Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 92 by R’ Eli Stefansky

here we go good morning rabboissai how's everybody doing it's a wonderful day here in ireland disro lilly nishmas mordechai we have three sponsors today by mark stroh for his for for slammer for his wife who is having surgery this morning and by john badler who i miss dearly my basketball cover reforest mikhail saraba i mean could you imagine we haven't played sports and i don't know what is it since chavez def cup udalloff it's a long time we're all out of shape it's not revived no i'm you don't care you're like all excited yeah good for you guys no he's to play with us until he injured himself keith ryan listen to this right boy's side we have people that mama should listen they take things seriously here in honor of the election of joe biden and kamila harris and hope for the smooth transition and peaceful transition of power i don't think keith is in real estate you could tell but i asked for it i said reboy size spans for joe biden so here you go rabbi said the seal coming up sunday november 22nd less than two weeks from now um we're doing the same format as last time get together with your buddies you know who they are we're not gonna make all these lists like we did last time was a big big hassle but if you don't know who your buddies are you're new to this you don't know who's in your neighborhood and where the cm is get in touch with me with yeshua he'll get you in touch with your local see them so once again you could be mistaken in a local city do your own thing at home by yourself you could go to belarus there was 70 people last time you go to the cave the cover of the rebbe you go to ponovich you go to the kaiser we had somebody kevin rocco this human all over the place you'll find your place trust me and the final day for the aerov video is tomorrow so if you are interested in doing a local area of tour and show us your community and your area of and perhaps there's some hidden that we can learn on the way so let us know by tomorrow yeshua kayak real quickly yesterday i had tremendous kazook i think a lot of you as well we were on zoom in the middle of sheer i realized that steven sokolow is watching this year and after sheer he told me something incredible it's very scary actually he works in a nursing home and he lost patience just now but not only that he lost two staff members young ones two 40 year olds in the last few weeks and he himself is very sick he's in the hospital so we got to wake up a little bit we're taking it easy yeah it was that was by pesach time two young people that he knows from his facility including himself who's sickness you know he's already out of it i hope and what's very interesting he once they couldn't get him a positive test on kovit the doctors were convinced he had coveted but they couldn't get the positive and therefore they couldn't give him the medication the what is it called the remnant severe whatever it's called once they gave it to him within an hour he said is anyways here's our tremendous cover stephen in the hospital with a half a smirk he's looking a little disheveled but bar hashem is able to watch this year also we had tremendous quizzes yesterday hillary kamiyanski on his flight to the states i believe watching this year so physical around real quickly rabbi so you're probably wondering where's our tremendous harvard lauren spiegelman where is he nobody's seen him and i don't know how long i know you haven't seen or heard from me in a long time renault checked in with me recently i told him i want you to know i'm still in the sheer but every year until i fell a bit behind many people fell behind on yantev i know your sheet is to jump right in wherever the dab is holding you make up the missing document all the time but i really feel i'm holding you i really feel you it's your choice but i really feel that the community important for understanding uh missing doubt and later when i'm not gonna see anymore will be too hard he wants to have i get okay i hear what he's saying so after circus i picked it up again and youtube from where i left off so i'm training behind a little but i still it's all about the yummy from today i started at 6 30 a.m so i can do two dap in the day until i close the gap and catch up so mr shaman will be back on zoom or better yet back with everyone at mdy in time to finish everything with you and the so we're looking forward and then he says meantime i'm glad you're nervous so thank you for the eight minute daff and the 600 charts and everything so in other words he did watch yesterday's dive i'm not exactly sure and then he says um he said i don't even have this printed but he said that if i do say this in sherry probably won't hear it for a few days so i don't know my mother he saw yesterday okay whatever it is so we're we're happy to hear i was thinking about it it's exciting when a new person joins the sheer but the hurt i was thinking like where did this guy go this guy mama feels i get i i feel bad like what happened to that guy was the share that bad that he did so remember when you decide to leave the sheer for a little bit you should know you're hurting me personally on my letter of vanilla avashi we're holding today is the base last last words on the colorful base so we're talking about the sheet of ribbon says that all outdoor areas ghotzer gaga karifa they're all considered one the one category and i could carry from one to the other and in addition to that in a review where there's no way roof mama is counter-intuitive no a-roof there's no error there's no concern that i might take something out of my house and bring it to another hutter but if there's an era of very problematic ask the gemara ravina toravashi who's ravinir ravashi the authors of shas both of them they wrote the gemara so they said to each other ravinithas were bashing their version really say that looks like shaman now we have a contradiction if i could prove to you in a mishnah if the mishnah says not like rip shimon and the mission is an anonymous mishna then we have a contradiction because ruby can always positions like an anonymous mishna and the mission seems like not like rip shipment and that would be a contradiction to rebecca who just said that like what's an anonymous addition we're very familiar first of all you have to know the rebirth there are others who don't hold like this damage very and we say it all the time i'll remind you you have a wall in between two katseroys and this fruit on top this is a solid wall this is fourth white and therefore it separates the two katseras i cannot carry from one to the other down here if there's fruit on top what's that you need to do separate room you can't say that these two khat series are one there's a solid wall between them this is the division what if this fruit on top we went back into the yoni picture even though it's not color but it's beautiful it's two geshmaki kids eating fruit on top of the wall as much what it says here island you see he even made a little brick here they get up onto the wall and eat on the wall and that's where they eat they're literally eating over the wall and they can't bring the fruit to them now what would rip shipments say in this case this wall is a rosh before it's an outdoor area you could carry from any outdoor area then out the air what's the problem you go from a hot so according to shimmy should be able to take the fruit off the wall and come down here eat it eat nicely what do you have to eat like a like a i don't know my grandmother used to tell me so you can't if you eat standing up your feet will get big i don't know what your company's a problem to eat when you stand up ireland the halo island mccann valley clinton eventually you read the la mata it's a problem so this is a very big problem for a birkhand so what's rebecca gonna do he's gonna have to wiggle his way out of this a little bit he's gonna have to explain the mishna to fit in with rip shimon otherwise he has a problem but he thought about this when he passing like from shimmer he knew about it so what did he say my la mato la mata la batem it doesn't mean they cannot take the fruit off the wall like in this picture of course you can take the fruit off the wall we're passing like we can take a fruit from the wall to the to the concert to the carafe to the gog i could take it on the roof if i want what it means to say don't take it into the house we spoke about it yesterday a lot you can't take we just said it this morning when we started you can't take something from your house into a khatzer into another khatu so you can't go reverse also you can't go from the wall to the house you can't go from the house to the wall so that's the concern be careful you're gonna take your fruit off the wall and eat it don't bring it indoors why and it's a big i mean you have to warn people what you're allowed to do is you're allowed to take it from outside areas so you go from a cave together car five and go all the way to the mikvah do whatever you want but don't bring it indoors and don't bring it from indoors outdoors that's already a different area that's the kids oh that's the gemara of a tony river theo now who's rebecca rabbit here is a talmud of ruby echelon and oisia are known to to have the brices the perfect brices their brices so anything that rebbe didn't bring in the mishnah rebrea would bring in a bryce so he added a little bit so so if he says something it's very it has it it carries a lot of weight it's not just a bryce from another uh a town or whatever here is standing right there don't move he says specifically don't take it off the wall there's no mention in taking it indoors the the concern is you're gonna take it off a wall eat it on the wall like yodi's picture just lean over and eat right there a malay a very interesting lesson from the mishnah you didn't see this rebbe the author of the mishnah didn't write in the mishnah it says uh yeah shalom you read the lama it says don't take it down where did repeal get it to write in the in his brain who told him that that's what rebbe meant so we're sticking to it rebecca is sticking to his shot in in the mishnah la mata means to take it off the wall bring it indoors into the house who told to write it so now we have a very interesting shiloh we know that you're not permitted to go from a hotzer that has an a-roof according to your birch that doesn't have in other words we're concerned that if you have an aero you might take things out of your house and bring them into the hotzer and from there you'll move on to another hotter if you have an earth what about the reverse what about bringing something from a place that doesn't have an air roof into your house that has an error is that a problem so that's what we're going to be discussing here in a roundabout way so you have two katseros on both sides and there's ruins in the center it doesn't matter who owns it they both own it together somebody else owns it here's an x this guy did not make an error of check this guy made an a roof now with the counter-intuitive thing that we learned yesterday who gets to carry where the guy that did not make an a-roof according to rav he has the upper hand because there's less hashash that he's going to take stuff out of his house and bring it to another khatu he's not carrying he knows he can't carry so my melo says the gemara omar ravuna which rashi points out right away he is a talmud movement of rav nice to nice of the zoo so based on rav i give the ability to carry within this horrible to the x to the guy that didn't make an eight roof avalanche this guy since he has a lot of stuff going on here look he has a lot of uh has laundry hanging here all different stuff basketballs bats all things in his huts or bikes he since he made an aero it's very possible that he might take something and bring it outside to a place that doesn't belong to into the corv dilma sila the son of rav we had in this mistake the writer of huda was teaching here the son of rav and rav overheard you know the son of raph he says in the name of his father this is what my father said afalis not true both of these guys are equal that's all rav said af there's no difference between the red x and the green check it could mean two things it could mean they're both us or none neither of them could carry here or can mean they're both multi which one is it first shot in the gemara is vishte in asuras that's an addition that that was added by the sun my father said that there's no difference between the how the khatsuri that has an aero and the hudson that doesn't have an aero and therefore i'm telling you they're both awesome why what's the safari they're both awesome maybe you'll say what my father meant is what's the logic now it's clear says that my father said here if we take the same picture my father said that it's us or to go in this direction from the one that has a check it's us to carry over here so what are you gonna tell me that it's multicarry over if we already know that it's also in one direction and they're both equal so they're both us are you can't take this away everybody agrees that raph said that you cannot carry from a house or hutter that doesn't that does have an a-roof you can't so if you can't so and and raph said they're both equal so they're both user says the gemara no perhaps even in this case rav agrees that this is not true that it's multi to go in this direction why what's the swara awesome keep in the middle monitor over here in the typical situation where people put their bikes outside and there's a concern you're going to carry from here to there great but when we're looking at the ruins keeping the lamentary one of the hats since nobody leaves anything over here it's dangerous to leave your bike over here it's going to get stolen the whole swara of rav is that i'm concerned i'm going to carry from one place to the other you don't have that concern but mela then it doesn't matter even if there's an arrow in that sir i'm not i'm not worried i'm going to carry over there i'm not going to leave anything there that's not a that's not a place that i could leave stuff so maybe i don't have that concern so maybe he meant that in both directions it's smothered not also the name of his father said when you have a khurvan the center both both are motor to carry into the horva this guy even the guy that made it and what's the safari the same story we just said a second ago and if you say no they should both be awesome because at the end of the day rav agrees that you can't go from the hutzer that made an arrow that way that's not true awesome that's only in the regular case giving them in the remainder of the batten bakata since it's normal for people to take their stuff out of their house and put it in a cutter why because nobody steals from a hudson you could keep a good eye on it le charitable rabona dos lapuke there we have a concern rabonan said don't allow it because they made an area of you might come to take your stuff from your house to another khatu al-bahr the inventory however in ahurva there's no protection and therefore they're both motor add can says another mishna that we are very very familiar with oh hold on a second we've got to do some david handlers here in nakamoto joe berry sham alaikum how are you mark astronauts i'm not going to talk about oh joel from los angeles is on i don't see his face aries lasky boy i got to see who who we're talking about over here what's going on official i haven't mentioned your name in two months sham alaikum i see you every day though how you doing and uh let me see if my guest was here where's my guest no anybody see replacing waxman i don't see him all right he's on he's on okay he came to visit yesterday all right there's a gracious host crisis he's hillel and avi and ellie's principal from los angeles says the helicopter this mishna has a lot of ramifications as we're going to see on the base many allah has come out of this mishna and that is that if you have a large roof a wide roof going into a smaller narrow narrower roof gaga so let's look at this gag for a second you have the wider roof leading into the smaller roof or the smaller roof leading into the wide roof now if you look closely at this picture the roof has let's say for argument's sake the larger roof actually has four walls one two and you could consider this a wall it's partial here you have an opening now back in the day a couple days ago noam asked me in the middle of share what about this opening is it wider than 10 or narrower than 10 i said it must be narrower than 10 and he said some something about him eerie in fact there's a rashi here that says the ain't happy to yo sir esser i looked up the me iri i'm not exactly sure if that's what he said but the meri seems to say that in addition to the fact that it's not then there's also another that has to be [Music] fine nothing rabbi rashid says that this gap and this is how we're going to go it's not important to the wholesuki but the gap is less than 10 fahrenheit than but what you have here really is four walls with an opening we'll call this opening a passage it's a doorway because it's less than ten but if you look at the small guy he only has three walls one two three there's nothing going in this direction so he's wide open he's oymed alapaar is parts into the mid so mellow it's awesome for him to carry he's he doesn't have him he doesn't have a roof also for him to carry carrion here this guy is able to carry this is nothing this is just a side room to the to the larger to the larger uh gag says the mishnah and the same exact halacha without any we had a whole extensive sugar in here finally we have the mishna now a few a few important things here here's the lashon picture here's the gag guddle and here's your little ghifufe they call it right this small wall and you can invoke you apply the concept of good assay these walls go up and they close it off that's one thing the very important i love that i didn't mention i printed it out back then when we're learning it but here here's the mission so we can talk about it tyson's in general holds because of the issue the smaller roof is perfect what's the problem it's okay so you can't really see the wall but it's therefore he learns and if you look closely it's a beautiful picture the wall of the small one extends into the larger one i don't know if you can see it great picture from kala alashan we're not going to go more into it but just to point it out that the the walls extend because if they were if they stopped here in this corner like my original picture then the cotton the small roof would have its own walls yes no it has to be a cleat that's on the gog you can't bring a cleave from your house to the god no that's what you mean you could what are you shaking yeah yeah i looked at what's rashi rashi says look at rashi two lines before the end of i actually underlined it maybe that's what you're saying hold on i have to read the whole thing how are you learning it [Music] um i don't know that it means that that it came from the house i don't know okay so i don't understand something the the words right before this who could go in they ain't appeared to the isometer because i got you from those words and you have to get me from the next words okay fine i hear so you're telling me you're okay say that you're saying that the the kingdom came from the house they came from the house to your own god oh yeah yeah right so timeout according you could go from so you're saying you go from your house to your gag according to remember you cannot go from the house to the god okay fine but according to so here once again it's not a great picture but we i don't know if you recall this picture we used this a lot in the beginning of the misata here's the larger hutter here's the smaller hudson you can see the gefufe here's the wall the little wall so it's the same concept the katana comes to the the doyla rules over the tunnel and that by the way rabbis i will see this is the main the key word of the sogia is rule the larger hotter rules over the smaller hots we're going to see in the gemara says not yet though why do i need two cases of a rooftop that's uh there's a large one a wider one and a narrower one and then the same exact allah with a khatu this is the gemara if you recall we had a macholic is ravenchamuel on a rooftop do we say that good asset that the walls that are underneath that you can't see they're not knicker you're on a flat roof there's no um what's the word um whatever the word is you can't tell that there's a wall it's nice and flat according to shmuel you say good assignment the wall keeps on going up and according to rav you do not so let's see how that rav and shmuel fit into this mission le rav that is no good asking if you can't tell tonight now the question is why when it comes to a rooftop so let's look at this roof for a second according to rav why don't we say good assignment look this invisible wall should come here close in the small guy now the small guy has a has its own form of so why not the answer is rav must say that it's the mission is telling us that's the continuation that it's like a cutter why is there a second case that teach us the shot in the first case just like a hutzer you can't tell you don't see anything in the ground nothing's popping up out of the ground it's nice and flat so through the rooftop it's nice and flat mma left is nice and flat there's no good assignment so the small guy is not enclosed on the outside so to the gag but there's no mejitsa cutting it down the center ushmore according to shmuel this this mojito pops out so nakamura we should have a problem even if you can't tell that there's a wall here underneath look there's two residents obviously there's a dividing wall but you don't see it on the top so it should pop out and do good acid the answer is because we're talking about a type of roof that people walk on it we had this before directly rabbit and once people walk on it they ruined the good asking krista there's no good acid we said if a goat goes through there's no good good aches if people walk through there's no good as sick right you can't have a wall when people walk there now according to schmuel if people don't walk on this roof they don't go back and forth it would be a proper makita the the cotton and the goggle wouldn't be the same i think and here comes a major eusait in all of shas and it might even have ramifications to our minion our outdoor minion what does it have to do with the outdoor minion because we we do a minion we're in a garage and there's other people that are in a smaller garage how does that work in terms of a minion could you be sorry if not being charged yosef rabo verb zero vera there's three amiroyem sitting around the yosemite bayou right we had this the same story with other miranda rabbi was sitting and overhearing something and they said that the just the taj the larger gag the larger hutter they live in the smaller one says rashi if you look at rep three lines from the bottom the rig de la machilimo they rule over the small hotter the smaller part of the roof that's very very important that's the key word to the sugya they rule it's very interesting if you're smaller than me i rule over you because i have four walls you only have three i rule over you so basically i take you into my possession you come to me i rule over you i dominate you then there you are but if i go if if my vantage point is from the smaller part of the roof the smaller part of the huts are looking into the larger part i have nothing there ketad so how does this apply to halal says a number of cases is you can't plant a vineyard together with vegetables that's called clay clay cam but is that if they are distant from each other four amis you could plant and if you have a wall a mojito you could plant it right nearby four amis is all you need says it says gamar tremendous tremendous finish listen what's going on here a guy planted his vineyard in the large part of the cutter it's awesome to plant in the small part it's awesome to plant vegetables in the small part why because the large part rules over the small part so the small part is considered part of the large part and now i'm planting vegetables together in my clay carrom even though it's more than four hours away tremendous because now i took my small part and brought it into my big part it's unbelievable and what if and here's even a bigger what if i went in and i was over and i was a ray i planted in the small part zuroy masurim the all the vegetables are usual why because i planted them visser listen to this definite muttarim but in terms of the gef and when i plant it over here so i'm standing over here in the small part and my vantage point is i'm looking out into the large part i'm closed off here's a tremendous kid says rashi there's a wall here look at this wall you see this wall the fufe make a wall i have nothing to do with you on the one hand i bring the small cotton to me tremendous it's awesome on the other hand if you plant over here you can't make an issue to me because i had a wall i was closed off you have to understand when do you jump it's like dancing in two houses here now we just turned to daft southern basement base sponsored by ellen estas in memory of his mother shane aaron hirsch and bracha and by the austin and tobias grandchildren and grandmother what if the reverse he planned the first the vineyard in the small part mortal israelis acted now when i'm in the the large part the large part of the clutzer my vantage point these guys i i could do whatever i want over here i'm closed off so mama i could plant in the in the title planting is okay there's no vineyard over here the vineyard's over here i'm closed off now it's kadai we have a few minutes here we're not in a rush so i think it's gonna die to jump into rashi i want to show you a beautiful cash and terrorists from rashi four lines down great yamara says i could plant over here so planting is one thing but as rashi okay what happens when everything grows i've got the oregano and at the end of the day i have large vegetables over here and i just i bring my vineyard into my large hot sauce because i rule over the vineyards so it's as if it came in here and now i just made my vegetables also ah this is the biggest site we have to know maison because what if you go ahead and you plant vegetables your friend you're jealous that your friend has a beautiful he sells pepper burg wine whatever it is you go you start planting vegetables in this vineyard they said the vegetables are us but you don't have the right to make somebody else's grapes awesome if i'm reading my time what's up shot convoy's beloved us retired the the terror only said canvas and love other vegetables are all in there about so listen to this here's the point of this really concern you planted it you planted it behind there now there's two things going on what's we're actually talking about there's two things there's the insert the plant that's one answer that's not issue he said because there's a wall here but there's another problem when it grows it grows busier that's the second problem i forgot what the amount was 1 200th whatever it grows busier so when it grows busy or says the gemara it just grew this or grew together with the vineyard no but since says rashi i had the right to plant it what happens later on the issue happens later on i can't i don't get a class for that it's like somebody else planted it next to me isho bhagava get bigtano what if the woman is standing in the large yard now that is when i when a person gives a gift to his wife he has to give it to her in her hand or enters her shoes if she's standing there so she's in the large one and he put the get in the small one it was gracious because the the large clutzer rules over the small one so she grabs how logically they get but what if the isha muktana will get big by law she's the main part here and she's in the small yard any deposited to get in this in the in the large yard she from her vantage point she has nothing to do with that get because she's standing in the small hotel hey name is guy rushes it's not a good gut what about zebra magdaleno if you have nine people let's say in the large yard because they are in the large one the small guy comes to the only the shliya who's trying to be mighty them in time of the gemara they didn't have someone else like us so the you had to listen to every word and the booze might see them should listen to every word today as well very important unless you're doing the messifta you're doing sorry that was just stuck for one or two people watching um so the shleek tibor comes to them because they're in the large one the small one is open to them they bring him in to them but what if it's the reverse from the zebra's vantage point they have nothing to do with the large one is nine are in the small one aim and styrofoam because from their vantage point the large hotzer has nothing to do with them what if there's feces you can't say krishna oscar liquor is so if you are if the now this is reverse we have to understand this if the soya is in the large one oscillator is krishna provided the the rule that we learned in brachas provided there's no reach i think also one other thing that we learned in brock is that you can't see it i didn't look into that but i remember such a lot of seeing that as well but maybe if this is it might change it so don't quote me on that and so now don't forget these three are instead and they were sitting and abaya was listening to them says abaya what you're saying doesn't make so much sense why now think about it this mikhita is supposed to separate you what does mkhitaryan do let's look at this gefufe this should be as if these two khaters are separate but what you did in fact is you're saying i rule on you and you come to me because i rule on you you come to me and you're basing that on the mechitas that you made so the mushitas are working it's counterintuitive i love that word it's the opposite what it should be the mercedes is supposed to be separating you not bringing the small guy into the large guy again look here typical case if you have a vineyard over here and you want a plant over here all you have to do is distance it forearm it's great but because you have a little indentation over here you have gefufe all of a sudden this ends up on top of this guy and becomes awesome the opposite indentations should mark off where my territory is you make it invisible from one indentation to the other oh look he wanted to finish it off it's a past you're doing the opposite of what's supposed to be here um so what's interesting is this points out each one of the three that were sitting there and said this asked the question on what ability just said the first one is from zera tomorrow we're gonna see ravo rabbo and and rabbit bearer of holland the gamer says places what do you mean there is such a concept that a mojito makes an answer we have a large hotzer that goes the wider hotel that goes into the narrow hots so listen to this mom has beautiful drawing here here's the large hutzer same pictures we had before the only difference is i made a blue and red line so you could see it clearly what if so if you have this red line just the red line so the large one is goes into the small one comes into the large one [Music] what if you took a blue you created a new wall blue you see this blue wall here so now you just got rid of this bump now there's no more foo from on both sides i just did blue because look if you don't do blue it looks a little confusing over here your initial your original wall was red it went like that you added the blue part now you just made the wall very straight what just happened this just became awesome everything became awesome they're open to each other without an arrow it's a mock-up on malay say he tells him beautifully so what do you see so he said i give you a per you tell me where do you see that makes it sir here until now the dialogue was mother i was allowed to carry everywhere into the town and now the dog is also awesome made it worse it says i buy it beautifully you didn't build a blue wall you know what you just did you knocked down the red wall you had a red wall that was that made everything motor and by you adding a blue wall you got rid of the red so snapshot that you made you have a wall and the wall makes it issue what you did with the blue wall was to get rid of the red wall that's something else i didn't say that i said typically america makes a hetero not a issa you're giving me an an example where your mercitsa got rid of a mohita of hatter and made a new answer that's something else completely and that i agree with you that it will make it it's a boy's eye have a wonderful wonderful day [Music] foreign my red and blue was from day one i love it it's it's it's it's it's uh what do you call it's not just red and blue it's neon red it's neon blue it's a whole where are you going what's going on here it's early by you wonderful day my boy sai why did we say some people what i don't know i you know these these porch menu on them are very uh very iffy according today's to today's gemara this is the whole minion together not together yeah kid sir shout out no for me i'm going to pour i'm upstairs by a window right if they have a mean together but they don't really have yeah i guess they have [Music] said what that he can is on and the youngster by entering kedusha and everything on zoom he says if the main place has a minion then you can answer you can ask yourself but what about what about shabbos and zoom is that okay also me