Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 74 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabboissai we're going to try out a new device today let me know if this works this guy instead of verizon i don't know what the difference would be but let me know if you see a difference by anonymous reverse labor for failed david ben bayla freda oh i think i recall that name now that i'm thinking about it i don't want to give it away but it's somewhere in the east coast i think okay this one another anonymous such sadiquim such you you would wonder where did all these anonymous people come from i mean especially to share like this one the most unanimous person in the world i'm also anonymous i go on the ishiba world news and ami anonymously these days sponsored anonymously on the seventh yard site gimel marchman of aravagoyan maran of vader yosef zaikazu this guy is mama she's he's into actos he uses yiddish words together with the swear dishes may his memory be great email today just got it actually i was going to read avi mandelbaum's email sorry avi you're going to love this though this is from eliyahu luria de rebelli aha what a pleasure it's finally writing this email i would like the listeners to know that this year is like an iv of wiz for wisdom though i love this year's content beyond any other alternative online i especially love playing the game of looking for ellie's dropped tidbits of life wisdom that he likes to scatter total i like to introduce myself in case my life story can give some hyzel and yes it does i am latvian my whole family including myself were born there my non-jewish grandmother from my mom's side was a microbiologist who studied bacteria and she had access to a microscope with the capability to zoom into anything a hundred thousand times she was in complete shock from her observations throughout her career i recommend actually that you go on google and you you look at these pictures of a hundred thousand you could see like the most fascinating colors and shapes i know what he's talking about here things were just too beautiful too perfect they could not have been random she realized there must be a creator but she didn't know where to look she had to try it all she looked in christianity buddhism but they were all nonsense in her mind for some reason judaism made sense to her being that is based on oneness one creator without conversion my grandmother slowly started teaching us about the beautiful word of world of judaism whatever she could at least this will connect i is sure when i was two years old my parents divorced my entire dad's family all jews migrated to america on my mom's side all non-jews migrated to israel mamesh i went to israel with my mom where we moved the nearest opportune school was the famous shiva school that you once mentioned they accepted to take us non-jews but told my mother that they would eventually need to go through gerus however they told her it would be advisable for all to get through it for how can a non-jewish mother raise a jewish child then the rabbis told her you might as well get grandma involved in this as well anyways three generations became gayrim it was an orthodox garrison and the best didn't even shed a tear for they'd never seen a three-generational gary's before this occurred when i was seven years old when i was nine years old an odd miracle occurred my parents who were divorced remarried so now his father married a jew we all moved to staten island but unfortunately because my father's in from we didn't move to the jewish neighborhood it was slowing down hill from there so focused on the new life here and learning english we stopped focusing on the yeast kind of 13 i had no bar mitzvah celebration notes filling it was only in cows but hashem that was mikhail again barak hashem for the good heart of campus rabbis i graduated from college once there i told him the entire story i'm telling you and they replied you have to do garrus again says anyone who converts before the age of 30 must be as confirmed as that kid sir like me saying no so i went through one a short one-day gears again now i'm 25 stagging every day first time treading the path to finishing shots rebellion your shear is absolutely the best i don't even need coffee to keep myself awake for it hope to meet you soon one day elio luria so now we know who rebellio luria's amazing email our voice is sending those emails i'm missing them it's been a long time since we got a really really good one i mean avi amanda bam that's tomorrow i hope to see in chicago soon i just want to say a loader of nakhon katz a good old friend i miss you dearly her bianca schoenberg all right we'll be back in arizona soon we are holding where we need to be holding the we're holding one line from the bottom the last last line so we are discussing abby you think i'm joking here's the email you see that i'll be mad about it's right up here so we're talking about rav shitto omarav ain mavui nitor billahi vikaira so as we finished off the sugar yesterday we have a movie we have a cutter and we have bathroom we have three things that we need to discuss rav is of the opinion that the only way a lehi which is the vertical piece of wood which could be a mashup could be extremely thin paper thin or a kaira the horizontal beam that goes across the mother right over here at the opening of the mother you put it from side to side in the mavoi or a standing beam only if you have two cats areas let's count them one two into the mobile and in each hotzer two baton one two three four so every cutter needs two houses and every mavic needs two cats arrows total of four bat if you don't have that then a lucky in a koiro will won't help you so what do you do if you don't have a lucky in cairo if let's say you only have one house and you want to carry into the mob you do something called sur sapeza it's more extreme it's it's a complete frame two vertical one horizontal or you need a lucky that's fourth wide okay are considered one because let's say a father and a son live there so without so that's the same case that's there's no sheet of there's no sheet of my voice here because it's a father and son so rashi says rab would hold in this case that al-lahi in aquarium will not work although he said yesterday inquirer will work rav will argue the only time leche and kyrie work is when you have halal two katseros comes and says even if you have one hotter with a house and on this side look at this you have one house but it has no khatta the house goes directly into the mother this is the mavory that's enough to have a lucky if you look closely over here did you guys see that it's raining like crazy in chicago no there's no there's no lucky but there should be a lucky right over here you know what here this one is the same exact but this is from same idea but they were more they put a uh a lucky right over here so here's a house right up into the mavoi here's your hutter house and a cutter you don't need another cutter over here you just have a house even ruins i love this gemara why here's a corva picture of a horva it doesn't have to be a house that's resided that people live in it a horva now why do i like corvo i'll just tell you real quickly we're running out of time almost it's a very long dive turn the page for a second you'll see why i made my first real estate deals were all in jorvus that's what i did i flipped over a hundred houses i used to buy a horva and put it back together i was a professional um horrible guy in fact any house that had mold i called it gold mold is gold i had one house i'm not gonna say if it was this one or not one house let's just say that it cost the price is 500 000 from the time that i signed on the house until the time i bought it there was a flood an entire basement had a layer of mold so i went to the guy i went to the celery i said it's it's moldy what's going on here he says okay you know what take off a hundred thousand dollars my sister it took me less than a day we peeled off that mold with bleach we killed it it's cold you put that paint on kills give valdic mold is gold so anyways horvas by the way i have to say one mice i have to say a miso because lewis column is watching i love lewis he's a great friend and he watches every single shift so this is a special mice it's just for lewis he'll be made on this mice there's a house here in lincolnwood that i wanted a loan on it was a 90 thousand dollar house i called him up i said louis i just found the house you're not going to believe it for 90 how do i know i should buy it because when i told my wife about it she said don't buy it so that's the first indication that was my first sim and that's the house you need to buy as soon as she said no i say oh gevali we gotta buy right away so he said lewis i promise him my social you he's listening you'll ask him lou said it's impossible so that she said don't buy it i said let's put her on the phone right now we put her on the phone and she says no that's not a good deal what are you doing solutions but how could you go wrong with ninety thousand dollars well the foundation was still crooked like it was starting to sink can't buy it anyways i think it was like 20 000 i lifted up the house he put stuff underneath at the end i sold it for like close to half a million dollars everything was great of course she wasn't my dollar ms but anyway that was he said louis you'll tell them aquaponics must be the golden nuggets that luria was talking about the golden dubs the golden what he's not married he doesn't have yet one day he'll help no listen that was my thing i couldn't do a real estate deal if my wife said it's a good deal if once she said it's good we're on the same page in real estate it's a riot something's wrong over here anyway when she said it's no good i used to jump well not really but that was my first simmon that we got to go for the deal anyway oh my god we said we're not going to make fun of the wife anymore we're not we're not we're not dealing but this is real estate advice this is not marriages a question well nobody lives in a corva you can't live in it it's full of mold what about if you have a bunch of grapes going right into the up up against the mauve so instead of a horrible you have you have vines you have you have a whole vineyard one side you have a house the other side you have a vineyard giveaway what's the it's more value the vineyard is more valuable than corvo oh marley no it's only the casino somebody could come along and renovate it and flip it it's great it has a roof the bottom line is it has a roof it's a house avocado what are you talking about it's a tree a tree is a hotzer what are you saying although you can't live there lie i just added some red and blue so if you have one category of russos you have a carfa if you have a clutzer you have a rooftop so we know you can't go from a house to a hotzer but since these are one category you could carry from one to the other jump around from throughout the whole city go from the carpet to the ghazal carry like that why because they're considered one category of versus what kind of versus are they there are shoes that are not roy ladiro these are not livable habitable places these are rooftops who lives on a roof a car fav an open wide open area so is says if you have liquelin the loyal calendar if you have let's say a football some sort of clear bicycle in the karafev and it was here from before shabbos so i can move it from the car from the hotzer from the hots at the rooftop and keep on going but if it was inside my house then it's problematic then you cannot do it and rav comes along and says that's because they never made an error of avalevu gazrina ossila puke money the battem [Music] so comes the gemaran says that if they made an arab where you can carry from your house into the hotter so now i'm concerned you're going to go from your house to hutter and bring it to another hut or somewhere else you're going to forget if the caleb were in the clutter the bike was over here before shabbos so i'm allowed to go within the same category that's fine i'm never going to be over and bring it to another type of versus but if it's inside the house within the blue when travis started and i made an arrow of now i can't even carry something that was a bicycle that was in the hotzer why because if i carry something from the clutch i'm going to carry from the clutch into the car with another hotzer so i'm going to think that i could also carry something from the house into another hotter that's because it's an a-roof or confuse me but if there's no arrow then i know that they have no relation whatever's outside i could carry whatever's inside i'm not going to touch at all it doesn't matter even if they made an arrow even if they didn't make an arrow i cannot carry so even if the the criticism even if they didn't make an arab i can't carry from the hearts of the carve so if i'm not concerned says the gemara rebecca and says that even if even if they didn't make an arrow or even if they didn't make an arab i could go from here to there i'm not concerned that i might i could take the bike from the hutter and take it to another hudson i'm not concerned that he might take out something from the house and go to another concert in other words i'm not going to miss mess up russia he's i'm not going to go from a private domain from a house to another hudson and get confused so two i don't have to be concerned that i'm going to go from the khatsar from my hother into the horva i'm not worried about ahorva so she tossed it says a little bit of stretch you look in texas maybe if you have a cash or not but the point is i'm not concerned i'm going to go from the hutzer into achorva and the horde is considered as if it's a hutzer and therefore i can make an aero i'm not worried about the horva that might go into it because i know that it's a different type of resource yasir rabbrino the omar al-hashmita rabbrina was saying over what we said on top of the ahmad that shmuel holds that if you have a cutter with just one it's a cutter with a house and the other side doesn't have a cutter at all it's just a house here where where is it no hmm this is no good we're using the floor today pretend this is a house pretend this hoover is a house i can't find the other one somewhere under the pile but if this is a nice house but it has no yard it's right directly on the mobile you see how it's right there by the mavic without a hot sure small says that's enough to put a lucky right over here you don't need two houses in a khattar in order to make a lucky it's enough to have one house in a hutter and one house without a hutter ask the gemara on my layer of allah be rav you're a shiva guy really say that show me where he lives right now i need to go visit him immediately here he lives right over there also this morning is it true that yushmul said that you don't need in order to make a lefke nakaira you don't need two houses and two katseras it's enough to have one house and a khattar plus one house without a hotzer on my way in i in fact did say that as the gemara anybody remember when we learned this seems like years ago when it comes to the riven it's exactly like what the mishnah says we have to be mendy in the words of the mishnah we had it exactly a week ago after sukkas believe it or not i know to me it seemed like it was months ago yeah and it's this right here but very good yeah good memory yeah yeah yeah i also when i when i started getting my bearings i was like wait a minute they said over there the mosque was it's only in one specific place i looked up over there and it was this specific place when it comes to aravind we have to be diagnosed so this is the mission we had the other day yesterday that again the last words in the mission if you look at and give along with base on the top of the page right at the end of the mission what the mission is telling us just like you treat a house and a hot sir you understand by yourself that you can't take something out of your house intel because the khatsa is for the communal usage it's it's more like a resource and your house is a private domain so it's like going from versus a rabbit so two don't make the mistake and think they could go from a hutter which is communal to amavu which is communal don't make that mistake just like you can't go from your house to your heart so you can't go from they're not the same and you need a sheet of my vase okay but look at the words the words say royce plural not mobile you yourself shmuel came up with this idea they have to be diagnosed okay here i'm throwing it back at you those words that you're medicine it says it's plural you need two katseroys and each hotzer has to have two bottom what are you telling me one hotzer is enough it doesn't make sense what you're telling me ishtik he had nothing to answer him says the gemara cabling veneer he asked him a bomb question usually usually when you're quiet it means that you agree but tactless was small agreeable was it a good question to the point that shmuel reversed his opinion and said like rav that in order for lucky to work you need two khatsarays like the diorgana mishna khat you need two he says i'll tell you a story and from the story you'll be able to figure it out maybe there's a person by the name of evo's bari now what do we understand right now that we're talking about that there was a hatzer with one house and the other side there was a shoal okay and in the show there was a place to sleep you know for the shamish to sleep says the good mario and now we're turning to indiana bays in memory of my mother sheindle bad iron hairs and bracha comes ravana we had a few of these stories in our merced with different people whether nachman whatever it was over there remember in the the resh galas he takes down there of knockdown you gotta be you gotta go physical somebody puts up a legend you rip it down so after jamal's lifter comes and it comes from shmuel i got a a haksha i got a temple from said at the end of the day you see that shmuel gave a heter on a lucky to a mother that only had one hotter one dwelling the other side was a soul doesn't count he says who told you maybe shmool holds you need you're right like rav you need to have two people living there the of the show used to eat his meals in his house was what's going on here see have a show here's the show nice fancy show next door is another house you have two here's the hotzer now the show turns into a house you know why because the shamish of the show they still have it i think today there's some places where the the championship the show lives like some out of town places they live in the show they have like a little apartment upstairs or something he sleeps in the shoal mma law so in melo you have a situation where you have two houses two hours over here you have a cutter over here on the other side you have a show with an apartment that a guy actually sleeps in not just a show with an apartment it's a show that the shamish sleeps because typically you don't you don't you don't eat and sleep in the show it's not a basement dress it's a show but the shamish slept in the show so if so what was ivas complaining about ibis i guess it was it's beautiful i was held that shmuel doesn't agree to rav you don't need two houses so what's important you all you need is one house and that's why schmuel said this is okay with the lucky and the fact is it doesn't have to do with where you sleep it has to do with where you eat so just because the sham is slept in the show that me that doesn't change the show's status at all the show is like nothing it's as if you have a khatta without a house and the chamesh wherever you 88. so immediately you see fakert you see that shmuel agreed that even though oh and i forgot a very important thing after uh after this thing happened the shamish no longer in the beginning of the suggest the shams no longer ate they have to stick that in he stopped eating there rashi says but ivis held even though he stopped eating there he stopped sleeping there sorry stop sleeping there it doesn't matter it doesn't go by by sleeping it goes by eating so why did ravana take down my lucky it goes by eating and all you need is one hotzer according to shmuel ushma says him it has to do with where you sleep and if it has to do with you where you sleep so then the shoal turns into a house and then mainly you have a sheet of rav here you don't have you don't it's possible that small agreed to up so perhaps we don't know exactly did he regret it not regret it it's not maybe it's not such a great riot you have avos and you have ravana although it does seem like abel's kind of made a mistake that he thought it was making pita right right that's what it is you're saying yeah so but at the end of the day he was wrong ravana was right for knocking out i mean so you stop asking but you see ravanan had a good time and that's why irvana went and knocked down his uh is lucky he saw he's he's talking to somebody that doesn't know 100 ripped it out and then you have to finish off but it's no longer making lena why is it all because the shaman stops sleeping there so because the shaman stopped sleeping there that's why ravanan had to rip down the arrow when the shamish slept in the shoal so now you have enough enough bottom like rav holds like shmuel agreed to afterwards but he stopped sleeping there stop sleeping there you gotta rip down the air omar have you done a rav you have a mother where the guy this guy here's the movie right over here you see how he did a nice little mask so this is a guy jew but what's interesting here in the story is that behind the jew there's other jewish homes they don't have access to the marvel they have access to the resource you see the crosswalk over here so this is what's wrong they have access to surround them but not to the mother the only way they could get to the mobile is if they climb through a window here's a halloween they have windows between the houses crazy set up you have a house all of a sudden your neighbor opens up the window he climbs into your house here i am what are you doing here oh i want to get to the mavi oh sure come on in it happens to be my bedroom not a problem you cannot make an arrow between these guys so that these guys can get to them the gemara at the end is going to explain it's just a concern that you're going to be befriend the guy but nothing to do with tilkaserov which we had before amelia bailey oh my rav afidou so this case again you have a guy on one side of the movie here's the movie in the center the mother divides the jew and the god what about same exact case but instead of a mother you have green grass you have a hutter does that also is that also a problem that these jews that live in the back and they use a window to climb through the guy's house they cannot make an arrow on my way in it applies to hutter as well d like omar mai okay so that's how you read it because if it's not so if there's a difference between a hotzer and a mavoi my what would be your logic to differentiate between the two so abbay tells him why have amino i would think there is a reason the point is rav says the first words we read today that a mother cannot you cannot use you need houses you need hotter but a hotter you could do a lucky you could you could do an aero it doesn't ruin it you don't need so when it comes to a mavoi you have a problem that the guy's house doesn't count as a house you need houses you need you need a certain amount of houses so you don't have the amount of houses because it's a geisha house not counted but when it comes to hudson you don't have that issue maybe that's what i would say so now let's go just turn the page back for a second and give a little base look at the last last line on either gimbal and base the first line that we learned today if you have a mavoi in order to use a luckiness to allow you to carry there you need to have two houses that go two hot series that each custard has two houses what does rav say here smack in the middle of the page omar have you done a wrap this case that we had you have a mother and on one hand you have a jew on the other hand you have a guy you can't you can't you can't consider the the guy's uh house as a as a cutter but he's telling me according to abbayo the problem is that you don't have enough houses so then why did rav have to say a whole case he already told us the first line that we learned today he told us that if you have a marvel you need to have two jacers and each class has to have two houses then he repeats himself raff says if you have a guy on one hand so his house is not a house so you don't have enough houses okay that's the same allah you just told us you told us you have to have a certain amount of houses so the guys out so the mars says i want to tell you another i want to tell you the idea that even if the guy has a beautiful mansion and he has all his cars in there and as people coming in and out it's not considered a house if i want to make an area of i can't consider his beautiful house as a house and the story that's what rav is coming to teach us and if i would just tell us this of a guy that lives in the in the hutter and his house doesn't count as one of the houses you need four houses and this is not a house however i mean to lay down a bathroom but he doesn't mention he tells us one story here's a story there's a guy on this side a jew on this side but he doesn't talk about houses not only that explains rashi beautifully it's marshmallow the whole problem of this story is because here there's a mosque there's a blue yarmouk on top but if this was a jewish house it would be perfect you couldn't make an error but it doesn't say how many houses one house owned by a jew on the other side is enough one house here one answer so they're fighting to tell us the story that we started out today with commas i wouldn't know how many come on back and train every time you have a hotzer you have to have two houses per hotzer [Music] says the gemara ashley norma affilo hutter time of the rav now says i want to explain to you the logic behind rav rav says it doesn't matter if there's a hats or dividing the guy in the in the the non-jew and the or there's a mother divine the the the the yid and andrew what's the shot the kosovar oscar you know we don't want to help this one guy that lives adjacent to the guy now what's gonna happen if you allow these clowns to climb through the window into this house he's gonna feel comfortable living in the neighborhood with the guy what's the problem the guy he's gonna come kill him but he's not worried about the guy killing him because his buddies keep on climbing in and out of the window but if you tell his buddies stop there's no arrow the window doesn't help so he's going to move out of the neighborhood he's going to get out of there and he won't learn from his if that's the case if that's the sparrow of yours it tells us i hear what you're saying it's beautiful now that now i understand something says this is what with table said um said from his mouth the word i became twice i didn't know what he meant now i understand says rashi look at this rashi tube shot the mirage the rashi right before the mishnah will i might call my hashtag how here's the sentence if you have a movie that one side is a guy of either that's number one so now he understands why he said are you coming twice you're not allowed to have a movie that one side has a guy because you might come to learn from the guy raviolis remember that he said go go twice he didn't realize why he said twice now he understands that the the second time tabla revitavilla said the word guy was to explain the reason behind not doing an arrow with a guy on the other side of the movement or another chat says the word guy is these two cases that we just discussed abaya says is this case also applicable to a hutzer dividing the guy and the jew and the answer is yes so he said meaning to the one case of a mother dividing the two and going the second case of the hotter dividing the two have a wonderful day call you there by surprise norm hello [Music] foreign [Music] how was youtube today nobody told me was youtube better with that device ellie