Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 39 by R' Eli Stefansky

[singing] [chanting] Look at them. Take the camera on them. >> [singing] >> this way. [singing] >> [singing] >> Oh, [singing] good morning. >> [screaming] >> just to let the know at 6:00 we had a siren in Bamesh and in a lot of are and then we had another one as I was walking towards Shir at about 7:02 or so I don't know like early 7 so it was an hour in between that's why many people are not in the mad and stayed there or went home. Uh there was a few people that were coming from your and the taxi like turned around or cancelled and said they can't go the siren. So that's the mat of these missiles so far coming in from Yemen. >> Oh, this one was Iran. >> But how come we didn't get how come we didn't get on the phone? >> I didn't get Oh, >> my phone is off. Oh, that okay that's different. So the balagan the balan is has started. We had quiet for a very long time and now uh waking up the family at 6:00 is not gishmak and now Iran. Okay. So that's differentially no school. >> No school that that's you should have seen the sim of the we had a few in this year. They were jumping up and down with joy. [laughter] Lady, how are you doing? >> Stay for the whole year today. >> The whole school is off. >> Look at that. You're giving you're giving mixed messages here. We're in a war and you're like, >> "Oh, the warning is here." >> This is the first sh that we didn't even >> we didn't even read an email. >> Okay, Rabbi. So let's uh at least start something said the safer gift. >> Listen to that. Listen to that. >> Okay. So if anybody's over the age of 54 cuz I'm 53. [laughter] >> Oh. Oh. That was that was the the the message that it just finished. So we we we jumped the gun. We came a little early. >> David, your wife is in the airport. >> Yes. >> Cancelled flights and everything. >> I'm waiting. >> Uhhuh. >> Let's [snorts] see. Let's Let's hear gift new sponsors today. New sponsors. The claf forbar my official the g my official yad parrot. Beautiful. Beautiful. $30,000 piece. the doarcus. So anybody else want there's the you could uh follow in my officials footsteps is available for oral for $50,000 besides which my official took sponsor the cipher is available $100,000 extend your ra extend para with a matching donation of 3600 5400 7200 depending on the para I know that uh Uh Benny said he wants to share his parish and in fact somebody shared it with him for 5,400 bucks. >> Jen >> J Rhoden. J Rhden. That's right. So there are other people if you're if you are interested in sharing your para >> like uh David Kryberg they sit together. David K is making his available $30,000 matching on his share the Yeah. Yeah. That's the that's the price now. Share the safer you sponsored as well. let us know so we can add yours to the list. Here's a list. I'm not going to read all the names obviously and I'm going to start reading them today. It goes in alphabetical order and there's many there's a a lot of lists here. We're only there's partial lists. Iron Schwarz is Ammud Amu. These are $720 people and these names are going to be engraved on the mantle and also Raoai right over there where you see that chass cotton sign that's coming off and there's going to be a permanent uh plaque with everybody's name on it. Everybody I believe even even words no >> I think so it's going to be straight. [laughter] So right now a guy by the name of Alex Katz from just sent in I'll share my parish Alex on the spot. This is you don't know who's watching and who's listening on the spot. Aron Schwarz Abe Hiken is a um Akiva Krauss Alan Grin all these are moods. I'm not going to say we all know alter hoffman Ariman Ari Freeman Ari Levy Ari checking out are Simon Adar global Ari Blumenthal Usher Stfanski a Remy Cohen works for us Mosa while a bor shafnes right over there beantock boys they got together I guess they got Bernard Zikman Charles side stern family bach Bach, Darren Adelstein, David Lizau, David Lawrence, Dove Eisenberger, David Levy, David >> Molmer. Thank you. And David Lisker. I'm going to stop over there. Uh, these are the Pukim partial list. These are the words. I think there's like four of these. I love this video. I asked him to do it. He told me that they're starting a satellite location here. Look at Shimmy in one swoop take. Gorgeous brand new base medish in Manchester. >> Boy, look at this beautiful freshly refurbished Basa Medish in the heart of Manchester. Holy Law Basa Medish. >> Beautiful comfortable chairs, stunning design, fantastic furniture. On top of that, we've got the coffee with the best coffee, Nespresso, beater cup, hot water for your English tea, whatever else you need. Next [music] Sunday night, Mr. Shm will be starting on this screen. The live viewing of Rellis Dafisher in English [music] mar 7:45 followed by the shar. We're going to have the best freshest pastry Manchester has ever seen. Every attendee is going to get a pair of socks. We're going to have this place set up ready to roll. Get in touch. If you want one of these for your office, school or shop, custom made, beautiful. You scan the QR code, you get today's daff. Whatever you want, get in touch with Shimmy Lifman or Leafman for one of these. If you want to know more about this, get in touch with Jason Celic. His name and number is on the poster. If we get a big turnout after this year, we'll be doing a rendition of the English version of Vita in see there. [laughter] The English reition of Vita was in one take. One take MDY satellite Manchester location. Look at that boy. How could you not go there and check it out? Dear Belly, we are sponsoring. Oh no, I want to read that later in a different day. What is it? Uh, I put it I didn't realize the date. It's not It's like next week. >> Oh, it's tomorrow. So, Mark, do me a favor. Put this guy in for tomorrow. Special shout out to the Goldish Green and Henden communities for hosting me this Shabas. I am standing with the miracle boy, Rebelli Sil Seliger, an active ND wire who he's been here many times who survived nine weeks in a COVID related coma. We're on the side of the arson attack on the ambulances which have now been replaced. That was pretty quick. I'm struck by the parallel between these stories. Individuals and communities facing tremendous hardship and making the active choice to rebuild, recover and >> proverbally go va best palic the palic family foundation proverbally. As you can see, Belgium joined together as a group to sponsor an inheriti. Before my son has moved his furniture into his new RBS apartment, he made sure the right photo is on the wall. Oh, >> where is he? He's not here. >> He was >> Marcus Kublin. Kublin. I would dear Rebelli. I would never have imagined myself becoming dy guy, but I joined MD over two years ago starting with and I enjoy it every day. It's true that it's not always easy to do the daf, but it's always worth it to have that consistent daily and I'm part of the valley village community in Los Angeles and this week I had the rare chance for a day with my younger daughter at Disneyland, just the two of us. She saw that even at Disneyland it was important to learn. I was able to watch this year while we waited in line for rides. She took this picture of me while we made our way through the queue for the haunted mansion. Anyone who thinks they don't have time for the DAV should know that one time opens up where we make room for it. And two, our children learn so much from seeing our priorities, especially when it comes to Tyra. That is so true. It it's it's beyond our comprehension. What they see and what they they learn. They know what's important, why you leave at certain times. Young kids, I had that I just got a video from this girl that says, "How come I didn't show it? Maybe I did. girl. >> Yeah. Yeah. A little girl, like a four-year-old. She She says the Tati goes to to Da. Daf, like the whole thing. So, where do I go? Daf. >> It could be that the MDY is really is really the happiest place on earth. >> Disneyland is called. >> Yeah. It could be that MDY is really the happiest place on earth. Not could be. What do you mean could be? My great thanks to you and everyone at MDY for all you do to conduct, maintain, and grow this year. I hope to learn with you in person soon. The island doesn't realize that in this room alone there's probably 10 people that work on a daily basis to make sure that the shear runs consistently. Phone calls, ideas, meetings, zooms, the doesn't realize on a daily basis. Yeah, even go through the names, but that guy up there, this guy over there, that guy, these guys over here. It's crazy. It doesn't happen by itself. It's a whole team. Again, I'm going to read what he says here. My great thanks to you and everyone at MDY for all you do to conduct, maintain, and grow the sharak. I hope to learn with you in person soon valley village, California's river helping out with the mooing for daff. By the way, I was a little cringey yesterday during the mooing during the mattress video. It it it wasn't it didn't sit well with me, but our editor Ariel, he said it was his most fun he ever had in any DA that he edited. He was sitting and laughing the entire time from beginning to end. [singing] >> So this is at a live satellite location. This is an unbelievable satellite location. They they they invest a lot in it. It's unbelievable. Ra side official edition MDY sh the z I'm telling you the shas I had this to learn from our shas on shabs I think it was I did a whole daf like as it flows so beautifully it is the future and people are going to be running to stores to buy it even not no connection to MDY the future versions of it eventually every is going to have a picture or two with graphs and and it's going to It's a different level. Anybody that tries it out loves it because it just flows. It's easy to read. It's user friendly. It doesn't say anti-chamber and sacrifice. And it's just the lushion that we use. It's and and >> it's it's more than that cuz sometimes he puts in parenthesis certain things that you wouldn't have known otherwise that might have been in the notes somewhere, >> right? There are no notes. So right before a tashma, it tells you what the tshma is coming for. It repeats in in one in three four words just to remind you to refresh your memory. It says over here in the gra um what does say just a quick little things that help it's just it reads it reads I don't want to say newspaper but it reads like a newspaper it just reads it flows easy to understand any kid can read it and and get good shot crystal clear shot it's a very very good product and it's getting better and better fures whose yard site is the 23rd of Son David Salomon. All these from now on are the sponsors the actual not the blue MDY dedicated memory of by the policy family foundation. We just heard from him in gratitude to the consortium and the alliance and all they do to support him dying. Thank you to Chief Benny. just said the first time since I'm a little kid anonymous for Rosenfeld anonymous. I guess his wife didn't let him come today. [clears throat] It's uh >> huh. >> I'm [laughter] almost as happy as lady Freriedman. The Spanish here sponsors m to them family on this incredible. Sorry. Sorry. >> I love you. I love you. [laughter] May keep growing across the world and in Spanish speaking communities and in memory of Hayald Shindel Herzburg. Herzburg Zev and Amy Neo and family. I just spoke to him last night, a long conversation. It's heartbreaking. And I said I said two words to the wife. She got on the phone at the end and uh it's a crazy situation and it was a from person. It's a whole it's a mess. It's a big mess and it's very very difficult the four-year-old. But the bottom line is people have to be aware like you get distracted. I don't know if that's I'm not saying what happened and where happened, but people sometimes get distracted. It happened to me. I didn't even mention to him, but it happened to me twice. Uh I was in charge of my kids in shul and I just left them in shul and I went home and uh at one time one time they closed the shaw and one of my kids was there and 5 minutes later. It happens. It happens to to you know especially absent minded people and uh just awareness awareness that there's all sorts of like devices to remind you the car just uh it's to hear the story and to to think about a a young vibrant normal regular healthy four-year-old girl four year I have a 4-year-old anol and it's like wow my four-year-old girl who shook up the world with her may she be a for and the family should have anonymous >> German on her 20th side by class of 2006 should have an ali son of the world famous on your graduation keep giving your parents and doing the daf amen Monthly sponsor art. We're we're doing okay. Don't worry about where we're holding because there's a very short d. So everything's bes. [clears throat] So basically we we'll be discussing do you have the power just in your mind do you have the influence over a you're the owner of that animal does your thought have an influence on what the cen in the b mikdash does on what a outside of the b mdash does so for instance [clears throat] if you bring a carbon to the b mikdash and you're standing on the side You do you have the power and the influence to influence the and say oh it's not going to be it's going to be it's not going to be it's going to be you're the owner maybe you have the the right to put a thought into his his and the same thing would apply if a Jew is sheing a non-Jewish animal even today Arabs they'll rely on on a Jewish it's consideredal for because it's so suppose imagine the talks about Arabs actually that they have not so but back in the day they were so Jews doing thealal process for him he gets paid for it doesal and the the Arab puts of into says this is for for an idol as this Jew is doing this the action the owner could he insert his his in it what do you guys think >> verbally or just in thinking. >> So that's that's also part of the discussion and uh in fact it's all these things are so says the Mishna. So says that we don't have to be concerned about the owner the guy. So therefore the iser and you the Jew can actually purchase meat from this non-Jew holds that the non-Jew the guy could insert his thought into your Jewish you can insert the into he [clears throat] what the Okay. We're going to see the gumar. That's We have to see the gar. >> Yeah. [clears throat] We have to see right now. We're not talking. We didn't hear anything at this point. There's no We didn't hear. It's a thought. We have to see if like you said, is is there a a norm for for the non-Jew? So that day that we did the we saw the diaphragm, we saw the it's called a skirt steak in English, it's a it's a wall that divides the liver. So even if the non-Jew owns that very small piece of steak >> from the lung, >> the lung to the liver, >> right? It's in between. It's like a wall between the lung and the liver. It's the first time >> actually diaphragm >> the diaphragm. Yeah. So, so even if he owns that little diaphragm, he's a he's a owner. He has a a partnership in this animal, a small partnership. He has the ability to ruin it. Why? Because the the norm of of a guy of someone or idol worshipper is always and you could say of a Jew should be for the >> a guy comes to the and says I need a pis I need to explain to me what I dreamed. Every dream has a new he says I dreamt of the I had a conversation with the so this is very good that means that during the day you're thinking about the usually you dream at night what you think during the day he says it's impossible I'm so busy during the day I'm running to schol I'm doing I'm going to k I'm I'm benching I how I don't have a second to think about the >> truth through it. There's a lot of truth. We're busy running to we're forgetting what we're doing. [snorts] >> That's what the Miller says. You're allowed to think about even during says the Garra. If you don't understand the right away, the Gar is going to give us the details of the indah talks about the thought process of the and how he could ruin the carbonas at the four stages. There's four famous stages here. I'll just throw it on the screen for the for the newbies. the forget the bottom ones. Those are all part of the and during those four processes of and receiving the blood and and bringing it to the and then doing the throwing the blood on the which is the most important one throughout that whole process you could think thoughts that destroy the carbon literally that if you eat from the carbon later you get misa it's that bad so in the bdosh when when the whole idea of ruining it with your thought applies only the has the right to have a thought not the owner the owner has no right so when it comes to let's say outside of the just your regular animal certainly a non should not have superpowers hours in his mind to change the the designation of this animal and and think oh I'm the owner this animal I'm turning it into into the B mikdash you can't do that if you're the owner and in the B mdash that's where the whole thing uh originated from the whole idea of pagle of ruining the carbon is in the bdash you can't do in the b mikdash if you're the owner you can't you don't have any power over the animal so certainly outside the bdash the go doesn't have power to make it into a desar so explains the garra Let me just Oh, here small video. >> You are sad. You are very sad. Dear, I also know why you want a burger. A double portion. Don't worry. I'll take care of you. That's our what do you call it? No. Uh >> the one that you relieve yourself. The >> I want a burger. A double portion. Sir, this is a shoe store. No excuses. I have a cow outside. I'll pay whatever it takes. >> Oh, you're in luck. I'm a certified choice. I'm already on it. [laughter] Here you go. Thanks. $5,000, please. What a nerve. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH. This is what I brought. You don't want it? Don't eat it. What am I supposed to do with all this meat? Is it even kosher? MDY saved my life. There's going to be cholin tonight. >> Look at this. Me over there is not me. Look at that. Look at my teeth. >> Just a second. I brought the cholin. It's all thanks to you. [laughter] >> Wow. >> Okay. So, that wasn't me. I don't know how they got my Okay, so they both What's the says that we don't care about the he doesn't insert says he does they they both hold but they hold they come out with different opinions that what I heard that as the performing the owner could be very interesting. I mentioned this when we were learning that yel he had a a very very strong cash said how's it possible that the owner could be then it comes out that there's no of a will never blow up why cuz she has to bring a so as she's bringing the mka in her mind she's going to think that she's going to eat the mka that you know it's going to be they're going to do they're going to put beactor the mka in three days if if a owner has the right to to ruin things in their mind so she could ruin the ma and then she never brought a ma she didn't bring him then the water doesn't work so he wrote a safer called to answer this question with 80 different answers and ind writes what a shame I didn't call it because he [snorts] he he was able to come up with 80 answers cuz he forced himself cuz That was the that was the name of the book. That was the name of the safer. Had he had he had he made a larger a higher goal, he would have he would have forced himself even to 100. Psych the psychology of a of a of a human. Set yourself um achievable goals but but but high ones. Z gamaro I remember we sitting once five years ago and uh we were I don't know two three thousand people in the shar was thou two 3,000 people who ever heard of a shar 2 3,000 people client says to me and he says one day we're going to have 70,000 and I I said look look it's a it's a beautiful goal but you got to be realistic you have to be within reason you know we're not holding you want to say 10,000 It's a crazy number, but it's realistic. 70,000. Like, what are you what are you talking 70,000? And uh now we're very close. We're very close. By the hopefully by the seash, we'll be there. We're like at 50 now. Unbelievable. What? >> We're at 60. The >> basic based on the numbers >> numbers. >> Yeah, we had crazy. We saw crazy numbers. I don't know. It's very hard to >> These are 60. That's what we came out with. >> 61. 37 + 20 is 507 more process for >> huh for 170. >> Yeah. [clears throat] Well, that's nothing now. Now it's 170. Where? No. 48. Now we had a new goal. I said 400,000. If everybody brings two people and the next people being there is 400,000. Okay. [snorts] [clears throat] I heard that the owner could could actually have an effect on this animal. If you heard it come out of his mouth, okay, but he didn't hear anything, so you can't assume anything. So therefore, he didn't make it up to say that this guy's we don't say that even though you didn't hear it directly from his mouth, but you could assume that that's his his thought and his thought does have effect on this animal. So the third in the is even if you heard the he said you heard from the goy's mouth that it means nothing why this gu is performing and this guy is thinking of a des even when you heard it directly from the Yes, I agree. There's something called that the owner is but that's only that's why I brought this mdash here. Not because Yseph is here, my brother Yseph, but because I want I want to is not a word. It's a thing. We're in the B mikdash inside here. You could you could have thoughts to to ruin the carbon. That's only inside the B mikdash. outside of the right over here any other place besides in the entire world it doesn't work why I don't learn outside of the inside I don't learn from a carbon so he holds taco no I do learn any carbon from the carbon any any from the carbon of the mid just like in the mikdash the owner has an effect on the so that's why if a Jew is shifting an animal and the owner the guy has a thought his thought it's unbelievable his thought transfers into the animal and ruins the animal makes it there's a there's a question people ask why does it say we always say should be before don't you want your kid to be a mench before he gets So they they answer that when could you tell that a person is a true that he's a true when he does with his wife when he does in his home. That's the we're looking for and it fits in over here when a when a person a lot of people they run around and doing this one that one but in their own home they're they're pretty and you could learn the outside from the inside. When when a person you see a person is with his wife and his children then you know that he's a true outside. comes and he says and he all pretty much like I think that's the standard that even the bum doesn't have powers over the animal he can't insert his power into the you're the owner you're Israel you can think whatever you want you're not going to affect So now we're going into called these are the four avoid right every pigle in the world basically is avoid for the most part because if you're having A thought during what's your thought? Not that you're going to do somewhere else. You're thinking during where are you going to do this? Where are you going to eat the animal? Where are you going to put the the the when are you going to put the animals parts on the misbeh? That's the problem of pigle. Pigle means I'm thinking to myself anything has to do with eating even the misbeh's food so to speak. So I think to myself I'm going to do tomorrow as I'm doing as I'm doing the one on the right I'm thinking about the one on the left isn't that that's my and that that's what pigle is so what about in do I say as I'ming the car now if I'm shing a carbon and I think to myself I'm shifting this not carbon if I'm shifting an animal outside in my garage at home I'm shing an animal of a Is that why is it everybody greets? There's no question that and this animal is not only that there Lauren you hear this this animal there's something think about we learned in that this animal not only is it and also for you to eat but there's also something super duper with this animal think what it is what could it be something really really head. Huh? No, >> it's a it's not stam it's everybody in the room becomes tom. That's how severe. So if I this animal with a knife and I say this is the whole building goes up in red. It's like it's me. But what if I think during this that I'm going to throw the blood could I could I transfer my thought of to the when it comes to outside? Obviously, it works. But outside that's the question. Here's another trick question. What if I think to myself that I'm going to take the parts of this animal that I'm shifting right now doing the and I'm going to put them on on a on my bama in the backyard. Is that of a despis? Yes. 100%. Does it make the animal apostle? No. Why not? because that occurs after the that's already the the putting on in in the B mikdash putting the parts of the animal on is after you're already done done so I can't ruin the animal after I'm done let's say I have a piece of meat in your refrigerator ready to eat and then say oh this is not going to work you're but it doesn't affect the meat so I'm just putting it into this line over is a problem. Is very much of a is saying it. But the question is does it have an effect on the animal? But the next line of to put the the fats the parts that go on the for that's already too late. That's already post. So now the question is could I have an effect on when I do my could I think about another says yes it's over here means it's not a problem but what does mut mean the animal is you are but you can have a great steak before you says because I could put my thoughts during about it. Why? Why? It's not. It's why because I'm learning from people's inside is outside. I can learn the outside from the inside. Says it's not a problem with the meat. You are it's not a problem with the meat. Why? I cannot go from in my mind. Why? Because because I don't learn from in the bish. Of course, we go. That's not even a question. Yeah. Who knows? Okay. Says because they go according to their own there's other there's another very very similar somewhere else and the says that this is over but if it's similar to that is over there and then the is going to ask so if so why do they have to argue in two different things that are the same thing it's the same now if I were to ask you where in sh where in sh does it mention and within the same lines. Where would you say, "Oh, you're looking over there." He says, "I just said it." You're right. I just said it. But when I asked Fster a few days ago, I said as a joke, I said, "Why does it say sometimes it says, sometimes?" I was just trying to bother him. He says on the top. So, here we are. We just passed I just went a few lines right there on purpose. So it says in line number six it says and then it says in line eight. So over here he's trying to prove that's the same person. We're explaining why says and the explains it's in in the same line. It's the same human being. You can't say it's two different people. You can't say that he was younger or older. He was a talent. It's the same person. So sometimes the it just says like this something like that and that's how he but his mind works in a very different way than a regular human being. The most >> editor [clears throat] didn't have space. >> Yeah. Yeah. Fencer said it >> but he said I we it's not even it's not even a question. I could have asked it anywhere in me in a second. Okay, it's the same thing the same idea we we remember the first first of it says the idea of what does the mean usually means like you have to have kavana for a mitzvah over there it means that if you're bringing if you'reing a carbon you cannot switch its designation tolam let's say if you're bringing and the k thinks to himself that's not He he's there's only two kurban he could do it to and egg >> pes that's it. So, but it's very similar to pickle. It's the same idea, but it's different. Pigle is I'm thinking to myself, I'm going to eat it at the wrong time. And this is I'm bringing another type of carb instead of I started off this is very good. I with the proper intent that it's a but I'm thinking to myself, you know what? In five minutes when I throw the blood on the I'm going to throw it as if it's a I'm allowed to jump in my mind from to that I'm learning the the problem of jumping from carbon to carbon from I'm going to learn from that I'm thinking to myself I'm going to eat this animal after it's time you cannot go from one to another I don't learn from saying basically it's the same we just mentioned with do I learn says let me just show you this video real quickly I thought it was a cute video um where is it Oh, it's this one. [music] >> You have to quit this madness. >> Okay, I'll try to stop. [music] >> [music] >> My mother always said I was the black sheep of the family, which [music] is messed up, doc, because I'm a goat. Welcome to another meeting of anonymous addicts. We have a newcomer today. I am Kat and I am an addict. >> We love you, Kat. >> [music] >> 3 months smoke free. Health is everything. >> With all that meat on you, you are no longer a hott you are a schllelamine. [music] >> So that that's what the schma is. Thema means that you switch the designation from all that for that. [laughter] Somebody I know very well, I learn with his son a lot. Anytime we show smoking, he basically and not every time, but he makes, you know, the smoking is not good, but I hope now like this is we're trying to get people to stop smoking. Okay, the I just as I was I'm not making this up. As I was walking down the I took the elevator and the elevator stopped on one of the floors in the building and and I see my neighbor in a wheelchair going to the hospital. So I asked the son I said so I came out of the elevator. I said you guys take the elevator with the wheelchair and I'll go down the stairs. So the son came with me said what's going on here? He said his is the mother got the lung cancer. So I'm like I we were just talking about this. I said did she smoke? No, she's not a smoker. Okay. should have a refor. If I just said this, it's because of it's outside of so I don't learn the outside from the inside. But yeah, that we changing the designation to and they're all done inside. Maybe perhaps you could go from one to another from one from if I only said it's a simple it goes both ways. If I only spoke about the case that's inside admits over admits that you learn from from I'm sorry you learn from but when it comes to maybe that's not a problem because it's outside you could go you need in both cases that what do you go from one from in your mind or Not what's Rash asked a question and the Gar is going to say at the end I'm just pointing out his name is Rash is going to answer the question. So he asks a very simple question that really needs explanation. What do we learn in the in a place where your thought ruins it in the mdash? Now Rashi points out the word. So if look if the person is doing what what would it say? It would say why does it say might be talking about even the case of I could ruin it so to speak by by thinking instead of that it's it's that works says it only the has the power to change it and to ruin it but outside mikdash where your mind doesn't work. It doesn't it doesn't have control. Now what's the what's the question right here? Outside the mikdash your mind doesn't have control. Of course your mind has control. If you think about while you'reing an animal, you think in your mind that it's there's no greater than that. That is so asks what does it mean your mind doesn't have control that it doesn't have any effect? It's the desire actually changes the design. It makes it put it. Oh, where was this the crav? >> Huh? >> The but is saying about the he says in a place where the has no effect on the animal outside. So of course the bon doesn't have an effect but he starts with the ind has an effect. The owner has zero effect. So outside where the the so to speak has zero effect. So certainly the owner has no effect. What do you mean the the doesn't have an effect? The can make it into a desire by thinking about it. So says so you have to explain [snorts] it must be we had a we have a video here. Oh real quickly. >> Hold on. Mhm. This is showing that Aid Desar, your mom don't like Aid Desar videos. Doesn't sit well with you. Good. That's a very good thing. [music] becomes a dead person and a dead person fills up the whole room with tommo with red tumo. Okay. What are you saying now that what that's not ava? It's what >> is asking when will you ever have? The answer is when he says I'm doing >> no we know we know that also works without the works. You can think about a des now you're inventing a new thing. >> Um it means that do do you have an effect? Of course you have an effect during the to say that it's but do you have the effect while you to say that I'm going to do could I can I go from one my mind And so like this even if I think he sells even I think that it's instead of like you saw in the video it ruins it from and I have the effect during the I'm thinking that I'm going to do this for but it's only who has an effect says only the not the owner says So outside where I shed an animal during I cannot think about I only I could only focus on the if I if I during the you're right it works but not I can't jump to another so therefore I have that only the person performing the can do it and not the owner and so then why are you so concerned about the owner the go inserting his thought of into >> [clears throat] >> says, "I think this makes it so easy." What does just say? What does he just Oh, I wanted to change. I forgot. Could you change these words afterwards where it says just put the word instead of that little I don't like that guy. I don't know why I did. I just wrote this lotion that what it's based on that what I could think from to even in the B mdash not outside the B mdash. So what's the problem with that? Two problems doesn't work with with with the part and doesn't work with the outside part. Why? Take a look. The the words are going to jump. Oops. No, no, no. Don't change it now. Don't change it now. Oh, it's changed already. Okay, fine. >> All right, it's there. [snorts] Now says you cannot think about from one and says we're assuming that go with and and said this from one to only inside not says it works even outside. So we can see there's one problem for each for each. So says this is fascinating before heard it from his rebby. Rashi calls him his rebi. [snorts] Yeah. You throughout they argue always argues with right. So before and and here's the here's the crazy thing. According to one says before he heard this from he was arguing under logic once he heard it's a he said okay I can't argue on the logic as tus look at this small little tus we do all especially if it's small basically I think is very bothered by this doesn't know now I if because if was like a beginner. You want to tell me oh he's a beginner. He wouldn't be arguing with has no right to argue with is in a da of arguing with so he doesn't know. That's why there's another rash also. Okay. Says >> we saw him. >> Yeah. But the there's a big question whether he was before. He was always >> Yeah. Yeah. I think there's a Yeah. Yeah. when we learned that >> he's holding the he's holding he's holding by the by the Hebrew says that you could go from one to another even outside the same as the question answer the question it's beautiful very simple We were learning what I'm going from. As I'm thinking to myself, what am I going to do by this? No, no, no, no, no. That's not the at all. Means literally means the four famous avoid. I can think at the that I'm I'm I'm ruining it. I can think by the I'm ruining. I can think by I'm not going I'm not jumping from the right to the left from [clears throat] all I'm saying is that in the B is four avoid and outside only two that's what I'm saying so that's that's the beautiful where I have four I could ruin it only the can ruin it so when I only have two then certainly only the can ruin it it's more more possibilities and only one person could do it. That's the cash days in a [clears throat] place. There's only so certainly only the should be able to do the should be able to do and ruin this animal that owner turning the global specialist in international financial services. What are we going to do here? Wow. that what says that you could ruin it from that as you're doing you could think to yourself I'm going to do this forever it says you tired he's woken up at 6:00 >> we do oh first of all what's your name >> thank you for So it's day today. Philip, who else is a guest? >> Oh, I didn't notice you. What's your name? >> From Manchester, London. >> Gates. >> No, that's a God. Gates is a big one. We haven't had a gates in Mish a long time. So, what's your kid's name over there? >> Huh? >> A from Gates. Wow. You came on the day you were able to get it with all the sirens. finish now. >> Oh, you do? >> How long do you live here? >> 17 years. [laughter] >> I'm from [laughter] >> That was good. That was good. And you still have that accent. Wow. >> I was so So, so I was right with what I said. I was right. You're not from Gates. We didn't have a guy from Gates in a long time. Your mom should give you ah can't forget. Okay. Welcome. Welcome. Wow. As he's doing the he's thinking about. So that's from just said and it makes it terrible. Oh, here's a question. What if? Hm. What do we do? What do we do here? We stop here. It's It's already No, we're an hour into Shir. >> It's an hour into Shir. It's 8:20. >> Okay, we're going to have to We're going to have to stop here and figure it out. Rabo, have a wonderful quiet day. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsored at mdy.com.