Daf Yomi Beitzah Daf 37 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] today's shares being sponsored by in honor of david zlatnick f200 akiva salko it's f94 sean randolph eight min 20201 yoyomi committee more from them in a bit by vlad zakharov rav boisei he this guy is new here he doesn't know that there's no talking now he just came from the safari his head is in the safari nom do me a favor refuse letting from my grandmother naham abbas haika ali zanavi sherman and family on the 10th yard side of our mother and grandmother starting with mdy for masekis rosh hashanah mazel tov and welcome yeti schwartz good one a giant happy birthday mazeltov to the most incredible and awesome chime lady grooner along with a shout out to his wonderful havrusa joseph hecker now we have more abba rennert in honor of andy brachfield a close friend who encourages me to keep on daffing with rebel shlita maybe because of this dedication he will join us well wow he keeps on bugging people to do it but himself not and because hashem i'll get another raffle ticket you get two raffle tickets i think for the second guy no something we have to figure it out sixth aaron hirsch not moisture iron hirsch in memory of the yard side of my grandfather shloimov and jacob her voice i i received an incredible amount of unbelievable emails and obviously we won't be able to read them all i want to share with you this particular one that mike russo filmed me reading this while i was crying i didn't know he was filming me but i'm not going to show you that part let's talk about the torah pyramid scheme this is the third pyramid scheme as you recall david zlatnick what is he f two o two i think the zlatnik went to the serum of akiva salkwitz which was akiva's first first serum and it was a beautiful scene and he thought outside of the box he brought himself over 30 guimaras and he pushed along to grab a gemara and join me so what is that 35 days ago and then he opened up whatsapp group for these guys and i started with three guys 35 days ago today there are over 70 i i saw it at 68. they told me there's over 70 people in the group yesterday somebody sent me a screenshot 68 guys let's call it and david is on top of them and other guys knew did you do the death we did the daf all this group is about is about to die and about how it's changing people's lives let me read you this email and this is doug zlatnick taking it in his own hands coming up with his own idea something that was out of his comfort zone he told me he doesn't like doing this stuff but he felt it was necessary hi my name is hill boyer from kensington in brooklyn as a teenager i always wanted to do the daf i tried many times i failed after the second and third day this past august i was on vacation with my dear friend like kevin sulk was f94 now whoever knows akiva wouldn't believe that he's capable of doing such a thing i saw him carrying the article gemara wherever he was going i asked him since when was he doing the daf he told me he started with sukkah and he's hooked for life he told me that i need to join the share not too long after that he scheduled his first season i went that day to buy two hours from kumar's one for myself and one for penny parrots who's also currently going strong keep up pinning i've been thinking about sending an email but i wanted to do it until i was hooked the gemara became the number one thing that i was always in my hand i haven't missed the day i've made it through all young typhoon without falling behind i was in orlando for sukis preparing for the khag i made sure to leave myself some time to do the death after they drove i drove to miami for shops i like to listen to music usually well i was doing the duff earth shops in miami while the guys were at the pool i was doing the duff on the flight back from new york doing the duff the next morning kid sir i'm honestly shocked i've lasted this long and even more shocked and i'm about to make my very first seal at the age of 25. i've never in my life felt such a strong love for learning it became part of my life and it's totally natural now this is after 35 days i do not go to sleep without doing the daf i love it and live it it's that simple you mentioned once that they're gonna say okay fine i've always had the love for toro but you were the one that helped me develop it your share is the one of a kind the charts are amazing my life has been changed forever i don't know how it's possible and actually became happier more chilled out person thanks for helping me give my parents the knackers you should see the video that akiva sent me when his father big long beard was about to see him first time that one of his sons made us see him the guy he should have seen the emotion over there unbelievable hugging and kissing for for minutes they always knew that one day i'd come around and learn gemara thank you for making it a pleasure and something i look forward to every morning when i wake up good morning ah as of last night two more of my friends have taken upon themselves to join himself with shashana i want to give a special shout out to the yomi committee and all that solid guys in the f and b ps okay thank you to the zlatnik f200 not f202 f200 who i became very good friends with and sexton he told me he left me a voice note that not only did he accomplish all this with the learning but his friendships with different people through this he made new friends and the the the achtus he checks in with me every once in a while to make sure i'm still on board dub it i'm hooked for life thank you aye choking up i plan on visiting in israel i can't wait to come to live sheer show ran f202 started the trend attached some pictures of my flower to trip and here he is rabbi sai here's the tsa the killer boyer schmuck a normal guy that toyra became part of his life here is orlando miami okay i think there's another one now so that's the one that made me choke up here's a funny one from the famous yoli doppel belly as you predicted keeping up with the daf of the young turbine was very challenging this is a great email for an american an english guy an israeli might have some hard time here okay and i'll tell you why from the picture especially here in the u.s midway today boston back to back with no possible routine inside that sometimes felt like a convoluted mush of arabs and matzahs with some days in between when i can't access youtube for the share i fell behind multiple times as someone dependent on routine and threatened to crush my rhythm and learning the daf in parentheses yummy but i took your advice and kept trying to do that days that regardless of whether i finished the previous days or the day before that what followed was a hot mess of skipped open half a quarter i moved him which after i sketched it i had on a paper looks like a complex football play that was drawn out by ambitious coach diagram attached it says like this the fjoymie holiday non-blitz play goes up to the top half test to the bottom to the right ah you could always depend on yoyoli your advice really saved me and what kept me committed so what if i learned the mascara two days before the havamina so what if i saw a picture of the shiva dog walker and the hat and jacket before the other shivers she got with the shorts and the white socks and saw to share with your kittle the same day as the share with the asuka so what if i knew the ending of the story spoiler alert of the two thousand dollar ibm kippers dhaka collection when asked by one of my children was a mild case of osher high individual syndrome aka ocd how can you possibly learn like that my reply was every word expression is a precious mitzvah and that is not about the daf it's about the yo all right i'm serious i have a pile here 701 days counting i made it i made it you know i said this that the day after i uh said kaddish for 11 months and every day i had to come to show before everybody here are all these unbelievable some of these are mamish tear jerkers and gervald stuff here the muscle here bring that over here bring that come here shim shi shim shi get over here i have one to read for you because of that uh hold on show what you have here subscribe subscribe listen to this mark ruttenstein mazel tubb you are just 1932 behind cal rivkin continuing to good health mark rottenstein brooklyn new york now we learn about to be macholic in the suggest we have shabbos isn't that new you're alarmed in mark what is the naf community and ellie stefanski and cal ripken got divorced cal ripken didn't have the streak in a row he had many many days he had vacations he had six months to go 700 let him come and say his share 700 days straight with him kipper with shabbaston with tisha bob big talk it's nothing what he's done okay fine we got to be alarmed in my friend now real quickly we're going to do something very very interesting here i first want to read by the way we have right now we're not going to learn today this is we're going to learn today there are 650 new guys joining this year so you all have to be on your best behavior the first day 650 just yesterday alone like over 100 120 something so i want to call out some of the guys here from the street a lot of them are in this room it's request you're the wolf you're who the hammerman marcia hamburg he's here marcia what did you bring mary salman okay the wrong cornbread sitting right next to him who did you bring ellie what agreed skip today so we can both kick tomorrow's next week doesn't work no who do you have from where joseph rabbi yosef richards mayor below abbey berger menachem wine rib even handle evan hendell nissin dueck perry moses parrot's rap report are any of these guys here who's paris rapport not your kid cooperman family daniel dax israel weisberg mark sivelnick gavriel battle of paris heinlein woman i saw i saw kim's name i'll keep the soul away here we go keep a soul away you see who did you bring akiva your grandfather wow what a grandfather do so that his grandchildren should get that special edition akiva come here i don't know if knows what you look like come here i give you a second get over here pinaka smiles you'll see shasha and avi burger yeah thanks for being your grandfather must have been tough now and two of your cousins yeah so what are you gonna do with the raffle if you win the raffle what are you gonna do you're gonna hang out with nothing seltzer we're gonna take the 5 000 cash 5 000 cash you're going to run a seminary for four days trading all the other days okay boise does anybody in this room have a smartphone anybody have a smartphone raise your hand okay raboisei do this with me please entertain me for a second where's my where's my smartphone here we go you ready take out your smartphone where's your smartphone our voice i we're gonna do this together check this out we're all gonna go right now seriously take out your phones take out your phone i don't see your phone oh son and during the show everybody's like this now [Laughter] what's wrong with you guys with with with one minute of your time you're going to be almost part of this torah pyramid we're going to go to listen to this everybody you guys watching also mdy status status.com do it don't look at me i see you know i'm staring at me and you know should i do it and i blow up my phone press go you know what happens do it and it says should you open this page in whatsapp and you click open now all of a sudden it gives you a message here you just press send okay i did mdy status and i got this from phone number 972-53786-0586 no that doesn't make sense okay anyways i press it i press it and you wait 10 seconds look what's going to happen here it's not going to work because it's live now didn't work it's the wrong number it didn't no it worked before here we go here we go okay you get you get all these things here yeah freaking motor raffle you get three things a video and this now you take this and you push forward what uh you know why because we're all pressing at the same time maybe we confuse the robot okay just do it and then you press forward and by the way i'm from the generation i didn't even know what status was like this you could bring i did this within two minutes somebody signed up to the share within two minutes and then afterwards throughout the day do this you take that video look at this you go to my you go all the way on the top it says my status you click on that and you just press forward boom that video whatever you have goes into your status and the young guys know how to use it it goes on to their phone they present the thing and they sign up that's all you have to do it takes one minute rabboissai you know how to do it mandy come here repeat yeah yeah we don't talk about this again fine let's go everybody so we have a lot to learn here this is yossi hirsch and robbie salmon we have guys like this also watching this by the way it's not just that's all the guys what next what what do you say no no no three things come up it tells you how to do it it gives you a message how to do it okay everybody said today's aflamezyan amazing sugiyo this is what we learned yesterday no that's this that's the that's the cafe that you do with your with your head with your mouth all right yesterday in the mishnah we'll just go over this real quick you're going to go through the whole mission of the gemara so don't worry if you didn't get the mission yesterday we're going over it right now [Music] okay there are three categories in the mishnah means means a little bit of a mitzvah and mitsu means a lot of a mitzvah you can mute them send them to nothing salsa he deals with those uh stalkers one of my students yeah don't tell my wife whatever you do don't she'll make me quit this year all right in the category schwarz of israel the mission says you can't do these four things on shabbos because this is the rabonan climbing up a tree riding an animal swimming and clapping your hands the top him i didn't have room for it i just took it off clapping your hands dancing uh patching your lap rashos semai mitzvah dunga dantera be makavich a woman doing khalitza doing gi bone we'll discuss it in the gemara a full mitzvah is creating hectic they're saying this goes to the visa mikdash erichen erkelai my value his value whatever that is 50 shekel goes to the base amigdas same idea i say this thing should be harim and ghost visa and finally to be mafix trump semicircus which is a mitzvah all asa and chabas all also in chavez all of us are in shops says we're holding by by where it says gomorrah 10 lies from the bat loyola elon xero shemo yitlois you cannot climb up a tree because you might be over isa right so right over here if you climb up a tree you might break off a branch which is kitesur kuitser is iso allah behind an animal on shabbos as well you're riding a fast animal you might miss the markers you might go too quick you'll you won't see it you're high up so you'll come out of the throne which we're going to be discussing at length today by the way this daf is so jam-packed with musagem and halachaz it's unbelievable things that many of us are very familiar if you're new to the daf you just go through one thing to another every every line is another it's a big problem oh you're not allowed to do this because of xero we only do zero in a direction that they're abundant like that you're not going to make xero2 or durability of zero like zero we have a big macho legs and shots where cuba holds their eyes but everybody else basically holds their abana from here would seem like a yacht so what's going on you're right alexa the problem of riding an animal is the same problem as climbing a tree you need to whack that animal sometimes and you're going to cut a branch off and that is the right village and cannot swim on the water why maybe you'll make a floatation device so it'll help you swim i'm not exactly sure if this is what rashi meant or maybe something a little smaller like what we have like a tube or something some sort of barrel to help you swim okay the idea is the same valois metaboloid missapkin william ragdon on chavez on yontif you're not gonna clap your hands not in troll not at the shabbos table you can't bang on the table and drum you can't whack your leg and you can't dance zero you suck in cliche because perhaps you might come to fix an instrument now as we had to show you before if you'd have a go to be malam it's question the people that do collab do drum on chavez you're not supposed to tell them it's better you should gain value is zidane there's a thousands on that daf that says that our days we don't have instruments like this do we we don't know how to fix we don't fix someone made that's not exactly the question is everything that we have today doesn't apply we're not going to make fires just because you're driving a car so drive a car the answer is we don't take off these xaviers so why all of a sudden this tyson took her off sriramisha feinstein came up with a wild chat that the kleisthen never accepted it there was always guys that were breaking the rules they were dancing bislavas and mama it's xaira that wasn't uh received by clyde israel so since it doesn't apply anymore with tyson svara so melee the two things combined great but north doesn't bring down thai swiss doesn't bring down reminiscent fighting stainless and says it's us to do today one of my good friends left me a voice note he's very hasidish and he said that i want to be mulamite's huss on myself and all my friends and show all my hasidah friends we clap a lot and i know that hasidim they understand this um i'm literally i don't understand what he was saying to me he was like chinese he said that we do it out of isla what the gemara means to say is if a guy is a professional and he's doing percussion and this and that but we islam was we can't control ourselves where our neshama he said is asking us to do it we're doing it via slavis so i wrote him back and if you know shama wants you to jump in a car and drive this slide is to get the show that makes him motor he's like i hear i hear but anyway i don't i don't understand i know that i have my sister's friends always say these things it's slavism that's not this just i'm making a point do what you want to do the rama says not as allah but as there's there are some that are making like that and he brings the titus yes but not that he passes like that zero he's pointing out why people might be doing it i also told him i said you don't have to come on to the slavis tyson says it and he says you're right yeah okay next velo hey mushrooms and it's not the mitzvah is not in him the mitzvah is with the rav that's greater than him so in mello nobody should do it there's always somebody there's always something don't don't do it below me catching you shouldn't do kidus you shouldn't marry a woman do kidusan ah mitsukovic this week's power show we had last week's parish april this week's pirate show was more of a of a bracha not so much the midsole but it's in the parasha the the idea of provo [Music] brings down that the three of us to have a boy and a girl according to missile and if you have that already there's a little bit of a mitzvah to keep on going so there's a whole thing here if he doesn't have a wife according to rashi it would be awesome to be a catholic woman on shabbos according to texas you would be allowed to be in casual women's shabbos okay but i heard a a very interesting story say at least a talber he was he said that he was by a rosh hashiva or a big goddamn that that just lost his wife and he and you s that hush of a person goddel the israel he said called him god israel was sitting shiva and during his ship he said do you have a for me in other words it's a it's a mitzvah not not to be alone to have i know it sounds wild and crazy but this idea of maybe i should do it on shops should be in college no he so even though he so that's the child what if he doesn't have or do you just say okay since he has and since fi huh harrison yeah not in this one villain so khalito what is halito if a person la eleno dies without children there's a guy in the sheer wrote in a bunch of emails slightly related to him he had to go through this process his brother was lifted at a very young age and he was the of them so if a brother dies without children you have to be me having the wife you have to marry his daughter and in order to so that he should have a continuation and if she doesn't want you don't want you do khalitza she removes the shoe she spits the whole thing it's all pressed special shoe he went through it unfortunately you don't do this in chapels valuable and you don't you don't you don't uh marry her von mitsukovitz it's a mafursh apostle it's a whole whole whole parish it's really well it's the real mitzvah or the better mitzvot so here's the picture of yoni if you want to know what it looks like couple's married he dies she's alive the next brother steps in and marries her so the prospect says over here and rashi brings the apostles meaning the older the darshan strength that's not the simple meaning but the murder the oldest brother should be the one performing the misform and we have the same idea you don't have the mitzvah the so it's not a big key of it's only a minor key um and what's what's what's wrong with all this zero that goes on all four of these then tara you're going to write out the sock hidushin one of the ways to even casual woman is with the star khalitsa you got to write it out you have to write aksuba so may all these have to do with writing do not do it on chavez and yonte you should be give honor to shabbos not doing what you usually do don't do what you do from doing your whatever your needs the da beard so the marshall let's say you own a car leasing company and a guy comes over and says how much is that new maybach gls 600. it's not a joke if you say the price and you really think some 160 grand by the way this is what they're driving these days in new york 160 grand beautiful car it's a it's a mercedes suv gorgeous but the other needs it and it's mama's just going together it's because i could get more guys to come to the doff so maybe it's more to to to to talk about anchovies is sir gummer issa gomer isn't there raisa talk about it and it doesn't help the joke the shabbos girat oh the show is great it's sold it doesn't help it's an issue people don't people think it's a it's a little bit of a humra no it's a possum what is that money called 160 000 i think it's better to talk about the daf so if you you know i do make a humankind and i'll do business on chavez mma law going from one wishes to the other taking food that belongs to me and giving to me semita she goes for one so even that forget about a car i want to sell you something even to donate something to base i mean it's awesome villain might be interested in my success in order to eat fruit the guys in new in in america and in florida england they're not familiar with this stuff you can't just grab an apple out of a shoprite and eat it in arizona you have to make sure that somebody took up a part of it out and gave it to the client and the lady truman maiser of course you can't why there's a number of reasons but the main one that we know of is that it's misakimano this apple is awesome to eat when i chop a little piece off of it and i say to the cayenne to the lady now i could eat it i just fixed this cleat i just fixed this pre so it's about that sauce why is it awesome i said mono it's probably the wrong way to say it niriki misakiman it looks as if he's fixing sight it didn't fix anything the apple is the same same color same size it looks as if he fixed it before he couldn't need it now he could eat it but what if it doesn't look like he fixed it because all he's trying to do is help the cayenne sustain himself and yante give him sim haciantev go over them with a basket of fruit nobody thinks oh he took turmeric some ice creams people think oh he's a nice guy he's giving food to okay nevertheless it's awesome vitamin period to the metabolism this is when it is also for you to eat already from here viante nerve shops but what if it just became muscle right now how does something become muscle right now if you make dough or we had another case even with wheat i can make it user you guys remember we had a sugya how does wheat become awesome now in travis because before i thought i was going to grind it and then i said i'm going to eat it mellilois i'm going to i'm going to eat it like a snack it just became muscle right now i'm allowed to make don chabe because i need fresh bread so mela my first novel then i could be mafresh trump is a mysterious rebuttal didn't say it's awesome to do they only said when you could do it beforehand don't do something you could do before look at this schwarz means isadora bottom rashos semi mitzvah going to the entire mitzvah massive mitzvah to be like what going to the entire is not a little bit of a is there about and it is this is we just said in the mission it's also to do also to do all these all these things four here four air all so they should all be called schwoz says no we kind of explained it that's why we don't understand the character so much more the the center column is only a semi mitzvah not a not isa mitzvah right so even the word trust a lot of people didn't even know which was yeshiva i don't think we ever mentioned that word it wasn't past that word or that base that word didn't exist so now means this category is only a mitzvah and you can't do it on yountif but it's not is it there what is this there about all right let's look let me buy a commander no of course lemon was great this is the hustler this category is only used to their abortion it keeps on going let's do absolute even if it's semi-mitzvah starting oh it's a little bit of a mitzvah you should be able to go to the entire on chavez commercial and not only the center category huge mitzvah donating a lot of stuff to the base hamikdash be my first room with some maestros was the mitzvah but since it has a little bit of schwarz it's also is there a bottom nami also says it says and what's the final sentence in the mishnah the famous line what is the difference between chavez and only the only difference is cooking you'll have to cook ask the gemara what about this case the famous case that i'm allowed to save my fruit that's not cooking that's saving a monetary loss which on yantev i can do it and on travis i cannot do it so here's another navigation why are you telling me only here saving money is saving something is awesome there will be only shabbos [Music] our mishna is going according to a lesser that holds i am not going to be mako when it comes to saving money the yeah monetary loss yeshua and sure says i will save money i will i could be mahalo young to save money where do we have the case the san jose visit i shouldn't offer a bar remember this case i couldn't find the picture of two cows so we had two elephants that fell in how do you save them revelations the shock you could take one save one any one you want the bigger one take the bigger one out bashing yourself the second one you throw in some water you give him some trees to eat and he's good to go kadeshi is just enough to sustain him that he shouldn't die he's allowed to do trickery first you take out the baby you say oh i want veal i'm gonna have to or take whatever you want the point is you take one and you say i want that one the then you do a trickery oh no no i decided i want to fill i want a fatty steak and you take out the second one why does he allow trickery to prevent the monetary loss so you see the results of the opinion that for monetary laws by the way i'm telling you i said this to mark this skill to differentiate between two similar things is a tremendous skill in learning but it's also a skill in business i felt that i was able to outdo sometimes in business in a meeting with to be able to to make a slight enough meaning between two things guys it does the same thing it's not the same thing and point out why it's not the same thing why the price should be different why this why that it's a skill it doesn't come naturally but the gemara trains is all the time by the way i noticed that a buyer recently was was doing it and i looked up i found a bunch of times in beta more than the rest of the shops oh i buy him am i what's the connection they'll not kindly call my rebel as a host when it comes to two oysters i should point out also a mother and a son cannot be shecked in one day it's it's their eyes to two of them so you can only shift one or the other so you can only save one really because you're only going to shift one so the other one is books it to you so that's why you do the trick i forgot to mention that that's why you do the trick no i want to shove this oh no no no no i made it i want to shove that one that's why you literally anyway another outlook i'm just saying this daf is full of alohas and you say this says what's the connection between saving your fruit on a roof and saving an animal in a pit they're very different new what's the difference what what would you think the difference is so he says dilma california that should prepare also you could you don't have to your elephant is not going to die throw some water and then he'll live but over here on the rooftop if you don't save all your fruit whatever is left on the roof it's going to get ruined in the rain so maybe i could save it all in or another shop when it comes to two elephants or two cows i could do trickery i could say oh i want this steak no i want that steak but with a bunch of grapes how are you going to do trick oh i want this script not that great they're all the same hello what's the difference between this case of the fruit saving fruit and now our mission was says you cannot have save monetary laws only don't ask me during the chapters is over still material even though it's even though it's not necessary so much beyond it so my mela that be solo is also going to say that you'll allow to save your fruit and move it into the skylight says gemmar de malay again let's differentiate this earth to take out from mississippi is it not a good differentiation nice try atutil the only reason why there is a concept of mukta is because of the xera that you might come to do it so it's one in the same mma law there's no way to differentiate the two the official mishnah spans of official reform forever so now until then the receptor really this is the last peric right we only have four days left we're going to be discussing a lot about so what's the here's hectic she pointed at something saying take this what oh unfortunately i didn't have time even to read those emails beautiful scene everywhere uh in london i know arie davis put up new projectors for the cm new things everywhere chicago is even going to have a big seam uh in lakewood iron hirsch running the scene there brought in ravi hissiger the guy that interviewed me from our scrolls he's going to be their guest fine what over here we have a big seam at stefanski's house big barbecue big kumzets which one is what okay no women this time okay so i don't know if this is the right one but this is that on shabbos you can only go 2000 amma from the end of your house or the end of the city whichever one comes last if you live in a city from the city limits you have 2 000 amaz in each direction a total of four thousand amas now if you establish your residence you say this is not my house my house is going to be somewhere else where where i place a meal where i place a piece of bread so now you just shifted your residence so now your residence became where this khala is and having you have two thousand arms in each direction from the khala but it ends right over here that means you cannot step one foot in this direction but you could step two thousand ammo in that direction because your residence just shifted it went from here instead of being the house it went to the khala that's it says the gemara beautifully the mishna hmm okay right here how if i own anything i own an animal i own a cleo whatever it is it could only walk and go and be carried only as far as i the owner am allowed and permitted so check this out i live in this house i made i'm allowed to go 2000 ama this way he lives in this house we're both from different casitas you could tell from the hats and everything he's a little he's a stickle uh conservative closet okay he has a stickled small towel and it's a very interesting picture huh with a talus a small little shawl talus that he got on the hook when he walked into the shield yeah in the steel yeah so here's the his house he could go 2000 i'm this way so his goat could only go up until this point it happens to be that they share 1 000 ammo that they could meet they could it overlaps one thousand ammo you see in this red this guy could walk up to this line this guy could walk up to here his two thousand armor finishes over here and this guy's 2000 ammo finishes over here so this 1000 ammo they could both schmooze and and carry the problem is that he cannot take this guy's goat and bring it back to his house because his goat is no better than him since he could he stops short over here so his goat also stops short over there that's the shot that habehema caleb correctly about how much mental illness what yantev this okay yeah shabbos move it so even if the zero is still true you give your animal to the shepherd to the babysitter to your son onyantif harelu kiragli habbalim again it doesn't go by the shepherd where his trum is it goes by the owner's trump because it happened on yantif it didn't happen in arabian so when yandev came in the animal we look at the animal who's your owner today this guy okay so you go with islam if it's the shepherd then it goes by the shepherd but since he gave it over on yontiv it's too late before the brothers divided the inheritance the arusha so they said this klee goes for now until we divide it goes to him you get to use this car you get to use this cli so it goes by wherever his trump is where's the chart so i think this is the chart meaning that if he made an arrow and he could go this way this guy could go this way they could only carry move this within their limits but then he cannot go one one foot this way and it can't go one foot this way because this goat this cle whatever it is is limited to this brother which is up to this point so can only go here and this goat is limited to this brother which is up to here so this goat is stuck in this area it cannot go this brother can say oh but it wasn't divided yet let me take it up to here he can't go past the limit the lowest the lowest of the two correct hashtag a borrower becomes an owner so if i borrow your your your your your bow on arrive i become the owner now and now it's correctly asshail so it goes wherever might no but if i borrowed it from you anonymtive correctly as you came in was over there and a woman who borrows ingredients for a bread hi really correctly now the ingredients are in the bread so you cannot move the bread because there's some salt in the bread that belongs to somebody else and that limits the bread to the trom of that someone else review the poetry reviews water dissolves it evaporates says the gemara mas nissin the liquor dice of wow record [Music] sponsor falls in each other issues please join them.com especially with children i call of and israel they should do well in that show and afghanistan every day if you buy an animal from your friend avapee even though he didn't give an animal only on yantav but the purchase happened before yantif so according to our mishnah it goes what hare kiragle it goes by the purchaser because he purchased it so he could take the animal wherever he could go on on cha yeah but this is the problem if you give over your animal to shepherd alphabetically master loyola biantov even though he gave it over the end of our mission says if you give it over in yanta what's that we don't care about the shepherd we care about the original owner over here it says he goes by the shepherd what's going on here do we care about the shepherd or do we not care about the sugar this all happened on yontif like our mishna in the mission it says we don't we disregard the shepherd because the transaction happened on youtube right if there's only one shepherd so mama the only place you are everybody knows you're going to give it to this shepherd so mila goes by that shepherd but our mishnah has two shepherds so we don't know where it's going so mellow it remains by the owner i don't know how to i'm not going to shepherd my animal you ever saw me take my my cows out no so if i buy a cow obviously i'm going to give it to the babysitter of the neighborhood i'm going to give tim may it goes by but if there's two like in our mishnah we can't differentiate they can ami and i'll prove it to you the tony living says in the mishnah to son or to the shepherd so mela is showing you that there's two people involved there there's two options in mela i don't know where where where it's going and that's why it goes by the owners not by the ship so that says in the mishnah that it goes by the owner not by the shepherd so what's the obvious answer we just said the answer a second ago all right is that that's how we pass it that depends if there's one shepherd it's obvious where this animal is going mma it goes by the shepherd's trump but if there's two individuals that it could go to then it's not obvious anymore and therefore it remains by the owner i apologize in advance but bazel shem will catch up today mata chavez and on sunday we have a short daf have a wonderful day [Music] you