Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 35 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rob boyce how's everybody doing today's share sponsored le ishmas my mother and in honor of shia greenfield he spent more money this month on all the sponsorships than he did last month right right she agree fell from greenstar electrical contracting who sponsored the whole month last month of turning the daf obviously business is going really well and he's not really 40 years old he's only like 39 his birthday is in and out but whatever any excuse he ran out of yard sites he possibly ran out of yard signs all right so it should be a tremendous mazel shield you should give us all brachas and uh today's share is sponsored by ira greenstein mazotov to tamar elisheva and somebody just uh put something on this on the chat so i couldn't read an leo on your marriage a thursday night i'm looking ahead so i don't have to turn around awkwardly this way but yeah that chat is going crazy it's unbelievable ah from avi mendelbaum in case you want to know who avi mendelbaum is he's the one that talks before the share and everybody else listens so today is daf hey and we have a email from rafal nelson he got his uh tara from he got his lashes from harry shalom from california this is what it says that my standard he sent me i used to watch this share on the way to work in the car at home after work but not anymore listen to this everybody this is very important ben schwartz said that his wife set aside time and made sure not to schedule any patients when schwartz is a dentist she doesn't schedule any pages from 2 15 to 3 15 pm new york standard time or otherwise known as in town time so you can be part of the sheer live so i figured why shouldn't i do the same or a boy side we're learning from each other everybody gets rid with one from another so he's also i post the sign of my office door saying in a meeting and join the live share it's an absolute game changer yehuda nelson p.s i've added a picture of my setup i forgot to print it tomorrow basically what the yeah that's the nightshare the nightshare here 9 15 is 2 15 in new york beautiful uh one more quick one from james saka thank you for today yes it's the same saka family i said i i noticed the name it's uh very familiar my brother sandy's daughter married sv frieden but it's funny that i myself never learned gemara and i decided to do only the eight-minute recap advice this is also tremendous monster high school tremendous and i was doing it all along until shabbas 85 or 86 where you guys didn't make an eight minute video so you think it's a terrible thing we didn't make a eight minute video you know what happened so i decided to do the full shear and since then i now study it myself then listen to the youtube show in the morning and then go back for the afternoon so from eight minutes became close to two hours it's unbelievable i mentioned to my brother about trying it out and he did one class and he said he knew ellie and that's his wife's cousin small world and by the way now my brother listens every day shabbat shalom james saka amazing all right zuck the halo gigamoro if you are joining us you weren't here last night i feel bad i usually don't do this much in shabbos but it was like smacking middle of the sugar so we're holding like two four six eight ten lines down on heyo mandala ten lines down sorry raba verav yosef the amrutavayaru so we have a new shot in our mishnah so what happened there the bishop says if a person puts his arrow in a closet in a closet locks the door of the closet and forgets where he put the key he cannot access his arrow so tanaka says it's a good arrow over if eliza says it's not a good area of what is the macholicas so we had shot number one yesterday they were talking about a closet built out of stone but the only thing holding the stones together is avir here easy to break it down and access it and we are talking about yantef only okay noob shot rabbit vera versus we're not talking about a young we're talking about shabbos as well and the closet is made out of wood and what's the shiloh the marsup now we're talking about a very large closet like we described remember in the demonstration migdel is a closet and we said then during the demonstration that the box is larger than 40 saw so if it's larger than 40 saw perhaps in that sugar it's not a that's what we're going to come out today as well so english lightest skin in a very large box more than 40 songs the microsoft kalihu so one mandarama holds is a clever binyan bikilyn veinster bk became so the tanaka holds that it's a cli and therefore there's no concept of breaking and building a cliff and therefore you're permitted to break it on chavez to get to your arrow so it's not a problem what's the problem that you can't get to the bread break it open you get to your bread um as a wholes oil who it's not a clean anymore it's more like an oil it's just a covering or be so what we gain here is that this whole question this like when i when we learned the shot in the mishnah yesterday i mentioned hey yantef so how does it fit in and all of a sudden you tell he's sticking in here a mission that belongs in some other megillah i don't know where in the him you bring it here in so now this fits in better it's referring to a narrative on shabbos so um and this is the majoricus that we had this not we're talking about azov hikkish agave shido teva omigo so if his zov bangs on a door so if he bangs on a door what happens the door becomes tall it becomes tummy whatever if he touches the if he touches a cle he's azov so it should be tummy so what's going on here hickish he banged on the door so why shouldn't it become tommy explains rashi he's wearing a glove see he touched if he touches like this so he's not really touching so the only thing that he could do is give it a bang if he gives it a bang and it shakes and moves it now it's hesis alright so he gave it a good move the game so let's think what could be the mclaren possible here and if it's a klee it's just the vessel of essos macabre that's what we said right whether it's a clay or if it's an oil it's so big it can't be a clue it must be an oil it's like a it's like a house of some sort omra vettesboro no i don't like this it says regarding tommy if even if it's something huge like a tent like a massive thing it's not a click but you're able to move it while you're able to move it it wasn't secured to the ground properly he was able to move it to zov tommy in other words we don't care there's no difference between a cli and an oil it's one shiloh could you move it or not move it oyo venise tome even if it's an oil but you moved it it's tommy cleave ain't it you take a clay you take a little coffee mug but you cement it into the ground and he can't move it safe in other words everybody greets this meaning even and shimin agree niseit if it moves from his power it's imagine that guy that we saw they took him out with a crane from the second floor in brooklyn somewhere and he's walking next to something and he causes an earthquake that's a radha dog if the if it starts shaking literally shaking because he he's stomping on the ground taught her why is that hard but he made a move because this is a kayak it's an indirect force it's a force of a force he hit the ground which in return hit the cli and then it moved so by says i don't like this shot you can't make any enough media between a cleaner oil they're all the same if he touches it and moves it it's tommy if it doesn't move it i don't care how small it is it's star and the story hello um yes if i move something because of his direct power it's tommy if it's from it's a little bit confusing the lotion here because it's using the same word but over here others talking about a vibration imagine if you walk over to a telephone pole a metal you know one of those metal poles in the middle of the street and give it a good punch so you'll hear like your vibe you're not moving it really but like it starts making a noise that's what we're talking about over here so if you make create a vibration you actually hit it not from stomping on the ground next to it you actually hit it it's not it's not moving you don't see it shaking at all but something's going on and that's like it's whether a vibration caused by a force is considered a hesitant now if it's more than 40 you saw then then it's a oil and it's not a room if it's less it is so what what's the mach like this and by the way just points out here so why don't we just say that is whether or not yes being of the investigated so it says that that can't be because that's actually my legs beside me still the more didn't want to get into that fight [Music] we're talking about somebody locked the door with a rope now if he could undo it with his hand okay great the problem is if he could undo it with his hand it's a good arrow if he has access to it he'll just go like this and and open it but you need a good knife and here's the macholicus a familiar machetes that we had in himself see [Music] besides these guys the the very large saw that you cut wood this is muksa kisarin kiss you don't allow other people you don't lend this to your neighbor this is not something this is your business you cut lumber or the little the knife or whatever you want to call it at the end of your plow this is an expensive tool without this if somebody damages it you're not going to have any food you don't lend this out this is moksa and mahmoud these are the things in other words anything that's muslim kiss you don't let your children play with it it's not a toy you don't lend it out so easily looks like a celery kiss any other klee that you have and certainly a kitchen knife is not muktu so if i want to use my kitchen knife to cut the rope mateova great go ahead what's the other sparrow if you recall from a safety shabbos even clothing a spoon any talent so everybody holds everybody rebel as their holds that even a cleave that you would think this most innocent looking clean the world a spoon and also a kitchen knife is muktsa if you're not using it to cut chicken so you can't take a kitchen knife and cut a rope that's not what it's meant for it was meant to shmear butter on your bread to cut the chicken but not to do something like that and if you want to use it to cut the lock it's mukta and it's us now let's look at rashi for a second very very important rashi here it's uh it's a good few lines but it's kadai to see inside rashid massachusetts smack in the middle of the page it says rajing the other but multilingual musically all day if you could cut it with his hand shopper dominated you have something attached to the ground over here he's being destructive he's he's damaging something so therefore it's motor because i'm now over here is there about the mexican slicer in our case you're breaking a oil you're breaking the cli and that is xerobona because it looks as if you're breaking something velocity has been your mama's it's not really breaking a real building you're just trying to open up a door by cutting the rope says rashid this is the point i wanted to bring out here kevin de swissoo so again since it's only is there a bottom because it looks like you're breaking like godzilla we're talking about it and the whole point of a roof is that moment of being smashes and during being ash marshall is according to rebbe we don't care if you're over israel says the mishnah is gal gil [Music] not allah in israel so what happened you have an arrow you place the arrow of 2 000 almost away from your house and then it rolls away it gets blown away by the wind so it's 2001 i'm away from you so now you have a very big problem and tyson says a very interesting thing if you look at the last last lines enticements says that robot did him a favor by not allowing this arab to take effect because it would take effect this individual would be stuck right where he is remember that story with mayor that a guy came to him said look i i'm trying to go to uh what was it called the tru ear din something and and he said i made an arrow with a with the onion and everybody said okay stay right over here you're not moving you can't move and the gemara said okay he used the leaves of the the onion but the point is that if you don't have a good aero it's out of the mirror of so where you are you're not allowed to be you're with without a roof so you're stuck you only have your four am asses this is very interesting so sort of like do your major favor here and they say we're going to ignore this arrow since it blew away it's not an arab and at least you could you have a little bit of space on jobs you can move 2 000 in each way you can't use that 2 000 you can't use that area and go from there 2000 atmos but at least from your house you can move around in any direction otherwise if we would say that that area was a good area of where is that era of 2001 i'm where you are and you're not you're you don't have a connection with it so you're stuck you only have four atmospheres i thought it's a very nice sight says says the mission is if your arrow rolled out of where you are but not or not a lot of gal a pile of bricks fell on top of it you can't get it you can't reach it or in this wrap or burnt you certainly can't get to it because it's burnt truma venitmus you made an area of added trouble even if you stroll we said you could use truma for native and it became tame certainly if you discovered all of this before shabbos it never had a chance to grab on you have to be able to grab that area has to be called during venus smashes and friday afternoon is nothing all this happened before friday your air of burn before shabbos comes in no good that's what we said as long as you are one moment in banishmashes it's a great area like we said yesterday perfect cases if yantef is on friday and then you have shabbos and you're concerned that an animal is going to eat your ray roof so a couple of moments after complete darkness after banana smashes you take your aero and you bring it home you protect it and then the following day right before you run back to the of place you put it down and now it's going to work for the next day the point is all you need an arab to be khao is one moment during bina shmashas i don't care that it got burned i don't care that i became tommy you had a good earth in suffolk oh now we're going into a sugi of suffolk i don't know what happened i don't know when it burned i have no idea it's 2 000 away when i showed up there it's burnt to crisp did it happen before shabbos did it happen after shovels did i have them benchmark i have no idea remember so remember of you to say this is a donkey and a camel meaning a donkey you you're behind the donkey that's how you when you leave you don't need a donkey you go behind the dog you have to give it a good few sets in and it's rear you know you're making move a camel the opposite you're standing in front of the camel now i went on google and i looked for a picture i could only find one picture and unfortunately it looked like this now this is illegal because if you look closely it has all these marks here i don't know could you see zoom in a little bit gary could you see this you see the watermarks all over watermarks fine but it was such a perfect picture i could i couldn't i like i'm gonna do it i can't it's kind of illegal and i can't even talk about that it's illegal because that's like cheating awesome so i went ahead and i i ordered it now look at this whatever couple things no i'm kidding i'm kidding no no no but look it says over here oh it doesn't i have it in the email this is in brooklyn so i thought maybe he's a firm guy so certainly now i steal from him [Music] anyways here's the picture i know i love the picture i don't do this often we try to find the free ones but look at this this is exactly what kamar is saying the donkey is in front he's in the back so what oh once i once i have the picture i had to go all out on this picture so if you look over here look at this picture for a second this is what we're talking about [Laughter] levy said the guy that owns the picture goes who in the world bought this picture and why oh they might they must be doing that behind me here's your house you place your arrow of 2 000 ammos away you're allowed to go 2000 amazon any direction this way this way this way so you put your 2000 ammo to your your your challah your a roof 2 000 away from your house that gives you an additional 2000 office because we pretend that this is where you're living on chavez what that does is that it doesn't allow you to go 2 000 almost this way you're stuck this is the end of your throne it's awesome for you to go 2 000 almost this way why because now this becomes your house and you can go 2 000 this way and 2 000 am is this way but not past the house this way says the gemara because we have a suffolk we don't know if this is your aerov and if this is your aero you could go this way and this way and we don't know if it's not your aero so now you live here and you go this way and this way so what do we do we make you into a camel into a donkey we say that you're in the front and you're in the back but that's it so you're allowed to go from your house to your a-roof but you cannot go from your house that way and you can't go from your area of this way you are stuck missus the suffolk limits you to this area between your house and your aerov between your camel and your donkey now what's very interesting is that the suffolk is worse than avada had you known for sure that it's not an error of then then you could go in any direction from your house like the rebellion says talking about truva and romanian says that when it comes to asham talley ashram is more expensive than akatos it has a price tag on it you have to spend the x amount of skalam on your ashantala akhatas could be for free because of the astronaut you're suffix since you don't know if you're over in a very or not that's worse than knowing for a fact that you're overhead of era of caution so suffolk area of culture i could go in every direction from my area of this is my area i go here i go there because even the five skein him said if you have a sufficient aero it's a good herb says the gemara on his gag if your aero rolled out of the tomb past you now it's two thousand one almost away from you so this is the famous rava we've been discussing a lot and here it is this is the this is the source we brought this as the rava but says that once you place once you decide where you're residing on shabbos you get automatically four ammos in every direction and therefore avalator that's why if you're if your aero rolls 2001 amis like i said before that's not a problem according to rava because you have four freebie amas and rashi says let's say a guy has a house a huge house that's a thousand amis so i could walk to the end of my house and from there i start my 2000 office i don't care how big my house is my house could be so i really have i have 3 000 if that's the case i go i enter my house i take a train to the end of my house which is a thousand dollars later and then i walk from there 2 000 amis so too over here this is your domain this is your residence so the trump starts from this line on it doesn't start from here wherever you place your your area on the tree it starts from where your house ends your house ends there you go from there so mamela if my aero rolls off the tree and rolls into this back somewhere i'm still good it's within my residence if a pile of stones falls on top of your area if you have no access to it because so could that dog they buy muttsy chocolate that mean it was that i mean but if i want i could physically move the stones away and get to it what is that called muktsa and why is that okay according to the tanakama it's fine i'm allowed to move the stones into the lake so when the mission says [Music] it's not a good arrow it doesn't go according to rabbi rebby says that if you just over issadira banon which is muktsa books is there a bonon and your erev has take place during being ashmoshas it's not a problem according to rabbi right yesterday we already decided that the mishnah is rebbi and rabban the first part is rebbi second part is rabbanam basically we don't go like rebbi you could say that this mission goes according to rebbe and according to rebbe it's not a problem to move mukto over here we have a different problem since i need to come on to tools so the tool is no longer we're not discussing the raw buttons now now we're talking about the arizona either it's baina or it's irish you're preparing it to plow whatever the history is there it's their isa we don't allow you to do it and therefore this herb is not here what happened right during banishments you have a pile of stones and you're saying well move the stones with a shovel you know if it was just a question of mukta i could just lift up a one pound stone and move it away and that's mukta then you're right according to rebbe this would be a perfect area because all you're doing is this is the rabbana but since you're using a tool so the tool creates here is the riser of either baina or khairish utsriha now why do i need all these cases in the mishnah not full of gal a pile of stones fall on or it got burned or it's truman what's going on here but only say the case of stones it's because i can't get to it uh sorry mushroom dallastic at bay it's not in his it's not in his domain i have another gal but a pile of stones fell over the isigh bay it's within his domain name levi it's within his root shows he just doesn't have access to it but it's within his house so to speak viton enough a little of gal machine to me cassie and if it only says stones i can't get to it even if i want to get to it because it's covered other than this goggles even though zika um isolate but why did it roll away because let's say a wind came and blew it so now a wind will come and blow it this way right back into eurasios et mala heavy aero so therefore it should be right now why it is what's the third case you used truma and it became tommy lomeli what i need a third case says the gemara returning to the flame at home in the base sponsored by ash lee leanish master's mother roy sebastian yeoman and make it a great day and by dr listaus [Music] why does it say the the case of nisraf it's not even here anymore it's gone that rubio sees makel even though it's not here it's not it doesn't exist anymore because he says it's a good roof that it's here it's right in front of you and you may remember who they both hold that it's not a good arrow even if it's in front of you that's how that's how mahmud that if you have a suffix what happened he doesn't know when it burned he doesn't have any idea it's possible to happen before shabbos possible after shabbos because it's a suffix not a narrative we learned in a mission there are mayor halls that when you have a suffix you go lukula thomas you're a little you have a person who's taught me who was totally suffocated we don't know whether he got his all his hair into the mikvah whatever it is a bunch of fakers now barbarous exactly okay fine we're not going to go there but there's other things like he doesn't know his hand made him start whatever he thought about afterwards he realized hey i might it might have been a boo-boo maybe i was floating and i didn't realize suffolk thought by bomb saw something like that by our bomb so we he this is a bigger this uh we can understand this more he's not sure if the mikveh had the full 40 saw the name and he went to like one of these beautiful mcfary's the baptist barbara i'm so bad but i'm sorry i heard later on shabbos here one of them didn't have forty saw he's not he's not sure which one he went into without maximum basement sir he has a sufficient that we say that as a khazakami kara you use his status as right before he went into the mikvah what was his status what was his hazaka he was tummy so he continues being tummy but we had all of this in mr chavez if you recall this morning are the 18 enactments that they enacted in the attic of hananya bench food cannot make a person tommy but he ate food on me that's tommy some mashem tomato many drinks liquids that are tame or he went to mikvah from from not rain water drawn water sink water so you think what's the big deal he went to mikvah so where's some source he went to mikveh no it makes you tommy ocean over there was that water fell on his head three log we are elite boy so back to the subject or in a case that he had the filo in the rabbana on before the bible saw something so he doesn't know if the mcmahon 40 saw the name mcveigh's and two mickey flies back at this bar by himself he went into one of the two and he's not sure which one of the two he went into one had 40 saw one didn't have without us and who is this this is the mayor who else is it anonymous mishna ramir and we're saying that a suffix is tame suffolk he's mahmeer suffolk he's not an aero of what's an arrow they're a bonon over here they're a bun on a star says the gemara beautiful answer that's part of it kosovo truman okay this answers it we're not dealing with our mission is not dealing with aerov that's the rabban on we're dealing with trum and trom according to remains there isa who else says that whom is the raisa who's the famous one that says very good rebecca is the one that says that whom is the right so who's remains rebbe very good rebecca so it makes a lot of sense that remain oh the trump is there right so like is rabbit oh does it make sense if it made sense great but the sovereign mate does he really hold that what i mean beautiful we're going to see a whole suggested but look at this ah no i didn't pay for this one this is beautiful this is the horseshoe bend i always wanted to go there one day yeah it's gorgeous and uh i think it's in utah no no share from you that before that we're going through the safari anyway a guy wants to make his arrow he wants to be over here he needs to make an arrow he needs to hang out right here what is he going to do so he takes a rope that's 15 5-0 ammo this is how they measure right we're going to get a it's a whole sugar we don't have to do it but the point is he takes a rope that's 50 ammo and he keeps on measuring 2000 out now obviously this is quite a span but let's just roll with me here so he takes this rope that's 50 ammo what he should do really is he should go down the cliff across the water and up again that's how he should measure how is he going to get here he doesn't have a helicopter how is he going to get down he is going to walk down swim across climb up no we're going to be nice to him his throne is only the blue line that's all that's all he has to measure okay so he does this um in this case all in this case is the rabbanan shamatish mekhadrim biharim we drill out the mountain meaning so if a person is climbing a mountain what he could do is he could he could take a rope that's uh four amis and he goes from his shoe from his toes to the stomach from the toes to the stomach and that's how he that's how he does the mouth he doesn't have to go this way so says but if in fact remember holds that at home is a director like you're telling me that he holds like rebecca that's the right so right everybody else argues on this these are all leniencies to go across instead of going all the way down vomit when it comes to ir miklot right somebody kills somebody else but schweig and the family take care you'll say if i really missed you it's good to see you the family has the right to take revenge but if he hides out in the miklot or immigration is good and is that as long as he's in the city he's fine nobody can touch him nobody can hire him but the city has a 2000 ammo extension so how do you measure this this extension not with these tricks of going across and going loyabiklat you cannot use that because arya miklot is iso villa beglarufa if you find a body and you're not sure which city is responsible for the murder you have to measure which cities if they're both identical in distance you bring a calf and chop chop it doesn't work in the raiso so if it's the raisa or yo m this wouldn't work either and you're telling me remember is the one that says it's okay you could do mikhain what is he talking to me is somebody else outside ah sorry sorry lycacio is the one that said that is and he could do this stick with this rope go across instead of down and around that he said in the name of his re he was saying it but he said in the name it's his rebbe over here he holds the retro is the riser yeah one of them but he learned by yeah but don't you remember bikibo was making he took his time and he's after the 24 000 he took these he took these yeah yeah look they had different hundred percent correct [Music] it doesn't matter how much time it takes you to go from point a to point b it's a but why is it that the rice the rice you ca you can't measure a certain way you can't be lenient because of the riser so two in an arrow if it's their eyes it can't be lenient you can't use any lenient season of their eyes so this they told you don't don't make yourself sugar you're not going to start going up ladders and and using ropes and and it involves 300 people and and all sorts of equipment just do it the simple way here here's your trom and the story why are they so lenient this is their ice and the racist you can't be lenient you have to take whatever it takes to ma the the answer is because the chiro a narrative is not their iso but ramirez says it is their isis so how do we how do you explain it it says they konami and i'll prove it to you remember says i heard in other words he's quoting his rebbe whoever is rebbe is i don't think he's quoting you could be lenient and and measure uh what do they call it the ear space the um the line of sight you know not go following the terrain but he's only quoting his rebbe i myself don't hold like this says the gemara ramirez doesn't know like that remember he holds us the rhizo and he cannot be makader his rebbe shanati i heard from somebody i myself don't know like that says the kimora we're going to have akasha andrew mayer and akasha rebuilding tomorrow i'm sorry you're going to have to i i don't like you know leaving doilong halfway through the story the who the cliffhanger but tomorrow based hashem we're going to see ruby's discussion on the top of the page uber romney the rights of the rights of the mayor we have akasha here on rebecca a terrible story he was touching his friend and i it is he's trying to let's have to calm him down no it makes sense his friend is in pain and agony he has a whatever he's dying from a mahla and he's like you know take it easy because will help everything is good he has no idea if the guy is alive or dead um what happened rosh hashanah the year before akushboko said he's not going to make it it's like uh i forgot who said it rebellion said that when you have meisser you take your animals go out one by one from the um from the gate you count one two and then the tenth one comes you're supposed to splash red paint on him that that sheep says really goes and starts playing with his friends has no idea that on his back he has a red mark he doesn't hop that in five minutes they're taking another shackling him he's amazer he's a neva we are rosh hashanah we eat this morning it was a beautiful everything was great the whole thing and we don't have that we just got the red thing we got to do true we got to like go into the bath and rub it off rub that that red ink off otherwise they're going to happen on the micer then take me away you have to do chuva unbelievable i think it's my wife heard me learning this and she's like i understand like what how did he die i understand how he died kids are trying to explain they were just talking here it's not didn't it actually happen whatever fine time holds uh sorry amazing that yesterday he was still alive so when you touched him what was the status quo status quo is alive now he's dead [Music] should be the same thing according to turmeric that the food that everything is good and is like what we find it not don't give me the guy was alive yesterday right now um [Music] was talking about here i just found the picture from uh i think it's chavez where was this picture here's a chariot a dead rat on top of your food we have testimony that this is what happened this cherish was on there the entire time during venus smoshes no but that's very hard to understand if that's the case so what's the math like this who argues on that lesbian suffolk area of kosher in other words if you have a they may have adam so there's no hazaka but but if there's adam why would you say that it's kosher says the gemara rava vegas i'll explain to you the explaining there's two against two when i was 11 years old a very harsh i'm not gonna mention his name a very hush like a goddaddle mama's a goddamn a person that wrote crazy about this fire he gave me a fair and he asked me what's the halacha two against two so i said commander lesser it's as if because i was just learning the sugar it's as if it doesn't exist and he said no it's casa i said no i looked at it i said no it's he was so upset at me that's why i don't want to mention his name he goes i said it's uh i said no my rebbe said it's commander lesson to me it made sense two against two you just cancel them out i didn't care anyways he he just he's furious at me and i was looking at this morning to see who was right because it seems like it seems like he don't say um but i don't know he wanted maybe that's i have no idea he's a tremendous tremendous person he's not alive anymore [Music] so what do we have here so we have a shiloh like this could you invoke your khazaka when you have two against two two against two plus they have a kazakh or no these two and two it's two people saying something you can't throw in a kazakh oh he was alive it wasn't like mustami was alive there's two people saying what happened here so ignore the khazaka so that's the mahalik is here and um that's what rebecca is going to say or no we could do this tomorrow because it's late but basically rava says that there's another kazakh here fine we'll talk about tomorrow have a wonderful day rabbi sai shir hamalo is from the basque coiloys no