Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 116 by R' Eli Stefansky

[screaming] Good morning. Welcome. Welcome to all the guests. I'm just thinking [clears throat] how they just cut it and now they're saying, "Okay, I completely lost it. They have no shas." Okay. M official edition. Thank you. Ai Kamyansski sponsor. So Ai went to Kyvski a bunch of years ago with his daughter, right? He didn't go with the daughter, but it was about Estie and Estie needed a coclear implant and told him learn. So he thought he meant like one or two. So he kept on pushing. He says no from beginning to the end and in the middle also. So he says he learned the and she here she converses in in loud places like you can't tell. So an ace it's an ace and you wrote a safer on on hearing the whole thing. So has it has a has a muck in your heart. We wanna we want to thank those few sponsors that dropped out to make room for you. [laughter] Just a few do left just a few dopp sponsor today. You know what has a big big part in know fixes heart. He he worked on it from beginning to end. Shamshi too. So it's a it's a it's a that's part of the reason just yesterday sponsored by Ellie Eisenstein TV Jacobs Abraham Tikki Abram Takotssky the famous Aram Totssky does remember who Aram Tksky is the first day of co >> he gave me that gorgeous picture very a painting a very expensive painting came to my door uplifted my spirits Kobe and Eti Moses paraman Moses is less than two weeks from now we're going to uh the Dead Sea for we took the entire hotel the Royal Malone Royale um Ravgav is going to be speaking in English the picture >> yeah he's not he's not not in the picture could you imagine how many people I mean if he didn't make it on the picture can you imagine how are not in the picture and he's coming I went to a guy's I I don't know his name. I never knew his name and I still don't know his name. What's his name? >> You're the fish. He got married last night. He said that the daff changed his life. In many ways, I don't know that I'm allowed to say how and where. We went to he was so excited that he walked us out. The three of us, we went three Jakob Shafness is all the way. B Shaf is his brother all the way to the right and Benny Rick to my right. And uh he he left the hall. He just kept on walking us towards the car and uh it was it was a beautiful beautiful scene similar to the nace of the had a kid when he was 88 years old ribbki. So I heard this is I'm saying this first here is writing a book. I'm not joking. This is not the same, but it's Anace Nigla, a 37year-old who big part of this year. Ellie Geller got married last night. Listen to this. He's so he's such a big part of MDY that he gave a braha to the MDY representative that came to Kasa. Check this out. This is this him singing. [music and singing] >> [music] >> Oh, it's my favorite song for now. But check this out. >> Mark Ashkarazzi. Mark a few. It's It's happening now. He's there. Is he on? Can we get him on? Show him Randon or somebody. Somebody get show Randon. >> You have Sean Rand's video thing. Call him up. Somebody call him. >> Why' you mention this? >> What? >> No, it's a big name. It's a big He's He was single for a very long time. He went to the It's a whole long story. I can tell you afterwards. There's a book that's going to be written about this. >> Uh Misha Gutman on May 6th, just a few months ago. He's on. Show him. You still No, I'm not. >> We're We're middle of now. So if we're not say Okay. >> We're not right now. >> Do you want to now? Cuz I'm middle of [laughter] Ellie's wedding. [laughter] >> Okay. >> All right. I'm planning to be Thursday morning at headquarters. You can add this picture. Okay. So, we all know about David Salman. Headquarters. >> Hold on. Hold on a second. Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. One second. >> What? What are you talking about? Okay. [sighs] Uh [laughter] MDY in Miami. David Salomon, a guy who gave a huge donation and then he just called up like two, three weeks ago and said he wants to triple his donation. Triple his donation. He's the only corporate sponsor. His donation was huge to begin with. Only corporate sponsor level ecopier. Now he's starting something else. He's saying that whoever comes and finishes 31 days of Mak's tightness in his satellite location at NYX $500 per bak and you don't or you could do just the regular share for 31 days. Tinus or the regular shar here we go started last night. It's for both. This for people. >> Okay. >> I said to myself, I I'm doing something I've never done before. Never. David Salman, because of his support and how close we are, he's making a kasa this Wednesday night in Florida. I'm flying to the kasa and coming back 27 hours later. Wow. >> So, I'll be back Friday morning, leaving Tuesday night after the Hebrew Shir. Right after the Hebrew Shir. It's an exception. >> Do not ask me to come to your even if you give $180 a month or even if you give $180,000 a year. I can't go to people's classes. We're going to make an exception for David understands. Got to Lake George, New York looking for a minion. First I first person I bumped into asked me if I was Ruben from Albany. Beautiful. Help [clears throat] promote the Spanish here with status clips in Spanish. They want to send out Spanish. Oh, I guess anybody could send it out. You don't have to be Spanish. You know how hard it is for me to speak like that? I sit and I practice and practice. We have David. How are you? Long time no see. You still live in Chicago. Willie Hman in celebration of my 50th bar mitzvah Shabbat and Loy's engagement of the Stfansky family. Willie Hoffman and Kendamilies LLC dedicated to the memory anonymous from LA. Thank you. David Solomon, Mr. Anonymous from LA. If you're how come you're not here in this year it's I think it's him David Salomon dedicated in memory of David Salomon foundation I called him up I said I'm thinking of coming to usually I just surprise people I said I'm going to call him up he said it's the first thing he says my father is here his father says he says you're my father right No, you're coming to you're my father. The whole thing will bring us closer to you anonymous and thank you to Chief Benny. Are you smiling right to tell you that? >> Yeah, I took there's other people that that weren't so happy, but okay. >> [clears throat] >> for my birthday. My family [clears throat] weekly sponsor Spanish Warren H. Feldman of MDY's diligent work. Thank you. Simon and Diana Diana Rosenfelder for Gabriela injured in an accidental Jacobson in honor of rebellion. I don't know if Mendel Jacobson knew or doesn't know but today is Klein's birthday. I'm assuming maybe that's why he did that. He said in honor. He didn't say exactly what. So happy birthday Schllayi Mish a big big part of MDY since the days of co since when he was in the hospital and found us when he was hooked up to all these machines. We have some Labavature representatives here for what's your name? >> From where? >> Miami, Florida. >> Oh, why are you so excited to be here? What's going on? [laughter] Yeah. >> The is on. Let's go. >> What? You're That's it. You're driving. Where are you? >> What? >> Where are you? >> You pulled over to the side. [laughter] >> At the right time. >> He's married. He's married. He's married. He got his whatever. back. >> No, no, hold on. This is very important. This is very important. >> This is This is a nice niglo. This is a nice happening. >> Yes. >> I'm on the way out the hotel. I pulled over to the side of the highway safely. I'm wearing a seat belt. >> Yes. >> I want to thank you so much for all the terror you told me. I'm up to date with you and not tomorrow. We're continuing non-stop. >> Unbelievable. Mark, >> I showed it in cheer. Why do you give him braha? just so curious >> because I have a car for the person who probably takes the most flack for MDY but does the most for MDY and dedicated and he gives me so he enables me to learn I wanted to give up >> wow wow mark takes the most slack from anybody enables him to learn one minute I can't talk to you right now you're not ready to come into the migdash right now is awesome to come into the migdash by zone I love you. >> I didn't drink. >> I know you didn't drink. >> Listen, Ellie, you and your wife should be to build a >> Mark. First time you got a bra in your life. >> Wow. >> No, >> you're one of the Oh, you're one of the tallest people under the I saw that. >> [laughter] >> That's what you're saying. You did something like this. Okay. >> Where are we holding? >> Oh, you were next to Oh, you're right next to Bender. Rabbi Bender got there. We said this Irish in celebration of a daughter's mitzvah. You could sponsor for daughters mitzvah and wife's birthdays. A H for the anonymous for the follow month. Rachel and Alex cats and honor their beautiful children. May they grow to >> Alex. >> Who? >> Alex's brother. >> Alex. Oh, >> wow. You drove him in today. >> What happened to the to the >> You're the pinch hitter. Unbelievable. Freddy Freeman in support of this groundbreaking initiative with credit to multi for changing the landscape for I'm sure wants to hear an update. >> Yes. >> These are real numbers. Until now, they were fake. No. Over 3,000 resumes, over 30, this is for Matiy's mouth, not my I'm not I'm not adding or taking off anything. Over 30 couples going out actively yesterday alone. 11 couples went out. Couples, some on fifth and sixth dates, some actually broke up. But it's moving. HYK ventures emerit for successful year ahead for all our clients is the sponsor for the day one day at a time months LLC as a and our kids too I'm waiting for the day that the sponsorships are going to be longer than the entire share it's almost there we go What we're going to do is we're finishing off the of and that's going to end somewhere like let's call 15 lines from the top of and then we have a certainly compared to the mat. So yesterday we were learning about how do you know that is so we learned from ara the first three years of a tree you can't benefit from it at all. says you learn from now if you stop over there that's one to almost like a sort of if it's from beginning okay is certainly also so says no our law is different because was never even for a moment where was in the beginning of it life meat is mut milk is mut if you combine the two it's awesome so okay so we bring a from and pes it has also m to eat before pes only when pes comes along but it's a problem is very very severe it has so instead of going to law we pick another thing called we're going to discuss this a little bit what happens if you go back to araw what happens if you go to kilaram what do you gain by learning from a third thing versus going back to at this point right over here we could have just gone right back to that there's no car and nevertheless bless [clears throat] instead of going back to our which most of the time that's what we do we go in a circle we increase the the size of the circumference over here the size of the circle and we introduced a new thing called I'm just curious what you guys think you take two seeds and you put them in the ground and what comes out is kilakum something that had a shaser or something that didn't have a in other words was it was it also from the moment it was created or it's there was a time that it was was motor >> what do you say of course >> each one individually was just like >> yeah but do you start here's the question do you start from when it's a seed or do you start from from when it grows >> yeah also says and this seed was mut when you planted it was you allowed to eat Oh. Oh. It gives you something to think about. >> Okay. You're saying it's a brand new thing. You're saying it doesn't have a chance. >> No. >> I don't think so. >> What? Okay. So, says the Gamaro. >> Just take it back maybe a step or two. Where are you? Oh, let's let's go. Let's go to the first one. Let's go. Two, four, six, eight. Nine lines from the from the bottom. Do it quickly. Even if we did do it yesterday. This is what we said in the You want to ask me a question. [clears throat] You want to say you want to say bring in yesterday we're talking about will prove to you that what it's but it's so it should ruin everything this whole circle he says no you can't bring a from an outside source this this is very for all of cuz most have you know one or two that discuss a matad and the limuim some People love it, some people not so much. But that's part of shas is learning the limudim over here. It's maybe the only time that the gumar goes into the rules how how these work. So it's maybe to remember today. >> Yeah. Yeah. It's it's in the nature of I get it. It's in your nature. Yesterday, today I love you. [snorts] Oh, sorry. Sorry. Yeah. I don't want to be distracted. If you could ask a question from within them itself and say, "Oh, this one has this problem versus that problem." Great. You don't bring in outside thing called and say oh it's but it's also says okay I don't understand why you jumping to why don't you just learn directly from law here like on the right side on the left side in this case on the left side we started on top we went to law we had a problem with so we went tot we had a problem with go back to law doesn't have the problem oft doesn't have the cars that that Pes has. And you go around in circle. Why do we have the one on the the right which sticks in another one called Those two have something special. They're different. Very different. They grow from the ground. Now, if you think about it, they grow from the ground. So what? If you tell me this has cars, okay, I get it. Wow. This is a a very powerful thing. It has carus has carus. It grows from the ground. Why is that something special? So makes it different. So you're going to see there's a there's a there's a a little push. Give it a little a little push to the side. Oh, you know what? Grows from the ground. No. And then this one grows in the ear. And this one comes from an animal. So what? Why is that a mil? So we'll say we give it a If it's two, maybe we'll give it a grow in the ground. You're not making any sense. What did you help? Why is the one on the right stronger than the one on the left? The one on the left you have only two component. You learn from two things ar and both grow from the ground. Pizza grows from the ground and trees grow from the ground. So that I could throw that off. So I introduced kilakam kilakam also grows from the ground. What did you gain? And the explains what I gained. You know what you gained? You gained another number. Now you're learning the top from three things versus from two. When you learn from three, it's different than when you learn from two. That's [clears throat] what the answer >> strong. >> It's a strong to break it. You need a very powerful p. You can't just This is a kind of a joke. Not a joke like a very weak >> should brush off. It grows from the ground. So what grows from the ground? Why is that a you tell me something has? You tell me it doesn't have a never. It was never it was never kosher for a moment. Great. You tell me grows from the ground. This is what they say from if you're going around in a circle like these guys. It's a you want to learn from from a combination of things. You're learning from Arlo but Arlo has a little bit of problem. So then we we bring in a a fixer called Pes has a problem and you go in a circle that's so that I could get rid of nothing. But now if you stick in something called you stick on the only way you could you could slug it up is if you bring something they say no this is stronger this has this has or it's weaker just the fact it grows in the ground doesn't work now at the end of the day all of them do have one thing in common they all grow on the So, let's use that. And now tells us we're going to tighten up our rules. I mean, if I were to ask you logic, let's use the common sense now. If I learn A from B, what's wrong? I learn A from B or A from B and C. Oh, even the way I asked it wasn't good. I I gave it away. Let's do it the opposite. If I learn A from B or I learn A from B and C, what's stronger? What's a stronger le? I learn from one thing or I learn from two things. >> Two things. And the says that's the opposite. Why is it the opposite? Because it doesn't work with common sense. It works with what said when he gave us the rules. And here the rules. If I learn one thing from the other which is basically like if you remember only in the beginning we learned from it's one thing I'm learning milk cooked in in with meat from which is so now it's very very strong according to the I need something very strong to say oh didn't have it was never m never for a second that's a wrong but a simple thing oh grows on the ground doesn't grow on the ground wouldn't work in this case that's why we didn't use it over there we didn't say oh grows in the ground because I need a strong however >> the is to take away the comparison >> yeah you want to compare two things you say no you can't compare them what's the comparison this has wings this doesn't have wings that's not a good pir That's what is >> the distinction, >> right? >> That's called au. It's But if you tell me, no, here's the distinction. This thing is so severe that from the moment it was born, you couldn't eat it. So now it makes sense that you can't have an from it. It actually has to do with ho. The fact that it grows on the ground has nothing to do with not. It's just a distinction between two things. >> It's a distinction without a difference. >> There's a real difference. I'm telling you there's a difference. This is something that was created the whereas is a weak thing. I took two things put them together. Why should it be? So if I learn then and this like I said it's it's a it doesn't make sense but that's how it is. I learned one from two then I could say oh it's what about like in our case now we just threw in here we just threw in a third thing and so it's one I'm learning the top guy from three different things if you know go around in a circle you know people say well this one has so I'll fill it in from this and this one has fine then I can knock it out with the answer. We're just thear asked the question how come we don't say all three haved the three bottom guys are it doesn't work in this case why like in our case that we're not going back in a circle I'm just using as the right it won't work a simple distinction of doesn't work in this case I need a and or says that's a good strong distinction never was never from the moment it was created. There's two ways to look at it. That's what I asked him in the corner over there. How do you look at at kilakam? Is it from the moment it starts sprouting and that becomes assur and from that moment it was always assured and I say the seeds used to be mut says from over here I see that I look at the seeds themselves and I say the seeds used to be mut and the seeds today are are are so something changed in the seeds they had a they were mut on Sunday on Tuesday when I put them into the ground they the seeds themselves became a Just like the actual seeds became and these seeds were 100% to eat each one individually when you put them in the ground they became as but wait a minute is that true that the seeds become I'll prove to you they don't become that's it okay so we're done basically we're done with the of mats and all these. Now we're moving on to much easier stuff. >> Huh? >> Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I'm throwing it in there. Whatever. >> Yeah. A few moments later. Ask the Let's see this for a second. This is a motor. Puts the green seeds in. Okay. Let's see. That's Russian. Noam. Oh, the wheat grows in the vineyard. Okay. So, if this guy takes his uh pot and the pot, the bottom of the pot has a giant hole in it where it [music] could nurse from the ground. >> Nourish. It gets nourishment from the ground and it grows a sliver in that pot. How much is a sliver? 1/200th not only if it added 1/200th it becomes the actual seeds don't become it's whatever was added becomes so you see seeds don't become let's make a distinction that it's interesting I don't know if anybody ever paid attention to this word means to be full that whatever grows in in the in the in the future becomes becomes becomes on the other hand it says that the actual seed becomes. So which one is it? What what you added is or even the seed to begin with? Okay, it's when you put the seed into the ground so the seed itself becomes when it takes root like we saw in the video it turns red. the seed itself turns red. But if you come with a a planter, you come with something that's already growing and you brought it into the vineyard, then only what he added on later becomes. And if not, not say it's time to wake up now. Oh, no. Say it. No, the part [laughter] what does it say in our everybody's aware of this is we have a say it's not it's to benefit from it uses the word by tra it also says we have this this yesterday says the word if you have a I mean we wouldn't be eating kosher meat right now if tra was because 30% of animals today are tra according to our standards what what can you do with it take a $2,000 animal throw it out in the garbage you have to you have to sell it to the nonju and get your $2,000 back and like I mean you take a little bit of a loss it's not so gishmach And that's why kosher meat costs a lot of money. But it would be impossible to eat kosher meat if this didn't exist and says that what you're allowed to benefit from from a tra you open up an animal. You see that there's a hole in the heart you sell it to non it's so therefore since we share the same word. So great a wild animal like a deer and a bird is not not chicken is what's the is to eat chicken with meat but with with dairy chicken with dairy schnitle sandwich with a >> parmesan >> parmesan oh Cooked cooked in butter. But butternit this s on what's this? Huh? >> What's a mis? Okay. If you say you have to tell me what you say or you want him to say it. >> No. What's code? >> How do you know that? You did before. >> We learned it already. >> So goes matza and smack in the middle. Either it's 100% mut nothing. You go into restaurant eat or 100% or smack in the middle it's is not the rice and not so says the so it's very very simple over here it's all look at these three we know the say it three times it says comes to exclude a deer comes to exclude a bird and it comes to exclude food, horses, milk and and and and meat is not a problem of says I don't understand if you all remember from yesterday we had started off like this. Remember he had all these limu the the red and the green then we took the red and the green and we combined them together and we did something like this. So we said these two guys go together and this and the we got all the way to a point where we have three limu the comes to include the fat of an animal. If you take the fat of a cow which is also for you to eat some fats your mut some the ones that are also you take it and you cook it in milk. The other lemur is it doesn't apply to a horse. And the third lemur is that a baby a baby goat a baby cow that's a benu and the mother does is to to to cook with with milk as the gammor if I'm learning these 123 123s. How does have room for his one two three? How does this work? How do you have extra in place? Says the gammor I'll tell you why. Because if you look closely I don't need a pic for number one. What's number one? You have a piece of fat, a piece of you're not allowed to cook it with milk. What's the O of course you can't cook it with milk. It's meat. Eli the is what's how do you add a second is to one is that already exists and the answer is cuz he holds. So if you hold I don't need a for that anything you want to add to that. So you add another you want to add whatever you want to add. You want to add um to it works. Why not? I don't need a P to tell me that it works. That's number one. And number three, to tell me that a baby is also, why not? It's a baby. Why is it not a why is it not a cow? Why is it not a a goat? So, I don't need one and three. Two. Anyways, he uses look two uses. Although, it's number three on this one, but it's number two. and I have two extra ones says first of all he holds therefore I don't need number one at all to tell me that that second it's a regular piece of meat why wouldn't it be right we did have in the interesting thing that you're allowed to eat a with butter we had that interesting thing. Okay, but he holds as a regular animal. I don't need a pass for it. >> Yeah, it's really cool. All three are extra and therefore I'm left with these three that the meat of a deer together with milk is not the meat of a bird is not the meat of the the of what I said a non-coosher And therefore learns that anything that's to do at the end of the day comes out that a bird doesn't have. So bird there's no Isn't that the same thing that just said that a bird is there's no what's the difference between the two there is yeah you're right in a bird there's no difference but the difference is in the difference is in a deer that says that it's only and says no is the rice to cook deer's meat venison together with The difference is the bird is the middle ground. The bird schnitle with butter with parmesan is awesome. Basically I feel awesome. There's nothing. Check this out. The three shittas in in chicken. I just like some pula milk. Breakfast cereal will be enough for me. >> [music] >> Hello, I am here on behalf of the basin headed by Tanakama. You have just violated a deor is of eating poultry and dairy. [laughter] >> [snorts] >> Sir, I am an emissary of the bedin [music] of Rabbi Akiba. You have just violated a dabon prohibition. >> Ah, it's only dabbon. [sighs] >> MAKAS MUS. [music] [laughter] HELLO. I am from the bed dim of Rabbi Yoshi Hagiri. >> What? >> Prove your heart. >> Why did you come? WHAT DO YOU WANT? >> NOTHING. I just want to eat with you. [laughter] >> All right. Talk to you tomorrow. Oh, I got the time. story time. [laughter] And wasn't even involved in that whole thing, I don't think. Everybody said, "Listen, listen, listen, listen, listen." You know what I see? I saw I learned this big thing. We have a big part of our that never watches any clips, any TV, nothing. This is their only entertainment. This is the first time is like, "Wow, this is unbelievable. There's there's a big if you do a perform a bris on shabas. What? What do you have to do with it? You're a male or something, David. >> Sorry. >> Are you No. Okay. I don't know why. >> Not in this way. >> Not in this way. [laughter] I'm not. This is like a mitzvah. What's greater? The mitzvah. over here to to cut down a tree on chabas to make to cut down the tree to make coals to to fashion a knife to make to make metal a metal knife. We hold you now, but they hold you. They would eat in the whole city. They would eat with parmesan. I don't know if you remember to some of the guests. Who else do we have here? What's your name? >> Oh shimm from where? >> White Plains. >> White Plains. How you doing? >> Yeah. >> Uh my son sent the email a few weeks ago from Jojo. >> Jojo. >> He forgot to say his name and says I was visiting Israel. I said I'll come by. >> Wow. >> How's he doing? >> He needs a He needs a refor. >> Absolutely. >> What's his name again? >> Yazar. Ben. >> Beniva Kana Adel. Wow. Refor. >> How old is he? >> He's 15 and a half. Wow. Jojo for layma. Unbelievable. >> Okay, for coming. You were able to get away, huh? >> Yeah. >> I came for my sister. So, >> how old was she? >> She was 15. >> Wow. >> Cancer. All right. Huh? >> What's your name? No, you. Yeah. His >> brother. One minute. You took the name. So, what's your name? Mendle. What? [laughter] >> Somebody wrote in. They didn't realize I was talking. They wrote in. He goes, "I I think I have to leave this year." He eats. I don't eat only. [laughter] No, I don't. I don't. Listen, everybody has Everybody has to. What are you going to do? >> Yeah. What's your name? What's your name? >> From >> Montreal. >> Montreal. You go to that pizza shop guy. The guy with the falafel. He's a >> pizza. >> What's his name? >> Pizza. >> That's what it's called. How do you know? >> I'm from Montreal >> also. >> Wow. >> That's what it's called. Okay. He has like a salad location there. Who else? What's your name? >> Gav from >> Wow. Okay, talk to you tomorrow. >> Do you remember? Yeah, let me show you this video cuz we didn't uh I I took out a video or two over here because I didn't like it so much. Let me show you this one. I I just I'm going back to this. >> What's up, guys? Welcome back to the Menim Donald [music] Ysef channel. Today, the arrow slaughter challenge straight out of the Jamo. >> So, what do we have here? A kit with three arrows. Interesting. Let's check it out. I'd rather like this. >> Hero number one is designed to [music] scatter sand for the Kisuh hadome. Amazing. Works like a charm. Now for arrow [music] number two. It's perfectly sharp, zero flaws, and 100% kosher for shittita. Boom. Looks like [music] a hit. Yes. Yes. Yes. I love it. And now we're sending the camera arrow to get a closeup of the hit and make sure the socken didn't get [music] stuck mid-neck because it's halid. >> Wait, what is that? What am I even looking at right now? Where's the pigeon? Are you crazy? You're doing shooting arrows in the middle of a hiking trail, throwing sand around, knives. I'm calling the police. Get out of here. >> All right, guys. It's an absolute mess over here. I got to fly. Peace. >> I love it. [laughter] He has two arrows in his head. He's He's has titus on him. He's making a mess in the belt. >> It's No, I'm trying to say this is the the over there that used to be able to shoot animals in mid-flight way before. >> But this is we know somebody. We have pictures of him. We have videos. cuz we don't have videos of Yeah. No, here we have pictures. All right. I call upon him. So, he goes to this the hunter. What's this unbelievable creature? >> It's like not the the beauty of this thing, right? >> Got one walking around in B. >> Really? >> Really? Y pictures. >> It's like it's just it almost doesn't make sense that this thing exists. >> It's opened up. >> Just a beautiful It opened up. >> It's the whole thing. Okay. So, this whole Shiloh if uh if it's kosher or not kosher need I just told my my he liked this. He was he was up his alley. So, I had to tell it to him cuz Rashi says over here what's a tavas? He says, "Check this out. Tavos phones." I said, you know, it's like a kosher phone and a non-coosher phone [laughter] says over here. Ah, it's one of your top top 10 top 10 [laughter] cuz we every day we talk about kosher phone, non-coosher phone. That's it. You know that and I'm not going to say the other things that we go through. There's a list of three four things that we argue about every single day. And then okay, but here here you go. If it's kosher not there. Oh, so they give him a head of a of a of a some sort of bird called a taps in milk. So obviously what is he? There's threeas over here. We just saw the threeas. What is he holding? Why don't you put him is this? We don't eat chicken with milk. He lives. This hunter lives in place. And I thought to myself, the a bird is not in the category of of doesn't have mother's milk. It's 100% m says the so in the English art world says over here what's ka this is of this is congealed milk looks something like this >> oh so the art scroll in English calls it renet I like I like renet we could go with ren but the Hebrew doesn't seem to talk about renet it just says it's congealed milk okay so let's let's call it renet I like renet the renet, not the intestines called ka, but the renet of the intestines. What does that mean? So, the way to the way it works is how do you make cheese? You take you take a piece of kishka like this and that that has enzymes in it and that starts the process. It's a chemical process that that takes milk and uh makes it into cheese. That's a ka. That's actually the intestines. You take a little bit kishka and then whatever you do and then you're able to you see but you saw over there he didn't put the whole kishka in there he put the the enzyme part of it and then it becomes cheese. Now what if you put the actual kishka inside that's much worse. Why is that worse? Because now it's nice and t it gives flavor. If the actual kishka gives flavor that could be problematic the says. So first the starts off if you get this renet from a or that of an animal that died without soar is going to ask right away every time you buy a dead animal from a it's an aa so what's the difference animal of a and a ve it's one of the same every animal is an aa they didn't they're not an animal so let's say they did they didn't check it doesn't matter if you buy kalal it's for us considered an aa So what the two things go, >> huh? >> That's later on. >> He owns it issue. >> We're we're going to see it's the opposite. It started out by the guy, but he sold it alive to the Jew. The Gar says that's one answer. you actually bought from a go. He's still not able to use the red because he might have non-cooser milk in him like this video that we just saw. He takes the actual piece of the intestines and puts it in the bowl. The the ka is kosher. Now we have a problem. It depends if it has if it gives off flavor. Let me ask you a question. If you didn't learn the sug answer, if you learn the sug Why is it a problem? Isn't it cold and cold? Cold renet in cold or a cold intestine in cold milk. Why is it a problem? >> Why is it kosh? It's it's considered pickle because it's there for a long time. If you let it sit there for hours, it becomes and it's as if it is hot. I just want to point out I'm not going to go into this whole rash, but Rashi starts off saying you have this milk that you found that's uh that's congealed in this uh the height of the stomach used the actual hide. He says three lines down% but this is what I want to point out in Rashi [clears throat] many many lines down probably 30 lines down says I made a big mistake in I have complete for my mistake. I'm being I'm telling the world I made a mistake and it's 100% why Rashi went you know to sometimes he says whatever the is here you see that we everything that we learned all the maybe they wanted to prevent somebody from making a mistake think that Rashi wants P and that it's Hey, so you should know I I take it back completely. Whatever it is, >> huh? >> How How was in? And and then don't make mistakes. Usually don't make mistakes. Okay. [clears throat and cough] I don't know that he ate it. He passed him that it's also passing. He could eat it. I don't know that he actually physically ate it. Listen to this. This is reverse on reverse. >> [clears throat] >> counterintuitive. Sherra, if you have a kosher animal that has inside it a non-cooser product. Why? Because it it it nursed from a tra animal. The renet is user. It's a kosher animal. But where did it get the renet from? Where did it produce it from? From a This brings up many many issues. Think about it for a second. Every milk that we drink guaranteed if if 30% of the animals are travell so they say it's not really 30% we're super mak okay it's 10%. If it's 30% you don't have so it some people don't drink milk but what about the reverse you have you have animal a kosher animal but it has a hole in the heart and they drink a lot of kosher milk the red is known as because it's considered gathered in its stomach in its intestines it's an entity its own we don't consider The milk tray like the mother it's in its own little bottle in its stomach. Anor healthare global specialist in international financial services. Talk to you tomorrow. How long are we in this? Wow. I don't understand the two the two concepts and ask you about somebody purchased a live goat a Jew who purchased a live goat from a concerned that the live goat drank milk from another kosher animal but the kosher animals asking are we concerned for such a thing but you could buy from an Arab sometimes the Arabs sell eggs is not a great idea cuz it has a bunch of salmonella and stuff. They're like, "No, seriously." They get like these diseased eggs and they sell them, you know, off market. [clears throat] >> Yeah. >> They keep them outside or refrigerated. Not a good idea. So, you're permitted to buy from them. I'm not concerned that he took it from a dead animal. Imagine a dead chicken. He chops open the thing, plucks out a couple of eggs and a How come over here we're concerned that the animal drink from a animal? I'm concerned that in the in the farm there's a little running around and a nurse from the But what's the difference? Maybe a nurse from a animal. Maybe a nurse from a from a pig. There's a lot of in the barn. There's a lot of animals. There's not a lot of I guess in time of the m not a lot of tra maybe even in our day not a lot of tra we're on like what's we have a this and that but doesn't really mean a doesn't mean it's strafe. See it's stuck the long st it's a you know it's not 100%. But if it's common, this non-coosher animal, maybe uh a pig from the next door neighbor jumped in here and they they drink its milk says we're very careful from or any other tummy animal. I saw videos we learned once you see like random animals. You see like a cow standing and a pig will walk over to the cow and start nursing the cow and the cow is you know animals shear like they'll they go to other animals you'll see we we distance ourselves from the there's no reason to be but a non-Jew he doesn't care about he doesn't even care if one of these walk in this barn we have to we have to be careful says no when when the says It's not two separate cases. It's one we're talking about the intestines the the renet of a says what's the problem with non-cosure cheese the problem is that they use the physical to make the renet but the renet itself it's only the it's only the physical part not the not the enzyme you'll see this again tomorrow I guess we'll stop here that retracted what he said before he said that the actual renet is considered law so he said it's law it's a but once he took it back he retracted so the ren itself is not have a wonderful >> [music] >> merit disclose of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdyd.com.