Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 38 by R’ Eli Stefansky

all right good morning rav boisei today lulu nishmas rossi roosevelt somebody said oh wow my mother is also after yesterday same no every day it's my mother he thought it's my mother's yard today the other day um today's share is being sponsored by our great friend a new one from south africa ian meltzer with massive thanks and hashem's richest blessings to you ellie and your team for getting me into gemara learning and rafa for mordechai maisha ben freda so it's a beautiful thing like i said people that started miseras aravin they're in for a little treat because once we're done with the aravin it's smooth sailing for a long time every event i think i forgot what it is i think it's iron irvine ivamus anita maybe i don't know i don't need this in there i don't know if the middle one is i in the ud i don't know why they say it okay well the last few days were a little bit rough yeah whatever so anyways oh by the way i met ian's son on chavez coincidence he the very good friends with my dancer's neighbor donnie sopher and it happens to be that ian's son learns with my son and yeshiva it's a small world aaron he goes to bury clients but kids are beautiful stuff all right it's not the first time he's sponsored i don't know if you noticed uh and today's share is being sponsored by tv fine in memory of his grandmother should have an aliyah we have a uh a surprise email here from our good friend a lot of you are wondering where in the world is michael cohen michael cohen he used to learn in philly shiva he's a hush of a lawyer where is he have you ran in almost five months oh sadly i took a shabbos and some of shabbos though i'm not on zoom i'm back i've been sidetracked by a very difficult personal professional struggle but ultimately realized that disengaging from my commitment to death you me cannot help me you cannot dive in i say le mans hirosha if you don't learn torah as soon as i recommitted i saw yadashem but of course like everybody else when they write email they have a sticklehara i was upset about one thing you said on the zoom i joined a few weeks ago on my first day back air venda yutes you read an email from someone who said he missed a lot and you said so you won't make a scene with everybody in metlife stadium you'll make your own see in vahulu oy hashem when you said this it felt like a punch in my gut if i heard that he would be making less hashism alone he must have been completely discouraged you must remind people that what remission said that one can make a scene on one daf that they will be welcomed with open arms to met life rubai ke kulai please contact this guy and tell him that i will pay for his ticket at midlife and he'll sit with me and my brothers and celebrate as much as he completed sincerely michael p.s please ask yeshua from akilah he's been texting me throughout the last few months asking where i am i've consistently responded that i found the better that you share with a magician that's even a more professional bhagava than you i'm assuming he means like he reads four emails about himself not two like how could he how's it shy to be more of a professional guy than me wow oh i don't think he got that i was kidding classic amaritz nice and to top it off we have he sent me the official airline of the sheer so you sure kayak michael we missed you and your graphics now by the way it happens to be it is rosh hashanah but because he stalked me i i'm going to take the liberty [Laughter] you know it's not a good idea to stalk me no i'm a navi anyway so la maison what i'm trying to say here is it's only because he called me a bhagava that i have i wouldn't do this to just a regular average joe i think the fact that he he wasn't learning for five months he pushed his his cup is for stopped he learned the wrong shot in the in what i told that guy this kid he's a is a a fitness model remember him and i told him don't worry about it you don't have to make a scene on 2711 daf with everybody but of course you go to metlife stadium people that don't learn a word of gemara go to metlife stadium you want to be there with 92 000 people say oh my ish mirab of course that wasn't my point not to go to medlife my point was that just because people finished shots on january 1st doesn't mean you have to finish on january 1st i went to ufc and what a month after a month before i didn't remember one everybody does different times so he'll finish a month after everybody he'll make his own team will feel special about himself be something unique but rather you go to metlife no michael get back into it i want to see the the kishrin over here here's another one from uh rababram to katsuki i have a special place in my heart for him because as we had we're pushed out of the space measures the first day of covid and i came home and i say this all the time there's a big giant box massive box with a beautiful um painting a piece of art from from what's his name new the famous artist no no um you know why rib beautiful for my wife with a plaque in it for the rabbits and it was beautiful anyway so i have a very special place in my heart thing hashem is still around and he says first of all i want to wish you some time to continue inspiring you then around the globe your live demonstration the other day with the boxing stick was amazing also your idea with cutting down a smartphone uses a wonderful idea and basically goes on to say that he made a bit this is he there's a base measure that he created in in lakewood after his grandfather he's in the backyard of his son-in-law speaking rubenfeld gets him to have a working program every evening for for bella it sounds amazing something that we want to do over here as well one day and they give food and people come have all my son and this isn't like good and then he says he came up with a poster and also if you have if you haven't seen this in america it's amazing a lot of shows have this this is a phone locker uh the show in chicago at least has um you can recharge your phone and every one of these lockers you take the key and what he said is that they do a raffle so based on the number when they see the key is missing they'll throw your number in a raffle and you can win 20 40 every night it's a very cool idea and the show has this thing right over here it can wait lock up your phone there's nothing on the phone that cannot wait until after your conversation hashem don't let your internet connection break your connection with hashem and um i got this uh text huh okay and i got this in a whatsapp from jonathan stevansky can't give up the smartphone but did take upon myself not to use it during daviding at least through assets this is beautiful stuff people rabbi uh david um what's his name no what life is father no bernard david yeah they're burned on david he sent me also that it's amazing now without the phone call turkey not called her give me a kid sir all right so we're holding daf lametress by the mishnah brand new parrot brandon secta revised me starting today musertus irvine uh section two rebelizer oymer you know it's amazing that we're discussing something that's happening in just a few days rosh hashanah is going to fall out on sunday in shabbos as well so this is basically what the mission is discussing what's even more amazing is it doesn't happen very often it's a real coincidence that tomorrow's the mishnah talks about rosh hashanah even mentions the word rosh hashanah def mem which is even closer to roshana talks about fila it's beautiful stuff today's mishna we're discussing is rosh hashanah what did i do with my charts oh okay got nervous there for a second okay let's let's call this chart you have a like this year you have a shabbos and yantif two days is it considered one long geduja or it's two separate days two separate douches if i set up one error of does it work on both days not only that could i set up two separate a ruben one for day a one for day b one for shabbos one for sunday in other words i could maybe walk in different directions if it's considered two different gaducious shabbos one gedusa has no connection to rosh hashanah that falls out on sunday it just happened to be one after another so therefore i could i can make an area of over here walk two thousand almost in this direction this is the end of the city and here's the end of the city this way on rosh hashanah i'll walk this way right roshana and chavez both near the earth do we call it all wrapped in one starts on friday night ends on sunday night so rebels falls out on a friday or roshana falls out on a sunday but back to back shabbos with the yantaf or yanta with the shabbos mire of adam schneider of him a person can make two separate a rule of them they have no connection shabbos and rosh hashanah aruvey berisha in the mizrah my first arrow will allow me to go to the east on the first day let's call chavez like in this year uba shani and the next day on sunday lemaire of i'm going to go to the west barishin lemairo okay i can do the reverse shabbos i'm going to go to the west sunday i'm going to go to the east or here's a big finish a ruby be reassigned i wanted a roof to last me for 24 hours only on the day called shabbos ooh excuse me uba shani and on the second day sunday kevin eerie no area of at all i'm done i'm only going to use my area for for shabbos sunday i won't have an aero and therefore i don't have an aero i could go from my house i could go in all directions two thousand almost not from where the area of his two thousand amis i could go up and down right and left because i don't have an arab i'm like a regular city person here there and everywhere on sunday and i don't want anything to happen on shabbos it's two separate days it's two separate douches it has one has nothing to do with the other it's amazing thing for 24 hours i don't have an air of all of a sudden bam i got an error of going why because i made it up before before shabbos came in i made up my mind i'm going to have her for sunday so that's if you hold this two douches in the gemara actually have a suffolk but let's call it for now one kedusha it starts on friday night and goes for 48 hours straight it's one continuous kedusha and therefore whatever you do before shabbos comes in or before yandev comes in that's going to last you for the entire 48 hour period there's no changing you can't do two you can't do one a half it has to be one long thing now listen to the slush because the kumar is going to talk about this lotion here or i could go to one direction for how long for 48 hours of cold icker or i have everything i'm all in or all out nothing in between i'm gonna make my air of either to the east and it's going to last for the entire 48 hours for shabbos and the first day of yante for the second day whatever it is or i'm going to put it on the or zero but i can't split it up because it's one long douche now i ain't a matter of collector in the first line no error and then the mishna repeats itself [Music] slightly different lotion but it means the same exact thing or i'm going to make an arrow for two days meaning on one side before he said i'm going to make an error on one side meaning for two days then the mission repeats itself or he's going to make an error for two days meaning on one side in one direction it means the same exact thing and the gemara explains why it repeats itself this certainly is word for word as the line right before or there's zero no area of at all or an area for two days kate yasa we just had this a few days ago the gemara brought this mishna word for word allah a person is making an area for two days he wants to use one bread let's say one loaf of bread he is concerned that if he leaves it outdoors in the middle of the desert a camel is going to come by and eat his bread what's going to happen if he eats his bread he won't have an error for the second day especially if you hold like rebellizer that says but even according to rabban they hold that you won't have an area for the second day so what does he do his shliyak goes and retrieves the aero he waits until the first day nightfall let's see if we have we don't really need a picture for this but first day shabbos no not a good picture sorry friday is rosh hashanah this yantev and the second day is shabbos so he on on thursday night he goes and puts his a-roof waits until it becomes dark yeah yeah this is before any of that stuff yeah it's just for for uh demonstration purposes only it's not blue usually is purple but for demonstration purposes i change the color sorry so anyways the point is it's just a muscle muscle by the way we did have that the roshana falls on friday and whatever we said at that machine so let's say rosh hashanah falls out on on just because this year we have something similar so that's why i did rosh hashanah he's going to put his area of when when it's still daytime he's going to put it down wait around make sure that the sun goes down it's night he's going to pick up his arrow and walk home with it why because all you need is that being smashes the area should be there it's hal it's a good heir of an animal could come and eat it it's okay and certainly you could take it home whole and bring it home then the following morning or not evening he brings his ear back during daytime places his arab in the same place perhaps eating the same bread and that's shabbos friday night the sun goes down boof it's the area for shabbos and then he's going to eat it right there and then he could eat it on the spot because it was roy lahilla for a moment during banished mushes now i just want to point out one thing that actually points out we're talking about why because we're going to see even today there's something called that is love he makes an area with his feet in other words if you yourself the the person that wants to use the air of is right there at the makam shvisa in the desert you don't need a challah you don't need the air of you are there you are kind of swissa you don't need an aero if you are there if you are not there you send somebody with a khala and say hey you be kindest visa for me pretend my residence is over there in the desert but if you personally are in the desert that is your era of kind of raglav so you're there for a moment during banashmash's you walk home so this whole story only happened with a messenger otherwise you don't need a khala the first day the goes there um they make sure that it's nice and dark the nightly and he takes it ubala and he brings it back home bashing so for the second day max he makes sure he's there right before nighttime and then the sun goes down it's completely dark and then he could eat it ubalo and he comes home without an aero but it's okay you don't need an arrow to be physically there all you need are to be there is for a moment during banash masha's video so he gained by going there making an error and he also gained that he's able to to eat the aero if he's really hungry what about this case rabbi first go shabbos the first day is shabbos the second day like an hour then this year rosh hashanah is on sunday also pretend son is one day tomorrow we're going to discuss the two days one two shabbos you cannot do this trick on chavez why you can't carry how he's gonna carry the aero all the way home so what does he do when this situation happens he brings his area right before shabbos he waits until it becomes dark he goes home without a nerve he can't bring it home the following day he's going to go to the aero and see if a camel ate it if a camel ate it then he cannot carry on rosh hashanah no not he can't go further this way he still has the 2000 amis of of his city he could go yeah but he can't he can't move this way but if it's if the arrow is there he knows that it's good and he ca and he can use the arrow and he can use and he uses what if the on the first day the bread was eaten a rue veiler re-showing the enerva la shaney it only works for one day then his second day he doesn't have an earth on milan rebellion don't you agree with me admit to this line say that if the aero was eaten between the first and the second day there's no area on the second day but if you hold that it's one long doucha so why is the area of not enough that it was mushes on friday this one if you hold that it's one gducha so then one area should be enough for both days you put the air down over here right before friday and it's a good area for the first day then it was eaten it should be good for the second day why not it's one geducho so you're telling me that it's not good for the second day that means you're telling me that it's two separate days it's two separate douches but it is good it is good for both days or i'm sorry it says ruby lashayni it's not good for the second day that means it's tugducious rebel ezra has a tremendous time here rebless is the one that holds that it's two separate days i can make an error for one day an ear for another day i could go in two different directions two different areas if that's the case so why are you telling me so it fits in very well that if i make it a roof and it was eaten it's not good for the second day because the second day this it's it's only if an aero is good for two days that means it's one we do so if it's not good for two days it's two douches it's so how come it's not good for the second day says so um great answers nothing much is going to discuss that language in the mishnah that was repetitive when the mishnah says in that you go to one direction for how many days obviously it's talking about that you go in one direction for two days and the following line it says you put it for two days the year for two days obviously you want to go to one direction so the mission is repetitive says mario okay you're right i'll prove to you that it's two douches out why because look could you make one aero until afternoon and then another area from afternoon to the evening and go into different directions obviously you can't so therefore so that's what they meant in the first lessons you look at the mission of you can't you can't make you can't split a day and a half so you can't split two days in half i do admit to that so they tell him if you can't split one day in half how can you split two days in half so what's the obvious answer to that verb you can't split one day you can't split a shabbos and and and split up divide the hours in half shabab is until minha i'm going to go east shab is after milk i'm going to go west that's one she can't do that but on two separate days says rebel ezra i could split them in half they're two different douches so it makes a lot of sense as i realize i could go on day one i could go to the east on day two i could go to the west now what's revelation um means that you are physically there if a person is physically there in the desert where he doesn't even need bread don't you agree my birthday that he has to come back it's not good enough to come thursday night right before jantef comes in and say oh i was kind of chavisa here and then walk home and then you have an area for two days straight don't you agree with me that he has to come back yontav afternoon and be and make another area physically and be there and say i'm going to be there for the second day of shabbos my viralium shiny okay now what about the last line in the mishnah nexon what if he placed the khala there on the first day on yantev and the halo was eaten that the aero doesn't work for the second day no that tells me that's two gduchas if it was one gadusha just like if i place an error of heir of shabbos for one millisecond of banash mashes it's good to go for 24 hours so according if i put it there for one millisecond management it should be good to go for 48 hours why do you say it's not good for 48 hours it's only good for 24 hours obviously they have a hole in their theory obviously it's not one long douche a hundred percent because it was one long doucha one error of in the beginning of of banished mashes of friday should be enough for two days um you're right bush's saying continues and says but no so this is proof that it's two douches if you tell me that you you required a second era of according to for the second day should we look at the chart again sam if this is one kedusha then if i put an aero right over here it should last me through the whole gedosha the fact that ham say that if it was eaten somewhere over here an animal came came and ate it this day doesn't have an air of that means there's a break here it's not one geducho says the gemara what's going on here vera bonanza but i'm not sure if it's one geduja or two dushes they have no idea so that's why they say let's go luchumra in every single case let's take the case individually and go to gold so in this case which the mission started off at i cannot put two a rule of him on both for some reason the article says hey roofs i'm not sure i have to look into it why he says hey robes shouldn't it be a reuben i'm not a israeli but no a reuben is but they know what they're talking about i'm not gonna fight with them but it was looked interesting anyway in this case that i want to be makel i want to put an arab on either side of my town and walk one day this way and one way that way saying let's be mahmeer it doesn't work i need to be mahmoud because i don't know if it's two duchess of wangadusha let's in this situation say it's one kedusha and therefore i can't divide the two days one area and that's it that's homura but in the case that the area got eaten up i can't be mako and say oh it's one kedusha and let one heir work for two days over there i'm going to be mahmoud again and say let him place another heir of i want to be mahmur on him let's pretend that it's two douches wherever it's more humor that's what i'm going to use if if the humor is to say it's one gaducion i'm going to say it's if the humor is because i don't know i don't know situation the unknown makes you do hummus that's what they said you need another aero and what do we call that we're not going to go into this second in two seconds we will it's a hamarigama kamar gummel in other words since you have a suffolk you cannot go this way and you cannot go this way perhaps your air of doesn't work so i can't go this way i could only go from my town up until thereof and from my ear of back to the town i can't go to the other direction of my city i can't go this way well i could go a little bit this way halfway through the city that's a different suggest but just let's make it easier i cannot go this way because perhaps my area of work my visa i my i reside right here by my khalas i can only go this way i can't go past my town to the other direction but perhaps this doesn't work my my visa is in my town so i can only go here so i'm stuck between a camel and a donkey that's what i'm going to say in other words suffic is a lotion of suffolk because it was eaten it was eaten no it was eaten yeah in this in a situation that was eaten i'm talking about eating if it was not eaten then yeah then i have uh then i have a then i have an area of another oh for one day in other words yeah i could go to that side if i make one error of to the east and one area to the west hakam say it doesn't work i have to be questioned for one gedosha so yeah that what that one area would work throughout the two days um so now what i'm saying itself where is the unto fear if friday is rosh hashanah could i make an aerov by tashel time yeah when do you do first arizona could i go and make an error for shabbos no i can't earlier under the shabbos only before so what do you see it's one kedusha it's if it's just let it make it over here let it make it by tashler no you can only do it before jantip starts for chavez why because it's one long medusa um i agree don't for shabbos that's preparing for shabbos and i cannot prepare but real quickly i just want to point out twice this if hana is isa right so how does the erupt of shielding help me to prepare and undo it is there isa how could the rabonan error of quote of sheilan heir of tafshilan overcome it isn't that right i saw preparing how could i prepare on the the answer is sister isis because even with the raiso i have the concept called oil i i pretend that i'm gonna i have guests and i'm preparing on yantef extra food for those guests and i just by mistake have extra food for shabbos so that is what gets rid of the isa de raisa and entices all the way at the end there's buses something very interesting that when you take ingredients you're not creating something new you're just fixing it up a little bit whereas the area of you're creating something brand new there's a noise out here taking a bunch of ingredients is not create food when you cook food you're not creating something new so that's not an answer anyway it says tara bono here of if you decided you want to be cheap you don't want to bring a role there you want your feet you want your physical body to be the aero so then you have to repeat that process twice you have to come for the second day also nehaleruba bingham if his arab was eaten on the first day and so we have three shitas here what happens if your aerov was eaten on the first day as usual we have the two extremes and we have the middle one that's coming that's uh apsara a um compromise rebbe says if your era was eaten between the first and second day you cannot use your red you can't do it no good reprisal say it is good one aero what do they hold what are they going to hold it's one kadusha it works you put the air in the beginning it works all the way through and through for two days so if the air was it rebutta says hammer gamo it's in between i don't know it's a suffolk so i'm stuck i can use it between my house and the area of the area of the house that's it so that's the in-between cheetah says the kimono inside me showing if his hair was eaten on the first day and yo it's alabama cheney he cannot use it at all for the second day vivre rebbe who is this rebbe sponsored by asher linden smash's mother writes the best in yemen we're coming up the month is almost over we're switching we already have two bar hashem no i don't know it's a surprise to me and he says raboissai you could decide to make it a great day and bye dr atsadek aaron the father of the tavik anyways dr gamara now i didn't say this weird joke when we were learning the mishnah but we'll say it now real quickly the they say in myself and i have our on this mice they say that uh amaritz came through and he says i would like to borrow your gemara so highway says i can't let you make gemara because you're known in the city you like to make harass on the side you have different common comments and they even sign your name on it no no thank you she says i promise you the shiva i'm not going to do anything so he says if you prom you promise he said it gets to this mishna says gemara and it says he looks and he says no hamar is spelled with av something's wrong here but he promised the replay of logic he's not going to do it but he couldn't control himself amir is not rich she writes on the side hamar gado and he signs his name so he brings the gemara back to behind he says i understand that you you made i already made a comment but why did you sign your name anyway so the reason why i don't think it's a true story even though it's running around the story he was the the original rasheed in the last you know in the i mean they had yeshivas maybe in the time of the gemara maybe even reshaded but they didn't have issues for hundreds and hundreds he reinstituted the kansas yeshivas i don't believe that he would stuck somebody like that you know it's not me and michael cohen kind of thing going on here this is what kind of village is there for it's a it's an interesting joke but i don't think it ever happened anyway the the biggest helmet of the villain going you don't need to you don't need to make an arrow of here in other words one area of is enough it was eaten by an animal it lasts me for two days why because it's one long douchey ruben if his what does revelation say rabbi sai schneider duchess rebel as a whole i could put one ear of for shabbos and i could go to the east a second here for rosh hashanah the second day and go to the west it's two separate douches realize it says two i'm going to give you a list of four tanayim that agree with him who are they valuable everybody's doing beyonce very small very clever hard to say his name even the gemara later on just says the hulu review and the last one here you see number four very beyonce bar you means that a lot of times rebbe who wrote the mishnah he brought rabbi oysi and he didn't even mention his name he's a stam mishna we know establishes we're mayor there are times in shas where rebbe brought him as established though oh the voice of what's going on here look at this rebellion says who who's number one and number two rabshimagam lil rabbishamal what color is this red it's just you can't use one error for the other day you get two separate same names different color reprimanding um leo ruby small say for two days one kadusha what's going on here no what's the turrets based on what we learned yesterday three times anybody apoc [Music] and some people say that you take out this name yo and you put in instead rebel um you take out reviews who's your beloved that the name remember this rashford entire shot anytime the mario mentions rebel azer it means rebel azerbaija not like we just said reblazer birab shiman okay we just finished saying that there's a that they hold that it's one kedusha if i have an error that was eaten i don't need another aero if it goes for all 48 hours says the gemara apo i need a flip rip shooting emilia and ruby small instead of yayte the green turns red and therefore it matches this list right over here so whoever was green turns into red says gemara new rebbe if you're going to turn rip shaming emilio henry red guess who else is red rebbie what's going on here this is the gemara so what rebbe it should be rebbie rip shimming him leonardo bishop says the gamora the rebbe so then why is rebbe not on this list here's the red list this is red look at this list who's missing from this list rebbe number one on the list should be rebbe why is he not here says the gemara tony lovely because he himself doesn't hold of it he mentions it as a tana he's saying over there just mentioned it and sent it over from the rebbe but they themselves don't hold it why is rebbe any different they were shipping him it says rav had a kabbalah from his rabbi him who holds water and not he knew there was small hold that united [Music] says states gemara kinnoyak is when i was learning this gemara i didn't understand what does the terror when refuna went into the base madrid and he asked the question astira what what's the connection one to the other if he was his rebbe why did he go in what's the connection no so it's the exact opposite says and also it's brought down from the maharashtra the masham says that this is a beautiful shot israel shalom runs if you know duran from the market speaks you know replace the crown series of swarm his grandfather is the marshawn trump says this is a beautiful chat i love the shot it just fit in he says because the gemara in baba mitsubi gimbal says that ravuna were in a big fight they said that somebody insulted each other for 40 years they wouldn't talk to each other so had to stay away from the basement for 40 years can you imagine he was exploding he had all these caches for 40 years that minute was lifter he ran mad dash to the base madrid and he started spilling it all out what do you guys say about this what so he said the first thing he says lumira de ravidera tremendous castro a stereo contradiction around me or my rav aloha dallas scandinavian rival as a domestic douche saying look at this list raph says that all these canims hold like like rebellious that it's too good if an egg was born on one day it's it's us are on the following rabbi so why is it that an egg that was born on shabbos should be oscar on the following day like an hour an hour on roshana coming up if an egg was born on the first day on shabbos it's us to eat it on the second day doesn't that prove to me that it's dusha akhas it's one long douche why should it be also the second day it wasn't naughty like on the second day of rosh hashanah was not on the first day it should be also that day the second day should never be also right if egg was born on friday is it also in chavez no so wife who was born in travis would be also on the second on the second day of yantef is talking about the man you have to gather the mon on friday and prepare it in other words only on friday you prepare for shab is the month on the shop it's being champions you cannot prepare from yante to chabas and certainly not from travis leonto so that's why an egg created on chavez's oscar on the following day so in our mission we learned on yontev right if you have a piece of bread you're concerned that an animal is going to eat it on yount if you walk all the way to your area of you place it down again for shabbos isn't that preparing for shabbos onyant so what so they could walk 2000 amazon shabbos i'm amazing i'm a lot of walk says rob i'm allowed to walk all the way to there nothing happened no area would have when does the aerial when is the year of khao when shabbos comes in that's when the area of israel big criticism we're going to see a little bit more why is that not considered preparing are you allowed to walk somewhere to get a taxi as shabbos comes out i what are you over here it says yes i'm allowed to walk with my bread all the way through the desert because the a-roof doesn't happen until shabbos itself if it would happen on yontev you're preparing from yantra to shabbos but i it only happens after nightfall is prepares itself says if that's the case didn't we learn the other day that if a person has a clue that's tom a and has food in it and you didn't take away the mysteries but if you're going to take myself and say whatever's inside the client's miser this clay is at full yoim it was in the mikvah but it wasn't harry of shamish it wasn't nightfall yet so it's mitama trumas and mysteries will make the nicer inside tummy i'll make the trim of tommy so what do i say i say when when it becomes night that's when it should be how now if the error is how shabbos later on so first what happened was it became nicer immediately became nicer later on here let's say this is you see it's still light outside this is bina smushes it becomes like we had also comes red letter dart so you have nine minutes over here let's say here's where it becomes nicer here's where your heir of should be why is that not good in that case of wine in a in a jar that's a full yum jar we say you can't make a nerve it flips into myself but it can't make an air why not the area of shibihal over here says the bottom line is i can't eat the meal you have to be able to drink the wine and he can't drink the wine because he has no idea where is it nighttime or not night time he has no idea since he has no idea he can't eat it you're right there's some sort of time here that it became nicer and it's really like you could eat it he could eat it but technically speaking as it probably doesn't know when he doesn't know if he could so it's not a meal that you could eat hello this naan oh oh okay rabbits i i'm sorry so we will stop here because it's it's a big problem we'll have to make it up sorry about that we'll stop right here if you want to stay for uh tillam please stay i am actually going to go to sleepless now in the middle of the hill have a wonderful wonderful day rabbi said foreign