Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 73 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabosai how's everybody doing if you  are in chicago good morning   you gotta wake up today's shiur is sponsored and sponsored by dove schultz  in honor of my father-in-law's   91st birthday the moisha lure of  fire rockaway for rockaway way to go   um no i'm you want to make a little speech now you  want to tell the other one's going on for the seam not now not the second later go ahead  give it a minute give you a minute go   okay the basic idea that we're uh that we're  playing with for the cm for airmen is as follows   it's actually from uncle phil's song and what  we're going to do is each community we're going   to focus less on the locations although we think  that's a wonderful idea if you guys want to get   together you should get together with that and  make the ceo together in the locations but if each   location can get together and plan a field trip to  the local area and go around with the people that   check the air if you can film it and you could be  makade something to the islam in the europe you   could video it film it edit it send it in again  very very short if you guessed it it's not a big   deal for us to show it but if you're going to get  10 15 20 of these then obviously it's going to   take up time video it show us something practical  and they send it in and then throughout the   course of our serum together we'll be showing the  different videos from the different communities the second thing that ellie mentioned  yesterday was this little game idea which again   to come up with a whole host of questions he's  going to knock them out throughout the course   of the event of the sem he's going to be asking  questions any location that comes up with more   of the right answers this is just to encourage  a hazara and come up bullet point ideas not too   specific on the doff itself but come up with  different ideas come up with different answers   whichever location comes up with uh different  answers we'll either get a slurpee from the oauth so those are the two ideas that we  have if you have any other ideas   and of course ellie's going  to give you a dramatic speech   and so on was that y'all at my door with slurpees  tell me the truth who's at the door it was yolo i would but i can't is he still there  now i'm i'm three stories up no that's   a that's a ten minute uh ordeal next  time you should have given me a heads up   besides i don't know i'm in a self  quarantine now it might be a problem what   i do i don't have access you probably have  more access to those cameras than i do   here's a quick email a very very not quick email  benjamin schwartz we all we're all very familiar   with beyond schwarz but this was very touching  although it's probably not going to go anywhere   but it's very touching derebelli thank you for  coming to new york over so because it was a true   pleasure to meet you and get to see you in person  if you would have told me a year ago that i'd be   learning gemara daily i never would have believed  it if you would have told me a year ago that i   would be excited to attend a 12 15 and 2 15 till  2 15 a.m gi marshy i would have never believed it   because of your share of now learning gemara daily  and was so excited and was excited to attend the   live share at midnight i was actually disappointed  when i couldn't make the live shiur the first few   nights that's how much this shiur has changed me  however seeing the share live has given me an even   greater perspective into what it really takes to  make the share a success the amount of time work   effort you put into the share is unimaginable  i don't know how you do it in addition everyone   that works behind the scenes they too must take  up valuable time and help them to why should run   smoothly i therefore humbly request that everyone  that learns from the shares should donate to the   share and look seriously it's not our style to  solicit funds from everybody or even to hint   to it so therefore don't take this as a hint i'm  just reading somebody's email and that's the end   of it uh people should donate what is that gary  again gary do me a favor mute you just click the   monthly donation option kisser he says he set up  something here it can be 5 500 500 can make sure   and he he set up a website i'm not even going  to say what it is but set up a quick and easy   way to donate to this year you just click the  monthly donation and it all goes to the same   place i don't believe it the leopard is climbing  up the stairs okay obviously bringing more members   to learn is the best option however this is the  close second in my humble opinion we have a guest come here i don't know if he's going  to come if he comes he comes up   first time in history that that foreign leopard all right go it's a baby it's only three  months old something like that   uh oh this is not good because  he's going after the wire did you see its ears hold on a second  here huh he just jumped up over here somebody asked who's coming up  here yeah come please get him all right here's the garbage room he has very  pointy ears he's different than a regular cat all right fine we got to learn some tyra here  um obviously please let me know how to transit   the remainder of the account wishing you much  only the best but young schwartz i've sent to   me like this before but seemed it got lost so  seriously speaking i really um i'm touched by   this that somebody wants to go out of their  way whoever wants to donate money could talk   to beyond schwartz we it's not our policy to  solicit or set up these kind of things and   with that we will go right there but it is very  touching that people want to do and want to give   so yes we are holding on that in base i just  want to show you something i got yesterday   from my good a relative of mine hannah feinstein  with davin for him he's a maggie cheer here in   lincolnwood and i i was discussing about the  capsule in israel and it says like this besham is   aerov nightmare i don't know if you've seen this  picture yet but this is what a capsule looks like   this is uh inside of the ishiba building and you  could actually see buckham learning in there and   these makitas don't go up to the ceiling  this would in fact be a big nightmare   we're holding today's gimbal the last few words  and that i'm based on the base mai makoi madeira   so let me pose this question to you and don't  think i'm crazy if you go to the stroller   you go to the uh waldorf for shabbos are you  allowed to carry in the lobby of the waldorf   no everybody carries but the question  is why isn't that isn't that lobby so you have a bunch of rooms and they're  open into a hotzer called the lobby   that's basically what uh what a hutzer is now we  all share a cutter all the rooms share a lobby   what gives us the right to carry in that lobby  so for that we have to see the gemara right here   the first line will answer it basically so  yesterday we had the story the guy had five   and does he have to make an air  even all the khatir is just one hot   we said the hutter that he lives in what is  the hutter that he lives in my malcolm deera so basically the place where you eat  bread so the place that you eat   so therefore when it comes to hotel we all eat  in the dining room that's where we eat so mamela   that's our makkah or let's say a kibbutz everybody  i don't even know if they exist anymore but uh   typical kibbutz you live here and there but we all  get together we all eat in this one dining room   that creates the makhumdira that's  about wherever you eat the dining room it's not based on the dining room it's based on  where you sleep on the bedroom maisve haroyim   the shepherds the kayatsim those who guard the  figs babur got him and berganam are like the   huts we have in the paris and those who watch  the fruit bizman laulin what does it say   it has to do with alina with sleeping this  manchester um when they sleep in the city then they're like city folk and if they sleep in the field yes so has nothing to do with eating has nothing to   do with where your dining room is it  has to do with where your bedroom is so we're starting with this idea that we know what  the person is thinking the person would rather him   bring the bread he doesn't okay so he's sleeping  out in the field now it happens to be in the field   there's no food there's no kitchen in the field so  he has to trek back to where people are eating and   he eats there so what's his main place where does  he want to be does he want to be in the dining   room in the city no he wants to be in a field  he's on a camping trip but there's no food there   if he would bring him a sandwich to his camping  site he would eat it there he prefers to eat it in   the camping site so mamela is making the camping  site we're going to see that sparrow again later   omar havisa fellowship immediately i believe that  irevan has this the most that's i don't know i   didn't really do search uh research today but look  we had it a bunch of times i don't know maybe five   times in myself aravind where the gemara tells us  again there are the eyes have got sick when he was   older and he forgot his learning and he tells  his favorite student abaya i never heard this   shot that it has to do with the dining room i  don't know such a thing um yes i'll remind you and you're the one that told us i bought that device i hooked  it up so i have another type of   wi-fi so if youtube i got  an email just before sheer   that the youtube wasn't good last night so if the  youtube is not very good let me know and i could   switch it over to this 18t i don't know if it'll  be better hopefully what it's good but you told   me it was good yesterday and i got a an email  saying it wasn't very good it freezes up whatever all right gevaldo rubio suverman from alaikum  everybody look down there you'll see you guys   superman he's known as my twin he looks exactly  like me at my son's bar mitzvah as everybody knows   people giving him gifts and of course he kept  it so you know what i did i went to his son's   bar mitzvah it's not a problem he thought he was  a great sahakam i know i did the same thing anyway right so we just had this you  have a father and his children   and the children eat by the father so each one  needs the arrow of shema and we said oh just   like we said yesterday you see from here that  it has to do with where you sleep otherwise   if they're eating by their father on the  dining room table why do they have to make   an error for each and every one obviously  because they go after they finish the meal   they each go to their own little house some  of my they have to bring you their own arrow no what we're talking about is that each and  every one gets a meal in his house in fact   their dining room is in their own little high  schooler and therefore they have to bring five   different a ruben remember that that was from  yesterday so what is the difference if it's or if they get food each one individ each one  individually so if they get if they're on their   father's table then they're considered one right  and if there's other people there in the hotter   than all they need as one air of if they all  live in one house like a typical family today   all the kids live in one house there's somehow so  that one house requires one arrow everybody else   in the chat sir brings one area and that whole  house brings one arrow if they're individuals that   get food from their father and there's another  person in the hotzer that each one of the kids   is going to have to bring their own arrows another  thing that we're going to see soon and then   talk about it this idea this concept of process  i should say mikawan pras means they get   food delivered to their house that only applies  to very special connected individuals like sons   like a wife like a slave like a talmud but anybody  else if i deliver food to you because i'm a food   delivery guy that doesn't mean that you have a  connection to me you have to be related somehow   you have to have a connection a physical  connection like a slave to his master okay what happens every 60  seconds it stops for a second by the way when you upload it afterwards to  youtube it smooths out a lot of that stuff   so i don't know if that's that's the but keep  keep a good eye on it do me a favor because   i want to change it but i'm a little  scared to try a new device a completely new   this is this is what ellie dykeman had in  new york it seems okay i hooked up to it   but i'm not sure if you know how good it is up  here anyway i'll try it out tomorrow tara bona   we're talking about one of the  unluckiest people in the world me she is somebody that's married to five women   michael is president of balayam and they receive  from him every single day food the hamish or five servants who get food from  their master so we have a machis says basically what we would think a wife is  a goofy so she's more attached to her husband   so she's one with her husband it's  considered one house one household   one a roof however slaves servants whatever  servants they require an error of per evid islam a question who's there now mishnah  is it reviewed by sarah or rabbihood since the servant is connected to the master  the mumminess like he owes him something   so mellow he's one with the master women  on the other hand not so much it's hard to   understand but that's what he says that  slaves have more of a connection caviar   not because because the the wife doesn't owe the  husband anything really what does she uh either   rabbit this is good for feminists what look  in action that a servant he's mashup to the to even though he wasn't really in the palace at all  times for character he was out he was learning   whatever he's doing but it's considered as if  he's in the palace as if he's in within the gate   at all times so melee is part of that and one  area of suffices for daniel and the king says like we have before that a son in the same  hutters father he receives food from his father   you don't need to not make another  heir of he's one with the father   that is a balloon of evidence of rabbi  that we just had a second ago plucked   verbum bubble which one is considered  more connected the wife to the husband   or the servant to the master what  about talmud it's a rabbi mai   a talmud which we know halal is like a psalms  you have to be muhammad a rebbe even more than   a father like assad and he eats by the rebbe  he receives food from the rabbit what's that   tashma the rav bay rabbi when rav was  in the shiva of rabbi omar ain't no no   we don't have to make a neighborhood we're part  of the rebecca and therefore we don't have to   make an aero so therefore talmud doesn't have to  make a neighborhood with his when he's with us in the shiva of the famous rabbi omar we don't have to make an error  because we are part of rebbe rabbo abaya asks rabble now this question is   going to be very familiar to us  because we just had it yesterday you have five people in the khatsar and they  gathered the a revolt together everything is set   so now we have one aero from five people kesham  is now so how does it work yeah the hotel right   i don't know if i have a good  picture of this but let's see well let's just say uh for argument  these guys got their arab together   so now they could carry over here in the cutter   but then they decided they also want to carry  next door so now they have to do another area   they have to be my arab with these guys so that  they could go from concert to hotzer first they   made an area between themselves just to carry over  here in the green spot one green you need to make   an arrow because it's two people they asked for  each other then i want to make another arrows well once they gather the aero is  it considered one and now one of   the people of the khashoggi could  take that area and be the shliyak   bring it over to the neighbors and be my arab  with another hudson or now it's two separate   people doing it with another hustler so each  person has to bring it over we had this question   yesterday so why is abaya asking the question as  if he never heard it says rashford never heard it   or he's asking for a resolution to the  question he wants to know what the sack is   he tells him once they five people gathered  together they make one like like the the rama says   they made one kala out of five pounds of flour  so they take that one chao and they bring it to   the next area they make an error with the next guy  with the next-door neighbors the next door hatsu what about brothers brothers if there's nobody  else living in that hazard they don't have to make   the hero so it's as if they have an era of already  so it's as if the brothers gathered in the erup it's as if they gathered their buktani srikun when they go to the next door neighbor we learned   that the brothers each one has to  give individually another arrow   so why don't we just say that the brothers are  like one before anybody shows up they're like   one the one so one of the brothers will take  the heir and bring it to the to the neighbor   but we don't say that we say that each and  every person has to bring their own arrows the reason is because there's other  people living with the brothers   in their hearts it's not a private huts or just  for those brothers or somebody else living there   and why and so what like we mentioned  yesterday the migui the hani asri hani   nami asri the concept of amigo in a  different way not the miguel bubba but   since since the brothers are us or in other  words the people that live in the khatsar   make it also for the brothers to carry without  a narrow if those other people weren't there the   brothers are one space but since the people  are there it makes it also for the brothers   so now once the brothers become user and they  have to make an error hana name so continues so if they if they weren't user at all great  but the problem is that the brothers already   have to make an error once they have to make  an error each one has to bring it outside   to the next to the next katsu let's say nobody  lives with the brothers they're all by themselves   so in one brother will bring  it to the next door neighbor   you hear because if nobody else is living with  them now they're one they're considered one one   once they could bring it for one guy and bring  it next door but since there's an there's a   there's a stranger living with them so for that  stranger now they have to each one make an arrow   of oh now they're not one anymore each and every  one has to bring it to the next-door neighbor and i'll prove it to you this applies when they bring  their arrow to another place   islam but if you bring the area to them ashamed  and nobody else lives with them hey in circumland   that's what we learned so you see  that the reason why they have to   be they have to make an arab is because  there's another person living with them question bene rav you have steve nahama bebago  very nice picture from cole halashan mama israeli   shiva building one of these beautiful new with the  ebbing roshami and they're eating bread over here   i gotta tell you the story i i'm amish i'm losing  it i don't remember what i said what i didn't   say but i gotta tell you the story either way  one of my favorite stories i'm sure those who   know me have heard this story unbelievable story  about the time it was like 2008 i brought my son   to yeshiva norfolk virginia and in norfolk the  basement is back then the best in one place   and the dormitory was a mile away so they  said oh you got to get your son a bike   so i said okay i'll give him a bike so they said  you know um we have to we have to bring all the   bagham into the sheer room and we're going to  start yeshiva today we're going to the first   the first year i said okay great my son goes into  the room to the shia to learn to to be introduced   his class is ready so i run and get him a bike  i go to the bike store get him a bike bring it   back i come back to the shiva building and the  door is locked there's a combination i knock   nobody opens so i want to stand outside so i go  to the backyard and i go to the back door it's   locked so i see there's a fire escape so i go up  the fire escape i climb one floor door is locked   so i climb to the second floor and i see  that the door is slightly ajar but it's like   not opening so i figure you know it's i'll  give it a little push like a geshemaka push   i'll be able to get in so i take a running  start i go i take back three steps i go one   two three with my shoulder poof the door flings  open now in slow motion this is what happened i   lose my balance and i come tumbling into  this room and as i tumble into the room   there's a tremendous alarm that goes off bam  bam and at the same time these flashing lights   for those who can't hear it's a sophisticated  building and as i gather my balance i turn around   and i see my son with this first day and share his  magic cheers there the whole sheer turns around   and they see this clown flying into the room  i turn around and i said hi i'm aaron's father   see you later i ran out the door and i left him  there to cook with the bush and the bazillion   that only a father could do for his son but  anyways yeah i'm very i'm a big professional in   that so hashem anyway so why i'm reminded because  this is the same thing here's the yeshiva building   it's over here and you get to eat all the way  here a mile away you need a bike to get here and they sleep in the basement so they eat it's  unbelievable if you think about it in those days   they used to learn the base measures and sleep  in the basement you only left the base marriage   to eat a little bit eat and anything that  has to do with food the processing of food   but you eat you come back to your smudge you need  it you need to sleep a little bit you just put   all these things that we had in this marriage  people are sleeping people are learning anyway wraps the sleeping in the basement they're  eating in this bag of place off campus when you measure the throne for them in  beiram do you go from the waste mattress   in other words the question is do  we go by the dining room or do we go   by the bedroom oh malay mashikino bay rav  it goes by the bedroom where they sleep what about a person any individual the homosexual  guy wants to go extend his terms what does he   do before shabbos he runs out of the out of the  city and he places his khala somewhere and then   he has a pai mama he has 2 000 from that khala  from that a roof but where is he going to sleep   if he's smart he goes back home so if he put his  arrows down and he came back home bus he would he still he doesn't lose his room he still  gets two thousand almonds from his bread   so again what do you see that it goes by  the dining room not by the bedroom says look the guy wants to go westbound so what  does he do he takes his his khala he puts it   uh two thousand almost out of the city west and  from there he wants to continue west he has no   reason to go back home and sleep we know  where he wants to go we know the direction   the direction is west it happens to be  that he needs a good nice comfortable bed   but where does he want to be if you if he had  an option he'd rather have a hotel room right   where his arrow is and continue on on his journey  from that point on he doesn't want to go home oh   so mellow what's important is where he  placed the zero not where he's sleeping we could testify to the fact the micellar rift  of the bay rav nicholas they don't want to ride   their bike to the dining room they want it  in the basement just they can't the food is   out there so that's why they walk there  so it has to do with where they want to be   where every individual wants to be at that  point that's where his making deera is if you have a father and a  son or a rabbi and a student are they considered like multiple people or  like them in other words so rashi explains   that if you're if you have a inner huts or an  outer cutter so if you have the inner people   that must make an aero and they don't make an a  roof they answer the outer cutter because they   have a recess regulator they can walk through  the outer cutter and since they make an error of   the fact they're allowed to walk through  the front cuts or they make it they ruin   it for the for for the front clutzer so what  does a father and his children consider is he   considered like a bunch of people that have  to make an arrow and since they didn't make   an area if they ruin it or they don't  have to make an error another question what about between themselves  they themselves with inside they   nobody else is there do they  have to make their own arrows so do we consider the father lives in one khatsu  this the child lives in another concert do we   consider it as tuchat we know that in order for  a mother to be able to put a lucky or a kyrah   on a mavoi you need at least two houses  per kata you need two katseras per mavi   so are there two khater is considered one qatar or  two katseras it's a father and a son we learned it by the way if you think about it does the  individual that's using a mobile does he need a   locking car just him it's him himself and a mother  yes because the the mavi itself needs a lefke in a   kyra in order to carry there now there's another  thing that you have to make a sheet of movies   if all the people from the khattar want to carry  into the movie they have to make a sheet of   it's like an aero but every every  mother needs a lachi all right you have five katsuras open to each other so  the way the mishna reads is all these khatsera's   open into a mother not only that they open up into  each other so as a quick review here you have two   houses that are open into a cutter for in order  for you to carry just from your house into the   green you need this blue line just the blue line  you need an a roof that's called aerif kazeros   in order for you to carry from this hotzer to  this hotzer through this door you need a narrow   called er of cats now in order for you to carry  from the grass into the alleyway that you need a   sheet of you need a sheet of mavacase so we have  a rubik say rice the blue lines to go from hatsu   khatri or from the house to the khatta and to go  from the hotel to the mother you need a sheet of   so this case according to the way we're reading  the snow later on we'll see rav says that   there's no opening over here there's opening  through and through and opening to the mavoi so basically the mission has four cases   case number one is that they made an arrow to  the khatzer but they didn't do an error of two   the mother so that is that they are motor to  go from khatsu to khatsur they could go this   direction but they cannot go into the mother  because they didn't make a shituf mavouse what does that tell me what does this tell  me this tells me that this mission must be   going according to amanda umar as we know him  as remayr that says that an aero doesn't work   for a mawi you need both you need a roof  and a sheet of because if one would work   you're saying that the arab is good enough  for them to walk in the hatcher so it should   be good enough for them to go to the maverick they  forgot to do the shituf mayor halls you need both we are turning to daf and giblin base in memory of   dr lister's mother shane del bat aaron  hirsch and bracha by dr alan listaus will be my boy and if they made  a sheet of mava's case number two   over here they only did it with khateros and no  over here they did a sheet of in the mavi they   didn't do an era of katsiras we're going to see  the gemara but right now let's just read it simple   they didn't do a katers but they did do a shituf they did one out of the two what's the halacha evo this is a major problem this goes according to  rabban who's saying that just the shituf of is   enough also for kateras so they just did a shituf  of they could not only do what a sheet of does is   the red lines go from the hutter into  the mavoi but they use also to the blue   which is going from hot to the hotter and  from the house into the hotel next case finished with they did everything properly  they did two they did and they did the shituf one guy one guy out of these 10 guys there's  an x on his house he forgot he forgot okay   so what's that so there's two  things that could happen here either   one guy in the huts i forgot or one guy in  the mother forgot in other words you have a   hudson open to a another hotzer somebody  forgotten that so case number three is and one of the guys forgot and he didn't do you're allowed to go everywhere green case you're allowed to go from the movie and from the  movie to the and from the hearts of the movie from   the house of the everything is great because  only one guy forgot and the gemara is going   to explain let me just cheat and tell you now  the game is going to explain this case because   the whole point of the error is that the children  shouldn't forget and over here the children won't   forget because everybody did an arrow just one uh  forgetful guy forgot to do it that's not going to   make the children forget and then mella the shituf  of is enough the arab is enough and that's it okay what happens if not one of the hotter guys but one  of the mother people he was a mistake then it's a little different then you're  only allowed to go into hutter and you   now let it go in the mother because one of the  mother guys forgot and the mishna finishes off so basically what the mission is  saying is that the relationship   between the mother and the khatsur is like  a relationship between a cutter and a house   don't think that a house is a yacht and a hat and  that's the history to go from one to the other but   let's say a mavoi and a khatsu they're the same  type of russos the bother is just a rabbit they're   both used by by multiple people so therefore  it's not a big deal to go from the hutter to   the mother no you need a sheet of my voice to go  from a hat to them just like you need an area of   khateros to go from a house which is to the hotel  which is just around the same exact thing yeah it was okay okay something more money so the first part of the mission of blue that they they they did a rove they can't go in the mall in other words you need  two things you need a revenant who does the go   according to it must go according to ribbon  mayor okay the gemara is going to rip this   apart step by step to see how could this mishna  align itself with the remainder how does it fit   the omaha being an arabian shituf of you need two  things and that's why since they only did an arrow   no good it only works for the hats are  not for the mother amendment see also red case there is a sheet of  how could it work for two things   that must be who rabban on so this is  roommate this is rabbana problematic it's enough to do one sheet of and that's  why if they only did a sheet of another aero   you could carry it from your house to the  hot serve from the hotel to the mother   so they might catch you it's not such a  problem to say this is rabona it's both this red case is not talking  about they only did a sheet of   they also did a sheet of they did an hero and  they did a shituf you could carry in the oh what's confusing about this gumbar  and that's why i made this chart   only the fact that the gemara uses  the word ration say for very loosely   and calls every case aeration ration a safa  it could really confuse you so amusafa we   just said sephora we said the red is the sepha no  we're talking about a different safe of a misery everywhere now so now we'll take it step  by step very very simple gomorrah hey   kidami what's the case one guy in khatsu forgot  doesn't he ruin it for everybody think about it   one guy forgot everything we learned up until this  point is if one guy forgets no way of what's the   eta out of this bittle relinquishing  your property so let's think about it   if he didn't relinquish him there's no reason in  the world why everybody should be muted to carry   ellipse to the bottle you have to  say that there's relinquishment uh we just called green sephora  no there's a new save a purple   purple is the new so three we we call three of  them already safer by the way so what's to say if if one of the mother people forget about  the khatsuki one of the movie like you have a   you have a hudson open to the same movie  as you and the guy forgot to make yoshitov wait a minute you just told me that the guy was in  the battle you had it you you were forced to say you were forced to say that  he was in a battle right you have to say that the guy relinquished  otherwise no reason in the world why should   be able to use this hair okay so he relinquishes  his property so purple also has to relinquish so he religious gravity so why is  everybody else at the walk in the movie and if you'll tell me that because this is  a mother case not a hustler can it's purple   remember how it's one of the all things remember  remember all is that you cannot relinquish your   soul in a movie that's not true but remember  when we had room gamaliel and that's dookie so   it says over there says the suzuki was run do  whatever you need to do immediately before he   takes it back but you see the idea that he could  be in vata russia's mayor iran gamaliel ramirez so he must say that it was not me vato where  this case purple we're going to say a bottle   ratio now all of a sudden we're calling  green ratio okay a minute ago we called green   safa but now compared to the purple green is  erasure so mele if the purple he wasn't mevato   so greenie also wasn't a battle  somebody forgot to make an arrow   you're allowed you're permitted everybody's  permitted to use the hotzer what's going on here   one guy forgot an arrow out of the whole hotzer  and everybody's allowed to use the hotter why   he wasn't the battle you're telling me it has  to be similar to purple purple there's no beetle   mammalia forces us to say green is no better  green is no pickle so explain to me how it's   possible that there was a guy in the hats or who  wasn't ma'arev and everybody's allowed to use it reshape is safe for roommate now we're going back   rabbi said it's a little confusing racial now  means something else completely blue not green   blue the real real real ratio okay that's why  i made this chart because i think to explain it   would be murder the blue when they were married in  the world if we were already established here look   remember nobody argues in that that's the nearer  mayor because the mayor holds that you have to do   a shituf of an arrow and he didn't do both he only  did one out of the two and therefore he could only   use the a-roof the khater is and not the shituf of  you can't use the mobley okay so this is vermeer this safe purple the safe of the safe of  the safa is remainer great mitsuya banana   so how are you gonna explain the green the reason  why i can carry air is because all i need is a   sheet of so what if the guy forgot a roof i  have a sheet of it's enough according to our   button it's great but that only goes according  to rabbana so the top and the bottom is remaer   in the middle is going to be rabbana that's very  very problematic we hardly ever allow such a thing   says the gemara oh no you're right cooler mayor  all four go according to the mayor everything's   great the time in mind like i explained before the  time it may have been an area of being in sheet of   why does remain require both not because unluckily  you really need both the shock absorbers that the   children shouldn't forget about an aero of  even the rubell and since over here most of   the residents they did an error of only one guy  a forgetful guy forgot mama the kids aren't going   to forget about aero so we don't have that  zero and therefore the sheet of is enough a little bit more omera vido rav litonep  such zulu doesn't hold of this at all   he holds that there's walls between every  cutter the only opening is into the mother mother also said in the name of rav you  don't need openings they're closed it's not rav that said that  they're not open it's said now listen to this rabbi's side it's just a  havamina but it's very hard to understand kosova in other words rav is going to hold that you  must take your aero and spatsir do a little   teal go from your house outside into the  movie and bring it into your friend's house   but if you go from a a secret passage  between your two katsera's that doesn't work   why i don't know but that's what raffles in  order for this sheet of to work you have to   show that it's a sheet of you have to bring it  parade it right through the mobile and show oh   i'm taking the movie and everybody's part of this  movie how i bring it and i go through this red   line take it out of my house go through the mob  bring it into the next guy's house and that's   why he was geyser that if there's any openings  between the the khateros no good the gemara is   going to ask a bunch of bomb questions on this  and eventually say that it's just a havamina is we had this this thing there was a barrel in the  middle and and then they were they were shoot film   they they bought the barrel just to drink wine we  had the case the other day and then they decided   later on to use the the barrel of wine for for a  neigh roof no but they didn't parade the barrel of   wine through the movie the barrel is already  in one place it's already in their backyard   hey srikun says okay you're going to be forced to  say huss and dab give ireland yeah they lifted up   the barrel and they started parading it through  the movie aceve imagine if you have all these   guys they have to go in and out in and out  they have to parade it from house to house   so one guy we learned could take a barrel and  say this barrel of wine is for everybody this   is all for so but but they no no nobody parade  it there's one guy that put it down hassam what if i decide that a piece of bread  in that basket should be the roof what it's not going to work i have  to parade it if you're going to say   yes and this is in the name of rav and this  is the bomb cache that the gemara ends with dark so any bread that's right there and then you   can make it into aero you can  make it in the sheet of but if you're in the hotter it works as a sheet  of if you're in the house it works as a   as an arrow the bottom line  is that you cannot parade it   oh why can't you parade it maybe they did parade  it so for this you have to see like the last   i'll i wanted to read the holidays but since  we're late look at the last last words entices because this says we're talking about  one guy providing food for everybody   mela you don't have the right to take his food  and parade it in the mother it's not yours   it's reuven's food he's he  he he invited you for a meal it only works when it's yours to begin  with and mela it doesn't work over here that you need in order for inquiry we're going to  talk about it tomorrow in order for me to work you   need two houses and two katsaires open tamavo  but if they're open to each other then a lucky   and a kyra don't work we'll talk about it tomorrow  have a wonderful wonderful day rabbi shira malloys foreign all right