Daf Yomi Horayos Daf 4 by R' Eli Stefansky

[Music] Good morning rap boys. >> We have a tremendous of having with us here in the room in one time the people that do the most for MDY. One of them is actually missing. Avi Kamyansski. Where is he? >> He's there already. He's there. >> Ah, he's there. That's right. We have with us our CEO, Yosi Klene. We have with us Mark Ashkenazi. These are people that have jobs, full-time jobs, run companies. We have with us Benny Rdnik, another person. The three of them, Ta, and we have Nom Fix and I was going to say Aiki Kamyansky. These are people that have full-time jobs. run companies every one of them but somehow find eight to nine hours a day I'm not and I'm not exaggerating last night I had the skills of having Yasi and Mark in my house they slept by me I thought they came to sleep by me I can tell you that at 2:00 in the morning they were both both of them on their phones and still going and at 5 something I heard Mark waking up Yosi 5:15 T is 520. >> No, you have a a talent. You're a talented individual. Wow. Let's do that again. I have to do Khazar now. I love when somebody comes in and just chops the legs right out. >> No, not jet leg. They do this on a daily basis. Mamesh, daily basis. But I saw it with my own eyes. non-stop phone call this and that. 1:30 in the morning is busy. How come the charts are not on the QR code? When you do the QR code and we got to get that on immediately at 1:30 in the morning, go to sleep. Go to sleep. And the same with Benny, the same with they're here every day. No, and doing and doing without getting paid a dime. The was gonna pay them millions of times overemi this this shabas this shab is a big shabas here in we took over the kar hotel and basm that's our first time basm next year it's going to be a 500 room hotel the amount of people 200 on the waiting list but that's what we had and we apologize to all the people that couldn't come anonymous the sponsors who's in the room with us today gives me a lot of when he comes sponsored by Global Anonymous for all our kids this year in just a short clip. Oh, by the way, it's in Hebrew, most of it. No vaccines. [Music] Oh, you know what? Because I'm in a rush, we got to go right there. So, I'm going to stop it right there. I'm 82 years old. Thanks to you, to your urging rebell again. Rais, listen to this. I am 82 years old. Thanks to your urging rebell, I have completed my first >> I can't believe that I learned 76. I'm looking forward to completing my second with you Sima Marchand Toronto Ontario Canada. Unbelievable. >> Here's a kid from Torah. I don't see my screen. It just went off. >> Uh in they I I believe they put Yeah. No, the screen is up and going in. Here he is doing something else. Beautiful. The nakshim the there are a few places right now that are in the works regularly normally I spoke to rasha very very famous yeshiva two days ago about that Boston the Boston this I don't know if I have maybe one day I'll show you uh the guy on the left kagan very of a guy and uh they sent me a clip of his speech at the very emotional to me so Matz, I hope to see you here in Arj one of these days. Three, the grandfather, the father on the right, and the grandson on the left. All three were mim. Beautiful scene. Williamsburg say check this out. This is in Williamsburg every Thursday night get together to watch the shir. And this I don't know if I showed yesterday in B park mat. Did I show it? Great. Um, this is Maz. It always touches me when young children, 9-year-old and a 14-year-old, do a seam and the mother made them a special MDY cake. Dear magir, I hope you don't mind me writing anonymously, but I felt it's important to share a heartfelt thank you. My husband who's from community listens to every day has become a true source of him. The way you're bringing the daff to life with clarity, depth, and warmth that makes learning not only accessible but truly enjoyable. He looks forward to it each and every day. began doing the D consistently starting himself as Buba Matia and now with Shaya has started himself as this has been a meaningful journey for him and Yashir has played a a major role in making that possible. This shop is the 13th of will be celebrating his 50th birthday. Beautiful milestone as his family we're full of pride and gratitude for his commitment to lira and for the genuine joy and he draws from it. Thanks in large part to your shir would like to take this opportunity to wish him a heartfelt maz and y o filled with continued and to you. Thanks again for your dedication for the you bring not only to the but to their entire families with warm appreciation a grateful family member. Thank you so much. Maz I chose that email out of I want to say over 100 emails >> guys like I said I'm not going to be able to read a lot of emails during this sponsor David Salomon dedicated memory of sponsor anonymous my father sponsors anonymous from London anonymous before Ben Rifka. No better way to ask for item. By the way, I forgot to say Mazov to the birthday boy 15 years old. Mazov monthly sponsors TCS Israel power of talking save anonymous for sorry about Moto and Shir Bats. Aaron Kesler in honor of the marriage of my son and my daughter and my relocating to Eden Gardens in Orlando, Florida. Weekly sponsors anonymous as for continued success in paro and to be able to support to and those in need daily sponsors family new garden in honor of the birthday of B37 at remember those days every day was another >> B is barbak Lovitz and fourth gang families happy anniversary Zisha >> where's he was here >> zisha was here he sat on the left side >> ah I was at the >> and he at his wore mdy sock which fits into today's as you shall see anonymous I just that now mother of >> daily sponsors anonymous basifo my daughter who's having surgery today cohen leishmas shim bino mali cats in memory of our beloved rebby principal Rabbi David landsman on his 10th yard site. That's you. All right. My uncle, thank you for creating the most sought after he is. It is it's beautiful the art monthly. This is our plumber in-house plumber. He it's his idea. He put in He put in the first money to do it. It was his push everything. The Gamarra right here. It's unbelievable. The Shabbat, the the charity, everything him >> I want you to remember that name if you're coming to the Shabbat. I have a great story that I spoke to him last night last night. They were there witnesses. All right. I have a question for the we're talking about making a mistake. They tell the to do certain thing. They made a mistake in what if they make a mistake in a mafurish of one of the misses in the is that also part of what we're talking about we spoke about the whole time that's in the no so again question if they said if they made a mistake in the is it best do they bring a par you say no so it's a different why people know it's >> you don't know. >> Why shouldn't people know if it's a pos? It's a certain people don't know. Certain people do know. >> Okay. The best Sanhedrin they speak 70 languages. They they I think they know the T like they should know the >> the audience know that it's >> No, not the audience. I'm saying even them them. I'm talking about the best themselves. Their mistake. We're going to see in the Gimar that know we see actually in the Mishna. So let's see the Mishna Bdon realizes they made a mistake. They make a retraction. They go they put in the papers. They put signs all over. We made a mistake. The that we said is actually it doesn't matter if they follow through bringing the car or not. They already retracted what they did. PM we're holding the mission of Gim Bay. Yeah. And this guy for whatever reason he didn't hear what happened. Yeah. You didn't hear >> about the retraction. >> I was just last nighting I said something about the Houthies and Bennett Rdnik. You think you know he's like what about the I said you know the 10 of them were wiped out the the head. They didn't hear like he's off social media. He's busy with the with the You don't know. Some people don't know. You just don't know. >> You got to know these things, huh? >> Dave is stuck in the booth already. Two years. It's like up there in the thing. >> You got to know what's going on. Who's >> this guy? >> Social media. >> Reban Pointer. Who? >> Bennett. >> Reban Pointer. >> This guy didn't hear that. Bezen retracted. Reban says he's potter. Why? First of all, there's a retraction. There's a retraction. So now the guy did a he's not he's not part of the carbon of Helm. He's after the Helm. Bez made a mistake. They they they they said that a certain that this is all the Jews that ate the part of the carbon that they're going to bring. But now they have a retraction. Now there's it's a new thing. He's not part of the But what about the fact that he he was shing? No, he was he relied on the best. He relied on a so no carbon saf but touching kachum. What do you do when you don't know if you did an a or not? Here we go. This is asham tali. It's a hung means to be hung. Yeah. Like it's you don't know. You wait to see what what the story is. So say you bring what's a safing out in he's all over the place. He just doesn't know that the Houthies died. That's his problem. He's not he's not on top of the news. That's that's not a that's not a But you went to another but if you're out of the country with no cell service garnish you're on your own in some jungle that's that's a situation listen when you left you knew that this is after you left bezen went and retracted how are you going to know about it so that I understand your potter he says that case that he went to he went to in those days they didn't have communication what are they going to You could ask a question. So, what about nowadays when everybody's supposed to know it's flying? You have wherever you are, you middle of the safari, you're you get all upset that it's not coming in quick enough. You know, like so, yeah, you're much closer to the says this is a how's he going to know? And this is remarkable. Listen to these words. No, I don't understand. The guy that goes to the jungle in Peru, why is any different than a guy that's sitting in his house in Bish? Oh, so that's the answer. But what's the question? >> He says, I don't understand the difference. I don't understand the difference. If you're in the house and you don't know who you have, she didn't get married to >> Yeah. >> to completely here completely. >> You mean in his mind >> get married and got the worst, right? But I get it. But when even when you're like that, you have to understand how other people operate. You have to >> Yeah. But is better explains what it is. It's not not as simple as you think. These words >> you're still doing it because that's >> Yeah. Okay. >> So that's the reason why it's the same thing as being in the middle of a jungle. >> Okay. Answers, what's the connection? The guy at home he could have heard you could hear you can know they say about the stipler I heard about a fugal that they would read just like the the headlines so they could be in this world like to know a little bit what's going on when people talk to them or just the pas and certain things you need to know something is sakana not a sakana is it a Iran shooting missiles not like I don't know a little bit just the headline something if you're sitting in at home great if you're not you're you're in the jungle nobody Sorry. If you're in the jungle, there's no way to hear. Okay. Now goes say that this gone. We no it doesn't exist. For instance, ain't there's no concept of that's not that's against you don't bring a par for that. Ain't shabas. No in 2025. No shabas anymore. You don't bring a parallel for that. There's no potter from you don't bring a parallel in that case. So what if they said part of the mitzvah like in our case of not is but that that part above the the kidney is mut the rest of the animal I'm asking the says it's they're not trying to uproot the entire a part of the a salant because it's salant says two interesting is that I think are important are over if you in case you don't remember them. He said number one that a built out of pieces. So he says that if a person accepts upon himself not to do an a on chabas on chabas I won't do this this and this I won't talk on chabas this is a tremendous thing it's not all or nothing takes that very seriously and it really helps for that a person does something like that a person says to himself I won't speak an hour a day it's not that oh the other 23 hours it's but I'm going to be very careful in that hour I'm going to be more mock cockpit or this thing that I'm trying to do one day we'll do it our from my the young guy one day we got to do it it's like if you're going to talk in and a lot of people are at least at least don't talk during kadesh the most thing here somebody did this last night because I said it in at least not during kadesh I don't we had a how to say it not not um >> okay the way you're saying Right. Last time how do we say it was the whatever it >> no at least not during k the most start somewhere that's very the second thing the says is how does view a very hard like a really bad a what's considered a bad a he says an a that's very easy for you to control any a that's easy for you to control and you don't control that's it's not oh is this that it's what's hard and what's easy if for you this is very very easy to control and you don't control that's very if this is very hard for you to control and you don't control it's less that's how he says okay so says the best said that from now on part of this mitzvah you don't have to you don't have to do part yes Now you have to bring a parad a bunch of good examples. We agree that the concept exists but part of the concept doesn't doesn't apply. Okay. So this we have to pause here and explain what's going on here. Is only seven days. After the seven days are over, there's 11 days of zea. So there's an 18 day cycle. Today we don't know the difference. And that's why we're makpid on ze and I'll explain in a second. If during these 11 days, so what happens with the if a woman sees doesn't matter how many times and how many days she sees dam five days in a row on day seven mikvah her that's it. There's no seven days of Tahara. The whole thing is seven days. Doesn't matter how even on day mikvah is afterwards you have 11 days. In those 11 days, let's say she sees dam one time during those 11 days, she becomes a zakan or as the gumar the mission is calling it here meaning she has to make sure that she's for one day and then she's she's mikvah she's if she sees twice same exact thing. All she has to do is make sure she's clean for one day and then mikvah tar m but what if she sees three times which is not our sugl then she has to wait seven days of tahara and on the eighth day she brings two carbonas she brings two birds that's the of now the peasant said we understand that there's a concept of nida we just disagree we don't think there's a concept called where in the say I never saw those words in the where you saw anything in the say that that part of the mitzvah it's a part of the mitzvah oh they made a mistake so they have to bring a carbon par but they weren't trying to uproot the entire >> oh so same exact acting almost we agree that this this 38 is in Shabas we don't agree this 39 if somebody does the classic of here's he's a he's the as the mish calls him and the ani because usher means he's in the house the means a person standing in the street and he he extended something outside. Placed it outside. He did. So that and that somebody does this is that the will be a little bit of a video here. Let me find it. In that case, he actually is outside. He did. >> No, he didn't slap it. He put it down. Okay. Provide he put it he put it down. >> Wants a little grape. [Music] This sounds authentic. Here you go. [Music] >> See on the sign that the down lot of >> lot of that's it. Okay. Okay. So that's lot of next I agree that but if you bow we passing you about is going to explain what kind of bowing what are we talking about this is a classic case of they made a mistake in something went missing a thing not entire mitzvah went missing one one part of it. Why does say that if you sinned after retracted that you are potterd because he did not sin. He was basing it on on a fact that he heard from some say according to there's no difference in when the most of heard that this is what said this is let's say if an individual does it why it's to show the difference between amazing and over here this guy acted based He's a shig he's potter me question. Yeah, we know in the B mikdash when you bring a car in the B they bring carbon every day from the twice a day there's other carbonas where do they get the money for it? So right my favorite it's a joke they would collect they have from everybody in make a pile and that's the what do you do with the money they come they take the money back boxes the whole thing but what about this carbon that the bezen has to bring because they made a mistake in where do they get the money for that so one man says from this the other says they go knocking on doors they made an Then they go every single person in class has to participate because everybody did a ver so they go knocking doors. Unfortunately, we'd have to here again to collect one sheke of nothing so that you could be part of the carbon. So they knocked on your door. So you know that they made a you you know they made a mistake. You know that is now is they knocked on your door. They said we made a mistake. We we we we have to bring a carbon because we said is and it's really so what do you mean he doesn't know about it? Of course he knows about it. What's the answer? >> Before that >> no it says that he they retracted and they they went okay >> one of the answers simplest answer he was out of town. He he wasn't there when they knocked on the door. So it says here's the here's the cash at first you go and we have to remember this is says they knock on the doors and that's the question according to you we're talking about says from why cuz you didn't know that retracted here according to you knock on the door it comes from the collect so he had no idea anyway Once they collect the money so the guy became aware that Bez made a mistake answer number one they didn't say they knock the door we were collecting money for the base of English they didn't say for what they were embarrassed they made a big mistake he wasn't at home he was out of town the what the famous um it says in the Mishna it says in thear says in other is they knock on all doors. Ribbuda says from Salishka, what's a great way to get out of this? You got to flip it. What do you do? How do you flip? You go this way. Who says that you knock on the door? Says knock on the door. Doesn't say you knock on the door. Says you get from Salishka. So there was no awareness of it ever says that you knock on the door. There's no deal. So now we have all the sheet is put together here again what happened came out with a big tremendous news in you eat this type of everybody's dying to eat this thing it's like today you know the the rear part of the animal what the what is it called >> a lot of people are oh one day basic says you know what is mut ohm >> if you have the thing you don't have the thing yeah yeah yeah >> for you it's What is it really? >> Oh, no. It's not. >> You know how to take it out. 100%. 100%. If you know how to take it out, if you have If you know how to take it out, great. >> Yes. Says, why? Because it's as if this person sinned without the backing of a bezdon. There's no backing of bezel. Why you eat potter? Because said to eat it. Yeah, they said to eat it yesterday, but today they took it back. And today when you ate it, you didn't have the backing of bez. So you don't have the backing of bez. You don't have a pur. It's like eating by mistake. When your wife served you, you thought you're eating shum. You know that you have two pieces and you took the wrong piece by mistake. You ate it. Okay. So it's not your fault. Great. You had a mistake. But over here also it's not your fault. You didn't know that you still have to bring a carbon. Don't tell me you're potter. That's your mayor says no. He did it because said it's mut. So if you do it because then you don't have to bring a carbon. What does mean say this guy? I don't know why they said I said it like that, but okay. This guy. Now look at the next word. What does that mean? just said and we said it means when says the word he does not mean that was safic safik means it's a little confusing it's uh >> what does he mean >> what's the word I like to use counterintuitive tali means over here >> yeah what does it mean >> nothing >> it's like it means it means it's a good it's a good chil but it makes more sense that he didn't make a mistake and Pter doesn't say potter. >> Okay. But he's saying that there's a little bit of a bay over here. >> What's that? He doesn't bring a carbon. He doesn't bring a carbon. According to bring >> No, but he's not potter. It it's hanging there. According to you're potter. No. No. Even if even if I know exactly what happened there over here, we don't know exactly what's in his mind. Maybe he heard something. Maybe subconsciously heard. Maybe he must have been in the mikvah over here. Maybe some there's a little bit of a suffic not enough to bring a carbon but not enough to say the guy's potter. I hear what you're saying. So what what does he do now? Let him think a little bit more and let him go to a hypnotist and or whatever or these people that know how to bring out your subconscious thoughts and maybe he'll be >> but let's say let's say >> you find more. >> I understand. >> He wants to know what does he do? He don't bring a carbon don't bring a carbon. No, he's not potter. He's not potter. He doesn't bring a carbon though. He might he might be or something. He's not potter. >> Okay. So, how do we know what >> potter means? He's completely potter. When he gets up to straight to this guy, they're going to deal with him. Exactly. A person does something based on but he didn't realize the bez retracted. He's potter. This case that we had back in the past. We'll just bring it out here. Here. Um I don't remember which one is which. Uh maybe this one. >> Yeah. Yeah. I'm pretty sure this is the kosher one. It's your song in the background. >> I'm not sure. Is that the kosher one or the one still on? >> You're going to hear it. >> Now I need to bring a family. >> What happened over there? >> So in that case, you bring asham to maybe >> there's a bit there's a mist there's a confusion here. there's a mistake and then he says and certainly according to the mand that says who brings the par we're going to see there's a says that the the has to bring not the but when the what's the difference brings it how how how known is it the whole world knows if the if the is going to bring the whole world comes brings a carbon everybody knows this is what happened but even according to say brings the nobody knows about it. It is still a little bit of a Tina against you. You should have asked around. You should have known what's going on. Should have seen the news somewhere. Now we talk about what does mean? He's he's potter. He's kind of potter. It's hanging without bringing a carbon. I'll bring you. This person brought his his carbon by twilight like in between we don't know if it's day or night says over here a very interesting he says first of all know you don't bring a carbon at night so chances that it was at night are very slim but even though he brought it there's like a it's it's twilight even that is a suffic if it's day or night we have much more of a reason to believe that he did not bring it during bes or at the night. And we have over here that it's good that he shouldn't bring a carbon. Here his a little thingy. He's crying. He did a little big a rough look at his watch. Look, the sun's going down. Oh, now the bike the bike is working. That's the so it's maybe in that case you don't bring because it's much it makes a lot more sense that this that he wasn't that he that he brought it during the day. So by us it makes more much more sense that he didn't hear from there still a little bit of a doubt but a very far out. So now we're going to go on the reverse thing and certainly according to the it says that brings it where there's very little uh way for him to find out about it. It's not famous even though if if you hold that the whole brings the carbon it's very famous over here he doesn't he didn't think that he has to ask well you have to know to ask if bez retracted how are you gonna know something like that so meah it's not his fault by the way real quick big news for MDY on YouTube which is not a big deal for We reached 10 million views and YouTube is not even our number one platform. Torah anytime and uh Aldaf our larger platforms for us 10 million views is a big a big thing. Another thing I I I hate to do this but it's the the first time we have to do this. We're holding and I must talk about the next [Laughter] we are starting we're starting >> very excited. We're starting >> and there's a lot of people that have never touched. They never learned the word of kachum and it's an opportunity for yeshiva for ky guys for ex ky guys fiva guys to finally learn kachchum. It's not it's 50 minutes a day. Take it. It's going to be gishmach with our animations and everything. It's it's it's a great opportunity. So once again start putting it on your statuses and start getting people cuz we're starting next week. We're starting what? Next, not this coming Monday, the Monday afterwards. It's it's crazy. It's almost over. >> And sponsor gumaras. >> And sponsor gumaras. Yes, we're not printing our own gumaras. So, we got to sponsor Gumaras. You're going to be allowed them off the shelf. Says, so Benazi says a weird thing. It seems weird. It doesn't like there's no shot in the What is the difference between a guy that's in the jungle somewhere and a guy that's in his house in a normal society when everybody knows the news? What do you What is the difference? Isn't it obvious? What? >> You the sheep. >> Oh, that's what it was. The seah when this Wow, time flies. 7 and a half years ago, they as a surprise, they brought a live sheep into the into the semium. They gave it to me. They gifted it to me and then they said, "Well, what are you going to do with it? We got a shak." So, they shed it and ate the meat. >> Yeah, we had it for the sem. We served it at the next sem which is what >> our neighbors it wasn't >> the sheep made a because it was nervous it made a a scratch in his tile that's in his tile to this very day in Nam's house and they chopped it up the lamb chops and everything put in a freezer just a few hund days later we sat on my porch and we had lamb chops and we had the whole sheep >> with with the drussa from the guy that used to be in a motorcycle gang 40 minutes speech used to sit right over here. What's what's going on here? What's the back and forth? Very simple, says it's the was not in this world. So, he's like, "What's the difference in if I'm in the if if I'm in the jungle, if I'm in the house? I'm not in this world. I'm aloof. I'm gone." I know. I know. I know. Married for one day. The whole thing. So he says the like the guy is on his way making aliyah or making whatever it is you know how busy this guy is moving trucks in out selling all your possessions selling your car closing down your bank accounts he doesn't know what's flying nevertheless you live in society know what's going on oh that doesn't know what's flying over here he says you have to know what's flying according to no potter is So you got to put on your seat belt here just for a minute because this is a freebie. These are word word for word for what we learned in the Mishna. It says in the that part of the thing is a thing was was missing forgot about you have to bring a par not entire but if they said there is a need but a certain part of the But if you do one one taking out a bottle of wine that is not that's they said they agree that there is a concept of but the bowing part we don't agree to perhaps I would think that they don't have to ring a parallel because they are missing one thing one of the Not the entire Okay, now we can slow down slightly. Not a lot. We went from three speed to one and a half. You should be wait a minute. I would think for a second that if they say that Shabas exists but one of doesn't exist, they shouldn't bring a par. Okay, they shouldn't bring back and you we already established if they took out the entire shabas also then what's the whole para of oh no no no no you misunderstood that what the is saying is I would have thought that they have to take out the entire mitzvah no they don't have to take the whole mitzvah they only have to take part of the mitzvah and in that you are not that bold you're not you potter Just I learned from means part of the mitzvah means the entire mitzvah part of the mitzvah. They only took away part that's a carbon not part from a carbon. How do you see from the word vanilla that it means partial van that the whole doesn't say now they say not that it says it but we read it as if it says from a thing not the whole thing a part of the thing from the part of the mitzvah they they they uproot it that's when they bring a parit wait a mitzvah is plural. So if it's part of the plural, that means what? One out of the two. So that means a full mitzvah. They uprooted an entire mitz. They said the whole shabas doesn't exist. No, we just established it's part of one, not part of two. Yeah. But in the there's no doesn't say if you just read it simply, it would say. So ma for us for that purpose we're going to read it as mitzvah that's part of the mitzvah part of one not part of two >> it only has one >> as one >> yeah because it's one the way it's written with if if there was no and I would give you this word you would read or >> fine we learned about that's who argues on the and then it goes to the Sanhedrin and they tell him no you are wrong and instead of agreeing with them he goes back and he pkins not he like he used to say he gets a death penalty says the word is not trying to argue on the he's trying to talk about the this particular part of it is talking [Music] and not the entire mitzvah it's part of the so he says a very interesting and here we go they're not arguing on they're arguing on the but the doesn't call the calls it on something that theim argue the zukim in general don't agree with anything in But there are things in that they do agree with. So calls it in other words if they argue on the our actual you don't bring a parallel because even agree to it. There's nothing to argue about. It's a only on something that's that's something that we learn from. >> Did I skip? But if it's something that agree any little kid you should know if you're the best you're amazed for not knowing this if you're in seriously certain over the generations certain whatever said don't do this it's you have to do it what do you mean but but my my my said not to do it so you know better than your right it says muring XYZ your rough says he could eat it says don't eat my rough said it's you got to know more you still amaze it if your rough tells you to do it the garra says so now we have to go into this we just discussed this they agree that this is the concept called but one part of it that if she saw during her 11 days of then you are potter now everybody's going to ask it's not where does it say in the you're right but agree to this and that's why it says it's interesting so if it's a and and and has to bring a parallel by making this mistake but Unfortunat it's something that even the duke of noble. Oh, so now the Gar goes in to find out that it's not. Listen, it's very important this whole it's not that they took out one whole part of the Tyra. It's one part in one part of the Tyra. It's a tiny idea in that one part of Nida this they didn't take out the whole took out one concept in the what they said that the beginning of the act is only the end of the act is also so they made a mistake in that so for that you have to bring a parser it's referring to the beginning of the act no so what what was a mistake. Again, we're talking about the only time it's the regular act. It's unnatural act then it's says that's not true. There's only unnatural act and the calls it as if it's a real act. So in the whole doesn't matter what unnatural is natural it's equal. So it's so here they made a mistake in they shouldn't bring a a parallel says oh no we're talking about we're talking about they said natural is also even the the beginning of the act but when it's unnatural then over there the the beginning of the act is not also that was their mistake in That was the mistake. So it's a a tiny concept in the I said so why you talking say this exact idea that it's in the regular they said it's we're talking about and it's not and what they the mistake was they said when is it regular but What was the mistake? Interesting thing they said that the whole concept of ze is during the daytime. There's no if she sees D at night not why this is the last in and then you say [Music] this is how it finishes. Moving on to the next another. Now if I asked you what was the mistake best than made in Nido when the says Nida it's a one small concept of in great I'm saying this because we're going to do for a second and we have to remember this over here I'm going to give you on this also what was their mistake they said you're allowed to take out a bottle of wine from my house into It's a virtual which is in it seems like believed in in anything that was written even okay what happened was you might want to stick around for this video I'm about to show so they said that they said like this they said this is mut to go from into is why in the uses the word it doesn't say they go literally what it says in the say don't take it out doesn't say don't put it so if I were to ask you what is what what's the mistake of bestin not an entire of shabas But one part, excuse me, one part of one of the they don't agree that throwing is they don't agree that it's one part of one. There's a concept called but if you bow you says bowing why they bring up it says you shouldn't bow to another god it says in a different way it means not natural the not natural way that they believe that if you bow Yeah, when we just learned, we know they're wrong. Par you sp how do you do par? You relieve yourself in front of the What if you bowed to bar? You didn't really You bowed it. You gave it. You're also made a mistake and they said you're potter not what's your name >> from. Your name from >> Anybody else that wants to say hello? You got to raise your hand now. Yeah. What's your name? Yeah, he took two language >> from don't tell me Chicago and you >> from sorry that I'm in a rush and we didn't get to or if you do it normally if you do it like this I can't show the whole thing now but maybe Dave do me a favor go Look at look how young men was over here. >> There was a picture I gave out. I showed like this. >> Oh, so so we fast forward >> the whole thing. You go like this. >> Straight down like this. Whose tiles is this? Move that all the way. >> Okay, fine. You get the idea. Great. >> Yeah. What's his name? >> Is down like this. Diane Feet spread also >> hand spread. >> I don't think I would do that anymore. >> The fourth one, it's Matu. It's like this and were like this sideways. >> Okay. Has anybody ever done that? >> Never. Nobody's ever going to do it. They say they say that if there's no that if you don't do it like that as I demonstrated on the table you just do what you bow you bow like this I don't have to do it anymore I don't have to make anymore I just show the video the anybody in this room didn't hear did anybody in this room not hear my story about me in the dive anybody everybody heard oh you guys didn't hear okay fine so for them those two Guys, I'm a grownic. I'm a grownic boy. And I And the gross says that when you I hear what you said. And the girl says that when you do oner, you're supposed to do get down on the floor and you do it. And my entire life, my entire life, I couldn't wait until that moment of me doing it. And I didn't I knew that in there's a called the zilman and the grronics they'll do they do it. So I I was I was really emotional about doing it. I never did it. I put my face on the ground and like I had the the right to do it. Everybody does it. I got seats over there. Good seats. It's hard to get seats. Got seats. Get up. I go I'm like I'm ready to go and there's a ma what happened? And let me show you what happened. We have I have the vide tape of that day. Dump your songs ready. [Music] Oh So, [Music] I'm telling you, I know I didn't make it up. If it wasn't true, I wouldn't show it. I'm nice to show you there was a there was a the bathroom backed up and Grunx I forgot to Grunx don't wear any slippers or anything on on Yum Kipper only socks and they they had a debate do do over is their right of holding it in you just go into the the whole thing and with the sapping socks they came back and davin and when I did my kim I got one of those socks mamish in my face in my face >> sponsor sponsorship global specialist in the national financial service. Do you understand the potential? We can do Remy the horse now. We can do all the stories on video. Anonymous that one also or your favorite >> the train anonymous in gratitude to MDY for promoting anonymous says the we only have to go all the way to the B of the summit then we have one minute if somebody says I believe in the says I believe in all of Shabas I just don't believe in plowing they they believe in everything but they don't believe in that so it's believing in half believing some they're uprooting the entire it's like uprooting an entire mitzvah and you don't bring a parallel love an entire mitzvah we just spoke about it and they don't agree to the entire what's the answer together >> it's just talking about it's not talking about being like we answered we're just doing a little says oh they wanted to uproot the entire concept of carrying on why did they bring a carbon we didn't say they're uprooting the whole what do we say just or just throwing They wanted to uproot the idea of bowing. That's a they want to uproot a whole. So what's the answer? Not they want to uproot the whole just what bowing >> par or or bowing not like he did on the table over there or getting a thing in your face is also like a guy thing. This is crazy. They believe in Pasin there is no concept of Shmira Shabas on the year of Shmita. You have one year off. It reminds you a little bit of the uh what do they call the the new >> the guys that look like Jews the certain year when you're 14 15 years old you have a year of you do whatever you want go figure out the world >> if you want they see if you want to but you can be on the whole their whole Tyra. Yeah. So we have one year free free no shabas is that you hear rabai would they the whole shabas or the just one day out of the seven one one one year out of seven years it's not mish the whole shabas it's it would be similar to saying that that uh you could eat khazer on Monday but not on Tuesday is that being the whole the whole khazer or it's partial and partial is a problem you have to bring you you bring over being arched completely on a Monday would not be same idea right and Gar is gonna bring actually a riot from that that concept of one day and the other day one year and one year yes and one year not is like one day yes and one day not yet that you understand no >> oh I have no idea where I am >> I have to do the whole thing again [Music] >> I am lost oh Oh, sorry. So it says in the when you do when you plow your field when you're allowed to then you have when this is plowing that's mistakenly weirdly since there is six years out of the seven then it's like breaking the mitzvah partially Since they uproot it completely 100% during considered as if they absolve the entire shabas I'll prove it to you when the said you got to we got to approve something from the now if avi ever tries to tell you that this a certain mitzvah is gone forever he's if he says that there's no mitzvah this mitzvah doesn't apply today tomorrow we could listen to him if he's a nois Now this went ahead and he said that the certain mitzvah is gone. But if he said he could do it sometimes, not sometimes now what is like what's a what's a thing of that'll be he tried to uproot some but left some and this this would answer our question about if he says you could do on Mondays but not on Tuesdays on Thursdays but not on Fridays that's that's considered the carbon hel on this mix. When you say one day yes, one day not that's uh not uprooting it completely. You don't say oh he uprooted completely for Monday. You say no he left in some of it. So he didn't uproot the entire seventh year. It's some yes some not. That's a that's a classic case of have a wonderful day. A good chabas shabas in the hotel and Sunday morning in the hotel next year. Monday morning right here Shabas is going to be closer to 11 maybe a little bit before 11. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atm.com.