Daf Yomi Gittin Daf 72 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning wrap boys live from Chicago we're using very very expensive equipment laptop camera today because our camera is out and we have to move because it's almost in New York so if you're watching New York keep uh pay attention to the clock if you don't want to go over her toys uh we'll just do real quickly we'll do a email or two I don't know what you would consider it's a kiss from Hashem to me you or both but I was flying from New York there's a strong Monday night and because he recorded that I in early because you were flying back to Chicago I was able to do Tuesdays in the airport before boarding and not fall behind traveling you're hopelessly addicted talmud Dr mayor wickler or voices reminds me that we have a very classification Millions what's your name again remember I'm all the way came special flew in just for today's share all the way from Orlando sponsored somebody sponsored you know you want to say his name no okay huh you're going for the great gift to whoever you are it's a tremendous honors I wish I had a camera that could turn around over here and uh oh this has to go over here sorry okay you know what I'm talking about I was getting frustrated with all this technology okay dear my River I mean who says that whose lotion is that anybody know it's amazing to attend your share in person on Sunday my wife and I decided to make a trip to the Catskills so what happens to be the Tannersville and Hunter is the real cats because the other one is the fake one kashamati at least the people in Canada want to say that so we could say they stopped off at patter skill Falls which is 10 minutes away from Rose's Mountain where I was I was wearing in the White Cap because she called over to me and said uh this year's changing client Israel more you know learning positive the sheer The Falls are quite a sight of a hole okay the white divider oh so after finishing supper about to leave a youth comes running over and asked if the where can you find milha see one thing that another he said he's going to share he looked a little bit confused he said I thought rebelly's in there just throw the kids are no he's in the Catskills he came over and he said that and he told me the story that he that he has a person who wouldn't be from today if not for this year and uh for coming over and tell me the story during this year revi mentioned the famous represents of Crohn's story helped his daughter find the on the way home I turned on kolbarama that we said yesterday kiss from Russia I realized that due to the timing of The Starving substitution Paris Khan Levin always thinks about getting more people to share so he says right before is when kiddushin starts would be perfect opportunity to do mdy recruitment driving the Catskills right before everyone starts leaving and I'm planning recruit and driving the castle of Sunday August 13th I would like to set up underway equipment booths throughout the Catskills obviously can't make man all the I'm trying to solicit volunteers to help this effort I send this text to some of them something always 13 just before stock induction is a perfect time to recruiting the shamas and the castles can you help the kids sir call him at 917-584-5722 I'm hoping I'm not going to be the only one doing the recruiting your time at always better Time movie and one last one so I set a mice over from Rabbi Spitzer I said I don't know where he is he learned with my sake and the knife caught his hand this message is for Ellie stefanski from Cindy Spitzer the guy from Passaic somebody told me those in the last few minutes of the this year it really brought back fan memories although some minor Perot them in this story were slightly different okay well I said happened 35 years ago so the fact that I even remember the story I can't remember gamara from a day ago but the mice of 35 years ago that stuck out it'd be nice to reach out and get in touch by the way I have a cuddle in London so he's a Russian in London beautiful sometime between this dish above next issue I hope to reach out to him the coilover respond to my knives from Lakewood Esther bass Balo the most responsible thank you for everything that I have the part is number four by Dr avram Epstein in memory third yard says love it is who was my neighbor in the building she was an unbelievable person always had a smile on her face she had the Mackle on her tongue and suddenly she was nifter I might even talk about it during cheer I have this moment our dear son is sponsor of a complete reformsai we have to make sure we don't go into is here we have a time limit and it's early in the morning from I have to say from the most difficult theorem of the Year for me because I only had until now to prepare uh we finished the share very late last night and I had a meeting until uh past midnight and then in addition I also have to prepare for multitish above and I can't learn on Tish above so it's fun stuff but it's fun for the item as well it's very difficult to learn today and especially if you're in New York and how you're going to get it and I'm asking please skip ahead after Tish above just go ahead forget what happened and don't fall off the bandwagon because the digital has yourself we're just going to finish this off we have another mission of fresh mission of new start a very famous mishna we have to finish off the machlaikas from yesterday and it's again going into that idea that Shiloh of when anybody in our case a husband tells an agent go right again give a get does that agent have the ability to give over those words to another person make another slave he's lazy doesn't want to do it he gives it out to another guy meaning you cannot give over the words so air made it very easy this is the beginning of the mission in the middle of the end of the mission when the mishna says in rule is go tell the cipher and he goes in the safer rights and the mishna says that it's no good why is it not good because he didn't say knew okay stop what does that mean he didn't say no and if you did say no he would be able to go to somebody else and tell somebody else to do it what is that the only reason it's not good is because he said he didn't say no he missed the word but let's say you did say the right words then I visually I could go make a second set of me and that's a meeting so the first part of the mission that seems like millimeters there as the gemara there's a big problem because at the end of the mission it seems like Miley where it says two it says it's a good guy it's not a good get until he says until he does the cipher excite mashma mililoi Memphis sorry it says he must tell directly has to tell the cipher directly and they them directly there is no giving over to another there is no watching after the others so what do we do the top of the mission says the bottom says you want to tell me the top is going quarter mayor the bottom goes according to review I see that's the deutschak and that's how we finished off yesterday so now we're holding like seven lines from the top of rabashi is of the opinion and I also try to do this it makes a lot more sense to say that it goes according the entire mission is one cheetah the you see that what foreign to do something he cannot give it over to another guy so why in the beginning of the mission doesn't seem like it goes according to another month Omar says the mission is going in a way sometimes the mission does it it tells you a smaller fiddish and then even a and it's certainly the bigger footage the the less let me buy a comment foreign [Music] he didn't just say it's a little tricky we had this little tricky thing yesterday also learn about new doesn't mean that he missed the word no it means that he said even if he said to new lying you don't say that you could give it over to Australia and then the gimmar continues that says if he told three people that's a lot easier to say that they could give it over because three is what a based them so not only three but even if he's told it to two and I feel a little bit uh he told it to two not the three dollars then we're gonna build up we go slow and then we build up lie also in a case where he told three people right again so it's like hey I'm telling you better to go appoint somebody else even in that case in other words the whole mission is just going in levels but let me buy a third thing let me buy uh the Omar imro that we could just you know the famous sounds confusing so simple it just means that the husband didn't say you write the get and then you decided on you want to get a sleep he actually told you to get a schlieff he gave you instructions number two and in that imro okay it's no good even if he said imro it's also not good okay so we went through all the steps no matter what whether it's two people three people whether he said everything is no good because you cannot give over anything to another schlier thank you the what this this thing right here that we have on the on the sheet oil is a puzzle that's a big Critters right even if the guy says straight out the guy says I want you Reuben to go get shiman to write a get he cannot do so because of the accordion because of the opinion that it doesn't you can't give over so we have a rioter of Ashi that is possible if he does foreign [Music] go ahead and tell shiman to write again that's good no it's not good he has to hear directly from his from his mouth what does it mean his voice now what we had this whole thing yesterday just to remind the Olam I took off the guy's ears because I didn't like the ears in a case where a guy was a big calf he's 100 regular normal and then he lost his Hearing in his and his speech RAV says what he could give and get by writing and I want to tell you not the price is saying it has to be you can't write anything the husband has to say straight out I want you to write a gift no not only that very good he wants to know if you write the rights again of course if he writes again it's good but Tyson says tremendous and this is very very important what about if it's a regular human being a guy that hears and and and and speaks perfectly he's a genius he has an IQ of one 180. and somebody said and he wrote on a piece of paper write my wife again we just said you have to hear it from the guy's mouth says Ty says it is a good get it's a good get I quit no we're talking about a cherish a guy that can hear us speak so you have to hear Carlo you have to know that is that he's he's confident but a guy that is competent and I know that he wants to write again how do I know because he text messaged me that's enough I don't have to hear it it's not unlock that you have to hear it's unbelievable places you know there's places you might make a mistake so going back now that you have a question about your guy a guy writing again of course is a good guy now we have a very famous mishna I think it's famous I don't know although on the side it only says it's brought down twice I didn't like that but I mean it just seems so famous like you have it in different receptors Maybe I'm Wrong so first of all in order to understand this the the point that this whole mission is or one of the points okay if a guy says that I want to get to take place after he dies obviously it's not going to take place a get could only take place between a husband and a wife when the husband is bye-bye there's no husband there's no wife there's no marriage to to break so the gift cannot take place after death so that we have someone who's showing us in the mishnah some of the language is he's saying straight out of state police after death those are the first ones and then therefore it doesn't work at all but then we have a very interesting lesson a retroactive lotion after the person dies it's retroactively work from today six years earlier that is okay I want to get to be it should go into effect if he dies it shouldn't go into effect today he's not saying retroactive he's saying when he dies you're going to effect what's that no good so here's here are the here are the three cases that the mission says is not good from this disease but when should it take place after he passes spread out you think by the way you're going not no good let's see if that is good because it is good but okay in our mission no good me so when should it take place this is straight out my Forest doesn't get any more of a force than this after death zero zero right not so caution that it's zero but the mission says zero that's how we read it but he says today if what if he dies tomorrow if he dies next year which take place from now not from today today now same thing or almost saying from this point or from today why because that's called the retroactive getting that clarification retroactive get a person gives a get on Sunday if he dies on Tuesday and he died on Tuesday so what is the get how on Sunday so it's not again so it's not a get after death it's a perfect get but now he says from today and after death now he's confusing us oh thank you Mark no yeah hold on let me go back Mark is controlling this but he's right in Matthew we have two cases of retroactive he says which to me it's almost the same came out the same match means this moment means these 24 hours but now there's another case it's a case that can go both directions he says it should be retroactive but then he says and after death by the way that's why it's a little dark here because this thing where do we turn this on it might be because I I think they turned it out no I know for sure in behind like right over here behind this wall yeah I don't know what it did to the picture I don't know I raise again so since he's contradicting himself he might have retracted what he said he said thought about it for a moment and then he says so maybe retract it or maybe no should work retroactive I don't know why is he doing this get we said it over and over it doesn't hurt to say it again why is a person divorcing his wife five minutes before he dies because he doesn't want her to fall to his crazy brother he has a Nutty brother he doesn't like himself is certainly his wife never liked him she doesn't want to marry him so why get into the whole mess gives her a get five minutes before he dies they had a great marriage but there's a again it's like a gift and now you don't have to fully evil but I don't know if that's what he meant did he meant that she but he wants to stay married to her until he dies he doesn't want to give up his wife now who's going to visit him in the hospital and everything right so he says so we have a suffer get here so what do you do so certainly she can't fall the evil she can't marry her brother-in-law because what if it was a good get and if it's a good get you now want to marry your brother-in-law uh sorry let's say so just to take care of the Shiloh you get you do halitza but you cannot do yibon because you don't know what what's going on here now we're going to see this later and Rashi pointed out over here so could I just do Hazara when it comes to get there's only one stage and again it's not a two-stage process divorce slice cut broken done it's one thing when it comes to a gift there's two stages why because a gift has the principle and the produce so when a person wants to gift over something to the sun let's say Rashi brings somebody wants to give his son a building but it doesn't know how long he's going to live but he wants to make sure it's now you know tax purposes whatever the thing is so he says it should work from today in other words you're getting the principle but wait a minute the father needs to to live he means he needs parnasso he needs produce the produce should happen after he does so that's very simple now I know why he said it's two stages stages one should take place today the Goof stage two should take place tomorrow the pay raise great but you can't say the same thing but it gets his rash he's just pointing it out and we're gonna bring that Macho I guess so tomorrow a person has a stage five yeah and he says this is your get if he dies from this disease and then he gets up he's completely healed and he walks in the marketplace the hola and then he gets a heart attack of a maze and he dies that's what I was saying about Mrs Epstein she was fighting battling cancer of the tongue and they smash walking around he saw her two days before she went by herself no no wheelchair nothing went to the hospital to get treatment and she got very very heavy doses of chemo and then she got a bug in the hospital and then within two days why was she Nifty it's important to the sugya that's what I'm saying the story why is she lift her well she lifted because of the cancer because of the bug or it's the same one led to the other and these are the questions you have to ask so the mission says we gotta we gotta assess the situation we ask the doctors I guess if it was caused because of the first one right A lot of people that have Vietnam they don't die from they die from pneumonia the last days whatever it is it reminds me let's say of covet during covet everybody died from covet every 97 year old that had the cancer covet covert people were in a car accident he died from covet he punched it he was this he had the mask on and that's why he veered and flew off the cliff covered every single person was covered they had to get the numbers High remember that not your volume so you have to assess you don't ask those doctors yes the uh why did this guy die is it again or is it the the pneumonia what is it you know so if it's obvious like I just said then okay think of them if it's not you gotta know because he stipulated and he said if he dies from that macro and then they got a pneumonia last minute well pneumonia is the same it happened because of the animal that's why the a regular guy just takes two antibiotics and he's done maybe maybe so yeah I said after foreign [Music] well we're going to get into it we're going to see exactly at the end of the game I think it will be clear if a guy gets up completely healthy goes on his vacation you know Mom is I'm done he's done with the mouth and suddenly he gets a pneumonia he gets a heart attack no connection he's done he's he was active that's not even a child if a guy goes from this strength to the next one it's obvious from the first one is going to tell us that we have an in-between case we kind of got up he was still in a stickle wheelchair Walker situation literally like this is a walker then okay by then the song we'll see and you're always high me some because that's not uh Lucas miso only only if a guy kid falls off the roof and he's about to literally a second before and he's literally there's no way to save him and then takes a knife may maybe even then I don't remember but a guy that that's alive you pull the plug on him three days before he's gonna die so we had to do with some of our recovery okay but says the word imati we said they start off the Mishra here if you look at this chart this this is already like kind of the answer of the Mr but we have two parts of the mission now it says imati if he dies we said if he dies meaning they get to be how when when he dies no good not a good and then it says from today if he dies so what's going on here so in the second part of the mission he says from today if he dies uh that you said it is a good gift why is it a good guess because he's going by the mahayo retroactive but he says imati if I die will explain I know what you're you're singing It's possum right um we had also in this masato I I looked it up I'm not flying with the bees a base is the same thing a different circuit but in the beginning but no because when he said I was like wait a minute it sounds familiar he says he says the same idea but in some with something else look at this chart it's beautiful the word imati can mean if I die in other words he's saying if he dies then the getcha bihao after he dies no good equals no good but you could the word in could also mean when so when he diesel today this is a value the word in who has two meanings to it depends how you use it in a sentence if you use it just imati the word means if and if I use it in the sentence then the word means when and when is very good to get is how today that's great retroactively when do I know that it's hot today as soon as he dies when he dies when not if when at that point then he dies then we go back two months and they get his cow all the way two months earlier foreign believes that we don't know exactly it's a Suffolk because if it's not again what should Allah be Bo she should fall she's never gathered a divorce she's 100 100 married to her husband her husband dies without children she she falls leave them to the brother-in-law so why does everyone say she doesn't foreign but wait a minute it says in the mission that nothing happened nothing happened means this should be you but it means that she's also to the whole world series but at the end of the day I have a suffix so she's listening that can't be it's a it's a nice try says the gamara okay you're putting in the words and stuff but how does it fit with the rest of the mission the the second part of the mysticism of furishas what does that mean how come part of the mission says the word says in the first part of mission doesn't secularizes obviously the first part of this is a great it's not a get at all and therefore this is evil otherwise you'd be consistent in the same Mission say the first part of this is the second part is why did you only use the word to the second part of the mission is [Music] so Rashi says over a bottom is what then when it comes to a gift they give your son you have to say and if you don't say the word mahayam it's okay A guy who wants to give a gift to son you must say the word my Lord everybody so we have to remember this is the nakuta of the whole Suge to the end of the day today says a very simple thing this is what does that mean you don't have to say anything look inside the star what does it say inside the star inside the Shire says the get was written today on Sunday so that means he wanted to give it again on Sunday then he got sick and everything okay so you go back retroactively to Sunday you don't have to say the word is actually you don't have to say it works without the again remember when I said you went like this I don't know what you did yeah why but Rebecca says no the get says that the get was written today today Sunday and then he said so after he dies go back to Sunday what's wrong with that I don't have to say you don't like it okay what's up guys let's hear why don't you like it maybe you're asking because then you always have to write a date and again doesn't mean they wanted to give it today okay okay yeah somebody writes the date whatever that's basically what you're asking yeah there's nothing to do with what he wants to give it so which is it that day or the next day oh yeah very good he's asking you on a regular again you give it give it two days later one was about the day and together fine you understand that it works because why did you write this date he he said I want it to happen today but then again maybe not okay but also maybe you have a child holds ravuna that says that you require khalito we have a something here Revolution the the time of the get is but there's no Yi bomb so what's obvious question if the time of the get proves that he want to give it earlier so you shouldn't even need halitza says tomorrow hold on or let's see um [Music] the time of the star proves that he wanted to give it earlier in other words that it's a beautiful good get and leads an ability so what's your suffix you tell me it's a perfect get how do I know it's a perfect get because he wrote a date in the get and anytime you write it date and get you want to get to bihal on that date so to get was how two weeks ago so she got divorced before her husband died and 100 she got divorced not 50 Suffolk 100 as you got divorced so she got divorced why did she even have to do anything with her brother-in-law why does it have to be a Khalid vegetables doesn't know 100. you're right he holds us 100 a good get doesn't know if I should pass him like your business or not was the talmud of Wrath the famous giraffe RAV who right there with the end of that who's rabbit who was biggest talmud talmud Raven some even say that rev nachman married wife very good our guest from Orlando so it's a child it's not 100 because some say that that was his daughter not his daughter they want to bring different rights regardless of okay so now he got sick remember avoid the red being the talmud of Wrath gets a punch is the person in our story right here we're saying it doesn't know maybe he doesn't understand 100 that Allah or not he doesn't know foreign on my legs from nothing says I don't know the reason behind it so how can I even ask him now I saw I heard him say that if you remember the other day we learned are you certain Jazz reviews like him because he goes he has very very good reasoning so they say oh that's the shadow over here that's when we know his good reason but if his reason is a secret then he figured it out here okay it's not a little upsettle foreign it's like it's interesting I'm not going to tell you now if you ask him you listen to me I'll tell you the reason later and asking the questions that's it no so what is he doesn't have a Suffolk okay now that you did your job well let me tell you the secret this is the reason everybody's sovereign the date in the star proves when the guy wanted to give a get he wanted to give it to the last last year and he's just waiting until he dies so if so Ella masakilay so what's the problem with everyone what's the deal ER you're my reviews beautiful another Shiloh can we apply reviews say that there's a time and again but at the end of the day the get doesn't doesn't say it tonight and as the husband is giving the gift to the wife he says this is your get if I die you hear he said that condition still hold of his own tomorrow says if there's a condition in the get and there's a but it doesn't say the word but it says a date a date is the same thing is a date means I go retroactive to the beginning of the date but that's because there's a condition in the get together with a date you have two components but if you only have one component it just says the date and the condition you invented when you gave her the get give me today every get needs a gift that's what I told them before right it wouldn't be again right that's the the people ask that question the ever again music date that's why you put a date now that's basically what he's asking me for sure which one where are the places yeah yeah exactly that's what that's why I'm explaining exactly what I'm explaining that rubioisi always holds you don't need the word oh you're saying that in the um yeah um let me think for a second um [Music] right right because of what that's that's what's going on we're talking about Bell pair it's not causal so you're saying that it should say um and then Rashi says foreign assistant it doesn't say Emmanuel yeah maybe if it says a regular get yeah it says and it says oh no no um she has a problem for for later on yeah this is a regular star there's a there's a tonight in this man about per he's not talking about maybe he's talking about yet I don't know okay we have to look into it overlay you already payload okay so that was his Shiloh the bottom line is that he had a different question because he he said it he said about pep he said in the get he wrote his man and papaya um he says he he makes the condition I'm giving you this good on condition if I don't come back for 12 months um he didn't he didn't fulfill the condition it seems like on the surface he said if I don't come back in 12 months but he died within the 12 months said it is a good get wine who are these reviews so we have a case again guy says he writes in the get today's date and then he gives a stipulation if he doesn't come back in 12 months and they hold that it's a good get even if he dies a month number six not 12. why because they get to bihao when he wrote it on the day that he wrote it upon him you see from here that even though the stipulation was about it still works you still rubiois is still we still invoke is together with the day it works essentially saying no no we're not ignoring the Opera we're explaining about that or explain what he meant he meant that there should be uh yeah but he said if I don't come back in 12 months and what if he came back and what if he couldn't come back in 12 months because he died in the middle so there's a certain explanation we have to explain what everybody explains that's different it's not like you think that tafka if he didn't come back in 12 months these guys don't want to be finished before no so we that says I wasn't sure if I should go with that Allah or not I don't know if they're right or not um you get if the person dies the shiny mace so this we don't have in the the mishna in Matthew we have in the mishna our missionary is a good it's a good get now in our mission says it's not again we're gonna have to explain why is it again because we're alcohol that we go retroactive means that it's a big get today if I go back to Mark who could this go according to her boy side foreign [Music] if this and this happens if he dies so that's the repeater we know that that's Allah again so we're going to say a bigger this year I'm gonna say that Robert said it exactly like he said it without the word said if I die it's a get manage the opposite of our mishnah but then it goes according to Rebecca foreign there is the time inside the get and that time is telling us that it should be retroactive it gets to be ready why did Robert say this case because he holds the Curiosity and he passed against and it's about pet by the way yeah so we have a case of a person saying the the tonight the stipulation about that together with the time and the get and it works according to realize it's a good girl my friend so why is wasn't so positive [Music] it's talking about a case where the guy said from today if he dies and it's a good get and you asked me a question you're right part of it is language that I pointed out while we're reading it that's not in the mishnah shiny maze that the worst anime is like himatidami that it's almost didn't say it doesn't say that's also it's not a get the first part is again second part is not again but we have two to show this one that's good one is not good and that's both not in the mishna that's why rubber said [Music] so some say on the second part of the mission not then we were talking about ravuna was saying this whole thing on the words no it's going on the second part of the safety that was on the mission that part if the dog has been stipulated this should be your get after he dies the mission is nothing um so this is a little trigger Rabbi side uh not really tricky but it's a little cooler says race what does this mean s is if he didn't say the word right according to see you don't have the same it's Abby's from the actual get I wanted from today you do have to say the word Maya but so something more says but in our mishna in a case where he's the guy said what was lotion so [Music] um so the the ratio of the in a case that he said they have to do halitza so rebecci is going to say that's in case what's the difference remove the word Mayon so reviews is gonna hold him okay so if you don't say because that's the whole argument in them whether without the word foreign [Music] who holds that it's a perfect gift so what does obviously have to say the the reviews is saying I don't hold like ready I would think that he holds like it's a great game please each one doesn't like the other one Rabbi doesn't know that you realize look ready and therefore reverse is speaking Remy says this case I hold you don't it's it's a good get s his case that he didn't say this is just the date in the in the get Rabbi doesn't agree to abuse again in the case of mahayon all things are said there really says it's a good get but I don't agree to you rubioisi in your case that he doesn't say the word I'm not going to greet you ready and and then the flip side everybody doesn't all the gravity they call it says this is again only my case is again not your case rep review holds from today I got gives a get should start today I don't know right this is the price I don't know if he meant it should start from today retroactive or he took he retracted and said it should go laugh at me if you see oh sorry the same manual after music get better together this case is again but not your case for BRAC where you don't say the word and what's your blessing it's not kids forget gotta turn this off because we're almost at the end kids together right again give it to my wife if I don't come back in 12 months if they wrote it within 12 months in the middle and they give it at that after 12 months this is again but I don't agree to you Remy died so he wants to make sure that everything is good all his everything all as long he's going to the right people he gives it all away amites whatever you don't have to make nothing it goes what happens if he has a miraculous recovery he comes back to life what did she be left with nothing he only gave it on condition that he he didn't say the condition was obvious to us he thought he's dying tomorrow she gave it away now that means he's alive and well so here's this is that I get that's given by somebody that's dying or one of those things it was given without the stipulation that he's giving it because he's dying he doesn't have to stipulate you hear this he doesn't have to stipulate we stipulate for him we understand what happened there he gave the get to get his bottom of Utica after the hour why because he's alive and well he had a great recovery so another just like get even though you didn't explain but since you said right even though you didn't say give of God the money because I know that the streamer wants to give it so even without a Kenyan it works it's not we learned in our mission you get from today if he dies from that I keep on saying if he I don't want to say it myself that's why I keep on saying that lotion to walk around in the marketplace and he dies and he got another disease the mace okay he had disease a he was strong enough he recuperated he's walking around saying hello to everybody and then he got loyal into another disease and he dies we have this we have to assess the situation if he died from the first disease it's a great get him live then it's a whole new story and again he stood up for one moment he was able to run around like like a like a young guy that doesn't have a disease it's not again finished oh Margarita is I just want to show you this real quickly um this thing right here in green is a good get in red it's not a good get so you have the two opposite cases if he never completely recovered from his first makla yeah and he never recuperated he he was in bed and he got another Mahal while he's in bed and he dies what's that Allah it's good it's a good get green green light you go what's the flip side if he completely recuperated from his makro he's walking around he made a suicide die and everything and then he got another waffle he got a heart attack and he died that according to everybody is not a gift so what's our Shiloh the middle the middle one that he recuperated but a little bit like he's walking on a walker says the gemara you figure out you for that you need a doctor exactly how it worked and how but we we we're not sure yeah he recuperated the doctor said you know what you're released from the hospital but he's still on a wheelchair he's still walking around he's still not a hundred percent himself then he hops another pneumonia and he dies no so what did he die from the doctor said he's cured will mice he died the next day from pneumonia is that cured or not cured he's 32 years old who dies for pneumonia and 32 years old he must have had some other underlying condition go ask the doctors that's our esophage so there was a guy who who comes to the United straw this is my scenario that comes to to the doctor and stroke with a with a knife stuck in his in his in his stomach so only another stroll unfortunately it was Russian harder Dr says sorry my office is closed I'm closing up now I can't help you out so the guy says what do you mean I have a knife stuck in my in my stomach what should I do like I said let me take a look he takes the knife out and sticks it right in his eye he says the optometrist is open until eight o'clock then I go to the third floor I ain't jump anyways he he went from one disease to another disease it was just it was this yeah this disease went to the another one it's the same thing he's gonna die from the first one die from the second one ah he's asleep he can't tell me that he he he went from one disease to the other Road the words it says he stood up he's good he he healed for a moment then went into the next one but he's walking around says the yamara and this is the point it's very very important he's walking around with crutches on a walker so there's a beautiful I just saw a a very interesting Shiloh what do you guys think stop think about here a guy killed somebody but because he's a big macable and everything he was able to do to his amazing on the guy is he killed them the guy was dead for 10 minutes and he remembered what was the thing is yes or no you say no from Carlin he says from this gimbara he says it says he says I don't know you could pass based on these brushes but it just I thought it was cute because someone says that Alicia use machines then your partner like you said says that's what you're concerned about ideas no collect life insurance then you come back to live well they constantly conniving so you die it's gonna die you die for a week and then you go to your friend that does once you collect the checkout Force sometimes two months you went in the refrigerator oh you hear this so that's the case the middle case when do I go to the doctor to see to assess only in occasion the guy is going with the Walker but in the case where he died like in case one in the green case that he died straight through for even though there's a second mock Club but he never got out of bed you don't need it's a good get a boyfriend have a wonderful day have a meaningful fast