Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 70 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning boys. We have some maztovs and we have some rule. First of all, we have big maztov toakovz. That's what he said by mistake. Seriously, his first his first anicle. There's a guy that comes to the share every day. I think it's his first kid. It's his first kid. But the kid needs for layma Ben had brain surgery. Comes every day. his friend over there that sits in the back. So big part of it was please learn and dive in urgently needs very very young woman um I'm a young from who learns to with you every day on the bus to on the way to work on the way there I learned that from so that I can catch up finish it and keep learning more and more on the way back I learned the daily d in English all began when I went out to work one month after my wedding after spending two weeks I started working while I were working listen to the sham but after some time I fell off I was one of the learning they were learning the beginning of after that's why I guess he's going back to after I found myself without a job and without a kyo in short I felt so bad about myself a laid the gator as they say in yish then my wife and I made a decision we bought a smartphone installed the mdm filter on it and left only the mdy app available since then from I've been learning to dive with you every day as well as catching up on previous 97 DAP. Ever since the opportunity was launched to take part in MDY family saf as a gift of appreciating the magir I wanted to participate but I did not manage to do so until last week this past Monday you read out my name and it truly felt like a kiss from Hashem I didn't know how meaningful my contribution of 104 shekels for one word would feel especially when you did not manage to read all the names of those who contributed $720 or more gave me a real sense of connection and belonging to the distinguished NBA family. It also does not work out for me to go to the view location because I used my bus ride last year. Okay, thank you so much entire MDY team and all the minds behind the great cheer for your tremendous effort in work which is not appreciated nearly enough. Um we get sir and then everyone writes you changed my life but in case that statement does not even come in my case that statement doesn't even come close describing what has happened. and I become a better husband, better son, better friend, much better person grant you more to your merit to see children gradually engage in mitzvah and Melo by David Salomon. These boys have been coming consistently every night, six days a week, including fast days of mo Shabas. >> It is well protected. It has the food that means it has >> the MDY Miami summer ky for everyone. It's protected from all >> and then in Tom's River the old screen got ruined by a recent storm. So now they have a 85 in screen. This the is at 9:10 m is at 8:50 is 9 and 10 o' you don't have to start it says there's always soup this is in Hebrew I liked it but maybe although maybe you could uh fast forward the half of its Why do you asking AI first year? Somebody pay you. I came up with you. Nobody paid me. >> Okay. Uh, you're driving kids from Cam Kaye. Not a minute wasted, but he's sitting on the side of the road here. Why did he take his face off? I don't know. I I covered his face. Somebody uncovered it. Maybe Mark did. A very interesting thing. We spoke about scooters and helmets. And Yonison Schwarz, famous Schwarz, has a popular WhatsApp status thing. And in his status, he shows an accident between a car and a scooter. You know what the I don't know if you could say kiss from Hashem in such a situation, but this the thing happened. what I'm about to show you in my parking lot. He's showing it in America. This happened by us. >> This is Galler's house. >> This is This is how Noam fix. That's my building right over there with the hole. That's where I go into park. This is where Noam takes that turn to his house. The the white car. >> And that's Abi Kamyanski's building right where the car is. That's Abi Kamyki's building. That building is Elli Stfansky. And he's going towards Noam's house. Mark says it wasn't him. >> One more time >> here. One more time. >> Whose kaya is that? Do you know? He says nobody's learning. Was the guy was the guy was the guy wearing a helmet? >> Yeah. It's weird that the video he's posting is a video that happened in our backyard here. This street right here. He's on a way on his way home. He's with us. This guy was with us. He came with his wife to >> Yeah. He's with us in in Austria. He's doing the daff. Uh, caught my colleague Mark Jacobson daffing at 2:30 p.m. in the office. I'm wondering if you have an MDY code. He can change his time, too. I'm sure he has rash. And this person is making sushi while watching the shir. He waited all day for the first the gave in Hebrew when I came back from Austria was like in the middle of the day. He Yeah. The official edition. >> He said he's on a roll. He's on a roll. off the peri you're going to have a lot of fun today in today's daf. You're going to come up with a lot of new ones. The period there was 20 daff left in total and somebody from Los Angeles picked up most of them. There might be a daff or two left. I don't know. So you can check it out. But it's great. We finished the entire and every single D was sold almost anonymous in honor of Mark Ashkenazi. I like this one that somebody has a not only to me but to the guys that do a lot of work behind the scenes in honor of Marshanazi. Somebody just did one for Yasi Klein in Marshazzi. Thank you for all you do for MDY and the people who benefit from all your hard work. Oh, you can go. Yesterday I saw a picture of the Shir literally there's 14 empty seats on this side. Not today. Oh, thank you. No problem. >> Oh, that's right. It's in my thing. Ai Kamyanski is not here. He's doing a bar mitzvah. The famous character of the neighborhood, Ari Kamyanski. He I brought him up here once. He's a He's a real He's a piece. Those who know. So, he's becoming bar mitzvah. He's all serious. He has his hat, his tie, his suit. I actually taught him uh the part of his laning. So, we'll see. It's going to be here in the on Shabas. It's very it's it's a big sim if you want if you're in the neighborhood right now going on in the right now uh 9:00 in honor of Marashi Ding at 9:00 in honor of Marshazzi. Thank you for all you do. I hear a knock on the door last night. The bar boy himself. I want to know is coming to my How's he coming? Does he have a ride? Let me give him a ride. This is a whole a whole >> you sent him the principal himself. >> Aha. He's giving me a shar. I get it. Okay, fine. But uh maybe I can get him a ride. Thank you for all you do for everything and the people who benefit from all from all your hard work. David Salivan, dedicated memory of David for all you do for making the Miami and the the satellite location over there. The policy family Latin American their warm hospitality anonymous and thank you to Chief Venny for our children. Anonymous for complete reform and Lou in honor of the MDY family year sponsors big close friend. What's going on with that Spanish here? It looks like it's losing uh momentum. I went on YouTube. It's only like 50 views or something. Maybe it's not good enough that uh Listen, when it doesn't go, it doesn't go. We're not going to family Friday. Another one. We mourn the loss of a beloved son of Archila, a very very popular person. Everybody loved him. Hundreds and hundreds of people by the MDY firefighters. Another very beloved person was our unforgettable chief Jacob. Two people on the same thing. Both in very very young. 50 and 40 something. >> Huh? >> 46. >> 46. Another one was Yonathan. >> 51. >> 51. Crazy. in honor of the MDY League, the the consortium. In honor of the MDY League and all the official non-corporate sponsors Wow. Another monthly. >> Oh, who's get him on Zoom. He's on Zoom with the baby. Got him. You able to pull him up? >> You don't see anybody on Zoom with the baby? Zoom. >> He's there. He's there on Zoom with the baby. Um, we're holding by the Oh. OH. MASLETO. WOW. This might be the first time. >> This is with the baby in the hospital. >> And in case you thought that it's not real, we got a glimpse of his wife in the background. Gavaldic live. You never know >> what listen it's cuz I want to talk about that the it's actually a whole that we're talking about today and the babies but it's it's today today we're going to come across one of the most bizarre two of the most bizarre cases in all of shas it's they're so bizarre that tis brings them down as a proof that cases people say how's it possible this is going to this and this is going to happen a lot of cases in it's impossible so brings this down as a that doesn't have to happen it's just it's an interesting case it's a case that will never happen and could never happen is exactly >> and the us of >> and we're going to see but you know what's Super interesting. I think that some of these cases were not possible in time of the maybe nowadays they're possible. So let's see. But we're continuing with the scratching of the head says the Mishna. There's an animal who's giving birth but having difficulty giving birth. You see we started off this year with somebody in the hospital. Every woman has a difficulty giving birth. It's who said so for women. But we have an animal. It's not all all the time, but so the the owner had what if I help out the animal? I chop off the feet of the fetus as they come out. Maybe it'll help. Now we're talking about this is akar the famous akar has a it's a special thing can't just chop off legs can't just throw them to the dog it has a but this >> the first leg that comes out is not akar the like they say on rebesh what does it mean from the moment he was born came out to the world says in the it has to be today some of the questions that we're going to ask and these are from the less bizarre but what if there's no what if the falls out the the womb the walls of the womb what if it doesn't touch the walls of the womb it was able to come out without touching let's say today use a uh some sort of device um what are they called some sort of >> bicep. >> Forceps for not biceps. For forceps, there's a better word for it. Okay. Foreps. >> Eclipse. >> Some piece of metal or a plastic bag. You wrap the baby in a or the the animal in a plastic bag before it comes out for whatever reason. Shouldn't get uh shouldn't get uh uh some sort of infection. I don't know what you wrap in a plast bag and it comes out in a plastic bag. Is that so? These are but that's it has to come out through the womb. If it comes out through cesarian notes, what if it comes out foot by foot? So the M says as he cuts off a foot and then a leg, there's no yet. So you could toss it to the dogs. Let the dogs eat it. Had it had if it had any whatsoever, it was a bar can't throw to a dog. What do you do? Like the next part of the Mishna if most of it came out and I want to add a word here came out together in one shot you must bury this and if this animal gives birth to firstborn most of it came out normally you put it in a grave and that animal the next the next offspring even though it didn't wasn't viable didn't live the next one is not a bakar we could start off the shear here with a not a heavy sug at all, but this this could help our mood. It's not funny yet. Wait, he's already laughing. Hello. Stop. >> But recently I have a ref. >> It's not a It's not a joke cuz it's based on a real story. There's a horse that was buried here next to Bish. They buried a horse and people now if it's a Tana or horse they don't know but in suffic they go there. Seriously. Whoa. >> What? >> Somebody give a top five for that. That's top five. >> Really? >> Wow. >> This is what you get when when he has two weeks off. This is what happens. >> Yeah. All right. I talk to him. >> I'm not going to see that lately. You're enjoying them more and more lately. Honestly, >> I don't think I don't think they're the I don't think they're better. I think you're just relaxing more. >> You went away for two weeks. I'm very relaxed. >> All right. Before we start the game, I have to say two very very guests. I have no idea where they are. Shamalik, what's your name? >> We >> from Tom. >> Oo. You ever go to that place? Boy, we just moved to Tom. >> Do you go to this location ever? Check it out. >> No, I do it by I do it. >> Why don't you go visit once in a while? >> I go once in a while. >> Once in a while. >> Good. Good. And you? >> Fromwood >> Lakewood. >> My brother-in-law. >> Ah. When are you going to move to Tom's River? Okay. Great. Who else wants to say? Anybody else? What's your name? >> From Oh, you're you're Dr. Sh's sonic. Sorry. Now you moved over to that side. It's a whole different van. You guys are new. You're you're new. >> No, you're for sure not new, but you I thought maybe. Okay. >> Back. >> Back row. Who's in the back? All the way. Oh, the guy that walked in. Yeah. What's your What's your name? >> From >> Moni. It's the same over and over. Moni Lakewood. Mwood. Once in a while we get a guy from uh >> who? >> Oh, maybe maybe get a new one. What's your name? Blazer >> from >> something something nice and new something different. Morocco. No. Where? >> Stand out New York. >> Not bad. >> And now RBS. >> Oh. >> Welcome. Welcome. You have kids and everything. This guy, how old are you? >> 14. >> You speak Hebrew? >> Not really. >> You going to start? You going to start? When did you guys move? How long ago? >> Oh, just last night. >> For real? Wow. What? >> Who's that? Another son? >> No. >> Who's your Who's your brother-in-law? >> Really? He told me. Wow. So now we can smoo through you when he we'll do all the smooing. >> Where are you on? >> Ah, too famous guy. I didn't know was on an email or something the other day and you Okay, got it. Wow. So, you're jetlike and everything. You come to this year. Unbelievable. >> Have a nice Yeah, I see him. What's your name? >> Aka. You're excited to move here. >> Yeah, >> it's best. You move before the summer. You go tim. It's all nice and rosy and gishmach. Go up north. This ra go on a camel gishmak. And then I don't speak the language. It's going to you better learn Hebrew quickly. All right. If this is it's the first year and the coming and the most I don't know how to describe these these cases that we're going to have it's like what happened? Okay. First about a 15 line is the the question of when does the the the start? Does the bakar start the moment he starts being born or once most of it is came out and it's a big because what happens if a third of the animal came out now if there's a guy partner this is what people do today they have thousands of animals they don't want to give every first born to so they get a guy partner you know a partner then you don't have to give a bkar what does this do he forgot to do it his wife warned him he better get a partner go he didn't and then all of a sudden the animal starts giving birth. So he runs and he gets a guy and he makes a partnership but a third came out already. Is that third that he sold to the guy is it valid? Because if the starts immediately once it starts being born then you can't sell to the guy. It was not a valid but if it starts at a different time starts later on. So whatever you sold was good. So we have of course one third came out and then the second third came out which makes it the majority of birth it works it does not work the sale the I'm sorry the means the sale does not work and therefore thear is the sale worked says It's the sale did not work. Ra says the sale did work. And anyesh says that the sale did not work. Why? Because right away when it started being born it we find out when two/3s come out we find out that retroactively the first third was also kadesh. You have no right to sell it at that point to the go. You can't sell once it's born. You can't sell it. Rube once two/3 came out or 51% then we find out now retroactively that it was completely and whatever he sold was nothing says in other words the sale was valid from here on out it is whatever he sold is greatord to their own reasoning they have a very very similar and is going to want to understand why did they have to argue twice on the same exact idea and concept so here comes scratching your head number one if an animal oneird was born through a C-section the other two/3 were born naturally what in the world how did it happen no clue but I do have a video to show you how it might have happened. This is Mus. And in Hebrew, Mustaf means a garage to to fix cars. Here the animal came Derek Ding through a C-section. And of course, you have to chop off that part. Yeah, there's no other way. Then the other part came out. And now, for whatever reason, he's weling them together. That's not what it says in the Gabar, but okay. So now this figure is understood. One/3 came out ceserian. The two/3s came out natural and you had to cut one part off. Although saying no, they cut from the ceserian all the way to natural. Okay, whatever it is says there's no why because the first two/3 that came out one of them was it was it was you start from all the way in the beginning you go retroactive because we have to sorry the one says why because we go backwards to where it started and it started as a ceserian is not so when you say because I don't care about the first third that we're going to ignore. We're going to do the second the last two/3s and that was a natural birth. So it's a good just if you pay attention and I'm going to show it to you in a second. They're saying rever they're saying the same but comes out opposite in both cases and I'll explain holds that you go start from the beginning of the birth and the first part was not from the womb it was from says it is there is you start from here on out and there's two/3 that came out naturally So let me show you this make it very simple. We have two cases. We have the case of selling a third of the animal as it's born to a and we have case number two is that a third of the animal came out with a ceseria. Now if you say the that when you sell third okay it was a great sale and you start from here on out the last two/3 that's that that's the birth that means we have a kula over here. If we're going to start from here on out and ignore the first part this animal is not going to be aar. If it's not a bakar it's a ka it's green it's good it's good for the owner. He doesn't have to give away aar. Why? Because I'm gonna the first part that came out was it was a valid sale. If I say it works, the sale works that makes it a but I'm using the logic of the whatever I did in the beginning works and that means it's so in this case because I sold it turns out to be a ka. But for you the same exact logic when it when it when there's a cazerian it comes out of why because I'm gonna say that whatever came out with the ceserian is nothing I'm going to I'm going to focus from here on out. I don't care what I did before. Yeah. I'm doing truva today. I was a big rush yesterday. Today is from here on out from today. Today on was a valid birth of a bkar. So it's a real bkar. Using the same logic all of a sudden I have a bakar under the first case using the same logic I don't have a bakar because I sold so one time it's a one time it's a soar says I would think that perhaps the holds only to be I want to be myself so I use the logic of but when that logic makes it a cool makes it green he's not going to use that logic so I need both cases when he go the case on the Right? But how come uses the other logic that he says it works from the beginning? Why? Because just to explain the words is you have to add a few things in parenthesis because the logic of so he's going to use the logic of what's the logic of in this case of but in the second case of which is a third was born in the in the garage over there in cesarian that when you use it actually turns intora Maybe he will use the logic of and then we just do the reverse and then we have a new and he just is the case of like the one on the left. That's why Rabbi uses it because it's it's red. But in the case on the right where it's green, that logic is green. It's it's a maybe agree that you don't use that logic. Use the logic of which makes it okay. But we learned our we just read that what if a animal is trying to give birth and having a tough time you cut off every leg as it comes out and you throw it to the dogs. You could pile it up. You don't have to It's a process. It's going to take him two hours. One leg comes out, cut it. You don't have to run to the dog and give it to him. Put them on Put it in the on a pile. When you have a bunch of legs, then you take them all and give it to the dog. But if goes retroactive, it works retroactively. You cover him in how he doesn't have to bury it like the guy buried the over there. If he has a certain amount and you find out later that this is aar, doesn't a require burying? If you don't know it's you had one leg, it's not a it doesn't have the dish of nothing. You don't know it doesn't have so you gave it to the dog. But now that you have a a significant amount and you're using retroactive over here and retroactively we find out that this was aar you have to bury it. So tries to say we're talking about a case where he never left it. Not that no but this is he he never had enough that was going to cause a problem because every time he cut a leg he gave it to the dog. No new. But what if he didn't what if he didn't give right away to the dog? He had a pile of legs and feet. So he has to bury it. Of course has to bury it. So doesn't say it in the say a case two cases. One case as as I'm cutting I give to the dog but if I leave a nice significant pile I can't give it to the dog I have to bury it. The mission doesn't say that. The mission says and if most of it was born in one shot they have to bury it. I have a much better kesh. The same exact case that you said that you could give to the dogs. That's only if you give it to the dog piece by piece by piece. But if you have a pile of legs, you can't give it to the dog. It's too late. It has now that pile becomes retroactively and you have to bury it. Why does what? >> That's literally the words. Why do we jump to a different case? What's the case that the Mishna says that you have to bury like we saw in the video guy's holding an entire whole cow and he has to bury it. That shouldn't be the case. I have a much better case within our case limit in the same case that a person is cutting off limbs. There's a case that you could give it to the dogs and there's a case you can't give it to them much bigger. When could you give it to the dog when you're giving it piece by piece peace meal recover? But if you pile it up and then retroactively becomes then you have to bury it says it's such a good that's exactly what it says in the it just says it in different words when are you allowed to give it to the dog when you do a peace meal piece by piece that's this is what the mishna means but when you pile it up is tremendous I don't like it some saying that it's not a according to he says this is too hard to to believe that that's what the mishna meant But if you cut it up and you leave it there. That's why it says the next case that oh if most of it came out you have to bury it. Meaning not that if most of it came out. If you keep the same case of peace meal but you didn't give it to the dog it's piece by piece by piece and it pile up and they have to bury it. All right. Here goes. Here goes a bunch of >> cashes stuff. Really good stuff. This particular one if we didn't have a chart it would be hard in the the words but we have a chart it's very very easy when you have an entire animal do we look do we view the animal as the majority and we don't care about each limb and each organ or we have to care about organs and limbs. What does that mean? Hey what's the case? So, we have basically only two cases. Here's an animal that was born here. Boom. It's being born. Boom. Now, take a look over here. 51% of this animal was born. 49% of this animal was not born. Is this animal born or not born? Yes. But if you take a look, its leg is still inside its mother. What's poking out? One tiny piece of the leg on the right side. You see that that little leg? It's a of the leg. Now in the in you go by the you go where's the majority of the front foot inside this building not outside. Ah you guys already learned the sugia. Okay that's fine. You might be disturbing other people over there including the mug. 51% is outside, 49% is inside. But if I take into account just the front foot, the purple, 90% of it is inside the animal. So shouldn't it drawly the hoof back into the animal? And then what's going to happen? Take a look. If you draw halahly the hoof back in then now you all of a sudden you only have 49% that came out excuse me and 51% out. So do do we view each aver by itself or do we view the animal the little part that's outside here? This part you see the little tiny part of the hoof that's outside. Do we do we view it as if it's part of the larger front foot, the right front foot? And therefore what? The right front foot is inside, not outside. And therefore, it changes the majority of birth. It's no longer born. So this animal wasn't born yet or do we go with the majority of the entire animal like Benny asked me last night. So, so when you have a roy animal out, so do you have to look at the lung and say, "Oh, the lung is 90% in only 10% down." So now you don't have a lung, you know, you have a this. So, so somebody said, "No, you we're only looking what whatever you could see." Okay. >> Extremities says, "That's not a question. When you're talking about an an entire being, you're not going to go break down limbs. We're looking at the majority of this animal. 51% is out. Like in this picture, I can't start looking. But but but from the foot, it's only 10% of the foot, which is no, you're looking at the whole animal in in in its hole. And in this case, it's 51% out. This animal is considered born. So what is the question? Beautiful. Check this out. Let me show it to you. B here's an animal. Only 50% of the animal was born. 50/50 equal. Now take a look at its foot. It's front left foot. 90% is outside. 10% is inside. Now if I use the R, it was born because now I'm going to move it. I'm going to move the leg. The entire leg comes outside. Why? Because 90% is already outside. The little part that's inside, let it be as if it was outside. If it's outside, now I have 51%. the the in in in mitas the in in the physical world only 50% of this animal is born but if I use the of I can make 51% born how by taking the hoof that's stuck inside and bringing outside does that work only half the animals born by using 90% of the front left leg is this little hoof that stayed inside the animal. I got to give it to our artist that worked very hard to make it in a way that you could explain it to children to to to people that are very sensitive. They did a very good job here. A lot of goes into this. It's not. So, do we take that small part that's left inside and pretend that it's outside? Now you have 51% like in this picture. I can bring it right cover it says in the mission if most of the animal was born in one shot you bury it my if you tell me that most of the animal came out what's the the entire tells us that I need I need that same all over again how many times have we had in that we go by the majority can't be that the mission is repeating that must be telling us that It's talking exactly about this case. It was 50/50 with the majority of the left front leg and we considered it a a real birth. It's not this case rather it's this case. >> What's what's the first case? >> Yeah, this one. >> Yeah. 51% only with the hoof and the like you said before that we don't go we don't consider the most of the leg that's remained inside this is considered a a good birth a 51% birth we're talking about now the says let's go back to the says that an animal in order to bear has to come out of the womb. What if it came out in a plastic bag? You wrapped it in some sort of leaf, the the palm leaf. They take out these words because the same exact question. In other words, a plastic bag. We we have this today. A natural bag called amniotic sack. So he says, "What do you mean that that's how animals born in the sack?" No. You took a plastic bag from your from your cabinet or you took a sack from another animal. What if a woman who's helping this animal give birth? She used her hands. So her hands create a animal's not touching the walls of the womb. Ty says a phenomenal thing here. He says it's not talking about a woman. It's talking about his sister. The animal had a twin sister and the twin sister wrapped herself around her brother and the brother came out without touching the walls of the womb because it was the was caused by another animal. So he goes through because he doesn't like what's going on here before this woman touched was had to be a beginning of a birth. If the head came out first and the woman didn't touch it, then that is the birth. We learned yesterday that the the the birth of a head is a birth. It came out feet first. says, "Here goes the most interesting question in all of a weasel or a rat goes into the animal, swallows the the fetus completely and walks right out. So now the fetus never touched, never went through the womb." So what's the question? It gets more interesting. If that's what happened, so it never was born. You're right. It shouldn't be uh it's not a it's not considered. Oh, so here goes the question. Like get ready this animal went in, swallowed the fetus hole. And it had karat. Somebody gave him says, "Okay, let me go put it right back where I got it." He went out, the animals outside of the mother, went back into the mother, spit him up in there, and then the mother gave birth. If you want to know how uh a weasel or a rat, right, is a rat in Hebrew, how it ate, it it ate the the baby, put the baby back in. Here we go. It's a mouse. Went out or went back in. Deposited back. Then was born then took in a coma. So brings this as the most bizarre. He doesn't say the most bizarre. He says listen sometimes in sh you'll see things that don't make any sense and it's it's there for you to learn. Tyra I want to ask you something and I didn't see anybody even talk about this. I don't I don't view it like that. I view it as the Gmor asked a question and 2,000 years later this is a possibility. Why can't we have a surgery where a doctor opens up the animal, pulls the fetus out, does surgery, they do it all the time now. They do surgery to babies all the time in Yuru. And they could also do it outside. Cut open, pull it out, fix the spine, push it right back in. And now we have a shaw. And then it was born naturally. Why not? You tell me it's the craziest thing ever. It's not so crazy. This this case is not brought down in but maybe maybe we could apply something from this garra to to to to reality today's reality. No, >> I didn't see anybody even talk about it. >> This case is >> No, I'm saying the Yeah, because they didn't have that that day. The point of these cases these the point of all these crazy cases that we have in sh you you if once it's to no the point my point is we have we're giving usarim it's to give us not in this case you're right is saying it never happened in the world this case and so and the next case coming up never happened but perhaps it could apply even the next case now I'm thinking it could apply today how >> if what's the problem No, but it it was already born was born. >> No, >> maybe this this particular animal was born once three days ago was born just because it's born again. Here, let me give you another case similar. Listen to this. Another case that brings as a as a ria that Oh, Raisa, here we go. Ai, somebody's tired in the background over there. But that's that's the right over here. This guy, look at him. That's him. Okay. And what is he wearing? What is he wearing? Twillery. Of course, you can see spicy. spicy boy. Listen to this. >> So I I don't know if this is okay, but I I brought a I brought the artist didn't do this. I threw this in cuz I thought it's mishap. We had his mish three days ago. This if if p moved from one womb to the other. So what's the shila? But pay attention this case there was 100% not this one. There's a 100% birth on the left one. The gar doesn't even ask that. That is a birth. It came out of the womb. But it insert itself in womb number two and then it came out. Could it could it be aar for the second animal? The first animal is posit it was a birth through a womb. It left the one on the left. What are you looking at me? That's look at this. Two wombs attached to each other. The first one his real mother. She's potter. She She already gave birth. And the one on the right is not his mother. Not maybe one animal could be two different animals. >> So today I'm I was just thinking this aloud. Today you could maybe transfer a pregnancy. You have a >> surrogate. They take it out and put it in another womb. I I don't know that that's possible that that ever happened, but they have a surrogate mother. Today they have the Muslim of surrogate. Okay, we don't have this exact case yet, but perhaps you start we start thinking it's 2026. They do crazy things with with medicine. Does the animal have to touch the actual womb? What if it widened up and that all pops out without touching anything? Is it the ear space and then it has to touch the and there isn't all these these are cases that don't ask me I I some of them I don't understand completely or at all I'm saying it but we're trying to learn here what if the actual walls of the womb were cut out necro got necro There's not a there has to be walls to do. So Yoshi did a whole beautiful thing here for this. I'm not going to show you the whole thing yet cuz I don't want to ruin it. But let's say these are these are the walls of the womb right here, the blue. And it went from this to this. Okay, that's what the Gar says. The wall, it was wrapped around like a scarf around its neck. My do the the blue walls if they're in their their natural place then they give to the wrapped around the shoulders nothing but it doesn't give the bottom line there's a wall there. So here this is what he did it for. If you have this and check this out, the blue disappears. Now you're touching something that we asked the question. Where do we have this? Where else? and clim parts with the with the graves and this fine but the idea is there that what parts look at this part of the wall is missing and he came out through the part that's missing but there's walls of the ram they're still there parts or parts that's most of the walls are intact most 90% are intact part not but here's the opposite case part most of the walls are not intact they're gone and where did he come out of go and he went out through the part that's still standing. Soar says, I'll tell you in both of these cases, take a look. There's still walls standing. This walls are standing here. Walls standing, but there's walls. But in this case, where the blue is gone completely that we never had a course, it's not now much easier stuff. Turning of the D sponsored by a dire global official non corporate sponsor of the MDY league encore healthcare as a source for all of CL Royal. gotta say I want to throw this out real quickly. I know it's kind of late but I was very very inspired yesterday by this yid that was sitting next to me Leo Burger first time that somebody made a sem first of all is a very inspiring st that he made a sem he stuck it out from beginning to end a lot of people fall off after four years five years it's normal but he made massive changes in his life he does he does I'm not going to go into all of it just mix because he doesn't want me to talk about But they gave me an AI and no we made a little sem first time ever in my life that I did hopefully not too many like that can't do breakfastes for people but he does and he he we ask him questions on from sait this he he says talks about these three things right Levy where's Ley he left already so we said we want to do it also we're going to start it's it's it's interesting cuz it's to take a put a picture to it the zikur program. I tried it once and it didn't work. But now he's going to help me out and and then get three from every three that you and you tie it to a picture. So picture you can recall much later. There's a Yeah. All right. Says the we have an animal who's pregnant and the fetus died. So let's go through this side. Let's do it again real quickly. We got to get clear with this. This there's a bilbo. There's something called people were talking to me after Shir yesterday after I said the whole thing they came over to me with questions new guys hopefully most of us know this but let's do something goat and they give off tuma so people get confused oh they give off tuma so other things don't give off tuma it's not true it's exact opposite every animal in the world gives off tuma when they die including kosher animals so a dead sheep that wasn't gives off tuma a dead cow that wasn't gives tuma a dead horse tuma Dead dog to dead cat tom sheep a cow don't give off to because the works dead pig Tommy dead horse Tommy dead snake >> not Tommy not Tommy not Tommy not Tommy that's why you got to do that for me rabbi >> why because the snake is a sher and only in only the Not the ninth and the 10th. That's the thing. Okay. But that's not to tell us 100% a little bit. So it says like this. What if you have an animal that's dead, a dead animal, his tummy? So the the the shepherd stuck his hand into the animal's body and touched the dead animal or not? No. You know why? Because what if you the mother, are you allowed to eat the dead animal? It was dead. It was dead inside. You allowed to eat it? >> Yeah. >> Yes. It's still so it shepherd stuck his hand in and touched it and he should be telling me no I asked a question and only your son knew the answer and I told him I'm going to ask you and see I'll give you why is it called and not Why? Why? Why do we call it? It's not. It's what? Why? >> Huh? >> Who? >> Okay. Which one? Why is a Why is a lion called a >> supposeder? Why? Why? So he said beautifully and I think I believe that's the right answer. He said because uh kosher animal you can make a tar. There's a way to make a t through a means it's an animal there's no way in the world you can ever make it. It's it's always and a knife and a won't make it. So and it's like if a shepherd touches a dead fetus depends if the animal is a cow. If the animal is a is a pig is a is a donkey tom. Listen to this. No, before you go, listen to this. Get back here for a second. >> A guy is stuck in a desert. You I know you gotta go. >> A guy stuck in the desert. He's starving. And there's two options. A donkey or a pig. Which one should he eat? Now, the word pig, I went to a pig is the worst thing you could even say or do or or think about. You can have in your house a doll, a play horse. You can't have a play. There's no nobody has a pig. So I'm asking you a question. You have a horse in front of you. You have a pig. What you eat? The Ramban says you should eat a pig. Why? Because it has one kosher simmon. >> One kosher simmon. And he know it. I'll tell you why. It your every simmon it doesn't have. >> Wow. >> That's what he says. He holds that if you eat a horse does not ma and it's not you get two that if you touch the fetus that's dead you're not if this dead fetus you're allowed to eat later after you the mother so certainly should get rid of the part. It's not an That's very good. How do you know? It says in the same puzzle I put it in red because that's talking about what could you eat? You could eat kosher animals. But the part before that is talking about the the the non-cooser animal. So that gives us the same we could learn one from the other. I lure one from the other that what you just told me. We said already we established that a animal if you touch the the the fetus. So too with a non-coosher animal say that only on a non-cosure animal it's he learns from a Anybody that walks on its paws, in other words, a non- kosher animal. The what? So if they were alive, they're so too when they're they're a dead fetus, they are to avail the famous this guy or he did better this guy as a fetus. In other words, his feet are not split. He doesn't have split hooves. He just have those two toes, but they're not split. We already established that this guy, this camel looking animal that doesn't have split hooves is kosher when it's a fetus. It should be told according to what you said. Why? He has paws. He doesn't have split hooves. should be. When did I say that? It's also when he's inside of an animal that has four feet. But guess what? A cow is actually a 4x4 or a 4x8, whatever you want to call it. Every one of its feet is split. So he has four. He has eight legs, not four. So it's different. That's why he's m. So, okay. So, I'll I'll roll with that. But the problem is, what about this case? If you have a camel that has a par inside of it, according to what you just told me, it should be, but it is. It's a it's a non-cultur animal. Yes, it looks like a cow, but it's a nonur animal because he's a walking eight inside a four. And you said only a 4x4, not a 8x4. Says, okay, you're right. You have extra that tells us that this case that a a cow is inside a camel. That is a problem. What if you have two kosher animals, but their feet are no good? In other words, a genetic defect. A mother has she's not maf so her baby's also not paras. So should be a problem. That's what we had before said that if you allow to eat the baby, so certainly there's no tomb on the baby. Okay. So, you know what? We'll just stop over here. A boy. Have a wonderful day. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysonsor.com or sponsor at mdyd.com.