Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 16 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning robert good morning how's everybody doing [Music] yo we're starting here okay gary is gary on thank you good morning everybody today's share is being sponsored by our great friend from borough park rugby stroll goldstein there's still some people that are unmuted for whatever reason ruby stroll golfing in memory of my late mother hannah yenta sponsored by our new friend from south africa ian meltzer for a car satov you're a great man hope you uh make siem and irvin with us to start with aravind because rashan will see you at the cm way to go south africa uh first email from dove era dove where's your dove the one day that i'm reading his email is not on okay there a valley i've been in several definitions in my life but since i missed more classes than i attended i never really felt part of the group so i'm so that when the last two suman shahs have it i didn't attend them because i felt i didn't earn being there like i was a pastor amongst society telling me them until i discovered you that classes what what did it do for me at your first class in brachas you explained it's not about the devil it's about the yoimi that i did hit me like a ton of bricks it was an eye you know eye opener for me to realize i didn't have to go back to class i missed in order to go forward in the past when i tried to make up backlash i felt so far behind that's another idea but similar okay i fell so far behind i just gave up completely for a compulsive guy like me that's saying about the yoyo he got me hooked to yeshir i was at the scene for broncos and shabbos and felt like i really belonged there and with hashem self isn't dove the guy that was in uh hawaii during the uh wasn't that him with the hawaii gear no anybody yosef is saying yes okay good and with hashem's help i hope to be with you at the next cma evenings on a boat and i get c6 as long as you bring along airsickness better it should be okay sincerely dove erratic one more from thank you thank you let's see okay turn this a little bit no but then my whole thing is off okay it doesn't look like you could see it here it's a little the lighting is off oh that's better dear ellie i can't believe that you're the brainchild of the chicago mr brewer calendar not really uh okay i you know what the idea is one thing the uh implementation of it is is 99 of the thing my father-in-law did the whole push what does ross have been doing a daffodil with them for many years i'm not sure maybe 13 14 years i picked up one of the small buckets in my show and began my wife thinks that this is at least my fifth cycle we're making a scene in november oh i know his wife his wife is that woman who does the navi for women on the whatsapp please thank your father-in-law for me and tell him i don't know her i just heard about her for me and tell him what an amazing program it is what a great school he has hashem should give you both you and him this is the main part of the email ps i disagree about the homoshare you should only give it if it won't take away from you preparing the daf thank you ah finally they make them smart over there in houston texas your main focus has to be how to give it over in the clearest way i cannot imagine that a homoshare won't compromise your prep on the dot he's 100 correct it would therefore i think you should decline coming from leon leon is the one who's telling me drop the night chair drop the night chair you don't need this in your life and now he's telling me okay listen each in their own leon is i can't move it up it only has one you know maybe i'll move it oh you know what hold on maybe we could do this yeah no it's because the sun is probably shining from there let me see if this works oh yeah how about this uh i see meltzer that's what i see that's a good one you know why because by the seam we're going to have a seam in williamsburg we had we're supposed to have a seam in the new square i don't know if that worked out there's a crazy guy that uses our charges that but all right he's still not good i know what are you gonna do you know what i need my these charts over here are more important let's see if i can get me maybe could start out this year with learning aravind for 15 minutes and then we can do emails and charts for our 45. we heard that we heard that title before and then we would have a share the size that we had before the emails which is 20 30 people says everybody comes to the emails nom you don't understand says the halogen mario holding why we're doing okay 7 21 5 minutes in six minutes in one minute was to readjust the glare on the thing then the strongest are going to have an alia with the glare without the glare everything is good and and that karsa type to ellie i looked at it i stared at it for 25 minutes this morning and i already got that i know and now during the day i'll stare at it again rabbi said we're holding tashma the bottom of the tesla with base that is zion in ireland well we had a shiloh what if the salad is the same exact size as the airspace 50 50. what's the halacha rapapa says it's okay says it's not okay brings it right from our mission and in fact we're going to stick with that right from our mission that it's okay that's at the end of the soggy but until we get there until we arrive there we have to go through some hoops says so guys are on their way it's a shayora it's a convoy a caravan and they stop for the night they stop for shabbas this is taken from carlos shawn beautiful picture again if you look closely they take all their stuff off pillows right over there in the corner then they have the the camels themselves they have the saddles they have all the stuff and they create a wall and they want to be able to carry within their encampment are pillows leaf in some sort of boxes and stuff bikanim reeds so you can create a wall a majitsa with all your stuff this is a huge problem for ref papa because it says as long as it's not 50 50. it says you shouldn't have between a camel and a camel the size of a camel in other words you can't have a camel that takes up ten feet or or let's call it five feet better five feet and then i know can't was that five but just for arm you can say five feet of cable five feet air space you cannot have five you can't have fifty fifty it says shalom you can't have a saddle and then an ear space the size of a saddle but raf papa says 50 50 is okay over it says it's not okay and between a pillow and a pillow of it what's republic going to do similar to the exact same answer we said by yesterday the ear space for the camel you have a camel sitting down on the ground that camel is five feet long wide okay makes more sense five feet wide and your ear space is five feet why because you want to put another camel in there but in order to put another camel in there you can't have something that's exactly five feet that has to be five feet and two inches so it can fit in nicely you should be able to pull it out and put it back in right pretty soon you want to put the next camel in there well if you want to put something that that's exactly five feet you can't give it exactly five feet it won't fit it's gonna be really difficult to fit it in so therefore the air space is actually larger than the solid we call it the same but physically it's not the same that's what republic says at the end of the day the reason why this is possible is because you gave it another inch so it's actually 51 percent and 51 is the problem says rappapa but it would be exactly 50 50 would be motor i it says over here bengal or government gumball but normal people when they have when they make space for a gummel they don't do exactly a gummel they do a gummel plus an inch and that's why it's a problem all right everybody said don't fall asleep here we need to pay attention now because it's going to take us down to the bottom of the ahmad try to make it as simple as possible we have three rules rule number one is lover this is a simple rule even if you're sticks you put sticks separated by ear space now if you look there's a lot more ear space than sticks than salad oh yeah nobody else cares kidding kidding don't get insulted and leave this year now you know those guys that start to share the second day and they write me this email you're so mean you said this just stick around for two days you'll you'll get the humor okay over here you have a stick every less than three this half is a salad piece salad as long as the goat can't go through it it's less than three twhim this is called love it but this is a big kiddush because you have way more airspace than salad so rule number one is everything is motor as long as the space between everything is less than three rule number two is everything is usur why because this gap the air gap between the pieces of wood is larger greater than the salad okay so in this case now we're talking about by the way i forgot to mention we're talking about climb we know about climb we even said aeroven is and climb are the same word ayurven means to mix up climb to mix up so if i have vines on the other side of this fence i cannot plant vegetables in the front of this fence even by these pieces of wood because these pieces of wood are less than fourth falcon wide and the gap is more than the piece of wood so you don't have loved and you can't plant by the wood because the wood is less than four you can't plant in between the wood of course you can't plant in between the wood because there's not no mojito there so the whole thing is also and finally we have a third rule excuse me if this piece of wood is so large that is four twelfth and wide so fort falcon is so significant that i can plant vegetables on this side of the wood you see this this check mark over here i could plant vegetables there but i cannot plant vegetables in between the wood so in between not so this is in between case you have a case where everything is melted to plant i could plant throughout this whole fence i can't plant anything and i could plant half and half by the wood i could plant by the gap i can't plant now let's see it inside tashman and and there's three different rules when it comes to a wall it's kadai if you have a pencil or something it might be kadai to pull out your pencil and mark in the gemara the different lashon and gemara that could go like for papa or could go like it goes back and forth if the pieces of wood are less than three so you need that between the wood there shouldn't be less than there should be less than three tv that is called lava we said and we know you go to the restaurant you see they have a piece of string and every three less than three falcon there's a string and you could even though it's very thin you could fill in the gap with lava running next to another vertical beam we don't care how wide that beam is even if it's very thin as long as the air space between the two beams is less than three i fill in the gap with a halachic lover so this is the concept of lava and i have to make sure lava doesn't work if a goat could make it through there because then physically you don't have a mojito so there's no there's no goat and there's levels everything is great so again once again the big dish is even though it's pirates i made even though there's a lot more ear than salad it works because of love now but if the piece the salad piece is um it's actually from three all the way to four but less than four because four as we see four is very significant that's where the significant wall comes we had it a number of times in the miserta fort falcon is very significant but over talking about less than significant from three to four sorry airspace between whatever wood you have should not be the size of the word you can't have that the open air space is more than the standing part but what does it say here you should mark this if you have a pencil kedai parrot it says mafuresh that the airspace should not be like as the salad it shouldn't be 50 50. it says here you have to make sure 5050 doesn't exist because 50 50 is no good problem according to rappapa who says 50 50 is good so in this chart right over here in aleph it says meaning 50 50 is no good and we're going to see in a second that 50 50 is good this is going to tell me that 50 50 is good because it says however if there's more air space than salad afk negative i meant also then even so in this case right over here if you have more open space than salad this is the middle case where you have a piece of wood that's about that's three taken but less than four fahrenheit but the ear space is wider than the salad then you can't plant anywhere you can't plant by the wood and certainly not by the air space but it says if it's more if the air space is more then you can't mashma that if the airspace is exactly like the wood you would be able to plant there that's 50 50 is motor so that's another problem we have here it says meruba if the ear is greater than the salad alloy oscar then you can't plant mashema i just stuck that in 50. it doesn't say this in the gemara 50 is okay it's only because it's meruba the ear space is more than the saucer but mashma that if it's 50 50 it's okay and a second ago we just said 50 50 saucer so this whole bryson needs explaining anyway now finally uh listen to this in this case when you have more ear than salad what what happens the ear overtakes the salad it's movato the salad so it's as if you don't even have a salad piece so therefore i can't even plant that's why there's an x a red x buy the salad pieces i can't plant my vegetable on right over here because i have vines on the other side and that's kalai final but if these pieces of wood are significant they're forth fake and all the way significant to the point that they're up to 10 ammo is so shallow benzelezek you need to make sure that the gap between them is not larger the airspace is not larger than the salad shalom and ah so now this is a problem again it says you now have 50 50. so once again there's a problem our papa here in the second and third i love him they call this the bright the safer image motor 50 50 is us and if it's the the airspace is the same size as the salad can negotiate so here's the third alaha if you have a large piece of wood that's more than fort fakhman significant you can plant check you can plant right in front of the piece of wood but you cannot plant in the gap however if the salad like in this picture don't look at the set if the salad is greater than the ear airspace then you could plant in the gap nifritz what's that so we all know if the gap is more than 10 am is us according to rashi the whole place is also twice it says wait a minute there's a full submission that says that if you have a fourth paul somewhere then you could plant by the fourth of paul in front of it why you tell me the whole thing is also 5. the quran and we have this as well this is re recall this karma the kranum it's a duiker it go you could it has a point at the end so you could shove it into the ground and you make a turta this is like a door jamb you put a vine from side to side this works and climb only we said right we had all shields to work on shabbos as well a greater gap than 10 it's okay i could plant on the other side of that source of pasta now the more goes through it ratio where do we learn the ratio we learned that from if the piece of wood is from three to falcon to four a little less than four or eventually have been zelda zeke light as long as the gap between them shouldn't be the size of the wood to you have to the red papa because red papa says 50 50 is okay and over there the 50 50 is not okay this is going to say the same answer they said before that it's not 50 50 it's actually 50 51. the reason why it's puzzle is because it's a little bit greater than 50 because you have to have a little bit of room to maneuver your thing to put it in and take it in and out so it's 51 that's why it's possible 50 50 would be okay bro and i'll prove it to you says rapper just continue reading look look at the green right over here from the next line is matchman the 50-50 is okay so i'm good says rav papa says ravuna but continue reading and it's matchma 5050 is not okay so rapuna is okay so what do you do okay so the ratio is much more like your papa the safest match and everybody goes home everybody's okay with it 50 50 is okay let me tell you a lot of times we have that the ratio of the mission is mushroom this is why the same is much the marshes can't do anything about it you can't bring any rice same over here that if it's 50 50 it's usually like ravuna say foreign this green checked matchmaker 5050 is okay that's a big cash on rafale and the save for this matchma the 5050 is not okay is the cash runner of papa what do you do say foreign i'll explain to you i did the ton of racial parts memorabilia ahmed look at the largener parrots it says that lotion so therefore it has to use a similar russian oi med even though it's not accurate and it's problematic to our papa but it's better wow that sun some something changed in the weather here the sun is coming right through the direct window thing okay but you see how the lotion is similar pirates it has to it has to it has to read nicely says the namara yeah the safe is a little problematic halogen but it reads well according to our papa it it it feeds off the ratio so poetically it's good cellular gastrointestinal apartment but he didn't really mean it racial or vulnerability i did that by limits to say foreign so reference is the same exact thing i'm i'm more concerned about the safer that's my bigger they see from the safer that 50 50 is no good and that's what i'm trying to bring out from this whole uh mission over here so mainly the the ratio also poetically mimics the safa even though it's off halal now the mars says but wait a minute so make sense according to our papa [Music] that there's there's a there's a ratio there's three halakhas because what if you have exactly three exactly three fifty fifty percent so i'm telling you allah if you have three it's okay it's kosher so that's that if it's parrots it's not okay fine but if the ear space is three and the piece of wood is three it's okay so it makes sense we have two separate but according to ravuna 50 50 is puzzle so just stick what say one long allah if it's less if the piece of wood is less than three you have to make sure that you don't have a gap between them that's three says mission delay dummy absolutely absolutely safe because we're trying to bring out two different points yes the outcome is the same to both puzzle but the racial the reason why it's possible because there's no lovered we're trying to tell you that and the safer i'm trying to tell you about me or that if they're equal in in space it's possible but it's a different type of allah one is a lovin so that's why i broke it up into three rules the two different rules the rule of lover and the rule of amin of parts even though the outcome is the same so i couldn't shove them into one allah because i wouldn't know the idea of love it i wouldn't know the idea of pirates the soul of the ratio is that the goat shouldn't be able to go in there meaning love it so let's say this claim it so now the image just goes off on a side issue the idea that lava is less than three who says that that's what we typically understand and that's rabbanani pakistanis you don't say love it from three and up amos what about the end of the mishnah it says right that piece of wood that large piece of wood or the second the second case this piece of wood right over here in this case not this case from three to four now that seems to be rip shifting um so we we don't like when the mission starts off as rabban on and finishes off as a rupturing leo two different than right and everything else here but we're doing that for me so just try to understand it in the simple so it seems like it goes according to the game leo that you could go you could do love it up until four so the air gaps match up to four the ira bona mishla and we just turned to that design on the base sponsored and a reminder that everybody should choose to have a great day i don't know if we're going to allow these sayings anymore we'll let it slide for this month i schmoozed with the sponsor yesterday crazy story crazy life story started off and there's stroll moved to muncie a whole story adopted the hulu i would like to dedicate oh sorry and the the second sponsor is by dr listen house so it only makes sense to say that the entire thing lines up it's either all rabonan or all rip shaming you can't say the race is one and the safe is the other says abayo in order for you to be able to plant opposite right in front of a piece of wood and not in the gap as we explain you need to have a mokkem khashov it has to be significant fourth falcon is significant you're right love it is until three but in terms of significance you need four that's a whole different halacha and that's why it says four raved when you're up in the sky somewhere in other words like a kaira we had two kairas about to touch each other according to leo you can have a gap of fort falcon why because up there there's no no issue of goats going through it's not it's not a majitsa that we have to be concerned of a goat down below we have to be concerned of a physical problem that you're not protecting your property goats are coming in so therefore even machine learning we had this before will agree that there's no fort fahrem it takes away the halal of love because physically you know you don't have a machita it reminds me i mean i just thought about it now and i hope i don't get a lot of flack over this but like for instance if you have to have a hit in a show let's say so you don't see the women so you'll see how logically you have a loved one but it doesn't work because there's no sneeze you're not saying like if the bahris is trying to accomplish something and you don't have that it doesn't help me love and love it all day long love it but at the end of the day there's no sneeze over here if i'm trying to accomplish that uh that uh that a goat doesn't come in that have some privacy who cares how logically it is it's together but it's not together a goat could come through so when do i say fourth is okay when it's up in the sky somewhere tashima foreign all these things exactly that so i don't if somebody from that show watching i don't want to you know i don't want to email from him now i think where maisha feinstein was mata or something like that tense all these things that's the whole shiloh tenth factor has tenfold i'm going to help people are told i'm not going into it i'm just saying as an example to expand your your your understanding of this but you guys remember the entire fence was made out of windows and we said windows doesn't mean glass because glass is a real machita it means openings of windows opening of the doors does the surprise work it doesn't work it says over there yeah oh that's right gazebo thank you thank you the gazebo yeah that was a good example um you have to make sure that the the salad is more than the airspace you just said the whole thing is windows and then you say but most of it is salad it doesn't mean the whole thing it means you put many windows many doors open that says before it's not like papa hook apart it's awesome it says you have to have more salad than ear it can't be 50 50 if it's 50 50. it's not good not like rap papa the boy's saying two seconds we're going to be in another maserta and this whole sugya if it went over your head it's okay we're starting fresh huggable now yesterday we had casio and they said the cashier is a very weak one to you if there's a bomb one this is a bomb kasha we have a we have a bomb cash or a papa that's not like raw papa and says the gemara i don't care about your bam kash nevertheless asked to give mario to you so you just had a bomb catcher from abrasive and you tell me that allah because at the end of the day the mishna says exactly like you're a papa and what's stronger our mission is stronger than abrasion you're right the prices have no way out of this nine it says in our mission allah you protest the series that the opening is the gaps the airspace shouldn't be more than the salad okay mother's mastermind our mission of is okay and that's why it's like our papa have a great day maybe this is what they decided that the aravind is a little difficult fine one out of 15 daff is a little you know it's okay we can handle it i just did a search yesterday i don't know why i want to see how many times it says that's not him i should i can't hear ah williamsburg you're right williamsburg williamsburg the other thing from williamsburg wow so i think uh rebbi is brought down like two and a half thousand times in shots something obviously way way more than a buyer but then i told you there's 50 something up different rather so this i couldn't really get a good gauge but rebecca you probably so oh boy this is not in order here we go suka time yeah you have three strings and this creates a lovehood now if you think about it for a second that only gives you ninth fuchem each string has to be slightly less than three twerkum so three plus three plus three even i know what that is it's nine so but you need a matrix of ten how do you get to ten says now you cannot have between each string rope three twerking a little bit less the strings these ropes have to be a total of more than a tether since you're going a little bit less than three so he's slightly less than nine for him so your your actual ropes look at this picture he does it well they're real thick together you add up between the rope itself the rope itself has to be a little bit more than to make up for that little bit less than threes falcon they have in between each rope but a total the bottom line is total ten making bitcoin condom caught them are vertical you stick broomsticks in the ground vertical otherwise known as chassis now when we're talking about vertical and horizontal vertical chassis because david feinberg was asking me yesterday what chassis was this area in a sucker on a shock on a flat surface there is no chance you could look at it from any direction but when you're talking about up and down the ones that are in the ground vertical our chassis we'll see you later again make sure that you don't have more than three between each one so you could have loved it says the gemara it says the mishnah bishayara debru behuda the gemara is going to explain but simple meaning is a caravan these are people traveling it's not an individual that decided to go on a hike and he starts making a camp we'll see if that's true or not it says the whole thing we're talking about ashayara normally speaking who makes a giant camp and starts taking animals these are a whole busload of people do this not an individual but individual if he wants to do this let him be our guest he could do it you need also not only a horizontal but you need a vertical if you have a vertical you need a horizontal this is no good unless you do something you know every once in a while you do some of these you fill in the gaps stam a long string is not good enough says it's not true you can do whatever you want you can do all strings or all poles you don't need the two you don't need to mix them up says rav hi ray so we just said when it came to we we started off today the first thing that we said today the first was the cabinet remember this guy the camp what is this chassis or arif these are standing up things these are suitcases standing this way they're not suspended in the ear like a rope a camel is standing upwards he's creating a majits of chassis so he said if there's more camel than open space it's great everything else if there's a gap somewhere they're all considered openings what about horizontal says gomorrah let's we have to understand what he's talking about um we said that in in order for horizontal ropes to work they have to be a total of 10 falcon three gaps of a little less than three plus the ropes says abaya if you are right that you could have horizontal also not only vertical lamilia [Music] then why do you have to have three three three you could have three three and four so the mark goes through every possibility what are the three possibilities that the four is on the bottom that the four is in the middle and the four is on the top so tomorrow all these possibilities don't really work with this burrow hypox where you're going to put the four imagine not that tall you're going to put it on the bottom have a lake in the picture if you want to see what it looks like i don't know if this helps really but three three and four before we said is completely puzzled even according to your shimmer leo hoes that love it is four he holds in this case no love and why because a goat could go through no good next he might e now if he put it on the top the four is over here three three and four giant gap over here and what is river moon asking that does a horizontal rope work no it doesn't work because if it works you should put a four says the mark but you can't put a four why what says the ear from this rope all the way to the sky and this fourth right over here should cancel out this rope right over here now if you say lovehood if you say it's three twichen is loved it can't cancel out because this is filled how long is filled so this is salad so there's nothing to cancel the rope but you want to say that this is fort falcon and it's not salad yet it should work because you have a horizontal mojito this horizontally goes bye-bye because the ear over here and the ear above it crushes it and destroys it and beats it it's gone says agamaro so you have to say now there's one left one one last one middle three over here three on the bottom and the four is in the gap over here now we had a similar look already in the miserta salad salad that each salad by itself is less than the ear space in the middle but the two salads together three fahrenheit is sixth fahim but three is less than four in the middle and three but the six together will overcome the four in the middle the three the six salads on both sides salad allah let me show you the case you leave four on the top and you carve out three in the center so now you got rid of all the problems this cannot be bottled to the ear because it's solid it's four this gap over here is less than the one on top there's less than three on the bottom so i don't have goats going in there so everything is good it's less than three from the ground so goat can't go in there ravaging says no this is a different shiloh the shiloh is oops i guess i didn't i didn't print it another one of those maybe somewhere here the point is that this whole thing is salad this whole thing is salad and the question is but it's hanging it's hanging from the ground can a hanging wall that you find in ruins could that be okay again if you recall this that a guy made a little bit of a mojito so he could draw water and that works when it comes to water we made a special hectare when it comes to water but not in a regular mojito what should we do hmm it's a problem big problem so we do two more minutes let's see where we could go in two minutes my keep in mind what so it says in the michelle you can only do it for for the public for a lot of people in other words like three people but not a single person but it says foreign even for an individual why are you telling me the individual cannot make a camp he can't make this together more than two saw you're right let's say an individual needs five soya so many animals he has so much going on no that's it only up the two saw for him where was it where did it say it right here in our mission that even an individual could make a camp make a a fence out of rope um what's the difference one or two people only get two saw which is five thousand amish shlaisha nasr nice lamb base chesh but once you have three you give them six they very basically review them remember this says specifically that individual gets to saw why are you telling me in our mission he doesn't get anything that you give him it doesn't matter if you're individual or you give whatever he needs just make sure that he doesn't have any open space that he's using all the space he doesn't have two empty saw so but how do you explain robbie's review though obviously over here he says that individual does get uh fine let's just let's just stop over here i guess so we don't go too far overboard my boy sai have a wonderful wonderful day welcome to all the new guys it'll get easier trust me if you came today if today's your first day air if it is not like that don't let it fool you share my loys [Music] oh [Music] foreign actually also pointed out about your mother at the very least what is wrong with me i can't whatever you remember every thursday night chair started like that it was it became a hat it's not a habit yet you gotta charlie arrary said you gotta do it over and over elasticity and it becomes part of your brain a whole massive good morning good morning avi rosen from the mirror yeshiva you see this guy kev oh hold on all right it's all easy you didn't see what calvin said colin said it's not a big deal you can't speak i have muted everybody i don't know what's going on i am unit everybody and if you can't if you want to speak maybe you you have to exit and come back in i said uh you show aaron price yesterday i didn't touch it i didn't touch it it says allow participants to mute themselves you heard about your friend levy eliot ellie la vie you schlepped him into this whole mess joey from south san francisco how are you doing is it san francisco's no no not san francisco from b b what's it called um where is it joey where do you live ken here hey before you turn off youtube there's a guy called it's from vienna who's just joined us they're ruling free it's freed his name is itsu malay i'm on youtube how are you from vienna we love vienna listen we've got to gear up for arrowven we got to get more exotic places this whole frat business is not going to do it for us we gotta i think his daughter came to my seminar really no i'm fixing sending regards to your name hold on let me let me flip this around how are you speaking now