Daf Yomi Beitzah Daf 12 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] sponsorships are over here there's a email from anna schwinger there's no greater joy than being on a night flight to the uk and doing the daf oh today's sponsors yosef mevorah lilu nishmat my grandmother hanabas simcha shalom exorcist today by sydney katz an honorable from ruben schliber rosenberg mark ashkenazi and all of the other mdy team who helped me get a gemara while i was recuperating in lenox hill hospital in new york over rosh hashanah wow i actually spoke to mark i believe he drove eric roshan roshani's drove to the hospital to deliver the gemara i think that's what happened at the end so me uh hannah schwinger says there's no greater joy than being on a night flight to the uk and doing the daf if there is any way to bring some light to the darkness of england it must be spreading inspirational rebellion mdy by living the dark uh raboism in the second picture here so here's henna on a flight learning the daf but better yet look at this picture in the second picture yeah no mask but there's nobody on the flight i literally pinned down my uncle from schwartz remember about vram he was on zoom every day i thought he's gone i thought he's still part of it so he pinned him down so he could show off his mdy sticker you'd never want to be on camera mashiach must be coming if a humble lit [ __ ] like himself is driving around with an mdy sticker on his car here it is his car with the mdy and this rib of rome we were supposed to interview him do a minute i don't know what happened with him okay survivor i'm still around now rabbi sai i got to give you a little bit of background to this email which really touched my heart actually made me cry shtickle and then i decided maybe i shouldn't read these emails anymore i don't have the emotional capacity but it was great so i was in uh los angeles remember i was doing some shoe room over there in los angeles and i walk out of my hotel on the way to ashir and there is a guy by the name of dovie hershberg and he's talking to his friend he says rebelli i just flew i made all these flights a whole nice how he wanted to come to the sheer to the live share so he rearranges flights he listens to everybody rearrange everything i can't believe i'm standing right here in the hotel fine here's the here's an email it was very special to meet you in los angeles and attend the live share i'm reaching out as promised to share my support and service to you and your family if you ever need anything here in los angeles i grew up here in la brea los angeles and i'm sober three and a half years now i try to give back to the jewish sovereign community as much as possible quick side note as you can see from my appearance i'm not the guy who anyone that's that sees me or knows me would bet i was doing the death it's crazy story how i started and found you and even crazier that i'm still keeping up daily i've never learned like this and looked forward to learning i never learned like this and looked forward to learning not because i don't like learning but because it was always been too difficult for me with that said i'd like to sponsor a thousand dollars worth of freaking wires for every message going forward rabbi said there's 43 mercedes i don't know if he knows it so this is pretty good 43 000 over seven years it's a great idea why because he wants other people to benefit from learning gemara and getting a freaking mario usually i would ask the sponsor anonymously but since i'm the last guy people would think is doing the daf you're welcome to use my name so one guy sees me and starts when he looks at me and says if he can i can it'll be worth it unbelievable ps listen to this i'm very much looking forward to making my team on sukkah on sukkos which i'll now have built with a lot more attention to the halachus and you can best believe i'll be buying the ferrari of lula vanessa this year with gratitude dolby hershberg unbelievable i don't know touched me big time he's giving he's lulu is different his estrogen he wants to give back unbelievable all right here's robbie tiffany with his baby everybody see this not the youngest baby we had but here he is by the way talking about guimaras and sponsoring guimaras tomorrow maybe the day after i want to announce a tremendous crementing project that we're doing that has to do with everybody in mdy even current people don't buy your gemaras yet something big happening for the next miserta all right we are holding daf youth base and by the way if you want to be like uh you have to you have to you have to tune in if you want to be like rabbi hershberg go to md sponsor mdy what is it mdyster sponsormdy.com sponsormdy.com if you want to be part of it right before you keep your happy rhymer boy say happy rhine says the mishnah we are holding up with basil by brandon official mission is sponsored by official reformer bas yanta devara base shamai omrim ay maitin loi esakotan velo we're talking about carrying on yantef what is the big problem with carrying the kimura is going to discuss say by shama you cannot take out a child you can't carry a child you can't carry even a lull of mamish a few days away can't carry lulu and not even to save a toyota into the surrounding why what we're allowed to do is that have to do with eating here's the pasta few uh if it has to do with food then you could do melaka otherwise you're over on this sister this is the lab okay now this love is not as strong as on shabbos with skela and everything else but it's nevertheless it's a love who loves only this you could do or not fish which you're not you don't have to bring it's not obligatory to bring on ianto you decide on your own to bring it and it doesn't serve any purpose you can't eat from it because it's oila it's kuli leshem so if you were to bring one you shifted it like why according to this because it's not all that fish and we don't have this concept that we're going to be discussing is this since it's already motor the shaft for yourselves you're a lot of chef kurbonis we don't have the concept who told you this thing that's allah according to bishop in our mission it seems like you don't say mitochondria now yes we're talking about the our mission we're talking about same thing you cannot carry you could carry permitted to carry food even according to vishamai but they don't extend that to other items food you can carry food but that's it you don't say since it's mother to carry food so that's it the whole lister flies away you allowed to carry a baby a lot of carry no they don't say that you can only carry food so my melo you could only shift an animal you're going to eat but a highla that you're not going to you're not going to eat you get malcus i'm here with and therefore adjust the logic continues if you're like a chef because you want to feed your family so you're allowed a chef even if you don't want to feed your family you just want to bring it on the mizbaya masking florabo there's no israel at all to carry who said this isn't the carrying out that's a that's a malachan shabbos not so much the ante the whole idea of a roof is on chavez heitz carrying from don't carry anything on chavez he doesn't mention yantif is immigrant of light so you see maybe that's the maclaikus base hillahold look it says in yermia the issue of caring it was only a sir set on chavez this is other historian this is this one of carrying is not one of them this says before the navi he explains that the whole issue of carrying is only behind the chaves chavezin biante massively lifted oh it's very interesting seems like that the whole isr to move a stone on chavez the the whole wizard of muktsa is only based on the issue of carrying from surroundings since you know this or is but it's all because you know what i carry from that's why they made such a surum but that is no issue to carry from according to what you're telling me so then this shouldn't be a nissa to touch a stone in chavez you should be able to throw stones and cars in chavez no problem so if so if that's the truth if that's the case then why does the mission talk about is save torah you go all the way to the holiest of holy talk about the lowest of the low talk but still going to be silly you allowed to take a stone from here and bring it over there because there's zero issue of carrying and since there's no waster carrying there's no it sort of muktsa because much has to do with carrying according to this challenge and according to my young tif is like chavez just like you know that carrying chavs and i like carrying on them and therefore a stone is awesome to carry and that should be the most likes why talking about babies and lu love and save a tire you see from here that the mahloikius is not whether or not there's a problem with carrying it out but i guess is are you allowed to carry something shallow litoral no need at all so again it's the shiloh of mitochondria a different map looks like we started out this abby remind me next time to just make the before and so i don't confuse the people on youtube the whole thing okay so the other david brought me the water she's a he's a horizon abigail so huh the problem for them not for you yeah yeah you know you wrote email today i did i mentioned plenty plenty and trust me when it goes to new york people run over to him you're having our gear used to be a cop in new york check out what's going on here we have everything here and it was 9 11 9 11 were you at 9 11 avi you carried two people down the building wow unbelievable that's not what he said okay so nobody hears what he's saying so i can just make up all right says the gemara ella may have to lift you up on him aid to bill clinton in the white house unbelievable we have it all we have it all we even have something here this is a very important point over here the gemara says so the mahleika says carrying for no reason no reason so rashi takes it literally you hear this is very important very important loyola tsar says rashi mamma's zero need whatsoever you decide to pick up uh i don't know a chair bring it from here to there for no reason sam you have nervin whatever it is other we shine them are you if you look at this over here six lines from the bottom twice is the all the way in the bottom twice is all in the bottom six lines but sorry sass so thai sticks in it has to be a little bit of a circle a little bit amino acid so there we have our idea since you're you're permitted to carry food because you're allowed to carry food for food food for oil netflix so therefore if you have a little bit of a tire a little bit it's not a major it's not a major reason to the weekday zero tarek almighty avaram and moving stones unbelievable that rashi argues completely rashi says that if it's shalom let's andrews like uh where it almost becomes wide right she says according to now if that's the case so shiloh stamina shiloh could you make ah toro onyantif can you carry a safety tire on the street anyantif so according to tysofis it would seem like it's a problem and we're actually passing like that if it's sorry it's not a tsar you don't have to carry it you have plenty of separate tires in the iron kite dish you don't need this extra fifth sixth segmentary so why are you carrying it it's not at zarya it seems like it's not a certain cloud it would be a problem to do so that's number one and then i saw something stamped that's not to get to the sugar but i thought it was interesting i just want to throw it out there for the island is there a problem to close off a main street in a city a busy street now you're messing up the city nobody everybody has to go around isn't that what do you say so zillowstein said that it's he thought it's a big problem he told him not to they should go through side streets is that but time can actually says like you mandy it's coming at torah you should close off the street what at the kylo oh so at the kyle yeah very good so the kylo when we had a it was literally a three minute dance that that that giant truck came and i felt really bad a woman came religious woman she came over and she started screaming at the truck driver she says turn off the music i think she missed an opportunity she managed she ruined the it was three minutes bit it was the middle of the day it was a 11 30 in the morning turn up it's too loud you're waking up people in the in their houses i think she missed an opportunity okay anyway what we didn't close the street garnish we danced on the sidewalk and then the truck was pulled over and but it was loud you know they have these big okay so they did your shoulder but it wasn't carry it wasn't carrying there was a roof and this whole thing i'm saying could you carry yeah we're talking about chiloli carrying all these are yeah it's beautiful anchovies that's the best way to do it they say that when you should i think some servers said i saw you're supposed to do a consequence right before schwarz that's like the the ultimate so they did it and there's no carrying because there the whole thing yeah no truck no nothing no no torches you save a lot of money the island was there anyways okay [Music] fine [Music] oh no before we go on this one little a little bit of a problem a little bit of a problem because um but it's could you carry or not but what do we do the positive year mia says don't carry on chavez in other words the atlantic ariantha so how can you say that you can't guarantee who argues on that who how can you argue on this puzzle that's rashi's casual so look at rashi for a second beautiful rashi it's like uh six seven lines from the bottom and he says says rashi it's not a steroid to the plastic you're right girmee spoke about chavez but he really meant jantav also the reason why he said shabzi is like the fastest like the faster halawa klaus should listen to shabbos which is hummer you get skill if you're overheaded let them first keep shabbos then we'll talk about yantov later but he wasn't it's not like he said oh it's muted that's how rashi learns this but it's a it's a very important point to point out says holding like again seven lines from the bottom of the gemara and rebecca also agrees to this idea that the mahlik is in the mishnah is that we say the concept of since you're allowed to carry for food you allowed to carry for other stuff that's the macholicus since i'm a type of bird solid sorry sciatic nerve here is the picture that we use throughout hulen from rabbit david safer but there's another picture i want to show you this is from called shown safer and it's a little bit clearer almost here you see the foreleg and here it just goes right here this white you can see it very very clearly this is a sciatic nerve and if you learn how to do it you could here here's a guy's thumb actually he pulled it out a little bit and that's why he's fired him they just take this right out they have a massager how to do it and then they go ahead and they eat it so if you take this obviously is it a right set to eat so there's no heater of oil fish oh i i need to cook today you don't know you don't have to cook because it's awesome for you to eat that so i'm a vascular eat it i ate it a few times you go to basil they don't tell you oh it's it is listen i was i was in a i was in a restaurant my son convinced us to go to some restaurant in the shook so we're eating there and i'm looking at the menu and i'm like wait a minute this is probably what is it called the the no sinta sinta stakes but what is it called the rear the the um no how do you call that part of the animal it's from the behind the hind whatever so i asked the guy that's the waiter is this uh from the high yeah so i said so it's only first fired him yeah so i'm looking around everybody this is all from bar park like rabbi said this is not your haksha exactly you know you're not in baro park you wouldn't be eating this he says so i explained to them you know there's the hind and the this we don't need it all right i already ordered it [Laughter] okay so that's just through the stroke it's okay fine anyway what happens in the show stays in the show there have some moment you know this is over seriously if you're on on hall of fame maybe you should also be making this i don't know hello i know that you eat it i didn't want to say anything we already spoke about it 20 times i know if there's a guy that's a good menacer i don't know it's okay it's still shiloh no no the r the argenizing that he did if a guy if the sparty has a missouri i had to take it out no the side knows how to take it out but let's not get into it we're not getting into it if you're in the sugar you're already ordered and the guy knows how to take it out then it's not wrong no and you're already ordered and you already ordered if you're sitting there right now you're watching yeah fine next yeah don't listen to anything i say when i forget about it next wow yes next [Music] no i'm serious there's a big needle this is ashkenazim from our show that eat it no problem that they say if that guy's a miso it's not that we don't have them sorry nothing we just don't mess with it it's too complicated what lazy ashkenazim are lazy and this that's that's from clearly what's going on here let's get to the to the issue here there's a way that a person is high of five maukas have a vasectomy he takes this giranosha and he cooks it together with milk biantof anontif but he eats it like a hummus it's a little interesting because it's not mamas but he eats it here he's my bachelor there find his way to get five malcols like one of them is to cook it the second one is also because he actually ate the possible call of the leica and the food based on the pays made a fire [Music] says this at least five times it's his uh catch phrase you're saying nourish kite it's that you can say outside not over here not in the beast measures havarro bishol ain't mishna there's no issa anjantiv to cook something that you're not allowed to eat and even if you say that's a mission let's be shy we don't pass it like that so you see before it subscribes to this idea that the whole mach like it says he says that's been shaman that don't believe me basil do believe me since you're allowed to cook this you're allowed to cook that there's no way sir to make a fire forget on asha there's other storm yes of course you're not allowed to eat it but the fire part no you're not high for the fire we just let's just say we turn to you based on base sponsored by every hill group for those who need shiddu before yeshua's please join the hillam.eaton.com and by [ __ ] lazarem from los angeles in honor of my wife with my son the ebay syllabus because you're allowed to make a fire to make steaks so you want to make a fire you're not over if you make a fire to cook up or get an usher also subscribes to this idea the next missionary sponsored by official laura forstner ben khanno by the way these mish nights are available nobody really bit this is official is this exclusive but if somebody wants it's only 100 to sponsor a thousand dollars that's something else because it's a whole month but there's one mission sometimes the mission will last for four weeks now i know that's why i said it yeah official would like other people to join him he can't stop it's an addiction it's an addiction he can't stop he loves giving to tara loves it yeah so the um i was going to say about the marion akash but not now fine it's very hard for you to show yourself i can't i can't control it i'm also addicted to these things we know that it's oscar to take truma and mice we had it just recently you know i take truma and myself on shabbos you have a bunch of fruit and you can't eat it unless you take truma you can't do it on shabazzi on the why because you're misakimana you're fixing something on shabbos however khala which is also a type of a trauma that you give to the queen khala today we just burned it but in those days they would give it to the kite you're allowed to take anchabazi on anyantef why yandevya because you're allowed to make khala yanta we said he has to have his hot fresh bread coming out of the oven melo you're allowed to take khala ayante and the same thing would be with the magnus kuna mares kuhna so we had mamesh over here outside of the basement we brought a sheep when we're learning hulen and the author the author of the uh sikh scholar rabbi david he came and he shattered it right here in front of the stairs ben david ben david that's you david yeah ben david rabbi ben david what's tamara something afraid what's that yeah yeah i know i said hello to him show him dark spacing out yeah so he came here and he did this whole it was beautiful he caught open the animal and he did a half shot then he showed us every how to do the street and and all the parts and he finally got to this royal in the we talk about it so much but i look for the picture i have to find the picture so anyways it was my sheep i bought it so i had the right to give it to whatever i want and i learned to lock it that day that you could you supposed to give it a kind bit you could also give it to somebody who's married takai hanes if his wife is a cayenne you give it to him so my habrus he's uh he's married to kyanis so i gave it to him it's the four leg the cheeks and the keva the intestines you can make kishke out of it put it all in a nice bowl here's mine and i gave it to him it's kahuna that's what you give to a cayenne from every animal you shacht that you can do on yante now the difference is though just one difference that i could think of without giving the kai in the halo you can't eat the dough can't eat halal an animal you'll not eat the animal without giving them out this could you give it later okay but you're allowed to give it on says the mishno um now the lotion in the mission is interesting you know i go and give it to the client texas points out right away it doesn't mean go and give it means just don't give if the kind comes to your house same exact allah you cannot give him khala and the madness is even if it happened today you shifted the animal today forget about that that happened before you own them of course you can't give those why because you should have given it before your aunt anytime you have the ability to do before you want to do beforehand but i wanted to check today i wanted fresh meat no refrigerators in those i needed fresh meat so even though i shuffled it today i cannot give the khala or the matano's today according to bishaman ube they say you're allowed to oberlin it's not a real xerishava it just means like let's make a comparison hello so here if you notice bishama is talking to me and that's for the most part in nigeria we're going to see at one point they still said to be shaming this exact safari but it's a different mandala and the gifts are a gift they give to the choir one of the 24 gifts you give to a coyote and truma this part that when you have fruit you give a cayenne that's awesome you can't give truman so two you can't give khala and the other stuff i'm being silo what's the connection with so that's the argument says it's a very very very simple circuit it should take us only like three minutes to read the all the way down to the bottom and it goes like this the mishnah says i may say it's us to give a matana to cayenne even on yantef even if you shake it okay that's what the mishna says you can read so now we're going to have three shitas and the kumar says which one adds up to the mishnah which one is similar to the mishnah so [ __ ] this one is a harem you're not allowed to give you're not allowed to bring them does that match this very much so it's identical it's just not the same word i want to make it larger just because there's not enough room for words if it was if you're not allowed to give to the kind that mamish fits the red now let's go to the next one according to review though that doesn't fit because the mission says anjantiv so this doesn't green doesn't fit with red and purple doesn't fit at all it's completely out of the ballpark it's ruby i see oyster truma viantev who's talking about truma the mission is talking about matanus khala and zarel khaimkeva we thought we didn't even mention truma just in the hakadoma that truly do on chavez yandere but that's not in the mishnah so purple doesn't match red green doesn't match red it's blue that's only if the mishnah says the red that the mission is talking about anjantiv what if the mission is not talking about yantiff the mission is only talking about aravinda so then this is i'm just telling you the whole so give up here in a second if the mission is talking about erevyntiff and akherim are talking about aravinda so they match and rebuild the says era vyantiv so everything matches it's because you assumed that the mission is talking about yantef so you have a little bit of a problem how do you how does how does the green match up to the red but if the mission is talking about araviantif so it fits in beautifully he says there is and then we just have to stick in that they're talking about every other because they they don't really mention akira doesn't mention that they're talking about arabian so you just say no talking about ariel and everybody matches up beautifully arab arab arab we're talking about arabia only everything matches now let's see it inside i'm telling you it flies it's a lot of words it looks big and fat but it's very very simple the have amino was that we're not talking about araviantev we're talking about the matanus happened today and the and the the street that happened today and also whether they checked it on araviantv and took them atonus according to me still you're allowed to give it to the cayenne even on yantev are you going to be shopping you can't manifest nissan so if so who does our mission to go according to lori it can't fit like anyone only like the blue because the blue says beyond their matches beautiful but they say aravyantiv and he rabbis he talks about truma not [ __ ] at all something else completely now let's see it inside oh my review he says no anything that happened here beyond if there's no majority at all [Music] you have a matano you have halo let's say talk about hollow because rashi points out it says matanis the whole time it's talking about halo also it's just easier to say one word we could wrap our heads around hollow you see the wives doing halal all the time we don't know what matanas are so talk about if you have khala from er vientev your wife made a batch of khala every other she has a piece of hollow er eviantef so that's muther according to everybody's review though if you're going to give it together with matana that happened today on yanta wait a minute bishamai are saying that if you give a matana on yantev so they say you're allowed to give him a ton of doesn't say in the mishna you're not going to give him a tony so this can't be this doesn't work with our mishnah you're allowed to give a matano a piece of color that you have from aravind together with a piece of cow they have on yomtif according to everybody even according to vishamai it doesn't work without mishna [Music] and give it by itself you have a piece of challah that you you will maverish before you and you want to give it to the cayenne and yantef but it's but not something that happened on youtube because something happened in yantev according to shaman you're allowed to give it new that goes against our mishnah so what was their swara so you can't do khali either shane zaka batter muscle terminator muslim no connection between truman khala very different you can't take truman yanta but you could take khala or maybe i see here comes your seam purple necklace that you're allowed to give all the gifts he sticks in the word truman we're talking about truman and therefore this doesn't go like our mission this rivalry does not go like our mission because he's talking about truma and he says there's no mach like this at all armstrong says there is a macloikas when it comes to matanos and this is as far as we still said now you see just i want to point out basil are talking now not be shyama in our mishnah it was beside me doing all the talking um and now he uses the same exact words almost i say the same logic but it's they still talking to me what's the logic one of the gifts not talking about truma we're talking about the gifts when they don't say a word they don't say error of yandere they don't say yantif they say ah the homach like this is could you could you bring it to a cayenne or not when i don't know when when you shifted it so availa that fits in says that will fit right in here we'll just stick in that they're talking about yonder the mission is talking about yandere boom it works and all igumar is going to do is know the mission is talking about argantive and also talking about arabian because don't mention if we're talking about a yante verna ava says rover no you don't have to force the mishnah like the blue like the mishnah could go even according to review though where we actually forget about we're not even going to try to go like your version because he's talking about trump all it says is that there was that there was uh that was matana taken it doesn't say when ullah allah does and it happened on erev so perhaps it goes only like review though because don't talk about arriving so look what's going on here you have your behavior that says aravyantiv you have a chairman that said you have the mission so there's no difference between blue and green what's the difference they're saying the same exact thing oh it's such a great catch that gamer asks it what if you have extra you have you have your w what have what happened there you have matanas that you took on aravyantov so beshami say you can't take those matanos that are vyantiv you're allowed to why because you had plenty of time to to to to be mahalo viantev why why do i yanta you want to bring it to the guy and do it on every one ah but what if you shake this and you shake it on yant of itself also that on yount if you're allowed to bring to the client according to everybody according to what we're saying now so now i just want a schlep a extra bag my stuff that i have my error of yantevin i want to bring that also so according to review the that's okay it's tougher it's just i'm going anyways to the kind of i might as well bring my stuff from er evante and we were like he's not part of the mishnah that's aloha that what that you're allowed to bring truma truma not the mata noise not the zoro kaimukeva and the khala truma you're allowed to bring truma on he had a whole barrel of of of of wine jerome i made there have you have a wonderful day you