Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 61 by R’ Eli Stefansky

hello you almost missed all share it's a very short time all right today today I have Samak Aleph we're holding although in the bottom of sample Bay's the last few words we learned in the mission to see money who are loyal nemrut this 24 birds mentioned in the Tyra but the tire doesn't give us any semen into these birds it all all it says that these 24 birds are traif says the Kumari over like what Tanya it does say the semen ne'er the first bird mentioned the Tyra is the worst bird off the nest cher doesn't have any of the four conscious Iman it's the only bird in the world that's missing the four conscious Iman them as we're gonna see I made a very rudimentary thing like in the olden days there are 24 Birds the nests are you mister huh that once in a while we'll bring it back the net sure the eagle or I'll explain it I'll try to describe a little bit of the Nesher has zero C Mon M of the culture which we're going to describe and the Paris anosmia which is two birds have one Simon the IRF which is the raven has to seem on him and all other 20 birds have three out of the four seam on him but they don't have four okay now what is it measure and that's sure the common translation is an eagle oh the lottery showing that say this is an eagle that are Nestor is an eagle now the problem with the eagle is is that it has an extra toe in the back we said that the chicken one of the C money caches is this toe or if someone's trying to say this extra that longer the eagle has this extra back toe and it also has the front one is longer we're talking about an extra now we're talking about one bird of prey called an Escher that's missing all for conscious Iman them the problem is it's not missing all four because it has one called a toad so how could it be the bald eagle but a lot of regime say it's an eagle bald meaning it has a white white feathers instead of black feathers what are the four seam on the ones going to mention in a second the forest seemed on above a kosher bird are it has one extra toe it doesn't it's not a race Duras is fork shot them the shot that we had from Rashi that it doesn't lift up its food and put it in his mouth like a parrot all the Shelton is that while it eats its food it holds its food with its claws other shot them what are the other chopped in it it kills with its its foot that's the third shot and the fourth track is that it eats its prey before it's dead there is kosher bird is not darkness it has this extra long so according to Rashi or this one over here it has a crop and it has as effect and it has the cook event that's Nick laughs you could peel off the layer those are the four seam on them so what it is an issue perhaps an Escher according to some resigning it's this vulture the Griffon vulture this guy the problem with them as well is that it has that extra toe as you see in the back so it has one semi-conscious and we know that the eagle has zero Simoni Patras the eagle is the only one in the tire that is zero Simoni countries the measure nothing you sorry the measure has no no it's a stroll if you go to a gambler or on the wait a lot to have these measure out looks so what are you looking at I was looking for Eagles and it turns out you're looking at this guy I went there on the way tail at once I just remembered a mice I have enough video I'm going to a lot and I see it says eagle look out why not I'm really there us by myself I was going scuba diving say I veer off the road and I couldn't believe it there's this guy standing there he's literally this tall and like I can't so I whip out my phone and put on my video and I start going towards it I'm like talking there's a like I'm gonna see this net let's see if he's dangerous you know I'm gonna I get up to like three feet away from and I realize it's a piece of plastic so yeah it's still there you can go check it out but in gamla if you go to ghana and it says ego lookout you will see these guys flying they're amazing they're about 2 meters wide their wings you see they're from a distance and they come they swoop in and there there's a valley over there where they hunt but it's the vulture they in Hebrew modern Hebrew measure is a vulture I don't know whatever but they're very different all right says the Gemara that was another shot in the mission oh that it has a high look but that's not all right we only have a few minutes to finish the devil yep madness mu Claude so now the Gemara describes the four c-money trifa's man that should be you Claude chain look Edd's by USERRA Pacific it doesn't have that extra finger and it doesn't have the crop does fa vain kook Avani Nikolov and it's cocoa Vaughn how do you say quickly run in English again the gizzard thank you the gizzard doesn't peel easily if it died raised voice huh and we said what terraces the fork shot him according to Rashi Durst means it just lifts up the food with his hands it feeds itself like a human with with its hand it picks up its food it puts in its mouth that's a semen of truth voil Tommy that's Tommy I've called chaotzu boy Tommy so anything that doesn't have these four seem Onam of truth is Tommy okay now why you're in a Turtledove here's a turtle-duck we all know what a troll tho that we have them here in israel all over the place this guy right over here and if you look closely you'll see that it has that extra finger in the back Turtledove she actually met by a row it has the extra finger vis F peg and it has a crap the cork Evonik laughs and his gizzard peels easily the ain't Doris invited him and it doesn't lift up its food and put in its mouth it just constantly puts its peak in the ground or in its food to her in that thar I've called cleared Samantha here so before we go any writer and the gamers gonna ask the question it seems like a big contradiction here because it seems like on the one hand you have to have foreseen monomyth tray phone in order to beat rave on the other hand it seems like you need for Seamon them to be kosher which one is it so the need for Seamon of tray for now if you only have three you're kosher or you need for semen or f coachmen if you can only have three you're trave it's a contradiction we're gonna get into that but the hardest question right now is you just said in the mission of that we don't know what the signs of caches are over here it says before us that these are the signs of cashiers says the camera the obvious answer I'm on about your loin mr buzhayev every time it doesn't say in the tire or what the what the signs are just by the animal it says you have to be you have to chew it Scott that's the truth Scott it has to have split hooves that's in the Tyra these for Simone M are lol with every surfer it's only the robot on the side from later on said what it was but we don't it sound unfortunate her says the Gemara terrible here oh if a bob is simian effort are incredible if you have a bird any bird in the world that has one simin in other words if it has a long toe you look at it see a long toe it's closer so according to that this vulture for instance is is closer maybe unless well maybe we don't understand what at all was someone should ever say means a piece of bone sticking out over here that could explain a lot happens to me that this vulture has a crap so it's another problem but let's say you're walking you see a a pink where they call the flamingo pink flamingo and it has a nice long tall let's see I don't know let's say at the toe so you could eat it that's what the Gemara says here why because it only has but the power of the flamingo is it might save a fortune the tire that you can eat it but suppose it's not one of the 24 ulcer Birds that I'm a person a tiger and it has one out of the four sides ah sure so I believe I bubbles in an avatar the fish a million Asha so he says a tremendous clout and by the way this is the mascot of the Soviet that we base everything on the nature the nature has zero C Mon M and if you have one simin you're not like an Escher and therefore you are automatically kosher unless you're in the Tyrol that tells us that you can't eat right that's what you said in other words he doesn't hear well over there but not what so why do they tell you say 24 why is it they say 24 megaphone just watch me on YouTube back there okay so when the Turks 8:24 because if it wouldn't tell us about these 24 birds they will all be kosher because they're not like an eagle and if you have a bird says Rashi that has zero seam on him you should know that you're looking at an eagle and if it's not the eagle you're familiar with it's a subspecies of that ego but it's an ego family because there's only one bird in the world that doesn't have four seam on them that's called the net not an eagle but in Asia fine so now the gamer just goes through the husband how do we know this exactly it's very different than everything else we have an entire that gives a description and says ok you see these 24 Birds they don't have a crap so everything doesn't have a crab you see this it's not like that just a list a complete list of what we can't eat but everything else you can eat what can we be including those 24 maybe that maybe what maybe usnea is a turkey they're mentioned mentioned in Rashi because a lot of a lot of you shouldn't try to say that this bird is this and this bird is that the rest is we have no idea but my collegues ration entices if we know so that someone should I'm saying we know what some of them are right since we have no idea anything and like like we see with the there's a lot of confusion even with the Nasher seems to be a big crowd says the Gemara measured the Leslie cloud who did I say ho the next show doesn't have any one of the four see modems so therefore she needed her eco the is like article but any other bird and this is what we're gonna remain with at the end of the day any bird that has even one sim and it's not on the list of the 24 you could eat as the Gemara of a label if Metoyer in why are you using the Nasher as the symbol and that's the halacha we're basing everything on on a ego London Escher let's face it all on the Turtledove and say Matt or indica cool our Bo you have to have all four steam on in my pocket Nami I think you could eyeball okay so the Margo's question number one maybe maybe the Turtledove is what we're looking at is on the top and we say okay Turtledove as for kosher seam on them so in order to be kosher you have to have four consciously mother makes a lot of sense since the gomorian k and shiro first million because of our mana lovely so then why the world is the list of 24 Birds just say one bird it has to be like a turtle though if you have four semen in like a turtle dog you're kosher if not not and all the other birds the list it doesn't matter even the 20 they have only three the NI for it really because you have to have four and you don't have four Obispo cheesier word like fire be like a turtle of and it knocked out or 24 purses and this is a rather view so far the whole thing is arising when they left me not you says the Amaro let's learn from the 20 birds you don't need you don't need the tire let's learn from 20 birds that was Matt how some claw so below yeah clean on I've called class of lading they call the college game tray the had so let's learn from the 20 birds why do you need my room let's learn from the 20 birds that are not kosher and say just like the 20 birds that are not close to them the Ricci mana and there's still not kosher because you need a fourth then certainly all birds that only have to see mine and wants to everything is straight and in order to be kosher you need for semen in pain order of the coast of Oman anomaly the oil rain the Raven is right over here it only has to see Marshall then why did I even mention him all the tourists say is the ones with the threesome one in March Rafe and certainly two and one yeah Raven crow I think it's the same thing no as a crow but what is kosher everything else so then why the tires specify 24 I could have gotten away with 20 just mentioned 20 the 20 that have three seam on them and everything else has two one zero is certainly not kosher if three seam on them is not good enough for you you have a crap you have a long finger and you don't you don't pray with your hand or whatever you're not kosher so of course if you just have a crap and you don't have a toe and of course you're not kosher so why do you 24 the emergence goes through all the steps just to verify that we're on the same page a raven is not a crow oh sorry and the Kiwi is a real fruit but the Sun is a million times larger than the moon they look very similar those are the same by the way tell me that they're not the same please have different color Oh what does a male when it's a female maybe okay fine they're different birds but they're all within the same and by the way within that family I think even they say these these Indian birds that we have that make a lot of noise here the very aggressive birds that are colorful in the end what did I think they're also part of that family the crow no maybe not yeah if that's some some Spock over there says the Gemara Maori because they're who normally hash it is like docile and clean on if we already know the threesome on him you can eat you need at least for this light train me buying Tice's points out that may be the question over here that there's between this question the question that we had in the beginning of the sugah is that as we're gonna see later on that the three seem Onam that we're talking about are identical throughout the all of 20 birds in other words we don't know which one it is but let's just pretend that it's the long toe so all all 20 Birds don't have a long toe but they have three other seam on them the long tall all of them don't have the long term and now that you are just asking that we can learn from from these 20 birds that have identical Simo name that if you have those those three see monami trades but if you have the other one that if you have that toe then automatically she should be kosher thats how Isis learns I'll go up on him says the Gemara that's how yeah that's awesome rishonim learn passages like plus oven cleaner this Lee trade me boyo oh sorry let me say it is the bloody emotion can trade the time okay no because Rahman Allah Molly Hatchet asleep lovely clean on the tray says the Gemara the Leila's my earth we should learn - all the tummy hurts mahasin trade Lloyd I've called trade lordy why do I need the 20 Birds all I need is a rib and that's it and I learned from there that all the other birds that don't have to see money that only have to see mana Mart rave and if you have in other words you need for this is the gomorian cane Paris Bosnia the Casa Ramona lamellae now the Paris in those New York they only have one simin so if I say I Rev just the Raven just the Raven then why do I need person is neon persons Nia is less than a raven it only has one Simon with the oiler of s - C Mon them so why do I need what is the Paris I would know that all right yeah but I don't know but I would need in order to be culture related my I have to all other Tommy birds that what you're just trying to make sure a little longer to or less but what I what about three what do we gave me that yeah I still need the 22 toss that three is no good the one is good [Music] step-by-step why why am i learning from Nestor than one is good learn from oil forget about everything we just said until now about three learn from whatever that you need at least two right so once we have by Rev one level down says the Gemara but then there's one level below that Nick Madrid Paris was near what's a Paris and once those near so the restraining say that a Paris is that's the Oz Neil Harris is a bearded vulture very interesting bird I never knew it existed it's a vulture but has a beard you see a little beer dinner are you guys able to see you know there's not soccer this is like a modern orthodox here this is a big old culture and the does Nina Zack spray you guys know about that spritz uh it's a it's a famous plane that cost 71 million dollars thirty billion I'll project that went bust in America and it's a helicopter plane it's a plane that all of a sudden I could lift its wings this way and it brings its propeller and it could just lift the swings towards the sky and it could just lift off it's called as what in a different way like with jets they do with the Jets the alright we discussed flying your finish oh okay Sookie Marvin making the marble past those knee up m'kay and now we're back to step one m'kay initially cuz Romano lamellae Paris Bosnia has one simin so let's then why do I need measure that has zero C Mon since the Gemara hash to Beasley and Lily no and Leslie climbing boy hello Nash should the Leslie cloud who do like a whole so we learn from from Anisha it has zero seam on him and that's why you can t from it hard is Lake Idaho and that's what he said in here that one anyone cinnamon if you find a bird that's not on the list and has one semen it's kosher so now the largest so this is that's Muskaan at the end of the day we learn from nature that you have to have at least one semen to measure has zero seam on them so if you have one out of the four it's a kosher bird provided it's not on the list of the 24 and we have no idea what the list of 24 is merely can't eat anything today unless you have a mister but the Camorra a swell time of the car horn Anisha whole eyeball we have a minute later compares Bosnia if the tire didn't say ego measure 0 so I would say okay let's learn from Paris Bosnia that anything that you I think that is one bad semen that's straight how do you learn prepares Bosnia Paris Bosnia is to separate birds and anytime the Turner tells us the same allaha twice you can't learn from it how many pairs was near snakes to my barn cat hunt which takes to Irv I'm Cal called Amy lambda so I tend of the day yeah Swati need national says the America me read the it kid behind like a bhai who think of a height like a bhai we know look of all that the Paris and those near they have one semen but it's different than each other so they're not the same the only time we don't learn out of what two things that that are the same is when they're the same but the person is they are not the same they share different Simona Wow we messed up because he's already leaving and means we didn't really even finish in time okay but two minutes two minutes so the Amara I told no I'm not asking to get conscious so you know Miri didn't get behind like a value but thinking about how you look about misty says the more s envira bottom am habu this 24 non-kosher birds EF shed the fat get behind a think about at the end of the day whatever seeming you're gonna you're gonna talk about let's say you say the usnea has a long toe and the paris has a crap or doesn't have a crap doesn't do see modern but one of the other 22 birds is going to be lacking that 7 also is gonna have a tray for Sinan my have Aleutian ache super-move i'm kappahd back to the original question now so we did discuss this bird so this bird is part of one of the 20 birds so if the tell repeats it you can't learn from it Susan morrow and this is what we said before give me a yes or a boy Vista may have this 24 or non-kosher birds very bossy monument is for simona las lajas hydra Kulu when we discussed the 20 birds we're only discussing three out of the four C Mon in all 20 birds have the three the same exact tree conscious team on them and the fourth one the unknown one we don't know what it is that they don't have a stream and moisture slideshow we trade boyev and added those three C Mon him to ieave also shares the raven shows that magma paris the had bosnia this valdez Abajo now the Oz Nia or the Paris has number four then nobody else has that's the tricky and male or its national extrema bumkey odd because we never discussed that kind of simin a bird that has that one cinnamon that all other 22 all the 23 other birds don't share that one cinnamon now the same away with me name and that's why we should learn from that and saying that anything that has once semen is not kosher cause I wanna measure naturally less like a little okay whole eco this they've had so at the end of the day if we're gonna learn from Menasha that you have that anything that has even one semanas caution as the jamario time because Ivana lovely so then why do I have to say that a Turtledove is culture a Turtledove has one cinnamon and it's not in the list of the 24 americano the carbon you're right I don't need it for cashews I just need to tell you that you could bring a carbon out of the terrible have a wonderful day [Music]