Daf Yomi Horayos Daf 9 by R' Eli Stefansky

[Music] Good morning rap boy. Welcome welcome official such a everything. How's that uh golf course going for? No, >> it's the first tire golf course in the world. What is it? >> First thing we do is see him there. >> Oh, you see >> and we ask you to come believe in the summer. >> Why? Why would you? You know how it is with me. Mo sir, listen to you. Oh, I have a great idea. Listen to this official based on this email. Good morning. You pushed, we listened. Please publicize the new share location starting tomorrow, Wednesday. Additionally, for anybody who considered opening a location on a minimal budget, if you have a blank wall, Wi-Fi, and this $65 projector comes out of the box with YouTube, and it's quite impressive. He gives the Here it is the linka. Keep changing the world. Oh, this goes over here. Fine. I should have shown this park, New Head. So, officially, you could open up a location, MDY location in the golf course. So these are our English MDY set locations. We have that many. We have an RBS right here in this room. And then we have another 16 places and Baltimore. We have one in Baltimore or maybe it's about to open. These are also some of them here. The Los Angeles two in Los Angeles 134 are about to open Stat Island I showed yesterday. the kabad thing your kids are basm I know in London Stanford Hill Manchester and here if you go if you have the MDY bat on WhatsApp you type in the city and it tells you the location and everything real quick this is in Hebrew I'm just going to loosely translate this uh father of a fifth grader saw his daughter's notebook from school and he asked her why is Ellie on the run. So she said, she said with seriousness, my father is learning. See, it's hard to describe the width of the heart that I have to do say drill in memories of to my children. Now every time I start listening to shear my my one and a halfyear-old says ah it took me a while to realize it's only when I I start to he realizes after a few times that it's he's part of this uh ah good morning every time he says give them good so they won't have the bad anyway at the hands of our children the life of our children are in our hands from abd Um, thank you for the shabaton which was amazing. Can't wait to the next one. This is my boss in a some sort of bakery max pi bakery learning marot the man just to see and check this out. Good morning raisai with this guy. I don't know. But he has a few of the a few of those magnets. >> Yeah. Yeah. Good morning. It says good morning. >> I didn't send an email. I don't like bothering with I'm showing this because of what he says here. This I wasn't aware of. He says the reason why he didn't he flew in to America for the first Shabbat, but since then he's lost his job. So anyway, this is avd and that's why he said he can't come. He wishes he had a job and he would come to the shaton. So firstly, if anyone knows of a junior QA position, I'm open for recommendations. Here's his number. I left his number and everything. Go visit him in somewhere. I like somebody sent this to me. It says in the bottom over here, after all these years in MDY, I feel left out having not been traumatized in yeshiva. It says over there 13,000 views for D of Haras your favorite D my favorite cheer that put that together with B and we have two winners. >> This is the picture I showed yesterday. Just this is the location in Staten Island of Staten Island. Um >> huh. Reach out to Mark for ads. >> Yeah. Oh. Oh. Taka. Anybody in America, if you don't want your ad to look like this, this is not bad. I mean, but we could I think we could do a little nicer. We have graphic designers that work for us. You could put in we already have it done. All you need to do is put in your address. You have a beautiful thing. He'll help you with new locations with all here in Benny, but in America, reach out to Mark Ashkanazi. Also, check out this week's Ami magazine. And I think there's a whole article about Mark Ashkenazi uh to add it to the list of things that uh and the people that call him the sponsored by David Solomon dedicated in memory of anonymous [Music] father Jackales monthly anonymous from London in business weekly anonymous No better way to ask for it. TCS power in honor of the marriage of my son and my daughter and my relocating to Eden gardens in Orlando of Florida. Anonymous is from London. Daily spans is anonymous in honor of the all the words. May the family have a true family on the day of my [Music] >> again on the day of his own bar mitzvah. Maz. I think we should sing him in again. New Zealand. [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] and Leelish from grandmother Simeon Sugar and family's dear wife, mother and grandmother Beth Sugar on her first yard. Remember that Marvin and Linda Diamond [Music] 17th in honor of my Hebrew birthday together. Amen. Amen. Jacob, where is he today? >> Hi Jacob. our niece, sister-in-law Toarina Nusbacher on her wedding tonight. The is invited Yeshua Feldman. Thanks. 22 years of marriage and to join the thanks Ellie and team. What's that word over there? >> One year. >> Oh, one year. Who was here? Who >> Oh, that is here. Yeah, you told me. Nope. You were at the Shabaton. >> That's right. The whole was >> the whole >> that right the whole row was B Shafness was there. Donnie and Rabitz who told me he's not coming and he surprised me. >> David, you don't have to look down. It's okay. I got it. I got it. I got you. >> No, no email necessary. >> Wow. Jersey Shore 89 in honor of HSF 217. Thank you for shabas. You should be benched. >> What's HSF? What? What? Where is that? >> No, no, no. >> Jersey Shore 89. Hatah of South Florida. I don't know. Anonymous. A little girl having a complicated brain surgery today. start of the month monthly. He's back. He was in the hospital yesterday. I don't know what his situation is now. easier stuff today. And then we have and then the is over and then we go to shorter much shorter. Don't forget to bring your friends and family to so let me show you the three things. When we say that when we say that it means the carbon of is this person is wealthy he brings a sheep. It's a certain carbon. It has a scale. Depends how wealthy you are. If you have a lot of money you bring a sheep. If you have if you're medium you bring a bird. Two birds. If you're very very poor get away with a little bit of flour. Fine flour. That's here are some things that you bring a carbon. If you look closely, it's our famous aid from the imu from the he has a binoculars. So he he puts something in his mouth. In other words, he saw he saw something he could testify for, but he doesn't want to testify. He swears that he he has nothing to testify for. means that he he swore about something that happened in the past or the future. Basically, he didn't know there's a carbon over there and migd is what we discussed yesterday. You can't go into the mdash but let's say you were in the mdash you have to leave right away. If you tell me before you can't go in the bezdon does not bring a carbon when it comes to on these issues if they pin wrongly the the whole par is if bezdon issued a false so they gave a bad about these three things they said you don't have to leave the mdash you don't have to bring this carbon whatever it is mdash when it comes to the to the king he also doesn't bring holds that the sp from all three this this has a lot of logic we could remember think about it when Trump had all his issues in America all the legal issues. The moment he became president or even before that, everything got wiped away. That's it. He's not going to sit there in court and testify. It's not becoming of a of a president of a nussi. This country is slightly different. Maybe an hour or before an attack on Qatar as the attack is sitting in court doesn't make a lot of sense. The Tyra is more logical than that. And the Nazi king does not testify in court. Imagine he's in his his fancy little thing and he witnessed an accident. So that night has to go to court and start testifying. He saw an accident didn't see an he's above that >> because the story of the car. >> Oh, >> very good. >> What an >> wrong on the bottom and on the top. But you're close. Close enough. I also do that all the time when people ask me the D. I'm off by one. >> I know. No, that's what I said. I said this. That's what I just said. >> What could be off by once? >> Yeah. >> You test someone else on the bottom. You turn the page on the top. Very nice. >> New What's the story? What's the story with this? >> It was for his brother-in-law that he was made on him and then after that he was going out later for they brought false adim and trying to whole story. >> Wrong story. Wrong story. But okay. I play wrong story. refused to go again. >> Shim, who was it? >> Shimetta brought in Yanai to testify and nobody wanted to testify. They were like scared. They're looking away. So he he said, "Whoever should take care of you guys cuz you looked away at the king." So Gabriel came and whacked them and and they died. So me they said, "Listen, you can't bring a king into court. >> You could have beat your president. Could be a legal issue." >> Okay. I'm just saying the idea the idea of him testifying sitting there like like a commoner and and testifying from the very doesn't work. So says the [Music] yeah we said this he doesn't he's not judged and you don't judge him. What's the reason of why does say that the is from everything? Because it says in the P. Let me show you. This is Galdic. I had such a I was able to fit the whole parish. Hold on. Oh, it's wrong one. This one. Check this out. The says if a person was a witness and he doesn't want to testify or I couldn't fit in the key or he was that's so now we have the three things that we just showed right these are the three whats then it says that's the we're talking about right now one of these three He should either bring a sheep or if he can't afford it. That's the entire paras. These are the three things that you bring for and it mentions smack in the middle one of these three. So how would you learn it? One of these three. What is one of these three? Is learning it? You have to be eligible for one of these three. for all three not just one of these three you have to be if I could ask you could you bring for for you have to say yes if you can't say yes on dal then you're not you you don't you're not in the parish for alf a king is not eligible for alf vu he can't be part of he can't be you he can't bring him to court so since he can't be part of the court so even he's not part of the tomah and But he's not part of the >> relevant. >> What? >> Each one of them have to be relevant. >> All three have to be relevant. All three have to be relevant. Now, if you and I were to be this, what would we say? >> One out of the three. So let's see if like a king who can't do one of the three he can't testify. Therefore, he's not in the whole par of asking. Wait a minute. Maybe you should dish in it simply means one out of the three and a king it's two out of the three. It's perfect. You're right. It's a bomb. It's not such a great deal. It was like a nice try. It was like maybe that's what he meant. No. top of here. Look at on the bottom. What does it say? If he can't afford Yeah. If you are you can't afford a sheep, so you bring two two birds. What's the next vimas and sass? And if you cannot afford the birds that is super super duper poor that's called dali can't even afford a bird a pigeon you bring the flower oh so says you have to be in a situation where you can't afford a king and a kud are never in that situation they could always afford. Have you ever heard of a poor king? There is no such thing. A king is a king. A king always has money. If he doesn't have money, takes the money from people. Also says the he always has money. So this whole parish is not relevant to him. You have to be in a situation you're a human being who could be poor, could be wealthy. Boanos is a guy in Lakewood who was very wealthy. Gave a lot a lot of money to BMG and he lost everything. It happens. Happens. And uh the was debating whether or not they should invite him to the dinner. They didn't want to like hurt his feelings. He's going to be there at the dinner. Everybody's giving giving and he can't give. But they brought him and he asked to speak and he got up there and he said that today I don't have any money. Don't have any money. But one thing I have I have all the that I gave money in the past that that stays today what I have I have zero but at least I gave in the past and that that that's my that's what I'm proud of. You have to be in a situation that you could come to the you could be you can be poor. So they can never be poor. He did one of the only one the only one above him is he's the top king is the top he's greater than his brothers. What does that mean? He's more beautiful than everybody else. Who is the famous kind that was very good-looking? >> Maybe Cole. Who said you guys were saying it? How do we know? >> Cuz his daughter took his face off. >> Yeah. Sorry. Why? How do we know that he's good-looking? >> She took his face off. >> But we had inar if you remember >> the story. What was the story? >> His two kids. They took his two kids. >> Huh? >> That's right. The parade. Very good. Also, >> the circumstantial riot from his two kids. >> Yeah. They took him to gull and the two >> the two kids they put them in the same room. >> Yeah. Because they're both beautiful and >> that was it. That was the father. >> Ah the two of that those are the two kids that they both thought there two and they put them in a room and they both cried and they died. >> My father. >> Yeah. My father. You're right. So anyway, you know the des says that there was a parade every 70 years and they would show like Jacob the difference between Jacob and as of the Roman and they they would use his face they had his face preserved. So has to be also in strength also has to be greater than everybody like like taller than everybody. You know, I have to tell you, it's it made such an impression on me. They have to say this about going from Tanos. I don't know. I don't know his bank account, but I I had this to visit him once in a while. I have to say it over. Rauri told me told me the whole story, so I have to say it over. He said that I'm not I don't know if maybe he was exaggerating. He said he had the nicest house in there underwater. He was the biggest actor here. He had a lot of money and he had the nicest house. And when I went to visit him, he was living in a man means no windows and it means a inlim in an older building. You can imagine in Roma wasn't a that like the size of this room. It was a that every person in the building gets a little storage to put your suka in. That's what he lived in. You're talking about 8 ft by 8t or something like something crazy tiny. You also saw it. I asked him how he moved from that house on Yaf. >> Yeah. On that's what he said. >> I'm preparing for my next house. >> To me it made such a guy willing to sacrif and the sink is outside of the bathroom. Little sink. Crazy. And the bed is over there but they put a curtain. Not normal. Okay. Anyway, going from Ashirus, you have to be able to go to that. He chose it on his own. I mean, this is the life he wanted to live, but it's amazing. Anyway, I think also I don't even know if he he paid them not to show his movies like he tried to buy off the rights throughout his didn't work. Okay. [Music] Oh, so anyway, first of all, he has to be wealthier than everybody. It says here he has to be wealthy. Let's say the kind doesn't have you do one of these should stand there in front of what's the name of that over there. [Laughter] There's certain guys in England that were not happy with your video. They sent me a it's your fault. >> All emails about that video we showed before is to him. I'm not sure how happy they'll be about this that you know Kol collecting. He was dancing with Kol. I don't know. Especially now with Elli Stfansky. Maybe that was the problem. Then he put I don't know. >> No, there were a bunch of people had a sensitivity to it. So I didn't show it again. We have to cut that out and show it. Loved it. >> If you chop a lot of wood, you get a few splinters. >> Oh, you chop a lot of wood, you get a few splinters. >> How do you know that? His brothers have to support him. A lot of a lot of people want to bring a ride from this gimmar that you have to support Tyra and then they have it's so interesting thing it says you're not according to some you're not allowed to take money for learning. So they say is if you're a learner and you take money that's okay but if you don't have money and you want to get a job as a learner because to support you that that's not okay. Okay, they make enough like that. You should give him money if he doesn't have money this this of because he'll always have money regardless. Even if he loses his money, we'll give him money. A king who has saras. Okay, let me show you real quickly. Ni means a king. Check this out. >> Here's the nosi. Has a little taras going on over there. >> Is yamaka still unbelievable? >> What's the point? You can't be a king. You can't be a ni when you have sass. In fact, had harass for six months. It's not even counted part of his middle of his so it's not even counted. So the question is like this if a king has did we give him do we push off this from him forever. So even if he has he still potter or perhaps it was a while he's a king that he doesn't have to bring oil but for the moment that that he can't that he's not a king then he does have to bring oil what about today there's no sass no saras is a disease there's no sas so what happens when a person talks or whatever it is says what co is for us. >> Isolation. >> Ah, >> but that was wasn't that for the whole world. >> It wasn't for >> people get it all the time. >> Oh, they get they have to go into they don't go into they you see them even the because you know maybe he'll save them. So a person loses his money says person has money issues when he when he when he deserves um him where's he where's he paying for this carbon from he's paying it from his own pocket. So if he's if he's paying from his own pocket and doesn't become poor then the whole is not applicable to him forever [Music] the says is potter from all these where is it potter from this kangal is not doesn't doesn't bring a carbon for this. But Rashi says and he brings he brings the gumar that when and you can put this in with your pencil. When Raaka says right over here potter, he doesn't mean he means potter from a regular carbon but he has to bring a a bull. Agrees he has to bring a bowl. Why is he potter? Here's the It's interesting. It needs a little bit of shot. How do you read this? Anybody want to take a jab at this? What does it say? This is the carbon. What's it seems like? Okay. And then it says, what's mean? >> Every day. >> Every day. But it says >> starts that day. >> So the is every single that gets anointed. Every brings what do you call it? Ale that it's called. But the himself brings this every single day. Sorry. A regular brings a every time. What? >> Exactly. How do you know that name? Yeah. Brings it every single day. It's it's a carbon every day. So he makes a deal. The only time a or should bring flour is for this carbon not for you here. >> Z is the over here. This is the one time or every day for so is every day but only for this only for this thing not for that's it. This is the only one he has to bring. He's not in the par of and therefore all these three things do not apply to >> what you said. >> I hear I hear good he's asking then all should be >> no but it says all the all the all the says >> good now on we know you got to look said it was a good kasha I didn't make fun of it for bringing it up again That's the This is This is a beautiful deal over here. Yeah, you're right. The shouldn't bring so that's the the the car for the very very poor. The never said maybe the should bring the other two carbonas. So what's the answer to that? The same idea that we had before. If he doesn't if he's if if he can't do all three, he doesn't do any. You need the full parish. If you could do all three, then you do if you could do one out of the three. In other words, even then, then you can do all three. There's no such thing as a guy doing oh to me only two out of the three apply. The third one doesn't apply. Since the can't do the flowers, he can't do all three. He can't do you can't bring a sheep either. Oh, before we had the same kind of deal here, just to remind it says, so maybe you have to be in the parish of all three. What about a king? The said that ai since he can't testify. So that particular one of testifying is is something that a king doesn't do. But the other two the tum and the that a king does have to bring a carbon. Ah it says should say if you if it all three apply to him then yes. If not all three don't apply to him. Here these are the two right one says and now we're talking about is different from means you have to have all three doesn't mean why is different than not because it's different because in the in Here I just put it together. Says what is that talking about? Which one of the three do you do? >> The flower and it says by the flower and givea. Why does all the way at the end of the par? Do you have to be eligible for all three? It should say it in the beginning of the para or in the middle of the parish. The answer is it just applies to that. Then in other words to tell me to make this deal because if you would say that he should bring a sheep and a bird but not the flower and the word should be in the beginning of the par in the middle. Why at the end of the B to tell you that if you can't even bring if the silus is not something you could bring because why can't you bring a cuz you bring it as a you never bring it as something else doesn't apply to the just because of the location of the word okay says the Mishna is if I were to ask you what does a regular human being bring as a carbon if he makes a he does a heav is by mistake what does Does he bring? >> What is a kos? What kind of carbon >> ais? What do you call it? The sheep. >> Sheep. >> What is a god? Forget the go. What was >> power? Very good. Power. >> Huh? >> Regular doesn't bring anything. >> Regular does not. But the I'm just trying to see if anybody remembers basic because we now we can get through half the without the other half is a different story. In other words, when you have to bring what does bring here there's a joke in here. I don't know if you can notice it. How about this guy? Anybody buy the shabaton? That's Yeah, that was Etan G walking around in his red frock during >> Shabas. >> He asked some singer. He told me afterwards he asked the singer >> some No. Oh, a guy from that show from the Howit show. He asked him, "Could I have your your uh your coat?" A couple years later, he sent it to him in the mail. She says, I got to wear it on chabas. She's wearing it in chabas. Anyway, moving. At least you enjoyed it. >> Aid brings here. Check this out. A if he does a kifsa or a female, what is the maybe? Sorry. And a king brings a male goat. Here we go. When it comes to the next one, let's see. Oh, the are all one. They bring a female goat. Where am I? and the bring a bull and a male goat. All you love is if a person is not sure if you did a you should bring it's like it hangs dependent if you did a or not. An individual and a king should bring one as we learned. When do you bring? Anybody remember you bring what else? That's a different one. That's different. But yeah, you definitely have to bring this. We're going into toim. We should know the stuff. We'll learn the stuff. When it comes to the three of them, they don't bring if they made what should be the headline again. What kind of car are we talking about? doesn't bring this is according to we're going to have to see holds. Let's see where here one thing he doesn't have to for we learned doesn't have to bring what does bring um the there's a rashy here. Here I put it over here. No, not this one. There's a rash that makes a um here this one. No, not not this one. This this one. Basically, I'll just show you in a in a in a thing real quickly. >> According to doesn't bring for he's a king. He doesn't testifies. He doesn't bring for that. The doesn't bring any of these and brings of course for all three. Brings all three. There's no question that. But he says the nih doesn't bring any anything and that's what we just learned says a king doesn't bring for the uh what do you call it the the tumdash and also the the doesn't bring for mikdash now I'm going to ask my friend from Los Angeles if you could repeat the whole mission about >> northern could you repeat the whole >> I don't think So this time >> I didn't think so either. I can't. Nobody can. Don't worry about it. I just just kidding. Wait, did you see this? Uh, we made it into a short actually. What's your name? >> From California. >> Oo, you're new. Yeah. >> Did you understand this whole thing of put you on the spot? You understand? You were able to repeat it if I asked you to. >> You want to try? two brothers and then one of them one of them had a daughter and the uncle got married to his niece and the uncle also got married to like a different girl and then he died and then his brother can't marry either of their lives. >> Unbelievable. Unbelievable goes on. We don't have to see it now. Basically we're repeating now when an individual brings the king also does but in that case the don't have to bring when you have to bring when do you bring maybe okay Then the king and miach are similar. Oh, I'm supposed to say >> somebody came over to me on chabas and he gave me a kitt and he >> Yeah. Well, it wasn't on chabas g with cash. He says like I he did it last year also. So I know already said no you can't take you can't give it back it's an insult. So he said he wants he asked that should say that he gave a why >> that they should also give but the doesn't give >> oh keep the out of it just send in the pigeon you >> for charity. Yeah, the boys were starting was starting. You know how is going to be >> killer? You're an animal. >> Now I'm going to go back and forth. >> You're beast. >> You're a beast. All right. >> It's part for the course. Oh, just the goat. [Applause] >> Now you're the goat. >> I can't I can't I don't know what to do here. 6 minutes left. Anybody else have a pun? He's part for the course. He's a beast. Says he's the goat. He's the goat in puns. Mate didn't get any of it. So he says you're listening you're going to over this whole in a second the three nod but a king and a but there are exceptions we know this is easy to remember that a king doesn't have to testify in court and therefore he's not on that doesn't have the thing which is a little problem in terms of what they discuss it anything that a king a king has to bring is going to make the So let's go to here. We're talking about here. So what do we have? G has to bring all three. When it comes to the he doesn't have to bring for its king, he doesn't bring form. So asking like this you see on the bottom what's missing on the bottom by the tuma. Well, yeah. So, and that's why it says by the two but what about the it says the last words that we read in this it says any any person that has to bring but completely under in the center should be zero not those two says the testing we have a contradiction are is two or zero when is it going in these two when we're referring to the birds when we're talking about the soil then these parts are completely Like we saw before he also in one thing but not in everything that we had a whole that does not bring is only for what for his carbon every morning but not for and once said once he doesn't bring flowers he doesn't bring all three that argues with I agree with you he doesn't bring flour but The other two he does bring about Dallas. You should know you have one of the most coveted jobs wherever I go. I go like if I go to Utah let's say I get to pay the guy he's waiting there like sponsors like they're all waiting. They're waiting and you they're jealous of you. You get to say it every day sponsor sponsor sponsor. >> Yes. Turning of the daff global specialist international financial services anonymous anonymous in gratitude rebellion and mdy for promoting van >> what's your first named where do you live now where do you live in the cat schools >> in the cat schools and now you just came for sukus >> you and your brother who else is a guest there do we have any other guests I saw some uh >> the left >> on the left. There's a There's a very quiet guy all the way in the back. You want to see your name? What's your name? The guy with the glasses. Oh, they all three have glasses. The guy that doesn't have hair. One of the Ballman brothers. What's your name? What are you doing over there? Okay. Very. It's a much better seat for him over there. Let's keep it like this. Oh, but you can switch switch with him. You come over here. Okay. Doesn't bring a carbon for easy stuff. Now, it says that this soul is going to be is going to have to be someone that brings a carbon like everybody else. He's not a He's not a a special kind of person doesn't have the same carbon as everybody else is coming up soon. He brings a par and the whole is two goats. He's differenti has a different type of carbon. The king brings a like everybody else is different than everybody else. So me when it comes to tuma he's different than everybody else similar to what Simon asked before also forget the allam have a differentap through the bull of the say they could use the par here I have a I have a riddle not for simon riddle when is it that isapper with the parhelm of the we just said that all use the power of the we had a whole that gets his own power when he makes a get his own when does he get the kapor of the bezdon >> when he follows the cloud >> a little close but not really a little bit more than that >> anybody >> what about our friend from Los Angeles what the answer is when he himself self paskins and the peasant also pass the same exact as him. So says the sh that's the case because if you just read it simply it doesn't make sense. We had a whole perk of a Mashiach our peric that we're learning now, right? We're not even done with it. The the god though brings his own par his own thing. He's not he's not discover but in a case where he passing is exactly like the ther and then he makes the mistake and he does it then he has to bring a par he's with the par of the why again what's the question why is from a carbon when he has the person that brings a carbon a person that's potter is because he's not part of the tur meaning the tur is the individual. We're not looking at the whole tab because that we had a problem. Kahal is this k is that kahan. Now we're talking about individuals that that make up the turb is made out of millions of individuals. Each individual in that when he does something by mistake he has to bring whatever when he's by mistake what carbon does he bring? >> Zero. That's why he's different than everybody else. And that's why when it comes to he doesn't bring a carbon at all. says, "When says that a king brings a male goat, he's only talking about one out of the three cases." We have three cases right here. There's a very big difference between these three things. One of them is super super different than all three. I'll give you a hint. One of them gets carus. The other two don't. Which one gets carus? Says when says that a king must bring a goat, he's only talking about one out of the three. And that is the one that has the most severe punishment of carus. And that makes a lot of sense. oil since it's not a typical it's like a regular carbon of chorus a typical chorus you bring a carbon so over here even though it's but since there's a in the back in the background there's a chorus therefore says the would bring a goat but I have a riot for it says maybe I should say about He's saying because if it's true again if meant that the the king should bring a carbon for all three in other words even things that don't have carus so then why doesn't he say that's same for say if he should bring a a bull whatever it is for the other two you're right he doesn't have too much should bring for the other two the answer is the whole carbon is only for something that has carus and since a god doesn't have carus at All he doesn't have too much. So, and the other two don't have carus. Therefore, he didn't mention a there is no carbon for if the if the carbon would be for anything even for things that don't have carus, then he should mention a as well. on all three. this goat of the king and the bull of the are instead of individual a typical individual maybe you're right there is nothing for a on number three for two miglish but on one and two there is there should be a carbon because there it's instead of the carbon of an individual and you should bring a bowl for that element since never mentioned of obviously he's talking about only something that that has a curse to it and the other two don't have curs therefore he's not he didn't mention the who told you said that a king has to bring a carbon on all three and the I you bring me a ride from how come he didn't mention the reason he didn't mention Cuz all three are potter. All three is potter. That's that's what I mentioned the said potter but you didn't understand. He didn't say completely. He's a bull and that's what we're talking about. He should bring a bull over here. So since so what what happened there? Since says you are in a bowl and didn't mention at all the is because only saying something that a carbon and mdash which is bring a carbon but only on the other two and they don't have cars therefore there's no carbon and everything fits it I don't have to bring any more proof we'll just finish the par says says maybe doesn't bring an asham says >> I don't have a pencil I'll write it in >> maybe yeah >> sh maybe I don't write with a pen but over here I have to write it so I don't forget you don't So the Tana said in front of when do you bring a mad if you don't know you don't know if he stepped in the mouse go that's what I said before because it's That's when the the the the king brings a goat says maybe you're right. It goes according to but says says doesn't bring why you say he brings have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a share today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmd.com.