Daf Yomi Beitzah Daf 39 by R’ Eli Stefansky

shuli davidowitz b202 and official eight-minute daf ymca committee revised that before i go on the very first person to bring somebody to the shir that was within the kabura was hilo kamianski hilukamianski has a taxi outside he's going to the airport he's going to los angeles right now i asked him to come here right now on his way to the airport so that come hello so i could present him the most amazing thing ever the one and only the special edition rosh hashanah look what it says right over here special america's deaf young edition he's the first one that i'm presenting to with the logos with the logo unbelievable wow oh it even has a little letter inside guivaldi and also i gave you there's a gift that i gave you it's outside for all the guys at the seam all right zach is on [Music] all right yes uh today's your sponsored by vlad zakharov reforest lama for migrant oh once we're here who else in the kabura brought somebody i have a couple more avi let's go furman get over here doc doc come here come here come here you got one so come here whoever got whoever matter whatever i only have uh four more for now come who did you bring you brought yes i brought your nephew wow unbelievable that's one of the hardest you deserve four let's go ahead god who do you bring look at this wow unbelievable and dr avi factor i got two people two rabbi rosenberg's son ezra adam say say hello say hello oh here we go if you see your face in that screen bend down smile back okay beautiful who else anybody else in the group you you guys so come here what are you waiting for oh you uh whatever no but i want to say your name schlofrock get over here here you go thank you you'll get yours tomorrow morning okay uh who else there's other guys here okay and i didn't get i'm dying for one i said vlad reverse claim for his grandmother the austin family on the occasion of her first yard side given our boat was able to see five generations of its voice the austin family i have a lot of cars of life he got me on to the meaningful people which is a big hit for this year akiva who wakes up every day at 3am to prepare the daf and the hillo for making rebbe cry little boyer common of five the famous his famous father happy birthday to my daughter adara sara it says like this in the email i'm sponsoring an englishman's father happy birthday then my daughter adair sorry you should know that when you go when we go upstate to monticello she loves listening to your shirt while i'm driving sometimes you listen to two three urim just a refresher really looking forward to our sim i guess on monday there will be a live singer and band the same guys we brought in from sarto uh awesome food free gamoras there's even speakers over there with blumenstein or kevin macgachir among other treats can't wait to see all my old friends hope to make new ones thank you for everything thank you for not only inspiring me to learn torah but give me the ability that's what people tell me to inspire others to do the same but obviously not the same level as you lol love always comment of the five towns um as you know i was in yerushalayim in ramada school for shabbos and i made it back by hashem and i actually made charts from the time i came back and here but things will be a little bit famished let's see if i can get some of this stuff out here oh an email by yeshua aaron price [Music] my name is yeshua price i'm originally from all over the united states because my father is the us army chaplain nowadays i work 24 7 for mdy eight minute daf if it ever comes back rebellion you say you're not a poisic rebellion recent pastor passing than my work for mdy as it didn't be quite confusing for me and it's habits we started this stuff you have to share three years ago with just a few guys today i'm swamped with many new people it would be a helles of learning daffy me if you can tell everyone to message me their name and where they are from so i can update my phone and strengthen that if you have me learning worldwide thank you and just keep on daffing wow took three years you should get over here get over here with your thing with your thing look at this if you've ever been on a bus and there's a troll there's a guy that comes and gives you a ticket now we have an in-house ticket man if you don't come to the daf here he is he has a little thing thing here's this ticket machine though he actually has a full-time job he works on the bus line now barbershop has a great job and in between he jumps off the bus comes here he gets coffee goes back on the bus you scratch his shoulder what you recruited him on chavez you got his number and everything unbelievable way to go where did he die for shabbos that's right what is going to do with it [Music] hi my name is william mandel i just started this year which literally changed my life now i'm going to get these emails you just can't talk people he loves it he loves it it's my first year since i got married and i left yeshiva a few years ago etc etc william and dell and do we have any time here what time is it oh okay two minutes uh by yaakov mayor i actually said what he had to say here but i'll say real quickly thank you for taking the time to read this email playing a daffy yummy revolution i don't watch i watched your interview on art scroll i thank you for opening up and changing story to the world hopefully inspire increase started learning at this time right about one particular part of the interview when you spoke about your wife or my obviously never met i felt some pain she must be a very specialized kyle i've attached a four and a half minute video of herschel chef i'm not from hawaii who tells over an absolutely incredible story of the wife of values if i watch the beautiful stuff okay i wish you tremendous success and everything please forgive me if it's out of line eventually they zoom in again oh here let's talk about the socks here here we go uh this is from haim pollock i'm a big fan of the share i was a little bewildered by the advertisement for the share that i saw in shiva world news featuring a newly discovered picture of shiloh kirsteer oh i've heard from descendants of rav shaila that they believe this is not the picture it's perhaps of a different family member now anyway what shaykh is to share in my home opinion a worthy endeavor like yours is not in need of click bait keep up the great work now i do have to address this i also had nothing to do with the picture of my socks and and you're supposed to click on it it goes to this and actually a guy from machlaw in ramada skull came by to sing and he's like you know i was watching i was on youtube world news i see this picture of sakshi no idea what it was i clicked on it and it was you like it actually gets people but i have no no if they would have asked me i said don't do it please don't be madish me i had nothing to do with the shot like yours there at the end of the day i got to say something over a thousand people new people joined this year from over a thousand people so all this clickbait and the we could say whatever you want about it the guy over there i'm not going to say his name now because it's la shanhara but asano ganz really knows what he's doing and he's amazing and rabbi said we have a beautiful daft today the first oh there's one more thing okay let's what is this from who from slimy klein this better be good is it another lubavitcher safer oh wow wow that's unbelievable now this just threw me for a loop i'll tell you why because we're debating the shirt started it was eight minutes off then we went to mdy and most the guys in the sheer know it as mdy but eight minute dove brought a lot of people in like schlemmy klein himself came in because of eight minutes he tried to cheat and do it with the eight minutes then he realized it very quickly he has to do the full share but so one of my big rides i was telling the guys is that the license plates that everybody's doing is eight minute dab so they care about the eight minutes they don't care about it and now he just threw me for a loop now it's a stereo now what do we do i think we're gonna have to go to mdy now beautiful i love it now my collection is growing your vow to get stuff what amy duff is clickbait friendly wife true and kaine pollock is not going to like that raboisei the first part of today's daf which is really yesterday's daft la mercedes all the way to the mishnah no you know what let's call it all the way to the bottom of the armor is an advanced sugya it's an advanced yo it's a beautiful beautiful segue let me tell you what it's all about here it is i have nine steps here only and each step is a beautiful piece we did a bunch of them already on friday we're going to start in the middle of sugar from abaya let's just review real quickly it's gevaldig if you have it in line let me leave you yeah come yeah you don't want to come to the front it's great for coming i really appreciate it we're just talking about him his wife is the doctor the oncologist and he and he learns all day the secret man i believe okay for coming we just we just started in the soggy perfect timing it's a beautiful beautiful sugyo we had in the sugar that if a woman borrows salt water from a friend and she mixes it into her dough now powder part of her dough kind of belongs to her neighbor and her neighbor has an arrow of atrom going to the right and she has the area of going to the left so the the dough the bread is stuck you can't bring the dough in the direction of the woman that made the bread because part of the bread is owned by the next door neighbor so the kumar asked the question that's the first step here the water should become bottle bottle barrage bottle why do we care about the little water that's in the the bread if you recall sorb abba tried to say a beautiful answer he said a great answer it seems like a great answer that they should everybody should accept his answer when he comes towards this role and they laughed at him what was his answer his answer is it's money it's it's something it's obvious you can't go to your friend and grab a pile of money and say oh your money is both arriving my money and i'm not over in geneva it's money it's mumminess it's not a issue it's somebody else's salt it's somebody else's water that does not become butterburried that was step two nothing murrah says well if that's true why did he use a funny lotion of pita brita you can't take somebody else's hit him and put into your heat and that's min bimino but everybody agrees that membership is bottle so do you agree that if you steal somebody's money my even my example you take a pile of dollar bills and put in a much larger pile of bills it'll be bottled arrive or shekel and dollars min machine and mino gold and silver maybe i could be mavato lebroid you could in fact or so so what you're not over in geneva no you'll have to give back something else of course you're over your neighbor we don't have to give back that amount but that's at the point the point is he used the wrong wording that's why they laughed at him he should have said a case of membership amino why do you use a case of minority fine everybody holds the membership in his bottle and not only that he used the case of minbi not like your the we passing the min bin mino's bottle even if it's the same exact item it's bottle so that's why they laughed at him salting water says but wait a minute remember this is a beautiful halacha of soy rice if i remove the stones from my friend's bag of wheat even though stones are worthless but because they weigh the bag down i owe that guy the amount of weight of the stones why because he has every ride in the world to sell the bag of wheat with stones it doesn't have to remove stones it's known that there's some stones in there and it weighs the bag down the fact that you remove the stones you cause them a loss you have to pay back what do you see from here that the monetary value never is bottle it's not bottle he has to pay for it says abayo and that's what we're holding right now we'll just go through the sugi about because it's a beautiful soggy what's the connection between ceres when you have stones in a bag the seller is going to want his money's worth he's demanding his money's worth of the stones so stones are actually worth a lot but in our case where the woman lent her friend salt and water she will never want it back so it's mom and she ain't no toy she doesn't care about it and if you don't care about something it should become bottle so think about it says wait a minute you're asking about it becoming bottle and not bother has nothing to do with ownership varia what about a piece of novella a piece and a veil becomes bottled to something else whether it's owned by anybody or not owned by anybody becomes butler automatically that's cash in two seconds and then the gamer proves it from hefcker i'll prove to you that something that's after let's say you find an animal a cow that's hefca is it has its own trom wherever the cow is you go from there 2 000 it's not on the person that found it it's based on the cow now the cow doesn't have an owner so you see that you don't have to have an owner in order to have a trump and on that thing finally says that's the final step tomorrow's question was let's be me vato de trum and not the money part of it in other words this bread that these that this woman made is two things here there's money this value that her her neighbor gave her some salt and water but there's also the issue of trouble the part of the tomb the gym are saying that should become bottle is sure and become bottle yeah let's what well we'll get to the suit you could ask questions there i'm just i'm saying also yeah again there's a there's a concept of trum that you can't take this bread out more than two thousand ammo and there's a problem that is somebody owned some money in there the money that her neighbor owns in there the little salt we're not gonna we're not gonna be moving you can't move out of somebody's money great but the answer of moving this to here that that part should become bottle let's say there's an israeli veil here and somebody owns the novella the issue in the vela i should be able to eat the food because the issue goes away i'll have to pay that person money because they own it you know what i'm saying it's two separate things this is the isser and the monetary value and the gemara is saying but at the end of the day the isser should dissipate and should become bottleberry okay now let's see inside so we're holding at this step right here smack in the middle of the omelet smack in the middle of this ninth step sookie and if you're not into the sugiya it's literally going to be over in 10 lines and we're starting easier stuff says what are you bringing me araya from stones in a bag which was by the way i thought it was a beautiful allah because i if you were to ask me if i remove a worthless stone from a bag of wheat why would i have to pay the owner of the wheat it's worthless the answer is because he doesn't have to remove it and because he removed he just caused him a monetary loss of however much that stone weighs so two says the gemara let's compare that to our case where there's salt inside the bread there's a monetary value and that's owned by the other neighbor and therefore you can't move the bread anywhere says a bible is a big distinction remember i pointed out that in in this massacre at least abbay is big into making distinctions here here's another example and this is counter-intuitive because over here stones which usually are worthless over here it's yesterday typhoon people are going to demand paying up for the damage you cause by stealing their stones stones are books on shabbos they have no there's no value in this case they have a lot of value where the salt in our case has no value why now that has no value but it doesn't have a trivea doesn't have anybody demanding payment because she actually lent it to her she said take it get you can have it nobody's going to demand salt hey you borrowed a shake of salt give it back to me you borrowed a half a cup of water it's mom and chain like type him and since this mom and channel they told him nobody demands it then therefore what it should become bottle and if it becomes a bottle you should be able to move that piece of bread any in any direction that your area is is it should be limited it should not be limited to the to the woman that lent the salt in there big enough that's why i think anybody learning the suggyo and just read the art scroll from top to bottom you might be able to understand all the words i'm not sure that you'll have the clarity of the nine steps here at the end because the bar is jumping back and forth the the point of the soggy is does monetary value ruin a bittle could you be involved with something that has monetary value in there okay you're telling me that it's dependent that the reason why there's no bittle in the the salt and you have to go by the era of the woman that gave the salt because she's not i'm sorry if i care you don't have to go by her heir because she's not going to sue she doesn't care for that salt it's not dependent on ownership at all he says so let me show you real quickly this is very simple i'm just pulling it out again just so we have hazard on it a dead person is the highest degree of tomo then comes avatoma an availa is avatuma it emits tumor could create tumor for something else what if you have a kosher piece of meat that will shake the properly so it's not a veilus it's not tommy what level of tumor could it be it can never be avatuma the most it could ever be is the region it could receive toma from a charity let's say this dead mouse which is dead dead it touched in a piece of meat whatever it becomes a region okay so that's that now we're done with that now it's a mess here oh this i did mr chavez i'm very happy i did this so we know review the holds meaning if you have two apples and one apple they're all the same type they can they cannot become bottles as we view them one cannot be valued two against one let's say one is arla and the other two are you you're allowed to eat them the one does not become bottle in the two min machine amino if you take an apple and two oranges and somehow you don't know whatever they become bottle that's what that's reviewed so refrista explains this it's a beautiful aloha here you have this meat now if you look at this meat they all look the same is there any difference between this and this no the color is the same the texture is the same they taste the same the only difference is the ramifications here this is an availa and this is kasha so is there a difference yes why because nevaela could turn into kosher so the here's the the question is this considered mim bimini or smith is an availing kosher two separate meaning it depends if one becomes mixed into two that's right you could eat it right you you fi different allah so hold on in general just the idea so it goes like this hold on a second it goes like this nevaela could turn into kosher but kosher can never turn to novella so the first one kosher can never turn to the veil why could caution ever turn to novella because novella is avatuma right the veila is a avatuma and crusher can never become as tame as in a veil it's one step lower always it becomes tummy it's not itself inherently tommy nevaela as as an animal drops dead it becomes tummy it emits too much it's a very high madriga of toma avatuma a kosher piece of meat that touched the share it is never that high it's one it's one level below so therefore it's too meaning one is avatuma however more says that an availa could turn into caution meaning if this decomposes at that point it loses its tomah and it becomes like kasha and it's so much says very similar so refrigerators is in the nevaeh law think what happens here the novella is like kosher it's this is eventually going to become like kosher because it's going to lose its toma status and therefore this and this are the exact same item they're both tommy at the same level which is no tomah and therefore if they're the same item the same min is not buffalo coin interview though but in this case it's very similar case but it's very different the rive is the kosher that's the one that you want to be in battle you want to take this one guy and be my battle in the three or the two this will never become this let's mean i mean i and min okay it's a beautiful criticism let's go back there i'm saying it has to do with everything without sugar it's not we don't have to focus on it if you didn't understand that it's okay the point of the gemara here is that this guy right over here will become bottle to these guys right min bashing meter bottle a piece of hazer nevaela mamish the worst of the worst becomes bottle even if nobody owns any of this meat even if nobody owns this the kumar is trying to prove that ownership doesn't help doesn't detract from the fact that you can be involved a piece of meat you don't have to own it let's say you found it half or whatever you found a bag of meat it becomes bottled without ownership so why is that by telling me that the reason why it becomes bottle is because nobody nobody cares but if somebody cares it doesn't do with ownership you hear that's the kimura's tiny here available a piece of kosher meat can never reach the madriga of tomah of an loses when it decomposes what has to do with ownership it doesn't have to do with ownership if you're going to be stubborn and say yeah it doesn't have to do with ownership so i'll prove it to you that doesn't but ano let's see if i still have that sheet out so we're holding over here the veil is bottle without bilem and then gamora is going to prove from here that a a heifer you have a heifer cow nobody owns it like that uh donkey that i thought was hefker it has its own it has its own troom without ownership it has him i passed you by the street i said hello to you how you doing it's as if they have owners ownership so you see that these things have owner without ownership it's kilo you do have ownership so is not correct in saying that it has something to do with the ownership says the gemara but at the end of the day here's the final final step omale here's the question to gemara when the gemara asked it should become bhattabharav again what's the story let's start over woman rahul is making a challah and she realizes she doesn't have salt so she goes to a neighbor borrows a teaspoon of salt her neighbor is very happy to give it to her she pours the salt into her khala lagumar says because that salt that's owned by the neighbors in herchala rocco cannot carry this challah 2 000 almost in that direction why because leia who gave her the salt her home is going the opposite direction so he said but it's mumminess you can't be battled it could be the salt that's causing a tum problem a trump problem not a not a monetary problem that problem should go away because of bitterberry eve sure bottle my mind okay fine i'll i'll give it to you that she owes her neighbor a teaspoon of salt but that teaspoon of salt shouldn't keep the neighbor from carrying the bread out of the throat okay so now that's it now it's coming easy from here at the end of the day why is it that the salt does not become bubble mark zero chamomile we're concerned if you say that the salt becomes bottle so again rojo borrowed salt from leia and you're gonna say the salt is nothing you can carry it anywhere you want tomorrow rocco is going to make a partnership with leia half the dough and half of everything is leia's half is rahul and she's going to remember from the day before that she was able to rahul was able to walk with leia's salt in her bread so what's the difference is it a little salt or fifty percent is leia's she'll walk out of the tom and that's a problem that you cannot do right that's the same exact case that we had the other day if two people own one suit and this person has a atom going two thousand diameter this way and this person made his home because he did it two thousand dollars away from his from the suit so it's four thousand feet in that way four thousand dollars this way they cannot move the suit even one ammo in any direction same thing over here instead of the suit put a picture of dough you can't go this way you can't go that way but she's going to be confused she's going to think she could go that way because yesterday he told her that even though this salt of her neighbor in the khala she was able to move with it and this is very different because this should false rava my robe is not arguing rasheed says robert is just talking about a different case my body was talking about dough and rob is talking about food a cooked food have a little time of the if you have salt pepper it's there for the taste that's without salt you can't even eat the food i'm just saying like like guzma but salt and pepper the tablet is the spices is what makes the food but i'm a bottle something like that doesn't does not become bottle type of laminated verification we're very familiar with this something that becomes multi tomorrow tomorrow there's no trom water and salt salt you cannot walk out of the drum water becomes a bottle but says and salt it says both do become bottle ruby who themselves says there is no difference let's look at rashi real quickly the top rash is doing if you don't wash your hands you might have a little bit of this dumb salt on your finger and you'll rub your eye and it can blind the person and that's why we wash my macro name one of the reasons says the gemara so there's the enough communion review the y says salt yes salt not depends if it's um if it's very thin it's bottle because you can't really see it and it's bottle but the thick stuff like the what is it called the sea salt the big stuff is not bottle melo what it says over here that water and salt our bottle in though but not bottle in a in a in some sort of food why because of the gravy like ash our mishna is talking about the thick stuff and the thick stuff it absorbs the salt in the water and you cannot tell it gets right in there into the gravy you won't even tell that there's any salt melo says the michelle official mission sponsored by official the fourth name from brandon let's make some say there as we go along of course these are all going to be backwards oh we're talking about two things here we're talking about the coal the gachalas the coal that comes from the bottom and the shallowest is a fire what's the difference big huge difference gajelles weighs a pound it has my muscles you can feel it what shall i have is you can't feel it doesn't it's not tangible you can't feel it there's nothing there you can't capture a flame and put it in a box and give it to somebody it's going to go out right so the hell is correctly ability the coal that hat is like the owner of the coal mma law it goes in the direction of his trump shall have as is not it's not regulated is that the word since it's not tangible it's not regulated to the owner it doesn't you're not limited you're not limited to where the owner is nobody owns this it's something you just grab and you go nobody owns fire what is what's the word and what i said regular regulated relegated really my daughter will have another one to make fun of the whole the whole shabbos she's telling people he said in the epic center of new york like any any girl we shall have oh now so understanding this what's the next allah if i ask you a coal is tangible so it goes by the owner of flames not tangible doesn't go by the owner so when it comes to hekdish can i use a coal that's hectic is cold no because it's tangible and you cannot use anything from hectares you can't benefit from magnesium if you do benefit from eggs you have to bring a carbon and pay a fifth what about a flame i should be able to use a flame hectic doesn't own the flame oh here's a little trick that's that's rob status should i show it i don't know rav goff status you will not get a free gemara from me if you listen to this share good tell me ravgav how successful that was you know there's a guy that was doing schneiderlin retirement so i'm like advertised online if you join his time right now you get a free r scroll that means he he liked our campaign not bad okay qrackly and by them you also won't get charged by rev you might get more humor though what what supplies last how many were there we don't know six like tonight five gamers that says uh supplies again when it comes to mila it's always a little tricky but you get used to it lai maelem means doesn't mean do not use it don't do me la it means if you do me ila you're not either late by allah means right because it's not tangible so it's not tangible so you should be able to use it no learn to handle you can't do immoral explain why now what about of a desire if i ask you now about it for sure can you use a coal what about the flame heck did you know how to use the flame if you use you know you don't have to bring your carbon but you're not allowed to use it you're allowed to use the flame of a desire absolutely go over to zara go into the church light up no problem so we have to understand why if i take out a coal and this makes a lot of sense calls tangibles if i go from russia to russia i even have a picture if you don't know what that looks like it's going to be the last one no i don't have the picture okay didn't print you go from your house with a coal into the driving hive but if you go with from your house with a flame you can always explain how you are father commissioner very simple stuff everybody say here we go the five things three of them we already learned in the mishnah hi guys of course it's tangible you're not going to benefit from result which i'll have is that's an amazing english because we said hectares you can't use hagdish flame from magnesium zarik use the flame of language as we just said if i say i'm not going to benefit from my friend anything i say i'm making a nether i say i'm not going to have enough for my friend also we got to be that fits right into everything we just learned something that's tangible i cannot benefit from a flame i could go over on mata shabbos light might have double candle from him no problem what's the difference why could i use the flame of english i have a desire to me he saw people really the spies of the zara over the internet and they they stay away from it like there's no reason for alban to be mahmur people mahmoud themselves planting this is the opposite people love egg dishes for their burning shallots so goes on i have to say stay awake right i'll say if you're going to use the flame you might use the coal tomorrow let's make some takana there's no reason to make takanos when it comes time it says saw different than the mission that says that if i take out a flame and there's a rabbit i'm hyped a flame doesn't weigh anything it's not tangible high oh my gosh he had a match it's a matchstick let's say and if i hold the match i take that out which is what's the obvious question you have to take out the matchsticks you should be high for the matchstick why do you have the flame that's the kimonos you're going to ask but they're limiting [Music] the matchstick doesn't have a shear what is the shear that's not hamati ate him how are you by taking wood from your house into s how much you have to carry the mauryan travis talks about every type of item has different this the shear is the vascular beta what's the easiest egg in the world to cook a chicken egg a boise i gotta tell you this i don't remember in history of since i got whatsapp many years ago and email this one item that people kept on sending me and saying i got from 20 20 people 30 people the same exact thing over and over and over and over a guy in kidumim he has a farm and he prints the the date on every egg the expiration so from success baits he wrote hadron allah i got it in an email after email i said you know what i got to get my hands on this egg it's impossible you can't get the egg you cannot get the egg boy ladies and gentlemen here we go it's right here i got the egg i've oh it has a little hole in it oh i know it is i made the hole i wanted to take the yolk out so i could save this egg forever it's a very valuable egg i want to thank the owner the owner of this place himself brought it to me on air of shabbos here's the egg so if somebody has i don't want to ruin it with all this yolk okay an egg this egg this chicken egg is the easiest thing to cook but how much how much do you need to cook from this egg it's a little tricky it's not cabeza this is a cabeza the egg this is the item but how much wood kid gregaris we're talking about an egg but how much do you need to cook this egg very very little keger is like a dried fig here just pull this out tonight you could cook an egg on the hood of your car if you live in certain places on a sidewalk it's very very easy to to to cook all right fine this one if you guys want to touch this or look at it oh you have it also here it's the same thing you see i asked him i begged him if he could do mdy in it he said i'll try he tried and he tried i kid you not he finally comes up he says i have bad news my why is missing i'm serious he couldn't do the y it's a special machine that does it on a round surface so i wanna i have to thank tomer levy tomer tomer worked really hard to get me this so you should have tomer i needed it you need it sounded like this myself this baits it's a once once every seven and a half years that's it only narratives throw everybody it's only in there as she says the same exact thing basically according to raj one shot he took a clay rubbed it in oil put some gasoline on it rather than he lit it up instead of a match he did it on uh on a piece of uh shard or something the same question but now he's taking out a piece of broken from his house which is into the street which is a rabbit says it's a broken nothing with devil okay but he took out a piece of uh a broken piece of earthenware bless this euro it doesn't have the right shoe it's not kaires oh here we go on the mishnah how much earthenware they have to take out from your house and there's surround to be over the israelites i used to be a carpenter believe it or not seriously and one of the things i got all excited when i saw this when you install a door in america in israel they don't have this so that's why your doors are crooked but in america you take a ship it's called the shim and you put it between the door the the jam and the wood here you could put it a lot of times i didn't have a picture of that but on the bottom right over here if you want to lift this side up more than this is all from rashi right so if you want to lift this side up more you put a shim in there in those days they didn't have shims it looks like a pizza it gets narrower and narrower so the further you put it in the wider it is so you can lift up the door more you give it a whack with the hammer and it keeps on going again it's like this this side right you put it under like this the more you go in the door goes higher and higher okay anyway back in the day we used to install doors so or rashi says if it's between the two sometimes they would fill the gap over here with earthenware because they didn't have enough wood okay the point is whatever that is there's a certain chair it's not a big shear it's a small piece that's the shear of earthenware and this piece that he lit on fire doesn't have the shear so you're not over it but you're either because you took a flame outside the flame now what's why is it khashov because a flame that's attached we got to talk about this for a second it's a nice hop here a flame by itself is nothing it has not tangible so i cannot be over but it's or how it saw me taking something that i i took out of oxygen from here there you're not over but when the flame is attached to a piece of wood or earthenware now i can use it so now it has khashevas now i can take it i bring it here and i do this now i'm over and i talk because the kashivas of this flame even though it has no tangibility it's still harsh over on is that a word and what intangible means yes you're not able to touch no no i'm saying it is it has tangibility tangible with tangibility is that a word i relegated that to tangibility okay fine [Applause] though nothing more asking questions you take out a flame and your potter hey chemistry if you took it out with a match or something else it is a word ah the part of it should be you guys missed the doctor mr lawyer both of you you didn't know a word that i knew just made it up but you still didn't know the doctor and the lawyer okay here's how you do it says gemara there's a flame at the edge of your home and you give a poof and the flame flies out into the surrounding i don't know the cure and the part so well but at the end of the day you move the flame from here to there and that's however without a match okay says the official mishnah sponsored by official again for fortune for brianna bassien to devour she gets to today when an individual owns a bar a well a pit he owns it it's in his head so the water that's drawn from there goes by his arrow and if he makes an area of in that direction that's the only way you could that's the only place you could do you could carry the water vicious you always say here but if it's a communal well correctly aren't you so here's this is a beautiful thing i didn't show the oil on this i like this one a lot and i when we were talking about home i didn't really have a chance to show it but it's it's beautiful it's just it's very simple and effective this is your home and you made your meal over here so you made it 2 000 away from your home so basically what you did is you shifted your home to the bread and now you get this is your home so you get two thousand dollars in this direction two thousand two thousand dollars in this direction for a total of four thousand dollars from here to four thousand but what you did is you can no longer go even one foot in this direction that's why there's an x over here why because your home is over here and you're limited to 2 000 to this direction and then stop short that's what the throne does okay so if you're a yakid you own the well and you made your troom over here so everybody drawing water can only go in this direction they can't even go one foot in that direction but if it's communal well so even though your trum is this way that way it goes by where the community is so you could you could you could move the water in the direction of where the community's arum is vishal oil now we're gonna see the gemara people that came from bavel they made their wells and their wells let's say it has a name of hefker let's say he ragley hamilly whoever draws the water from there it goes by here's the aero in other words what is that called rabbi's eye anybody remember yes breira because on yante if i draw water now all of a sudden the water is limited to my arrow you draw water now it's limited to your ear if that means yes breira i decided on youtube retroactively what direction it goes romelay roberto renachen so rava asks his famous rebbi it says in our missional that individual well goes by by the owner of the well veriminu you have a river that moves or you have a spring that keeps on overflowing hurray but rashi says that it doesn't go anywhere just keeps on coming up comes out of the ground but stays within the well it's constantly moving and something that constantly moves doesn't have a trom you can't it's constantly moving so you can't have a turn something that moves hare hain kiragli kaladam whoever draws the water grabs it that's the trom how come by us in our well in our mishnah it has a trom it's limited to the owner it's moving no says gomorrah omar rabbo many many many times i don't know how many times hundreds when it says rava there's a gears on the side rabbit oh my rubber hook on my skin awesome we're not talking about a natural oil we're talking about a pit in the ground that just you you store your water there it doesn't move me mellow it goes by the owner it's gathered water bishop if this is very interesting you have a a well that's there from the early bubble the people that come from iraq and you've filled up the water to give to your friend we said that whoever draws the water that's the arrow that goes by what if i draw for you now what i look at this is it me because i drew the water but i hadn't intend to give it to you would have told us right away that is says it goes by the person that received the water at the end it was for him it was drawn for him and had intended for it representation is almost correct it goes by the person filling it up what's this holds baby oh this well is hefter and this allah when it comes to to have care that you cannot be kind of something when you're when this hafka i cannot pick up a piece of gold and have a mind for you because i am damaging for other people oh i'm i'm taking away their chance to grab the gold you want to grab for yourself great but don't do favors with somebody else i can't do it that's the aloha in in according to them yeah so mela over here too i don't have the right to draw water for that guy it's a lockheed after and if i do then it became mine i i drew it so it's for me it's my so it's my tum oh my gosh that it goes that goes by the person that it was filled for because at the end of the day all of clay's troll owns the water in the swell it was made for glycerol so all you're doing is taking out water that i already own and that's fine ac revolving arena if i say to you you are okay about me in other words you're not a lot of benefit from me hamudder also so you are user to benefit from me and we're turning into that somebody sponsored the white healing group for those who need to do refugees please join the mdy taylor group sponsored by nathan kushner for my children i call her van vora and historically i am to you so you cannot benefit from me because i am on you okay and if i say if i carry it you are tamir so here's the question just if we stop right here we have the question what is early bubble if a bubble is a partnership then we should be awesome we're all we should i should be honest on you what do you mean how could we be how could if everybody owns a little bit of the oily bubble well then i should be awesome to use the the i love the well because i'm oscar to benefit from you and you own some of the water in the baba well alomai you see from here that oil above the well is hefcare and not a partnership now we continue going vasura mission here but in that that city's world is awesome because obviously they have a partnership in the world but well they don't believe in dorms what is early buffalo harabayas the holy harabayas hallows should have pulled out the the chart here you can't see the base i made this stuff it's by the bubble owned by all of israel uber and a well that's the middle of the way here what's considered the city haruhi the streets obey sacramento's in the shoulders america is in the bath house behind his bedroom now the kimono goes to the question we are just barely shooting who but if the well is owned in a partnership by my mother why can i benefit from the well you own part of it two partners that's where they won't benefit from each other i swear they caught us by bart you see what happens when people fight they say crazy things and now they can't go into the pit and then and wash up in the pit so over here you have a pit that's almost you shouldn't be able to use it there's a difference between what bathing yourself in a pit and drawing water from the pit bathing yourself in the pit you are going to be using all of the water in the pit every part of the water touches you and even if not then that guy has no right to even take water from there afterwards because you touched it all you can't do breira anymore and but to draw water i draw one pail you don't own all the water in the pit i'm drawing one of the pails and that's mine and the rest is yours whatever this one of those pails is yours but i'm not taking from you my did they come in value you might remember they go each one is going to draw water that he owns you can't just because you have a partnership in this well it has tens of thousands of gallons you don't own all 10 you own one gallon okay that one gown but if i'm gonna bait myself in there now i'm using even your gallon and that's a problem [Music] but there's not gonna really hold the cans of bread so real quickly a cowboy every year you must bring a half of a shackle right the famous sugar but they have to add a cowboy it's a tiny little coin because the money changer he takes a little bit of a fee and we don't want the best amigos to suffer now if two people bring a whole shekel half his mind have his mendies and we give it we still have to bring two components but if a father gives for his two sons you don't have to give a compliment that's allah number one okay that's the love of calvin a lot of people that haven't done the daft have no idea what cowboy is if you didn't learn skalim my favorite what skull yeah yeah my favorite mistake though oh yeah it just gives me neighbors because i had to do four death in 17 hours and i don't know how to get over it i have to go to a psychologist or something it's not even that hard yeah it's very it actually is very hard it was very hard and it said okay fine well i literally i my body started shaking when i said the word skull so combine skull anyway fine i'm scaring the whole island because when we get to scholar okay hopefully it'll be purim time not pesach wow i don't know if i told the island i didn't shower for this either i walked into the sailor what's going on like my kids like nothing i didn't have to as as i was closing the computers like how two minutes before ski fine for you guys or in their talks i had to give she room for prairie shell but next myser myself every 10 animals uh the newborns that are i have to give one bring it to you eat it for myself what if i have a partnership and that's how you get out of the whole microwave today you have a partnership you don't have to bring my superman if they have to bring a cowboy meaning there it's abbas it's the kind of when the father leaves an inheritance and they then divide the inheritance so how do we view it if they are partners partners don't bring micer but partners have to bring a cowboy right two people me and mendy who bring a master master one shekel half his mind have his amenities we we have to bring two cowboy cowboyne but twister bias does not have to bring two carbineum so it's a very similar if they are considered partners not part of the inheritance then they're positive for micer but have to bring a kalban but if they're part of the inheritance they don't have to bring a cowboy but they do have to bring my sir well if we divide different types of animals so then it's like a purchase it's not a beautiful division it can never be perfect i get two goats and you get three three uh sheep that's not fair somebody's gonna miss out in a if i get two sheep but you get through sheep then it's perfect and i can say that's how my father left it that's how the father left it for the children as he died it's just breira but if they divided like things that are very similar to each other you get your share and you get your share vernacular that's if you hold breira the two goats that you got and the two godzilla we both got an inheritance it wasn't it wasn't a purchase we're talking about a pit that's completely healthcare before we said mars the majority is different when nachman holds if can i not if can i be kinda a healthcare object for my friend or not that's how much is renown says no have a wonderful day we'll see you tomorrow boys side tomorrow night 8 30 i think it is at my house a beautiful barbecue and humz and everybody gets a gift when they're there what'd i say see him see him barbecue tomorrow at my house please sign up you