Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 72 by R’ Eli Stefansky

and bye he was an extremely business busy businessman he's an extremely busy businessman further caterer oh i like haters then i'll tell manager and then i'll tell owner i like hotel owners but he woke up every single day at 2 30 in the morning learning the daf at least four times a day rabbi sai i think gary's not on yet so if everybody could please mute pretty soon he'll get on and mute me and i'll be talking to myself but until that happens raboy said please mute steve is it possible to mute also sponsored by andrew fuchs for a foolish lama for nachman bin shendul who's having surgery today all right real quick email still a bunch of people that are not muted i know it's very difficult to find that button but you could do it i'm sure you could do it you know what i'm going to rabbi say i'm going to mute myself and then when gary because i have to mute you guys because it's it's coming through so i'm going to meet you guys but i want to i want the feedback from the islam so eventually when gary comes out and mutes everybody let me know dear rebbe this very interesting email i put it aside three today and then i realized that it's nigea to today this comes from avi sherman from queens he says i really appreciate you allowing me to learn from you in person while you were staying in queens please don't tell some of those farakaway folks there in queens as you might traumatize them they're not in queens in far rock way the five towns they're you know they have their own he's right whatever virtual connection we may have had priorities is now a real connection and when you said the first night here there are people you've never met but feel like you've known them for 40 years the feeling is definitely mutual it's amazing to see the energy enthusiasm you have for learning tomorrow and giving a share even during the wee hours of the morning and as much as they came to share midnight half asleep i was wide awake not by not just by the time the ship was over but even only a minute into it probably right after the good morning on the china rabbit night when you recorded the double share the entire chevro there with you agreed we could have gone for the third beautiful they were all there and then he goes on about here i can't read the entire thing this is the whole but i want to tell you what he i asked him why he sponsored lily nicholas the pittsburgh arena and he told me he had a very interesting story here it is all in writing i'm going to go through it really briefly basically in 2002 he was laid off from his programming job so he went to the pittsburgh pittsburgh rabbit told him you should have an alia in your job so he wasn't sure what that meant aliyah in the job cancer within six weeks of getting the bracha the same company that laid him off rehired him to double the salary as a consultant and he went from the fifth floor to the 20th floor oh what are you telling me gary's here okay pausing crusader i'm back on i guess there's no way for him to do it without uh muting me okay sir i thought he does now i see that he there's no way out of it great anyways he had two alias one was double salary second he went to the 20th floor the kitzer and then later on they told him he doesn't even have to go different job maybe he doesn't have to come into work which was you know 90 minutes 90 miles just stay at home go to alias go to your attic work there and the mail mdy literally spreading tired throughout the globe but you your respective families continued and all they do it's to you know i'm to you yosef to you yeshua even you should see tremendously i wish you a safe trip back to chicago and let me get home there's a stroll and look forward to learning from you via youtube and hopefully also back in zoom when you're zoomed the night chair that's already a different story first let's get the eight-minute daf up and running then we'll give the rest to yasuriddinski and i'll call you say that abby sherman ishokaya all right so why did i say it's negative today's mishna we learn about aliyah with avi mentioned here just to go back here okay am i too far away from the uh maisha hirsch and fuchs i don't know today rabbi say oh and real quickly uh mark ashkenazi let me know that his father came out of the hospital bar hashem that was a long one like maybe three close to four weeks well three weeks let's say so he should have a complete recovery or foolish lima also talking about mark ashkenazi phil uncle phil he had he started the the ideas are coming in a boy said listen if you have better ones let us know fair even different groups different cities should go see their local aero take a video of it send it in or another idea you had was that we could uh do some sort of um put up a picture of aravind or something like that and let different cities try to figure out what the picture is and whoever wins gets a certain maybe you get a muted on zoom you get uh whatever different stuff we'll fly you into mdy i don't know what all right come up with some ideas to make the serum exciting and interesting and just like roomy leave it with zoycha and we had such an unbelievable experience halawai the next one as well so today is that base it's rich the the well maybe by you guys not so much next row the it's the the beginning of the winter's month it's a tremendous like we just went uh beginning of assist unbelievable and uh we're here on the bottom of aleph ahmed bayes discussing the idea of of my voice one of the same not one of the same what if you do a sheet of for your mom allow you to go from your khattar to the mavo to the alley is that enough for an heir of as well so we have two lines from the bottom one of the two say we're to have this twice today we don't know exactly who says what but we know that they argued if you use bread one bread is enough for both cheetos and both and a a-roof keep leaking where does your mayor say that's not enough the i so the savara would be that there's a concept called the migoi now we know that for an heir of wine doesn't work you need bread but a sheet of maybe if you're using the wine for the sheet of and it works for a sheet of so once it's working for the sheet of will allow it also to work for the a-roof typically it doesn't work venero but it's really working you already got it to go it's already accomplishing something for you for your mother let it accomplish for the heir of as well that's the macholicas yay and wine doesn't work for an a-roof everybody agrees according to her mayor brett is not enough for both the cheetos and oh thank you i was wondering what you're doing there i know that when you're on there it's good i thought that there was an issue with the with internet how's the youtube today it's better because i i feel bad yesterday after share they told me the youtube wasn't good there was a way for me to fix it i forgot to get off my home's wi-fi because we had two two devices on one wi-fi is never good zoom and youtube so now i'm just going straight from brian hopefully that's better you throw where's he stroll he's in charge of youtube tell me if it's good what i know but somebody could just tell me a middle shear and i could get up and fix it it's better than having uh okay so they're saying it's better today great i mean i sat in this room because the verizon is better here and i forgot to turn off my my my wi-fi with the i'm staying i'm sitting in this room this is a con i could get attacked any minute by a mini leopard and uh for no reason all right the key plea give a pass so the whole clip is when you already did a sheet of with a loaf of bread is that bread good enough for the arrow or not remember this is not good you need to make another arrow of mason we just said that the top line here when it comes to wine everybody agrees that you need another aero wine is not good for a sheet of anna a roof you take the bread and go with it for everything or means you'll take the wine and use just the wine for the shitof and the roof my love or my irvine super pass either you just use bread or whistle in other words wine alone is enough gary's that you somebody's still on unmuted i hear them a little bit the kids are so from here the higher you see the one enough one bottle of wine will accomplish two things a sheet of and an aero not like the top line of this ammo that says be i in the kula ama please be in entirety that you need wine and bread it's not enough to do just one arab arab story of gil says the name kamba khan you learned it a little bit off you thought that mestatvi means with wine and wine is enough no we're talking about just bread oh my god so material can either start off with the air of but it was with bread of course arab is always with bread and it works for both the pasta we thought the word cheeto means typically can you do a sheet of with wine so we thought a man that he did it with wine and it seems like mine is an offer sheet of an heir no he did a sheet of but he used the superior product which is bread and that's why it works for two things umitari mechanical and that's why if you use bread it's good for a sheet of and it's good for an arrow oh my you have to do two you can't just get away with one for both the sheet of an arrow you need a sheet of alone and an error by itself we should know what this means already because he had a number of times in this maserta that one person says the next person says min hug and the next person says what does it mean so we had it ready means i go and i announce it in public i say this is like or minogue in other words if somebody comes to me privately on a one-on-one basis knocks on my door asked the rug rabbi what's that i'll whisper him i'll tell him you could do like remember it's okay but i'm not gonna go with nate colander and announce it in a public uh arena in front of a yeshiva and then you have rebecca um if a guy first if a guy comes knocks on the rabbi's door the rabbi is going to ignore him he won't tell him about romero but if he went and did like rip mayor without we're not going to do anything about it we'll just let it slide the question that that arises here is it says omar abhinum so sorry minicure mayor what does that mean military mayor so rash even says you don't make a much so the problem is remember is mahmeer ramayan says you need two you need an a-roof and you need a sheet of what kind of am i going to do if a guy wants to go out of the halacha let's say let's see that because all you need is one and he decided to go in here he's a bad person because he went like ramayana i'm going to make him i'm going to get up and say what you did is wrong so he did it he did a battle away what's the big deal he says isis the big deal is according to one shot because he made two brachas maybe there's a broccoli over there if the is not like ramayana all you need is one bracha all you need is one sheet of and that's enough so if he did like remain i'm not gonna yell at him you know i'm not gonna i'm not gonna tell him [Music] kaplan we have a mission so we can say show malaysian my voice is still shady [Music] oh you also been zev i miss you where's your bjoel bergman i don't know and meisha hirsch of course is on because he's sponsoring tonight then he's always on andrew glasses gevaltic okay mayor sherman calachava jeff jefferson it's just interesting that i i saw on the ramada rama says that when you make a in his days what they would do is each person had to make a uh a roof each person would bring some flour and together they would bake a challah with everybody's flower he just goes on to say different he doesn't passing like you're mayor exactly okay fine and this is rushing places here exactly where you put the sheet of do you have to put the sheet of in the house or okay so it's interesting you have five groups that are in one mansion how do we view them does the mansion make them one chabura one one a roof or do they all need separate a ruben let's say there's a hotzer and there's other people there do they all go with wire because they're all in one house one giant house different groups so there's does it go by the house the one house brings out one loaf of bread and the rest of the cuts are each or it's each group within that trackline like a like a kind of thing you know like different here here's uh this room is the one another room what exactly is going on here how are they separated what kind of walls that we have a major majorities in the gemara are they serious walls are they small walls do they go up to the ceiling is it made out of real material what's going on the kaburo that each group needs to participate it's considered the the trackland the mansion makes everybody into one habura and all they need is one hero um explain what the big conditions if one group is in the act i see here avi sherman the alios you're in the attic you're not a leo you're having an ali ah he's talking as in mama's like an aliyah you you're going higher you're getting closer to the british level so if you're one group is in the alley of the addict the other group is down in the basement of course they have to bring different so what's the kiddush exactly of course they're like different rooms the different sections or different rooms now i think we should just jump into this for a second just interesting stuff here we'll go through it really quickly the really large thai system um should be i guess there are a few there's two of them but the better one does so if you go like four lines down if you have people in one house of course there it's one a-roof sometimes we're going to see a little bit more of it later on in the next few dapham different types of people come together the the children et cetera but this is interesting we know about this but we're so far removed from it [Music] you have bachram that live in your house they don't live in that city and they come to you to learn torah so do they have to make another of us they don't live with you in your bedroom they have their own room of course he says even though is why so if you jump a couple of lines down he says they all go to the same kitchen they use the same bathroom you do the same thing they use your stove your oven your refrigerator so what we have here is we have your six cheaters really easy two of them they're actually the reverse of each other so when it's a very weak wall when the wall is not made out of strong material like flimsy wood but there's no mach-like is if it's a solid mojito the second motion of nachman is the exact reverse the mach like this is not exactly reverse but even okay so that's two sheets then we have rebria and shimon i didn't have enough room to put the other name in there i just call him if it reaches the ceiling if the machine goes all the way up to the ceiling then you have the but if it doesn't reach the ceiling everybody agrees that they're separated i'm sorry that it's one kabura if it reaches the ceiling that we haven't like is whether they're separated or not but if it doesn't reach a ceiling it's a half a wall it's one house then everybody in the house is one and then you have the same repair shipment we don't know who says what the reverse the mccoy is when it doesn't reach the ceiling but if it reaches the ceiling how do you have a much like this it's a different room and then you have fifth street this much like when nothing to do with walls the attractant is one one mansion bring their together the macholicus is when they took the aero and they brought it to the other guy to the neighbor that's where the maclaiques is but if the arrow was within the mansion everybody agrees that you don't have to make more than one arrow and then you have the reverse of that or the majority says when they come to the mansion and the area is in the mansion then you have a macho but if you go out of the mansion everybody agrees even basil agree need another hero let's see inside that's basically today's suggest this one put over here somewhere okay not going to work here zog overnight when you have some sort of picture here let me see what we have here so first of all here's a picture from the here's your five rooms five people living in one giant house as you can see shorter walls much like this let's call this a mesipas here's my likes so in the isfani in the um carla washington safer i couldn't make out the difference between mesipas and it has a blow up right over here mojito cancer beautiful picture five doors and if you look over here there's a wall wall there are little wall shorter walls one is a mesipas one is a mojito we understand what that is it's when it's a weird like a flimsy wall but if you have a starker wall that's tenth cold agree i'm sorry you may still agree that each group needs a mojito uh there's no category that everybody agrees on a verb and now this is an argument on what said another two shitas these walls reach the ceiling if the walls reach the ceiling or don't reach the ceiling if the walls don't reach the ceiling and everybody agrees it's one open house one a roof but if they reach the ceiling it's open space to everybody so you have a little partition somewhere there's another group but it's one house one arrow the hadamard or perhaps no the reverse is don't come to the ceiling because they're saying what how does it make any sense that makes a lot of sense if the partitions go all the way up to the ceiling so you have different rooms so what's the sadness like that because these are flimsier majitsu's maybe they're not completely separate rooms today's turning of the daf i am based is in memory of my mother shingle bat aaron hersh and bracha by her son dr alan listaus [Music] you'll never see this name again in chat once in a lifetime review review that i guess use somebody else that we don't not familiar with the tana bryce what does it say in the bryce this is like what we just said that if the mercies come all the way to the ceiling there's no mach like us it's a separated separated rooms it's like a hotel it's like different houses who cares if it's a giant amman they're considered one house now so the mother says based on this price we have a major problem with everything that we learned besides the lashita three out of the four sheathers are off we just said that there is no mach like this if it gets to the ceiling if the majitsu has reached the ceiling that's a beautiful division it's a great partition nobody argues of course it's considered different houses so why are you telling me when it comes when it gets to the ceiling so this bryce orabi huda is a steroid to number three number four that there's no accolades when it gets to the ceiling that's exactly what we just said beautiful so that's a good ride to them now let's is when it's very very weak mean what if it's not weak what if it's a starkey mojito not a flimsy piece of wood they still be maida that you don't need that you do need a aerial veneer that's a very strong mojito it separates it tiufta we're just saying that america is that the whole likuses that don't get the to the ceiling in other words it's a majitsa that doesn't reach the ceiling and that's where the machine is according to nachman the whole macholicus is in a flimsy makita if it's a strong mojito there is no mahleikas says no there is in a strong majitsa forget about the fluency this is even about like it's in a strong majitsa that's a problem with me what about the second listener this machine is even in america but what we're saying now is that i argue and now we're saying that even the reason why we argue over here is to tell you that even a strong wall they still will hold that it's considered one the strong wall doesn't divide it up as the gemara of the life so let us if you want to tell us power the how far they go they still say even in a brick wall there's no division it's considered one house it's tremendous right so tell me the opposite tell me even if in a flimsy wall bishop may say it's considered a division i'd rather tell you a cooler than to tell you a brick wall a bunch of brick walls and they're all considered one house that's a tremendous that's a bigger tradition to tell me that a bunch of flimsy walls are considered five different houses when the walls come to the ceiling there's no majorities everybody agrees that it's a division even they still agree that you have to make different a reuven and now we're going to go to the to the to the part of the mishnah we had a little bit of a problem avi sherman's part of the mishnah dictation when people are working at the attic and in different rooms of course you have one family living in the attic it happens all the time people rent that an attic and somebody else rents out a room the different houses what's the why shouldn't they need why shouldn't we require from them differently room so we're not talking about a real addict we're not talking about real rooms we're talking about partitions they made sukkas in the middle of a mansion they took a giant ballroom and they partitioned it off and that's considered as if this family is in the attic and this family is in the basement but it's not really that they're in the attic because if they were really bad and there's no hadith at all the tradition is he took a giant dining room he said oh i'm from mexico i could live in a place uh five feet by five feet and that's my house in my mellow i have to make my own eru tana and here we have a fifth sheeta what according to rashi what the macholic is beside this mansion according to everybody i don't care what the places are it's considered one it's one house so male if it's one house when i make a native we don't need to make we're all in this together but if we're gonna start with other people with neighbors that's where we come and top out that's where we have kish but if the arab is by them since within their house they're considered one and everybody's bringing the heir of to them then there's no mechanic but perhaps if i need to take my arab and bring it to the next door neighbor so since we're leaving since then we only participate in it my entire house has to participate once i'm leaving we all have the president we all have to participate so in mello that's the shiloh do i have to do we all have to bring a separate a-roof or no one guy will be the shliyak for everybody look we're all in this together so maybe basically so say one person is and he'll do it for everybody else they gathered five arabs they're going outside of the house all you need is one arab so who does this according to you need an era for each and every one so this must be going command q basilo this must be going according to the base still they still hold trackland the mansion even if you go to the neighbor all you need is one arrow that's according to the zip chat and now the sixth and final shita the ign when the arab comes to them then we have a macholikes even basilo would agree that once we're leaving the trackman then it's all over everybody has to bring an era of the machlakis is within the trackline that bishop may say each person has to bring their own aero so therefore this is what we just read before the so how do we figure this out five people that gather in the neighborhood when they bring it outside which we just said everybody agrees even we still agree that you need an error for each and every person what does this say all you need is one but even basil you need five key man this can be according to not be because you left the trackland so we don't know how to fix this all right what's interesting if you think about it i don't know about an america i didn't see so much in america but in israel even in the show that we dive in in in venezuela's you have capsule you have these that are that this mission is talking about this whole no it's like these flimsy walls that are a little bit more than tenth falcon made out of plexiglass i never saw it in america i don't know maybe in america they also have it it's like it's like literally little boxes for like you know four or five people 10 people whatever it is i never understood it i don't understand how it works because bacteria i'm not a scientist but i would assume the bacterials that fly above uh you know a five foot plexiglass but anyway and that's why maybe those uh capsules failed and all these shivas but that's what they have this dismission right here the suggestion yeah but but paris that has the capsule that beneath shiva they had 90 guys that had corona okay at work uh work plexiglas works um just not 10 because your head is buff and falcon so you need like 20 whatever it is 15 all right beside her whatever but i'm saying we are we have a better understanding what it is you have a room divided with these fundamentals so we're going we're continuing with this theme this idea of different people in the hearts are are they one are they not one how they connect to each other and how many of them do they need yeah brothers that are supported by the father via shane and but they have their own little rooms they look they all they eat they all eat together dinner nicely like a like a nice american one table and then they disperse they go into their own houses in the hot sun is gonna start off saying oh you see that it goes by where you sleep and not where you eat so if one of the brothers forgot to make a nerve since each and every brother then we can do the concept of beetle you could relinquish your shows and you have to relinquish yourself you can't say oh i'm a brother i'm part of the meshbach no you ruin it for everybody else so if they bring their arrow to another house within the khatsa suraj says this is like amigo here they they answer on the other people so they asked her for themselves they have to bring the aerov out to the other guy but if they're bringing the earth to them they are in the hudson or nobody else lives there it's meshpacha they own the whole thing then you don't have to make an arrow so again if the earth comes to them to this mishpacha or there's living there you don't need another arrow you don't have to make this here see from this look they're all eating at the same table so there's nothing to do with the suit though it has everything to do with where you sleep i'm going to see myself in this i'll review them around not a good writer why they make habit pressure we talk about really spoiled kids father gives them a place to sleep and he also delivers the food to them snapchat they're all eating around the same table but he provides them with food excuse me so let's see if we have this here bass shower is like a little bit of a i don't know like a lobby sort of base shot like a whole alsadro like a gazebo right over here and it repairs this we'll call it like this rapus is really if you look at rashi i think it was like non-tess on the base last ration is a little bit like a lobby actually uh maybe not so it's this is good this is the what the vestibule the base shower is more of a vestibule yeah and this is a professor this is nice i think this fits nicely into rashi here the doors are open to open we had this remember we had the sugiyo with the dhaka okay says mario mishi is a base shower he in the hot sear he owns the vestibule he owns the sandra uber passes he owns he owns the the porch over here he doesn't require an aero because all he has is a porch base at heaven however if he has a room for for his hey bashar bakker gevaldik in middle of one of my employees called me out i'm just thinking about this yesterday one of my employees he worked for me for like 15 years and he moved out to tennessee i said what's going on tim he's like oh he has four goats 30 chickens he gives me a whole list of stuff that he has that's how he used to live in those days in the middle of the haunter he has a bunch of cattle believe it or not this requires an a-roof um if you look closely in these pictures you see some wood peeking out of the door a little storage facility razor all of probably this is what you're thinking to yourself you need a residential room not a room for cattle not a room for wood so they said what he's going to ask for five different katsers he has to make five different um whatever could be lived in says because you could but he doesn't he doesn't live there he lives over there he doesn't live over here the place where he lives that's the only one that is boise have a wonderful wonderful day and now we're going to say something hillary for those that want to stick around [Music] foreign hey