Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 31 by R' Eli Stefansky

Oh doo [singing] doo y. Welcome, welcome to all the guests. This is very, very important stuff to start off the week with. I was watching Shir today that you mentioned there were sweet breads in Morocco. He said they were brains. This would be a huge misconception. They are thymus glands. We've been serving them for over 21 years. Even though they are very popular, at least once a week, people come to us thinking they are brains. Harry Zinstein, CFO, Mike's Bro in New York City. >> Oh, Mike's Vistro. >> Where is it from though? So, where is it from? >> He just said gland. It's a gland. It's a gland by the neck or something. >> No, it's part of the pancreas. >> Pancreas. Pancreas. Okay. Okay. My name is >> Deari. I'm n I'm a ninth grade. >> You're doing great. Let's continue. I am a ninth grade bery. On the first day of minus I went into the van on the way to yeshiva and the driver was playing the da and I got connected. I've learned the daff every day since then. >> I listen to daff every day on Torah anytime. One small action from the van driver caused me to learn 134 dapham so far. >> Wow. >> Attached is a song that I made up. Thank you Jacobson 14 B. Dear Rebi Stfansky, first of all, I want to tell you how much I appreciate your work. Your daff the way you explain the gimmar such clarity together with the pictures visual aid makes the learning so much more accessible, clear and alive. I feel like if you go to I don't know like chach like that's the first I heard exactly these words like 100 I wanted to respectfully ask if might be possible one day to create this type of shar in French as well the same way it was done in Spanish. And so it's interesting. Last night, right before I read this email, before I read this email, the guy who won the second place video looking out of the window and seeing MDY and coming in here and there's a cow. So he went over to Benny and he said that he speaks French and he would like to do the whole thing like say it, do the whole words and everything. >> Did Benny tell you this? >> Yeah. >> Okay. So So So now, now we have now we have competition. We have competition. It's good. French competition is always good but with your clarity style teaching visuals no one is really doing it yet for French speaking public I truly believe there's a real need for this in the French community and that could help many people connect more deeply to that we have to get the lips work better I think so that's also issue in my opinion could be a tremendous zik thank you again for everything you do may hashem give you the strength to continue spreading t so many people with great respect sagun from pari official Moses Marovich. This is the guy who uh what's the word? >> He's well I don't know the bank rolls and he's behind the whole Spanish thing. Mos Marovich for all the hats for the hat of all our children >> from Mexico. David Salomon dedicated memory of the foundation gratitude to consortium and the alliance and all they do to support MDY. Notice the sea of consortium is capital. It's the real deal. Anonymous and thank you to Chief Benny. Anonymous for complete reforester. Maybe they should put a on the next line. The Spanish sponsors wishing the MDY family continue that by Robert Early. Whoever heard that I didn't know who you were, Robert, back then. I mean, when you wrote that anonymous email, I didn't >> and I and I and I called you out on it. >> I'm saying it was anonymous >> and and you didn't like say, "Hey, that was me. Stop." >> That's why that's that's what anonymous is. [laughter] >> Oh, that's what anonymous. You got to hear his email. Those who heard it last night heard it. It was Gal email. Preston, you're going to if you heard it, you would say send it to me. Preston Harris group. >> It's one of it's like you said, there's a lot of stories, many stories. Most of my stories you can't you can't can't publish. He says this braas from rebell, but there's also clawless. And he wrote an anonymous email saying that he he recruits people this that, but he gives his money to other places. doesn't he doesn't give to MDY. He said I called him out on it and I said that's ungrateful and I'll tell you if you learn from you say this is a source of this so why don't you give back he says from that day on his business went tanked he lost all his clients everything and now he got a major client so he's doing chuva the rabb says that when when a situation happens you do the opposite and he's giving he gave a whole week he's sponsoring and he he he recommends that everybody do the same >> just in case >> but how long ago was that email >> n months. >> It was that one. >> It was like two years ago. >> It was a few years. It was that one particular client was a few years ago and I was a great client a lot of money from it. And as soon as you as soon as you >> open my mouth >> the filter me out that particular client everything went wrong. [snorts] >> Do you want do you want that email now? Yes or no? It's one of these. >> I don't think so. President Iris Group recruit making money from the shear. Give back to the shear. >> It's not I'm going to not only make money from the shear make money give back to the shar >> anonymous in memory of Nissim Til who helped save their Aaron Cutler. in memory of Nissan T. He helped save >> that he did not ad he didn't help right >> says save the mirror and cutler >> anonymous David Benester a daily sponsor of the consortium we're retaining Michael Chessel as our intellectual property attorney and we'll be issuing a seasoned assist season we pledge the damages will will be awarded uh we will be awarded will go to MDY [laughter] >> very good very good HK ventures of the month in this what's going on in this success of all our clients Danielle Rosen and the white I have six seconds before it's 8 minutes into the share. So I want to say welcome back Ellie. We missed him but he's back for Should I tell him what you told me on Chabas or it's not >> tell >> he comes he comes over to me says I want to be the first person to tell you that you inspired me to leave the daf what happened he asked me once how how long how much do I spend on the ds I said all day long he said oh I also have to spend all day long in what I do and that is mishna is for kids and he spends many many hours since then more hours giving overn so I said that's great but it's before before you start your day [snorts] so here he is today the first day of and you'll see it's give me a recap from everything [laughter] >> first secure your mask before you secure >> oh first secure your No but that's what he's doing securing his mask by giving No by giving over he's doing Great. They're giving over Mishn to kids and hundreds of kids, thousands of kids. >> All right. >> Um, we also have here Rebeni Kruskll, the famous Rebi Krukll's father's right over there in the corner. And that is your grandson. >> What's your name? >> Oh, Kuskal. >> Oh, you're Kuskal? >> Yeah. >> Wow. We know your uncle, the famous Moy over here. >> Oh, well from New >> That's right. Hundreds of milas. Hundreds all over the world. >> Thousands maybe. >> At least >> is he there? I don't even know. >> When I left before >> which how long was it go? How long ago? >> Before Morocco. >> Oh before Morocco. >> Morocco. >> And this is your sh. What's your name? >> Also >> all right. Galdic sham. Welcome. Who else? Anybody else? Okay, here we go. We're on into here's the shock person is to go to the mikvah. Say a woman has to go to the mikvah. She's walking on a bridge. She slips and falls into the water. The entire way down she's screaming. She thinks she's going to die. And as soon as she hits the water, she's trying to save her life. She gets out of there in one piece. Was there a here or no? She had zero kavana obviously because all she was thinking about is her life. Was she mut to her husband? >> No, forget the kita. No, it's not a problem. It's not a problem. Loose clothing, not a problem. We're not talking about that. We're talking about not the the details. I'm talking about the the of >> she didn't make the bra. >> It doesn't matter. She had zero. Of course, she didn't make a braha. She made a bra, right? She was thinking about dying. >> And is not No, it just shows whether or not she had >> pillow. Hello. It's doesn't matter. You have to say it. All right. [clears throat] Z and we're holding seven lines down from the top. Don't get used to this. We're holding where we have to be holding. Not only that, a little bit more. There was a video that I needed to show last night. It was and it was a it was the best video of the night and it was all the way at the end of the suga. >> So, we had to get here. >> The video at the end doesn't show the covering of the offer after. >> Right. Right. Right. No, cuz that's not a problem. That of course he's going to do. problem in the gamarra was the the offer before and we had to come on to that he had a kavana to be so that was a special arrow for that it's just says the says the if a person was shing two animals or one animal let's say one animal knocks off the head says it depends how long the knife was we learned in the Mishna that the knife was like this. If it's double the size of the neck, then it's okay. So, we're going to prove that it means double the size of the neck. What the Mishna means is the size of the neck plus I don't know exactly what he means and the Gar is going to say what does mean? Does it mean a little bit like in this picture? Does it mean two widths of a neck totally have two or it means take a look at this slide how it happens. Boom. It just means a little bit more than the knife. Let's go to the next case over there. It's a little bit more. It says if a person was shingling two animals at the same time and knocked off both of their heads. If the knife has one width of a neck, it's ask the obvious question. How's it possible that if you're shing one animal, you need a little bit more than a neck? And if you're shing two animals, all you need is one neck. It's impossible. So what does one neck mean? One neck means one neck more than what you So if you have two animals, you need one neck in addition to the two necks of the the width of the animal. A total of how many necks? >> Three. Two necks of the animal. One extra neck width. That's the that's how long your knife has to be. And that's the end of the if it means when you're shingling two animals, all you need is a knife that's as wide as one neck, it's impossible. If you're shingling one animal just said you need one neck plus a little bit more. So when you're shifting two animals, all you need is one neck. So when the mission says one neck, it means whatever width. If you're shing 16 animals, you need a neck that's 16 animals wide plus one neck. It means one neck in addition to the two that. So therefore also when says on one animal, it means not this picture right over here, but this picture over here. >> [snorts] >> End of the suga. So this is a typical that we had for the last 30 daf. Easy stuff and it's going to continue to be easy. [laughter] >> You say sorry. >> Some people like tough. Some people like it hard says. When do you need a knife that's this long? Like in this picture. You need a knife like this when it's one motion. You're only going forward. You're only going backward. So to make sure that you did a good, you need a knife that has an extra width to it. But it says the Mishna, if you're going to go back and forth, you could even use a small razor blade this big. And if it takes you 20 times back and forth back and forth to chef, okay? In that's okay. You might be a little bit of a Russia, but that's what it is. It's talking about specifically, this is according to the school. I drew a completely different picture, but the argues with me, so I'm going to go with the I think Rabbi David knows better than I do. Means a decorative piece that comes out of a knife. And let's say let's say this is just for argument sake. This is the the this part is a razor. So he's shifting like this. He's going this is the neck of the animal. So he's going back and forth back and forth like that. Now the problem is that has these little horns that come out decorative horns. And it might slip and it might poke the simon. Not good. Meny, what are you looking at? I see like you're very concerned over here about this knife. The people that sit next to me. [laughter] Another question. What if I use a needle? Obviously, they're going to poke the animal with a needle a bunch of times and make small holes. What is that? What is that? >> Dresa, I'm pushing downwards. You need to cut with a nail with with the So, so he's going to take this. This is like the worst of the worst. I don't even know the the mitas of it. You take a needle and you start going back and forth with it. You start scraping the surface until you get in. And then once you get in, then you cut. I mean, this is what you have. You're on an island. You have a needle. You pack yourself a needle >> and some thread. and you don't have a knife, you know, like like sometimes you're in an island, it happens all the time, and you don't have a can opener. So, what do you do? So, you got to I don't know, you find something. It take it might take a few hours and then finally open up your tuna can. It happens. Just happened to me yesterday. Whatever. Okay. No, no, no. Good. Yeah. You're going back and forth, but one of those back and forths, you're going to poke the guy. And once you poke him, that's diss. No good. >> He says it's a >> like ripping. Tearing. >> Okay, you're ripping. Fine. Better. You're ripping. [clears throat] So you have a tanner's needle. What was this for? I I don't remember. I Okay. Oh, here. over here. Maybe you might rip. Okay, >> that's the act the other way. >> Yeah. >> So, this guy right over here, you don't really see it's not a 100. It's not It could have been a better picture, but the point is that the top part of the needle is a little flatter than a regular needle. A B the tip the tip is flat. B the sides are very very sharp. This is what the the people that you that that work with leather, they use such a needle. It's like a scalpel. >> It's very thin. It's the the size of a needle. It's a little bit It's a little bit uh wider than a regular needle. It's a giant needle. The kids are a giant needle with very sharp edges. I don't understand the problem. If you look in the Mishna, I should have had it on the screen. It says the last words in the if you're doing a back and forward motion like a knife even a knife that's the smallest of the small and then the continues even a a razor blade. So in all a razor blade whatever you want to call it. So says what does ku mean? It's telling us a type of a type of a type of a cutting instrument. The smallest knife that I know of, which is a a needle that they work with leather. No, it's referring to a razor blade. But that's the next words. So, what does mean? It can't mean the same thing. Says it does mean the same thing. Irish my saying you could use a knife that's khu even a very very small knife but what's the smallest of the small is the width of a a razor blade and it makes a lot of sense logically if you tell me something that's one millimeter wide is kosher it wouldn't make sense for the to say 1 millm is kosher And also you should know a 20 mm millm um uh razor blade is also kosher. Of course a razor blade is kosher says no no no no on that if that's your whole that's not a good riot. Why is don't forget about this guy. This one we already established is possle. So maybe all razor blades in the world should be possible because the is they used to they used to have these decorative pieces to the razor blades and they could be dangerous for so maybe I should say all maybe a needle is good but a razor blade is not good because some razor blades have horns. Now I'm going to ask you a trick question. Don't look in the Mishna cuz if you do, you're going to make a little bit of a mistake. What if I have a knife on a table? This knife is sitting on the edge and uh there's vibrations going on like you know a lot of houses have vibration. I'm just waiting there for it to fall and I know that when it falls it's going to fall so perfectly on my chicken's head which I tied down right below the table and it's going to cut my chicken. I want it to happen. Is that a good or not a good? I'm watching it. I'm looking at the knife. >> He says it's good. He says it's no good. >> What? It's good, Arie. Why is it good? >> Even if you throw stone. >> Oh, so maybe I give it cuz you threw it. >> What? So that's something else now. Oh. Oh, now you're talking about something the opposite. It was your throw with zero cavana. ovaria have full zero kaya it's a different case completely different case so it says the Mishna it fell over here it did not have any of a person no it didn't come from the power of a human it just fell even though it made a beautiful slice ice in the neck. Cut both of the it's not a good you have to and then you eat. >> What if you bumped it by mistake? That's how it fell. >> Oh, so now the goes into that. That's because it fell who does a mean would mean you didn't throw it. You let go of it. So this is my knife. I let go of it. But that leaving go, me opening up my fingers, that is a I used human force. And that human force of me releasing it let it go down and cut. >> That's the example. >> Well, I don't I didn't see that. Why delay? Why is it delay? >> Is it your is your power not your power? [snorts] >> Okay, but here's the point. The big point is that's today's the problem is over here that he didn't intend to when you you you from here it's mashma that you don't have to have intent when you as long as it was a human power it came from from your power you you threw it whatever it is even if you didn't have to it's a good mantavita Who is this that says that you don't have to have any intent? This is the famous which we had 20 days ago. When we were in Morocco, we had him. So that was 20 days. We were in Morocco 20 days ago. That's alone. So Rashi says you could read his name two ways. You could read his name. His name is Zero. He's the youngest of the whole or maybe his name is the Tony. That's that was his name. He's part of Kabur. So he wasn't the youngest in the group. His name is the young. It wasn't the youngest in the group. He might have been the oldest of the group. Let's see the video. Remind because a lot of people might have not seen this cuz we were away. It sounds like Kiran Kiran. They got the whole vibe of that that shook without being there. You have all these weird people doing weird stuff there. Throwing knives, [music] snakes, monkeys. This is a typical Lakewood So his cover was did the bullseye and by mistake [music and singing] Those [music] are real. That's a real song that we sang in a real. So he threw a knife cuz he wanted to get it into the wall and it went and it chucked in an animal by mistake says you don't have to have intent for you do not have to have say you have to have intent and continues to say you should know that you don't need to have intent to you have to have intent to throw to move the knife. That's it. Ask the what does have to say that is like he already said it before where the [snorts] first mission of you see rebell few we did we went to that so now we're doing what it says no good but if you're standing there You have an adult watching a good but don't have intent. So who says you don't have to have intent the same that says it's the same that says you don't have the intent. So why does he repeat his same 30 days later says over there at least the is [clears throat] >> is I was just thinking about that story that I told my friends I don't know if it's appropriate for >> okay it is it is it is [laughter] >> as you know as you know as you know my my >> you don't know usually it's not >> correct I'm going to say it I'm going to tone it down I'll tone it down everything I'm saying everything I'm saying multiply by 10 or 200 my grandchildren two of them they go to non-Jewish school in Utah because my my kids are doing kiru in Utah so I was on Zoom with them and my grandchildren said some words that typical Jews in Jewish schools will not say especially to their zi. So I said I said listen you don't even know the good words let me tell you a really good word but you have to promise me you're never going to use it. So he said okay promise kid the one grandchild is six other one is four and they're using these linas. So I said, "I have a word. I have a word for you, but you promise you're never going to use it." Yeah. Okay. This is the worst. This is the biggest curse word you could ever say. And then they start saying, I SAID, "DON'T SAY IT. SHAITA, YOU'RE SAYING." And they go to the cleaning lady. You shite you. And my daughter said the whole day, that's all they were saying. So I felt good. I felt like I switched it out. Switched it out. Stuck it in there. What? >> Good. You said, not something else. [laughter] >> I didn't go to one of those schools. I don't know what you're talking about. I only went to [snorts] >> For whatever reason, my daughter really enjoyed the whole thing. She was on the floor. She's laughing. I was like, "What are you?" Okay, whatever. the people the say I said that triggered this miser that just happened literally three days ago [snorts] [laughter] should have not said the story [laughter] it's one of those okay [laughter] [clears throat] >> if you're not going to make him I'm going to have to make He had wanted to cut. He doesn't know anything about he wanted to make he wanted to make an incision in an animal. But over here that he just he dropped a knife. He didn't have to cut. Maybe it shouldn't be a good. So it is a good because it had the power of a human being. But if I was just say the case over here that he dropped a knife at least it came from a person that has over there we're talking about maybe it shouldn't be considered movement at all. You need the the power of a not just a human being a human. No in all these cases it's a good >> what? Oh, there's a whole Gar now B is about cutting and not cutting. And then the Gar actually says that it doesn't make sense that cutting should be a thing. But the Gmorra says cutting is a thing at least a cut. It's a partial piece of the it's a part of the so I'm going to tell you the end of the according to one means she had meaning she had to go she was to go to the mikvah and she was walking on a bridge and she slipped off the bridge and fell into the water. So we have Raph says this is a thing she's 100% to her husband in other words there's no this by mistake removes carus on the other side on the flip side should beer to consume truma which is only a lesser is than it's a is get the death penalty from heaven but it's not as worse as bad as which also could affect children etc. No, both are the same. This didn't help at all. It wasn't a she certainly didn't say a meaning she didn't show intent. She didn't want to be in the water at that point and it doesn't help her. It's not a no. >> Most people are not aware of these. I don't understand what's going on here. What it removes is so certainly should remove the lesser Iser of Truma. You're not going to believe this. A husband is a piece of the wife is also meaning we are notes. We're not >> but true. >> Huh? >> He's he must be living with that. We we we are we are a piece of he says very willing we what are we learning now become huh >> what about you [laughter] [snorts] really appreciate it really [laughter] says when it comes to you don't have to have any intent but when it comes to Truma it's different. You have to have intent better than this. How do you know this? This nano listen to this. We know you could go bey in in the ocean. Ocean is galdikvah. A wave that's attached to the ocean is part of the ocean. But what about a wave that detaches itself from the ocean detaches 40 of water has to be for a tsunami poof whatever however works the there's an earthquake and down and grabbed water down and pushes water up doesn't matter a whole wave for at least we're talking about a minimum of 40 saw because less than 40 saw there's nothing to talk about you have 40 saw of water flying through the ear a moment ago was mish galik to do to go in the mikvah now it's flying through the air once it's earboard. No, you can't. You can't be toable in it in the ear. But once it lands, you could. Now, first of all, any rainwater that's that landed that's in a pit, that's make ch that's what we make all mikvah out of. That's great. But what if it's in in midair? It's flying through the ear. One edge of it is touching the ground. The other is still in motion coming. It wants to rest on the ground, but it's in motion. And you put a cle, let's say you have a vessel, you have to be type of a vessel that's tom, not a one that you bought in the tom vessel. And you you're standing up, so you don't want to bend down to the ground. You grab the wave in midair. Which part of it is touching the ground and part of it is flying through the air. That's okay. That's called not keeping Russian. That's called Russian. Russian. You're you're grabbing the head of it when the the bottom of it is touching the ground. So says the this wave is detached and has 40. So we're going to have to see exactly what type where it was, but it's right now it's not it's not attached to the to the to the ocean. It could it has the power to give to a person and to a vessels since the human being and the are mentioned together. So the similar you know that a doesn't have to have kavana doesn't have d doesn't have a brain. So a person also not real quickly remind of the story because it has it has a good muser hasll if you think about it. There was a a grandmother walking with her grandchild on the shore and all of a sudden one of these giant waves came out of nowhere. You see it all the time. You know people take pictures and all of a sudden they get knocked off. So this giant wave comes knocks the grandmother grabs the child and rips him into the ocean. So she starts crying to she says, "I never really asked you for anything in my entire life. I'm asking you this one time. Give me back my grandchild. Give me back. Mama is crying, crying." Nine seconds later, another wave comes and pushes her her grandson right out. And she grabs him and she says tom, "But where's his hat?" [laughter] The muscal is that sometimes we get a beautiful thing but we're looking at the at the >> get a whole you get your grandchild back and all you care that that's what you're [clears throat] complaining about is the hat I I just melan said the story it happened to me I fell into a sewer you know in shash of um bungalow when I was three or four years old and I almost died and when my father pulled me out the first thing I said aba where's my yarmaka No. Even when I was a young kid, no opposite. That was the right thing to say. You all you cared about was amazing. >> That was good. >> Okay. That That's why you could write a book. That's why you have the right. No, we don't want a book like that. Okay. Who told you there's no here on the way to put the two things says that one of his people that he's very close to went to the cave of the the he's sitting there and he sees dening and crying and I recognize this guy. Wait a minute. I know exactly who this guy is. He waits for the guy to finish. He goes over to him afterwards and he says, "Aren't you so and so?" He says, "Yeah." He says, "What happened? I recognize you. You went off to Derek. You were gone for like 10 years." He says, "You're not going to believe it. I was smoozing with some guy." And this guy tells me, "Do you know that since you left your parents' house 10 years ago, they not once, not even once, did they lock the front door of the house? They're expecting you to come back and when you come back, they don't want the door to be locked. They want you to be able to walk in and realize that you're welcome over here." He says, "Yeah, that's how much." And that that started the process of him coming back. The says that is he's waiting for us more than than a father waits for his child. Maybe this guy is just waiting there and [snorts] waiting for a for a wave to come. So he does have Just like when a person a person talk he could be. So tom the the human being is for the sponsors video sponsors turning of the daff global specialist in international financial services. We have a murder to get video here. [snorts] Here we go. >> So, I told him I'm not spending another shekel and he folded and sold me the cup. Dirt cheap. Awesome. Now, I'm going to go to it. You have to pay for the mikvet. I am not spending another shekel. >> I'll be a little late. I just take the cup to in the sea. >> Okay. >> Excuse me, sir. Beach entry is 20 shekels. I'm not spending another shekele. I'll just wait here. Look at his beard. [music] Yes, I knew it would would work. Tila in a wave is kosher and it's free. [laughter] No, if he's waiting there and it's a wave is when there's a big storm, there's a lot a lot of rain and you sit, let's say, on the bottom of the street, over here called I alone and all this rain water comes down 40 of it and you sit on the bottom and you you sit there in your bathing suit and [snorts] say oh that's no good why is that no good because it's rainwater that's moving rainwater can't move rainwater has to be stationary so I would say that moving seawater should have exera that people would confuse the two commercial works Inami lizar Russian auto keeping. Here we go. Check this out. So this is a detached wave of 40 saw and this is no good for tila. So maybe I should be geyser this kind of thing. I've never seen one of these yet. But I should say that when you have a kipen, it looks like a yamaga, like a kipa, like a a detached a what? >> Canopy. >> Canopy. Okay. Canopy of water. You have a detached thing of water. You should say that it's user to use one that's attached to the ground because you might come to say that a detached one is okay. [clears throat] >> What's the difference when the goal No. So Gaus Nitlash is attached to the ground. You have to say it's attached to the ground because it's not attached to the ground. It's keeping [clears throat] so that's attached to the ground, but it's still a movement is kosher. But I would think that it's not kosher because of this uh this one that's that's completely detached. >> Gaus is Russian >> is Yeah. I I would think that Gaus is Russian. That's what I think. Yeah. And how do you know that you shouldn't be in a detached wave? So obviously when you read this you see right away that does not mean a because he would never ask how do you know this they wouldn't the wouldn't ask it. It would say right away not. So that's why they say on the side that it's not a it's a that you could use a wave that's attached to the ground, but you can't use a detached wave. Something that's midair. You can't be. So, how do we know that you don't need to have any intent when it comes to like we said before that a husband is you don't need to have by by a husband? It's not. So let's just show this again for those who haven't seen it and even those it's a beautiful just the words how the words work here the whole thing is >> fruits aren't tumo unless they were first and there are three that need to be in place in order for the fruits to be the first that they shouldn't be because as long as the pre is not at all even if water fell in it as the fik says Zerua Zauru. The second night that one of the Shiva Mashkin should fall on them which are dash the third tonight that this should be because if water fell on it it's not moer as the says and Only after the pre is and one of the smashkin was put on it. Now the pre is and if a dommy was in it, it becomes okay. So if a fruit had water touch it and you wanted the water to touch it or as we're going to see soon if you want the water even if you don't want the water to touch it you want the water then it's and if a touches the fruit now it can become but without any mash touching it and a shar touches the fruit the fruit is not to so here we have interesting situation perish You have fruit that fell into water. What does he do? He's [clears throat] trying to save the fruit. So he sticks his hand and grabs the fruit. The thing is that this person has hands that are tummy and in order for him to eat food that has to wash his hands. So his intent was to grab the fruit, but he wasn't he didn't have intent to to be to his hands. What's his hands are? So if we stop right here and this is the end of the what do we have now that in order to make your hands tar you don't have to have kavana to put them in the mikvah his kavana was to grab fruit not to be m's hands that's enough how we doing so far >> it's very good no it's and the fruit are not susceptible to to tum But he he had kavana to take the the fruit out of the water. He wash his hands, >> right? To wash his hands and take the fruit out of and but to take the fruit out. He wanted to wash his hands and take I don't rash sticks in his hands are why obviously even without his hands now that he wanted to wash his hands now he wants the water and once he wants the water that's enough to give to give the the fruit the the upon him >> what >> the water >> he doesn't need the water the fruit he wants the water. He wants the water and that's enough. That's if you go to the first line and you see that you put your hands in the water and you don't want to be tire them. You want to grab something that's enough to make them. So too, the woman who fell into the mikvah becomes without. So again, Rav says you don't have to have he says this is incredible. Listen to this. Listen to this. You're not going to believe this. Another unbelievable today. If a person goes into the mikvah and he says, "I'm going into the mikvah to eat my sheni. I want to be able to eat my sheni, but that's it." What's a level above my sheni? Truma. What's a level above truma? >> Kachchim. What's a level above kachim? It depends on the level. It depends on your mind. I could go into the mikvah and be completely tar for one thing and not another thing. I'm going into the mikvah just for I didn't go into the mikvah for truma. So that's it. No good. I'm going to the mikvah truma. I didn't I didn't think about the next level above that which is which is uh so I'm not for incredible it says a person who's he goes into the mikvah over here means he had only for that limits him to the lower level of he's only tar for something low level of but not for the the the next level which is so it says again that he had so over here you see you have to have a second ago you told me that I could put my hands in a mikvah but they become with over here it says he had to have no that's not okay he is already good for if a person is is for it's not good not you have to have for you don't have to have but if he's already good for it's not good enough for which if I would have asked you this question beforehand most of you would have said no a guy went to the mikvah and and he's he's tar for one thing he's tar for everything what's the difference no he only removed one layer of of of tum the rest is he still for those things if a person did but he didn't have any it's as if he didn't go to the at So you see that you have to have means it's as if he didn't go to the mikvah at all he went to the mikvah and and and the first first level of hulen that's automatic without any intent what you need to have intent is trum those things you have to have intent you don't have to have intent so it's ku you didn't go to the mikvah for >> level two which is messer level one you don't have to have any intent. Even if you you fall off a bridge, you're t it is good for says he's just pushing him off, saying, you know, throwing things at him to to get him off his back. Went and looked into it and he found I love this. It's like another he didn't have he started going through and and until he until he realized oh if a person went into the mikvah and it didn't have any he's still good for he's still you don't have to have fits in with you don't have to have the woman doesn't have to have kavana is the one that says that a woman has to have she she can't just fall off a bridge and say, "Oh, I'm t to my husband and that for the lowest level of to be t husband, it's okay without says you're right. It's a great but has backup. He didn't he didn't make this up. These are other previous this referring to a person's clothing that a person that has saras on the clothing. So you have to wash the and you have to wash it again. The word over there is extra. It's to tell us just that the first time you wash it and the second time are the same. You had to have human intent. Now what's the over here? [snorts] The is that a begged what is a beggim or begged is this is yet you have to have intent when I put the begot in a mikvah. I dunk my suit in the mikvah. It's a funny thing. We're not used to it. But when the comes, if our beggs if somebody eats a kosher bird and puts in the back of his neck, he becomes his. Yeah. A tummy bird. Na bird. His suit becomes tummy. See, what do you do with the suit? That's you have to put in the mikvah. But over here it says that it has to have das. You have to have d where [snorts] the twillery. You go like this. You just >> Not the wool suit. >> Not the wool suit. Well, you're not going to have a bravery. You're going to have to do wool suit and then there's going to be special >> saying just going to wear [laughter] >> you should be wearing jalabia. Just come to it. Finished. Alam. Oh. So, what do you see from here? It says mufurish. You need das like like the first washing. The second washing also needs d. you need with clothing on on that says you don't need maybe the f the first washing had have the the intent of the maybe the second one also no the second one doesn't have to have a say that you have to have intent there's a clout that says that when a Mishna doesn't bring down a name. There's a reason why Rebi took out the name. It's not that there was no name. He knew the name. Let's say he knew it's Rebecca, but he wanted you to know that this is the way we pass him. So he figured if I put Rika's name in there, you're going to think, "Oh, it's only but everybody argues on him." So I'm telling you, no, no, no. This is an anonymous Mishna is like this and that's it. That's you should know this. So it says is always like an anonymous and it says in an anonymous our knife fell and created even though it's a perfect and we asked it's because it fell by itself but if he knocked it down on purpose it's a good and there's no this says you don't have to This is the ribbon of of Morocco video. He threw a knife and bounced off the walls, shut an animal kosher, but it's anonymous Mishna holds like that anonymous Mishna and it says anonymous. You don't have to have what's the answer? You're right. Is going to agree that you don't have to have but you have to have and other stuff. that yeah why it's you don't have to have almost there's a special that tells that you have to have in the mdash that tells me that outside of the you don't have that but that's great wow it's already E13 says, "So now make this distinction." Oh, so who's Raon? Rabon by the knife. They say that if you throw a knife and you didn't know that there's a cow and a cow, it's no good. Why? We have a big problem. We just said that only in the B mikdash, if you throw a knife, you don't have it's not good. But it is good. So says, "Okay, I'll answer that." You don't have to have to but at least you have to have to cut which Noah in the beginning of the year didn't like. This is where beat because it makes no sense to cut it. So if you need to have say make the distinction between cutting and if you need to have for cutting then you have to have for if you don't have to have now let's just finish this what does it mean that she was forced to be if it means that her friend took her and forcibly threw her into the mikvah Just like when you take a clea and you put it in a mikvah, >> you didn't ask the cle permission. So too, if you take another human being and document mikvah, it's a good >> I want to ask you a question. I want to ask you a question. What if what if listen to this >> boarding? >> What if raise your hand if you think this is good. A person falls off a bridge and another person, a friend is watching this and is completely composed and instead of screaming, "Oi," she says, "I want that to be >> new friends." >> Is that is that a good feel or not? Could another person have nothing to do with her falling just happened to be watching, could she put a doss into this? Now we just said if a person takes another person physically and dunks them in the mikvah that is a good enough d force somebody to go to the mikvah but somebody that watches on the side is that a good feel yes or no is anybody in this room does anybody in this room say that it's okay it's a good let's say it's a good so then you don't need another person okay whatever fine listen this when it comes to trauma you have a shait though. Did I tell you the story about my grandchildren? >> Okay. [laughter] You have a person that's completely [laughter] off the rail off the rocker. Listen to When it comes to Truma, you got to have an Arabus a woman who makes sure that everything is kosher, that this person is right to go to the mikvah. She grabs the dunks her in the mikvah and she could eat truma. So says good real quickly. How did it happen? Like we said the whole time she fell off a bridge. So it's a complete and so says that you don't have to have says you do. So Raf says just like you don't you have to have kavana. So, you don't have to have says no is different than the next is this is a little tricky. Don't run out yet. Listen, she went into the water to cool off her feet. And then what happened? She slipped and fell. But listen to the here. No. This is what you you said before. You had a problem with this. There's a say there's between this cutting and the what's cutting cutting is noting. Cutting is cutting cuts. So cutting is a little bit of So over here we have something similar. There's a little bit of going to the mikvah. A little bit. It's not enough to fall off a bridge because there was zero in falling off a bridge. Over here there's a mice of mikvah. What? Putting in part of your feet in there. It's like cutting. It's part of it's a little bit of so a little bit of of is putting in the feet and then you fell in for the rest. >> And on that there's anime. Hold on. >> She wants them to go swimming. >> No, no, no. That's something that's a complet swimming. >> That's something else. So let me just finish so we can go to chakras between rab and again there's anina just like by it's enough to have cavana for cutting and not so by also it's enough to have kavana to go into to the water a little bit and not a complete and says no needs complete and it's different than have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.