Daf Yomi Gittin Daf 12 by R’ Eli Stefansky

my background when I left my Lakewood Taipei Shiva I also felt that baby was not for me as I needed to learn be Eon well day after day due to lack of time that did not happen in 1990 I received a complimentary ticket to Madison Square Garden to tend to see my shots who pretty much tied to death all these years and been learning to death for about 33 years now I'm on my fifth cycle I can say for sure the past 18 years I've never missed the line of gamara okay what's my secret always stay ahead never fall behind thank you more every single place you go throughout the day wherever you travel every doctor visit everywhere I really like your excuses people give not to do the stuff they all sound 100 valid but are really invalid by the way he has another excuse some people like me thought that everyone who learns enough loves to learn so if I don't like to learn I don't need to do the stuff but I know it's not true it's also not an excuse I want to tell you many people in Lakewood audience did understand the Biden joke but the boister's ones overpower the quieter ones that did get it Lakewood has changed a lot since you were born there and many businessmen professionals are making their home I know I get it I did it daily with art scroll but now Carlos said you should drive to work keep inserting the human to the doctor if it really helps the people to understand the importance of tamato but need to keep engaged in different ways thank you so much you heal mints sent in this picture spider and butter pocket king a man doing the duff while waiting in line to take a hasidisha haircut it's all Yura belly Gideon and this I got from Donny fine until I started learning that feeling with rebelli I never finished sphere with the Brava this is my third year in a row where I'll erase this one finished glamor with a bracha and this is where boys I no sorry so I got it from somebody else sorry apologize I was trying to give you credit ready wasn't due huh what was the guy's name Avi new nusephi the fousey is the one who walked from gimmel once a year he comes to this year he listens every single day but it's only been the live share twice once every year on show us when he walks in so I'm like what's your name again she left what's wrong Brooklyn you were there in the chair in Brooklyn yeah and he was there no way did he say that was a true story he said he's gonna kill me I didn't say his name I just said pink is the sun you hear this I said the mice of the princess's son when did you go after Derek hey rabbi love quotes is sitting right next to the I'm not gonna say his name Rabbi pinkos and he says like all my smash you just you have to find people that witnessed it magazine he wrote over here a line I want to read it to you real quickly it's 2023 and we're seeing the wonders of shim and foretold not just thinking which always war and still are the safety the positive boxes of the fire of our Sinai but in the weary jaded eyes of accountants School administrators restaurant Amazon sells and yes even eyes that have suddenly become bright again there's a revolution happening during the past decade or so Rabbi at least the fans could discover thousands of people who hadn't found the sheer cavusa format that worked for them who looked longer the custom shots gardening dust on their shell and wonder if it was even past that relationship ask him any one of them of any background in dress and you will see the answer even before they speak they are alive driven and euphoric now this line This is the line rebelli has no listeners or followers he has ambassadors each one of them exploding with gratitude at the gift they receive each day you're an ambassador you're you are not my Ambassador you do your own thing you're another person's Ambassador We're not gonna go there diravelli we are we were listening this year on githan and they had a shot over there but I like this part his name is Carlos and Zaki tabas from dabbas from Brooklyn New York Avenue O friends of Jacob ayal now listen to this blows a picture at 7 pm before the start of you see him in Boro Park we sat second row Center love it he got there an hour earlier to get the second row not the first the first is always too close no second and Center that I'm able to thank him for everything that I have yesterday was sponsored by shamshi slap frog what was the Lawson for all never-ending kindness I think of Stanford's never ending kindness the parents of the months if another parent is because I don't know that I have to read everything every stus that's put in here but I'm making macaw I'm going to read it making it in honor of harava going with Ellie's commitment to traveling the world to spread Tyra the the first words are not necessary taken from art of the month for complete review Ben Leo but boys I if you weren't you yesterday a lot of us were here just about seven hours ago Bobby Schoenberg himself was here and uh 20 people were here all the way till about 12 a.m a little bit after all those who were there three Sheeran within seven eight hours Vivaldi we're holding eight lines down we're discussing if it's a sauce if it's an advantage disadvantage a negative a pro I can't to be freed or to get a divorce so if a husband or Master gives a gift his wife through Australia he says here give this to my wife so that's the he goes to give it to her could that or he give the master gives a getchikura for a slave to get foreign he could do so he doesn't have to feed him but he cannot stop feeding his wife he has to give her support so therefore it's a disadvantage for the woman it's an advantage for the slave he can be free he has no disadvantage because anyway what are you gonna say by him being free he gained this freedom but he lost support he could lose the support as a slave also the the master doesn't have to support him says the immortal foreign so I just want to show you these terms let's become familiar with these terms these are new terms for the sugar terms that we haven't had yet and they're very very simple and with the Gamora come in guests the the gemara is going to go back and forth with these terms so it's kadai what's going on over there dollars you see that we're online we're good it's just that screen isn't that good okay the first term that we have to know and this is the whole entire Suga is the first line I say IMI venison can a master tell a slave I want you to work work hard work all day in the field I'm not going to give you one iota of food nothing zero you figure it out yourself can a master do that we're gonna go that's the whole so good we're gonna go back and forth could a master tell a slave work for me and work hard I'm not going to give you any food how in the world is it supposed to live He's supposed to knock indoors when he's done his his work at nine o'clock at night then he starts going from door to door okay that's how lucky number one it was a schnauer called Schneider a collector that's such a nice one guy came to collect money in America and uh he thought he was fundraising in America and the guy opens up the door and the guy starts berating him he says what's wrong with you get a job stay in your country why do you keep coming here why do you keep knocking on my door what's wrong oh back and forth the whole the whole Spiel and finally at the end he opens up his wallet and gives him a hundred dollars and then he says to the guy he says I understand something I'm yelling at you screaming at you I'm embarrassing you and you just stood quietly you listen you took it what what's going on what happened it says I'll tell you the truth is here you see this list this is the list of all the people drivers that we should go it says over here Mr brownsdorfer yells for three minutes then gives a hundred dollars so I was ready and I what's the most high school I believe it's a tremendous tremendous myself is that if we know that all the bushes and busyness that we get in this world is it's for the right thing so you get the bougie you take it like a man you take it because you know that at the end of it this is what's going to happen if on the other hand we don't come prepared so everything uh you get rattled up he yelled at me he embarrassed me this but no if you know that the yelling and the screaming is all good at the end you're gonna get paid well you'll be quiet you'll take it you'll you'll be smack no yeah go ahead go listen my business every day you weren't here last night mistakes in the gamara straight out bushes the Harpers okay so that's number one let's go back first thing we have to remember is the sugyo of assay IMI venison I am I want you to work for me I'm not going to give you any money the antidote to that is perhaps from all the rights that gemara brings as well not all but some of them maybe he's talking about a situation where the guy the master said not that I'm not going to feed you you make your own money and all the profits from your whatever you do with that you buy food the fact that I that I'm not feeding you is not a riot that I can tell you to work for me maybe you work for yourself and all prophets go to your pockets then we have another idea called loisapka that he works for himself but it's not enough he needs he needs extra support that for a woman for a slave maybe for that he could go back to the master and then there's the opposite hadoffah means that it takes about ten dollars a day to to feed a slave the slave earns 12 who gets the extra two dollars the master who gets extra two dollars okay these are the musagon and we're going to go back and forth with these Muslim not to be confused says gamara smash me no we're here from our mishnah because it says unfortunately that the master could just stop supporting the slave whenever he feels like it and therefore the fact that the slave becomes free is not a disadvantage because he could have that disadvantage regardless if he's free or not the message is just at any given time say I don't want to support you know okay so that's the that's the the headline of the sugar you see from the mishnu that the master could tell him I want you to work full time and I'm not giving you any food why why could it do something like that because a slave we could view a slave as no different than a cow a cow doesn't have a right to say hey support me I want you to give me milk do whatever I want and I don't want to feed you you die you die whatever it's not you're just you're just my belonging that's how you could view it says I don't have a Raya that the master could say something like that perhaps what's going on here is in our mission also that the master tells him go out and work and whatever you earn you buy your food with Suzuki Mario very good but then in our mission we have a slave and have we have a wife so it has to be one for one they both have to be equal because so then you have to say that the exact same thing would be by a wife though my Lord see my sister died from his other side you know that the husband is entitled to the wife's earnings the whole thing went through the whole studio but he's definitely to support her it says um you'll I am going to support you there's no there's no way out of this you have to support your wife so how does he how what is he saying he's going to say the same thing that he tells his slave he's going to tell his wife you go work you keep your own earnings and buy your own food so you shot my life so at the end of the day so why can't ubisoja in the get Isha for the wife what is she losing the whole reason why you can't acquire the get for the wife because you said you're saying it's a disadvantage for the wife because she's losing her support she already lost her support we're talking about a situation where the husband told her go earn your own money go go earn your own food I'm not he's not even supporting her so the fact that she gets divorced it's not a loss for her because we're talking about a case where the wife doesn't earn enough to support herself you're saying it's one for one the wife and the event have to be the same exact situation and just like the wife you're telling me it's a story where first of all he told her go earn your own money and take that money and buy your own food but it's not enough for her to be supported so he has to add a little bit more from his own and therefore you can't divorce her without her will you can't be a Schleich without her telling you to be asleep because it's a disadvantage for her she's losing that a little extra so too you have to say the same thing by his life Evan not maybe about yourself he's talking about a situation where he can't earn enough says anymore that's impossible why because I have the the crazily shavier if his he's not even worth the bread that goes into the stomach muscle said they picked up a slave for what to feed him he doesn't even earn the ten dollars that it costs to support him why do they need him let him go free so obviously you can't say that the slave can't earn as much as as he's working that's impossible that's not that's not a slave by a wife you could say that touch them out I'm just I don't know if I even should say this one of my our we all know this person but he's a very very good friend of mine and Mendes and I was in his house I said it's Misa and I wanted to plug in the light that was giving shears I was going to plug in the light into the outlet he says Ah he starts screaming I said what he causes Abram Abram the guy comes like Mario plugged it in and I like I imagine I still thought it was it what happened by then the meaning is you know what yeah you call Abraham he does it he comes home from show it has a whole breakfast spread I might slice the vegetables the egg the whole thing everything it's the first time I I understood what it means it's in a different country not here huh Abraham you cannot plug a thing in it's like the the Union in New York you're not gonna plug it in they have to plug it in okay Mario good old days sleeping now so you can say whatever you want seriously you're safe uh was up at 4 30. no that was Yoshi Yoshi was up at 4 30. you also have somewhere around there what time 4 10 this year came out he had to do two rooms and he wanted to do the second chair before the first year because the second year was that field and the second and the first year was Davido so you had to wait until the second she was over in order to start okay is there a tissue around here somewhere yeah things are not going well see you don't have the seven smile okay again what's the question we're going back to this question could I tell my slave work and I'm not going to give you food you figure it out yourself here you go beautiful there's a whole chart here there's the six official Ari McLeod you can see exactly where they are two four six they line up beautifully throughout our destroy if somebody kills someone Bishop by mistake he has to go to army clock otherwise the the relatives could kill him so a slave killed somebody by the way we're talking obviously I I didn't think we have to say this but it's there's two different types of slaves we're talking about anany over here the whole song is a a Jewish slave has completely different Allah it's not you don't own him like a shark there's no Shiloh that you have to you have to feed them etc etc there's also Allah by the way at the end of the day as much as the gamara sounds you know really tough in it we have Allah how you treat your even your eviction you should feed him the same food as you you give your your pillow or maybe the pillows by everything okay back up on them every day we fight back upon him the Irish the certain ways that you that you but okay what can you do he can no longer work he had to run away to the irony Club Aiden rabbit Kyle designer the master doesn't have to feed him this is you have to work all the earnings that you may go to the master and the master doesn't have to give you any food at all you see over here that he could say so work and I'm not going to support you how can my skin is so go right back to this antidote no no Ryan maybe he told him you work and with your earnings you'll support yourself if so if he told them that you take your own earnings and buy food with it so why should the master get any of the money he needs the money to buy food he doesn't need all the money he only needs ten dollars a day the guy made twenty dollars a day so the extra ten dollars goes to the master well if we're talking about extra money it's his slave of course anything extra goes to the master says You're Beautiful on a day that he doesn't find work the master doesn't have to support him because he made a deal with him you work and you support yourself so what if he has a slow day then he didn't earn enough so when he makes extra he made twenty dollars instead of ten maybe take the extra ten dollars put it in a in an account for where he has a weekday and then use that money on a weekday that makes a lot of sense no I made a deal with you you work and with the money buy food so what every single day I'm gonna make a husband Maria every single day we have to see how much money you earn if you earn more money than your food it goes to the master I tomorrow you're you earned less than the food and you're gonna be in a deficit and you're gonna have to go collect go collect but today you have extra money give it to the master commercial and goes to the master um Laurie McLeod now why are we talking about uh ear mikla that we're talking about a whole story if he told the slave I say I want you to work for me I'm not going to support you what hold on a second no if he told me the story I see him even on venison and he went to the Irma cloth oh my soulary McLeod so just because he went to our McLeod so that's why the hadoffa should be for the slaves says you are like this right so what's just what what difference does it make that he went to the ear Mickler why should it make any difference to the extra money that he earns so gamara says because the possible of the sugar the guy that kills Michelle look what it says and the last word is what we want but it says is for people that foreign no he doesn't get the extra had off but later on in the rise it says there's another story a woman a wife who had to go to the amygdala because she killed somebody the husband has a supporter so obviously he didn't tell her she might see a diaper he didn't say go support yourself because the Omar law because if he did say your earnings should go towards your food I'm not going to take your earnings then why is it 5 to supporter we're with the Savior the Lord or my Law And since by a wife he didn't say it rationale so obviously by slave also didn't tell them right they go one for one whatever happens by the wife happens by the slave and by the wife we just proved that he didn't tell her support yourself so by slave he also didn't tell him to support himself he did tell them in both cases he told him but his wife we're talking about that she didn't earn enough money to support herself she earned 90 and therefore he has the supporter for the extra amount and by his life we said that doesn't happen because if you have a slave that doesn't earn as much as he's worth let him go one minute later on it says that if he told her go earn your own money and buy your own food that's okay so you can't say that he did tell her and he did tell a slave because at the end of the price it's talking about such a case so the beginning he writes he's not talking about medication we told him to do your own your own food this is what the saving means if she earns it off and he says go earn go do your own go go buy your own food then it's okay my spec is now let me ask you a question let's say a woman has a great job she's a lawyer she makes a lot of money could the husband tell her I want you to be a cleaning lady go go wash the stairs and then the different buildings that we have here we have is it permitted she earns a lot of money says this pausing by the way I believe I don't know for sure this is either the most hated possum girl or the most beloved it's a positive the year hundreds and hundreds of times maybe dozens of times a day sneeze this is what does it mean that since Jewish women are princesses they belong in the house a princess doesn't go out and then and and mingle with people and work and clean staircases they're supposed to be in the house because she's a princess Pastor to be to be inside Milan that the husband can tell her no I don't care about this Apostle you know you go you're right you're in the area club and you don't have your clients that usually have and you don't earn the way you usually earn that you could be home work from home you know what too bad go out and earn your own money go out in the street and do whatever you need to do to turn money but this is a famous mice I'll say it again there's a girl in Austria who had a very very nice voice and so she was in the fruit family but she people asked her you have such a great voice why don't you sing for women her father was not happy about it so her father brought her to the competition and the rabbit told her listen you're right I logically you're probably allowed to sing it from the women but I'm telling you that if you don't do this and you you stay you stay uh sneeze whatever I promise you you're gonna have a son that's gonna be the light of Clyde Israel and who is the son um foreign special situation we're talking about famine there's no food anywhere so a slave could tell his master you have two options either you give me food or let me free so if we just look at it right now what's the opposite of parnasseni you have two options either feed me or if you were right in the gamara what would you write what's the opposite of feed me free me there's another option in between what oh work for food either feed me or allow me to work you don't have to free me but allow me to work for my own food but that's not what it says here the event could say one or two things either give me food or let me free that's all I remember starve I don't care I'm not feeding you my lovely so maybe this is good for them he could say well myself and Robin Leo says you don't have the option to tell your slave starve either you feed him or you let him free he says bro but is that so hi or your parents I just made a charter in case you want to see parasaili what's the opposite no what it should be in the dark blue particini or say mycode that's a to work and I'm not going to give you anything is work for yourself and buy your own food service isn't that famine you don't need famine in the world he has a personal famine his his master just told him work all day long and I'm not giving you any food that's famine so why do you have to come on to a situation of famine foreign and because we're talking about famine so as much as he works he's not he's not earning enough to support himself representing release so that's why it says free me because we're talking about something about sources famine and because of famine it makes sense that he's not earning enough but the point is says that if he was a slave it's famine things are very tight for everybody nobody wants to give Ducker to a slave yes you're right he's Hive him this is like a woman blah blah blah it's a mitzvah but it's difficult to give it to Darko if I'm gonna give this dog I'm going to give to the guy that looks really Jewish not to have a Jew ish people like me yeah the famous myself the guy goes he's trying to collect money he sees that the guy in chills doing much better than him he listens he says he hears the guy says dockets.com so he he decides oh it's a good idea he goes around he tells everybody I'm again things are picking up it's very nice the next day you see is the guy's making much more than him so what since the guy says I'm the intercoolerable oh people are giving you schmuck so this he starts going he goes I'm again but so this this never yeah he's a he's a vet I don't know what he is he's a half a girl they don't want to give him Leo you have to you have to let him free Dr um no I just thought it's a mice I don't know it can't be a true story there's a message a guy came to him he says listen I need a Yeshua whatever you said naturally here she says whatever I don't have I don't have any money I don't have a dime so you don't have money how did you get in here uh what she also okay I'm saying if you ever went to um what I'm just like it okay rub on inside every Monday no you know you're gonna give you're going to give a regular year they're going to give this the seventh I I never had the opportunity to see one of these but they're very Jewish in a way you know the moments like women The Hive in all Mistress of a woman they can't do any others they're Jewish again we're trying to figure out if a master could tell a slave I say I want you to work to the Bone and I'm not gonna give you any food sounds mom is true so we have a dilemma over here a person says I want to give my slaves hands to hegdish so now what happens everything the slave does with his hands become a major major problem how in the world is the slave gonna eat he's no longer the Masters the master gave him up to attack this here the the hands of my evidence he can't eat from hagdish why because you can't eat food from Agnes haggis doesn't have the right to give its own slaves food from its own it's hegdish so he's gonna go earn money and buy food that also doesn't work why because every money he earns goes immediately today so we have a proud catch 22. what does he do the answer is that he works at the end of the day we're gonna see he works and every small part that he earns right before he becomes a pruta becomes his that's not hegdish because heck this only works on a Pluto and that's how so he borrows money the gemara says he has to borrow money now he owes money to Reuben so every time he earns a little bit less than a proof that becomes Reubens before the best of English has a chance to grab it foreign so again the slave is working all day long for the base of mcdosh and he doesn't have food why doesn't he have food doesn't the master have to give him food the answer is no the message doesn't have to give him food so he's working he's not getting food it's a Raya that I say in me venison says perhaps I don't have it right maybe the master gave him food he wants to have his question if he gave him food yeah why does he have to borrow money teeth what does that mean because let's say a human being could survive on 800 calories so the master gives him 800 calories the the the slave is going to be starving all day long what are they eating in the in the concentration camps a couple hundred grams of bread and then potato soup so you could survive on 800. but it's very very painful the slave doesn't want to he doesn't want to survive in 800. he wants to eat at least 2 000 calories so for the extra 1200 calories he borrows money and he pays it back says so it was sponsored by Freeman Family for our sisters until now when you're under the master you ate 800 calories and that was enough for you you survived rational numbers property what now you need 12 2 000 calories because now they have a nice schmuck a slave that works better how could he work and pay it back every time he earns a hundred dollars it goes straight to the heck dish says he makes some sort of deal where every less than a proof that he earns goes immediately to the lender because RAV says rap says listen to this we have to remember this wrath who's gonna have a contradiction Raph says if you make your slave's hands heck dish the slave he works and he eats and he says if he won't work who's gonna feed him who's gonna who's gonna work for him but we have a contradiction arrive right over here Rob says and what does he say over here uh what happened two lines from the bottom oh I saw your Avid live he works he gives everything to hagdish and he works and the he pays back over here it doesn't say that he he pays back that he does it all he does is he works for himself and he and he eats it doesn't say that he has to borrow money and pay it back is going to say like this if you say the rap holes that you cannot tell a slave I say immigration you can't and that's what rap holds you can't tell a slave I say maybe on his uncle Rebecca can hold you could rap says he can't that's the end of this not yet but that's what we're gonna get it then so RAV holds you can't you can't do that so in the ratio it's talking about that the master gives the slave food so you give them food his hands could become hectish because he fed him well he's feeding himmela I can make his hands haggedish and the slave is not happy with the 800 calories so that's why araf says let him borrow money let him pay back but of the safer is the fact that he didn't give him food and he has to give him food he didn't give him food so if he didn't give him food then his hands do not become hegdish if his hands don't become English so he works for himself and does whatever he wants that makes a lot of sense if you hold that you cannot say I say I cannot tell my slave to work so let's see inside so we have a contradiction between rap on the one hand Raph says he should borrow money and pay back and on the other hand he says don't borrow don't worry about it just work and take the money and pay and pay for your food even though the master set your hands are eggless says talking about that it gives him food because he can't say he cannot say I say you can't tell a slave to work and then worry about your own food you have to provide food so in May law the first price is talking about where he gave him food and therefore what his hands become Magnus and the extra he works for and he pays It Off the second brightness where it says that just work and pay for your own food is talking about where he'd never gave him food so if he didn't get food his hands don't become hectish shapir that makes a lot of sense but if you say that according to Rav a person could tell a slave go five go work all day long and I'm not going to give you any food now that is a problem how do we understand the safer so the duration hitting him food but he could say it so anyway what's going on here who's gonna help him who cares who's gonna help him that's not our concern I'm allowed to tell my slave go work and I'm not gonna give you food why does rap stick in who's gonna help him according to rob you see from here that a master cannot tell a slave I'm not gonna provide you food if you work for me you must provide food if he works for you and therefore there's no contradiction between the rage and the safer tashma now we have everybody that says the opposite if a person chops off his friends slaves hand noise and shifter through fossil rabbi so let me just show you real quickly here's a Slave and you did whatever it's not so accurate this picture but basically he destroyed his arm so what happens if you destroy your your friends slaves arm so there's five things that we learn through our chance to give somebody that you damaged his body nezek is the permanent damages you have to give him permit you chop off a guy's arm now he can't work anymore in construction so you have to give him a million dollars Tsar all the pain and the pain you have to give repoy is all the medical expenses although the doctor bills and the surgeries and everything you have to pay chevis is lost income so we're talking about repoyan Chavez medical expenses and all the Lost income says Rashi even somebody that just lost his arm and he's in a lot of pain he could still he could put him on a field of kishorium of cucumbers and let him sit there and watch the field how much does he earn a day ten dollars a day so pay him 200 for that loss voices were not discussing the bottom one why because we're not so sure that uh that there's an embarrassment to a slave okay if you chop off the hand of your friend slave noise and shifter fossil rabbit basically we're discussing all the four but we're only going to talk about too yet you give the Lost income the shifter and the medical expenses to the master voice and that slave gets fed from the DACA I mean oh what do you see from here I'm taking all the income all your medical expenses everything everything and I tell you go figure out your food on your own he just lost his arm he's in in bed he has to go knock on doors with his other arm that he has same thing over and over right now we're getting familiar with it it says the word Nissan means the basics you get the basics from the darker it's not talking about but he's talking about the the extra I so Rashi sticks in over here because he's sick he needs a little bit extra he needs more food whatever to make him strong that is he went to this doctor says it's a wrong word nizu means basics it shouldn't say that it should go for the basics I should say the basics he gets from his master the the paranaso the extra the additional that is see from here that you could tell Rebecca holds you could tell your slave work all day I'm not giving you any money noise and shift to reverse of the rabbi shifter lost income of course goes to the master why not that's why he has a slave to produce income why should the master take the medical expenses unfortunately to eBay he needs to heal his arm what do you mean you're taking that money how's he gonna heal his arm says uh beautiful what happened was that all the doctors came together they said it's going to take this guy five days of treatment they gave him a very very intense dose which is very painful and causes a lot of aggravation and it only took three days to heal him mouth the same out tired maybe he took that extra dose and he had a lot of pain maybe he should benefit from that gain hamash Milan that he's like a like a like a hamar he's like a guy he's donkey cow any extra benefits so you gave the cow extra shot and it hurt him and he jumped so what the extra benefit goes to the master there's a interesting Child by room Silverstein a guy caused a lot of damage to somebody's car now here there's this role if you go to the stahim you go to the Arab Villages you can do the same job for half the price if not less I did it once I didn't want to go in you send this they have no fear of those guys they know everybody they take your car they come in they go out you get an Arab job back it's givaldi your friend your Fender falls off after three days but it's half the price they also they know how to if you're missing a fender they come entire destroy they take another Jewish Fender and they put it on your car so he had a Shiloh he caused two thousand dollars worth of damage but he knows how to go into the and get it done for a thousand dollars since he took the risk of his life could he tell the guy it cost me two thousand dollars pay me two thousand and then I'll fix that so resolution passing he could because he's taking the the all the all the risk and everything so you could take you could take the initial whatever the amount is in Israel fine next he proved it from this gemara the proof was from here that you could tell a guy listen it costs it should typically be five but I want to do it a little extra and a little faster and I the master takes the profit so over here the owner of the car takes a profit you know what I guess we will just stop over here unfortunately but tomorrow's a shorter death Rabb boy Sai have a wonderful day