like new jersey because toyota is the best pirates of hawaii number two striker k vitario 149 is supposed for my family myself so this is the game of our solo partners number three israel and family in memory of maharashtra menorah and three cousins sarah klein ricky rachel menorah on the 12th the other side didn't all have an aliyah it's very hard when i know the people right it's unbelievable and here's another one that i know very very well parents of ladies number five dr avram epstein he lives directly two apartments below me on the second i live on the fourth floor he lives on the second floor and his wife was such an unbelievable person she was that smiley bubby that everybody loved and she was nifty very very suddenly she had the macho on her tongue she went in for some treatment and before you know she had some sort of infection and it was like one day next day she was gone in memory of my precious southern belle wife mother and grandmother rita gay epstein and the parents say here we go we today is lag big subus lag and uh we're holding on the bottom of llama bay's on the base in the middle of the sugar beautiful sugars here today so just to recap a little bit we had a stira between our mishna and the mishna in marcus in our mission that says that if somebody has relations with his own sister he has to pay a fine you're fine immacuz it says he gets malcus which one is it is it a fine or malcus so oola says that the shot is our mission is talking about his sister but she's a naira and therefore there's a fine the one in mac is sister but she's a bagarish is already older than twelve and a half and therefore he gets marcus ruby ichan says no they're both the same age both mishnais the same age just as the difference whether or not they were the person was warned if he was warned you get malcus if he wasn't warned there's no hassra warning is called astra okay so now we're going to be discussing no matter who you go with whether you go with rubio or ullah everybody agrees that you don't get two punishments at least for now these two agree that you don't get two punishments you could only be punished once either malcus or a fine now according to oola you get the fine and you don't get malcus and according to your biophenol you get malcus and you don't get the fine and as you look at the top of them basically days the top line says because ullah learns exercise everybody learns it there's no argument that it's of alexander so if so he should agree to oola that you pay the fine and you don't get malcolm's says the gemara the reason why he doesn't go with ullah you always pay you'd have to pay and not get malcus he says that's a big problem why is that a problem cain bitauto is have relations with your sister the torah is telling you get punished a punishment of the torah is malcus you get whipped if you're telling me that you never get whipped you only have to pay then this whole passage doesn't really belong then what's supposed to come to tell me anytime there's such a harder thing it is so it should be malcus not paying so you're uprooting or passing in the tire i don't like that this is ruby i believe says ruby on you you have to get markets and you don't pay not like you like ullah says you pay you know says top of lemonade i really believe everybody has to learn learn this possibly i had a conversation today with a certain person who was involved in hitting other fruit people they didn't agree with them and i'm like do you know the possibility this is the risa to hit another jew is it the rise i don't know if everybody is familiar with this is that a joke lays if penny isn't here's the pasok it's a pasta about best than giving malcolm's that person give him 40 minus 1 is 39. like if you can't add even one penny because if you add one something terrible will happen it's isn't there a riser to hit somebody the peasant have permission to hit this guy because he's over navera but you just smacking another jew hitting another jew over isn't there right it's like eating hazard rafe and sometimes people aren't so careful with it [Music] also if you will pay for hitting your friend it comes out that is possible of la jose pena is bottle what's going on over there right i hear something okay aiden's another question now the famous case of eight observer you have witnesses that are testifying falsely and they say so and so these aid him now adam that came and and testified about somebody were found to be liars they were in another place completely so whatever they intended to do that's what we do to them they intended to extract money from somebody they have to pay that monetary obligation they intended to kill somebody they get killed [Music] now you're saying instead of marcus it says the possibility should hit him but instead of that we're giving him a fight so it comes out that the possum is not necessary you're tightener right sign of the deposit is not necessary because instead of b somebody being with a sister instead of getting markets he gets paid he has to pay that that means that the puzzling is is not in the right place so to all these other people that are in the right place they're not saying the right thing not a good time why ella eden says think about it adam common testify and they say that so-and-so is not a real queen he's a fake client his mother it was a divorcee that shouldn't have been married to the father and therefore he's not a kind he's a halal but those guys these liars that are saying that they're you throw you you can't what are you going to do to them you're going to tell them they're not going on them you have to punish them exactly what they want to do this guy you have to punish them but they're not quite him you can't make them not the unless if they are crime you can't make them not so what do you do in that case you give them malcus later themselves there is a case of malcus and atoms are in one case if the edem zone try to say on somebody that he's not a kayan then we give the maltese and that's what the positive is coming for so we have a good reason why the positive says malcus let's keep on going all three two we have to answer now this is also a case when somebody hits his friend he can look human how do i give malchus this to me was fascinating listen to the story you believe this if you hit somebody and it's not worth 25 cents in other words you didn't create damage that's not even 25 cents whatever proof is let's for argument let's say it's uh 25 cents somewhere around there let's say it's a dollar a dollar how's it possible so actually explains first of all you didn't appreciate his value you flicked him in the air you didn't become depreciated he didn't miss any work because right we have to think about the five things that you have to pay somebody when you hit somebody when you damage somebody repo chevy's okay so he went through two of them you didn't appreciate him he didn't miss any work he doesn't need a doctor he didn't have any tsar what about buja you flicked him in front of a hundred people bhusha he was a shaita he says rashi okay so it wasn't even damaged 25 cents in that case he gets malcus i thought it's fascinating you hear this you you hit a guy very lightly instead of giving him the 25 cents of damage we're going to give you 39 molecules that are almost as close as depth when we turn the page monitoring through the page is going to say maybe marcus is worth worse than death itself that's how that's how bad marcus is i would say if a guy flicked somebody in the ear and was only 25 cents flick him again so now you have 50 cents and you won't get malcus you know what i'm saying it's like it's unbelievable says okay so that's where i have a proto by hitting somebody so our sugiyo when he's with his own sister since he's not paying her a fine or the father of fine so he should get malcus so great you rebuild and say what's your whole time i don't want to say like because it comes out that the whole pasta the last words are unlimited based on the bass doesn't make sense it's talking about a case of giving malcus and according to ula there's no malcus there's only paying no i do have one case of malcus or it's actually a lot of cases his own sister but she's already older oh so then why doesn't rebellion say like going back to the question he should say like what that if you have a situation of either receiving lashes or paying he should pay like hula says in other words there's an actual word over there i could use it and use it for xavier shava says no i have something to do with that word and once i have something to do with that word it's not extra anymore it's not extra i don't have exercise so what does he say oh sorry you know i need for about what you pay the 50 because it's instead of what you gave her tsar the mclaughlin in other words the positive is saying you pay the fine the fine of 50 cassette which is a lot of money by the way the final 50 kasif is only for one thing it doesn't account for all the other things on the list it doesn't account for the budgets of god okay if somebody is violated she's not going to miss work she doesn't have to go to the doctor but she has a lot of embarrassment she has voices she has gum she was depreciated what about those two things does he have to pay for them yes the that's what the puzzle is coming to say you should know that the money that you're paying doesn't cover everything it doesn't count for everything it only counts for one thing eno the tsar but not for boys so okay so rebecca has a good time i need the word takas it's not extra for this what is going to say how do i how does he learn it he learns it from robert you should give the father of this girl 50 cassettes the enjoyment the benefit of this mesa is 50. you're paying for your honor it doesn't account for the for the embarrassment and the depreciation i thought it's very interesting how much does kamishian passive think about it you say how many pesos it's exactly the same amount as xuba it's one year salary so if you want to say it's fifteen hundred dollars on the low end ramasha feinstein what do we say twenty thousand i remember the no the enjoyment is worth at least fifteen hundred dollars it's unbelievable says the gemara um how do i know that let's talk about indian zombies for a second and there's also okay aiden's again two witnesses come forward and they testify saying something about somebody and they're found out to be liars the day that they're testifying about that particular day they were in a safari in south africa we have adam there was it's impossible that you saw a murder in your july so says rebel yes if they were testifying about a monetary claim and they were found false they pay and they don't get lashes they don't get maltese why for another reason not like gullah michonne de la vine he says the unbelievable it's impossible to warn and give astra to adam that are testifying falsely omar raven i'll explain to you why when exactly where they warned myself when miss ruby caro let's say i tell you i know that you're about to testify so i warn you if you're going to testify falsely you might be liable to the death penalty you might be liable to a tremendous fight says the gemara army initially you're going to say oh we forgot about it why because hasra has to be right before the act you can't give somebody a warning two days before because anybody could say oy i forgot what do you see from here very interesting that a person is believed that he forgot because it actually happens why does it happen something you're not interested in you forget about they say they're vague yourself who's so famous for knowing colletary cool about that knew everything belpe he couldn't remember his own wife's phone number he just couldn't he didn't have the capacity for it why because he didn't care if you don't care about something you forget about it it doesn't matter how big of an eloy and photographic memory you have if you don't care you don't remember so in may law they could say we don't remember so option number one is just to warn them a day before an hour before that doesn't work they don't remember mr wilbur so what as they're about to testify in best then hey by the way if you're lying you're going to die so what's going to happen what if they're not lying nobody's going to want to testify they're going to start shaking any witness that comes through the door invested they're going to walk over them and say by the way if you're lying you might die if you lie you might have to pay a hundred thousand dollars if you lie okay you know what michael clevis i don't want to testify why should i testify so what are you going to do warn them after they already testified in best thing you they can't take it back it's too late whoa it's it's an interesting thing what you're saying but i have a problem with what you're saying says what you're saying is wrong in other words he's saying that you could do astral foreign and i'll tell you how else is about when the adamson are finished testifying within a second or two of when they're finished you start saying you're as wrong now this points out the testimony will only finish after they are finished with their ass row you see they finished astro then they come and warn them ask tysons but then they can't take it back anymore because their warning takes 25 seconds it's too late their their testimony already finished 25 seconds ago they can't take it back they can't recant the answer is that slices no their warning and their testimony are attached now so now they could take it back after immediately after the warning okay venezuela i'm going to see in a second that abaya retracts what he just said masking laurava roberto i have another etho they should give the astra beforehand a day before let's say what do you say that people could claim oh i forgot okay very good unravels do hints do you remember iraqis says do it very very gentle not to scare them away in a way that they'll remember there was a sword yesterday oh there are a lot you'll see the army no this which i said that there is a way to do astral i was wrong why beautiful if you're going to tell me that need to be warned and if you don't do astra you don't warn them you don't kill them says abaya it's impossible what you're saying why because what did the aiden want to do the adam the two witnesses are liars they came to bed and said we witnessed this guy murdering this guy so they testified that this guy deserves to die did they give him a chance did they give him a warning no there's no warning it's a lie so there's no warning in the line and castro zama means we do exactly what they intended to do they intended to kill that guy without a warning so they should get killed without a warning she says abayo there is no warning there is no asteroid scratch that whole idea of asteroids and everything makes a lot of sense now so again rebel yes is trying to say that the reason why adam's women pay and they don't get marcus because there's no asteroid okay so that's blame and for right there's no asteroid behind get exactly what they wanted to do to the other veleca masculine of sound beretta of year me ask the gemara okay but what about the case of angus the one that we had before the kids we had before that they testify about a kind that is not a real kind he's a fake his mother is a divorcee or his mother is a haluza instead of doing gibbons she felt her brother most of the remo she removed the shoe and she spat the whole thing but he's possibly kuna deloitte we catch his own code miss robbie where did we learn remember look at the screen for a second where do we learn that [Music] where did we learn that a bengal when adam zoom say to a grusha to a kid that is hollow where do we learn that he gets marcus from this apostle not from the positive you just discussed your harayah is that it's cashes almost exactly on to him as he wanted as they intend to do no there's another possible for another case it's another puzzling so in that case this should be astra says there's one rule when it comes to aiden zimmerman regardless if he were testifying that is hollow regardless of testifying that this guy is hiv miso one blanket rule videos now we're talking about beating up your friend you get a fine and you don't get marcus you don't get lashes why i have a proof this is a very very interesting case think about this case to yourself and think what the law should be this is a case that happens in chicago every day five times a day unfortunately it's called the drive-by shooting so a few of the chevra in the south side of chicago they take their guns they drive by they try to shoot a certain guy and they miss and they hit a nine-year-old kid in the park happens every day are they high i don't know what the american law is i don't know but we have to ask ourselves they intended to hit this guy and kill him they missed and they killed this guy if they killed this guy they would be high of misa kill this guy what do you think so the puzzle talks about it the puzzle says and this is actually my flakers says there were people fighting and they hit they punched this woman the yachts and she lost their child they were trying to kill each other it was a fight it was a fight to the death they're trying to kill that cavanaugh to kill the civilian at the end if something happens you okay so instead of killing this guy once he does instead of killing him you try to kill that person you kill him there's a this is a deep one but maybe if you went to brisk yeshiva you'd appreciate this there was a brisket guy went to the rub and he tells the rug that guy wanted to hit me so they're also how do you know he wanted you he says because he hit me she said wait he hit you so he hit you he didn't want to hit you why are you telling me he wanted you he says because i don't have proof that he hit me but because he hit me i have proof that he wanted to hit me and i just thought about this over here he wanted this guy but he ended up hitting another guy fine a little deep but okay you can't kill another person without giving your master everything in the torah you have to warn them before so obviously yellow as everybody was astral on one thing on misa does that include also malcus the lesser thing i'm giving i'm saying if you do this you're going to get killed i'm going to kill you messing's going to kill you that also includes the lesser punish of malcus and the torah says listen to this or so again start out you're you have a soil for misa which also includes marcus and you don't get malcus you get to pay so over here i have a rayon that if you are high of malcolm you're the freshman i give you as well for me so that includes malcus and instead of malcus you pay so you see if i have two things i have maltese and i have paying you pay and you don't get malcus like hula says [Music] who said that if i give you a warning for the death penalty that also includes a much lesser irish of marcus dilma like maybe it's not true anything's only happy and if you're going to say no you're going to fight with me and say yes it does include who in the world told you and this is unbelievable who told you that death is worse or more humored than malchus so you have to ask yourself a question what would you what would you uh by the way i had an argument with my club russo what would you prefer to get lashes 39 serious lashes where you need the doctor to come in after every lash and see if you can make it to the next one etc and then you see the guy can't make it you let him go for a few weeks then he comes back if they keep on going this is serious stuff that or i don't know twenty thousand dollars what would you prefer he said it's not even a question everybody would prefer to take the the malcus i said no way so i went around the beast manager i started asking people i couldn't believe it some people said they preferred the malcus some people said they prefer the the money they prefer paying the money not getting malcus and somebody said no i prefer getting marcus not paying money unbelievable i thought it would be like a given that you just pay not each person on their on their level what they can even if they can't afford let's say they can't afford it they're not wealthy but would you take out a loan a serious loan to avoid that pain no i'd rather take the pain i don't want to pay okay says the you mario muscular muscle okay um how do i know that it's more humber to die demo marcus it needs explanation that i'm giving him oh i gotta gotta do the thingy here hold on sponsored by maisha horn in honor of zach the rock rocklin and lenny learn a cpa and yankee calling the official mda mdy msp and hori numan in honor of myself says mario duma listen to this they said no he's okay we're going to throw you into the into the fire they threw them into the kit shot and they were saved miraculously but says the gemara listen to this to give up their life they were willing however they wouldn't be able to withstand the beatings that's what the mars says giving up their life they would be willing but not taking a beating there's a very interesting shiloh if somebody tells you that they'll torture unless you do if somebody puts a gun through your head and says or i'll kill you you've got to take the bullet what if he says that torture you says this and it brings the right view of akiva there bikiva wanted to die and they were torturing him you can't imagine the torture hot combs of metal combs going through his just ripping his skin apart before he died his neshama went out with such a sewer so says tyson it's just like a bullet you have to take the torture but says tyson's if they had to take the torture [Music] of not take the torture the gemara says no they would they would do that by the zara how because we're not talking about true abuser we're talking about a what is it called um you know like in baghdad they had of saddam hussein a statue it was a statue of the king it wasn't that the desire of the king was to give him honor and even for that they were mahmed to be thrown into the kitchen age for carrot you think that they were on a lower level they're on a very high level they were willing to give up their life they felt it's not honorable to bow even to the statue not out of a desire but if they would be tortured then they would bow because it's mother only or something radio vascular abashi [Music] says see that's a beautiful question what's the touchstone what do you bring me right from canada they're being tortured they say i read it in a few places that to stay alive in the concentration camp was harder to than to die so many people wanted to die they just threw themselves on the on the bar on the on the electric fence and that was it they got rid of their to the the will to live was harder than the will tonight in other words there's so much torture there's so much pain going on that it's it's hard to live that's why it doesn't say that there's a limit to the torture they said we're going to torture you until you bow to the to the idol so maybe they didn't have to because it was unlimited but so that if you know for a fact it's only 39 whips that's it there's a limit so death is 100 worse than that how can you compare death to only 39 whips it's not like in the lager where's a million whips it's only 39. anybody remember where we just had that word in the heart we had it in the studio where the guy said i'll rent you my donkey but you can't go through an arab coyote with this water you just had it maybe a week ago or so nicolas [Music] now says asked anymore according to the mandala like we discussed before when you try to kill this man and instead you kill this woman we're talking about mamish killing and you deserve to die for that great a little bit of my mommy but according to everybody says you don't lose your life if you didn't intend to kill that person you only tend to kill somebody else they don't take your life for that then you have to pay my equilibrium so if this woman didn't die she have to pay for her baby whatever the value of the baby was if she dies you pay for the woman that's without hesro but if it was astra then you do get malcus and you don't pay so you see that you do get malcus in a case where you have the two options like shalom until now we're saying all time here's a riot that you pay you pay you don't get over here you see you should get malcolm's according to rebbe would be proud somebody beat somebody else up and he survives the beating he's able to walk on his own strength guess what the guy that beat him up is clean in other words he doesn't have to die you don't kill him as the gemara is we're trying to prove something what you gotta have a minute if somebody beat somebody up we kill him even though the other guy just got up on his own strength and walked away hello so what's shot in the puzzle we put him in jail you see there needs to have jails these lock people up vimay is kathleen lane we wait to see if his victim dies at the end so he killed the guy he killed the guy you killed him villain is but if he doesn't die shifter he didn't rapper he rapped he should pay whatever he has to pay the damages what's the case you can never kill somebody without us wrong i have to apologize to the guy that that said it's just an interview you said this hydrous pardon maybe just itchy what do you do i don't know so i guess when it grows in it's uh we have to wait another few weeks okay fine we'll try it no of course you can't kill somebody without asura without warning so it has to be that it was a warning um much like you said before word for word and for the miso for the mountains and if you have malcols and you have money you pay and you don't get markets how do you know that if i give you hassro on miso that also includes malcos like we had the top of the page the first words on top of the of almond bays who told you that death is more severe than malki's they threw themselves into the fire but they wouldn't take the torture oh there have don't you see the difference between unlimited punishment to a limit of 39 master mari we might do amazing oh now a new question as for mario how do you know that we're talking about that he did it willingly vinico mctala and therefore when deposit says vinico clean from the death penalty you're asking me it doesn't make any sense a guy beat somebody up and vinico mctallah let's go back beniko mcdowell how do you know the word vinico means he's clean and he from death dilma bashary maybe talking about over here that somebody killed somebody else by mistake he had no idea he was swinging a sword and he killed somebody vinico and his partner miguellos you were asking me how is it possible only three minutes okay how's it possible that the guy walked away you beat him up and he walked away and you hired me so no we're talking about you you it was half a minute you'd be high of to go to arie miklot here check out this apostle decrees you have to build cities for people to escape when they kill other people by mistake they should be able to escape there so that the goyle adam the relatives don't kill the killer even though he did it by mistake it said and says that then the positive bishog if somebody kills somebody with a mistake he goes to the army club now that there's no marcus uh i mean there's no asteroid vinegar okay kasia you're right i don't know very good we're going back as we started this year that there's a contradiction in the missionaries our mishnah says that somebody's with the sister pays a fine and the mishna immaculate says that he gets malcus this interesting uh story about a fine just to finish off over here and i'm not passing and i'm not saying this is a good story not a good story everybody asks the rabbi because i don't know what allah is exactly in this story and i don't want to promote this kind of behavior but i thought it was an interesting story there was a guy driving down to the mountains to the country you just saw a picture and a non-jews at the side of the street asked for he was hitchhiking so he decided to stop for him why i have no idea takes him in and then as they continue driving no he didn't get killed the middleweight he gets pulled over by a cop for speeding cop writes him a ticket a cnas usually so they keep on driving and as the the jew stops for the non-jew to get out of the car then andrew says i have a gift for you and it gives him the entire booklet of the tickets he says here's your here's your ticket you have nothing to worry about i pickpocketed the cop here it's all yours so the guy goes through it and he sees different jewish names in there so he starts calling up these people he says don't pay the ticket you don't have to pay the ticket i have your ticket it's in my hand anyways i don't know if that's okay if it's legal not legal it's probably it's probably problematic but i thought it was a cute story of a canas anyway says the gemara my sister might tell you has another answer to to resolve this this um what does it say over there oh it's times of i was reading it also m-e-s up but the t-i was outside of the screen okay i thought i messed up i probably did but you wouldn't know says anymore how many remember we have a contribution our mission says that he only pays he only he pays a five the mishnimaka says he gets malcolm's which one is it guess what rich locker says it's both it's not a contradiction he has to pay a fine and he gets marcus oh my goodness the eighth zombie men so it should be higher if a person is with his own daughter his kai miso he should also pay the fine leslie maybe i'll say this is the famous concept of comment check out the screen oh he missed it this is watching come live with your happening what's the case of color sometimes i like to ask people younger kids usually i talk to them about the daf my my favorite go-to is what does come lay with the rabbit mean okay commonly if you're having any means we had it before if a person let's say kills somebody with a knife and as he's killing him he cuts his jacket so because you are liable to the death penalty for killing a person you don't have to pay for the jacket that would be the whether or not yes i'm not going into the details let's just say that's the case or that's the allah if i'm liable for a major punishment i don't i don't get the smaller punishment so remain is going to say since this father who's with his own daughter is hive miso he gets the death penalty so he doesn't pay the small fine of 50 shekel you know 2 000 but when it comes to getting malcus lashes then he does he does okay so we have the famous case a guy that steals an ox or a sheep and he does one or two things after he steals it he checks it or he sells it so if it's an axe he pays five and if it's it's a sheep he pays four so the famous gemara why does he why does he only pay four check out his picture because when you steal a sheep you have an embarrassment you have a boucha you put it on your shoulder you carry it that carrying the tower has you it gave you a reduction in the fine you only pay four times the amount but a larger atom like like an ox you don't carry it so therefore you pay the full fine of five great so again guy steals a sheep he's a ghana at that point he has to pay double k for but if he checks the sheep he pays four times four times the amount but this all happened on the shabbos so this is a case of coming up with the revenue why on chapters if you shipped an animal so if you're high misa as you're cutting the the neck of the animal that makes you liable to death penalty so you should be potter for the four times the amount of the animal you only get one punishment not two however guess what ramirez says in the same case but he shifted it for the sake of zara so once again he's hyped me so god have sharon is called this is the axe that's doomed to die because he killed another human being or he's involved in bestiality says not only does he get the death penalty he also has to pay for five times so you see that he's not concerned there's no compliment with the rabbi name okay that's not casually occupied [Music] you shift to the animal so you're hiv who pays the four or five i do i'm the ghana i stole i pay the four or five what's the obvious question how is it possible that you shocked at an animal and i pay a fine there's no such thing as sending a messenger to do an average kamisha baku it should say bashar with the base what is it what's taha instead of the that's actually word also so one man says in order to sell something you need two parties you need a seller and a buyer so selling is done with somebody else how is it possible that a messenger could do more than the guy that sent him you hear the conscious unbelievable a messenger could do almost as much as me usually less than me but sometimes as much as me how can a messenger do even more than me i myself am not capable of shifting an animal in shabbos and being higher four times why because i get the death penalty so i can never pay the four or five but he could so how's it possible that he could do it in sky 4-5 no beautiful safari listen to this logic you live the guy that the oh the guy that stole he is higher four or five just we don't make him pay it elevation you hear what's going on here the guy that stole it he is high of the form five and he's high of miso so we tell him okay we'll only give you one out of the two but you're high in both just as a special locker that says you can only get one out of two snapchat that he's not hive at all the four or five and the messenger is high of four or five no he's high four or five just he doesn't get to pay it we continue [Music] uh okay fine raboisei have a wonderful day and a wonderful venus hashem we'll see you tomorrow straight from the safari have a great day you