Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 45 by R' Eli Stefansky
4 views
Thanks for learning with us! -- - Good Morning - Emails - MDYsponsor.com - 44B - 45A - 45B - Have A Wonderful Day! -- Take the Quiz: Kahoot.MDYdaf.com Support the Shiur: MDYsponsor.com Where to Watch & Listen Find us on your favorite platform: https://mdydaf.com/learn#platforms US: 605-562-0066 Israel: 055-DAF-YOMI (055-323-9664) UK: 03-333-661-463 Belgium: 0480-201-272 #DafYomi #EliStefansky #Chullin #MDY
Chapters
Featuring:Daf Yomi
Categories:Torah/Gemara
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Good morning.
Chavez at the Baltimore satellite
location. Look at this. Over 10 people.
It's unbelievable.
Baltimore.
>> The the Zidland boys also making an
appearance in Vegas.
>> [snorts]
>> I don't want to know. Knicks versus
daffi. The daff wins.
>> Stand island satellite. Is that a Rams?
I don't know.
>> I don't want to ruin it for the
>> He doesn't care about the Knicks.
>> Staten Island. Check this out.
Valde doesn't care.
This is a very confusing email.
The guy tried to translate it for me
line by line. It's my first time
learning the DAFF every day. I reached
over 40 days in a row since I was
introduced to by Boro [snorts] uh before
a decade or something like that. I
learned the daff some days, never on a
daily basis. I re I never really
connected the English here. So the
started stepped up to learn the daff
more often but not steady. Then right
before I saw the clips a good friend of
mine, the legendary tour guide.
I just jumped in my bike. It's one week
from now. Ah, you're gonna miss me. I
know you're gonna miss me. Going to be
gone for a long time. The whole thing
was u off going for two weeks. I just
bumped in. I have karat. I just jumped
in the deep end and didn't wait to start
the beginning [clears throat] of I
started the day toward the end of the
kids. We got 40 days straight. That's
the saw he got 40 days straight and
where this is the second person in two
days that told me he started doing the d
because of liwoods and the guy's
statuses he does statuses wherever for
every waterfall every place he is he
does a status I reached to over okay
this one is in Hebrew I'm going to have
to try to translate it's already it's 5
in the morning I didn't go to sleep yet
because I'm trying to figure out the
last 10 years of my life
um
I just found a little notebook which I
wrote down that I I sat down when my
wife was in uh recovery after she gave
birth for a son. Bris was on a Friday of
Shabas Zar and then was Purim. First
time I heard about you was the 28th of
the month. I don't remember what year
but it was basically
and I learned it wasn't it wasn't
but from he wrote this down
I'm with you every single day. I started
learning through YouTube zoom in Hebrew.
Now he asked that I shouldn't say his
name because his brother-in-law is do
the shir.
Um,
most of it I learned in English because
I wanted to to brush up on my English
which I that's is fatim I'll call upon
him. Um,
now during kim I started learning in
Hebrew. Two days ago I started learning
with somebody on Zoom.
Why is he so excited?
I learned with you nine and a half mas
and before I knew you I learned 11 mas.
So anyways
I don't know but kids this guy's up
middle of the night I don't know what
this is. He's up 5:00 in the morning
doing then he finished n give valdic
now.
>> O how do you how do you get this to go?
>> Huh?
>> Put in a picture.
>> Oh it's a picture not a video. I thought
it's a video. is the guy doing the
physical.
>> No, this is the kid. He does say join
MDY and he got two people to join.
Yesterday I read the the second uh row
from the from the left because uh the
second column because nonfix was in
there because nonfix is here. So I'm
going to write read the one on the left.
Michael Chessel Mo Brown Amu ra all amu
are sold out. Oh it's not I feel bad.
245 people now people I don't know what
they're going to do for 720 bucks. What
else can you get for 720?
>> Oh, you can do share.
>> I'll share.
>> You'll share. I'll share my own.
>> I'll share.
>> But you don't have an omelette to share.
>> No.
>> What? Which um is it?
>> Tell me a number.
>> That's the whole point.
>> Par.
It's my para.
>> What is it?
>> In between. [laughter]
>> Okay.
>> You got a mim and he's got the bam. The
white
>> Misha Brown
Hindi Weinberger Mosha Mosha Kinsburi
Mosa clear
no fixitz
fiber pine liitz I said your son before
you
>> yes but it doesn't go in any order I
don't know what's going on there's fiber
pine liitz rafall and ra katan ruven and
gy epste Ronald Kagan Razen Jaffy Sam I
idler Sam Kleiner
Sam Kleiner Sarin Navi Sherman I I I
recognize a lot of these names Sarah
Rifka Vaselblau Vaselbu Sham Cohen Sham
so shim
tesler all these people and are all
going to be embroidered on the manter
hashem you see the last name on The
second column Zev belski from cheers
cheerarket.com I don't even know if he's
part of the shar he does sh
be part of every what
>> that does the shar
>> he when he comes he sits over here but I
don't think he's part I don't think he
does the shar like no no
>> he's part of the shear yeah he's part of
the shar he doesn't do the shar he's
part of the shar he has no he has a he
has a live shar that he goes to sponsor
the magnet to read all the names on the
mant
You worried? You getting worried?
>> Who cares? As long as it's there.
>> Oh, here it is. Somebody wrote it in
English for me. Very good. Now that
after I read it, it's all in English.
The official edition
and Mary
to remind that Elan and Mary they bought
the name of the for $100,000
Moses for the merit of my daughter
Miriam Basra to find
look him up
>> if his daughter is anything like
David Salman, dedicated memory of
the home, the one and only corporate
sponsor.
The policy family foundation gratitude
to consortium and the alliance and all
they do to support MDY. Anonymous.
Thank you to Chief Benny
for
our children doain. Amen. Anonymous for
complete reforman.
These are all sponsors. Danielle
Rosenfeld
monthly sponsors
anonymous
is sharing my
just committed.
>> Wow. [laughter]
>> There you go.
>> Gishmak.
Anybody want to share?
>> Wow.
>> The Spanish sponsors.
>> No, we should really know. I'm seriously
give every single person an om. Tell
them what it is. Each person should get
their um and then decide if they want to
share or not. Like this.
>> What does that mean by
a para?
>> Did you buy anything yet?
>> Yes.
>> What?
>> What word?
>> Word. So what word? Let's say Israel.
You bought the word Israel. So let's say
somebody else his name is Israel and he
wants to share your word. Do you let him
buy that word with you?
>> Does he pay the same amount?
>> Same amount. Same amount. Same amount.
>> No, he's not going to get a deal now.
Once you're in, you're in. The other guy
pays even more. Sometimes we had a guy
seriously a guy. It happened. The guy
paid for a parish. The other guy paid
even more than for the parach.
>> The It has to be minimum as the
original.
>> The Spanish year. This is a weekly
sponsor. The Spanish responses in honor
of the first three brim in the Mexican
satellite location
15 moi 15 and in Greenberg 16 Ruben
Klein in memory of S rata basel on a
yardite [snorts] zan daily sponsors
happy 70th birthday to Dr. Ellie
Weinberger from Montreal from his
children and grandchildren I believe if
I'm not mistaken yesterday also we had a
happy 70th birthday for a woman
>> two in a row maz of Dr. or Ellie
Weinberger.
>> Kobe wants to share his oven.
>> Who?
>> Kobe wants to share
>> Kobe.
>> Yeah.
>> He doesn't know what his oven is yet.
Let's
>> We're going to organize it right now.
Monthly.
You know what? We should do a we should
do a poll. I said that the they should
sell the the claf of every parachute.
Just the claf part. And somebody bought
all the cloth of a whole kish my
official but for some reason Mark
Ashkinazi decided that it's not
something to sell the cloth only the
whole thing not one so if anybody's
interested in buying just one parachute
let Markazi know that he's wrong
or [snorts] you can let him know that
I'm I'm wrong whatever either way
there's a lot of 3600 people 3600ers and
there's not a whole bunch stuff to do
right now. They're looking for stuff.
This is a serious aloo tra. This is like
>> Wow, that is
bigger than here. [laughter]
>> More people in Manis than in the
mothership here in MDY.
Ziggler Levin Dykeman.
Oh,
what is it? This shot is the the pizza.
That's what it is. They start giving
pizza in the morning.
>> Okay.
>> That's what it is. That's what it is.
They come at 1:00 in the morning because
they get a free drink. NO WAY. THEY'RE
GOING TO LEARN to
you came to a great cheer to not this
year. The DAFF is great.
We're starting out with a little of a
and then we're moving on to a lot of
different animal parts. We're going to
learn about them in great detail from
head to toe. Literally
is the like 12 lines from the bottom
maybe more
8 10 12 14 lines from the bottom.
Who is considered
says is a person who No. Isn't that
where we're holding?
>> Yeah.
>> Yes. You hear who's
a person who has that doesn't have to
give money when he loses something. He
does
I recognize this thing. It's mine.
A person sees his own animal and he
looks at he says this is a
instead of trying to bear and coming up
with every type of in the world to eat
it. He says no I'm going to be not going
to eat this. That's
is the Oh,
oh, I just I just got something in
maybe is when he is so good at
distinguishing between a tra and not a
tra by looking at it. So he could rely
on his eyesight on his
for also. Okay.
What does it mean I hate gifts?
He says that this animal is a I'm not
going to eat it.
So he he had a gift. He could have he
could have he could have taken it for
himself. No.
Anybody that learns
understands it well he learns
and he and he looks at his own animal.
He says this is I'm not eating it.
He went ahead and he and he served.
There's a whole there's a constantly
talks about there's something learning
from a book there's something doing
physical
to
I once had this of bringing me we're
bringing uh Weiss we were talking to him
and all of a sudden he says in the
middle he says I got to go be you want
to take me I said yeah do you have a hat
because I wasn't wearing my hat I said
yeah I have a hat in the car so he says
okay great and I went with him and then
he started he told me what to do he says
you got to go like this you got to go
like that you gota make room for me. The
whole Zach like uh I had no clue like he
gave me directions. I went in by
the Ras got him a seat the whole thing.
He didn't tell me like he was mamas
certain things like how to do it. It's
not something you could read about or
just was like on the spot and they told
no you can't take me because no didn't
have his hat with him. [snorts]
In order to be a shamish everybody, you
have to you have to look the look. And
we went into like a real f play, you
know, everybody's wearing hands. You
could come in
got a a faker guy with a
>> Yes. Am I exaggerating here?
>> No.
>> Okay.
By the way, told me that he didn't see
he didn't see the shear yet. To my luck,
this is the shar he's going to watch.
[laughter]
Huh?
>> Different
>> in what?
>> Oh, let's see what over here.
>> Where? Oh, she
says. So, very good. I like that. You're
right. Rashi says it means to learn
Gmorra to to understand how to resolve
contradictions
because talks about mikra mishna.
Thank you. Galdic
>> beautiful
all so forget that whole scratch that
whole thing I hope he doesn't watch this
year what Mars didn't look he says over
a story about me
your the hard work from your physical
hands you're going to eat
what there's a good song for this
you get two worlds
So last night I was [clears throat]
struggling. I remember the story but I
was struggling to get the details and I
said the last word and Benji was here
and Benji helped me out this [snorts]
morning. So I was I was concerned maybe
I said the story too often. It's a very
famous story and I love the story and I
I know I said it. I have a riya that I
said it. I have a ria and I'll tell you
the ria soon. I'll tell you the story
first. I'll tell you the ria. I don't
know when I said it, but I'll give you
the ray that I I said it often. So the
famous story of the rebaran cutler
you're collecting money and a big told
he says you know I support so many so
much I have a tremendous place in he
about a you know back then today it's
the private jet the mansion the whole
thing
looked at him he said very good you have
but what's going to be with
so he says what who are you [snorts]
talking about he says says
sits and he enjoys learning to he sits
you're worried about this deal worried
how you going to pay the mortgage and
how this and how that you don't have
what about
I went on chat GBT
to check out the whole the lotion of the
story now I left my phone in the base me
so usually I chat GPT from my phone I
had to do something new so I go on a new
chat GPT and I do this so it says Yes,
you may have. He says on the bottom,
there are several versions of the story
in circulation. Some are attributed to
if you heard it from a for example from
Ellie Stfansky or another speaker. I can
try I can try to track down the exact
version you're looking for. [laughter]
I'm like I guess I said the story once
before [laughter] that was a little
scary when I saw that.
>> Wow.
>> Mike
dress of iron at a booty convention.
Yeah.
>> Mike for everything you did.
>> See, you changed the story around a
little bit. Okay, good.
>> I wonder try it out from your phone. See
if it works. The same thing if he
>> Who said no? Right. Who said the story
lately of this story?
>> Who said the story? Oh.
When the
also a wealthy person would send him
like a gift, he wouldn't take the gift.
And when they invited him for a meal, he
wouldn't go again.
You don't want me to live? I don't
understand. You're trying to kill me
here.
If you hate gifts, you live. If you take
gifts, it seems like you don't live as
long.
Says
when they sent him a gift, he wouldn't
accept it. A nice
golden bottle of wine, a nice silver cup
to drink from. They wouldn't take it.
That's different. That's for the part
for the I'm taking it.
But when they would invite him, he would
go. Imagine imagine if ate in your
house. Is that a for him or for you? I
mean, who who wins over here? The
galador sits in your house. Your and the
Reb eats in your house. The comes to
visit you and eats a a little shabas by
you. Who who who benefited here? You or
the Reb? You
>> Omar is
>> what? He just said it's
not
with him.
He's not in another thing. He's in I
don't know what what Gemini
they have covered by the fact that is
theirs is not mine.
Okay. So here we go.
We're going back into hands on
if you have
Oh, I have to get my stuff.
Could you take out the knife, please?
I don't know what happened to my Oh,
so we were discussing the trachea the
kana the windpipe.
So we know that if it if it's open ro
more than 50%
it's it's strafe. Now what if it's not
open like this? It has tiny little holes
in it.
Uh like this. Let's say
little tiny holes. These are pictures
from the
so how do you how do you decide if it's
a robe or not? Says the styima you take
all the little holes all the ear and you
you combine them together. you do a a
calculation how much if you put all the
little holes together you don't
>> have holes like that like what's the
>> I don't know what why a worm ate from it
or I don't know now it depends if a worm
ate from it then it would be so the is
going to discuss and the is going to say
at the end it's not it's like somebody
took a needle and poked it but nothing's
missing physically and it weighs the
same it has the same amount of flesh
just punctured in pushed in
>> matzah
>> like a mata a guy took a a matzah thing
over its neck.
It uh I don't know what it was grazing
and a bunch of thorns got it in the in
the ka. So
if you if you also take the the piece of
meat in between the holes, let's assume
we're just looking at the holes
themselves all the holes together. If
it's 51% of the circumference of the
then it's
so I couldn't put the picture in because
I didn't have my phone, but there's a
picture. Maybe the editors will throw it
in there. Oh, somebody put this in for
me. I didn't see this this morning.
Somebody just put it in. Wow. Who put it
in? Maybe Kobe. Who's up now?
>> Mark.
>> What?
>> Kobe's up.
>> Yeah, but Mark doesn't have access to
Kalasha. Mark is up. If it's mish, it
was like literally.
So, this is the gyas we're talking
about. It's interesting. They use the
thing of an animal. So, it says if it
has a long stretch, a cut like that or a
little tiny holes like this. But say you
get the idea. If it has a bunch of holes
that together it's the size of is so it
doesn't give off tuma but it's not a
it's not an animal skull it's a human
skull fine maybe just not now we know a
skull without any other bones creates
tum of now if it's missing a part of the
skull then it doesn't give how much is
it missing
either a long a long uh cut in it
or even it has like a bunch of small
holes
MD. This is a shear called MD like a
oldfashioned drill bit. Whatever the the
shear is, it's on the bottom. Whole
thing 3 mm,
whatever it is. So, if all the holes
together have the shear of a of a drill
bit, then it's not a real skull and it
doesn't give off the tuma like a skull.
But it mentions here a shear of a mah.
Now
get you you put it all together to see
if it's the size of a drill bit.
Over here the shear is here. This is an
isser.
It's a type of a coin.
Put all the holes together and see if it
adds up to this coin. Why are you
telling me? What does have to do here?
This is a says you're asking the
question because you you simply forgot
something.
You forgot what Rav says. What? It
depends. There's a difference.
Check this out. Beautiful picture from
the if you actually remove the flesh. So
then you add up all the little circles
whatever they are and see if they add up
to this is coin
but we're not talking about that
but over here it's just a puncture the
flesh is still there nothing was removed
from then you do arrive
now if we're missing this is just the
other picture of of the you take all the
little pieces that I'm missing. See if
it has a hole that size. So here we have
uh a windpipe that has
a whole stretch of it is missing.
Even though it's let's say square, you
just you take the whole surface area and
see how much is missing. If it's the
size of a of a coin, then it go we do it
together and we say it's the size of a
coin and it's straight. It was kobi. It
was figured
has a bunch of holes like
we just said if they're missing
literally took the flesh out a worm ate
it. So then the shear is the size of a
coin.
This is super interesting.
We're guarding a bird. What's because a
bird this is way too large for a bird.
This whole pipe is is the size of a half
a pencil. How how you going to use this
is
on something this size. You can do is
you have this guy. This is like a real
animal thing. So is makes sense but not
on a bird. She says, "What do you do?
I heard this from
you fold it up and you put it on the
opening of the trachea
if it fits in the opening of the con.
And now I'm going to show you what it is
live. It was interesting. You know some
it happens to me a lot. I guess it
happens to people when I wake up in the
morning. As I wake up I get an idea.
That's what happened to me on Shabas
afternoon. I took a nap. When I woke up,
I said, "I gotta do this. I'm gonna do
this." Imagine you have a bunch of holes
in this trachea right over here. So,
what do you do? Says good morning. And
this is this is the trachea of a bird.
Okay? And ostrich doesn't even have this
size, but this is just
what's your name
>> from.
And you, what's your name?
[snorts]
>> From
close.
>> I don't even know what that is. I don't
get out a lot.
>> Yeah, it's a nice mush.
>> 1059.
Nice.
Check this out.
>> Oh,
>> what you do is
the drill.
>> I see you. I see you backing up. Okay.
So, what you do is you go like this.
Oh.
So, now I took it out. I took I took the
whole the whole part with the holes is
out. Now
I take this.
Oh.
Today I did it better cuz I have this.
This is what I drilled out. This is what
I cut out. And then you take this piece
and you see if it fits in this corner
like this. If it's ro or not.
>> Is this ro? What do you guys say?
>> It's not a ro. No way. Is this a It's
not 51%.
>> Surface area or by radius.
>> Does it fill up? Does it not the radius
surface? Yeah. Does it fill up the
surface? I don't see it filling up. I
took this piece from here. This is where
I had all my little holes. I cut them
out. And now I'm going to see if it
fills up this gap. And that's how I
decide by a bird cuz I don't have a
isser. Great. That's very clear. should
sleep off. [laughter]
So
>> Omar
you
>> I remember just so it's part of part of
the you know oh my cheer this that one
of the hard things one of the hard
things I used to back in the day make a
quick meal go to sleep after the meal
and wake up ma time sometimes I would
you know m who know you know the seven
Now we're gishmach. You know what I'm
talking about.
>> No, no more. No more of that. No more.
[sighs and gasps] Those those are good
days. Maybe they were bad days. They
were bad days. Those were bad days. Bad
days. So let's see inside. Basically,
you cut it out. You fold it over. The
point is
and you put it in the opening of the
trachea.
If it fills up most of this opening,
then it's a
Oh, so here's a I was told I asked Benny
to get me one of these cuz you know
today you can buy for another two shekel
can buy it's already done but people
still use it. One of my neighbors uses
it even though she could afford two
shekel. She said for some things you
have it's much better. But anyways I was
told you're not allowed to wash this. If
you do like it's not it could get all
clumpy. So that's why it's a little
dirty but it's good.
>> Explain what you're talking about.
>> This is a seieve. This is you put the
flour in here and you go like this and
in cuz there's of bugs especially in
people I remember even my wife back in
the day when we got married everybody
was doing this. Today what
>> put a spoon in it.
>> I didn't know about the spoon. Really?
>> Two spoons.
>> That's that's the tricks of Israelis. We
didn't know. We're old American the dumb
Americans. American.
>> So anyways, this is like the see the
what this is the this is like the ka
this is like the trachea and you put
that thing in the opening to remember.
You put it in the opening or other
people can remember the way Stfansky did
with the drill in military. Fine.
>> You can't talk through that.
>> Huh?
>> You can't talk through it. Strain your
voice.
>> Oh.
>> [snorts]
>> You'll enjoy the two weeks. You better
be doing the daff, my friend. I'm going
to fet you when [snorts] we're done.
Says Oh,
I'm not going to do this again. I did it
last night. Let me see if I can find it.
>> No, not this one. This one.
Oh, here
>> check this out. You see it's closed. Oh,
it was really hard. I don't know why it
was hard for me to cut. But if you have
a opening like this in the trachea, but
it closes. It's only cut on three sides.
So, it actually could close a little
bit. So, what's
not like a soda machine that you open
this up or in Chicago? I don't even know
if they still use that word pop. Pop
machine. Not like this way, but flat.
Not this way.
You have to see how much surface area
this takes up. If it's the size of a is,
then it's traved.
What if it has a slit down down the
length of it? Now, the interesting thing
about a slit down the length, if you
think about it,
what's easier for an animal to heal from
a slit like this
or a slit like on the screen down the
length? What's easier to heal?
>> Huh?
>> Not not not straight.
>> So, no, this is harder to heal. Think
about it. Every time the animal bends
its neck down, it pops open. It just
keeps on popping open and closed. So,
it'll never get a chance to heal. But
when it's down the length, every time it
bends down, it's actually closing. It
closes. This the tension closes it up.
So, ma, that's why we're very make with
a long
a cut down the down the length.
So when you read it means a single ring
but Rashi says no over here means
according to the that he prefers it
means three rings. So if you look in our
gam it doesn't even say it just says hya
three rings that's it no notes three
rings why three rings says when you do
we learned you have to do means you go
around three times
that's the that's the basics so the one
means three
over here also means three rings
they said this over
what are you talking about the what is
he talking
Why do you need any rings?
This is we're not concerned about a cut
down the length of the trachea. As long
as a tiny bit at the end, well, both
ends, then we're good. You don't need
rings.
They said over to you know said the same
thing like you
didn't know that in bubble they know how
to learn like that. Wow. Very impressed.
callita.
Imagine a giraffe. The entire neck is
kosher for you allow to do on the whole
neck area of a cow. So this is our cow.
The entire neck
just what's the problem?
Now that is a little problematic.
Let's just remember if this is uh
is the last ring basically and it's
called because it's larger and it goes
around and around circumference. It's
all um cartilage material around and
around. Oh, I even I got a a good
picture here from Vice. Give Vald a
picture. Here it is. You see the
cartilage all in a complete circle. You
can actually see I believe those are the
>> if I'm not if I'm not mistaken. But
anyways, that that's a nice tabas. go
from that area all the way to the to the
lungs. But we're in the lungs. Listen to
this.
How could that be? You go to the bottom
of the lung. So the Gar explains right
away.
No, the bottom which is the upper one.
What does that mean?
So what here? Let's just explain what
he's saying.
This is the lung.
So it means the upper part of the lung.
You could cut that trachea pipe to the
first when you blow it up like a balloon
and it's obviously going to spread
everywhere. So the first lobe up to the
first lobe. So why are you calling it?
The answer is because usually after you
shed an animal, what do you do to it?
>> You hang it upside down.
So when you're looking now the the the
now is the you're from the bottom of the
picture upwards till that this is called
and we're going to do this another time
also it's not like a that [snorts] point
>> what should be
>> yeah but you're looking you're looking
at it afterwards with
>> I understand but you tried to see was it
a good or not you're taking a look
that's what it's called it's not the
first time by animals the animals always
upside down. We're going to see in the
next also when it comes to the
if the guy knows what he's doing, he
wouldn't shaft. He shed it already. Now
I want to check it. It's already it's
already it's up there.
What what does it mean? Normal action
that an animal takes. He constantly
moves its neck up and down, up and down.
So all that part of the neck that goes
up and down while it's alive. That's
it's
don't give it a nice yank and then
normal normal movement. In other words,
don't pull out pipe from its lung and
start shifting down there. Whatever is
within the neck area of a normal motion,
that's what you're
what if itself today in the really pull
that neck very unnaturally. So obviously
they're not going to all the way at the
ends. It's just the the the center part
is there for the but let's say it did it
to itself. It moved its neck in a crazy
B. It was trying to lick something off
its back and it started like pulling its
neck and then the guy goes and he
shuckss it all the way on the you know
got its knife all the way on the bottom
but next to the lungs. Is that okay?
What do we do in all the rash? Keeps on
saying means we got to be you can't eat
from this meat
means we got to wait until Msiah but
right now what do we do? We don't eat.
They came up with
if he forced the
lower down, he forced them out of their
place, so to speak. He pulled them out
more.
What if the trachea got punctured,
lowered down by the let's say closer,
very close to the lung,
then it has like a lung. And what's by
lung? If there's a puncture wound of a
mashu in a lung, then it is tra. So too
in this in this trachea, that part of
the trache is also like a lung and a
mash is
where is moving from thing to thing.
It's unbelievable.
We're talking about aim. You give a
schlamim, you have to give when you
bring a schlamim, you get to eat it, but
you have to first give a gift to the
kite. Now this is not a cheap gift.
realizing now this is a pretty nice gift
that you have to give the k before you
can eat anything. You have to give the
the breast of this animal. What does it
mean?
The one facing the ground
from where to wherever
all the way to the neckla
up until the the car until the stomach.
What does that mean? So here here it is.
Here's the picture. That whole red area
is facing the ground. We're going up is
on the picture to the left. Down is to
the towards the neck. Why is it like
that? I I Yoshi wasn't around. So, we
did it ourselves. Dave did it last
night. I just added the thing. Up is the
left ar is the red arrow. Down is the
blue arrow. In other words, when the
animal's hanging upside down, Yoshi
would have done a lot nicer.
So, now the car is up.
And the neck is down because it's
hanging upside down. Also, let's go back
to the picture. Not get dizzy here.
See you you the blue the blue uh area
over there is the first rib. So, holes
they take one rib from each side from
the right and left. So, that's called
state slice. According to typhus, it's
two on each side. Go two down.
Who sent me a video of showing the
slice? I wanted to put it in today. You
did? Who sent me? Somebody sent me uh
like um Dear Shoe or some organization.
>> Oh, you guys very and he's like this.
You take the he's one two and he's like
showing it. Very nice. The animals
hanging sideways.
Ah, Mark sent it from Yeah, exactly.
That's what it was. Okay. But I don't
know if it's I just remember he said one
rib, two ribs, three ribs. We'll
probably have to use it a different
time.
This is what we give.
Next, it says in the
if you punctured the membrane around the
brain, that's a trad
there are two membranes. Now, the
problem is problem. It's difficult to
even see the membrane around the brain.
Here's a great picture from Kalash.
So you can see on the left, the left,
that's one memory. You see that folded
piece of skin? That's a membrane. This
is the membrane around the brain. Now,
why is it so difficult? Cuz it's clear.
It's like a little plastic bag, a very,
very thin layer of plastic, so to speak.
Grabbing the entire brain, puts it in
its place. So, it's pillar bria how
everything works. that brain central
nerve system that gives it whatever the
whole thing and it's protected by a
little a little bag. If it has one tiny
little puncture in that bag is maybe the
question is which which which bag are we
talking about? The one that's closest to
the skull on the left the folded piece
of skin which is the thicker and it's
very easy to see or the very thin one.
If you punctured right through the skull
into that big that thick piece of skin
that membrane
even though you didn't get to the lower
membrane you are you made this animal
tra
I said uh in the Friday shar to the
Israelis I said I can't believe that
some people say that aloo tra is
difficult so a guy a guest that came
from he say my father-in-law just told
me today that he skipped alphas it's not
for him It's too much like he did but if
you have all these pictures you have all
these it has a name like people say oh
the trade is so difficult I I I don't
once you have all the pictures all the
and there's so many out there that it
started from David so that's you know
that's a little older the cafer but
there's a lot of information there and
it's black and white but then you have
the and you have the you have all these
oh he has here
that's a crazy safer
with all these great color pictures and
they clean it down, you know, they take
all the blood out. They made like this
uh where was that picture of? They made
it so nice. I I I was holding a lei oh
full of blood and everything. It looks
they wash it down, airspray it, you
know, tight
>> sanitiz.
Anyways, I don't see the the problem. I
think it's easier than most.
Wow, Dave.
It looks It looks almost appetizing. You
know what I'm saying? It looks I could
actually look at this for a minute. No,
cuz I I showed the one of me holding it.
It's like you can't even see the You
can't see the tongue or anything. It's
all It's all red.
>> His hands were dirty with
Right. Yeah. Yeah.
>> That's normal. That is normal. We're
going above, you know, beyond normal.
>> This is uh 2026. You could uh Photoshop
a little bit. out of the air. Okay,
great. So, says the
where are we?
No, you need to to puncture the bottom
one in order to make it a tra
this this bag that the brain is in it.
So, that's the bottom. That's the lower
one. That's the thinner one. The one
that's hard to to to discern.
You should know that the Batesim also
have two membranes. Besides the outer
pouch, there's two membranes here.
Here's the outer membrane
and here's the inner one. The inner one
is very it's like almost colorful. So
you can see in a second here's a vice
showing you the difference between the
outer and the inner. The people that eat
this stuff, they're mamish into it,
whatever. So
versus the brain. By the way, I'm just
going back to this to the Bim. The the
the brain is very hard to discern.
That's what the is trying to say. That
has different colors. It's easy. The
brain is very hard to see through. But
in the brain itself,
everything that's inside the skull is a
brain.
But if it's
closer to the body, it's in the in the
spine area that's already like what's
the difference? Brain, what's love
brain? How much do you have to puncture
from the brain in order to make a tra
needle? But the the spine is a you need
51% of the circumference of the spine of
the of the not the spine. We're talking
about the which is the spinal cord
because we don't care so much about the
spine. Spine is not a big deal. People
break uh vertebrae. It's not a big deal.
We're talking about the blue part the
so
where does the brain end the or or let's
call it where does the skull end and the
>> spine begins the spinal cord begins.
I wrote here in my gam that I was in
Poland when I learned this gimmar I
don't know what I have to do I have to
check it out in the buton there's two
pand here beautiful another from kalan
these are two guys right over here at
the entrance to the skull from that
point on is you can even see the there's
a they show you where the spinal cord is
here you see that there's an arrow
spinal cord That's where the spinal cord
begins and that's where is it is this
making anybody queasy
>> cuz Yoshi was all concerned that he said
he's getting a little one guy in the
Hebrew said yeah it's making me queasy.
So he says like this
from those two guys into the skull is
all considered brain
but anything from the other side is
and you need a what about the actual two
guys themselves here these what about
that's in between those two things
what's
I I I really don't know says and that's
the it's like the brain you have to be
and say
Oh, I have to do the
sponsor.
Turning of the Dad Global Specialist in
International Financial Services
actually found in a chicken that also
has these coming out of its brain.
there right there by the entrance to the
skull.
It says if the heart was punctured all
the way to the chamber inside
check this picture out from from vice.
Unbelievable. He was supposed to come.
I'm I'm I was touched that all these
people want to drive in from England
from here. I hope I hope to see them. I
call upon him. There's two chambers.
This is He took a heart, chopped it in
half. I hope you're not queasy. This is
a larger chamber. This a smaller
chamber. Which chamber gets punctured?
Says
looks appetizing.
What's the question
in our Mishna? It talks about a heart
and it talks about lungs. Guess what?
Look at this. Ah, what a beautiful
picture. This is the lungs. There's a
there's the main
kana that goes into the lungs. Then it
branches off. Dr. What are those
branches called?
Bronai
>> Bronai Galdi Bronai. I'm going to need
you because I remember you helped me out
seven and a half years ago on this daf
>> when it when it came to the
>> uh the vinova or something like that.
>> How do you pronounce it?
>> The superior and inferior vennea.
>> Vina. Yeah. Okay. So, we're going to get
there in a second. Exactly. Those are
the words you use then. also [snorts]
says
like like fence
maybe I don't know
says
no I'm serious if you're learning this
and you're 100 years ago something
what's going on here I don't know what
you're talking about but now we
understand there's the giant main pipe
that brings in oxygen into the lungs.
Then you have all these almost looks
like a root system over here. Those are
the smaller ones. No, what I'm looking
for is a puncture in the main one. So
the wants to understand that just like
in the same since they're both brought
in the same Mishna. And when it comes to
the lung, we're talking about the main
pipe. So when it comes to the heart,
we're talking about the main chamber,
not a a side chamber, not the smaller
chamber. Says, "What's the
what's the connection?
It says in plural
the the the pipe that all pipes lead to
this. That's only one pipe. But
it says it in in singular.
It says into to the cavity, not a
chamber. Cavity.
What difference does it make? What
cavity? Cavity is a cavity. It doesn't
matter if it's on the right or the left,
small, large. If you puncture into a
cavity, you made a tra.
So the artery coming out of the heart
something like this.
A small little puncture wound in there
makes a puzzle says you need most of the
circumference. What is this?
This is the fat that's on the walls.
Says I don't understand. How could you
puncture fat in a wall? Who cares about
the fat? Why would that make it an
animal tra? So says, "No, no, no. You
didn't understand."
If you look closely on this picture, you
can see fat all the way around the the
trachea as it enters the
the the lung. Yeah. All this is fat. So
what it means is the pipe that has that
fat on it that if you have a little
puncture that's that's
three pipes.
Rashi says something interesting and
everybody struggles to understand what
Rashi is saying. They're saying you know
that's not the mitsus. He says there are
three pipes that come out of the heart
or I'm sorry from the trachea. Three
pipes that come out from the from the
trachea. one he says
one goes to the heart, one goes to the
lung and one goes to the liver. So they
say no what Rashi meant to say is
there's three major arteries
one is the aorta how do you pronounce it
>> aorta
>> aorta and the vina ca whatever it's
called the hulu
pulmonary artery there's three major
arteries one goes through the one really
goes through the the liver one goes to
the the heart and one goes through the
lungs
so what's what's an why do we have to
know this
he says da the one any pipe that goes
any pipe this pipe that goes through the
lung we have to treat it like a lung
just like a lung a small puncture wound
makes it a mashu makes a tra so so when
you look at the the pipe also a mashu
makes a trad but we know what makes a a
liver trae when you remove the entire
thing if you anything remains of the
liver
it regenerates so it doesn't make a tra
so too whatever that pipe is that's
going through the liver. You have to
remove the whole thing in order to make
it trick the cal or the c. Huh?
>> It's not just removing the liver. It's
removing the pipe also.
>> I'm talking about the pipe. I'm not even
talking about the liver.
>> I'm saying in order to if it's
considered like the liver, you don't
have to remove
>> I don't I don't think I don't know. I
don't think it has I don't think that
that's true. He's saying it's it's
[clears throat] a pipe that's like a
liver. It's not the liver. That's what I
think. I might be wrong.
But when it comes to the heart is
ra is going to say
the opposite.
He mixes us up a little bit. The lung is
like the liver and you have to get rid
of the whole thing in order to make it
but the liver is like the lung.
is strafe
then I'll I'll give you that in the
heart says
so he said over what holds in in the
heart that even a mash makes a
if that's what he said he doesn't know
anything about now it's interesting to
point out that the Sanhedrin says that
Rav wanted to know what a is what
[snorts] he parked himself self in a
barn for 18 months.
You can learn a lot from this. He put
him he went into a barn, lived in a barn
for eight not a day. Some of us would do
it for 10 15 minutes max. He got a bed,
got himself some food and a gumar and a
lamp and lived in a barn 18 months to
understand what a what a mum is, what
not a mum is just to be the mum. And he
says if you think that that's a tra, you
don't know anything about traas. I'm
just saying there's not a person that
stam it was all his whole life in
doesn't know what treas
I think we do
>> a doctor
>> right exactly
>> was a doctor okay yeah
let's keep on going we have four minutes
so now we're going back to the spinal
cord which transes all the nerve system
in the body it's a very important piece
of equipment
It's very deathable if you
you have to cut a majority of it.
I'm not a doctor. If I had a guess, if
you ask me, I would say a puncture, a
little puncture in a spinal cord.
Bye-bye. No more walking. I don't know
what he says. No,
>> that's what a lumbar puncture is.
>> Who? What?
>> They do a lumbar puncture to check
someone. make a hole in the spinal
>> through the nerve system.
>> I don't know. I don't know. I wouldn't
want you to be my doctor.
And they said that love that even
says
it's not true. You could puncture like
says it has to be arrived.
But how what's arrived? There's two ways
to look at it. the circumference the the
skin that holds everything in place or
the inside nerve system rather
I write here menitis I have no idea
where's Dr.
Lumbar puncture is a sack.
Is it the inside the nerve tissue inside
or it's the outside?
Because the inside seems like could
heal. The outside once it that that's
cut then the animal is a bye-bye. It's a
goner.
But if it's if you say that the outside
skin most of the outside skin was
ruptured
what what about the inside if you messed
up the inside
and I look
>> I looked this up it's the only time in
that he's brought down
but I looked up
I said is brought down only now this guy
sitting here he says no it's also
what
he says this older fellow over here it's
not the first time he throws out he
knows I don't know. And we looked it up.
It wasn't me. Gimmel. She said, "No,
you're wrong." Twice. And Gimmel. He sat
right in your seat. What's his name?
>> Vice.
>> He knows his stuff. I don't know.
>> Vice.
>> Yeah. Everybody knows him. Vice. Okay,
good. I guess I I apparently do knows
him.
>> Uh, so we have to ask Vice if uh if
Niveli is the only time. And I did look
it up. I looked in uh in Barry Lad. And
it wasn't it wasn't there. It says but
maybe saying maybe it was written with
two toughs and one top. I don't know.
Fine.
Means the outside skin.
I couldn't care less about the nerve
system inside. That doesn't bother me.
Doesn't make it.
He sat in front of the rav.
He checked the outside. Then he checked
the inside.
If there's skin on the outside, it's not
punctured.
I don't care about the inside.
If the nerve system becomes liqufied,
it's that's a possle and also if it
became soft
what does it mean?
We have pictures over here
give you an appetite.
This is liqufied.
Check this out. Great picture. This guy
is holding a spinal cord straight. But
if it if it's soft, it's going to flop
over. That is
what if it can't stand on its own
because it's heavy, not because it's
damaged.
And one more line over here. Maybe more.
What do we have? Oh, we have 30 seconds.
Not good.
Now we're using a new lotion with a
Zionism
means that it emptied out on its own.
Some of the some of the nerve system
emptinal
cord became
says you you learned it wrong in this
masmas. If it's if it if it lost a
little bit then it's kosher. If it
became uh uh
means that it can't stand it became soft
then that's any
story in a video. Listen to this was
sitting in
the guy slipped on the water banged his
head right into the wall.
this guy's brain just lost a little bit
of his brain. So says doesn't mean he
said used and it seems like that he's
not going to live. Why else would he say
this? He's like this guy's not going to
live.
This this guy is not going to be able to
have children anymore. Why? Cuz he got a
bang in his brain.
>> Where we stopped seven years ago.
>> What do you mean? Where we stopped?
>> He finished for the day.
>> Really? You haven't But we didn't have
we didn't have a video.
>> Check this out. Listen,
they want to slaughter me tomorrow for a
barbecue. I am not letting this happen.
We made a promise to each other when we
met that we'd build a family, have a
son, and maybe he'll merit to be a
corbon in the base of Mikdosh that
should be rebuilt Bimho via Manu.
>> A man? But what are we going to do?
>> I have a plan.
What did you do? Are you okay?
>> Excellent. I'm a trafo. I won't be
kosher for them anymore. We can stay
together and build a family.
>> You butt loin. Stop sleep on
Dafyomisher. The muskina of the Gora is
that if neat Mosmma's hamoyak, he is not
a trafo. No.
>> What a gone. Now you're an anomal lead.
[panting]
>> Have a wonderful day.
>> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout
the world. Sponsor Ashir today.
mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.