Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 5 by R' Eli Stefansky

Last night the camera went to a beautiful beautiful castle. What? Gershon David his name is. The mystery Glenn Esterson. He's a brand new. Yeah, his name is really Gershon David. That's what I said. Yep, that's what I said it. Gary Bimmel says Gershon David. Beautiful backdrop managed like right by the car everything you did there was by the car so. We had the source of being by Glenn he just became a gift. Said it. And his wife is a girl is also. Oh. It's coming. Actually he walked me down I think. It looks like This is the first time in history of boys and history was made. First time [music] that the guy that walks down the house and also read the Cuba. Never happened in history. Look at that. Unbelievable. Yeah, so Mazel tov to Glenn and his wife. Um this is a very long email and I think I want to read something from a book in a second so I'm going to skip around there. Basically, how do you engage 6,000 new people? We have 6,000 people that joined Hulu. The only idea of engagement of members WhatsApp groups doesn't really work. The high level ideas I think in these are really functioning like a non-for-profit version of an LMM. What's L MLM? Multi-level marketing. Right, in a good way. It's not a scheme it's a pyramid. It's the pyramid without the scheme. It is a pyramid scheme for Tyra. I In a good way but without the tech that is what >> [laughter] >> the participants The people actually bring others in. The kids are agents. I'm envisioning listen but this idea is married it. The question is how do you how do you implement it? I'm putting you on it. You get on it. I'm envisioning a well-built platform a well-built platform where users can have profiles, see real status and understand and understand their impact. For example, who they brought in, who those people brought in, how many people they connected to across multiple generations, how many hours of learning that represents. Each person represents hours and then you get a total of your hours with your ankles in there. That represents an even and even visibility of their own giving history with MDY. Think of it almost as an impact account something like people check periodically the same way they check bank accounts. The kids are outside the celebration of B as the famous Tyra the death keeps on to the Yomi Hollywood, Florida. Oh, this is in our little steeple over there. Oh, they're dancing outside in the parking lot. I don't have beautiful. It's in Hollywood, Florida. And then they have this MDY I don't see anybody there. Is anybody >> [laughter] [laughter] >> You see eyes and all our boys saying bells them. Showing all the Yomi he says he claims it grows. I don't know. I didn't count all the people he says it's growing. See him above him at sea. See him above him at Astra. Sanhedrin, Shavuos. I mean the Tsar look he's keeping track of it it's very nice. Zevachim, Menachos. And the time we were set a location like Boymer event they made a big match up over there for MDY and the camera or they're making one. Tuesday Tuesday May 5th okay 7:15 the items invited. Um I'm feeling tempted why so it wasn't around when you considered open up a Yeshiva. Nor when you decided against it. But I want to tell you something you might not fully see it but you actually have several Yeshivas already. At the various viewing locations groups of wonderful Yeshiva Bachman gather every evening at the third seder and even sneak away from my room and come to learn Tyra with real enjoyment. No one forces or persuades them. They come on their own giving up their free time to learn and enjoy and gain understanding along the way. They even take care of organizing the viewing locations properly for everyone. So maybe you don't wear get to wear a frock for it but officially you're not and and officially you're not there as a Yeshiva but you should at least know that these virtual Yeshivas exist, are growing and are bringing new life to these sweet Bachman. Oh, and I almost forgot to mention you're changing their lives. Your time is from the VR Cove MDY with regards to the coming call check out this beautiful video you put together here. Otherwise we're allowed to listen to music. This guy's unbelievable what goes on in the VR Cove is unbelievable Bamas. Every night every night. >> [music] [singing] >> He has ear [music] pods in right? He has no idea what's flying. >> [singing] [music] [singing] [music] [music and singing] [music] [singing] [music] >> They have a projector on the on the >> [music] [music] >> It's one of our 30 something locations. [music] It's unbelievable. It is literally like that every night. It's unbelievable the VR Cove unbelievable. >> [applause] >> The boys I here's the map of all the locations in Earth Israel. It's unbelievable I didn't count. What are how many do we have now? 33 like Boymer 33. A lot Boymer 33 beautiful beautiful no. They just opened three new ones. We were at 34 once went down we're 33. Including a lot. The boys I we have a guest in the house. He's back. Shamshe Schlager with Ireland. Ireland is used to be a this but this this represents MDY. Literally the Xiaomi and the good governor with the pink shirt. >> [laughter] >> The committee has returned. The guy that knows how to learn and the guy that wants to know how to learn. I'm not going to say which one. I'm not going to say who's who. Those who know know those who are in the share long enough. So this is the first day of Hulu in in the Hebrew share the boys say this is what goes on in the Hebrew share once in a while. Check it out. >> [singing] [screaming] >> They covered Hulu and they did a move. Wow. It was a surprise. >> [clears throat] >> Okay, where's that book? Give me the book real quickly. How how many minutes are we in? I'm reading it first time. This is the book Rabbi Murray Mazelton. Oh, that's who he's sponsored is. Aaron Aronov's father. Few weeks later my husband Aaron and I attended Shabbat for Reb Elazar Yomi and Nachman was there. Without telling me Aaron approached Reb Elazar and asked if he would write a book about my father. Reb Elazar responded that he would love to but he needed family's approval. When Aaron told me this I said it's not going to happen I said too many opinions too many people. Then Reb Elazar spoke about dreams. It was Parshat Vayeishev he spoke about Joseph's dreams Pharaoh's dreams and how everything begins with a dream. Smart guy speech who If you don't dream he said nothing will happen and when you dream people may discourage you push forward and suddenly something clicked. With Hashem's help I decided this book would happen. That's it. That's it. You said oh that's the first Shabbat on. It's she was everyone pushed and said no no no. She heard you speak. And I said dreams. You got to push forward. So it's true you see that it is true. Dreams come true. Wow, you have to have a dream and go forward. Beautiful. I don't want to without without I need a dress in here. You know on this side I can't pull it off. I will but I I I don't trust you you know. All right the boys I we're we were promised the document of of a garden towards the end of Menachos but it's happening now. It was pushed off a little bit. So first of all I'm here. Therefore I had more of a vision Schlita. Uh first of all I'm anonymous Mazel tov Mazel to surely follow up upon finishing his 19th in Shas. Mazel tov MDY coffee corner the man's back covered at field committee dial if you need me at home and official edition MDY Shas Masechta Zevachim Shulchan Aruch Perek the Benedict family Daf Hey Joel and Rachel Gedalye in honor of Bella Chaya Yehudis Moshe Aryeh and Devorah. So he took another Daf here. >> [snorts] >> The first From the beginning I know. David Solomon dedicated memory of Ovi Meiri who's yesterday Baruch ben Chaim Zvi Dov the project family foundation gratitude to consortium >> [snorts] >> and the alliance and all they do to support MDY. Anonymous has luck and bracha and gashmius and thank you to Chief Benny Anonymous for complete refuah shleima and arichas yamim to Leah bas Esther. Coil sponsors AHK Ventures CFO Services family. Hello, I thought you were going to change this. And the companies they own. Binyamin Rosenfeld bracha and parnassa. Kinovations LLC as a zechus for a simcha ben Feiga and Rivka Yehudis bas Chava Chaya. Aryeh Simon refuah shleima of Meiri Baruch ben Miriam. Binyamin Rosenfeld parnassa be shefa. I think he's coming with us. Is it Is Binyamin Rosenfeld he told me he's coming tomorrow. Be if we could all get out of here. Moshe and Ruchy Margulies just to give you a heads up. The plan is we have a yearly MDY trip for the sponsors of MDY to keep the operation going. This year we're going be'ezras Hashem to Morocco. Hopefully we're able to get out. Getting back in is a different story. First we have to get out. >> [snorts] >> Zelig and the Zeitlin the Zeitlin family. Reboy say we have a tremendous tremendous zechus. Yesterday was here. He's very quiet. He didn't want He didn't want to say anything. But Shawn Carter and Hunter Shawn Hunter Spencer Zeitlin's rebbe is here. One of them is here. What's your name? Asher Dretzin. Asher Dretzin. He's here. What is it? He's here. Shavua tov reboy say. You did a wonderful job wonderful job. They're wonderful boys. He says they're like the only They're the only kids in the school with long hair like that. We don't want We don't want to get into it but they're they're cool kids and look it's not about the kishronis. They brought the Daf to to the school and a bunch of kids are doing you know. A bunch of guys are doing it. Mazel tov. Ethan Zelig 15 and Hunter Zeitlin 14 on their 500th Daf halfway to MDY 1K status. Wow you me five l'iluy nishmas Sheindel bas Rav Yechiel Mechel uh Sholom um Yortzeit is on Lag Ba'omer. Daily sponsors Mitzvah Motivators l'iluy nishmas Aaron Yisrael ben Shmuel Perera Akiva ben Avraham Avinu Price. And of course Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai. Shmuly Kleiner l'iluy nishmas Rav Shmuel Yaakov Bornstein zechusam livracha. L'iluy nishmas Rav Shimon bar Yochai zechuso yagen aleinu and the 45 kedoshim of the Meron tragedy. Aryeh Hershkowitz l'iluy nishmas Leah bas Zvi and Sholom ben Yoram tov v'aleh iniftar bas son Meron Lag Ba'omer taf shin peh alef. Aryeh Hershkowitz was friendly with that mishpacha. Nissim Massalian and family in memory of Moshe ben Shimon. Anonymous thank you reboy say. Yossi Mark Benny artist and editors for helping me finish 500 Daf of Gemara. Shkoyach. Jamie Azulay Meir Planken Aryeh Blau mazel tov. Shmuly Portowitz and the Se'um thank you for hosting the Toronto MDY Se'um. Mazel tov shkoyach. Yisrael Goldstein. Whoever started with Mishnahs and Hedrin got to 500 now. Beautiful. Yisrael Goldstein my grandson Yisrael Shulem Chalaka and the five of Shimon's from three years ago. It's actually [snorts] four years ago. The nice happened three years ago. Zvi and Sara Corlin in honor of our son Ezra's upsherin and he should follow in the footsteps of Rashbi. Chaim Weissman bizchus Rashbi bizchus Rav Zalman Auerbach l'iluy nishmas ben Priva rosh yeshiva Chava Bracha ben Devorah. should give him zechus kiyuma. MDY art for the month before shleima Yona ben Nesanel ben Shmuel bracha refuah shleima Mordechai ben Esther refuah shleima Daniel Zev ben Ayelet Esther. Reboy say Zvi Corlin is coming? Very nice. So let's see where was he? Ah here it says Zvi and Sara in honor of our son Ezra upsherin. Beautiful. She has young kids at home. Reboy say today we have like an Agadata Gemara tomorrow as well be'ezras Hashem we're easier stuff. It's turning out to be a shmak in the sechta. I hope you're still with us. You 6,000 guys stick around. It's just getting better. So we had a we had a tremendous chiddush from Rav Anon and today we're going to knock it out. We don't We're not going to go with it but Rav Anon says that somebody that worships avodah zara he's a good shochet. You can still eat from his shechita. The Gemara says where do we know this from? We know it from the story of Yehoshafat ben Achav. Achav made a bunch of steaks and he made a tremendous barbecue for Achav and his men and Achav ate from it. Yehoshafat Yehoshafat ate from Achav. And Yehoshafat was a tzaddik. He did not do avodah zara. So you see that you're allowed to eat from somebody that's oved avodah zara. So the Gemara goes through a few questions. How do you How do you know it? We're holding like 14 lines from the bottom of Daf Dalet Amud Bet. Who told you that that Achav the rasha he was the shochet? Maybe Ovadya. Ovadya was one of Achav's men but he was a He was a He was a One minute. He was He was a tzaddik. He hid 100 He was not a navi. He hid 100 Well, he asked me he had a he had a There's a sefer called Ovadya. He hid 100 nevi'im in two caves and he saved them. He saved 100 He worked hard. He He said He risked his life like you know think about the the Shoah risking risking their lives saving Jews. He risked his life to save 100 nevi'im. And in that zechus he got nevu'ah. He was a special person. So maybe Ovadya was the one who was the shochet. And for that for that you're certainly allowed to eat Ovadya's shechita. Did Ovadya do avodah zara? Says the Gemara no it's impossible for a human being to shecht that much. If you remember the video from yesterday there's a lot of food on the table. L'rov k'tziv Ovadya had a safek. It was impossible for him to shecht everything. V'dilma shishim elef v'od 7,000 >> [cough] >> Yidden that did not worship avodah zara. That was basically all of society came from that 7,000. Every Everybody else was wiped out I believe. The k'tziv V'isharti b'Yisrael shivas Here it's a pasuk. V'isharti b'Yisrael shivas alafim. I only left over 7,000 kol avirchayim asher lo charu laBa'al all those knees that didn't bow to the to the bow to the avodah zara. Says the Gemara yeah but they weren't around to shecht. Tam urei have mitamrei Mizevel. They were all hiding from Mizevel the rasha who killed all the gedolei hador who killed everybody. V'dilma gavrei Achav avah malu. Maybe who said Achav was a bad guy but maybe his people were all good. Lo yosif k'dei That's not how it works. The k'tziv Moshe machshiv al divrei sheker k'mo shorshei resha'im. If you have a a bad leader all the people are going to be bad. They follow him. V'dilma gavrei Yehoshafat nami lo avah malu. So maybe Yehoshafat's people are also no good. And mamila they're the ones who ate the bad meat. Zevach gavrei Achav v'zevich gavrei Yehoshafat. The whatever the bad guys shechted the people from Achav so the people from Yehoshafat ate cuz they're also bad. Zevach We already established that there was at least one good shochet but he couldn't shecht enough. Okay so he shechted for the good people. Zevach Ovadya Achav Yehoshafat. But Ovadya was around and he shechted. Whatever he shechted Yehoshafat ate. And the thousands of people that came with Yehoshafat they all ate the the treif meat from the treif guys. Lo yosif k'dei It's the same svara that we said a second ago. V'dilma Moshe machshiv al divrei sheker k'mo shorshei resha'im. When the leader is a rasha all his people are resha'im. Kol divrei emes mishum sh'tzaddikim. It goes by the leader. Follow the leader. L'chora [snorts] if Yehoshafat was a good person so all his people were good and therefore they wouldn't eat from that al shechita. And from the fact that they all ate that meat you see that you're allowed to eat meat from somebody who's a mumar d'avodah zara. They weren't that bad. Maybe they weren't mechallel Shabbos. They weren't They did They kept the Torah. Just had a little little yetzer hara for avodah zara. And that's okay according to Rav Anon. V'dilma zevach gavrei Achav v'zevich gavrei Yehoshafat. Maybe whatever Achav's people shechted his own people ate. Zevach gavrei Yehoshafat and Yehoshafat's people also shechted. Achav Yehoshafat gavrei. Maybe they came with their own shechted. Says the Gemara lo avah malu nafshiynei. You seen that video? Should we see it again here? Let's just show it just one more time. We might understand a little bit better now. >> [music] >> You see that Yehoshafat and Achav were very friendly. They They did everything together. They were best of friends. Yehoshafat You don't see guys who's a tzaddik. Achav became and they themselves shechted maybe. This >> This is Leroy. All the steaks, all the lamb chops, everything. Oh, this is what the Gamora says. They have a mother of Ashima and best friends. >> [music] >> Put on them. And then they went to war together. Menachem says Gamora, how do we know that they accepted the all the bad stuff and the good from Ahab? You lay with Kameni Kamoycha. We're we're the same. I'm like you, you're like me. Kami Kamecha. So, I accepted by myself all this and hef that you do. So, when it says right in that same the two words later it says my horse is like your horse. It also means in this of hef. My horses and your horses, we all accept they accept all this and hef of yours. I said this to when the beginning when I started saying this year in Hebrew so the wanted me to to say Sefardi Havara. And there's a whole should I speak like a Litvak, like a the Yeshiva's Havara or the Sefardi Havara? So, I tried it out in the beginning until this was the part of this got to the Ela Berecha Vela and I said Ela Berecha Vela Batutim. >> [laughter] [snorts] >> Yo, yo. Okay, now my sister Raya. Hachinami. It's a big problem in the Hebrew. It's a serious it's a serious problem because the we started out. So, even if we're more let's call them cooler guys, more modern but they all went to Yeshivas and they said you cannot talk we don't want the Sefardi Havara. Don't say cash like like speak in Hebrew. We want Yeshivish Sprach. So, okay. So, we established the Yeshivish Sprach which was better for me cuz I'm more used to it. But then the problem is you have we want to get to the me Havera. And they don't some of them Sefardim they come in like what do you what do you say they don't know it's like a different language to them. Literally they don't understand what we're saying. Okay, you have to make another show. No, no, no. Takes it takes about 3 days and they they get into it. If they could last for 3 days. Hachinami. You hear I told you I told you guys that the first day the first I looked it up last night the first day of the Spanish Daf Bais is holding close to a thousand views already. It's unbelievable. Close to a thousand views. The shaila is if it's all because I said in shia that we do it in Spanish so maybe all the Americans clicked in there. So, we we don't know. We'll see. If it keeps on going the ship it's crazy. Yiddish is coming soon. French is coming too. French. Oh, so what's Kesusacha? Your horses are like my horses. The Haviasu Secha to Haviasu Sai. The is they're like tanks. The horses is a tank in those days. Whatever happens to your tanks going to happen to my tanks. We're going to war. Whatever happens to your horses going to happen to my horses. We go we're in this together. Hachinami. So, Kameni Kamoycha is not referring to it's referring to our bodies that our physical being we're going into war. Whatever happens to you, however many people are not going to make it they're not going to make it from my side either. So, how do you know that he took upon himself all the of Ahab that he suffered was masking to everything that that happened over there in wise? They're sitting each one on their own chair. They're wearing the the the clothes of of of a king. The The is the the threshing floor. I saw in a in a Gamora that it calls it the one of the one of He's he's mastered as a silo. I think it's a mistake. means a threshing floor. Silo is more of a Thank you. >> [laughter] [laughter] >> Silo is more of a of a storage vessel. A means a threshing place where people come and thresh the the I'm just trying to not not if you don't don't think it's a silo. It's a threshing floor. You know what? It's Shoyim. In in the in the gates of Shoyim. My in Editor, you don't have to edit. Don't leave it in. My in all the in the other It can't be physically a threshing floor. What do you think there was a threshing as you walk into the Shoyim by the gate over there? What's what do we sometimes refer to as the threshing floor? That's the Sanhedrin. It's not Sanhedrin is going to something like this. They would sit the 71 would sit in a half a circle. Why? So, they could all see each other. And you don't do it in a complete circle cuz then you lock everybody out. It'd be impossible to come in. Let's say you want to stand in front of the Sanhedrin. How you going to get in? It's very So, you have a half a circle and like this. So, that's what it means. That there were It's referring to the Sanhedrin not to literally the the the threshing floor. They accepted they accepted their Halachas. Says Gamora they didn't say anything. Maybe have proof to Rabbanan which like I mentioned before it's not going to last. But we have proof that what? That somebody who's a desire it's a tremendous we thought about it before we started the Sugya. You have to say to yourself guy is a desire. He doesn't believe in the he he he's he's worshipping someone else. You you going to trust him for a sure? Rabbanan says yeah. So, the Gamora goes into the beautiful story. I got to tell you. Eliyahu Navi he decreed that there should be famine for 3 year famine. So, Ahab was upset at him. What you're putting an embargo. He's going to go kill him. So, he had to run away from him. So, how did how did he how did he live? He ran away into a cave. The ravens they bring him every single day a small meal of bread and meat. In the morning and in the evening and also in the evening. The morning and the evening. Oh. What's the says Rav? Where did where did this meat come from? It came directly from the kitchens of Ahab. Says the why why from Ahab? Should be from Yeshafa. Maybe some people actually learn from Yeshafa but not it doesn't fit in this Gamora. Says that's what the does. He shows you who's in charge. The person that's trying to kill you is the person that's going to feed you. I'm going to make it like that. He's feeding you every day. Beautiful here a voice I beautiful video. Some server says it. >> [clears throat] >> Who's first the >> [screaming] [laughter] [screaming] [singing] >> They say why why why ravens? Ravens the Gamora says are mean they're they're they're mean to their own children. And it was like a sign to Eliyahu Navi enough. You know, you're you're being too mean to to they're in famine. Let them let them go. Oh. So, the Gamora says like this. I'll be had Shani. You can't bring any right from there. This is ravens from and Eliyahu Navi was whatever if sending him meat I could eat it. It's from the you don't bring a right where did it come from? From Ahab so maybe you could eat it. So, says as we do all types of them especially when they're Obviously have to come on to the gave you. You have to come on to that answer. Says the Gamora. What's the answer? No, but obviously if you don't say from you have a different problem. So, you have to say automatically you have to say it came from he says no. Obviously if he got the the the meat from the raven obviously what's the problem is it from a [clears throat] Jew or is it from a so obviously it came from a Jew. But at Obviously it didn't it doesn't come to be matter a of of that much what? No, in the in the it's going in the before. That's why I have to say no. I'll be a divinely and that's why I cannot bring a raaya from >> [snorts] >> That's something else. It's not you're not passing. It's just the Torah isn't. But you could you from Torah from shamayim you could see whether or not it came from a or yid. That part yes. >> [snorts] >> My orvim. So we're we're learning orvim means a raven. Literally a raven. But how do you know if I want to break it down with maybe their names were orvim. Orvim orvim two orvims. It says there was a guy his name was orvim. >> [clears throat] >> Two people with the same funny name two orvims. Nah. You're you're right. The two people have that same funny name. That that the name that's the bird not some a bird a raven. But maybe there was a place called orvim and they came from there. So that's that makes more sense. Two people from orvim. Maybe save. Irvine Irvine they came from Irvine. >> [laughter] >> Says they came and they they they captured a naroktana. Now anybody that learned Torah throughout shas what's a ktana? Up until the age 12. What's a naara? From 12 to 12 and a half. Here how do we know here here we go. Ktana boom. From zero to 12. A naara is from 12 to 12 and a half. A bigaras is from 12 and a half till 120. So how can you put those two words together? Naroktana. She's 12 and a half she's 12 and she's also below 12. How does it go? So calling her a naara. How can you call her the same thing? They're opposites. They're they're they're contradictory. The pshat is that she's actually a ktana. But she happens to be from I know but how does it in in English? How does it fit into this a city in Los Angeles? When you come up with it let me know. Says [snorts] the Gemara if that's the case if they in fact came from if they're both two people that came from a place called orvim it should have been called New Yorkers. You don't call it New York. If two people come from New York they're called New Yorkers. Two people come from orvim they're called orvim. Which one? Oh oh it's a city in Japan. Gevaldig. Let me say it like I have another raaya and this is a freebie boys I we learned this sugia yesterday. Have a raaya to Rav Anon that there's somebody that shechts and he's a big over there with the zoyre as a shtikel uh of the zoyre going on in his house. He has a nice uh gatchka. Says a kol shechted everybody's permitted to shecht a kusi even a kusi. Even somebody without a bris mila. And even somebody that doesn't believe higher aleichem dami. Who are we referring to over here? If his brothers they died after the bris mila so they they passed and he cannot have one. He's a perfect Jew and of course he can be a shoychet. He's a guy that's mizalzil in the bris mila. He's meva'ez says Rashi kicks it. He he he looks down at bris. >> [clears throat] >> Am I a feel mummer? Says that if somebody that that that doesn't believe in something you're allowed to you're not allowed to eat this hey even over here hold. If he if the over here the means everything besides things that have to do with the nevela and eating. I I know Sorry you could do shchita. I said not. You could do shchita. Then what? Somebody that doesn't believe in something in the Torah. One of the mitzvos in the Torah. He doesn't believe in love of an esrog. So that's like somebody that doesn't believe in bris mila. What's the difference? It's the same thing. So why are you repeating the same case? It can't be that you're repeating the same case. Hello love. Love of an esrog. Let's let's go with the Rav Anon. So write the Rav Anon then what? Somebody that doesn't that doesn't love of an esrog. Shtikel a taiva for love of an esrog. He's allowed to be he's allowed to shecht. Over [snorts] there Rav Anon that's mutar. I'll say no absolutely not. That's too much. Why? Don't have a love of an esrog. It's like you have a love of the whole Torah. If you if you deny love of an esrog it's like you admitted all Torah. And if you do have a love of an esrog it's like as if you deny the whole Torah. So you deny the whole Torah that's it. You can't you can't shecht. Hello love of an esrog. He's a mummer to nevelos. And that's the big chiddush that even though he's he's a mummer to nevela he doesn't he he doesn't believe in in nevela but we could trust him in shchita which is in in the same category. It's food. The chiddush of Rav And like Rav Anon says that a mummer to nevela guy that eats cheeseburgers the we could trust him as a shoychet. Mayseif. No that's the chiddush. That's good with the chiddush. No that's Rav Anon. We we already yesterday we already established this is a Rav Anon that says that's not a problem. If you're a mummer I hear what you're saying. Why jump? But we already have that shita. Rav Anon said yesterday that a mummer with the taiva on a nevela is okay for shchita. So the Gemara is saying why jump? Why go to taiva dizara take it down one step to nevela? Why why take it down from taiva dizara all the way down to to to to to megila to to to simple thing? Take it down one step. Mayseif. Mikem v'lo kulchem. So it says in the pasuk So it's not everybody. Mikem which is talking about an ola on a dabba. Mikem v'lo kulchem not everybody could bring. Lo yotzei mummer. A mummer cannot cannot bring a korban. Here. Let's see wow it went in the order. That was not that was by mistake. Let's see. I I did this literally at 7:05 five minutes before shiyur. But it happened by itself. Baruch Hashem. Maybe somebody did it for me. No I I copied from another place so could be it goes let's see if it goes in oh gevaldig mamesh. Wow. Maybe Yossi got up and he did it for me. Mummer No cuz the then the lamed wouldn't be touching the top over there. Mummer mikem v'lo yotzei mummer. A mummer cannot bring a korban. Mikem Umois only in klal Yisrael a mummer can't bring a korban but in the nations if you have a a who's a shtikel mummer he could bring a korban. Min habaheima lo haba bnei adam sh'domim labaheima. They're going to talk about this in beis. They're human beings that act like animals. They're not mentioned. What does that mean? They don't they don't they don't they don't keep the Torah. They don't keep mitzvos. So they're animals. The Ari Zal today is the day of the Ari Zal. Like Ba'omer. I think he invented like Ba'omer the the the going to the cave of Rabbi Shimon So the Ari Zal says that sometimes a person does an aveira and he dies without doing chuva. So Hakadosh Baruch Hu puts him in a in an animal. Puts [clears throat] his neshama in an animal. And then another person does an aveira the same aveira but he does chuva. And he takes he goes to Beis Hamikdash and he gets an animal. Hakadosh Baruch Hu zamin the animal that he that he shechts as a korban is that guy's neshama in there. >> [snorts] >> And he shechts and you you take out the neshama. You get you give you give that neshama a tikun through the same the same aveira the same thing through that. This is bnei adam sh'domim labaheima some beheimos sh'domim labnei adam. That's why we shouldn't be metza'er animals. You never know you might be metza'er your own father. Zochronam livracha. You give him a smack and he's father. Okay. Mikem amru. Mikablin korbanos miposh'ei Yisrael k'dei sh'yachzru mim t'shuva. You hear this? It's marid. Why do we accept a korban from a guy that does aveiros deliberately? Posh'ei Yisrael. He does it deliberately. K'dei sh'yachzru mim t'shuva. You have to give them a chance to come back with chuva. And if you push them away say no I don't accept your korban then they're pushed away forever. It's almost like all the psychologists today say you have to show them a lot of love. Never push them away. Give them a chance to come back. So our boy said there's a song I just you probably know it. Not so many people know it. But I want to those who don't know it I want I want to teach to them. Not that I I don't know it so well. I'm here he's going to help me. But the few times that I heard it I'm not joking. I I cry. Every time if you don't see me crying inside I'm crying. It's a it's a beautiful tfila. It's a tfila that women get to say. Us men don't get to say. They say by now I know why they cry. You know women cry by hadlakas neiros all the time? Cuz the words are beautiful. Especially the high part especially the part in red. So I want to teach to you and and say it as a tfila. It's marid. Who's going to help me out over here? You guys over there? Levi, you know it? All right, here we go. This These are the words. Well, we'll only do the the the the the things one time, but the the best clear ones we'll do twice. All right, let's go. We're on the right tune. >> [singing] [singing] >> We're holding in the green thing. >> [singing] [singing] >> Skoyach. It's more dick, no? We should all be zoyche to see our children. And our neighbors' children, all of them. Oiskim ba'Torah u'baMitzvos, they should all come back. All those who left. Zol dig more. There are two who we don't accept carbon from. Chutz min ha'mumar So, we have to understand what this mumar is. Chutz min ha'mumar, that's one thing. U'minasech yayin, that's number two. Somebody who does avodah zarah with wine. U'mechallel Shabbos b'farhesya. He does chill Shabbos b'farhesya. There was a thing I didn't show you yesterday. It was a chill Shabbos b'farhesya. This guy is not a chill Shabbos b'farhesya. I don't know exactly. IT'S ON SHABBOS. THAT'S NOT B'FARHESYA. OKAY? ARE you done, man? I need to mop. You're 2 days late on the protection money, which means I owe you every bone in your body broken. But it's Shabbos right now, and on Shabbos I don't draw blood. It's forbidden. So, you come to me Saturday night after sundown, and I'll give you the beating I owe [laughter] you. No problem. I am going to pray at the synagogue. >> [snorts] [gasps] [music] >> Okay? If you chill Shabbos b'farhesya. Chill Shabbos b'farhesya. Hugu forgot you like it. Who said top one? Oh, for that? Ellie liked it. Okay? Top. Hugu forgot you. Amris mikabel leikuchem leitzan mumar. So, you have a shikul problem. Here we go. In the reisha, we had uh mikabel. From Just remember the word mikabel leikuchem leitzan mumar. What other time mikabel? So, he said mumar mumar can't bring a carbon. What other time mikabel carbonos b'feirush? So, then it says he could. How do you got you? That's not That's not a big kasha. Reisha mumar l'chol ha'Torah kulah, as you see over here I wrote mumar l'Torah, the whole Torah. So, no, he can't bring. Mitziosav mumar l'davar echad. But the the middle part is if he's if he only he doesn't believe in one thing, doesn't believe in lulav, bris milah, he could bring a carbon. Eima seifa, we have a problem. We just read chutz min ha'mumar minasech yayin. Besides somebody who's a mumar, and somebody who does avodah zarah with wine, u'mechallel Shabbos b'farhesya. Hai mumar echad domi. So, let's do the seifa. It says mumar, no. What does it mean? Which [clears throat] one is it? The the purple. What's the purple? Mumar or not? Eima mumar l'chol ha'Torah kulah in the reisha. That's exactly what we said in the red. The red says mumar l'chol ha'Torah, no. So, you you're not going to repeat yourself. I read v'eima mumar l'davar echad. And if he's only mumar for one thing, not for the whole Torah, kasha m'tziosa. It says m'foresh that you could, it's green. V'eima mumar l'davar echad, it's okay. Ela lav od komar. Chutz min ha'mumar l'minasech yayin. Mumar and nosech yayin is one thing. It's not two separate things. It's not a mumar plus somebody does it. He's a mumar for avodah zarah. Or the chill Shabbos b'farhesya. So, if he's a chill Shabbos b'farhesya, so so Rashi says over here, it's a beautiful Rashi. He says, and we do all Rashis. Mikabel carbonos leitzan mumar l'davar echad chutz min ha'mumar l'minasech yayin u'mechallel Shabbos The honey chamiri. These are very severe. A mumar l'chol ha'Torah kulah. Okay. Hai tana chamiri Shabbos k'avodah zarah. He says that Shabbos is like doing avodah zarah. Why? D'avid avodah zarah m'chached b'Kudsha B'rich Hu. You Somebody does avodah zarah says he believes in another entity. V'eima mechallel Shabbos koifer b'maaseh. Somebody who mechallel Shabbos says Rashi, this man don't uphold. As you you don't believe in the Ribono shel Olam who made check sh'hu shavas maaseh b'reishis. You're saying that Kudsha B'rich Hu didn't rest, and that's why I'm not resting. You don't believe in that whole thing. So, it's very severe. Alma, what do you see from here? Mumar l'avodah zarah have a mumar l'chol ha'Torah kulah. We just said that the word mumar over here mumar. The purple we have to say, we have to write over here, I didn't have time, mumar l'avodah zarah. That's what it should say. And what do you And what? And he cannot bring a carbon. So, you see, not like R'Avana. You see, somebody who does avodah zarah can't even bring a carbon? What? Okay, [clears throat] I don't know. We'll have to see. Maybe that's the roots of the Gemara. It was this, that. Yeah? His own people did different things that We got out of it. We said no, but it could be. Alma mumar l'avodah zarah have a mumar l'chol ha'Torah kulah. Let's go Let's go by that. Alma mumar l'avodah zarah have a mumar l'chol ha'Torah kulah. But to youfta R'Avana, the Gemara goes away from R'Avana. Somebody who does avodah zarah cannot be a good toyche to youfta. Says Gemara v'mahog nafka v'mahog nafka. You bring me old posuk mikabel that you could bring a carbon. You can't bring a carbon. Am ha'aretz, problem mumar. We learn from another posuk. Daf ayin mem beis. From the posuk different posuk am ha'aretz, problem mumar. R'Shimon Yosi omer R'SHIMON R'SHIMON. OH! R'Shimon R'Shimon. In the name of R'Shimon bar Yochai. So, I just got I got to remind the oilam. Yossi Yisrael Goldstein just sent in a thing. Uh he he dedicated. So, the the quick maaseh, it's not gaavah b'chalal. I don't usually say maases of gaavah. This is a story by R'Shimon bar Yochai. Four years ago, there was four R'Shimons on the daf. On Lag B'Omer, and Yisrael Goldstein, he called up. He asked me if I could mention every single time that I say R'Shimon bar Yochai, stop and say Zaro shel Kayama for his two daughters. He gave me the names, and I said it in shiur. Look back on Lag B'Omer 4 years ago. Stopped the shiur, and he actually played a little music. by Yochai. Zaro shel And then on the fourth one I said the voice let's do this with kavana. Let's have kavana. And wouldn't be interesting if his daughters gave birth nine months later. Sure enough four four nine months later came and went and no phone call. So no nice nigla. Givaldig. Erev Lag B'Omer. Can't make this stuff up. Erev Lag B'Omer. Phone call from Yisroel Goldstein. My daughter gave birth today. Exactly a year later on the day. He says I want to tell you something else. It's even better. My other daughter gave birth nine months after Lag B'Omer. I just didn't want to tell you I don't want to mess up the whole thing with my other daughter. >> [laughter] >> This is a picture I I went to visit that I couldn't believe it. So when I was in New York I went to visit that baby. But here's a picture of that kid. Today it's his chalaka. The kid is three years old today. That's Yisroel Goldstein's yeah. Narei ayin. God is the whole story is a ayin. made up. >> [laughter] >> Neither neither. I was wondering the same thing. I was I was a little deflated that they didn't They would start and they would have killed. [snorts] Okay. Vayter. But please don't be mefarsh in the maaseh. Zog to the Gemara. Anybody want to sponsor this Reb Shimon for $10,000? Going once. Going twice. Nobody's a believer here. A bunch of koifrim. Reb Shimon Reb Shimon. Huh? >> [laughter] >> Mumele Lag B'Omer. Mumele MDY. Mumele Eli. Doesn't believe in the maaseh. If you believe YOU JUMP UP. YES. 10,000 20,000. God is there's a guy on the screen over there. Scream yeah please. Too late. It's too late. We're saying it. Reb Shimon Reb Shimon. He said the name Reb Shimon. The what? Only Hashomayim the ossur. If somebody is willing willing. If somebody you tell him what are you doing? You're eating chelev. He goes oy vey. Are you serious? That's the guy that could bring a korban. Not a mumar. A guy that says I know that it's ossur but I don't care. A guy that says I know it's ossur and I don't care. Tomorrow he can't bring a korban. Hashomayim the ossur maybe korban. Ossur If he would known he would have taken it back. That's the person who would bring a korban. Any shomayim the ossur. But if he doesn't take it back any maybe korban. Ossur But maybe not. But according to everybody according to both of them a mumar cannot bring a korban. Let's just let's finish this and then I'll do the sponsor. Says in the posuk look at this. In the same in the same word after word. The whole dam lo yishonim chelev. Same line. So the chaitz almost the same maaseh. Person who doesn't care about chelev always eats chelev. But blood he doesn't drink. And he drank blood by mistake. That's the nafka mina. If you hold that had he known like Reb Shimon had he known he wouldn't have done it. So he's over here also. Had he known it was blood he wouldn't have done it. That was that video we did a long time ago. This is like one of the first videos that did. Anyway he he doesn't drink dam. Eli. And that's Mendy's favorite. Foilin foilin. Oh. So the voice is not to this is a typical this is a classic Gemara. So we just said and and what just happened? It's we're in a kasha in the Torah. What are we doing over here? It's a kasha. We're going to have a kasha. Why does the Gemara say before that we learn mumar not from the word mikem. We have another posuk. We have another source. Mamar is the first two words on the samach. Gives us another source. So what's going on? We have two sources that say the same thing. Says the Gemara no. One source is tell us that he can't bring a chatas and the other one he can't bring a oila. And I need both of them. Yesh me a chatas parah. This guy is not he's not ready for kapara. He's a bad guy. He should he shouldn't be able to bring a kapara. Aval oila. But I would have a have a minah. The Torah and who it's a gift of Hashomayim. We should we should accept it. Why be mean to him? Yesh me an oila chiyuvo. You don't have to So you don't have to bring it. Don't bring it. I don't want your your zevach. You're a rasha. It's a teiva. It's a It's a abomination. Aval chatas the chiyuvo. But a chatas the chiyuvo ain't kabul minay. Why should why should I have a minah you should take it? Because Mendy always says What does he say Mendy? What does Mendy say? Let's hear Mendy. Ah shlay chait niscar. There was a guy guy didn't have a very He said you know what? You don't have to pay $500. You're such a bad guy even $500 you don't have to pay. That's not right. If a koifer he should pay a thousand. Now you shouldn't get out of it. The koifer Mendy shlicha. Reb boys I'm turning over the daf. It's by a daf global specialists in international financial services. Chaim Miller red. Full shlayma emuna merosi fraleto maskano basoich shaar cholei Yisroel. What's this picture over here? Ooh. This is 2020. Really? And he swore he was here with us today sitting. Wow. That's mamesh a He hasn't sat in this table in in in ever in ever. This is the first [laughter] time he's sitting. Are you sitting here You knew it was going to be in there? Wow. This is very cool. Who's the guy on the left? I don't recognize him. I said Joey Levy is on the right. Oh Joey Levy is Uncle Joey. Goes Uncle Joey. Joey Levy miss you. Okay. Givaldig. He's not coming with us to Morocco? >> [snorts] >> But Marrakesh is coming. We're going to get to see beheimah. Reb boys we're going at we're doing a gata. We're going to get to see beheimah you'll see. What every time that a person [clears throat] acts like a beheimah the Gemara says you're like a beheimah. A person like a beheimah. So the word beheimah refers to derogatory thing. K'siv. Odom u'beheimah Referring to another maaseh. Odom u'beheimah tishah sham. Vomar Reb Yona Reb Odom bnei odom she marumin b'daas. Referring to great people that are very very clever. They're very smart. They have tremendous kishron. U'masimi nafshom k'beheimah. We have people like that in our kollel. I'm not kidding. Going to oilam. Like geniuses. Wipe the floor with anybody in this room in kishron. And you'll never know about them. They will work they're humble sh'ba humble. A few of them. Most of them I think. We don't know. We don't have any bad guy here. But I'm saying the You see this guy? He'll talk to you regular. Looks like just a average You walk in the kollel you'll never know that this guy like contains in his brain a hundred times more than a regular human being. What? A rishum chabura okay. U'masimi nafshom k'beheimah. Nevertheless they have a tremendous anava. Hoshim k'siv. Says the Gemara okay over there k'siv odom u'beheimah. It says odom next to beheimah. So it's referring to a great person. Hacha beheimah l'chudo k'siv. When it says animal itself is referring to a person that acts like an animal. >> [clears throat] >> What? That's what he's saying. He says a rishum He says a rishum chabura is at the chabura but he doesn't act like an ari. Doesn't act like a He acts like a beheimah. No he acts like a beheimah like a beheimah. Okay we we have to understand shatz and what he said. Says the Gemara odom u'beheimah. Why you say what every time they say together it's a good thing. B'zera Yisroel zera odom u'zera beheimah. So Rashi over here explains U'makriv l'sachseida l'korban l'shana. These are bad These are people not that very good. Am ha'aretz. Never learned never read. They don't learn Chumash. They don't learn Mishnayos. He didn't even Okay so you don't want to So at least be a macher. Go with talmidei chachomim. No zera odom u'zera beheimah. All the people that don't have children. >> [clears throat] >> So the Gemara says over there so it's a bad thing. Hoshim hacha ki kra. But it doesn't say odom u'beheimah together. There's a word in between. It says u'zera beheimah. Zera odom l'chud. U'zera beheimah l'chud. What do we do? We stop over here. Uh okay. Reb boys I have a wonderful day and a givaldig Lag B'Omer. Thank you for coming. Yashar koach. Merit this chos of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shiur today. mdy sponsor.com or sponsor.mdydaff.com.