Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 34 by R’ Eli Stefansky

how's everybody doing wow nice island over there naftali rachel are you back in rbs oh beautiful beautiful email number one from yonko shepherd derebelli schlito fantastic clear sheer dealing with a heart with a hard technical study with brilliant predictions and diagrams making sure we all understand the concept my wife comes from basel switzerland are you related to mickey stefanski that's with an eye i learned things from denmark about 35 years ago any relation shepard you know what i call this how does he not know all's fancy related also fantasies are related yes talking about a marathon dear rebelli as always this year is great i love the live demonstration although my memory isn't great i'll never forget that sugy please keep them coming i'd like to make one suggestion only one bar hashem each if i only took one suggestion from each person it's clear that i'm bae seems to be a little rushed i was speaking with david feinberg and he mentioned most people would be okay with starting 10 minutes earlier yeah i'm sure to give time for emails while not having to rush their own base he calculates you know what i call this email verboise amaratus look look look at look at that flaming dialed it's this short and looking on the base what do you mean everybody knows this it's the volume you're doing go through shots you'll see almond base is much harder much longer rabbi say what's going on here these guys need the i hope i hope they don't make the mistake again also fancy related omelette base takes longer than i'm at aleph skye for the suggestions daughter feinberg i can't believe that dove and feinberg didn't tell him set him in his place shut me around him okay so zog digimon giveaway oh yeah yeah yeah today's share sponsored leading nishmas basmati sponsored by shea greenfield and if you don't know who shea greenfield is you know what you are i'm alright she greenfield sponsored four times this month four times at different yard sites finally he couldn't kill anybody he made his own birthday last month he uh he was the sponsor of the turn the omod it's she greenfield from greenstar electrical contracting and um i was i didn't put up iri greenstein's mazel tov because i got it like whatever it was on your marriage thursday night so mazel tov i apologize it was supposed to be up on on friday as well my problem all right zuck the halo and mario holding the flaming gimbal on base enough of the zamaratsus people should just get that t-shirt that says former atom know all the rules no other column yes also especially if this fancy he spelled it with an eye so i'm not sure if i'm related to that guy actually but also the fans of the y are related what says the gemara yosev rap pop evil call my lullaby base today is defla medal so a quick review we're talking about this fascinating sugiyo of somebody that placed a basket on a tree and the area was in the tree uh in the basket kamar says what are we talking about is it a tree that's fourth less than four talking so i'm shot that we had was that it's less than fort falcon and together with the basket it's fort review says no what's going on is and we had this yesterday we could have saved it for today but we had a we had some time we're talking about look if you look closely at how they did the picture it's not necessarily so but it's interesting they put a peg on the bottom of the basket and then they put the basket they flipped it over on the peg so the peg over here acts as a hinge that's what revere mia says he took the basket and went as so so now the basket goes from him to the basket is a bit of a caramelist he's allowed to remove the food the bread from the basket because he's in russia from a cabinet says okay bananas that's your beer mia so what does revere me say rebirth says i can i could flip the basket i mean the way rashi seems to say it as it's not so much on a peg but it takes like he he takes part of the basket and he opens it up you know he goes this way same idea okay this is a little bit more interesting because i would think that he hangs the basket on a peg and then he takes one handle off and pulls it down sort of like what rashes says over here the pegs on the bottom how does how does it not fall i don't know yes so now that we know this idea this concept of hoyle heil again means we pretend we imagine as if he turned the basket over since he could do so so it's as if he did so if that's the case aceve rav bar chevrolet case uh how does this do it in other words there's going to be a mishna this week on wednesday that has that this is the case so if we know the case today we can run through it tomorrow i think i i think i can't predict it maybe i'm that much thinking now um is much longer and much more difficult i was just trying to confuse the island okay fine i'm the emirates i'm definitely i'm a ritz i'll be in the same category as bianco shepard and who was the other one that i called ahmad mordechaines oh and he says hashtag on the base learning matters hashtag almond based learning matters he's not watching the video anymore because they called him amiritz he's gone for life but we all had a good jo laugh at his joke hashtag with based learning matters it does matter a hundred percent fight dr kimbard what's going on is his follows there's a two-day shabby-chantif sort of like what we have today in the this coming week so either yontev is on friday and then shabbos is shabbos or the case where shabbos is shabbos and yantev comes on sunday okay not like an hour not like rosh hashanah this year but let's talk about for a second both guys we're going to talk about in order for an aero to work both on both days the area needs to be there for two days so if i place an a-roof on thursday night right before jantef friday comes i could use my area of everything is great comes a dog and eats my my my bread i have no air even chavez i'm done done so what do i do very simple i wait until after sundown on on thursday night and i bring the aerophone i bring it back to me i take that same arrow right before shabbos and i place it again because all i need is the arrow to to take effect banish mushes so as soon as this banish mush is 100 night time i take my aero right a dog could eat it then or work for for friday it just won't work for shops i think they're bringing it home on shabbos on friday afternoon on friday on friday afternoon i bring the a-roof towards the place i place it in the same place and now i have a good area of four shops i just wait and if i want to eat it i could eat it on the spot let's see it inside quesadilla now we're talking about i still hear myself in a you know what do you call it what does the shliyak do yes especially your voice and and my voice you know what get him uh maybe headphones we have headphones in there to get them headphones oh i hear it through your headphones so maybe you you have a shtickle hearing problem i'm in a good mood tonight if i hear your headphones you're the end of the bass manager something's wrong here wow rabbis i'm in a great mood i am in a great mood says the guimara like this why do we have to be talking about because rashi says an amazing thing think about it if you yourself are there then you don't need a heir of at all you don't even know what do you need here for so i'm sending a shliya and the brings my area over there it's as if my making cheese is over there it brings it back home quesadillas [Music] and then i could bring the air of all the way home the second day max so friday night it's already shabbos i can't bring it home i can't carry yay i set the stage for a bunch of late sundays what's going on here everybody so we gotta learn tyro i'm literally i can't i i'm hate to say this i can't wait for a sega do they send me back home back into my little house i don't have to deal with all this all these people coming without permission and all these guys listening and driving talking from the kitchen talking in front of me it's so i'm like whatever anyway i'm going to be home soon just letting you know says thank you tomorrow now what happens if it's shabbos if shabbos is the first like today rosh hashanah this is this coming week we have rosh hashanah and then we have sunday yanteff you can't do anything about it so you put your heir of their heir of chavez what happens if a dog eats it then you can't use it on sunday so what do you do so you go check it out you send the guy to look to make sure that the area is there mate shabbos going into yandev and then it's a good aero but that's that's the only thing you can do you don't have a good atom okay so ask the gemara but according to review me as sparrow that logically i pretend as if i i turned the basket upside down and moved the basket am i since i have the ability to bring my aero back to that place for yantef muzzy mantelli so i could i don't have to now think about it is there a difference between me taking a basket and turning it this way five inches bottom or taking my arrow and going 500 feet from my house to the place of the air in both places i'm moving it somewhere i'm going from here to there oh here from here to there what's the difference how much i'm going and i'm allowed to pretend that i went from up on top of your head down to your head to rochester avenue up on top from downtown i could pretend so let me pretend that i went from uh rahmapit chamesh to outside of my bedchambers i'm pretending anytime i make a roof says rashi any area of in the world why do i even need to bring my challah walk it and go 2000 amis on friday afternoon spits it up and bring it over there let's pretend that i brought it over there everything is great [Music] it's a problem i cannot allow you to pretend and do so because you might think that it's always okay even in a case where like this year of hashanah falls out on sunday right after shabbos i'm going to think that it's okay even that case in that case it's not okay for me to bring it home because of shabbos so therefore i met xavier and said listen no matter what you have to bring it there you have to stay with it you have to look at it you can't pretend that it went there by itself aceve great situation here niskava and lisbon if a person tried to do now a person wanted to put his arrow in a keisel oh man i thought i had this all set up here's the kaiser you ready garshin here's a wall and he puts his arrow in the wall now if you look closely there's two parts of the wall there's a part that's higher than 10 fahren and a part that's lower than 10 fahrenheit says the gemara if he put his arrow in the wall and rashi keeps repeating himself over and over because of this idea that we had yesterday rava that no matter where you put your arrow you have this invisible box around you that's four ammas and everything in that box is included considered in your domain in your a-roof domain yes it might be in but it when it comes to ayurve we don't care if you're next to your a-roof and you are next to your area because there's a box that goes around and goes all the way up to the sky so it's fine so therefore actually explains throughout the whole sugya that this area is on a wall beyond your four amis you don't have a box that includes your arrow in your domain okay fine so he's he wants to be on the bottom on the ground over here vinnie aka bakay sol and he put it in a wall la matama sort for him if he put it in the wall in this little guy over here by the way i finally figured out it's not a salami it's a bottle of red wine okay it's just to me it looked like a salami from romanian if it's less than 10 fahrenheit it's an error of why because we're going to say that it's a surrounding why is it because many people use it to unload their loads and we said the other day that if a lot of people unload their loads when it's exactly ninth falcon you have to say let's see if he did a good job here i don't see what he did i don't know where this is this line but rashi says it's oh yeah sorry he does say it night for him i don't know if he could zoom in on this let's see gary do this knight right where my finger is more uh yeah now they can read it it says it's night why is the ninth because that's where people are able to unload their loads now we can see the mata masara could mean five six no we're talking about that's where people unload they they readjust their knapsacks at ninth not less than nine falcons it's a very exact amount and therefore it turns the wall the hole in the wall the raven into a russian raven and you are also located in rochester so you're in the same domain which is ram it's perfect okay but if it's above tenth it's in this guy right over here any review okay it's not a good area of why you're richard you're here at the millisecond that you're here you cannot get that aero you can't eat from it because you can't move something from him there's not a dora bun on it's a director therefore your ear is not good niskava and lynchboys versus trevor now i just want to warn everybody that there's a massive rash in here that's why this almond is so small and the rashi we're not going with the first platinum rash we're going with the lotion it's the main shot why in the world the messifta chose the first shot i don't know but that's what they do sometimes the hard scroll on the other hand goes with the icker shot i'm just pointing it out so if you're following with me in the and it doesn't make sense in your messifta it's because they went with the first shot at any rate the scavenge boys a guy look at this i love this picture this is really not from colorstone this is my a little rendition called shone yeah well carlos just had a box i put the guy on the box he had a bird on the box i'm not sure why public bathroom no so the guy decided to take his residence onshab is on top of ashwavak so in other words he's high up or buried amigdo on top of a dresser a box in the first place it's a beautiful chat i wish that we'd go by that we're not rash in the first person says that he goes down and he can walk i forgot to mention also before we're talking about pakis if if his arrow is outside of his little backs that rubber talks about so we have to say that he brings it to himself less than four amis less than four atoms and that's okay during banishmashes because it's the rabbana and that's okay so now so anyways according to rashi he's up on uh now where's his arrow his area was up he he's his heir was above tenth face his arab is a good arrow why because it's right next to his arrow is in a wall above tenth he himself is right over here so if you look at the picture this picture let's say so he's on top of this guy right over here his arrow is on top over here now this is the the second this is the first platinum actually the the sec the second channel rashi this would be closer over over here so therefore he could grab his arrow they're in the same domain it's great there's no this is problematic because there's just a rabbit on the bottom and we said already you're not going to carry something from it from here to here when there's rushes around the bottom that's rashi's second shot is that it's close by okay oh so now he's sitting this guy is a sugar right we're not we're not talking about a guy that's 100 he's sitting on a on a bird house the entire shabbos that's where he decided he wants to hang out for shops great now if his arrow is below him he has a problem how is he going to get his arrow says the gemara what's the problem [Music] look it's very simple what he does he takes his he takes his uh you know whatever he's on i'm i just i'm using the second picture let me show that he takes this thing and you see over here how they did beautifully sean nice job you can't really see it didn't print so well but this is like supposed to look like invisible like it's see-through so so basically you take this and you you could move it down and if you look closely that's why they're the the the closet stays exactly where it is in other words one of its legs is never going to move you just tilt it you're not lifting it up you're tilting it on its hinge and you put it down now once you put it down you're ready within the lower level where your arrow is and now you're good what's the problem if you say this idea that i could tilt things i could move things i pretend i moved it i pretend i moved the basket so why can't i pretend i move the closet what's the difference between a basket in a closet says the gemara [Music] now if he brings it down what is this what is this called right over here if he brings it down is it over here is it this whole area is what is this part of the closet called when he brings it down to the ground but a caramelist is fine i could go for my caramelist to grab my my bread that's next to me banashmosh as i'm talking about that mili second of banishmash is from a caramel list this is rabir mia who said the whole idea to begin with he's the one that says i can flip a basket upside down explains revere me how come over here i don't say i can flip the closet on okay you're right you could do that not in this case because here i'm going through the eyes of a hundred picture for a second they had a nice summer right over here it's nailed into the wall and here's how they have their bread a bread in the wall it's nailed in i can't move it physically if you could move it you're right you could it's a good heir of rob omar robert says he tries to explain review you don't need to say such an extreme case i have a better case what's my case this picture it's a giant tower and therefore after i move it downwards you see this nice box this box of the dalai ramos that's my resource right everybody rub a hold of the everybody gets a four amma box an imaginary box we're talking about something so long let's say a uh a six ammo dresser you you put you push it down it's past the box mma like i can't get it finished washes it can't go in there it's going to move the top of it is going to be out of the outside says the gemara what case are we talking about kafsa um if there's a window and a rope here if my bread is tied to a rope and it goes through a window not necessary to say a window it's just cooler the kumar is trying to be making schmack there's a window and i pulled the bread through the window but the point is that there's a rope my my food is held on my rope and i'm holding on to the rope during bananas me i get a whole situation here let him bring the bread to him what's going on asking you're not going to go from one wishes to another banishment also but i could pull something to me banash mushes that's not a problem i remind you out of suga this is not exactly this is the picture i was able to pull out much of shabbos rashi brings the suggest of a guy was reading from the torah on a roof remember shabbos and his megillah fell off the roof so you could pull it to him i just this is not the real this is a scufa a different sugya but the idea if you recall since i'm holding on to the safety torah i'm holding on to this part so the fact that something flew off the roof doesn't matter it's still in my hand something that's in my hand i'm not either on ho it's on china i could i could bring it back to myself so i could if my bread is held onto a string i could bring it back to myself tyson says so why didn't the gemara ask this question when we were talking about a tree his is his area of his tenth high he's in the he has a string why don't they go like that he says this is because we're talking about a closet you have a lot of stuff in your closet we're being practical a guy that's uh in the middle of a just around him somewhere on a tree not necessarily doesn't have a rope now we're asking if he already has a class and he has all his tools maybe he has a rope too so he marked the leslie capsule misno we're talking about he doesn't have a rope doesn't have a window okay so we're going into a little bit of a lighter so you know so it says in the mishnah that if you put your arab inside a pit it doesn't matter how how if this pit is originally pit or should say it goes downwards just like it goes upwards it goes all the way down 100 ammo too let's understand exactly what's the case where is this bar element ooh now it's getting far further and further away in other words all the areas surrounding the bar is private domain and the border itself is a private domain so why can't he take a roof out of a private domain into the top where the where he's at he's hanging out on his lawn chair right next to the bar that's where he's inside there let him grab the arrow it goes from one of the other returning to the aflame dalit on the bay sponsored by usher leonardo's mother raised the basketball and he says boys i make it a great day and by dr list house ben aaron rabbi say i want to tell you something because i could say it now i will keep it private but dr list house called me up and he told me that he noticed that somebody on zoom that watches very often but they're in america now so they're not watching you notice that their ceiling is peeling and to him that was a sign that they need they need help and he asked me how he could send them a lot a lot of money a lot it's unbelievable it gave me tremendous physique like the the camaraderie that the fever have he's just he doesn't know the person but he sees the person on zoom everybody's thinking themselves okay now i'm going to start making things in my ceiling and but rabbis i take it easy but we have a lot of tzaddikim around and unbelievable anyways i hope he doesn't kill me for saying this but he doesn't he didn't want that person to know and the whole thing but that person base hashem is not going to watch it later on so we're good zogding amara goes all the way down to china if you dig you can dig as long as far deep as you want all the way to the next whatever is on the other side of the planet you will be going it's always just like it goes all the way to the sky it goes down so what's an afghanistan you're sitting right next to yourself here here's the picture so if you're you're sitting over here your bar is it doesn't matter how deep the bar is it's always the koi brushes so let's let's pretend this area is a rabbit and your bar is it's a big problem depends what where does he want to be where does he want to take up residence in chavez on top of so this area would not work why he's above his error of is he's an interesting he wasn't able to grab it it's from not a good arab illamato if the guy decided to be crazier than the guy that's hanging out on the shoulder he wants to hang out in a pit the entire shabbos so okay so what if everything around him is versus a rabbit but in in the pit together with his heir it can't get any better like that he's literally with his arrow why is that what's the problem with that says the gemara all this around here is a caramelist it's a field it's a it's just an open area it's not it's just a rabbinator it's a caramelist when the scavenger is lamalo and he wanted to be in the carmelis oh so he wanted to be in a caramelist and during banash masho he's could he grab his ear of the remarkable monsters according to rebbe yes because to take something from a russian and bring it to her sister rabbit into a caramelist during banash mushrooms is only the rabbanaan and the rabban and is not a problem according to rabbi virabi the omar called anything that is like bringing something from into a karmalis is only the ramadan like godzilla allah may not smash so therefore it's a perfect arrow for about on hold that you can't do so and therefore according to our button this wouldn't be a good arrow no we have to be we have to be done in five in seven minutes it's only 45 minutes but you're saying what's the shabbos okay nissani beresha khanna every person puts his arrow on top of a pole if you look at rashi it's very i thought it's funny interesting kundus plow we call it a pole they call it a plo it's the same like it's the same uh letters i guess poem maybe we get our paul from plo just saying so nissani berejacano he took it like a read or brochurcundus a pole this is the case right he has a pole it's skinny on the bottom and on the top according to rib yehuda you need fourth by fourth according to our banana rash she says it goes to review they need fourth why is this not a rashu because it's a skinny pope in order for this to be say it has to be fort's falcon throughout the whole thing all the way down to the bottom the notes if this is not attached to ground the reed is not growing straight out of the ground you chopped it down then you plunked it into the ground afidou this pole is a hundred amish 200 feet tall high razer arrow it's still a areo because it's just it's not attached to the ground now the fact that the mishnah says that it's not attached to the ground who does that go according to we had a whole mishna on the base on the base we're talking about a tree and we said it's not a problem to use a tree on chavez on penis moshe's according to rabbi because using a tree is only the rabban on and banash smashes is what all we care about is banished mushrooms finish mushes we didn't make it easter to use a tree the mission says over here that has to be detached from the ground to read lloyd but if it was attached to the ground it wouldn't be a good area of why manny rabbani because this girl is going through a bottom who say you cannot take something off a tree on banash mushrooms now let's just stop for a second i need to tell them this i don't know if everybody's familiar you see this mission over here this is actually if you open up a mishnai's aravind right now it's part of la mid-basement-based mishnah it's the same mishna it's not mishna alef this is the safa this is the second part when they when they put the gemara together they decided to chop it down and and and and make it two parts so not ravashi no no it's probably the lady who put together the gemara in vilna and rabbi shomer is going to be yelling him you know it's before that okay but the point is when they printed the gemara is like that i don't think it's the gemara the mishnais anyways the mishnah has a ratio and a save you see from the gemara here that it was at 1.1 mishnah this is the safer this is the end of the first mishna so ask the gemara bomb question vamrez ray sharby you gave me a whole speech and you told me the other day that the first part of the mission of the the the mishnah that we learned on friday and thursday where a person places his bread tenth above the ground less than 10 above the ground we said that the whole mission that goes according to rebbe that since during banash ashmore is i'm permitted to use a tree the whole listener is to use a tree on shabbos but banash mushroom since it said the rabbana i'm permitted to use the tree and therefore it's a good arrow of that's with rebbe but rabbon on hold that you're not permitted to use a tree and our mishnah which is the end part of that mission that goes according to rabban on racial rebbe the safer abortion how does that make sense for a boy's side you can't have one mishna that goes according to one person and a second later the end of it goes according to another it doesn't work like that on malay now think about who's asking the question here romulaire of adelberla so ravada was asking rava okay and what does rava say on my leg fair omelee rumi is the who's ramen barham and who's the so rabbi barkham is rafi is the son-in-law but guess what so is rava rava married rami barham his wife that's the famous story where rava said uh if both of us are going to marry you he told the lady if both of us are going to marry you let me come and marry you first and so was he robbie mccombe married her first roman muhammad was lifter and then rather married her so i just said i'm saying it's interesting says rava my father-in-law rafiz already answered my brother-in-law well he's not really i don't think they were ever brother-in-law's but my wife's ex-husband robin bachman vishanilay and my father-in-law raphizda answered raysha rabbi the safer abanon we have no choice it's very difficult to understand but when you have no choice you have no choice yes the first part of the mission is rebbe the second of the second part of the mission is rabban and malasat we try to avoid that as much as we can once in a while you see it in chats they'll say yeah okay we give up the ratio is so and so the safe is another person review we're talking about reeds here and when you bend the reed you might break it now rashi says if you look at rashi rashi uses the word vada i notice rashi says vaday meaning i'm assuming he means to say it's a ninety percent chance it's not that they but it's a really really it happens so often that we don't want you messing around with the reads you're gonna start bending this way it's gonna out of two three people are gonna do it two of them are gonna be over they're righteous of quite sir we don't want you doing it says safe exactly what are you talking about you're saying that you want to put your ear on a reed but if you're going to start messing around around with arabs on a reed you're going to break the reed a little bit it says rashi vaday not vada but carvalho valley because gamora doesn't say about it says actually it's not a shama it's not like a 50 50. i'm talking about uh 85 uh 85 plus 15. okay says the gemara [Music] says unbelievable myself for aravind there's an army that came to narada and that's rabbi say i'm sad to say that's the end of the story in terms of the story part because this is irvine stories are far in between so the army came to narada says what i need you to do rabbi is start taking the reeds and bend them over in the swamp because the army is here they're taking up way too much room i don't know if they took over the shoals or wherever they were learning torah we need some room we need to breathe let's on friday let's go out to the swamp and bend over those reeds so that on shabbos we could sit on it so we could give shir we can learn torah on these reads aceved robin bachman so robbie barcama again this is you know uh son-in-law again we're seeing rava learned by rav nachman bahamas asking probably the same generation we started to figure things out here and some people says allow people to bend reads and use them on shabbos it says in our mission that it has to be detached says rashi because you're going to so how can you do it how could you use these reason shabbos if the reeds are tough and they hardened up then they're not then they are considered they are considered um trees and trees are a problem um but if they're soft then there's no problem to use a bush on shabbos you're allowed to use a bush so here's allah myself by his side if your coat is hanging on a low laying bush that doesn't have the issue that trees have the issue that rabona said you can't use a tree on shabbos is something tough and hard like a tree but not what rav nachman was talking about the soft stuff that's different so i want to say it's two different types but okay um how do how do you know that you can make such a distinction between the the hard variety and the soft one the sannyas two other things some sort of uh uh thorn min elon these are trees the enon climb the so there's a there's the you're not a plant vegetables in a vineyard it's not a vegetable it's a tree so you can plant a tree in a vineyard but there's another bright another rice that says here we go connor reads now the kumar is going to make a little bit of a fuss with the akidon but we we need to focus now on khanim so one bright sun condom says it's a tree and over here says it's not a tree it's a vegetable if it's a vegetable you can't plant it in a vineyard then climb big carrot so what is a reed is it a vegetable to read as a tree could you plant it in a vineyard you cannot so we must say that there's a variety that's tough and hard like a tree that you could plant in a vineyard but there's the variety there have not been told this tell me that you can bend it over that you cannot plant in a vineyard ask the gemara now let's talk for a second about akido kida min yoroku it happens to be here we go gary's spacing out you better be i know oh what is this it came out very bluish this color okay now it's a little better it's the the it's the angle pagom is a ruplant and the white casio i don't know what it's called que de lovano so these two guys don't grab them together now you know i graft any plant or any tree together but it says here mr york it's the kedah this guy is elon is a tree so how are you telling me that's a vegetable look what it's called it's called keda levana the white variety we're not talking about the white one we're talking about the regular one just regular casio whatever it's called regular kedah okay not a shiloh says the mishnah nissani you take your bread your a-roof you put it in a box right shida tava migdal we all know what a table looks like next time we're gonna have to do a mig doll it's not referring to a tower like in a palace it means like a nice amoi or something you know like a nice tall closet [Music] so it's a very interesting chile you're the shia la you can't get to your aero really easily your area is locked up what are you going to do lost the king hares tanaka says it's a good idea of rebels it's not a good a-roof now what happens if he finds the key on chavez he finds the key isn't going to say it's okay so we have a much like this that's we're going to have now until the bottom of the ahmad whether or not if you find the key is that good enough could you retrieve the key and bring it to you is that is that an option or not we have the tenant company says it's never a problem i could always break into my closet break in i could open up a bag of potato chips so i could break into my closet what's the problem break it open it up revlon says no you're not allowed to but what if you find the key revelation says you can or blessed as you can't let's see the suggyo why is it to go to a room it's as if your a room is in a place that you can't get to so it's in another domain it's another place so what if you so what if it's in your house in your closet in your house but you can't get to it it's as if it's in mars what's it there it's in two different places ravish more damage we're talking about a closet that's made out of stone if you're mayor he and mayor holds wait wait a minute you'll see there's a few rules here if it's stone it's even harder to get into right no it's easier because it's stones that don't have cement says [Music] you're talking about you filled up a whole house full of fruit before you on tiffany we're talking about anyante if the house is completely closed but there's a there's a place that you could get to it it's not muktsa even though you couldn't get to it beforehand it's okay remember what's the problem bust open a wall and get your fruit says bomber what does that vera mean you know what's between the the stones ear instead of using cement to use the ear to attach the stones together in other words they come apart easily so in our mission we're talking about a classic made out of stone and the only thing holding the stones together is a bunch of ear vomit zero beyonce [Music] homosexual shabbos right a root for this area for that etc and now the mishna on that flaming down on the base is talking about yantef it doesn't really fit in here but i guess it's it's the same thing so talking about beyonce if we're talking about questions around so here we have a letter that says that if his ki get lost in a city it's a good heir of imbec so in a city as long as you can explain i could go from place to place i could jump from rooftop to car fifth to this it's all within one area one domain so male if i find the key i could bring in this on melo it's a good arrow vin bianca that's the gemara but why if i find it in the field if i lost my key in the field i cannot bring it back and open up my closet so therefore it's not an error of but it's jantef maliere mali soda what's the difference between a city and a field ayatovam allowed to carry the flaming helmet says yeah you're right you have to fit in a few words here we in the time of the gemara we understood it if you don't understand it we'll we'll help you out you put it in a in a in a large closet and you locked it up and the the key got lost i raised the aero that's the great area of a medium it hutter to kharfaff you know those open areas this will consider the whole city i could get my a-rope i could get the key all the way to the closet and therefore it's a good day group besada is considered a caramelist and could i carry from a caramelist to my rashu-sayakid on shabbos no but we're not talking about chavez we're talking about banishmoshes could i carry from my caramelist to my roshus moshes when the eru of israel yes or no depends kira banan robot and hold you cannot rebbe holds you could so according to rabona it's not a good aero because it's the schwarzenegger and it's monstrous it's also going to rub out on raboisei you have a wonderful week tomorrow after sheer shears at 7 15 just in case you want to know what's going on in rosh hashanah so rosh hashanah shears at 7 15 as usual the first day rosh hashanah there's going to be sheer in the basement we have to announce the time or whatever but also again you know just we'll try to make sure there's only like 10 people might say rosh hashanah shear at regular time let's call it nine o'clock and what we'll do is i'll i'll repeat the sheer i'll repeat first we'll do the daf of rosh hashanah and david feinberg is going to tell me why you do that for shauna do the first half and then i'm going to tell them no that's not the way it works and we're going to have the whole conversation so first the daf for that day and then whoever wants to stick around we're gonna do the daft that we didn't record so we could record it that's for recording purposes only everybody should try to do their daf by themselves and there'll be another so we'll do to dap him on matsuri rosh hashanah the sheer everybody's going to learn normal learning because it's about the you're not going to wait for this year so this you learn on rosh hashanah and we're going to learn i'm going to give you a mata hashana in case somebody missed it and just for those to have it on on file and have a video of it i'm going to give the rosh hashanah of the first day's death after rosh hashanah's second day death have a wonderful evening a good ever