Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 44 by R' Eli Stefansky

D [chanting] [singing] [chanting] [singing] [chanting] where we >> [singing] >> He died [singing] D. [chanting] [singing] N [singing] I know. It's a late shave. It's one of the latest like maybe it gets one minute later. very difficult because especially a night like tonight, I had maybe 30 different pictures I wanted to do and only like 45 minutes. It's uh it's a problem. But I see that the it's late for the nobody slept enough and Oh, you guys made it from Shalim. Oh, he made it all the way from Shalim. Where are the people from Jamish? Got like two empty tables here. It's crazy, >> huh? I'm going to read the second line. Remind me to read the first line tomorrow morning because I see no fix his name. So I want to read it while he's here. Formai all the ammud sold out. 245 amoud sold out at 720 each. Maybe people are going to want to do. Wow. idler, Steve Middleman, Steven Bax, Steven Sichel, Tvia Eisman, Eisenman, Warren Kimmel, Yankee Liowitz, Yeshua Abraham, everybody. Yehudo, Danos, How do you You could help me pronounce it over here. >> Not that Danos. That's how you pronounce Rothbitz Klein. Yity and Tami Loey Yity Freriedman Yitsy Hollander >> that I know >> Y and Hindi Jacobs Yanon Adler Yoni ah >> I don't see Yan Yan Adler Yonyi Pollock Yseph Machani [clears throat] Maz Yseph Morai networks are changing >> Greenberg is Is that Yos Mortai Greenber? That's two different names. Yoseseph Mosha Lafler Yosi Shakar Yuri Freriedman Zman Kravitz Zev Belski. Oh hello Zev chermarketer.com. All right. So tomorrow hopefully they don't change it around. Uh somebody sent me this picture. I actually found this picture in my between my pictures. This is the the line I was talking about in the airport in Africa. See the size of his claws of his hand. Dear belly, we're learning about in school with Rabbi Pik at CTM Philadelphia. He drives in from Lakewood and listens to the shear on the way. We're learning the s of how long you need to announce the lost accudes about it and Titus and Bitsia before AI existed. Arabi said that our whole class should write you a thank you. So you will at least read one of them [laughter] from Morty Schwarz and Eshkanazi. Okay, I read one. You have a great rebi who watches the right shear is not embarrassed to tell you about it. Yeshua Goldman see picture of a local shear in Stanford Hill London base medish with mag or as we call him MDM. Without the pictures, these lectures wouldn't survive. That's what he says. I don't know if that's true, but okay. There's a lot of pictures. Many things. Keep it up. MDM David Mutin. MDM. MDY MDM. Shalom. My name is Rabbi Yon Yeshua and I'm in the incoming Yeshiva. I'm reach out because I'm deeply impressed by MDY's ability to bring clarity and tutorial learning. Your high quality visual tools, illustrations, and diagrams are exceptional at helping learners follow the suga. We're more serious about the learning and benefit from more structure and support approach. We believe underwise visual approach could have meaningful impact on our which is the key component of our broader mahal immersive t study with MDY consider small pilot collaboration with us. So we're requesting permission to use select charge. Yes, we allow all yeshivas to use our stuff as long as they give us credit for it. We're here to spread to so we don't take money for it. And yes, you could use it such as the hand shure. Here I just showed a video uh MDM uses our stuff. We ensure clear attribute attribution following follow all your guidance and limit the scope to whatever feels appropriate. We also welcome show if you're open to discussing the possibility grateful photosho's name Mary in celebration of our children's wedding may be to build a neon that already happened. I'm assuming David Solomon dedicated memory of the sponsored by the family foundation gratitude consort to the consortium and alliance and all they do to support MDY anonymous. Thank you to Chief Benny for continued and from our children. Anonymous for complete reforester monthly sponsor for Benlav the Spanish sponsors in honor of the first three in the Mexican satellite location and enon greenberg 15 and 16 years old Ruben Klein in memory of Saratasbaba Peril on your side and chim Leafman in honor of our 1,800th DA. Thank you Rebellion and all the MDY staff for giving us life. Paris Levin and Shim Leafman both tremendous pillars of our sheer maz. It's incredible. Zev Sandman for the immediate refor of my father Yosephi Beno Rafing Dobby Glansstein for the merit and complete refor Simon happy birthday Tati may zo to complete many more cycles of a anonymous for the special occasion of Ruth Burman's 70th birthday mazto kids sponsor monthly What happened? Any any news with him? He's in the hospital. They canled the the Friday with him. Benlet Esther Rabo. Here we go. So again, it was tonight. tonight put this together in seconds. So according to Rav and with the what is it called? This is the vash. This is the eating tube. The very end of it, the one closest to the mouth is the turbat. when you puncture it. Now, this whole entire tube, when you put a little tiny needle hole in it, it's a goner. It's a tra. But what about the all the way on the top closest to the tongue? So, says even a needle, it's like the rest. And says, "No, you need to cut 51% of the circumference." Rav says, "We understand now." Rav says, "M, why?" Because the very top part by the tongue is a mimita and says it's not a mimita. Since it's not a mimita, it's nothing. It has nothing to do with the veset. It's not a vet. It's not an esophagus. What is it? It's another part of the animal, another part of the animal, you need more damage. If it's the esophagus, it's the eating tube. Even a small amount says, but it's not it's not the it's not the esophagus, it's not the eating tube. Raph says even so we're going to see a little bit now says the Gmorra story. We are going to have a little bit of a today. But here's an axe. That's the end of the story. Oh, so for that I must pull out my trusted knife. This is a small one. We got to start using the larger one. If you ever notice, he's not here, so I could talk about it. But when I pull this knife out, Nakzer takes like three steps back and picks up, he goes into he pulls his gumar above his face. It's like as if that's going to help him from this knife. If it slips, it slips. You know what I'm saying? [laughter] >> I don't care. Yeah. >> How many hours? >> A week. That's it. >> A week and a day. >> That's it. You're done. You're done. You don't have cravings anymore. They get they went it's it's easier. >> MSH was nicer. >> It's nicer. You're starting to breathe like a mench. You can cancel that CT scan. You took it already. >> Yeah. >> Okay. We'll talk about it later. >> They started the all the way over here by the and then he went inwards. They started cutting cutting and they they cut into the actual. So what's that? >> [snorts] >> Now, if we take a look at this chart, according to Rav, if you nick it a little bit, the which he just did cuz he cut it. That's more than a little bit. It's it's a problem. It's tra, [snorts] but it's not a problem because it's this is where you so it's a problem. So, you start cutting cutting cutting. He started at the right place and he ended at the right place. So according to it's not a problem according to that the t is not really a place to so he started a little tiny bit gave a little nick he forgot about that he started cutting downwards and he did a great also not a problem why it's only a problem when when you cut a when he cut he didn't do arrive he cut a little tiny bit so according to both of them it should be great the shockingly says it's not Good. Why? Take a look at the chart for a second. This is ma stuff. I'm going to take a little bit of rav and a little bit of I'm going to mix it all together. I'm going to come out with a with a with a trafe that what he chefed a little tiny bit of the a tiny bit is only a problem if it's the makita. So I'm going to go and use and say it's not the and he did a little tiny bit and not of oops if you say that was a concern by so go be consistent and say who says is a problem ra and rav says it's a good place of and I'm doing I'm in the middle of killing this animal. So I started I finished. It's all it's a great no no. I'm gonna go like but says that you need a R. You need to cut 51%. And he didn't cut 51%. You could cut 1%. So I'm not using I'm going to use Rav's but I'm going to use that says that the is not part of the and I'm going to use Raven and says but if you do a little tiny bit it's possible strange I'm going to go with says but it's a problem if you're going to go with be consistent says and it's great. You could start a over there. No, no, no, no, no. Then I'm going to go to I'm going to move over to the left lane and say it's not but if you say it's be consistent says he need a he didn't do a he only cut a little bit of the tubers for that. I'm going to go very very serious and obviously just like we don't understand it in that generation they didn't understand it this thing rolled around it came to if you take all the way it's 100% good because he did a little he didn't do you're right it's not he didn't do so this this animal's kosh prayed. He didn't want to call him by his first name. He was too scared. They called him the son of which means who's the son of the famous Raa. Tell him he must pay because he said such a silly he has to pay for it. Says Rashi the only way a RV has to pay for it is if he caused the damage with his own hands. If he pasined and they you went ahead and listened to him, you don't have to pay. So it must be that Ra took this animal. He saw that the the fetching they're saying what do you either decide? No. So he took the animal and gave it to the dogs. Give it to the dogs. They have to pay for it. I have a big question to the enemies of Rava. Again, he was scared to say Rava's name. Why? He's about to embarrass Rava. He's about to call him a fool. Now you don't call Ra a fool. So you call instead of saying Ra, you say the enemies of Ra are fools. Guess what? After all this, Ra was right. Just letting you know he was right. I did notice I don't know if I'm right. I asked my he didn't argue with me. He said many times you see the Rava made mistakes in shas more than other people. Mistakes he regretted it. He took it back. He says, "Uh, I forgot the L." And like I I made a mistake, you know. So it seems like he made a mistake. So he say he told me, "Oh, cuz Rob is mentioned so much. He said so many things." Okay. You got to say a lot. When you say stuff in public, you're going to a certain percentage is going to be a problem. You don't see it so much with other whatever. Okay. >> Good batting average. He has a lot of time. So high percent. >> Yeah, that's what he said. But I don't I don't know if that's we have to ask fencer. We'll see what happens. It goes it says in the price like this is always however if you want to do like you're okay whatever you want to do you can do. I think is going to ask it's contradiction. You tell me that looks like then you tell me you could do like bishame. Now listen to this shame Russia if you just pick all the kulas. I told the guy I had an argument with somebody I'm very close to. I said I don't understand every time he has a cool there's no when it comes to electric stuff electric cars this. It's only electric that has a cool about this a cool that. I said, "Yeah, but the my rebi told me this and he said it's okay." He said, "I never heard you once saying your it's always a cool once in a while you had a good okay fine. You mix it in once in a while. Every time I speak to you, you have another cool and another Hey, you take the You're Russia. If you're such a big the knife, you don't want it there. We might need it still. Let's put it over here. Fine. >> It's making you nervous. Also, another guy. >> If you're like sh always and a big mad like the fool goes in the dark. There's a guy a big big wasn't working much. Saying a lot of tumm all day. His wife said, "We're going to have pasa." He says, "Listen, light a candle and the dude le will be okay." Gets a new did you make? No, not today. So, light a candle for the babas. Babali. Every day it's another another gle. One day he comes in and he sees a lot of candles. He says, "Oh, you finally got it. You finally." She says, "No, no, no. They finally turned off the electric here. [laughter] >> [laughter] >> The the fool goes in the dark. But I love this ma. This is a mah. It's a inh there's a big argument in the suga. They were going through the going through the suga and uh they finally they came out that you have to you have to pass in the kula. So the guys we got to do it again. So they do it again again and they they comes out the then third time like what are we gonna do? So one guy gives a clap on the beam and says listen this is a [laughter] no those who know Either you go, you have to be consistent. Either go with all the way or you go like all the way. So, it's not as simple as it sounds like. I'm not crazy about this chart that we did on Friday. I added a couple of things tonight in a rush. But Raji points out, it goes like this. In a certain area, you can't grab Bishamo. No in in you can grab is and in ha you can grab in hila's tra in hila's spine you can't grab a bish in the same for instance so just to make it easier don't look at bis at all just look at bish we had this when a spine of an animal is missing two vertebrae Then then it's then it's uh then it's a tra meaning what if it's one and a half one and a half vertebrae. It's not a tra. So is that a ka? It's a ka. The animals you're allowed to eat the animal all the way until it's missing two vertebrae. So two is a koola. If you take that same two and use it on a human being's spine. say a spine of a human is is is is mama like like the skull of a human being. If it's in a room just a skull, the whole room is tot everybody in the room is tot. So if you have a vertebrae of a human being it's tame. And if you're missing two then it's not mama. So that's that that's already why cuz up until two it's mama matama. One is matama. One and a half is matama. One and three/4 is mama. That's a tremendous all the way to two. Basil say no you don't need to what so you can't grab and say you know what when it comes to an animal eating an animal I'm going to go like that you need two vertebrae to make a tra one and a half vertebrae is gvaldic so I'm going to use that kula and when it comes to tumas I'm going to go with basil left bottom corner I'm going to say that it's not mama once you have one vertebrae missing that's not fair because the point is two vertebrae makes and doesn't make. So that's what we're saying that you cannot grab a in different things. Okay. Anyway, or or different things. So now we're just going back told me is always like we all know everybody knows every kid knows and you tell me if you feel like going it's okay. There was a basket that came from and said that. So before the basketball you could pick and choose. You could say I want to go like today. Tomorrow you say I want to go. But once the bas came and said that we go like [snorts] even after the bases goes like so the famous story I'll just show it to you real quickly. Here we have the the makus of of the town of it's made out of this this oven was big and passing one way and everything went ribblear's way and even the the carob tree was uprooted the walls of the vish the river went backwards here the river is going backwards They said if that was like realized the wall should cave they caved in everything went his way and finally they said we don't we don't care about walls we don't care about water we don't care the says against so finally basel said heavenly voice comes from says like It's a very sad story because they put him even though everything I mean I can't imagine something like that today that the you hear says the is like him and the walls the all the m go like him no put him can't talk to the person until he died to the day he died crazy story but upon him give him basal we don't go with the basal So since we don't go like a bas who said that was like basil the bas said we don't care we don't care about a basal so you can pick and choose you can pick and choose [clears throat] but the the problem is how in the world does ra do this is not fair this is grabbing a little bit of rav grabbing a little bit of and making uh a mix and coming up with says The entire thing is Rav. You learned it wrong. It's not the that the reason why Raf says that a little bit of a nick at the top of the veh is is a is a problem. Not because it's a because it's not and it's still a problem. That's the here. Don't listen to my brother. I think I think in all of I think he's brought down the most. That's what I once heard. Don't take me don't take it for but it could be that Rav Yehuda is is the most in all of he always brings down from Rav and all. He's brought down the most ins don't listen to him. He made a mistake. This is what raf fact said is they're not dependent until now we were learning that because the you can put a little needle and make it must be it's the like the rest of the no it's not a he agrees ra agrees it's not a and yet it it becomes tra with the mashu and that's why ra said that if you start the up here. Let me get my knife. If you start the up here and you go down, he says that's why because it's not about the and traes it. So that's why that's why it's nothing to do with he didn't jump on twoas. It's one called rav it's a mash and it's not. So now that we have this eating pipe, where can you go until where can you how much says the you grab it like this? So you could only right over here. Oops. [snorts] >> I did on purpose. >> You could check from this down, but not from here on. You got to grab a hand grab. Now the part that's next to the lungs or not the lungs, the stomach, sorry, the stomach. Oh, you take a picture here that Yoshi put together stuff. Really? It's phenomenal. Oh, hold on. I think I could show this one. Let me show this one. I think so. This is okay. Check it. Check it. Check it. [music and singing] [music] telephone. [music] [singing] Okay. So I don't think multib understood a word. It doesn't have the but you you'll explain it to him. But you got it. >> I just heard it says >> and what about no you didn't get it. >> Okay. Ashias here. Check this out. Ashias is very gush um in the animal. Look at this. It has like hairs. Sort of like hairs. These help digest the food. So you do up until where it becomes hairy. All this what are they called? >> Follicles. >> F really follicles. Okay. [snorts] Here's also called a follicle in a way. >> Oh, I don't know what those are called. >> Look at anyways you could do on that that entire pipe the the eating tube the esophagus up until where you see here says it's not true. You get a whole from where you see the hair that way and you can't do there. It's it's it's called the inner and inner car we learned by the way in the Mishna even it makes it the so you can't you can't you can't so when you see that esophagus that goes into the stomach you're not a it's not part of the esophagus it's called the kis it's called a stomach keris means a stomach it's there's four stomachs number one is called the keris number two is called what you guys remember >> number three >> hempis number four >> ka if I'm telling you it's kis then it's not it's not esophagus what am so you have to say notice with the >> the first inside with the follicles with those hairs that first that's the after that what is it called The is how much of a hole do you need? The first from the saf is called one tiny hole that that trapes it up. The rest of it you need like a is talking about a bull. Look at this beautiful picture. How about this? Great. Here. Oh, the right. It's a of the esophagus. And the reason why it's tra is because it's not it it looks like an esophagus, but it actually starts acting like a stomach and it has hair and there. But we talk that's only in a bull, not in a smaller animal. Let's see if I think we have a picture here. We didn't have it on. Oh, here. Right. So you see how the this pipe is connected to the back of the the mouth. Now it's disconnected disconnected over there to the jaw disconnected. It's we in fact learn if the bottom jaw was removed. Even though you see from here even though the bottom look the bottom jaw is disconnected in this picture. What does that mean when it's disconnected? it disconnects with the two pipes. So you see it's okay if they're disconnected. Ask question one of the problems in in in one of the is when when the two sim the trachea and the saf are disconnected it's disconnected. It should be trave the the bottom jaw is removed it's kosher says so no misio when it's completely um disconnected that's straight [snorts] but when the the two pipes are connected to the meat they're connected they're not dislodge. It's the jaw that got disconnected then it's okay. How could he say that if the tubes got disconnected that it's kosher is the end of the esophagus the eating tube and it's disconnected it should have says not the entire thing got disconnected 51% because it has 49% left it's kosher but wait a minute we learned that if even 51% you just told me it's 51% That's why it's but he just said that if are are are like hanging and most of it got got disconnected is one one one like uh marshall comes to mind like sometimes you have a a sticker on a on a product if you rip it off real quickly what's going to happen it leaves a lot of like streaks and stuff if you go really you peel it really nicely and Slowly you get the entire thing off. You have a dish right right before you go. You want to be to in the mikvah. It's it's causing if you if you don't have patience, you go you're going to leave like three little lines and with your nail. It's a whole problem. You right. Oh. Oh. Oh. Here. Let's do this. Exactly. Watch. It's going to go like this. >> Leaves the residue. >> Oh, see I left that a little bit of residue. Look at this. That's what he's saying. Now, when you rip it like that, You need it. Then you do it slowly. Do it slowly. It's different. >> Oh, you when you do it slowly, nicely, nothing will be left there. Awesome. The bug. When you have a little bit left, that's it's so so that's not going to regrow. It's not going to it's not going to heal. It's it's a it's little tiny pieces are not going to heal. Oh, when you have a gargeras, this is the trachea. When it's when it's split a little bit like this, it's tra when you have a tan most of it ram in the art world. This is scary. these two words full page. I'm not sure why. Take a look. Very very Galdica pictures will explain it all. The the the rings are not evenly made. The top part of the ring are very thick. >> They're not symmetric. Good. I like that word. They're not symmetric. Top very thick like you see in this picture. Bottom very thin. So, if you were to measure from the top to the bottom and come up with a a middle point, it's going to be like the right picture, but >> huh. >> Oh, show the Rabbi's picture for a second here. Here's a here's the real thing. And here's a knife going down the middle. The top part is thicker. We exaggerated a little bit. Yeah. Just to make the thing. The top part has a thickness. The bottom is very thin. Okay, now that you see that, basically it's very very simple. Do you measure the donut hole? Do you just measure the hole? That's this the left side. If you're going to measure the hole, 50% of the donut hole, right? If you get the knife gets up to there, but the problem is the donut hole is lowered down. The 50% of the donut hole is really 60% from if you start from the top because the top is very thick. So that's the whole idea. Are we starting from the top and then 51% is going to be the right picture or we start from the donor hole just the the the the the empty part and then you go from there 51%. So for that there's a whole picture in the whole thing in the article I don't know exact maybe there's a whole thing f sponsors turn of the global specialist in international financial services the reason why I'm going fast because you know I don't want to be tired of the um of the Israelis So they had a situation where they found an animal like this. That's how he came. He was he was born like that. He had a problem. So he checked it out to see by the he started measuring from the top. What was going on here? You yourself taught us you start from the just the whole donut. So they sent to know the He checked it out actually from the donut hole and he said this is great. It's kosher and himself. This is a problem. The rabbi himself who gave a to this meat bought meat from that guy. This is a problematic piece of meat. Rav started chucking from the top and it would have came out really bad. Lynx, what are you doing here? You every time you come, give me this. Then you stop coming. And then I have it's like a roller coaster with you from the first first guys of the daff back in the >> in what? >> It's eight years already. >> Eight years. And you you're going to tell me you do it every day. I'm going to fing some of the jokes to see. >> But it's great to see you. >> I think they skip out in the just >> huh? >> I think they skip out in just the >> Ah, you do just I can't f you. I got it. I got it. Nice. Nice. But >> only >> anybody want to say hello? You're you're new here. >> Sort of. You You're new. What's your name? from >> Lakewood. You're in yeshiva here. >> And who's this uh sadic next to you? What's his name? >> He's not. >> Huh? >> Captain. >> Captain Captain. Okay. Who else? Anybody else want to say hello? Okay, fine. >> He's new. >> He's new. What's your name? First of all, what's your name? The guy that said he's new. >> I know. I said with your father. But what about So that that's your brother next to you? >> Yeah. What's his name? >> Everybody's helping their friends and the brothers. It's great. Captain, you're not the only one. >> This is the >> How's you still doing Mick right now? >> I am. >> No, it got easier. >> Uh, it's it's going. It's good. It's >> You do with Uncle Lungal. >> Uncle Louis. Exactly. >> Yeah, >> of course. >> Very good. Mario, we we only have four minutes. We'll smoo later. So listen listen to this. If says this is you know how to go against your friend says tomorrow himself never said it's awesome. He checked it. He started checking his started giving him a hard time. He said go give it to another. He didn't say it's awesome. Ask the the famous I'm not going to go over it again. My father told me to ask is this there's a problem to eat from and my father told me only if he tells you that it's okay. He ask there's a problem to eat it's not to eat meat that said it's okay. So it goes certain won't won't sell that kind of meat. They give it to the other says we had this already. This whole is a freebie. Says Hashem Hashem told him to to to lay on his right side with a brick to to the whole thing for a whole year to to pretend it's the he says he tells everybody I never became. So you have to understand what's the big deal and of course he didn't come to this is a bigger question I'm such a I didn't eat how could he say something like that every every year today could say that even when I was a young kid till today I never ate an who's going to eat so we have to explain like this so is over there explains already I didn't think says I didn't think during the day not to come to carry a night but says a lot of people on his earn it but not everybody was successful like was successful he's never taught me there's a video I'm not going to show because we're we're going to up our our uh level so some videos we won't show there's a very very good video in the second chair I don't know what to do I liked it a lot it was very funny but the last le last word we I have to if they can fix it, I have to find out if they can fix it or not. Otherwise, I'll show it after this. I'll go I didn't need an animal that they said to the right away it's about to die about to die. So that was the then that's why we brought this whole story then it's a problem not a problem. You see that it's a problem but this one I never ate. That's when I said the story then of the chicken I never ate from a piece of meat that ate from that looked at and said that it's okay to eat another is they didn't need from an animal that they didn't give even though he himself was a he was to give miso says okay so the question is how this meat says what's the problem with the problem is that he's relying on his own logic and tomorrow we're going to find out that his logic is flawed. So comes out the eight over here. He wasn't he wasn't he wasn't he wasn't depending on his logic. He was depending on something that he heard from his rebas from generations that you check the animal from from from the inside not from the outside. Okay fine. Ask how is he allowed to eat by the meat from the owner of the animal? People are going to say, you know, you know, he passed that it's kosher because he wanted the meat. If made up, he said, "This guy is is okay. He doesn't have to pay. This guy has to pay. This is Tommy, this also. This is also this." And also witnesses. They're all permitted to to take some to take from the from whatever they spoke about. You should stay away from this disgusting boy. I heard a crazy story on Shab Benny showed me this thing from me. Famous uh speaker Big Bish and he says uh it's a gross story. It's going to gross you all out. A guy in found an unbelievable house. Did he say it was on the water? Like a mansion. Beautiful house. And he knew that the owner was in a little bit of a pickle. So he went and negotiated a crazy deal with the owner. He got the guy to come down 50%. He's super excited. He goes to the RV and the RV explains to him that he can't buy the house. It's not it's not for him. It's probably not for him. It's in the wrong neighbor. The whole thing, don't buy it. Not for you. He's very depressed. But what are you going to do? You have to listen to the rub. See? Month and a half later, he walks by the house. You know, he's telling his wife. He sees the rub walking out of the house. [laughter] So he goes up to the RV. He says, "What are you doing?" He says, "Listen, I I I explained to you the house is not for you, but the house is for me. That's" And he finishes off that the guy went off the DK. Now I know I know my neighbor over here on this block went off to Derek when his RV was caught doing disgusting things. And he's a famous story. He's put in jail. That r famous guy from not going to go into his name, but he went off the DK. You you can't I'm not saying if you're at holding like that that your whole is dependent on one human being and human beings do some crazy stuff sometimes it's >> okay find another r and move on but okay >> huh if you're rebi no sometimes a person says my father did this and this I'm going okay >> how many guys stop learning gamarra because of their r >> what I'm saying >> yeah oh the bame in yeah okay stop learning gamarra is different than going off to Derek. But yeah, 100%. I know one or two of those kind of people. >> Yeah, me too. >> I I mean, let me rephrase. I know one or two people in this year that that didn't happen to them. >> One or two that didn't that didn't happen. >> Okay. I don't know where they are, but they're here. Zamara is perfect. >> Exactly. Exactly. Judism perfect. Jews aren't. >> That's cure. Don't. So don't don't do something silly that people are going to say to you, "Oh, the reason why you said this meat is kosher is because you you you got a great deal in the meat afterwards." That's only something that goes by evaluation, by assessment. Everybody knows the price of the meat. Everybody knows that it's a certain weight. And you pay, how much do you pay for a steak here in Israel per kilo? 250. 250. I said yesterday everybody knows. So the RA is paying for a kilo 250. told nobody he thinks he got a good deal said that this tra they came to they thought it's a tra said no it's not a tre could you could buy from it the daughter of tellsa who's the daughter of boys everybody knows this who's the daughter of >> rava's wife how do I know it's wife because the famous story that had his daughter on his lap she was a little girl and she said I want to marry those two people and Ra heard it. He said I want to be second. So first she married and he died and then she married. That's what's going on that the calls her. So obviously if you're going to marry's daughter, you better know your stuff because she's a little bit of a and she says, "Wait a minute. How did you purchase that meat that you just said it's kosher? My father once allowed." Now in the time of is already there. There's no B mdash. Then he was an amra. So when you have a firstborn, you give it to the kay and what happens? You can't bring it to either. So what do you do? You let it roam around until it befalls a m and then you can eat it. So now it's always a thing. New rabbi, is this a no go back? Come back tomorrow. Is this a So he said, "Oh, this is a this is a but he wouldn't eat from it because he he allowed this to be shed." He says my wife, my dear wife, it's a very good question you're asking. But let me explain to you the difference. There's a famous when it comes to when it comes to a firstborn even after it has a you're not allowed to weigh it. You're not allowed to sell it in the marketplace. You have to treat it with respect respect. You don't put it on a scale. So you look at it. H this looks like 2 lbs to me. This looks like a pound. Here, give me give me 250 shekel because it looks like a pound. Oh, that's why that's going back to that you can't you can't know for certain that he paid the right price. So, people are going to accuse the rabbi of doing the wrong thing. But over here, I rather always buy by weight. Nobody's going to accuse me of getting a better deal. My dear wife, I know what you're going to say because he gave me the top top. Huh? >> Oh, >> I didn't say. I was looking those two words. >> Huh? >> Penny had reception. So stepping in. >> If Penn is stepping in, we're going to let him have it. [snorts] We'll give him this one. I'm very upset at the bak today. Your son-in-law, he messed up. You better speak to him. He went the whole parish without making a single mistake. Usually he gives me a han like one. He He gives you that one. He does it on purpose during It's always invi pretends he made a mistake. Nothing. That was for you. Enjoy it while it last. Oh. Oh. So what are you going to say? What are you going to say? Because he gave me the top the that one pound that nobody could get only in that one animal. Wherever I go, they always give me one pound. So the says always used to send somebody to buy him every sing but I thought it's interesting used to eat meat every single day but to answer it because the says that he would actually send for the neck and we we also learned just the other day that if you eat from the it it's a to what >> it's healthy >> healthy yeah >> we have a big time you know he he throw he knows gar pence and stuff. It's It's a little scary. Fine. So, should we stop here because it's Shabas? We'll stop over here. Have a wonderful week. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.