Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 45 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning i'm on a flight from arizona to chicago and the point is your boy said it's all about the army it's all about the yoini on a flight i won't be able to say the share now because it's way too difficult they only gave me permission to record here a pre-recorded message um gary ask me a question anything how's your fight okay so anyway i just want to say this it's all about the enemy and no matter what we're gonna we're not gonna break the street every single day there's going to be a sure-based version of me in honor of yummy schwartz and gratitude for arranging all the details we'll get together this week in queens for abnormal pictures amazing thing there's 20 guys there at least they're doing side stroll they've been yummy we can't hear you why not why didn't you hear at all zero why can't you hear how about now did you hear i will no issue i just leave the screen gary gary pretend this is live what's going on gary okay this is not going to last for a minute only a minute um this is sponsored by yossi sasha for my wife you hooded youtube there are days there's too much which is the voice that reminds me it's all about me nobody says all about behind me i should send their strength and success to continue to be an amazing wife and mother happy birthday sponsored by ira greenstein murray mordecai talked about just for a second yesterday we were talking about this amazing phase is where a person has 4 000 ammos below ground and i'm going to describe it in this year you'll hear it in a minute the person has four thousand dollars below who's playing this visa below the ground has two entrances and when he comes out of one entrance and he makes a left turn he has 2000 ammo if he comes out of the left entrance and makes a right turn there's two thousand amma and the two the two people overlap each other and therefore he's walking on the top then they overlap and you can walk from side to side but if they don't if they're more than two thousand if they're more than four thousand ammo they have to go back into the cave where he could walk as far as he wants and then come out on the other side says that's because that all happened on shabbos but during the week or sorry it happened before showers happened before travis but on shabbos if the people put him overlapped let's see he goes on a hypothetical and he goes out of his home and we give him a need to come and now they overlap he cannot go back in and our voice i remember it's all about the thing you know me no matter where you are forty thousand feet above the ground vacation i vacation there it's all about the army and now i'm gonna ask gary gary are you there gary yeah um i would say just start it from the beginning if you can because i didn't think and i won't be able to give the shoe from here all right so i'm just going to join watch myself and watch you guys have a wonderful day everybody i'll see you later in a few hours that's mem above that is that's the next year see you then for me at least good morning robosai today shares sponsor sponsored if you're watching this now i am probably already on my way to chicago mid-flight what we're trying to do is because it's all about the yoyomi it's not about the dave it's about the oymie every single day we have to do that so the idea is to try to transmit from the flight live i have everything set up there's a couple of issues that we might bump into first of all the people around me might not like it that much there might be a choppy uh what is it called the choppy connection so if that's the case you will be seeing this year we're going to go to the sheer otherwise it'll be from the airplane uh it's just an hour and a half before we are leaving to the airport and i haven't packed it so i'm going to be thinking about that a little bit but don't let that bother you so we're holding that down on the base the water says so check this out we have a uh a fascinating case here where there's a cave and the cave itself is four thousand ammos or more it's a little blurry oh and if you're kornish visa you're here before shabbos then you could go the entire cave like you do in your house but what's fascinating about this example is that there are two exits to the cave two entrances to exits and suppose the person on shabbos leaves the cave from this exit and he makes a turn this way and he goes on top of the cave he would be allowed two thousand amish because wherever you come out of your house you'll allow two thousand dollars in every direction two thousand this way two thousand dollars this way and if you come out of this entrance you'd be allowed two thousand diamonds going this way so what we have here is two tromim combining and in this particular case they combine in the middle with this green arrow and there's an overlap of the tutum and therefore the halacha is he's permitted to come out of the cave and walk the entire thing provided it's less than 4 000 ammo but if it's more than 4 000 i'm um let's say it's four thousand one so they don't overlap he wouldn't be able to go more than two thousand ammo he'd have to stop and if he wants to get to this side he would have to come back around and go all the way from inside and come back out beautiful case so this is the case got it this is the case of that is absorbed when the they overlap each other okay so mario said there's an afghan that happens in this case where on shabbos a person realized that he went and he bought himself another 2000 amma and it overlaps his renal trum that case is different because he wasn't kind of schwiza before shadows in other words there's a big difference between a cave where he's there before shabbos where he's permitted to go through the overlapping tome and when it happened on childhood says the gemara so the lord but if he wasn't kind of schwiza like in this case where it happened on shabbos we got himself he's going on a hot solo call and we we allow him another 2000 amas but this happened on chavez and it overlaps his original he's not allowed to go back but none so by the way i just want to point out that i am barakasha i'm going on a streak there's no streaks near the sky we discussed this already but i have a streak of over 320 days straight of sheer and that's why i'm going through this trouble of recording this year now hopefully to have the shear on the plane on the flight so that we have consistency there's no stopping the daf i wish i could say the same thing about the minidaft that's a whole different story but in terms of the daf we want to be consistent bosnan so very similar case and this is what we have uh in the last ahmed of this peric so let's say the blue dotted line is this thumb the blue and he goes out of the throne revelation says if he goes out two amos it's okay he could go right back in and this would be an idea of overlapping truman over here he's out of the trum but since he's allowed four ammos every person has four rounds so his four ammas are the red line pretend it's the red line it overlaps into the blue line and therefore he's allowed back in this and then he goes back home even though he's at two thousand and one and a half hours away from his house and that shouldn't be like well he says he's allowed two hobbies but if it's three not my life on is saying that he's in them smack in the middle of the four almost he has two on each side of him the album is diable rabbanaon and the four obvious that rabona gave him command ballon doming they are overlapping become a reconyx if eliza says it's great you could go all the way home alma because he holds i've lost home and milsi because he holds up this concept of overlapping tremen you're asking me a question from lesler on rebbe already rabbah on malay sabbah says yes in correct i heard from rabba atkan everybody greets this idea what ad can we please virus where is the macholic is between laser how many ammonias a person has say once you go one inch past this blue line in this direction you can no longer go back home revelation says he has two hammers why is your machis because they're discussing virus shows a person decided on his own to go out of the throne but over here in our case agreed that he has two two hamas in each direction everybody will greet this and it's a cache so why in our case we're talking about that solo call we're talking about give a lady giving birth to the kid and therefore everybody agrees he has those extra hammers all the people that go to save things save people they could go all the way back to their place says the gemara um tuba so it seems like you go all the way back to your place it doesn't say the distance even even more even more than two thousand ammo what does it say only two thousand amish you that says in the name of what's going on here you talking about soldiers jewish soldiers go to war when they come back are they permitted to carry their guns their swords the clay zion are they gonna bring it back it's muktil so you think no just drop it wherever you are you did your business you took care of business put your no so they're loud they're permitted to come back they're not gonna go all the way home you're right they only have two thousand atmos because what's the point of them coming back with their tools they're remote see we gave them we lighted them up until 2000 you talking about soldiers if they drop their tools what if the enemy comes surprises them and they don't have their weapons they have to be able to carry the weapon all the way home ellie castro so in fact what's the question [Music] we're talking about so somebody would come to testify that he saw the moon he would have to stay right there by the sanhedrin and not move well you have that little enclosure but he wouldn't be able to go home he wouldn't be able to go around syrian he has 2 000 ammo in every direction especially takana you know otherwise people might not want to come testify 2000 even a midwife helping a woman give birth the habbala hatsune and we're talking about the soldiers and this is the nakuda right here the soldiers that's what we're talking about people saving from a from a uh a river in other words people drowning or or rescue workers there's a earthquake women had like a fireman harenka anjio vegeta so they don't lose their trump they could go in every direction but but they they only have the 2000 amma they don't get more of america it seems like if you're going to war you come back it doesn't doesn't say an amount i feel even more vivid they're coming back with their weapons but they only get the 2000 ammo so again they're going with their weapons we allow them we give them a special dispensation that they're allowed to come back and they have two thousand dollars they can't go all the way home glad to take their their weapons with them to start out with they made a rule that when you come back from war it's mukta a gun is mukta so what do you do you can't just show up some alecha i'm with my god i just went to war so why do you need your gun now so they said the first house closest to the wall of the city put your guns in that house put all your weapons there the swords whatever it is terrible tragedy happened the enemy noticed that the jewish soldiers don't have weapons anymore so he chased them down on so they ran back to the house and grabbed their weapon and they were chased into the house and what happens when there's a panic i mentioned the story already i was a child in the mirror yeshiva in brooklyn and somebody screamed fire fire there's a fire in the boiler room and the entire place in the middle of mussels whatever it was they started trampling each other running out of the building and uh i don't think anybody really got injured from it but it was just i just remember the panic people pushing each other and the tossing is everything panic causes more damage sometimes than the actual fire than the actual problem itself right where they have they had a they had a panic in one of the stadiums in europe they had a in uh one of the bars i think there's a big panic and people just trample oh by by the way by um shave it a little bit i'm going to mention by reversing this by reverses levia reverses levia two people were nifty unfortunately the panic the mamas died no no they just got trampled posture trampled but i don't know if that's panic that's a little different that's just a lot of people travel but panic people don't know what to do they just run we had a fire once in the hotel on shabbos and people were running running over kids is terrible anyway so they decided go all the way home with your weapons very simple answers excuse me when the jews win they don't need the two they don't need the weapons anymore and here's when the gallium beat themselves it's a it's a nice it's a proper language you don't want to say that eleno they beat us you say they beat themselves the point is they are fleeing when the jews flee they can flee with their weapons israel when the non-jews they surround the jewish cities you don't go to war with them to save your property let's see you saw it if you see somebody coming out to steal you don't come out with guns blazing you don't you know you be careful of the muk have a ball that's going to foster so obviously if they come to kill you of course even is the fascist number one mitzvah that's the first in the line of defense even if they're coming to steal the straw because once the enemy comes in even to steal and they overrun you then they'll go through you and they go to the next city so you're the first line of protection you have to put up a fight yes and bubble is considered the first line of defense with our gumo and they explained it nahir dawg nardo is like demon city so the main city you got from there you get to the other cities you've got to protect that city those who haven't destroyed them in berry and what are they doing they're consuming the the the wheat so for that that you go to war tonight yeah kilo was the jewish city on the line mainly to push just you would ask it a question for clyde strong and it would light up sarah you know the different thing you had to know how to read you have to have a question to know how to read it and interpret it but it would light up the the stones would light up it's very interesting is like this is the side stories that david he wasn't a king yet he was running away from shoal and he felt that if he goes to ila he shall could trap him there in fact shall chased him in tequila and he saved kilo and then he asked are these guys that i just saved are they going to give me up the shoal and the urban tomb said yes get out of here and he ran unbelievable he did a favor to gili save their lives from the pollution and then they were going to give him up to shaw he says what was david asking eleanor we know what to do when there's the shia lana what do you do haribo why is there like a light shining on my face do you see that on the screen it looks like on that screen at least okay if they were asking shia lana harry based dinosaurs they should have just asked directly to shimul they're the best you says over here so what do you see from here how do you know it's on chavez how do you know anything because it was a mohammed it was a muhammad of and a war is mysterious looks good yeah that one for some reason you see that one looks like there's a shine on the face three screens two good one is interesting interesting color everything is like white look at the hands i guess you have to readjust the that also huh okay something needs to be adjusted sorry boys it's for the sorcerer better enjoyable a better experience while you're watching this year try to fix it just don't shut me off completely this is only by the way it's only me gary and yeshua and the beast it is what time is it now it's close to nine o'clock right no you don't can't let people in there's another share the the nature is starting now but uh this comes first i'm sorry anyway so you hear what tyson says he says since it's a muhammad and uh every war is the sukkot is the fascist obviously it's muhammad now i just want to say a couple of allahs that have to do with that salah because this is the suggest allah they go on a call are they permitted to come back home we know that they come back home originates really from the sugi i believe are they allowed to play around with the radios and shabbos so you have twice this that says that well we'll start with the hazardous hazardous say that if there's going to be more more calls and that you assume that you're going to need your car and everything so you go back home and what does this say now according to titus it comes out very interesting that if a person thinks in his mind let's say khasa saw me there's a tragedy a lot of people in a tragedy let's say a bus whatever and he thinks to himself that he's not going to make it home for uh you know by the time master chavez comes she's going with the intent to be there for a while and then bar hashem he comes there and nothing happened one person a little broken leg so now he wants to go back home could he go back home according to saucer because it has to do with his intent what he thought now according to ravner sauzader says even if you like to come home even if you are going to be over is it right meaning driving a car let's say is it alright so and according and then the the ship television which is the reversal says that according to them are going from only uh is there a bottom you want to come back home now and one last allah says that this idea of of going back home only applies in a situation where um basically makes an afghan between if he's the only person that's able to help or not so that because robson someone says what's the problem the problem is that if he goes there he's going to think themselves well maybe there's other people that will take care of it so if there's other people that could take care of it he's not going to go on a call and then nobody's going to go on a call everybody's going to say the same thing well let that guy go i think that guy's going to go but if he's the only person in town that you don't have that svarium and mela he cannot go back home it's very interesting if he's the only person who comes out of closing his examiner about he cannot go back home the only reason he let it go back home is that he shouldn't come up with an excuse that somebody else is going to do it but that only applies them there's other solo members etc there's a person who didn't pay attention that is within the he trump down the omad baron also he notices wait a minute i'm right there i can make it to the city what am i doing he had no intent to go into the city he cannot go in divira be mayor now it doesn't mean this is very important law economist if you're just reading the words you'd think like on this means don't go into the city that's not what it means it means you could go into the city just he cannot act as one of the people from the city in other words he cannot have the 2000 amazon every direction he could only go from where he is into the city but doesn't get the 2000 amnes around the city like a benier economist he acts as a person from the city he's part of the city and immediately gets the two thousand dollars on the opposite side as well um he went into the city unknowingly now who's reptile from stam like reptile for tiffany was very close to rebecca typhoon was extremely wealthy just want to remind the islam there's once a story a beautiful story in the gemara where rebecca told republican give me some money i want to buy you a bunch of cities it's a good real estate deal and they gave money and later on reptiles knew where my cities i want to see my investment and he brings him into bismarck and he shows them the background there and the water says retirement was very happy with the investment he says this is much better obviously you can't go around to people and say give me money let me invest in real estate and go give it to kylo digmar says it's specific over there where rebecca knew there would be typhoon would be extremely happy and that's why he did it for him we learned actually we learned who's considered wealthy rebukida says somebody has a good wife no bimeison and that's what he had rahul and riptifen says somebody has a hundred orchards and fields so that's what he had anyways that's his wealth tanya i'm just saying just to to point out who retirement is give a little bit of a background very there's a story reptile who is very wealthy but a tremendous goal of attorneys you're going to see he was walking and it became dark the longhorns layer no he took residence on the ground to roy bakker on shabbos morning it's very interesting the head chapters the shepherds the jewish shepherds worked on chavez allah says you have to feed the animals before you feed yourselves they went maybe they dumbed the seeking they they brought the animals out before they ate themselves they ate armor lorry rebbe what's going on reptile finish why don't you just go into the city reconyx unbelievable he's on the way he barely he goes in the basement darshan's straight the entire day maybe he had an intent to go into the city so maybe that's why he's kind of so our case is that the guy was following he didn't realize it's a city maybe a retirement realized you don't know that friend didn't realize maybe the basic measures was within the two thousand not that he was going to go to the opposite side of the city and go 2000 he was just going to go within his trump base measures within his time says there's a sleeping person we just had a few daff ago and it's based on this mission what's that if a person doesn't realize and doesn't have that's to be kind of he doesn't have the intent to take up residence why because he's schluffing he's taking her up he's napping really why not let me ask you something very good you need that semicondition does your computer have two thousand arms in each direction if the answer it does that means you don't need that because the computer doesn't have deaths although there are some computers that beat people in the chess but they don't have that anyways it's a good thing you're here now you know you have two thousand amish according to your bianca minori but you are going according to the majority and that is you don't have anything you have the bare minimum that everybody has which is four almost because you need das to be showing this okay revelation says ruby laser that you only have and we're going to see so pretend i'm just using this over maybe this is a better picture for that although it's pretty soon wow let's say this line or this whole entire thing is for amaz so he's in the center and he gets two amis in this direction two hammers in this direction i had more things to print but my internet went down as i was leaving here but it's bashar rabbihood a guy has four amis so pretend that each one of these boxes is four amis he's in the middle he has four armies this way four rounds this way four hours this way four hours he gets to pick and choose but only one way one one time one one picking review he decided to go to the east chennai but he goes four arms from where he's standing to these but he doesn't have four amis all the way around him to pick and choose yes but once you choose that's it now we're maybe more only because it's yellow i didn't have time to highlight it better now you have two individuals very beautiful case beautifully designed this guy has his arm is going this way this guy has his thumb going in this way and they meet the overlap in the center so what's that if they want they could nash and you're not allowed to take from one area to the other we just turned to that base sponsored by mike's mark steinberg the coven of her son is his family to be toro jews wow that'd be cool if we make it all the way here on the airplane on united flight i don't know what to chicago direct flight one of the first direct flights from israel to chicago it would be record-breaking with set another record not only the cm will be the first time we have a shirt that's listened to by thousands of people barakasha on a plane that would be unbelievable what are the chances gary broadcast from the plane what are the chances that that works garrison is giving me very very low chances okay so this will have to suffice i am there's three people we're a boy's side three people here we go there are three people and each one has a little box the center guy has the blue box and each guy on the side i know why they use yellow okay they're very into yellow i would make it red or something so it's more noticeable the center guy gets to be in each guy's box but the guys on the side have no relationship to each other these guys you see these guys cannot go to each other they cannot the middle guy could go to him he could go there and this guy could go to the middle and this guy go to the middle but they cannot go to each other let's see by the way here's another picture from sean all very very beautifully done a little uh oh maybe more ah here's the guy in the middle here's the guy the little palm tree going on this guy cannot go this way it's the same idea just i'm talking about graphics okay fine now using this guy's graphics because it's simpler what we have here is three categories one two three as we always say a cutter needs two houses two has opened to khatu what happened was if they make a giant aruvei khatsera is great but what happened was this guy made area of katers to him and this guy made an error of khatiris to him but they didn't all make it together so he could carry here and he could carry here this guy but this guy cannot carry over here the bikridge that i could bring my barbecue or whatever something that's not most into this hotzer i'm not concerned that he's gonna take it and bring it over here i'm not concerned but it's the same idea as the guy sitting next to each other what time is it because i gotta go pack soon wow taxi's coming in 55 00 minutes i need a pack and i need to finish the the three right as you can see from the picture they are open into the saraba ritual we have to finish the death sorry they're coming for the next year airbus time i'm sorry simultaneously he gets two thousand amps in every direction in other words the computer doesn't need das uh but dino would lift like the kalin so really should argue about computers and watermelons and why are they talking about a human being that's sleeping that rabbit hole even a human being if he acts as in uh as a computer as a watermelon he doesn't get atom listen if he was up he'll get his two thousand amazon in every direction so what if he's sleeping it's like choleroy libido maybe just as an example he should have the that if a commercial is sleeping he does not get it he's no better than a watermelon and that's what you were saying very good maybe he holds in general that a watermelon doesn't have and over here he owes a human being is different than caleb don't compare this to a human being for the same reason that we just gave them a or khan yoshinomi khan since if he was awake he would have two thousand so we don't differentiate and we say even a sleeping person has two thousand omar abby i'll prove it to you are the mayor of yanter if rain fell before yantav in other words the rain had the ability the brain this in i said it before inanimate object has the ability to be coinishvisa why because it was before yanta if it happened yes the rain has it could go you could carry the rain in every direction beyond them but if a fellaini author of hurricane so whoever picks up the rain whoever picks up the water then whatever that person has if that person has 500 i'm a left 500 to that direction and if that person gives it to a third to the second person the second person has nothing it's whatever the first person that lifts it up has now because and again because the water that falls on the outside doesn't have the ability to be kind of cheesy because it's happening now what is reverend so if you hold that he that if you say there are no holds that this cup this watermelon who's this going according to omani rebecca great because ruben says you have the the rain is just like a watermelon just like a watermelon has two thousands in every direction so too does the rate elia ain't quite so but if everybody can hold that watermelon does not have two thousand ammo hamani who is this golden coin that the the lockhart and certainly not rabona no hold that a human being doesn't have two thousand arms you know a sleeping person only has four apples so who does this go according to joseph so so i was saying this over in the name of his rebbe of yosef maybe we're talking about rain that's next to the city and it's not that the rain has its own ability to to be carry two thousand amma it's because the people in the city ivan here died the people in the city want to decide they're gonna move the rain and the mela they were kind of and the rain gets their visa [Music] if there's a pit owned a well owned by individual correctly then the water could only go as far as the owner of that pit goes so wherever he goes wherever his term is that's where the water goes bishop but if it's a well owned by the city by this chiraglio wherever the people in the city go on the different directions of the city bishop oil above but if it's for people in other words it's hefty it's people coming from bubble territorial kiraglia then each and every one could fill it up now we have to cash vitanio we have a contradiction in the branches borshol which basically means the same exact thing as we said a second ago oily bubble a second ago we said oily bubble get whoever fills it up yesterday it doesn't go by the individual that fills it up it goes by the water the water has its own caching isn't this a contradiction on the one hand you say water in a well could go 2 000 in each direction on the other end you're telling me that water in the well could only go as far as the person that draws the water and if that person has five ammo left to his five ammo so you must say al-afsh must be that is that says that an inanimate object has two thousand dollars in every direction remember we just had a buyer reminds reviews is the one that got sick late in life and abaya was a big talmud of his he used to remind him all the time but over here it's not about that he also committed obviously is still with it of software ask perhaps the reason why rain can go wherever it could go is because it's based on the people from the city it's not the rain itself so why does the bryson mention that the rain could go 2 000 in each direction lohen like the rain itself hakka raglian the lesson should have been it has only to do with the people in the city wherever they go nothing with the rain we'll just finish up here i need to catch a flight oh my god when it comes to jantiv then harayan kiragli call autumn when it comes to rain rain that falls then whatever the people whoever grabs the rain that's how that's how far you could go with it where did the rain come from rain comes from very good an ocean very very good from the ukianas so let the pianos so that's where that's where it started out so should go 2000 amazon from the ocean what do you have an extra from where it falls rain doesn't come from nowhere rain comes from the from the from from the ocean and the evaporator goes let me look at it with the azer rebellious of the opinion like what we what science understands today the kirby laser oh my quality the rain starts off in the ocean evaporates becomes a cloud comes over the the land and falls it seems like it's not like him because according to rebellion the trump should start in the ocean not from where the rings fell from there yeah it comes from the ocean it evaporated it was in a in a cloud and then the cloud moved there so i'm going based on the cloud not on the ocean but how could you pay attention which cloud it was how do you know this cloud was above your house when java's came in maybe it's a different cloud says the gemara of this lucy it looks like a fish it looks like a giraffe the cloud and he followed this giraffe through the sky oh here's the here's the cloud that was within the trum when chavez came in the boy saying i have a subject to develop me right maybe i don't know but it's still a soft episode there i am says the gemara two more lies we like the sweets let the let it let it behold the trom in the cloud itself could you prove from here that we had a whole chain on it guys on a tightrope is there above 10 so the clouds are going by so the the trim should be over there yeah so we don't care about clouds because there's no water in clouds there's only an evaporation and this evaporation is not considered anything until it becomes rain and falls down rabbis i hope to see you in a few hours from now from the flight if not i will see you baser hashem from chicago live from chicago whoever wants to join in chicago please be my guest a good today have a wonderful day we have to pretend it's daytime now have it is it's wednesday it's already halal it's already wednesday so we're not over on the yoyobeam thing zeitgeist wow you