Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 91 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabbi sai let's do that again good morning rabbi sai it wasn't with such kavana that's why i had to redo it how's everybody doing it's good to see you today's shirt sponsored and this is huge your boy said this is huge elio berger cu mashas it's unreal unreal took him i read the email on friday took him eight and a half years extra year because it was on again off again the usual but it's all par for the course it's normal in honor of making a cinema shot it's unreal two and a half of those eight and a half years he did with us every single day he's on he watches on youtube and the podcast so he's before brachas before a lot of you guys so tremendous tremendous mazeltov the bad news our boys is i know what you're thinking you're thinking to yourself okay so when i make a sema shots i'm also going to sponsor no no no you're not going to wait seven years to sponsor i'm sorry that's not how it works here all right um we also have the force leima for the holy choir wait this is not good we're going to start calling him from now on no more this steven people don't even know how to pronounce his name stefan p h is it stephen steph stephen sakula simcha nakam it's a lot easier should have her for slamming they'll also never force lama uh real quick uh derebelli this is from yaakov rosner you can't imagine what joy i had air shoutouts when i opened my phone to do the regular learning schedule and saw the comeback of the 8-minute daf i love so much something i always looked forward to as well as your you remarkably well explained day to day share a big issue to you and all the devoted staff members working so hard to make this happen you know i'm so not used to doing the eight minute daft that i did it last night everything was great i sent it to ravenchait and then i went to sleep at 12 30 i went to sleep i forgot to check if he sent it back to me sent it back and i forgot to send it out i sent it out this morning all right i hope uh yosef didn't wait up for me three in the morning it's very possible he did um this seems to be a major problem i need somebody to get involved here my my uh my streak is on it's a little shaky a little shaky i uh i found out from the street record holder david hagal that he's not so sure i mean it's up it it's almost like the presidential uh thing like some people are to here to there and i don't know i don't know what to do there's a shiloh weather the day i arrived in israel i didn't give the share but i gave the share beforehand and i sent it in and there was a share every day does that ruin the streak and since i see he's hesitant and he doesn't want to give me the streak and i think that happened believe it or not i'm not kidding on day 365. stroll it's not a streak he said it's not a streak what's going on i think the fault said it is a streak if i would have known i would have given the shear i i would have gotten up and given this year rabbi so i did something else i'm going to for something else i put it behind me 600. if anybody could guess what the 600 is 600 gift certificate from mdy what is has to do with myself to say even anybody want to give a jab at it want to take a jab somebody nobody no i'm what is it too easy too easy all right this one is a little difficult today is what 600 print ding ding ding ding very good i'm adding it to your shopkins good very good 600 charts for boys size charts and miscellaneous irvin wow very good now very good very impressive okay dollar the gift certificate this is real dollars my friend this is real dollars from mdy all right so once just so real quickly we're we're only two weeks away from the ceo uh mark i mean mordechai was marked by back in the day when he promised to do the video so whoever has an error video or wants to do one at least tell us about it so we we could prepare for it tell us by tomorrow please is over iceland as we speak and he's watching live i want to see a video of that a video pictures over iceland hello wow all right hello where's ellie's elian alekamianskis incredible 90. 600 charts probably will never happen again even in khulan we had a lot of charts never this kind of volume so we are holding the california from the top four lines down we ran through those these three lines pretended they were easy a little bit of a complication in rashi not complications just a little bit more than i wanted to go into so we'll pretend that we did it and we'll go viktor thai gabon we have a bryso that is exactly like rav and exactly like review though two different alarms rav as we recall from yesterday arrives of the opinion that if you have a rooftop and there are two residents below the roof and you cannot discern you can't tell that there's a wall in between the two residents when you're on the roof you don't see anything there's no there's no uh any market anything there's no in the indication that there's a there's a wall below therefore we do not say good asset not like in this picture this is schmuel we don't say that the wall goes up and if you don't say the wall goes up we have a major problem according to raven rabban the two rashiya is these two blue arrows they pop up through the roof and what happens is when you're on this side of the roof you have the other side that's open to you because you don't have a good asset that's separating you and you're open tom welcome that's awesome and when you're open to malcolm that's awesome you can't carry there only four almost it's like a caramelist it's opened the mokumos so we're going to see a raya torav ravi hood is of the opinion we went through the sheets yesterday ramayana holds that you have a gag khotzekarpav there are three they're independent of each other they're not connected so you cannot go from a gag to karfa from a car after a hotzer and according to rip shimon in review though rebujo is the one that said this review the learns there are shipment holds that you could go from one to the other we had this from the shabbos and i'll show you what the maybe i won't show here here remember this chart you go from a character and from the god to the khatsu they're all one so we have a bracelet that says just like rip the way ravi who the learns of shaman thank you for saying the rabbit hunting people say there are a vehicle oh here we go again looking for the oh here he is called thank him and this is going to be the [ __ ] of romere that we're familiar with called gaga all the rooftops in the city even if they're owned by different individuals you could go from one to the other provided that there's no height difference so remains of the opinion that within the category within the category you can go from one to the other within the khasi category you go from one to the other but you cannot go from a gag to a katsu but you it's also to take from a gag up there to the hutter below um and that's your major cheetah that we're geyser tail bishop perhaps you might come to carry universes rabbit you'll go from this rabbit onto a beam in versus ram which is and if you have a klee that started chavez off in the yard in the khattar motor you're permitted to carry it within your cutter even without an aero and even from one hutter to another cutter begagin what if let's say you have a ball that ended up on the roof and it's there heir of shabbos so motel italian big you're allowed to take that ball if it started on irv shabbos on the roof you let it go from the roof to the to another roof but you're not going to take a ball out of your house and bring it to the roof and start going through the roofs it has to be there from before shots as long as the rooftops are equal in height they're not you don't have one that's higher than the other one by 10 fahren what if it is then we have a problem of tel birches or rabbit people might come to confuse this with a beam in middle versions okay so this is a river we are looking for because rav is an is explaining the mach like between rav and shmuel do you say that there's an invisible good asset an invisible wall that separates apartments below and it comes through the rooftop this invisible makita do we say it on a roof or not that's a shiloh and here it is this is exactly rav every rooftop it's one roof but every roof that's above another residence here's two front doors so we have two residents so every roof you're permitted to carry within the entire roof not the entire roof but that section of the roof from the from the invisible mojitsa and back and from the visible mojito that way but you could carry the entire roof why because according to shmuel you have urushi you have four walls here because we do invoke good asset according to iran there's no good asset we don't have this middle wall therefore it's wide open tamakim that's oscar to you and it's open time that's also you can't carry at all you could carry four albums so it says your management first like rav so here's the brides like crowd tanika will say the review and here we have a great rally to rav yehuda who says explains rip shimon that according to shimon they're all one category all one and i could go from one to the other from the others though oh my rebbe amaisa shahoyo an exciting story an exciting arabian story we're looking for shimon what does your shimmer hold when it comes to these three categories gag khotzekar here it is we're learning torah by rib shimon in a place called kaya oh you know malin shemin we used to take oil on shabbos we had to go to the mikvah so we took our oil today it's soap shampoo and a towel and how do we get to the mikvah this is caramel how do we get there mega gag um we jumped we had a route we went we avoided all caramelizes all resources by going from rooftop to rooftop from kaif to roof from a hotzer we went through until we got to the mikvah with our things in our hand obviously as we explained before the towel had to start out on a rooftop or in a hutzer it couldn't start out in your towel closet or in your shower because that's already a problem you can't take out from your house okay so started out on you put it in your own private domain you're not worried somebody's gonna steal it shop this morning go to the mikvah you take your towel your shampoo jump from roof to roof now you don't want to leave it in the mikvah some other guy is going to come and take your stuff so you bring it back that's that's the hector here take a picture i know the other picture was boring so i made a picture now you're asking what the savatery is that's that's for that's but here's a guy it was mama said a steering wheel it was it was a hussed with one of those prayer shawls i didn't like that but it worked out great it became a towel here's his towel and he went from gag to hotzer to cairo until he got over here to the mayan to the nice river and some say it was even like inferior it was a hot river not a problem in our days it's a little bit more of an issue we're not going to go into it oh you let it be right it's not really good it's fine and another story where the game said we can't learn tyro you know now here goes the same picture used it twice grab a savateuro and he went they went the same route ancient when it comes to doing mitzvos when they go and tell us not to do mitzvahs so haha lowered the standards they said okay you could go from the from hearts to the hots don't bring me a rayo that in general i could carry a baseball from from a hotel gaga in la vie right and she said ancients is kind of right fine says the amaro oh we can make a hard pause here for a second let's see it is on that's great we saw him already the other day rebecca epstein show malaysia how are you neighbor downstairs haven't seen i have to go on zoom to see my neighbor that lives two floors below me and jacques i see your shoulder but i know you're there i saw you before now i see you thanks schmover show malachim how are you all right we could go right there now rip shimon oyemir so we learned according to uh reviewed at least shimon says rooftops what are you doing up so late it's what is it it's like twelve o'clock in the morning over there very by him okay gevalting by the way you made my my whole trip over there in chicago i have to tell you i was getting a little nervous but you ah it's great to have you there at night on [Music] according to rav this allah that you're allowed to go from hotzer to gag in a gag to a kara five etc is when there's no way roof because if there's an aerov we are concerned people might take stuff out of their own house and bring it to the clutzer once it gets to the clutzer they're going to start bringing it to the gag et cetera so manmela this is halakha when there is no aero and this is going to basically take us through today's daf this question so we have to pay attention this arab shimon says that he could go from a gag to etc it's all one says rav provided there's no arab it's almost counterintuitive you think that it's the opposite no if there's an arrow of there's a lot of stuff that comes out of your house goes into the clutzer and you're going to get confused you're going to start taking things that came out of your house you're not going to realize without an arrow you're not going to take anything out of your house into the concert the error allows you to take something from your house into the khatsu if there's no air of so whatever's in the huts or is in the cutter so that i could take from the concert to the gag is no problem but once you have an arrow and you're allowed to take stuff out of your own house so the kids start taking their ball out of the house into the cutter and before you know it they say oh you let it go from a clutch to the guy so now they're taking it on to the rooftop but that saucer because just came from the house to the rooftop and that's awesome rabbi i want to tell you i see um i haven't seen his face i know he's he doesn't want to show his face i guess he's all hooked up to stuff oh here he is you're in the hospital still in the hospital no if i am well it's great to see you you should have a reverse layman we're down for you every day your name is on the board as you i don't know if you were there in the beginning of this year you're there yesterday the day before should i have a first name or whatever is going on but you're looking good torah is going to be mikhail it's a tremendous physique for everybody in the hospital and this is not the first time i saw him on there the other day also i mentioned he's there so barclash let's go back alive there's no way but once they make an arrow you're not permitted to go from the khatsu to the gag why the gazreen and dilma also might take out some kaolin the batim from within the house le chatzer is going to end up in the hotel and from there it's going to end up other places according to ribs you let it take even if you made an arab we're not concerned that something's going to end up from your house onto the rooftop or into the closet next quarter you know what's in the hots or what started chabas and the khatsu what didn't start that's not an issue right rebecca was an artist's role rav who whispered to you this allah who told you that it has to do with the area of another neighbor made a difference rashi is not guerrillas these words it seems like all the gemara's bring it as if they didn't care about rashi so that's why i'm reading it it doesn't it's it's not niger because maybe it doesn't fit in so well the studies points out but everyone should learn fine even with an arrow where people might take out stuff from their house into the culture and it might end up somewhere else into another culture not a problem think about it you have a fork that you left on your barbecue in your backyard and it was their area of shops so that fork says shmuel says rav sorry says it's not a problem that fork you take from one cloth to the other not only that the knife in your drawer in your kitchen that's in the house you could take out from your house and bring it into the concert but you can't bring it to another concert okay so now a person is in his backyard and he has a knife and a fork in front of him who tells him which one he could carry to the next hudson the fork that was there before shabbos he could carry the next cuts the knife no no how is he going to make the distinction how is he going to know how is he going to realize how is he going to remember like every sugi we learned we did hazard three times says rip shimon this is similar what's similar so i couldn't really find the pictures hidden somewhere in my giant uh book but if you recall we had the sugya of three people sitting next to each other the middle guy and two guys next to him he could share their error of nature there and the gemara says over there it's similar to this case you have three katseras and the middle guy is sitting right here and the outer guy the guy in the right and the guy on the left made an arrow with the guy in the middle so that is that they are allowed to and we had a whole discussion could you go this way you go that way the bottom line is that the guy in the center he can share with the guys on the side but the guys on the side they cannot bring stuff in from one cuts to the other they didn't make an a roof the guy on the right didn't make an error with the guy on the left the guy that made an error with the guy in the center the guy on the left made everything in the center but they didn't make area with each other so you have to be careful not to go this way but what's going to happen is that the guy on the right is going to take his baseball and bring it over here the guy on the left is going to bring his myth and put it over here eventually it might end up that the guy's baseball is going to end up all the way over here because the guy in the center is going to give it to him so that's the legends in the gemara that we had are we concerned says if you're not concerned that things are going to travel from side to side even though it's awesome no we're not concerned people know to be careful the guy in the center he could he could dance on both khasanas he could take from him from him we're not concerned it's going to somehow travel home say we are concerned very important to remember that we're concerned we have three katseras that are open to each other and they're open to the rabbi and this the guys on the side made an arrow with the guy in the middle what's that the middle guy is mother with the outer guys the mutarsima and the other guy is the motor with the guys in the center with the guy in the center um but the two outer guys asura zum zu they cannot carry from the dog but like godzilla and when he wasn't ripped she wasn't concerned that perhaps somebody's gonna take an object it's gonna travel to the center guy and from there mysteriously it's gonna end up on the other side the godzilla pokemon we're not concerned that the two outer guys are going to somehow switch stuff and carry from one to the other so two by us just because we have a knife and a fork and one is motor to carry and one is awesome we're not concerned that the the knife is somehow going to end up from my house from the drawer of my house into somebody else's roof into somebody else's house not a concern we learned this what is representing saying the three categories gagos katsers they are considered one category provided that it's kaelin these are vessels that were there from the arab shabbas the loyal killings this doesn't apply to vessels that were in a house when chavez came in there so he has a very nice cop over here how did a cli come from his house to some concert how did it get there how are you permitted to take something out of your kitchen and bring it into the cutter obviously this is an aero hill kamianski i see you on how come i don't see you i want to see what you look like here we go are you able to show what's going on on the plane i don't i don't see that you're on a plane i see a bunch of dark if people are sleeping it's the middle of the night oh okay i see very nice you valdic so we have literally by me side to side we have stephen sakala in the hospital and we have hill kamianski flying over greenland gevaldic all over the world in all sorts of funny places if you tell me there's enough community between aero and nowhere but you rap say that you cannot carry vessels from a hotzer to another hot serve from a cutter to another rooftop if there's an arrow involved why because you might take something out of your kitchen but wait a minute it says in the mishnah that this only applies to things that were shiva's in the yard before shouts what do you mean how how did you have how do you have a case of something that wasn't showing this in the yard how could you possibly take something out of your house and bring it to the cartoon that's case number two not for calendar that you took out on chavez but how do you take it out in chavez what are you shakings no obviously you have an a roof and you took it out on shabbos but do me a favor don't take that cleato you took it out on chavez to the next hotzer okay but you're talking about that you have an area of otherwise how do you even get to step one take it out of your house again with the area if we're talking about a situation where there's an arrow of not like grav this is a big question around because rap says you can't make an a-roof if you're talking about a situation that there's an error of haines islam then i could understand the bad house a vessel from your house ended up in the yard elo yamas bishop according to you rav this this whole allah of rip shaming that you could go so give me an example oh your kid to get out by mistake you're going to start being how did you get a vessel from your house into the clutzer which you're telling me you know how to do there was no way of obviously there's an error says kumar i do have a good way who my civil law fire khlo the the person asking the question had the answer that what in other words refseishes himself you probably recall we just had it recently i was in chicago then but i'll remind you with the picture here's kumta visudra basically it's lightweight items such as a hat or a scarf so the gemara is answering with those words more or less that you're asking how did i take a vessel out of my house on shabbos and bring it into the hots or without an air i'll tell you how i had a black hat i had a yarmulke i had a a nice scarf i wore it i took it out of the house without an arrow because i'm allowed to it's it's clothing and then i took it off in the hotzer that's how i did it we're not talking about a baseball bat we're talking about clothing okay so there's a way there's a way out of that question and now no you could put it back on you could what's the problem that's not a problem that's not that's not a history to put it back on you're asking it should be xera of uh of uh of going through the closet now on that rip shipment says i'm not question that you might lift it up and bring it to the next clutcher that's uh sir and i'm not guys with that i'm not you're not you're not crazy you're not going to pick up a hat and start bringing this to your friend's house you might put it back on and that's fine you'll allow to put it back on so we're turning the sonic aleph on the base 90 daffodil in memory of my mother chandelbat ironhurst not my mother but dr alan listen house's mother and bracha by her son dr alan estas and sponsored by the austin and tobias grandchildren lilu nishmas our bubbie zissel bass she was 98 years old and she had five generations of unbelievable five generations it's a way five generation toyota mitzvah jews tashma again question is when rib shemin says that you could carry from all three categories hotzer kharfav gag from one to the other is it only according to rav raf says it's only in a situation where there was no a roof to allow you to carry from your house to your khatu and the thing started off in the hot so now i can bring it to but if i'm allowed to bring stuff out of my house i have to be glazer maybe i should be kaiser that you might carry something from your house and it'll end up in somebody's roof or somebody's chiropractor or somebody else's hot tash again another sugar that we had here's the picture to remind you there's a mir pesset and there's a hotzer these guys made an error between themselves these guys made an area between themselves and there's a ladder here that allows you to go up and down rashi points out that we learned just as hazard we learned a ladder could act in two ways two opposite ways it could either act as an opening as a door as a pettah or could be not and by the way yaakov rosedale i was thinking about i'm telling you i was thinking about you this morning i said i haven't seen you in a month this is great to see you somalia it could act in two ways so we're going to act like cooler and we're going to say that this ladder is not a peta because if it is a peta now you have a problem you have the merpesic guys going into the hutter and they're jurisa's regular they're walking there and they're ruining everything so we're going to say they're closed off ladder act says uh it's closed off nothing okay so what's the problem with and they didn't make an error of so called anything that's taller than 10 fahrenheit and within fourth [ __ ] to the merpassive remember we said it has to be closer and past that and it's not further away from it's not the distance between this mound this beam whatever it is is not let more than ten [ __ ] away and it's higher than 10 fahrenheit all the stuff goes is owned by the merpes they could grab it now if it's less than 10 fahrenheit now here's a rashi alert because if you just read the word le chatzer you're going to think oh the guy's in the hot chick grab it no rashi says affleck it's both of theirs it's the upper guy and the lower guy as we learned back then meaning they're both awesome because once you have access two people have access to the same thing they answer each other no one could touch anything on that beam because it's less than 10 o'clock okay that's only in a case where there's many people you see many people one two all these doorways a lot of people live on top a lot of people on the bottom and there is now if there's a lot of people here so there's going to be a bunch of stuff so melo we have to be geyser that they shouldn't come to bring it into another place um now think for a second what's missing here which word is missing this is this is owned by a bunch of people and they forgot to make an arrow gag you have the rooftop vehicle um there's one one thing is missing here if you notice and that's karfaf okay you have gag we're adding to the categories uh pergola merpasat this is the mermaessen coulomb that what this is going according to the truman obviously shimon holds all these are one rashos and the gemara's media it's only because there's no arrow as it says over here they didn't make an error doesn't matter like rav it says here that if there's an eruv then what you have all these people that are going to get mixed up they're going to they're going to start taking stuff out of their house and it's going to go all over the place so if there's no aero of now we're we know that whatever's in the in the hots are great that you can bring into another hotzer to another gag but don't bring stuff out of your house so that's a great ride to rav says this is not rip shimon this is rabbana in the mishna right we have three sheets in the mishnah we have ramayana who says gog is by itself hutzer is by itself half of by itself then on the other hand we had rip shimon he says no it's all one thing then we had the middle we had we were born on rabona and say that a gog and a hutter are one category karfaf is all by itself oh beautiful what word was missing here it says rumor passes and the chiropractor was missing because this is not going according to him shim and rip shipment says kaif is included are the ones that say that it's not included but what's beautiful is think about it arguably back on um we're discussing when you have these three houses of the opinion i'm not concerned that if i bring my baseball bat into the guy in the right some i'm sorry the guy let's say the guy on the right takes his baseball bat puts it in the center i'm not concerned that the baseball bat is going to end up on the left because the guy in the middle has access to the left no i'm not concerned although it's because it's also to go from here to here from the right to left and from left to right i'm not concerned i am concerned stop don't carry anywhere ah so this is this is the concern right over here this is rabbana who said we're concerned and this is and and and also fits in very well that's rabbah and we say that what's a category by itself a gag and a hotzer kharfaf is its own category taikanami and i'll prove it to you the katana karfa it doesn't bring the other two the kaifa venom shmammy know that it's going according to rabona i'm not a so don't ask me if it was rip shimmin the whole mach like is raven shmuldy you need an error of no area of its without air is only in rip shimon but once i tell you that we're not even talking about i'm talking about rabbana so i don't have a kasha in rav tashima it's a case we might have had something similar but not exactly here you have five katsers right every cutter every yard has to have two houses to it so therefore two houses two but five katseras and they're all open directly into a mavui they all forgot there was no way now the gemara understands that there's no a roof even within each cutter between these two guys is no hero forget about the aero to go into the mobile and to make a sheet of movies and allow everybody to carry over here but even within their own yard it's also to carry asur let's remember this line it's user to take things in and out from the culture to the mobile like a caravan saucer um you cannot go from the mavoi to the cotter the calendar of but if you have a baseball bat that's sitting heir of shabbos in the clouds oh but i shouldn't say baseball back because maybe all the english people have no idea what that is so uh a football so the americans will think we're talking about a football and the english guys will think we're talking about a soccer ball and everybody will be happy okay so there was a a football in the hotter moter li then you're allowed to carry within the hot sir as i said before now the marble becomes a caramelist so it's oscar even if this if this ball let's say was in the cutter before shadows verb matter shivan says it's okay you could go between a hutter and a mother sharp shimmer calls manchester as long as there's many people there the shack your so now we're not so concerned that there's a lot of stuff going on in the culture a lot of caleb so do we wearing geyser passes vicariff look at this picture over here here you have it all you have a mer peset you have an exaggera you have a cutter you have a mavoi you have a chiropractor that's the enclosed area to that store you store wood and stones et cetera and a gag oh what is this six one two three four five six six different things they're all according to rip shipment all considered one resource i could go from one to the other time of the light year but it seems like there's no way roof and when there's no aero i don't have to be geyser that you might come to carry from within the house and it'll end up on the merpested or somewhere else but it's only because i didn't make an error and who says that rav hi ervuloi so what do i do this is a big problem it says mephorus over here coulomb beforeish there's no aero that's exactly rav who says you know how to do a narrow if there's an aerov you can't go from a gakta khatsatakar to mavui to uh asadra so what's going on here so we have to be duck like a little bit it's a big problem for for small milo your vu loyable gonna have to say that not that they didn't do an aero they didn't do an error of a mother they didn't do a [ __ ] of my voice that's what it means they didn't they didn't make an arab at all between themselves let me see hold on so even though there's a lot of calum going on here but since they didn't make an error with each other nevertheless the kiddush is there's no zero there's a lot of stuff i'm not geyser that you might end up somewhere else so what are you telling me you want to be dark i can say that at the end of the day there's sorry the the we're saying that these guys didn't make an error with each other the hots are to the hotter this guy and this guy this guy to this guy they didn't make and that's the kids that we're not geyser that you might take from here to there even though you have caleb you had a roof there is an area over here between these two houses erupt eruph aero but between the two there's no aero so that means there's caleb sitting around there in the clutzer but i'm not worried that you might take the clean and go from here to there from evo but at the end of the day it says there's no error at all right those are the words it says so we have to say that we're not talking about heir of mamesh it's talking about the [ __ ] of my voice that they didn't make a [ __ ] of over here that's there that we're discussing that they didn't do so may allah has nothing to do with a lot of people not a lot of people a lot of caleb not a lot of caleb they didn't make a name over here the boys so now you can pick if you don't like this turret there's another tutti rolling that might might fit you better the boy is saying or shimla devre there are bottom comma hold that okay sorry i thought i heard the youtube go on rep i hold in other words talking here in rip shaman uh yeah there's no an afghan meaning between whether there's an arab or no arrow even if there's an arrow i'm not concerned that i might take stuff out of my house and bring it to somebody else's house is cool in other words you should be concerned that it's warning us something might end up in another place where it shouldn't happen in other words the mother in the karfav according to four out of the six are one rashos that we had in the mishnah but mavui and karfaf they're in their own category that was the middle sheet of the mishnah according to the mayor each one is its own category according to shimon all six are one category according four of these the gag khatsur sadro amir pesset are one category but the mavoi and the kai five are by themselves so you can't go from an from a gag let's say tamawi from a gaga karafev that you can't do it's considered to rush let's just finish up here we just learned uber movie oscar even if we we understood it even if the caleb were in the movie heir of shabbos not a carrie there let him say hello omarov is this a riot or observer in the name of rav dumas so it's a caramelist if there's no sheet of my voice you can't carry in it you could carry like anything else like a middle versus wrap you can carry also four albums doesn't mean in the marvel it means to the mother but if that's the case high narration now if you go back to that one line it's like 12 lines from the top of the subject from the top of the page taj mahal is so why are you telling me that the next is that you now go into mavi we just said you can't go from away if you tell me that the shot is i can't carry in a movie it's started out of the movie you have a cleave that's in there area of shabbos in the movie and i can't carry more than four ammo's in the movie great but you just told me chad is no you can't carry from the hotzer to the mobile villa movie you know let it go from the hudson to the movement okay i already said that aloha why are you saying it twice high narration says you're right it is twice but it's very important to say it twice why mishnaya tiruit srikhali i need to tell you the same i keep playing rabban ali maybe i think it's like rav that argue when they say if there's an error of mma i have a hashtag that people might take stuff out of their house because they have an arrow into the clutcher and they'll end up somewhere else but if they didn't make an a rule agreed they could go from one to the other commas milan wonderful day foreign [Music] um [Music] on i haven't seen you in a while management regardless from chicago you guys could try to unmute yourselves i missed a good chart i i i made a chart multishoppers i missed it should i show it to you real quickly no it's not it's not uh hold on let me see if i can find it you're gonna show up and turn everything unclear video from the sky this is this is the chart i missed only this explains one rashi when the gemara says so rashi explains why he's not schver ravelra bonang because according to rav that a gag is a russian so you can't go from a gaga karfa i know it's confusing now that we and and how come the mars is smaller upon and not smaller of mayor xav i'm just saying it was one of those is a daft that has so much stuff to it it was incredible yes i do hello you should have done it during shear but yeah why not don't wake anybody up though don't wake anybody up hold on we're getting a live tour of the plane the steward knocked him out here he is is