Daf Yomi Beitzah Daf 05 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rambo side live english massive today sponsored with jeremy and alison cohen to mark the special occasion of the bat mitzvah of our dear daughter sophia i yelled which falls out tonight air rosh hashanah i should have known from this service on our boys on it tonight so we have over here a picture of yankee berman here we go he was the messiah in the new york tell me i printed it the new york cium now i'm thinking about the miami museum which i know that i was playing around with it did i not push the print button hold on hold on this can't be good we're gonna have to start over the whole share go up oh boy hashem this is the miami museum which somehow got lost in the whole after the seal and preparing the next morning for the new maserta they got lost somewhere but anyway beautiful scene beautiful place here you can see over here there's a little bit of the mdy logo great hebra and you should know that if you are going to miami for sukkas so it says like this they're hosting a spectacular simcas bay is also miami by the way it seems like okay fine michael benjatree contact him so yankee berman at the seam the berman's ellie brought in about 20 people his whole mishpache is doing it literally 20 people from his family friends are doing the sheer and he yankees named after ellie's father so it's a beautiful seal in new york this is from the one and only joe levy now we have uncle joe but this is a different one he's from boca it says like this i was asking wow i can't believe i'm starting to feel me where i left off 12 years ago thank you thank you thank you three times there's no need to say it there's no need to say it's the best of yamashire ever that point has been set in stone by now i did have sukkah and here i am with bait so for a second time enjoying it like delicious aged wine so how are you supposed to study on friday before rosh hashanah with all the running around the work to finish easy tell everyone to go home turn off the phone and irresponsibly leave all the mundane work for after yanta zahari got a kick out of this one see attached here he is kicked everybody out leave everything for after yantev beautiful see he's getting the message the island's getting the message shabbat the best community being right now venezuela joey levy so i received a few of these there's actually somebody put uh one on on on youtube i'm using something once or multiple times cheers that is simple as revolutionary employees can do as they understand so again the question was a woman put her candles on a cheer in the hotel so became the chair became a business of double user came unemployed took the candles off put the cheer now it's mixed in with the other chairs it's dover she's material because the following day you're allowed to sit on it comes the slap otherwise known as the udo and says that it's not devastating ethereum why because today you'll never get back those hours that you can sit on the chair so if you tell a guy you can't sit on and tell him to shove us he lost out all those hours that's not double-shield material so a bunch of people asked this question including libya i was arguing with him in the coyote about this he says but i don't understand if the chairs belong to the caterer or hotel or whatever doesn't the rule ain't all them ice or dove or shane and shallow apply yes it does if you're in a hotel you don't have the right to make a cheer us or that is very true but it doesn't take away from the question because what if you did have permission what if it was in your own home the shiloh is there yes they say that as an answer great but it's a beautiful question nevertheless what if you're in your own sukkah and you lift the candles on a chair and then somebody mixed it around so then the child doesn't does apply guccifer garrosh and duben and all those who wrote in about this and finally i joined this is avi younger i joined your daf yummy group last week and from day one i really enjoy it my name is abby younger from vienna austria 24 years old thank you very much and also a different email from yakov nissen yakov all right here we are daff hey so what did we decide about tomorrow tomorrow we're combining mignonem so we have a million of chakras before shares here's that 750. there's a minion typically at 6 30 and we have a minion after after sheer at eight o'clock so we're going to combine the two miami we're going to do before share 6 30 slikhas until 7 15. about 45 minutes leave us come whenever you fail you come a couple of minutes early life is looking at me the coyote guy's like what 45 minutes she was an hour and 45 okay each to their own and then at eight o'clock chakras when is the shoal davening over there where's many shoes 7 15. if you don't want to learn you want to die instead of learning go next door and do sleekness there live here you can just watch afterwards on youtube or you don't have youtube okay so our boy sai here we are here are the three makhoi kisim the rav argusan and we passing like rav in all three what happens if shabbos is on shabbos usually typically is on chavez and the day afterwards is yantif and egg was laid on shabbos can you use the egg on yante says rav no we said the reason is not because of us the reason is because of hana rav prescribe holds like rabbah rav holds like rabbi about a channel there is a problem of channel preparing from shabbos too young in fact that's how we pass kin that's the only shita out of the four shitas that the rift brings rabba okay so we're passing like ravin that yesterday we also discussed what happens two days of yantev in hutzlaretz and that rav is mako he says you're permitted to eat to eat an egg that was late on the first day of yanta in hutzlarz like the first day of sukkah and then you do a second day of sukkahs because over there we don't say and we do say it's and therefore it's a motor now now we're going to be discussing unbelievable right rosh hashanah we're talking about air rosh hashanah here now i'm completely out of whack naftali what are you sitting over there for i feel like i'm in a mirror or something okay actually no but when we started three years ago you actually sat right over there that was your spot it's okay we're going back to there rosh hashanah is rosh hashanah different than a regular yamcha amazing that we're going to learn this idea because i think there's a lot of confusion people know that it's slightly different how do we know that's slightly different than a regular antenna because in largest role we do two days rosh hashanah why why is this why is rosh hashanah different than sukkas and pesach you know we just roll we do one day circus one day face up but when it comes to rashad and we do two what's up maybe we'll have a little bit of an understanding today after we finish the suggyo okay so three lines from the bottom of dalaran the two days of rosh hashanah i think it's incredible think about it all that's good there's no there's no stamp when we were learning we finished literally three days before pesach we finished we just finished mr sukka a couple weeks before sukkos last year rosh hashanah on the two days of rosh hashanah i believe it was both days we were learning the sugya of rosh hashanah a whole suggestion and this year we've been discussing rosh hashanah day after day and finally now we're talking about the actual yanta version why do we do two days a day before rosh hashanah rosh hashanah ravishme was laid on the first day of sushana asateed on the second day roshana what would be the reason rabbi it's one kedusha it's like one long day in the beginning they would accept the witnesses the entire day all the way tonight what happened a sheer shall you of the weak and if it's rosh hashanah you say special shear of rosh hashanah i don't know what everybody does i know the village obviously has in every yante of his own cheer and i just show a lot of i know that fire they like do the day i don't know how it works exactly how do you do rosh hashanah ashkenaz rama but savart says like if it if roshana falls out on tuesday you say which is very hard to understand okay i don't understand exactly how that works you'll have to explain to me later but you see that saying the the proper shear was so important so important that they changed things around because of this niskalkaluhav they ruined it they said the sheer of a weekday instead of saying the share of rosh hashanah so is they instituted they made a rule that once means the carbon of it shall be in our body once that carbon table shall be our body comes you can no longer make that day rosh hashanah now i just want to point out a few things rashi points out what about the sheer show you in the morning isn't that going to be a kyoku so let's say it's tuesday morning i say this and then three hours later they them come and say oh by the way today is rosh hashanah now obviously because you don't know if the eighteen are gonna come from huff tess at night you have to start keeping yantif you don't know if it's gonna be octave or not so everybody starts keeping yantev you do kiddush the whole thing you don't do any melaka and you wait you wait you wait you wait and then in the morning comes they didn't didn't show up yet the levine are going to say sheer all of a sudden 12 in the afternoon the levine comma the the adam common to say by the way we saw the moon it's rosh hashanah today isn't that a kyoko says rashi it's not a kilco because no matter what they always said in the sheer of a weekday in the morning even if adam came before the shear why because most of the time adam came after this year so that's that was the thing okay so there's no kilcope we're going to say the shear oh that explains this expired no matter what they said this year of weekday yeah i'm not kidding on rosh hashanah i asked about rosh hashanah and i have to explain you this inspired man have to explain the other young town i just explained why it makes a lot of sense now actually more sense than ash guys okay at least for day one day two i don't know how to explain this let me say this has a bomb question which is in fact a rambam texas asks if you bring the carbon tumid then you can no longer bring any other carbon so you know what else you're calcula on the first day of rosh hashanah you didn't know it's roshana you went ahead and you brought a carbon turmeric in the afternoon and all of a sudden they didn't come and say hey it's rosh hashanah so now you can't bring a carbohydrate you can't bring a carbon muscle it says tysons and one of his tyrosine maybe you could bring a carbon muscle maybe it's that assay and bringing carbohydrate will be done of not bringing any carbon after atomic why because it's a carbon of a seabird fine now as a side note the tour asks a question he says why is it that you say pithy mctier is in milkha every day i don't know about us maybe not those but you don't say shouldn't you say every single min because that's when you bring you bring a carbon comment and the carbon tummy goes with that shear and you see how important the shear is if you mess up the shear we're going to do a whole special thing here okay i don't know what the answer is exactly but that saskatchewan bottom line is we're middle of a suggy middle of a line here here's the point that the gomorrah wants to bring very important point if the adam come after i already was macro of the carbon tamid it's already too late i made it i am not accepting testimony anymore about the moon no matter what you can come and tell me that you saw the moon it's not yant of today yonder is tomorrow nevertheless but i still have to accept it by myself and i have to treat it so boys say we have to understand this point it's very very important it's almost counterintuitive if ham say that tonight we are going to treat this as a yanta even though we know for a fact it's not how do i know for a fact it's not yandev because i'm not accepting the testimony testimony is tomorrow whenever haha decided and they said we're not going to accept any testimony after the carbon talmud so hundred percent tomorrow's yontif and not today yet i'm going i'm saying you have to keep yanta for now you have to be mahmeer is that one kedusha or two douches anybody again know for a fact that yantef is right here in the red this is where i'm going to do yantev but just to be mahmoud because they came and said that they saw the moon i want you to also do the blue how do you consider that one could do a show or two kadooshas that's the whole point of the song you have to understand this point it's considered one kedusha because when do i say two kadushas when i'm doing it bisophic i'm in hutzler somewhere i have no idea what happened down in the base of magdesh did they do did they do rosh hashanah over here did they do rosh hashanah over here i'm going to keep both but one day is one thousand percent hall the other day is one hundred percent kaidish that's called one of them is not a real douche so i'm going to treat it two separate yamaha type but when come along you hear this i'm making both yontav why because i feel like it then it's one kadusha they're not saying i'm making two days young because i have a suffolk it's not a suffolk i know exactly where they aid them are i spoke to them and we're going to make you tomorrow but i want you to add this part of the day to make it college because they were here that's one kedusha yeah you hear why it's a little bit difficult to understand it's considered one kedusha not two kedushas and that's basically a sugi here so so what do you see from here that's why rav says let's go back i have an egg that was laid on the first day of rosh hashanah can i eat it on the second day of shout out answers no it was one long kedusha how do i know it's one long even when they know that that we're gonna be makable if so to speak when they make the second day not the first day they still said make the first day keep the first day not miss suffolk because i want you to keep two days and that by the way is going to be the end of the suggyo that we and that's why there's this role we keep two days because we don't have a sufficient nervousness role we keep two days because it's one long day and that's it that's it keep two days and everybody argues on him this takana said keep two days became bottle and since it became bottle so it's not we don't have to do it anymore so now why are we keeping two days for a different reason suffolk whatever it is now it's already two douches it's only one kedu show when it's one taken but once i get rid of the takaras it's not two it's not one by the way you remember where birchmen is how many tommy them eighty tell me them the greatest rejections in new zealand a bird would fly over and would burn the weakest talmud but the weakest talmud you know he makes takanas he does everything he's in the mission of the whole thing from anybody that will get too soon libby lyezzer i'll explain to you later that's it so what happened what changed the whole reason why they made it takana is because not to mess up the shirt show you but it's not weekdays it's really rosh hashanah oh terrible it's gone there's no reason to make it takana what do you see from here that if there's no reason to do a uh a takana it goes away there's no reason to have a minute it goes away so that's a very big issue and one of the big things that maharil regen brings that there was the takana to say nenu between hashkevenu and truman esri because in those days they're diving out in the fields and they're too scared to be in the fields so they said like schweinsteiger it's like a kid searching 18 askaras fine but today we don't dive in in a field we dive in the shoal so the the minute should go bye-bye no the minute stays forever even even if the time is bottle the minute stays and that's what we're discussing here in the sugiya rebecca zakai says rabbit says it's bottle and everybody argues that it's not a bottle so the tour brings this and he says but there's some daily that said not to say nano i want to tell you something that i saw who are these bismanenu there are here in arizona's role we typically don't say uranium why not because the vilnigan came there destroyed with his tummy them and the bellatania and most of the monogamous as well are based on the villain on the ground that's why we do because and all that stuff so tell me that girl didn't do it says ramasha finds him unbelievable he says since they came there's strong they instituted it they started this minute it's a great thing that they started it let them continue with it but he says if somebody from america's role goes to america to huss lauret i keep on saying americans that's where i'm from but england also he should not say you're a nato that's not his minute his minute is not and a ben huts lawrence don't think you get a freebie when you come there to struggle says ramasha feinstein where you come to america's role you must say you're a nato that's your minute however if you're ahazin you have to be very careful that nobody should know in america that you're not saying you're a nano so you must say you're a nano if you're a hazard and he says when you don't say yuri naenu in hutzler it's in england and in south africa you don't say it keep it to yourself pretend you're doing something else i don't know move your lips don't let people know that's what he says but americans i don't know if i'm married if nick's say you remember himself nobody says i'm not saying either you have to sit there and say it i think it's like your emotion feinstein i don't even know it you should not say amen because it's a hapsec right that's what you're saying you're not going to say i'm into it unbelievable it's a pellet that they say it i mean i mean it's a takaras ghazal but it's a big tremendous half-stick between the thing okay the gemara it's a good one i don't know if the these clothes snakes are going to listen but that's i'm just quoting hutzenik ramosja feinstein he went back to the original [Music] what happens so there's only one day and we do two days miss suffolk i don't understand something about he tells rabbi what are you talking about rav and shmuel both say that you're now going to have an egg that was late on the first day to the second day it's one long day you bring me a raya from ravishmule against mulan what are they how are they going to explain says the gemara holland valhallahu they're talking about bavel and we're talking about arizona for this we must see rashi inside rashid the first white line amazing raj the way he explains the soggy it's a beautiful idea this egg is mother to somebody in there to stroll on the second day but us in the saucer listen to this shah shahree we always did two days of rosh hashanah says rashi we're still in the original takana nothing ever changed inherits israel there's takana it went away we broke the takana then it came back but the takana was broken but in the in hutzler is that the kind of never went away lemonade suffolk not because we have a suffolk in irish israel the reason why we do today is we have a suffix so it's two douches but in hudson it's the same takana of hazal that what that the two days of rosh hashanah are one longadusha it's a takana not because they have a suffolk in khutsallar it was never because of a sufficient roshana it was always because of the original today it's because of the suffix or whatever it's based on the first takana helkochaya since the original economy never went away it was always two days and stay two days even when we didn't have the reason it stayed there therefore we are as the original told us to be which is one long day raves of america argues no it's always also my time i'll have a double dominion i really believe the gemara had a sense of humor because when was the last time we ever saw the word dovership dominion yesterday and and before that i don't know a few years so the gemara says developership a minion demonstration yesterday meant that we sell eggs as individual pieces and all of a sudden here the government says doesn't mean that complete a completely different thing it means that they took a vote no shaitan minion all the ham gathered and they took a vote what should the halacha be i'm serious i see it all you see it all the time the gemara sticks in words just to like get you like it has no no is they're playing with words and they want you to think you have to you have to be on your toes it's double ship of minion well it's a bunch of kamikaze like we said yesterday cabbage stock is a double shipping minion that's not what we're talking about here we're not talking about cabbage talks we're talking about the de la dar and they're called double shipping minions they said rabbi there's a big tremendous problem that happened this year the levine messed up on the churchill young and because they messed up on sure yard from now on that's it we cannot accept testimony anymore after the carbon talmud in order to undo that all the dolem whoever they are i don't know how many the daily head door of that next generation have to get into our room and do a count should we be movado that minute not what's the problem there's nobody there's no you're right great idea okay let's be my battle the minute but you can't have rabi flame and zachary stand up all by himself and say oh the dominic's bottle for that you need all the de la haddar to come around in a circle take a count take a vote and go with it with that on three riots he brings in the gemara every time you bring more than one raya we need to know why there's more than one riot first ray is that by her sinai because baruch himself commanded khleistral to separate from their wives three days and then he says so if you were listening to hashem three days meaning on the fourth day you could go back home so then why in the world did hashem say go back to your tents there's no need for it it expires after three days the command is for three days then there's an expiration date so there's no need for hashem to say go back that's right number one voymer that's what the governor brings we're talking about ish and says after so the more is going to explain ahu means that you're not going to the mountain so then why do i need ahu means when i when i coach borg when the shrine is there who when he's when the shrine is there skin is gone you're allowed to go on the mountain so then why do i need a passage to say that after there's a big kill you let it go onto the mountain and finally it's not it's mishna karim so caramel means if you have fruit on the fourth year uh glorious karim neta look at the last words in russian on the omelet the point is if you have fruit you bring it up the fourth year we treat it identical to mice or shiny almost identical so meister cheney on years one two four five as you see over here of the shmita cycle you give 10 to yourself but what if you're a millionaire you have many many fields and your ten percent equals six truckloads how you gonna schlep that up to your slide so you redeem it into money you transfer into money then the douche goes from all the truckloads into the cash and with that cash you go to your slime anybody does not there's no way you have that much cash you can't schlep it up the usual item one suitcase is enough you bring it to your slime you buy whatever you want in terms of food and the rest of the money you leave over there let the the xiaomi's party for the rest of the year if you have pro this for the fourth year you do the same exact thing 10 goes to you your latter redeeming into cash but there's one difference when it comes to carrying your bag if you live within one day's worth of your slime we probably here in the chamesh live one day's worth of to slime even at the time of the gemara you probably could get up there but it's only 20 miles away so we would have to schlep all our fruit no matter how much it is all the way to your slime ten percent of it you can't redeem it into cash big problem to live in amish if you want to do a camera event so everybody shines you have one one day distance to each direction of the airport and the mayor of viarde israel no i'm just vomiting what is the reason behind it now we need to know the reason because if the reason goes away then you don't have to you don't have to be making this the whole reason is the beautiful marketplace in your slime should be full of fruit produce so we force you to bring your produce and now all the marketplaces are going to be full of produce caravaggio loyal river lieser was he never spoke mundane words in his life he was always the first one in basement and always the last one in the basement and many other things that the kumar brings down over there in sukhudaf kayak i don't know if i said it there i do remember saying i don't want to bring the name into base measures but it's kadaif to learn something from kobe bryant if you look up the inspirational videos of kobe you learned a tremendously sorry for you this kite the reason not only was he a super athlete but he put in the most hours of anybody in the nba and it's a sight in life he was always the first one in the gym four o'clock in the morning and we should always be the first one in the best marriage four o'clock in the morning yes it's not that and they say the same thing about jordan shouldn't even mention the name but it's emma's those two put in the most word yes they were naturally gifted but they put in the most work and if anybody wants to be good at anything they have to put in those extra hours the ten thousand hour rule etc cetera fine vitagno cameron realizes now happens to be their beliezer who was the first one to be smashed last one out of basement bridge and i'm saying this on the daft gun has to do with the vehicle and zacchaeus is ready he didn't have time for all this fruit stuff i think he had time but he had fields they used to work in those days they had they had the that produce but he didn't have time to start schlepping to your slime he said it's too much for me i want i want to give it away to that i need him let them deal with it and they they they don't even have to bring it up now we just turned to that phantom and base sponsored by the new italian group for all those in either troops were for us and she do him please join the camp los angeles in honor of my wife who is my nephesh oh which reminds me her shabbos i got this beautiful tray of chocolate and a bottle of wine from yossi klein so i called him up to thank him he says he got the gift i said yeah yeah it's good chocolate no no you got the gift what are you talking about now in their drill go to any of these stores or even if you go to like a vart here in israel what they do is they buy like one knife like this big and they they buy a giant box it's just the empty box and they put the knife on top and they put a big bow and then they bring it and they have all these empty boxes with nothing in it just on the top so it came with boxes it was like a tear with chocolate on top and a wine says okay so we took the boxes and we chucked them out and we took the truck he said no no go back to the garbage and there's stuff in there so we went and this is a beautiful collar tray and it wasn't just boxes with chocolate the chocolate was on top why they did it like that i have no clue it's very deceiving okay yossi klein what happened he lived after the baysamidosh there's already corbin there's no market places in russia the whole reason to bring up the fruit is to beautify the marketplace no marketplaces no marketplaces you don't have to bring up the fruit you can bring up cash carry revised still exist you still have to bring it up to your slime but not not all the fruit within it within a day's worth you know if they bring up who are your friends very interesting it doesn't mean your friend because he wasn't a friend of yours he was actually a talmud as we just discussed it means the people like you the daily like you they already said that it's mother taima but look at what it says look at the second line here what does nimno mean nino everybody gathered the dolem gathered and made a vote took a vote and they decided that it doesn't exist anymore this practice how long they have to bring up actual fruit you can bring cash but you need to make take a vote so here's the third source that you must take a vote like your visa if you can't you can't just be rebelling that guy and say oh this uh the the the whatever it is and this doesn't exist and i'm making a new takana no you need to take a vote now think about just goes into all three reasons my volume why do i need three raised revisive bring one raya the best one let's say from her sinai shem said stay away from your wife three days and that's it why did hashem have to say go back to the tent a statement you cannot do it there's no expiration to it he needs to undo it himself maybe hashem wasn't giving you permission to go back maybe you have to go back well whatever what if a guy says listen i'm here at harassing eye the inspiration is unbelievable i just saw a mata on toyota i'm not going anywhere i'm staying here for another week so gusbox says you must go back to your wife you know i know not that you have a hatter but you have tashma okay if you don't like that chat i have a second shot that we made a big giant kia to tell people they could go up the mountain even though it says in the past that the mountain is only kadaish and it was college for a very long time but it's a classic leaves then you can go up the mountain you don't need a shaufur says it says already when the skin is there why do i need another possum oh that's only there but how do you know well the part to take the fruit up to yerushalayim that's the rabbana the camellia you need to take a vote maybe there was a vote when it came to an egg and they said oh since things changed with with the way the base amigos just run there's no so therefore the two days rosh hashanah are considered two kadushas so if an egg was laid on day one you could use it on day two he knew i but at the end of the day there's no there was no count at all when it came to an egg they only took account the most about the testimony do we take testimony do we take adults after the carbon thomas was shifted or not but there's no discussion about an egg now abaya asks a bomb kasha everything we just learned is predicated on the fact that this egg big word for partner guy is giving me this look i have no idea what it is okay let's go back there yeah where were we whoever spoke about an egg were taught if there was xavier on an egg you can't use the egg and then for that you need another besdon to come around and say you could use eggs nobody spoke about an egg it was just is this there a yantef or not a young it's just a byproduct is that also a big word sorry not really no that's this one you know i know like when if many tells it's a big word it's a big word fine just thought that i was looking for an explanation of a word and i went into the art scroll and i i needed an art school for the art school it's praise and khan i'm a three word like i've never in my life heard the this expression it like throws in like what good is the art scroll if if people that speak english somebody they can't even understand you know like the only only guys that went to college that could read this book okay fine do you know what i'm talking about san cran con i don't know some weird word okay three words that's sarcasm no no but i love the artist it's unbelievable i'm not knocking our successful but sometimes they throw in that they want to be like you know hush of a safer then but you got to talk to the to to the simple pundits guys if they say that there's a problem with the testimony and it becomes too douches then an egg becomes user if they say it's okay then history this issue based it's unbelievable kasha i don't see an answer for this okay so we said before that according to rabbah once rebirth and zakai took off the takana in other words not they weren't accepting adam and then zack says you could accept adam so what happens is it becomes two douches and a egg that is laid on on first day of hashanah is mother on the secondary version says very very soon and there's going to be a takana not to accept adam after it's interesting not an hour days because we have the cell phones but maybe yeah but if the base dimension comes then we have to make sure that we don't accept any edos after the carbon sheltometer bin or bang why because they might mess up the shusho it's unbelievable i mean somebody has to explain to me why is this such a big deal yeah how many times did we run out of show things without saying no this is so important that we're not accepting it we have to do two days yanta because it's just okay yeah yeah and that's why i don't know about pet because i ran out of show many times i've no idea yes now if you say you make a new takana so everybody's going to remember what happened last year and they say look we had eggs that were laid on day one we ate them on day two and today this year also and nobody's gonna remember this thing and i can remember that a real big difference happened last year was two douches and that's why you could eat an egg that was late on one day to the other day but today the ashtab because things went back to the original takana regentakana creates one long kedusha maro in our days we should not accept any testimony after milkha here people are going to forget next year they'll accept the eidos after milkha let's make xero no edos anymore why should we do such a thing here the baseline is going to be rebuilt you don't remember we accepted a this even after hashtag and rashi says a very interesting look at rashi three lines from the battle they call him yeah they'll call him callebaum it's a bad thing says rashi to be something on your minute without knowing what you're doing i have a meaning [Music] i have a meeting that's it no you can't be somebody on a minute all the time it's a problem rob [Music] whoever got this far and this year says already he's already good rav and this is very very very important this line right over here based on this line that's why today rosh hashanah according to most chinese israel is two days there are some in china that say but most were trying to argue with them that restaurant should only be one day really interesting but based on this line that what i mean no matter what we do two days end of the story where is that one it's always in the wrong place here we go talk is like rav in all three of these bain lakula which is the middle one that he says that when there's two days in and uh egg was laid on day one you're permitted to eat it on day two and banana where he says over here in rosh hashanah's asserts won kedusha and over here shops and then afterwards young saucer that love is like rav have a wonderful day [Music] ah [Music] you