Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 16 by R' Eli Stefansky

[music] [singing] [music] [singing] [music and singing] [singing] [singing and music] [singing] >> I go to have Shabbos around BOYS SIDE. >> [screaming] >> WHO NEEDS MERCY miracles and all the kind live from Morocco. From the Banyan Tree. The nicest hotel that I've ever been to. MDY, top of the top. Yossi Klein. Only the best. The best of the best of the other. >> [applause] >> I want to mention our unbelievable caters and the ones who organized the whole trip. The Nesiya, Nesiya's travel. Yishar Koach to Shimi Weiss and all the guys that are working very hard and tirelessly. So, wherever we went, we had three singers and a band. And for Shabbos, we have five singers and no band. Uh it's just incredible. We have two of the top speakers in Klein Israel today, Rabbi Ari and Yossi Ben Shushan. Together they they mamish they Yesterday we had a I said it already in sheer comic relief. It was just spontaneous good vibes, good let's honest. It was unbelievable. And wherever we go, of course, it's Torah. Right now, we're just a couple of hours before Shabbos. And we're sitting learning Torah. This morning, we had a sheer for an hour. And uh it's Torah. It's chatzi lachem v'chatzi l'Hashem. It's a lot of gashmius and a lot of ruchnius and a lot of uh chavrusaft and and bonding and and seeing great places and doing it's just a it's unbelievable experience. Unbelievable. And we're very much looking forward to Shabbos. Shabbos kodesh. It's going to be unbelievable. Um a few things. I want to remind all of them to say Sefiras HaOmer. So, depending on where you are and what you are, this might be the day. This might be the day. Um Sefiras HaOmer is the first time I'm learning Mishnayos. K'vod Kedushas Moreinu v'Rabbeinu Yisrael ben Leah Esther l'forash l'eima. Dov, I have to I have to apologize. I just I want to be selfish. I want to be able to see the view. Cuz that that's pretty much my only chance today or during this trip. I was hoping I was really counting on going after this year. It's going to be 2 hours and I'm going to go. And then the the internet fell and uh we put it back up and kids are Um this we saw yesterday. So, these are the the security guards. They they >> [laughter] >> Me. >> [laughter] >> And then and then >> [laughter] >> And now you have uh Benny's son who's 10 years old. He thought that his father is real in the AI. And he says sends him a message. He says, "You explain p'shat very well." He says. [laughter] Here it is. Here. Oops. Maybe I have to click it there. I'll click. Daddy. Bye. Mushroom only. >> [laughter] >> Heavy duty with shininess. Um yeah, he calls him daddy. Very interesting. Sure I'll make a belly. I'll try to keep it short. It's something of base since something of base which equals 2,000 days straight of Torah. The emails that say I've never missed a day are definitely a harsh of accomplishment. Recifus is incomparable to fragmented learning. At the same time however, even if one can't say that they never missed a day if they're still in the Yummy mentality, each day stands alone and it's better no matter what happened yesterday. Thank you for 2,000 days. See my email from November 24th, 2020. Yankel Sham Schreiber, he has enclosed a song called Shabbos song with my brother my brother-in-law and he was in Yummy growing from the Hebrew sheer. I didn't get this here yet. Makes no difference. So this [snorts] I thought was very interesting cuz I got in the same day or very very behind the new emails. Uh but we'll try to have some good ones. Two of them from a Yeshiva bocher and a Kyle guy. So the mainstream so to speak. I'm a bocher in Yeshiva bocher Sham I'm successful in my learning. However, even during my breaks I started getting into watching movies and TV shows. One of my friends suggested MDY and at first I brushed it off saying nah, what I needed for I'm bocher in Yeshiva. I love it. He's bocher in Yeshiva but movies are okay but the Yummy is terrible. I learned MDY I I I learned MDY for a bottom but he insisted saying how I'd love it. It's interactive and entertaining etc. So I decided to join for good. Now I know I shouldn't speak too soon but since we started changed me. Instead of going to my room at breaks to watch movies, I now go to watch the sheer. Even though I've learned this part of cool in the past already learning on a whole new level with the props and picture. I really hope it goes through the whole cool and if the taket t a k k e h goes well, maybe I'll continue with the highest. Thank you so much hot sloka the oil. Dear everybody my letter is not like all the other letters. I'm going to stand out letters and call letters. I learn in college all day truly enjoy my learning and have tremendous satisfaction from it. In the evenings when I no longer have the concentration to keep learning I enjoy watching this year usually just the videos and it gives me a real when in parentheses somebody says I usually just watch the videos that means I watch the sheer at one speed from beginning to end not even a 1.2 speed that's what usually what it means that's code that's my code. I spoken enough people to know that that's what it means. What? 0.75 and sometimes he does three or four times but he's a guy he says listen I I don't always watch the whole sheer a lot of times it's just the the videos okay. Now when a boss says it a boss tells me listen I watch this year every day I'm doing well that's code for I see my friend's status once a month maybe once every two weeks I saw that video of 30 seconds that's what it means they said as always that's the side. So Thank you very much I wanted to point out a few things there was a video about sending the it appeared that the lottery box was made of gold but specifically says it was made out of wood. that roof yeah they did a with water not listening means a hard rock okay great. Shkoyach. This is from a woman in Israel who says I have to I have to let you know that I've been doubting for my husband was a great guy he's a Yeshiva product and he tries to learn whenever he can but he tried here and there didn't really work and I'm doubting for years and finally found the sheer it's a treasure under the bridge. The time of the came she says. It's my mission close to where we live. It's a beautiful atmosphere. blah blah blah Gut Shabbos All right, Reb boys, I the official edition MDY Shas. He's sitting right next to me on my left. Maseches Zev and Yael Shulhof Perek the Benedict family We're we're working Noam and I and and our staff cuz it's a it's a full-time job this this Shas. We're working on that Meyer is going to come to me one day. But in all seriousness, now he's going to say, "Yeah, now also." No. When he really comes and says, "Listen, this is the best investment of my life. Mom, I got a great deal." That's that's what we're that's what we're working towards. It's going to happen soon. Daf Tes Zayin by Reb Yaakov Bleich in memory of my father Reb Reuven ben Reb Ephraim Fischer's corner of So, he just did one. Didn't he do Tes Vav or something? Okay. David Solomon dedicated in memory of his mother Reb Shmuel Boruch ben Reb Chaim Tzvi Deutsch alav hashalom. The Posick Family Foundation in gratitude and to the consortium and the alliance and all they do to support MDY. Anonymous alav hashalom begashmius and thank you to Chief Benny. Anonymous for his full name and everything alav hashalom. Yoel ben Daniel Rosenfeld brings us simcha. Does the oilam know that we're giving shiur? They They don't care. They're in the spot right now. Okay, so in the room, that's it. Whatever they decide to do, they do. Ari Simon for his full name alav hashalom Boruch ben Miriam ben Yoel ben Daniel Rosenfeld ben Reb Shmuel ben Chaim. Moshe Reuven Markovich our weekly sponsor proudly supporting Daf Yomi in Spanish. for his full name alav hashalom Yaakov ben Lulu Meshulam Dear, mazel tov Yaakov Schreiber on your seal. It's good for you and for his full name alav hashalom ben Chaim ben Shmuel. Howard Wimmer alav hashalom ben Miriam Chaim ben Avraham ben Nachum and in honor of Bernie Litwak who got me to MDY 2 years ago this week. Bernie the bird, gebaldig. Anonymous, mazel tov Turey Klivat, how do you pronounce it? Pulievach. Pulievich. Pulievich. Oh, Boris of Turetsky Pulievich, one of the biggest investors in Jewish education worldwide. I heard a lot about him. All right. Anonymous, for the merit of shidduch for Sora Goldenbass and Rivka. Daniel Cahan. In loving memory of Chana Bas Yisrael Moishe on yahrzeit Yom Yerushalayim. Meyer Damby, oh we miss Meyer. Where is he? This master Eliyahu Getzel ben Yitzchak Halevi Reiman, zechor tzaddik livracha. Anonymous, refuah shleima for Avraham Yishaya ben Slave devorah and Rebbe Ruchama ben Yehuda. HYK Ventures in the zechus for success of all our clients. The young man Daniel Rosenblum, bracha u'v'racha shleima. Is it called a sponsor? Did I say those were called a sponsors? HYK Ventures. HYK sponsors Mordechai Kanievsky and Zev Wolf Kieve. Feiga. And refuah shleima for Chaya. It's a big zechus for us that Mordy Rubin and everything going around, he's here learning with us. This guy doesn't have social awareness. >> [laughter] [clears throat] >> Situation. What what I say? Social situational awareness. Here, bring that bring that robe here for a second. What I say? Just as a this this beautiful robe. Check this out. Check this out. I told one size fits most. >> [laughter] >> That's a nice way of saying it fits more than me. What I say? What I say? Next year believe in that there. Next trip believe in that there. Yossi Klein is going to do a custom-made robe for Meyer Feigel. Custom. They're going to come 3 months before with four different sizes just in case you go up or go down in weight. The official edition a What I said, this right here is skinny man's edition robe. I would look at the fabric. Look at this. Look at this. It's It's not a joke. This is high end. You want to bet? Great. What else do we have? Um MDY Art month for me Jonathan the man Sheva Bracha. Oh, this is a big so I was going to say that Mordy Rubin he got on a plane and came just for Shabbos. He did He did an unbelievable job of just all the stuff that that has to do with Morocco and the the history and different things and hugging and just different bottom. He spent hours upon hours and he spends hours upon hours on our website. He just showed me brand new app MDY app. So, you should go to my Thank you for enhancing my Shabbos. It was a big surprise. Thank you Mordy. Uh turning of the daf. Not there yet. Okay. What did I say? I didn't? First name Jonathan Oh, you're right. I wonder why. MDY Art. Refuah Shlema Jonathan ben Bracha. Refuah Shlema Mordechai ben Esther. Refuah Daniel ben Esther. Omar Mar. They're holding up the design of the daf. Guys have it. Design of the daf. Omar Mar. I am working with the shears. Very interesting Sugyas as usual. Shulchan Aruch turning out to be fascinating. If somebody shechts with a wheel, with a machine, so here's a picture. Here's the machine. So, there's a wheel, but the wheel itself is not what's doing the cutting. There's a knife on the bottom of the wheel. It's a little sideways, but okay, you get the idea. And you put the animals this way and it shechts by you pushing some lever which pushes which turns the knife which cuts the animal says the Gamara, it's a good shita even though it's on a wheel, it's like a machine. Mukhni is like a mukhana like a like a machine. But Tanya shita is pasula. But it says somewhere else that we even mentioned it, the shita is pasul. So you if you use a machine it's pasul. It'd be great. Imagine you put a a knife on a machine and all the shitas have to do is move animals past the machine. Cut cut cut. He doesn't have to do anything with the zed. They got you. Ha bisarna de fakhra. There's a machine they used to use to make earthenware. Today I know that they have these machines that spin the earthenware and with your hand you mold it in certain ways. Maybe that's what it is. I have no idea. But they used to use a machine. And that is considered koah adam. It's the power of the person, the human being, pushing a pedal with his foot, with his hand. It's it's it's human power. Like a like a bicycle. A bicycle would be human power. You go like this and you're powering with your legs. Oh, but ha bisarna de maya. When you have a What is this called in English? A wheel that turns from the water. A water wheel, okay. What a what what a khap. A water wheel, it gets all its power from Hakadosh Baruch Hu. Human zero intervention at all. And that turns and spins a knife, that's no good. Now there is one situation where a water wheel would be okay. Water mill, but that's the mill. This is not a mill. This is for uh for shita. What is the case where a water wheel works? And it's okay. When you open up the water and the initial gush of water starts the wheel to spin. That is considered human power. Why? Cuz with your human power you open up the water and the water came and pushed it. 5 seconds later, however many seconds it is, 2 5, it's already no longer it's no longer human power. That is already from the from the from the water. A great example would be if you're on a plane you're on a you're in a in a restaurant somewhere and there's no water uh thing. You have to wash your hands. So what do you do? You want to wash negel vasser in the morning woke up on a plane. You're on a United flight and you want to what? What do you do? So a good aid to me is to push the water and stick your hand in immediately or stick your hand, push the push the button. Take your hand out. You have to wait for it to stop and then you do it again. There's only like 25 pushes like that on a plane and then the water runs out so you got to be careful. Yeah. So that's what they say. NO. NO. Y'ALL SEE. Y'ALL SEE. You can't you can't do anything about this noise. >> [laughter] [snorts] >> I was once at a shear and a cat came by and Rebyosi ben Shushan said machlokes machlokes machlokes and the cat died on the spot. >> [laughter] [laughter] >> Yeah. No, seriously. You know what it means to be on a trip that all 7 days you have the the ben Shushan brothers? They They speak and I can't wait for the for the Shabbos. I don't want to put the pressure on. No pressure. Just remember Rebyosi uh of you, you can't make me cry. It's also the crying showers, yeah? It's easy. We can't You got to be Just try. Very good. Very good. And now they might tell us the other answer. That even with the water will there's a way that it's mutar to shecht with and there's ways assur. Because like because of rishon, the initial burst of water is considered your force. Your force, good good shechita. How about acharonim? But once you whatever that acharonim is, 2 seconds later, 5 seconds later, the the turning a complete um rotation of the wheel, then it's already or whatever it is, I'm not sure what it is, something it's already not your it's already water that's going to continue going. Imagine I turned on I opened up the the dam. And now it's my for for 45 years. No way. It lasts only for a few seconds and that's it. Then the rest is is is Hashem pushing the water through. Says the Gemara like Rava Papa, great story. If somebody ties up his friend and he puts on him some sort of stream of water and he dies he drowns. Chiyuv. Why why why is he chiyuv? You did not obey. This is shooting an arrow at somebody. So over here he shot a bunch of water on him until he died. But how do you know this is because of rishon? If he died from the initial force, I will shine you grow but once it's the second force whatever that means that he's patur. We have a video. Take a look. This will explain the whole sugiya. I recommend that everybody that's behind the screen should come to the front of the screen. You're able to see? You know it's a lot of fun. It's fun. I'm going to go get the cash. Wait here. >> This is the most gruesome video we've ever done. What's good eye? >> [laughter] [laughter] >> Yeah. The device the device of dial is going to remember that you know what? Okay. So it's good my alma. How you doing? You enjoying? Yeah, I'm good. I just I was >> [laughter] >> That's okay. It's okay. Go. Yeah, yeah. Thank you. We finish soon. You also rather heard Rabbi here says the more my son. You know in in in Yeshiva it's not like this. Let's say Rabbi sitting where I'm sitting a time of the sitting right in front and then there's the second row. Rabbi imagine this Rabbi who's the God of the other but he started out somewhere. He learned by Rabbi. Rabbi was the one who wrote the Mishnah and Rabbi is the the first time I wrote. Rabbi was the last time I wrote. Rabbi was the first time I wrote slightly a time I wrote. They call him he's uh time I wrote we could consider him a time I wrote because where's the cut off line exactly? So he he's right there. Even Rabbi who was his contemporary is not considered a time I wrote. So but at a certain point he sat behind Rabbi here. He was in row two. He wasn't up front. Uh when I learned in in the sake I learned in the sake for two years so in order to sit in row one the true ones sat there. You know the guys that you should for a long time and then the guys that understood the sheer the sheer row one. I was row seven. You know what I mean? Like for two years. Yeah yeah. What? With who? With Rabbi? Yesterday? Listen yes this is too far away. No yeah you're pushing it. So you also rather heard the Rabbi here. Rabbi who who's Rabbi here now? Who's Rabbi here? You wrote the you wrote the braces. You also rather heard the Rabbi here. Rabbi here come in the Rabbi. Rabbi here sits in front of the Rabbi. You be also Rabbi come in. The Rabbi says when I was here he wrote how do you know he wrote it must be done with something detached from the ground. It can't be attached to the ground. Rabbi here now takes the knife to shut it's hard. So the Rabbi says you know there's a whole thing here. How do you prove from here this before my entire okay. I call upon him there's no TV for Shlita. Because I'm a class. He went and he took something that's detached. Why else would it would the tire tell us that he took the knife? All the all the Rav so Rav was sitting in row two taps his you know row one says my camera what is he talking about? What is Rebbe talking about? So listen you know it's kind of a it seems like almost. All the way above the was the camera. I I'm very proud of Yossi. I I told him I don't like what another artist did because the the other artist and it goes according to one of the they say he did it with the grain. I I wanted I felt it should be against the grain. I felt I like that shot better. So I So this is more like it against the grain. You're writing above against the grain so you have a ton of cuts in the valve. It's it's split up. So in in like 23 seconds he sends me back the new version and it's all fixed. Great. So basically he's saying Rebbe tells Rav you're right. It's a good thing you tap me on the shoulder because I I I I agree with you 100%. I don't think Rebbe knows what he's talking about. That's basically what they're saying. Rebbe Rebbe Kodesh tell me them mistake. Okay? So he says the the crow camera brings a right from what he he's not saying to listen. He says cross you missed it from what you said. Rebbe here is telling Rav that this possible you can't bring a right from the possible. The tire is just telling us what Rebbe knew how how how how he had reasons. What's reason mean? He didn't want to have any issues with knives and looking for a knife. I'm going to get there I'm going to have it. I'm going to do it. It remind me of my mission of the Maggid, himself. He brought a knife to Morocco to have Zrizus. We have a Shvirah. Just Just so he can say Then I felt I felt good. I felt good cuz you told me that you're scared of the knife. And Baruch Hashem, you worked on yourself and and hopefully you won't have trauma when I show the knife in Shiur. You just watching Benny. He goes like this every time. Every time he swings it. Yeah. Don't worry about it. I come see later. And listen, if there's blood, it's better rating ratings. The blood crawl on my craw is not a problem at all. Great. So I'll talk to you tomorrow. Omar Rava. Just want to make sure we have everything. Oh, what's this? What was this? I didn't Oh, we didn't get there yet. Uh uh uh Uh okay. You have all the >> [snorts] >> Omar Rava. Pshita Li Tolish Mi Devarim Sheb'Avodah Zarah Have a Tolish. So first, Rava starts out talking about Avodah Zarah. And then he brings it back to our Sugya when it comes to Shchita. Now, what? How do we view something that used to be detached and you made it something attached? For instance, a brick. You build a home. Everything in this hotel right here behind us, all these beams, were once upon a time detached. They weren't attached. They detached. Unless, you know, they they got them from the ground or something. But these are all man-made materials, probably, like cement or whatever. Detached. So when you take something detached and you attach it, then it becomes a Muchbar, does it have a Halacha of detached or attached? Which one is it? So, there's a Halacha in Avodah Zarah that tells us that if it's attached, it cannot become a It's Mutar B'Hana'ah. So in other words, if I worship a mountain if he worships a mountain for a desire, he cannot make the mountain also. He can make an animal also because it's detached. He can make a glass into a desire, but he cannot make a mountain. Why? Because the mountain is the whole world. What about a house? What about a house? Can you make a house of a desire? The answer is yes. And why? How can you explain it? The only way to explain it is cuz it used to be detached and it's attached now. But this is the fact that it's attached now. Let's make it attached. So, therefore, he says, "You see what happened, Dave? The sun went behind me now. In the morning, it was we were on the opposite. Now, it's made a full circle. It's weird how that happens even in Morocco. The sun goes >> [laughter] >> Morocco's flat here. Morocco's Morocco's flat. Huh? Later. I've never been This is I I I I have to say this out loud cuz I know you're thinking it. This is the first time that I could think of that the oil wants to get stuck in Morocco for a few more weeks. >> [laughter] >> Yeah, yeah. What? Trump is going to bomb? Yeah, I think it's I think it's happening. And what are we going to do? What? We're going to stay in the banyan tree for 3 weeks? Oy vey. Oy vey. What about the kids? Oy no. Yes. Yes. She loves Please bomb. Please. First time ever. Wow. He's got to do what he's got to do. No, no, we might have to stay here. >> [laughter] >> Which wasn't the banyan tree. Which wasn't the banyan tree. >> [laughter] >> With the Ventriloquism Brothers. As long as we can get the meat from Europe. The only thing we have one problem, we don't have any sperm. What are you going to learn? Okay, the Vietnam. Okay, all my brothers. She So, we said this. Oh. No, I'm not. I must have a little bit of oil and sorrow. So, here I want to stop for a second. This was a body cuz I I told him already what I was going to say here. I'm just talking about the by shul, I believe is is a is a common thing in chutz la'aretz. We don't have it that much in Eretz Yisrael. Uh especially in the neighbors that we live in. There are neighbors and nice neighbors in Eretz Yisrael, but not not in Beit Shemesh. In America, you have a mishakhavel by shul. Guy builds a gorgeous house. He puts in his whole thing. Sometimes you see people I know a guy in his 80s that's that built a house. Mamash in his 80s. Uh like and What are you thinking? By the time it's done, by the time you move in, like what what is what's going on here? Seriously. That's very You don't need a good actually for that one. And and people No, people start building these houses in their 50s, 60s. This is it's very interesting. So, you mishakhavel, you you go, you buy the marble from here, and you this and that. But what's what's what's beautiful? When I was we built a beautiful house in Chicago, right? 1,100 square feet. And one of my friends built 11,000. What did I say? 11,000 square feet. And one of my friends one of my friends' wife I just saw in in the she's she was in a Fortune 500 and a very famous firm lady, very masculine. They built a house with a basketball court inside. I was like, "What a shock house I have." And then and the next guy I'm not I'm not Okay, you can't make this stuff up. He has a basketball court and then he says, "I'm going to have a pool AND A BASKETBALL COURT." And one of the guys, one of my best friends, uh he's part of the shul. I I I even gave a bunch of shul members house. He has a He has a pool that makes the Byern trees' pool look like mamash like like like a mikvah in the in the in the Mea Shearim. It's gorgeously gorgeous. So, the the point is that no matter what you have. Then I thought about it. Hey, yesterday we were in a unbelievable hotel. I was I myself was taking pictures. I built a hotel once. And my family's into hotels. We have hotels and cool and cool. And I really appreciated this hotel. This hotel, the design, the Moroccan had a room there. I don't know if you guys saw this Moroccan restaurant. The cigar bar and a dish and that and the ceilings the entry And then you come here and it's like, what? That that piece of garbage? It's rubbish garbage hotel like like if we would have stayed there I would have been rubbish happy. But Shabbos in the Radisson of of the Maria Maris. Sorry, yeah. I don't I know they changed them. The Marriott in Fez rubbish tops tops. It was one of the nicest hotels I've been to period. But my say compared to this it's like it's garnished. And then I remember what Rabbi Reuven Shushan told me this morning. He said you know what the biggest Gehenna is? The biggest Gehenna is when you get up to Gan Eden and they show you unbelievable mansion and you look next door and you see that's half the size of the guy next to you. That is Gehenna. Gehenna. You're in Gan Eden but it's Gehenna. No? It's it's What? No. I don't whatever. I mean Gan Eden. Reb Elly's room has a second bedroom. Yeah. Is that >> [laughter] >> So everybody here has a You can't even You can't even use it. You can't even use it. It's like Yeah, it's the same thing. Right. >> [snorts] >> I'll just I'll just I'll just move out of the way. >> [laughter] >> Yeah. This is recorded. Don't worry. It's hidden recording. Yossi has it all figured out. All right. So that's I'm just talking about the issue. The point is that you get a chisel. You get a chisel cuz at the end of the day even if when you get up there and you get a Gan Eden with the with the there's going to be rivers and Zaken and ocean from views but it's going to hurt how much more you could have had. And you don't realize how much more you could have had until you see it. You only see it when We didn't know that this is a Muslim even. But, once you're in the Muslim, like What? I'm going to go to Holiday Inn now? I'm going to go to How do you do it? How do you How do you What? Yeah. Okay? Zog the Gemara. Beautiful. Zog the Gemara. So, if you if you bow to your own house, a sorry, you make your house awesome. The what? That there's a Muslim that their gods are on the mountains, but not the mountains are the gods. The The mountain can't be a god. The mountain can't be a mizara. Just the mizara on the mountain. There's a possuk that tells us a famous we said in we had this in a mizara that a mountain that's cannot be a mizara. You can't answer it. And we have to understand why a house is awesome. And the answer is cuz a house started out not and you made it a mizara. This is different. Let me show you. You know, you can go. Go go go go go by the seder. No, men. Let Let men go by. Just It's It's fine. It's fine. What? >> [laughter] >> He said he said He said men, not boys. They just It's Ask me if Ask me if it bothered me. The kid was in a Do it again. I don't care. It depends where. It depends what. All on the matzah. Oh. So, now we have a beautiful Let me show you this. Again, if you don't remember this video. Oh. First of all, ele hayem al haram. Here's Here's a ele hayem al haram Rebbi Shaya, take a look. >> [groaning] >> So, you can't You can't make a a har of avoda zara. Why would some He's trying to It's always an explanation. Why would somebody want to worship a a mountain? Does it save his life? So, Oh, sweet pinzo. Tell him not to call him else here, please. Oh, my Does he not Oh, cuz he doesn't have to We're doing this. Now, Rebbi Shaya, this is one of my favorites. It's a recent one, but it's one of my favorites. In order for any food item to become tame, it has to be muchal tuma. It has to have uh a situation where you put you put one of the seven liquids on it. Water, let's call it. Blood, water, dew. Min ha Torah, fruits aren't mekabel tuma unless they were first muchal mekabel tuma. And there are three tnayim that need to be in place in order for the fruits to be muchal to Unbelievable. First tnai, that they shouldn't be muchal mekabel tuma. Because as long as the pri is muchal As long it's not mekabel tuma at all, even if water fell on it. As the pasuk says, zera zarua asheri zarea tahor hu. The second tnai, that one of the shivas mashkin should fall on them, which are machsher them mekabel tuma. Yayin, devash, shemen, chalav Look at the blood. The blood The third tnai, >> [sighs] >> That this should be muchal the same color. Because if water fell on it little tunnel. It's not more sure. As the text says for you done. And we're going to clean for you done. That's over the water. And only after the priest told me that I They see this. One of the machine was put on it both of them are on it. Now the priest martial art capital tournament. And if it over told me was in the game in it, it becomes Tommy. Oh. Now, I want to tell you a few more for the sewer. Another dish. If you want to use the water for any other purpose, stop. You want to use the water. And then that water touches your fruit, it's also martial arts capital tournament. You don't need to put the to want the water to go on your fruit. You need to want the water, let's say, to wash out your path. And then the water goes. Now. Right? Even if it if if whatever that that usage was, even if it wasn't for food it's considered cute. But it has to be something that's not correct. Let's say I want water to wash my roof. I have too much dust on my roof on my on my on my skylight. So I want the water to wash it down. And then the water goes and hits my fruit. It's not martial arts capital tournament. Why? Because that water was for my neighbor. Now that we know this, we go by there. It says this not. Oh, we have to write in tonight. So now we have when it comes to martial arts capital tournament. This not. How can we all the somebody flips over a bowl on a wall. Why did he flip it over? Because he took that. So that the the vessel should be rinsed out. How is the that water is good enough to go on the fruit and make the martial arts capital tournament because I wanted the water to wash out my my dish, and my dish is not kava karka. Bishul shul What if I put I flip over the pot so that my wall that I just painted shouldn't get wet? Any because that's for the wall and not for something that's tallish. It's for a which is a wall. Wall's kava. As I go over this I'm just going to I'm just going to share this cuz food my head I shouldn't be talking about this, but it doesn't matter. I'm going to say it anyway. Am I getting into trouble? Is this So this thing itself, I don't know if anybody noticed, but to me it seems like we're going a lot of times and we're fighting for things that are less important than important things. For instance, the The was shut down. was shut down for a long time. I haven't heard one protest. Not one person tried to break into the that I know of. But the by like by man. Oh, that's a that people went crazy in their protest and they broke in all the But isn't the I don't understand. Isn't it No, it's the so. No, it's sometimes people make a bigger fuss out of the to me. I don't get I'm going to get into trouble for some What do you mean? How can you compare? Yeah, but maybe the is more I don't know. People might tell me that. I don't know. But even if they do, I don't care. I'm I'm just saying what I what I The I don't remember anybody making a So it was shut down for a month. Who cares? You can't go to the No, no. Okay. By there. Oh, it's talking today. Yeah, today. Oh. Oh. I should have said that I should have said that how to say. I had a I had the opportunity. Okay. So tomorrow Oh, she said she said she said hello. Talk to me more. So, says in tomorrow. I can't let them surely agree then. What time is it? So, we are What's the What's the What's the catch? If you do it to wash out the dish, that's considered good water to be master of the capital. But, if you did it to wash the wall, ain't no big deal. So, washing the wall is not a is not a is not good water. If you flipped over the dish to protect the wall, then it's not good water. Then I can infer I can make a deal. But, if you want to wash the wall, so then I I'm inferring two opposites. So, what do I do? So, one one option is I'm going to blow the cover. You're right, it's a broken thing. It's a like this. And this [clears throat] is exactly what Robert referred to before. They have a like this when it comes to >> [cough] [clears throat] >> One man holds that by my neighbor. My neighbor you you want the water from my neighbor, it is considered good water for my natural capital. One holds not. No, this is one kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a The wall of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of a kind of Meaning it was You dug out a a cave, but there's a cave. The wall was there from the beginning. So, that's my neighbor. It's my neighbor from the beginning. But, you have a wall that you built like a hotel wall. That's a hotel that's man-made. So, even though it's to the car, it's not considered my neighbor. This is what I meant to say. If you flip over a ball on a wall because you want to rinse out your cleat, then it's considered good water for for for most of the capital tone. But, if you want the wall to get clean, that's not considered good water. We're in tomorrow because we know and then it goes on to explain we're going to explain the difference is if it's a pre-existing wall from time of then it's considered we're going to go to being. But, if it's a regular wall from a home that you're doing it that the the wall the the wall shouldn't get get wet. Sorry. If you don't want the wall the wall to get ruined, it's not considered good water. But, if you want that the wall should get rained on and and and cleaned, then it is considered good water. Now, how does this whole thing have to do with it? So, by rubber tells us in my eye. What if you have a knife and you attach it to a wall? Is it considered or not the turning of the dub by the global specials in the international financial services You know what? I It hit my head now so I'm going to say it's sometimes it's not a good thing. I don't have a good a filter. Naturally, I I like my filtration system is not the best. But, this one is not bad. Myer Fischel told me that he gave up his massage. Now, the massages are very harsh. Seriously. It's top end. It's It's It's not some massage. It's banging through massage. My wife told me it's the best massage she ever got. I hate to make you feel bad. He gave it up so he can come to sheer. And then the guy he gave it to he gave it to somebody cuz he didn't want it to go to waste. He gave it to a guy. The guy came over to me before sheer. He said, "What do you What do you What do you think? Massage or your sheer?" I said, "Massage. 100% massage." He started hugging me. He thought I was going to tell him no sheer. No, massage. For him he needs to go massage. If you even have a suffolk, you have to massage. Why? Because at the end of the day it's a one once in a lifetime opportunity. You have a thing, you'll make up the sheer later hopefully. And you don't want to hurt yourself because then you're going to regret it the whole shot. No. Torah has to be in a good smack. We learn Torah and then that's another thing about this trip. That it's a big point of the trip that we're able to enjoy life and do good smack of things and then go ATVing and camel riding and then and some of us even jumped out of planes. No scuba diving. That's because of whatever reason. But it goes we could combine the two. We could learn Torah and be early diving the minion and and and and learn Torah and also have a good time. It's not a stira. And have massages and all that stuff. Okay. >> [snorts] >> Don't worry. I'll make it like it's going to pay him up his massages a different way. Okay. So what's the question? Question is if you take a knife you take something and you plant it into a wall what's the guy who shita? Is it considered and it's no good or is it totally it's considered totally and it is good? It's a good touch my he actually did some cool things. I don't know which one is what. I'm supposed to know this by myself but they're all they all look the same here. Are they? Yeah, but that's I don't know. Oh, here. Let's call this one, okay? There's a there's a stone coming out of a wall. That that's good that's a good one, right? Because everybody can tell that this wall now I saw a wall similar to this here I guess in in the the yards of the rooms has this kind of stuff. But everybody can tell this is man-made, right? This is not this is not I have the two bedrooms. You all have the same room. Just I have two bedrooms. Why? Because of that maybe maybe if the Okay, I'm not going to go there. They saw how much time I spent with my wife preparing to share. They figured okay, maybe we're not going to ask questions. We'll give him two rooms. Okay. Or maybe I'll sneak a kid out of my suitcase. I don't know what they were thinking. It's the same room. It's the same room. It's the same room. Same room. Okay, the living room was a little large. That's it. >> [laughter] >> No. [laughter] Oh, the kid is coming out here. Everybody say it live. Okay, listen. Listen. Listen. Listen. I'm just like when you guys get the massage next time in the morning and you go for steering on the on the beach over here and there's not Just remember at least the fancy sitting in his room preparing to share. Okay? How many rooms? I need more rooms than you. I need more rooms. I need to prepare a little I'm going to have one room. I'm bathing in the other room. I need You You guys enjoy your spas, okay? >> [laughter] >> I don't even know what it looks like. I didn't even go in. I didn't even It's okay. Never. Listen, if I was in a I'll just tell you that don't feel bad for me cuz even though I was there for 3 days and I wasn't giving a share, I wouldn't go into that spa. It's not like you matter. Not not for these reasons. I don't do spa. That's not my thing. If there was a basketball court, I'd be on the basketball court. I'd I'd go jet skiing. I'd go scuba diving, skydiving, all this all those stuff. Not sitting around Roman style, not my thing. Nobody understands what I'm talking about. Anybody here don't do massage? Anybody? What? You all do it. What are you hacking Chinese? Oh. Listen. What What happened in that restaurant on the fourth floor stays there. Someone has to remind me one of the best lines ever. It's like two serial killers walking on the street. It's like, "WHY ARE YOU ALIVE? WHY ARE YOU HERE? I WANT TO KILL YOU MUST YOU'RE RUINING IT FOR ME." OH, that was so good. Yeah, okay, fine. Possible. This case of Boise again, I got to show to you again cuz we we lost track over here. And by the way, there's another sheer coming up, but if anybody wants to not go to the spa after this, and wants to stick around for another sheer, I'll let you stay. So, it says in the Gemara, Oh, so we have a problem here. Even though this wall is not considered You just told me it's man-made. So, why is it a problem? Why is the sh'chita possible? So, you see from here that what? That even though you attached the stone to You You're the one that attached it. So, it was it was not It was then it's possible. So, here's a great riot that if you take a knife and put it in the wall, it's possible. No. How am I supposed to know It's talking about something like this. And may I know this is from Bereshit. It's not man-made, and therefore that's why it's possible. I cannot mean I'll prove it to you. Because they're both in the same sentence, this is and it says the Gemara so may they both A kind of a read, obviously it came from Hashem and stuck in the ground. So, it's a kind of a read. Sh'ma minah. Yeah, yeah. This piece doesn't look so good in this picture, but yes, it's a piece. This looks like somebody put it there, but Uh no, the point is it's a cave, and that's how it was. Sh'ma Tishma. Not Here's another one that says that if you take a knife and put it in the wall, the sh'chita is possible. I think he might have even made a picture for it. I don't know why. Yeah. Yeah. Like this. You take a knife, you you shochet the goat like that. It's good for the next Sugya. The Shulchan Aruch Shchita doesn't change it. So, what do you see? That even though you it was Talush and then you made it Mechubar, it's kosher. Says the Rosh Shani Sakan Lo Mevatel Lo. Shani Sakan De Lo Mevatel Lo. A knife is different. Why? Because What? Right. You're not Mevatel the knife to the wall. You're going to one day come and take it out. Tashma. B'Mechubar L'Karka Shchita doesn't change it. Now, this, as you remember from yesterday, we had a contradiction, so we said when it's the fact that it says Mechubar L'Karka, it's good good Shchita, it it's referring to that it was Talush and then Mechubar. So, here here's a great case of Talush and then Mechubar that the Shchita is kosher. Says the Gemara, "Do we approach it in a different way? Maybe the Shulchan over there is just explaining my Mechubar L'Karka Sakan De Lo Mevatel Lo." Maybe we can't bring a Raya because it's just the upshot of what's going on over there. What what what does Mechubar L'Karka mean? It means a knife, and that we already established a knife is not something that you Mevatel to the wall because you're going to pull it out. Okay. Now, it's time for you to think about it for a second. If I were to ask you, what's what's a worse Shchita? If the knife is over here, here's the knife. Putting the animal on top of the knife and cutting like this, or putting the animal below the knife and cutting like this. This is the knife. The question is, and this is the animal. What's worse of a Shchita? Putting the animal's neck like this, or putting the animal's neck like this? No? Anybody want to take a guess? The top is worse. Why? Because there's a better chance of Grisa. Correct. What do you say? Why is there a better chance of Grisa? Because you're pushing down. When you're pushing down, you're going to you're going to Same Grisa if you're pushing up. No, you're not pushing up. So, also, you you can't move it. Yeah, because right right. I hear what you all are saying asking but the the answer is that if you were to let go would be Deresa right there. Cuz the animals head how much does the animals head weigh? I don't even know if we can lift it. It's probably a couple hundred pounds that that head. So you you you're holding it back from coming down. So as it's coming down on the knife that itself is Deresa. The gravity is creating Deresa. I get it but that's if you are in control of a knife. When the neck of the animals on the bottom and you're in control of the knife so you're doing the knife you're not doing Deresa. Over here the neck is pushing down. Yeah okay right. But that you could see. Deresa is a problem you don't even see. You don't even notice that you're letting the pressure of gravity go onto the knife and you're not controlling it. I'm a marid not sacking my koso if you put a knife in the in the wall. But Shaka it doesn't share it's a good Shaka. If you did this this is the only way it's kosher. That's crazy. So what is he doing he's moving the he's moving the neck back and forth to do how do you do Shaka? He must move the neck back and forth. But he does this. I shouldn't have made this always a concern maybe he'll put push down on the knife and do Deresa. We learned there's no difference that we learned yesterday. Let's start with the Katana. It's two different that what if the knife is on the bottom and the animal's neck is on top and the knife is in his hand Great. So but if the the knife is on top and the animal's neck is on the bottom, so even if it's even it's No, no, no. This these are all kosher, but the only way it's kosher when the knife is below the neck. In other words, it's coming down is only if it's in his hand. That's how they today, I think. How do they today? Yeah. I'm pretty sure. And pull the thing back. Also, it's it's coming down. Coming down and the knife is coming down. But the knife is coming down and that's not cuz he's controlling it. But over here you have when you have the cow's head pushing down The knife is not moving. I don't know. Here, let's see this. What did he do here? And nothing. No, no, no. He's holding up the cow's head and he's coming from below. Okay. So that's only time that it's okay when the when when he's holding the knife in his hand. But if the knife is stationary, in other words, in a in a in a in a wall, then it would be a problem. But if it's the reverse, if the knife is on top then it doesn't matter if the knife is in the wall, then it's also okay. Also okay. What? Good. We have We have another one. Here we go. Over here we don't have a a problem with why? Here you all see there's no problem with because a bird it's so light that you're not going to use the power of the the what do you call don't tell him no he's telling him to be quiet He's closing the door. Oh. Let them move it. Rab Bar Bar Bar Bar the cow doesn't bother me. Omar Hizda Omar Yitzchak Enemies fire small bees fire and you're in control and there's no way you're in control. You're you're the the the working and what are you going to do? Omar Hizda Omar Yitzchak I don't know what this is done Khamisha Bar Omar Bar Kureisha Kona. Oh, things are going to get weird in a second. I didn't get weird yet. >> [laughter] >> There are five things that if you have a broken piece of reed so the the best picture I could come up with actually we have a better one but this again not to mention that I don't know how many times I mentioned sugarcane and ginger and lemon but if you I took from this picture now if you look all the way on the right side so there's a broken piece of sugarcane. That's very very bad for a few things. What? For five things. Ain't no way you can't do sugar with it. Why? Cuz it has a bunch of splinters. It's going to tear the animal. May do not do milk with it. Oh they it's a lot of splinters here. He he did a one Yosha did something like this. Okay? Splintery. You don't never know. If it cuts from a bosser do not use it as a knife and cut your steak. Then and do not use it as a toothpick. They make do use it as toilet paper. Ain't no ball but Tanya because maybe it's all because of this it's a way you can use a reed. Omar Bar Bar Bar Bar the Agma cuz we're talking about reeds that don't have splinters a special type of reed but a reed that has splinters you're not allowed to use for maybe it's a bosser you do not use it for cutting meat. Omar Bar Bar Bar Bar Dogim he said you can use it for the the innards of fish the ziggy. Now I want to show you Rashi, I I saw today. Look at Rashi. Ziggy, what does Rashi say? Anybody can read? Clear. And that's ziggy. Ziggy means clear. Ziggy, why? It's transparent. So, if it's transparent, you can see right through it. You can see if it has a splinter or not. And the Rabbi would would cut chicken schnitzel. Why? Cuz it's soft, so it's not going to splinter into the into the chicken. And you do not use it as toilet paper. If you use toilet paper that that that could catch fire, sheen of noishers, you could have what is it called? Hemorrhoids, whatever. So, in other words, it's it's it's more of a cabalistic thing, I believe. Why? How do I know that? Because it'll be a big problem. So, if you're Sefardi, Rebbi Weiss, if you're Sefardi, do not listen to this. Sefardi not allowed to use toilet paper today. Why? Because because it's it splinters and it's a problem. According to the Shulchan Aruch, Shulchan Aruch paskins, anything that catches fire, you can't use as toilet paper. So, I'm sorry. Rebbi Ari, no more. But, and this is where I get into trouble. I haven't mentioned this in a long time. And it's usually not the place of a maggid shiur to talk about these kind of things, but I feel I feel I need to do a public service announcement for the oilam. There's something called a bidet. I'm not kidding. >> [laughter] >> I'm not kidding. I'll tell you why. It's not a halacha. I'm saying a halacha here. The halacha, if a person doesn't use toilet paper correctly, he has a big problem davening. Learning. There's a little piece. Now, there's something cheaper. People should know this. It's cheaper than toilet paper. It's a one-time purchase. Costs $25. It's a little hose. It has a sprayer. It is mordik. I shouldn't be saying this, but I have to say it for the I'm taking one for the team. Taking one for the team. Everybody should have one in their house and you save a lot of money. What? Every bathroom. It's the best thing ever. It's the best invention ever. And you have to cool off. I'm serious. You have to feel better and you save money. I don't know why it's not in every single house. Anyways, and by the way and by the way, if anybody wants >> [laughter] >> if anybody wants they can come to my room There's portable ones. There's portable ones whenever you go. 100% you got to use portables. Yeah. What? No, you install the ones that have the heaters and the design and the fans. $25. What? Ah, maybe it's a divider. Yeah, yeah, I know. And I just saw 25,000. Wow. Okay. Yeah. I can buy them so that's yeah. I'm going to pop up. No. What I was telling you is if you if if you have let's say a a scar from a monkey do not go like this with a with a reed that has splinters because it can go into your into your into your wound. It says in the Mishna how could you say but how could you say that? So you want to say how could you say that? How could you say that for the wife? You do say that even for a bird. What are you saying but what do you mean by that? What is the goal of this? What what what happened? No, I see I see it in the I see it in the camera. I see it in the camera. Okay. It's fine. No worries, but time out. What you think of that? Yeah. She's leaving. No, she's insulted. No, but did she have a burger thing? No. Oh, it's one of those. Okay, so take it out. So there's a straw cuz said they're allowed to eat meat. Stop, have a steak. Why? She There's a lot of people here that they love meat more than they love milk shakes. I don't understand it. Pizza's number one, obviously. But some people like steak more. So imagine if you couldn't eat any steak, garnished. No spa. No spa. Sorry, I know. I was hacking. I was hacking. Some people there for 3 4 days before Shabbos they're smoking ready up the meat. And here we have the Rebbe of Hill coming out. He's the God of Darn and he's also coming asking and here is Rebbe sitting right next to me. Rebbe Mendelson, he taught him everything he knows about smoking and everything. Well, I taught him. And then we have Yitzy, what's his name in Lakewood? Oh, that guy, yeah. Who's coming in for a siyum and it's first siyum or something? cater the next MVI trip. All right. Goldstein, Yitzy, okay, yeah. Gevaldig. When was done? So so believe that it's unbelievable. In the beginning it was awesome for them to eat meat. But once they came in there it's all good and then she will say okay, go ahead and eat meat. The once they go to gallus they have a have a have a meaner that you that you don't need any meat anymore. Why? Because you went to gallus. Kashino, that's one of the reasons. I'm asking you Rebbe Yosel, I don't know why I can't eat meat. The point is that they're allowed to eat it. So that should be the point, not that you could shat. The point is that you're allowed to eat meat. Why? Let me call my time What's the whole Let's let's think about it logically. Why was meat also? We shouldn't have to make a mishkan. Once when they're very close to the mishkan, so just bring a carbon and every time you want to eat meat you can bring a carbon and you can eat the steak. Well, we're saying my time is too. So why did meat become mutar? The Rebbe like right now we're in gallus we're >> Have a Well, well, it's also here. >> [laughter] >> Hello everyone from TV. This Okay, I guess we have to We really have to The boys side, the spa is open until what time? Have a wonderful day. Merit the schuss of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shear today. mdy.sponsor.com or [email protected]