Daf Yomi Gittin Daf 16 by R’ Eli Stefansky

Mordecai so we receive a lot of these kind of emails but this one was a little different and actually made a bunch of guys cry I sent it to all the people that worked on the tri-state area tour and within a minute or so I got back three four replies and I have them here on the screen so like this they're a belly I don't even know how to properly thank you for how you're changing my life I tell you sharing a Terrace golden Borough Park even though I've never watched this year before I never dreamed that I would join but I was just curious to see what it would be like I'm mad at Yeshiva for almost 20 years with a very very busy life and other than occasionally studying homework with my son I pretty much have not cracked the safer for all that time in 20 years he hasn't cracked the safer besides when he functors with his child he pretends he knows better than the child really the child probably knows better than when the sheer in borrow Park was over and you had given all those reasons of cues of excuses that people give not to join I literally heard myself talking giving all those excuses I said it's enough it's about priority and I decided then and there I came over to you and I told you I'm a cobble and committing myself to every day it's been over 12 days so far but so far it's 12 out of 12 and I never I'm never giving up I used to always feel like an outcast and schwu's night and simchast feeling so distance from the Torah this year when I stayed up learning the whole night of schwizz I felt excited and part of the learning people I felt amazing thank you so much for what you do for me and everyone else and he says I'm in the middle of watching this year as we speak the most amazing feeling of finishing the first peric can't explain it haven't done that in 20 years like a flying you're talmud forever Mendel from Borough Park and then there's a voice note here from nasano he says it brought a tear to my eye and it was worth because we just came off a zoom meeting where we discovered that the trip probably cost us more than out of pockets for mdy more than fifty thousand dollars she says it's worth every penny and then it says over here I see you Mama shaking your head Avi and over here also from uh yossi Klein worth every penny and no that was from Saul Rosenberg worth every penny invested oh gave me tears that's from yasi Klein so so the mice is sometimes these emails you know not just they're not just entertaining but they're magazik the guys that are involved the guys that work really hard behind the scenes Tomer also saw this email and he he sent me a whole long thing spiel about this so you subscribe for the email thanks for giving us the kizuk and if you have a similar story why not share it give other people his belly I enjoyed tremendously you share thank you for this the photo attached is my father took me learning today's death with a real copy of it get my grandfather gave me he's a die in a Muncie the iPad is tagged kosherized only Torah anytime in aldaf David Kaufman your Tom and since mcgilla so this kid is doing it since Magilla unbelievable I don't know screens are not working Gary what's going on Mission ready good morning hot solo air good morning your boys because [Music] Hashem that I'm able to thank you for everything that I have this is we're down to one yeah success in all my Endeavors Joseph go bird lillianism and the third prime success in paranosa the art of the month for complete reforms oh I received a number of emails about that uh sponsorship that said uh whoever had a hard time in in the first parrot and then there was an explanation from the guy himself he said that he didn't mean the learning was difficult he meant that people that are going through akufa of divorce and separation this brought us to them for the explanation all right here we go today we're holding two four six eight ten of course 10 lines from the bottom of this following Bass asks go for you die into Horizon we know today we wash our hands even if your hands are tar you should wash your hands with a reviews of water or reviews of water even according to kazinish I think it's like 96 milliliters it's not a whole lot it's a very small amount it's uh probably like something like this amount of water what yeah but I'm I'm showing half you see the the water is not the whole cup okay and uh so it made law he wants to know based on the whole city that we had until now we said if one person comes and says the other person says could you be tired of two different people then the gamara asked yesterday what if you have a wall that's five somebody also sent an email I didn't have time to read all these names but he's just a kiss from Hashem he's learning himself a soccer and he just was learning the the sugar that he has a wall of Minnesota and then he dug out a tefach and the guitar system or it was dug out it's inside of one and nine and he thought it's partial but then when he learned our Sugi so it's not so simple because when you look from the outside it's only nine to inside his ten now he understands this will get better kiss from Russia fight so I'm tired what if you do half and half are the two halves with tires like we asked does one Aid who says and the other it says what about with watching your hands says tomorrow we're going through a nice Sugi here what exactly means half and half Elam the commercial Bay Tree miravius two people and this is going to be a bit because it's a lot of people can two people wash you fill up a reveals you do 96 milliliters in a the dime cup and two people wash from that cup each one takes 40 what is it 96 45 48 48 then whatever 48 each one takes 48 is that good enough or not what do you say you need 96 look at that Pockets right wrong each one as long as you fill up the cup says the gambara here that can't be the question that elf is asking is time this would be a big cash on those who wash and wash and you know you stand behind them in line and they're busy filling up more and more and more water all you need is one reveals to start out with then even two people if you start out with the right amount this year even two people it seems like from there you're showing them even if one person washed completely and he's done another guy has 48 left over milliliters he could also watch the second guy because he started out with the right cheer foreign [Music] from the audience I'm allowed to say whatever I want or to wash your hands 45 times this is that what's the biggest building 45 times so you need to learn more tired to understand that you're wrong reviews perhaps his Shiloh was like we do today he watched one hand and then he watched the other hand that somebody watches for you some guy Pours and you like like a lady pours with a client and you do both maybe if you do one-on-one it's no good no that's not that can be the question of us not I know the other he washes one hand from a cup and he puts one hand in oh he actually did a it's not I don't like this so much because it's not so accurate but here let's see what he has here here one hand been a Tila and one hand bishtifa now if this has to be 40 saw oh I put the 47 afterwards and it just okay now it came up the Rashi says he's talking about a river fine I don't know that this is the most accurate depiction of it but you get the idea one he dunked into a 40 saw a body of water like a river and the other he poured the water on and what's the halacha yada is in other words you don't have to do both hands in the same time they can be one after the other Velo commercial I just I wanna this is a public service announcement as usual when we talk about it this time I got to show you real quickly why is the TLC dime so difficult for people it seems like many many people are not yet many if you look around you'll see because all different stories that said that people are really not somebody said somebody put up an invitation to a bris this is how the story goes he put up an invitation to the briss and if you put up an invitation you invite people to Susan you have to come so that's why people are knowing not to invite for brisk but he did so people so some guy he went to the casino and said ready do I have to go I don't want to go he says don't worry the people there are not hugging because they don't wash their hands properly and they may look you don't have to something like that I don't know if it's a true story because there's another story they say that if the khazana's stories are all true it comes out that he lived 240 years or something because it's just it's impossible that all those stories happen to a single human being anyway so the reason why I put this on is because you must wash your hand although it's up to the knuckles if you're washing your hands you should go from here to here why is this so difficult I don't know most people you watch you watch people they go like this and it comes up to here to here go up to the wrist now another problem is they don't want to get their sleeves wet that's the threat so right over here something's the Miss or in the middle they miss that that's the big issue I think that's the big issue but it says something more like this yeah yeah finally you'll you'll you'll bring water for poor room okay now what happened was the guy went like this mom is like oh by the way you can't get this tape in America in there it's this role so I brought it all the way from America it's the blue tape they don't know about the stuff here especially the Arabs when they paint they're not it's a minute here they paint like a wall so they get a lot on the ceiling and a lot on the floor so you say what are you doing no no we'll clean it afterwards and nobody's ever cleaned it afterwards you go in all the buildings and I saw this always paint on the ceiling paint on the floor because it's in my blue tape blue tape works anyway so the guy pours the water over here and then he he uh he wipes his hand it's not and that oh and then after that's done he goes like this he takes it up with blue tape and it goes like this and then he washes this part so it's two parts the same hand two parts but each time he wiped it down if that's the case that doesn't work that's for sure no good so what's elephant's question I'm Gonna Leave This on we're talking about that the half a hand that he did remained slightly moist and then when he did the other half the midstarif the two halves come together why because one half has a little bit of moisture and the other hand they just poured a lot of water on you know what I'll take it off okay first he washed over here okay so now he puts the blue tape on where the blue tape is it's slightly moist so then when he goes and he washes the other half it's a good wash right because this moist and full wash it's dark but wait a minute that's not good enough that's not good enough but not it says this where boys I um gives me a lot to look at these uh depictions that Yoshi made the beautiful stuff just to look at nitsuke is on the right catafres is on the left it's the same idea they're identical so let's just see one you see that the wine from the top pit is spilling down a wall into the bottom pit the bottom pit is Tommy the top pit is tar so there's a connection between the two it was electric you'd get electrocuted if you're on the top but the wine on the bottom doesn't send and doesn't connect to the top well of or whatever that pit of water of wine even though the batter one is coming even though they're connected through the the wine that's going down here here's the wine going down you see that doesn't create a connection the same exact thing same just it's not going on a wall here you have a stream of wine from a tar Barrel going into the bottom barrel and they don't connect halocally so if they don't connect so why would your moist fingers over here connect colonically to your non-moist fingers that you're pouring water on the top of your hand huh oh yeah yeah yeah um so what you have here is two this would have been better I forget I whatever it's my it's my bed this would have been a better drawing for us just understand it's talking about two mikfest next to each other each one doesn't have 40 saw and they connect through a mask moisture that is not enough to connect so if you have Tommy food in one it doesn't liquids doesn't go to the other bar and if you want to use one Mikvah to be titled yourself and only has 30 saw let's say and it's connected to another mix of bar that has another tense uh 20 saw it doesn't it's not a good mix so why is it good for washing your hands when it kills the time says this has so much moisture like uh I love this Marshall I can't get it out of my head anybody that learned in the mirror went to the bathroom there knows they have towels hanging on the wall those towels they have a lot a lot of moisture in them from all the people that wipe their hands down on them to the point that when you wipe your hands on the towels it's very recommended to wash your hands in the sink especially I'm not you know this and if you've been there you know I'm not making this up there are people that blow their noses into those towels so lamai said has I'm saying yeah Miss what do you mean what do you mean you learned in the mirror and you've never seen it you are hanging around in the bathroom ask Abby he likes to hang out in the bathroom ask him Avi have you seen it you never went to the mirror anybody learned in the mirror and saw it anybody here I actually do have I have a picture of the towels here no but this is some guy's selling it I just looked it up on the internet if you you could you the guy's selling it you could buy these dowels they go in a circle you sold two towels together but he sells it it's a lot of money it's guaranteed to save you money on um on the towels on the paper towel stuff okay seriously in terms of Allah means that there's enough moisture let's say you take a uh here a plastic thing and you touch the object now there's enough moisture over here that if you touch something else you'll see the moisture oh so here's the suffix it's the exact same thing asks IL for a question what if I wash my hands up until here then I dried it off and then I only washed this part of my hand and then I drive whatever I don't have to dry you should dry it out do the two Washings of the hand connect now the first washing I didn't dry it off completely there's enough moisture on it that it's so moist that it could make something else moist and then I went ahead and I watched the second part of my hand do those two things are they met tariff to washing your hands why would he ask a question that we learned already we learned specifically if there's that much moisture then it's considered a Heber for washing your hands says maybe that whole Allah is only foreign this case you don't have four walls around this pergola so you pretend that the the rim around the pergola the top part goes all the way down Allah it creates a so over here also he's saying good as good as the water should go downwards and connect Ed and this is I'm going to show you how it works in a second in the picture it's not mikvision that's exactly 40 saw to the to the giraffe in other words if a person goes into the Mikvah and he has a bunch of water on it when he comes out because that's what happens when you go into Mikvah you are immediately gonna have a Mikvah that's slightly less than 40 saw and it's completely possible for a Mikvah foreign and two people here's the picture you ready here's a mix of 240 saw and two people went in and they both came out what's that the both tar why because when they were they were both in the mic for simultaneously and when they were in the Migos simultaneously there was 40 saw so they're both cautious but what if it's here's the thing first goes in yasi now when it comes out it's no longer 40 saw it's 35.4 39.5 he starred he has on him a half a salt water let's say now comes this other guy whose Tommy goes into the Mikvah with the get comes out and he still taught me why because he went into Mikvah that's only 39 and a half so rich and talk about Shani Thomas now check this out says look at this case Here Comes y'all see goes into the Mikvah comes out of the Mikvah but he's floating on top of the microphone he's still touching the mikfo so what do we have we have a guy we have a maker that only has 39. he only has 30 that's 39 and a half saw 39.5 in the mcfar I have a saw on yossi and a strimel but because he's touching the water we're gonna say that the water item goes downwards good aches and says if it's in the Mikvah and the Mela when this other guy comes in I don't know what his name is whatever his name is he's a nice firm guy with pace and a beard very smart individual he is tired because he just wanted to make about 40 saw you like him the second one is also tar oh oh so Milo um yeah so according to review though we say good access we don't really we still have a Shiloh because you're asking me maybe you say good actors on hands says no maybe we don't say good access on your hands when you watch maybe only see when it comes to Mikvah in this case but not in the hands that's why ilfa asked this question do we say good aches on hand you washed half your hand and this is moisture enough to make something else wet does that is that mysterious to the other part of your hand foreign the bottom line is where boys say after all this you should wash your hands correctly if possible especially tell your spouses and a lot of times the girls don't know these a lot because I see a lot of my guests they go like like it's the Yom Kipper you know like they only do the top of the fingers kind of thing and a little yeah water is very cheap these days especially if you filled up the whole thing you know pour the rest out what's the difference Omar Riviera Royce oven if a person uh goes his title himself in water that's drawn water not not make sure not from rain water the Target or let's say a guy took a shower with three lug of water Tommy so Rashi says this is one of the these are from the 18 halachas that were done that night and uh that day in the Attic when the Tamil of myself they came up with the idea is that we're concerned that if people go into the Mikvah now don't take this literally until today and we'll talk about today you go into the Mikvah and Rashi says these are going to very disgusting Waters in caves that's where they had their mcflies obviously they didn't have filtration and all that so it's really terrible water smelly water so immediately after dunking yourself in the Mikvah they would go and take a nice shower eventually what happened was people that Marathon started thinking that the shower is what to retire them not the Mikvah so they cut out the first part yeah this is what why go into the smelly water and take a shot I'll just take a shower straight so they made it that kind of that if you go you take a shower afterwards your tummy if it's that day that you wanted to make finger you poured on yourself you go into the mixame and in general if you take uh a shower of Logan your tummy okay now says that you should not take a shower there's a there's a people that say you shouldn't take a shower after you go to Mexico so you could be should be around it the villain going brings a lot a lot of cheetahs and he says that whoever takes a shower after the Mikvah has nothing to worry about but whoever is they take a shower beforehand in order not to make the water dirty for other courtesy huh beforehand and then they they don't because also they want the the water the douche of the water to remain on them there's another problem of taking a shower before diving doing its Trucking before diving so they don't take a shower before uh after usually no huh yeah it is fine but they they want they want me oh I don't know whatever someone do something don't huh yeah well it covers all different story that's people like like Toma or whatever a lot of unfortunately people that were there's a lot of people that are not religious that are destroyal to go to the Mikvah and uh during covert they stopped and it became a it's a big problem they didn't come back but what about this that discussion of of a Mikvah of of the eraser so they they say look higher you don't have to I think there are people that are uh not to take sheriffs but you don't have to and um when I say here yeah okay so by men there were men there were macmur it said stop there's a story about the Gary rabbit that he had a guy sleeping in his house for a while and he asked him he asked him you go to the mix every day he says and then it turns out he goes to the mix every day but he doesn't go into the Mikvah he just uses it for the shower but okay fine based on what we just learned that you shouldn't use water and everything would be uh what if he went into a like a a bathtub a bathtub of of drawn water the cat benefit my and then three look fell on half his body half his body is in the Midfield half his body had three look for on him is that a problem or not now if you notice it's riberia Mia and riber Mia starting from Aila Matthias and other plays in shots he always asks these very interesting questions like different oquintas different things okay tomorrow we don't know yeah because a lot of times these kind of questions technical questions like that and now we have another one or a part by Rihanna interesting I don't know if everybody's familiar but it's a famous Allah that even bismar is there if you can't get to the Mikvah person who's about carrier can't get to the Mikvah you could use t-shirt cab of mindshoven meaning you take a shower they say it's approximately four minutes I want to do the calculation for Teacher Cobb and came out to two minutes I don't know exactly why they say four minutes maybe for home depends on I know I know but I'm saying different pressure my shower it's one minute I get it I was doing like five four minutes but I guess because some people have really bad if you live in an apartment building you have these guys and all these properties they always come to sell you these devices you know you save a lot of water over a year you could save 400 million dollars if you put this one little device like I never paid more than a hundred thousand dollars for water no you could save 200 that if you put a little thing in there and it it fools all the ten and meanwhile the tenants hop right away and they take it off and you know they throw in the garbage whatever fine so depending on the pressure four minutes of of a shower water is also a tire or a person if there's no other makeup so it says now what happened Ezra said that you cannot learn Torah if you're about Carrie you have to go to the mixer so he says but if a person is sick he can't get to the Mikvah it's dangerous for him to go to the makeup so you should use t-shirt how are you I haven't seen you know I didn't notice welcome back Papa so as your papa the same question we have a good picture I think hold on let's find it oh yeah check this out oh no you ready what's the problem it's going to zoom here let's just do this real quickly here's a guy he's half in the Mikvah and half with maim shuvin what's style offer that's a republican same thing as we had before now I want to ask the oil of Shiloh here we have half maim shuvim have Mikvah doesn't work what about is this is this question I'm about to ask is it similar to what we're learning what if a person puts on on his head it's feeling of Rubino Tam and on his hand he puts film of Rashi is it the same kind of same kind of the question or not the same kind of question thank you what oh says what the uh some of these Farms say that's two separate myths it's no connection over here we're talking about Want Villa I want to be one tar through two types of waters one is mixed with water one is uh nine Cavs but over here I'm doing two minutes Russian yeah but then the same people that say that they say but wait a minute the rush says that according to Rashi Rabino time is completely puzzle and according to Urban rash is completely puzzle so then you're doing a styramid and it like you're according to both the other one is possible so you know you should you're not yelling to like that okay fine enough we had in the we had in the mishna says yeah one ABI Factory schmuck he testifies on the top and the Rashida testifies in about it what happened you want to see blade okay so I just want to show you real quickly this is our Sonia Al regalajas with a few more details what happens if if two people bring a get and they sleeping they were they were sent by the husband to bring the guest and they don't say before enough time so we have two two contradicting Australians listen to Karma says it's 100 caution and they're going according to rava that says the problem is to be mikaian to get so I have to to a the mirror they could be my kind to get all day long what's the problem the the second lotion says it's possible because they hold like rabba and you have somebody has to testify that they get wasma nobody testified nobody said anything they were just sleeping they brought it so let's see inside in the name both of these are in the name this case right over here when you have this is not working that's slow this case of ah the reason why it's possible in the missions because you don't have you don't have they weren't both Messengers only one out of the two was a messenger let's say Dr fact was the messenger the receiver was but if the get came and he was he was they they were both sent by the husband kosher [Music] even though they did not say Define it's caution you see what's going on there both of them were sent by the husband kosher sponsored by the Freeman Family for our sisters we're going to zoom or not let's try it huh it's late let's let's do the guy is waiting already for a week oh here he is you hear us hold on I see you now yes you got 20 seconds what do you got so I'm like what's your name where you from Las Vegas after 50 years 50 years yeah I learned that in high school Under the stewardship of that woman's brother and uh this that's the only also gives me a chance to see about the bar with my son Rob please cut them off cut them off Gary all right you still have 50 years so Mama's changed your life all right all right okay now we know who he is he's from Las Vegas and he didn't learn in 50 years I usually don't come to see them for less than 500 people but for Vegas we'll come yeah okay tomorrow we have seven minutes from the base which is plenty of time I'm gonna go sobering the foreign you see from here because the gemara understands that when the two are together it's kosher even if they don't say the fun enough to have enough again it's going according to according Rebellion holds like rava that the main part is to be mikhayam the star and therefore if there's one person if there's one so there's one consistent thing here throughout the whole sugya and this is I'll be Factor threw it out yesterday in Middle share the idea is that we shouldn't confuse get with we shouldn't make a mistake with other stars and think oh one person is enough but when a person says something funny which you don't say another star is you're not going to confuse the two okay that's the the theme there confusing the two not confusing the two I'll go upon him if it's true that when two people bring a guest from him they don't have to save a funny enough to have saved for dictating this case right over here about inside two witnesses testify on the sieve on the top of the gift that it was done because they're not both testifying on the entire get two are testifying about the top part of the get one is testifying about the bad Empire again it's possible very behoo them action according to what you just told me it's because they are not the husband but had they been sleeping with the husband it would have been a good gifts okay according to you it must be by approves it must be that the get did not come from doesn't send them they they they witnessed it but he didn't send them because Harry sent them it would have been a kosher gift according to what you just said to a them come they don't even have to save it yeah you're right so then the Gamora as somebody continues this question is if so how do you explain ribihuda but my pleading means what's The Spar of one of them the meaning what's the story review how in the world for you to say that a get that only has one witness and no neither of the come over here or from all three nobody said be funny enough to find enough time nobody could say that but you don't have one individual that could save so how in the world tribute to say that that get is caution isn't there a problem you're going to confuse with other stars of the world and make all the stars caution such okay but my pleasure means has a review to say such a case is caution says so people are not going to confuse regular stars and say they're going to say look this is a funny Star anyway to begin with there's two on the top one no no concern that people are going to get confused he says such a star is kosher so let's just go back to this thing just to so we have a clerk listen to comment says when two Aid them bring a get from hootslarge they don't even have to save it's kosher because we're going the team of the star is the most important thing of the game delicious gonna tell us no Corner such a get this puzzle even if two Aiden brought it and again because the concern is of rabba Rabb all the the whole reason why we have we found enough to have is for the Shema oh yeah we have a problem so let's see inside let's knock Reno Army law yeah 10 lines in the tab all right even if the get came from from then then nobody will confuse this kind of get with a start um everything is in Reverse from what we said before let me just get to there is even if they were both Aiden uh two sleeken came it would be possible they didn't say before they never found another yeah you're right but what is this foreign [Music] and this reminds us of you know the famous mclacasma I'm gonna say that the problem is and they didn't say anything these two witnessed these two they didn't say yes but they must say something they must say that it's they didn't so male it's possible um the problem is rava and guess what you have Perfect edemere Two martua them great says the gemara if so comes out that the Malik is of the atana and is very problematic because robin never mentioned rebuilding it's as if they made up their own rabbit says oh I hold the problems with Shema and Robert says my I think the problem is Adam Robert should say I hold like rib Yehuda that lived hundreds of years before me who says that the problem to save them he never mentions it so it's impossible to say that no you're right it's a big problem MMA law [Music] Rover so rubber check this out now that we go back to The Shard it's a little bit easier to understand Robin is going to just say chat in this homage this is like the listener camera what that is kosher that that even that bring again it's kosher why because I have a Kim star I have a Kim get I have two Aiden who say that they brought it in they don't even have to say before anything fun enough time there's no problem with according to Robert the problem is Kim here I have to weigh them that are gonna testify that they get as a good guy grab on my law a rap is gonna say and then wise reviews say that it's okay it's not that you're gonna confuse the two star the uh with a regular style rabbit no rap of course is gonna hold like himself the world rabba says Liz schmuckino [Music] foreign now let me just go back to here what case is this oh you see this case Aston Martin of a lift like Nami ribby who the biracial in this case when one person says and the other person says I'm right what's that apostle ask there's mushroom we have Allah here we know and what's the whole parabola that maybe they're gonna go back to kilco they're not gonna go back to kilko it's not gonna we're not worried about that the one day they're gonna go back you're right he does argue in that case and he says that case is kosher review The Matrix [Music] review the according to this only argues in this case and only in this case in that case it says kosher mashma that in the case he doesn't argue it's coming to exclude this case where he says I only saw the signatures and I didn't see the writing says I thought maybe in this case what happened he didn't see the writing of the get he saw the hashimasu again so I would think but since the River Youth is not concerned at all in in the case that we discussed before that it might go back even though they know about the Shema but maybe one day they'll forget about the small the Muslim people started maybe in this case he's also not good is it from marshmallow on it's my Nami and now they finally we'll finish on with this the mother says just like this the the second lotion here let's go back to the second last show what's the second lotion f2a then bring again from they are messengers of the husband and they didn't say before it's possible so here we go it's my name is so we have it's not so partial that it's cautious boys I have a wonderful day