Daf Yomi Bechoros Daf 12 by R' Eli Stefansky

Ah, what a beautiful day. Sham is doing with us holding up that rain. It started raining slightly after she yesterday. It was raining slightly in the morning today. What a beautiful. It rained a little bit. But what a beautiful day it is in the suka and so many. Thank you so much to everybody for coming. Breaking news. Breaking news. I'll talk about it later. He's trying to make up for something not nice that he did to me yesterday. I'll I'll tell you later in cheer. But uh he loves donating breakfast. He does many times during the year. So for breakfast it's together withra in this unbelievable yesterday we had a tremendous tremendous of having one of the of America willig and I love this picture because he just it seemed like he was really enjoying the shar I was recently in another country I'm not going to came where I was in a different place and the RV who was a super nice person he came to be the and he sat down right in front of me and I was showing some of these AI videos and the whole was laughing and he's like looking the whole time he had this face this sour face and it hurt me like wow like maybe I shouldn't show the next one so I showed the next one and again just this and over here it was the mish the opposite look he's laughing and enjoying himself more than the other people's mash kaldic. Look at him. Ah m enjoying it was great. It was great. We have a tremendous I don't know I didn't look around but I can imagine if not the oldest one of the oldest of our talid is sitting right to my left. Let me read this email. It's a very very meaningful letter and I'll tell you why. Joining us today is your oldest Talmid 90 years older Solomon. Wow. And I hear like this. I hear that he's 100% with it. He discusses this here afterwards with this. He is the father of Mrs. Kiki Davis from Tiffra. What does this mean? Raoite big circle. When I was 10 years old, I learned in Tiffra there and I was homesick and the food, I'm not even going to call it food. It was something they put out. I discussed it a number of times. And every single day, I would eat at Mrs. Kiki's house. Every single day. Every day. So, it's unbelievable. And and not only that, I can prove it to you. When I went to Tibra a few months ago with Benny, I stopped off in their house, spoke to her husband. I I she wasn't there and I got on the phone with her. So this is not I'm not it's not something that I'm making up right now. It's ems. Every single day I would eat lunch there. I remember what she would give me like a a yogurt a yogurt with the with pasta whatever it was just at least I didn't have to eat in the yeshiva over there and they they're they're American they spoke English it was so and has a whole it's it's a plan but listen to this letters that she's writing. He's born in the US at retirement age. He handed over the business he started to his son and immigrated with his wife to Israel. He joined for the morning sed and in the evening focus and devoted himself to the dafi when his rabbi passed away about three years ago just before he was about to fall into depression at the ripe old age of 95 he discovered rebellious since then he has never missed a d of the rebell some of his grandchildren great grandandchildren have learned from him please invite him to come up get over here and say a few words you want to say a few What do you want to say? Hold on. May maybe I'll I'll give you the mic. Hold on. >> I'd like to say I'm enjoying this here today and I've uh been listening to Shia ever since I was in the United States Army. Seven years. >> Seven years. And I the guess is that everybody in the United States army listen and also in the United States >> right >> everybody United States you like wine to the musicians we have a saxophone here we have a keyboard I don't know what's your in your name. We also have a list. It might take like 10 minutes to get through the list, but these are the kids of the neighborhood and of the shar that help every single day. Aron Gner of course is is leading them over here, but Yeshua is not a kid. He's one of he used to be mad at the coffee station, everything. Yan, I think his name is Gha. That's Dave's kid. Nahi fix. I don't see him. Mushi Aka Cohen. Mayor Cohen. You the mayor Gner. Ellie Sharfman, you the Novak and Aas Lavitzki. You know who else? I think Shiman Kramer helps a lot. Um for sure missing some names, but you should go ahead and call the kids. Who? Who? He's here. Your son whose son I don't know. Ah, Aaron Prize. Okay, very good boy. Do we have any special guests that want to say sham from any exotic places other than Manchester? Oh, we have Yumi for singing from all the way from Australia. That's pretty exotic. Probably took you two days to get her for coming. Who else? What's your name? Where you from? Lakewood. Very exotic. You You're here. What's Where you from? The the brothers. The Goldenberg brothers. Crazy. Uh it's a oneyear daffary of this. What's your name? Are you Klein? Now boys say also take a look this right over here is MDY. Take a look right over here. You have one of our oldest Tid a 99year-old and a 10-year-old sitting right next to him as real cats who's been doing the D with us for a year, right? No. How much? A year. She started when he was How old is he now? He's 10. So 9 years old. So that's pretty young. From the youngest to the oldest, there's only a 90 year difference between them in age. Beautiful. Who else? And we have the the the great the great grandchildren. Grandchildren over here, great grandchildren over there. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. What's it What's your name again? You're like you're like a young spring chicken, you think? Yeah. Yeah. 78 new big deal. What? What's his name? Tell me. Abe crap crap with a G with a K. Crap. Babe, thank you for coming. Where are you guys from? What's your name? How you guys doing? Who else? Who else wants to say hello real quickly? What's your name? From Houston. That's one of the most exotic. That's where are you from? Where? He says London. Okay. Not bad. Not bad. That's the whole Manchester London over there. Where are you from? Houston also. New city. Where's New City? Like New City square. No. What's New City near? We have from Renan over here. All right. Galdic. From where? From where? Manchester. Is that why you guys are not singing back there? What's going on? Come on. A little bit more back there. Who is that? Is that What's his name? No. Um Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Tali Tali Fgang. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Uh to Yasi Klein, listen to this. this I want to wish you a good thank you for your because of what you said that you learned I changed my schedule even though because of my financial situation I got a header to work I decided right now to stop trading stocks until after yont spend time learning I said to myself if yasi client can do it so can an thank you again so can I thank you again Jonathan poster sushi tent Niagara Falls wire casel shiller he's the guy when he made his first scene on me danced with the gamar with such mamish crying with tears for months. He finds AB Friedman of MDY Toronto offering a free roll of sushi to anyone that joins the DAFF Paris at Doodles Farm near Lakewood doing his magic inspiring people to join the DAFF. We'll open up a thing. We have to get him a new sign. We have to get him a new sign. Yo, >> good boy. You see, good in this context works just as well as good morning. My name is Yoni Z, but in this space you probably know me better as the son of the man from the Great Wall of China. My father has had the to learn with MDY and the honor for the last year. I cannot tell you that it brings him every single day. And uh I'm opening myself up here to a real question. So new Yoni, so where are you? Why aren't you learning with MDY? First of all, who says I don't? But Lisa, I should I should start learning with MDY. It's an incredible incredible thing to be a part of and I wish you all to continue going. Also, be sure to ask my father about his connection to Ramir Shapi. He doesn't really he's very humble guy but Lama said it's my great great grandmother's brother. My father's twin's name is Yehuda Mayor. So, the daff runs deep in the family. But let's end with a song. now with music. Listen to this. It's very nice. Listen to this. Boys, I heard Mark told me that Yonyi joined the share officially joined the SH now. So, welcome to the very first day different uh I like when people put together signs and try to push other people to learn 40. We have 42. Now we have 40. Yeah, last week was 38. Now we have 42 satellite locations in Manchester and we have Tom Watch this. Passionate satellite location. But it's not a screen. He's not buying a screen. He's putting it on the wall and walking out. The guy that pushes able to do that. Those are the guys. That's why Jackson is so successful. And one last thing, dear good morning from a few of your Kushner class of 2002 MDY has not only brought us back to daily learning but has also helped reconnect old classmates. There's a picture of us together tonight in the suk in front of our special MDY sukus posterv zealer Jacobs Andrew Weissman and Rafi Cooper Coopermanman. Here's the poster even are doing the daff. That's a real sim. Oh, ZC4 will show this because you're wearing your MDY sack. MDY cap. Somebody hook up Kiki Davis's father with a with a cap. He needs a cap, right? You want a cap? We have to get him a cap somehow. Okay. My boys Nathan Kamyansky LP and Fish and Arsen Rosenberg and Sam Fishell. May they be blessed with many more years filled with health basel on her 37th yard site. to be that Dan had a distinction that he was in the most places different places giving where I gave him in different countries different places I'm not sure if that's still we have to ask him David Salomon dedicated memory of he's a triple corporate sponsor e-copier and our second corporate sponsor dedicated by Dr. Nick Sabo Sheridan dental services and Dr. Nick the family foundation wishing family. Don't tell me we're 24 minutes into this year. Wow. Anonymous for complete says it's when you're having fun. anonymous. So nothing but the daff. All they have to do is chop off the first the first emails and yeah nothing but he doesn't have to do anything. These guys are getting restless over here. getting restless. The Spanish sponsors with gratitude starting a new year with daily sponsors Dan Rubenov memory of my motherino peril. So you're wondering why is he sponsoring here? Was he sponsoring the garra? It's the name is in there loyal and now he's sponsoring the day family prager in honor of godly prager who becomes bar mitzvah today. Maz. Wow. For the year. Follow that for the year. Anonymous for ambassador month. Rachel likes cats in honor of their beautiful children. MDY initiative. Mo Edlas in honor of Montibelski was in my last night. mdy.com today is my name sakes yard site and we're starting the thing is like this I was so excited we got to where we need to be unfortunately Looks like we might not even who knows if we even turn the page today. We will I have a question for this is going to throw everybody for a loop. I want everybody to think about this for a second. If you were here my This kid made my He does these fancy things. He's giving me his money. It's beautiful. Wow. She made 205. Wow. He's a professional maker. This is beautiful. This mom is beautiful. Wow. What do you want me to do with this? Wow. He's 14 and a half years old. Wow. Who's in charge of money here? Benny. Wow. We have a new thing because because of you. Look at look at the screen. It's me giving a shir Salomon. That's that's the name Salon. He inspired. That's why. Oh, and I what? I changed my yamaka the beard. What's going on here? Ah, you sorry. Okay, anytime. Yaldi. All right, so our boys, here's the question. Let's let's start learning a little bit. There's there's the idea of redeeming the firstborn donkey. How do you redeem it? The Torah says with the with the sheep. We learned also you can redeem it with anything of the value of the donkey. question. Instead of a sheep, can you use a goat? No. Nobody wants to answer. No one. We have 200 plus people in this room. Anybody want to answer? You say yes. He says yes. Anybody else? You say probably. Yes. But the T says sheep. You could. No. No. No. I'm not. Okay. Okay. Okay. Let me explain the question. Time out. The value of the donkey with the with the goat. Of course you could. You could give the value of anything. You could you could use wine. You could use anything. The value I'm talking about when it's not the value when it's it's only worth $1 like a sheep. If a sheep is worth $1, you can use like a sheep. Can you also use a goat? He says no. He says yes. Yes. Most of the people say yes. Hello says it's what do you say? Did you hear the answer yesterday? The answer is yes. You could use a goat. Goat and a sheep are equal. What's your name? You look interesting. Where are you from? You. Yeah. Yeah. You. Yeah. You're from here. What's his name? Nice to meet you. Wow. Okay. Dr. Gar is the Mishna. We're holding a Mishna. Brand new Mishna. Listen to this. I'm asking you a question right away, so you have to pay attention. You cannot use a calf to redeem a donkey. And you cannot use a deer. Here's the question for those Aziz and all those other kids. Ari was here last night. Not for you. Why can't you use a a calf? What's so special about a calf that you can't use a calf? Why can't you use a calf? Why can't Oh, eagle. Maybe because of the eagle. Very good. Why can't you use a a deer? So, the answer is Rashi might not say right away, but it's obvious. Of course, you can use a calf. You could use a deer. You can't use it if it doesn't have the value. That's what the Mishna is saying. We're talking about the value. The only thing you can use when it's less value is a sheep. Don't try to get away with another animal. That's what it's only a sheep and only a goat. But not a If you have a calf that's worth $10,000 and your donkeyy's worth a thousand, of course, you can use So, here we go. can't use a sheep and not a and you can't use an animal that was born from a goat and a sheep together or what's a koi or so here this picture right over here to remind father is a is a goat mother is a deer together they have a koi this is like a real one even Look, look how look how big it is. Kind of large. Yeah. So, I have a question for you here. This question is worth 10,000 MDY points. When can you use We just said, "When can you use a cheap?" Very good. Let's see if anybody else knows the answer. You get 10,000 points. When can you use a cheap? 10,000 points. 10,000 points. No bun sashaya kamyansski. Only one paying attention here if it's the value. You could always you can use anything. You could use schnitle. You use green beans as long as it's the value of the of the of the donkey. The whole mission is telling us when it's not the value and you want to give them a dead sheep. That doesn't work. But if the dead sheep is worth more than a donkey gate. If you have five dead sheep in the world, huh? >> Use points. >> Sure, you can use MDY points. It's very good for you go on our website and putting your resume over there. Any girls that want a guy that's paying attention more than 250 people in the same room right over here. And when you get married, the points transfer to you also. So, you get to share in the 10,000 points. Unbelievable says who who are the parents of this a goat and a sheep. So it's automatically a se as we're going to see in the gor a goat is a se a sheep is a se. They're in the family. But when it comes to he says no a has a little bit of a goat in it. So maybe it should be okay. It's a S. No, it's not okay. It's a suffic. We don't know what it is exactly. What if you give the donkey over to a you don't have the the patience to do aar. So you give the donkey to a kayen. You give him straight immediately as going to say you have to actually witness the cayenne taking care of the business of redemption. You can't just let him have it. The coin has to take care of it right away. Redeem it. We're concerned that he might use it. Says who's the going to according to it goes like who's been the famous says and everything is in the inra like you used to he used to ask him questions in in in medical stuff. He found it in the gar told you according to the gar exactly how the brain works how this work different things that maybe you and I don't see. This daff happens to have a tremendous tremendous amount of concepts in chass. It says by pes the word say and it says and we know you cannot bring any of the stuff in the Mishna. You can't bring a calf. You certainly can't bring a dead carbon pes and say oh this is my carbon pes already. You can't bring klayim. All these things are no good by so they're no good by us. We learn if you're going to learn from we know that has to be a male. You can't have a it has to be a year old. What did we learned the other day that you could even give a as as your for it doesn't have to be a male. It could be a female. It doesn't have to be a year old. How do I know it doesn't have to be a year old? It says the Mishna means young and old. How do I know? You don't need all these things, all these conditions when it comes to we saw it the other day. It says there's when it comes to says the word twice to include more stuff. So why are you telling me that you could it comes to tell me that you could use a female and a balasm and a a 5-year-old? Maybe it also comes to include a calf and a and a dead a dead animal also says we have on the one hand is a is a boy comes to include more things. This this set to exclude. So we have to do as rash explains it makes much more sense to include these things and exclude these. So now we have a series of questions interesting questions. We had a a great sugakua. What's a benua when you I never showed the video because I I think it was a little gory but there's real videos we have from vice was in the house right here. He shed a cow and then when they opened up the cow they found a live baby. Holy cow. He said last night he was on fire in the Hebrew sh they wanted to recruit him and I said please please just take him and then he started saying then he started he was winging this idea maybe we'll go to both like no no no fine fine just keep him in the English so that's it he stayed over here he's slowing down though he's much better in Hebrew if you heard him in you don't understand how good he is in Hebrew yeah what was your big line in Hebrew how did you get here you were just there a second ago you crawled under the tables what do you do I didn't see you moving here. Okay, great. So, this Benua is super interesting for the new guys. My uh was telling me all about this and I said I mentioned in cheer that a guy in there from Australia, right? The freezer from Australia. The there's a rabbi in Australia still around. He came up with this idea. You take a ben pakua, you take this newborn that was cut out of its mother's stomach after the mother died. It was properly according to Omar going to you don't have to do on it even though it's alive and walking around you can just start eating from it. Why? because it's part of the mother. the mother on the mother and this it's au. So the idea was that if you take this guy and you take another one and you make a bbemin take one bakua and another bbequa a male and a female and they have offspring then they're also bakqua and for generation generations you make many many beakuas and you never have to sh them and there's never a problem of tra. So if one of them has a hole in the heart or a hole in the lungs it's fine. So you don't even charge them anyway. You just shoot in the head. So you do just, you know, to make believe. But if there's a knife and there's no issues for you, he can have thousands. This is what this guy wanted to come up with. There's really no great reason to stop it. But you know, it it would hurt a lot of people's businesses and the Rabbon felt that, you know, people might get confused, you know, Xer, and they stopped it. But the question is the question is can you take a benua and use it to redeem a donkey? What's the question? I leave the so we had this depends on what month this was born is more complicated. He says he says no no no there's no freebies you have to so then it's a regular regular animal. So where's the question? I leave according to the army and that's how we asking we asking that this baby doesn't need my what's about this whole Australia thing. So for him perfect something else in the who's who's the very very first time ever listening to the sh here in the suka anybody very first time you no not in ever it's your your first time ever where you from Lakewood okay send regards over thereto first time Where? Where is he? Where's ahama? Where are you from? From where? Washington. Washington. And his father was I saw you spoke speak to him outside. >> Meny. You're related to meni. He says he's your cousin. Meni. Is he father of ley? He's ley. You see he's your cousin. He knows. Shalom. So listen to this. What? >> Your nephew. First time here. Shalom. Nephew. Alvin. So says the Garo. Okay, you guys can whatever you want. We have another 18 minutes to do the whole since you don't have to this baby. Maybe since you don't have to. It's literally like meat in your in your set in in in a bag. It's it's it's done. You have meat over here. M what? You can't use it as a You can't use meat. It's meat that's running around. But it's or no is walking around. It's a second that's considered a sheep and ma you could use it and everything is great. Here's a bit of cool M drama. So we have you can use this sheep that's what's your reasoning because you learned from carbon pes that what that you can't use for carbon pes why think about it what would be a good reason you cannot use a benu for carbon pes so rashi says something fascinating places argues he says because how did you get to be pakua you had to tear it out of its stomach Because you saw in the video there's a zipper you had to pull it out. It wasn't born naturally. So any carbon any animal that's not born naturally can't use as a carbon. So he says doesn't make sense. Okay. But if you're going to go and learn from has to be a male has to be without any can only be too by the redemption of should have these three things. Like we said before, no, there's a puzzle that tells us to include these things. You don't need a you don't need a you could have a you could use it. So maybe include also the like we said before. No, it seems like comes to to remove things. And one of the things we're going to take away is the mahuidma nidma. What's a nidma? Here's a nidma. Let me just show you real quickly. Nidma means that the the parents were the same species, but out came something interesting. A muzzle. It's a boy. Yeah. What is it? So nidma nidma means that it's genetically from the same parents. I I I believe that there's many many people in the suka that have children that are nidmas. You look at them like what what happened there? I'm normal. My wife's normal. What's going on over here? No. And and and by me it's the opposite. I look at my kid I'm like what happened? I'm not that normal. Okay. Like my wife finealdic. So you have this animal that's a nidma. It's a weird thing genetically it's great but physically looking it doesn't look like the parents. So according to if the two parents are literally two different species, one is a goat, one is a sheep, it works. So if the two parents are the same just he looks like a goat what's the problem said that you cannot use for redemption but perhaps it's only over there because the two parents are not the same but it's much less the two parents one is a bull one is a a cow the mish is the same genetically the kid is perfect just he looks a little strange so maybe could use it as a redemption there's a corny joke that I I I wasn't I thought maybe I'll say it anyways for the kids in the in the room. There was a mother looks at her father and she says, "You know, I just noticed that uh our kid doesn't look anything like us." He goes, "Yeah, of course. In the hospital, the kid had a dirty diaper and he told me to change it." Uh good. You get it? He kind of liked it. Okay. He was doing it for me. Okay. If a cow gives birth to something that looks like a goat, which is called aidma can't use it. That's because it's a cow. But what? In other words, that it's considered a considered a calf. We said in the mission, you can't use a calf. But what if it's a it's a sheep that gave birth to something that looks like a like a goat? Our case seems like he could redeem it's only because it says a cow. Why does it say a cow? Say if it's a a sheep that gave birth to something looks like a goat. Seems like he could redeem money. Who does it go? It can't be the same thing again. says even not you could you could use certainly so must be that you cannot use but perhaps you could go like that says what you cannot use so you could use so what'sma you should know that you could use but you cannot use a cow that gave birth to something that looks like a that looks like a sheep And that's it looks like a sheep. It looks like a goat. Why? Maybe should go and and say, "How do we determine if this thing is a good red?" You look at the the actual physical animal that we're using. This physical animal looks like a goat. And a goat is great. No. How do you determine? You'd look at the mother. And this is actually a real full-fledged calf. Its mother and father are calf are are are cows and therefore this is a calf. What's considered a real and animals? So you're going to have to scratch your head over here. If a sheep gave birth to something that looks like a goat, why is that? His father is also a sheep. It's perfect. Why is that considered clim? So the rightway asks if the father and mother are both sheep. So how is this baby considered a kilm that's says you're right it's not it's what is similar that said just like clim too something that's not but similar to you can't use if the two parents are sheep and they give birth to something that looks like a goat you cannot use it fine what are you not using over if you can't bring it on from the same puzzle. It says he can't use something that came out of two different species. So also the same puzzle tells us he can't use something that looks like another species. Sorry bull or a sheep comes to exclude oatma it says or goat. So that comes to exclude the nidma says in the same Excuse me. I don't need another now. If it comes to say that you can't use a if if aar is this thing you can't you don't have to redeem. I also have a you don't you don't do you don't do redemption on it. So we're talking about a guy has nine animals and the 10th one looks a little strange. He has 10 sheep. The 10 the he has nine sheep. The 10th one is really a sheep but it looks like a goat. And for that it doesn't work. No, I learned from that. You can't use it. Oh, must be since I went through all the stuff. It must be our I cannot use aidma. So it looks like a goat like it looks like a goat but it really is a sheep as says the micer is coming for the case that we just mentioned. He has nine sheep and he wants to use this funny looking guy as a tenth as a as a minion center. and he looks a little bit like the rest of the sheep. I should learn from that it's no good. So I got to tell you a boy. I kept this under wraps. I made yesterday a semium in my suko. It was an unbelievable event and I only invited 15 to 20 people theim the partners of the Shia people that because of them we are here today in the suka because of them we're able to give a shir that cost $3.5 million and it was a phenomenal finale with the food was out of this world I have to give a tremendous to Benny and we had Barry Weber most of the from beginning to like almost the end and we And the it was just an amazing amazing thing. Uh that's why I was I said upset at the Shiman that he was invited. He's a partner and uh Berm next year we'll get him. But uh it was just Yeah. No, not not talking. No. Bam. There's a few people very very very happy with how it came out. It was like every seat was taken. The It's a because it is a partnership. part is a way to show to our partners to I just wanted to say and here I'll show you a clip just and and just to explain this clip just to explain only one time in my life and basm never again I was a guest of honor at the largest uh institution in Chicago it's called YDT they have a girl school and the boy school my kids went to I had a girl in the the girl school and the the Kamyanskys went there and the and they have a boy school my boys in school and somehow they they got me to be the guest of honor. Whatever. Whoever likes it, great. I'm not trying to under. But the day of when I was being honored, Schweki was in town. I had a dilemma. Do I go to the I'm a guest of honor. I have to go to guest. But he's new. So what does what does any normal person do? I went to the concert. I went I got dressed tie and everything. and my wife and the homish they went to the thing and they were taking pictures and the whole where's Ellie because kids I'm sitting there right by and sitting in the front over there all the seats next to me are empty cuz it's my homisha I'm sitting by myself and people like what are you doing here like don't worry I'll get there I got there I was is everything is ber but that's that's that now that you understand that you have to understand and 9:30 I pushed off the shear by a half hour 9:30 came and I told him, "I'm sorry. I have to give a shir and for me it's very tough cuz I love Schweki. I love him." And he was singing and I was my and at one point he was singing in my ear in my ear. I never had that in my life. I had Schweki over here in this ear and Barry Weber in the other. And they're singing harmonies like Gan and one of my favorite songs because you know I grew up on Rahim. Who the you know 27 years of hearing raim and then it was in my ear. So let me just show you. I want to share this with you for a second. So this is my suka. It was just the food and whoever was at Yosi Klein Chevraus, this guy made me sugar food with fire coming out of the meat and it was unbelievable. >> That's crazy with for again. Yes, sir. Every battle of wine was a $500. That was unbelievable. Thank you. Thank you. You know who you are. The guy from Carmel Wines sent us his best bottle. It was a 2012 I don't even know what it's called. It was Anyways, everything was like wow. So, next year we'll have more partners. We'll have more people coming to the we'll tell you in advance. I left I left the last words for that. But I didn't even tell my best friends. I I don't think I told men. I didn't tell the wasn't for for my friends. It was for partners. It was 15 20 people. Oh, we have an animal who was designated to be a carbon and the carbon befell. So you can't bring it as a carbon anymore. So you redeem it. Now can you use it to redeem your donkey always holds that the donkey you're allowed to use it. So we see that if you're allowed to use it doesn't have it doesn't have anusha. So you could redeem it. The question is so what's the question? So this is very fascinating this question because holding the donkey my you'll never guess the question. We're talking about a interesting case of Israel because the is one is and you want to put the on the is like interesting but since the sheep that you use to redeem the donkey never has from it you can do whatever you want with it. It does. So it doesn't really have all it's doing is removing is that it had ma you could do it. Now I said this in I know everybody heard this. The question is if anybody remembers it and I'm not talking about last night's cheer. So whoever heard last night's cheer please don't answer. Question. There's an issamar a donkey and a bull. When is it that when you use one animal you're over on that is use one animal and it's like using a very good very good when what's your name again? Nano stand up for a second because you have something very interesting on your shoulder. I want to show Here, pick it up. Pick it up so they could see. Don't point it at anybody. I mean, the guy's 99 years old. Listen, don't scare him. Good. Anyway, so Natal, you're you're you'reim. What are you? So, Natal from Miluim answers like this. You know how hard it is to learn to when you're can't I can't I can't describe it, but you could guess. So, he knows the answer. Very good. He's saying that when the animal is halfish, half and you work it in a field, you're of working two animals together. So listen to this. The says it right here. No, we learned in it. So you're putting away why is it so small to you? It says like a deer and like a goat. That's the we view it as a deer and a goat. And that's why if you if you plow a field, you're playing with a goat and a and a and a deer. Uh a ram a ram and a there's a that tells you you cannot use to do you can't use you can't use. We saw that in the in the beginning of our mission on top. Yeah, I said a ram. Not a ram. Uh, whatever. You know what I'm talking about. It's not a deer. It's a heart. Yeah. says once you're saying this says but over here we have a problem of and even holds he can't use for redeeming sponsors anor healthcare bua adar global making answering question is great again boys. I I want you to pay attention for a second. Just pay attention to something very very interesting. You're sitting in a suka learning a daff of garra. There's only two mitzvah in the toyra that I'm aware of that your whole body is immersed in the mitzvah suka and roll. And today we're in No, that's not a mitzvah. I said a mitzvah. It's not a mitzvah to go to the mikvah. It doesn't say it anywhere in the Tory. Okay, it's fine. Your whole body is in the Your whole body is in and we're learning to How could it get any better than that? Think about it. Just take in the moment. You're sitting and learning to So, he's singing. >> Oh, he's doing I thought it's a kid singing. is Oh, hold on a second. I almost messed this up. We got to show this. Hello. Hey. Hey. Anita, shut down. I guess it's what do you call it? It's uh virtual reality in his virtual reality. Maybe he got I don't know. I don't I don't but what's real quickly? So here's the question. Can you use that sheep that was bought with fruit? If it's a meaning you were there when the mother was born. You saw she never had any other children. You know exactly that's a donkey. You know the whole thing. Of course you can't use the fruit says you could eat those fruit. It's you could eat them. Enjoy them for your own benefit. But you cannot use it for business. Did I ever tell you guys the joke about the tuna fish? Yeah. Yeah. Yoni. Let me tell you the story. So a guy once bought Okay, fine. You can't do business with it. What's the business? You're trying to use a donkey with fruit. Doesn't work like that. What if you don't know for sure that says he holds it? So there's no there's no sufficient that says you're not benefit from think about it. Is this considered business? You're not giving anybody anything. You're giving yourself a sheep and then you get to use your own donkey. There's no business. There's no transaction. So maybe that's not considered business. But on the other side, on the flip side, you're benefiting from this sheep because you have a sheep that you bought with money. You're able to use your donkey. Maybe it's considered eating. There's no therefore is considered like business. It says you're allowed to use bought animal. I only want to get to the Mishna. And I have a very nice video I got to show you. So we got to talk about this. this particular sheep that you bought with apples that are if it's a firstborn you don't have to redeem it but you have to give the the different when you have to give to a I'm not going to show you the picture again of me giving it to the whole thing great is a concept since you are going to burn the on The Torah says you can take the apples and eat them. It doesn't say anything about the apples being burnt on the misb. Since you're taking the apples, you're getting a sheep out of it. You're getting a yeah, you bought a sheep and that sheep you want to put on the asar part of it. You can't do that. You can't burn the apples. You're burning apples in the sheep. So comes out anytime you burn something, it's no good. So the is going to ask a question. Why why do you have to give this to the is considered eating is actually if you bought not bought if you have like wheat that grew on and you didn't and you didn't take off the part the micer part that you have to give to the you die let's use the same logic since if somebody touches it a dead person touches it touches you would have to burn the whole dough. So once it's burned, that's considered burning and not eating and it doesn't work. Says different. This is a special it says you should always take no matter in all situations even if it might come to be burnt. Same case. How do you know that if you eat dough that is made from wheat that grew onto and you didn't take oh by it's not a problem even though it's going to be burnt you can still use it over here even though it's going to be burnt you should be able you should use it as aar even though it goes onto misb and is bought from fruit it goes on you could still use it No, when it comes to dough, you you want to eat it once in a while. A dead chariots touches it and you have to burn it. But the 99% of the time you're eating it, but when you have a 99 times or 100% of the time, you have to put some of it on, that's why you can't do it. What if he gives the donkey directly to the Oh, Israel had a donkey that needed to be redeemed. He was lazy. He didn't want to do the whole thing. The says knocks on his door. Give me that donkey. Don't worry, I'll take care of the whole. Don't give it to him. Unless he stands there and redeems it, you have to make sure that he doesn't do any with it. We're concerned that they might use the the donkey without redeeming it. She thought that's exactly what it says. It says you have to stand there and watch him. Meaning I don't trust him. The same we're talking about that is already famous for doing. I got to show you this video. But he's not people are it just happened now somebody took a gar out of here with somebody's name and used it for the it's people I'm not I'm not the number one stolen item in this farm store this is from a guy that owns this farm store is art scroll gamaras people steal gamaris to It makes no sense. But the people come every month and steal gumaras from us. They say, "Oh, probably Ellie wants me to have it. Probably this. We have piles of garas that are for sale." They take without paying. People take food. They take things. Why? What? What are you doing? It's not yours. They're not going to love him. The It's Geneva. But the So, I want to show you this video real quickly. I'm a customer now, so the cart's for my use. If I can eat as much as I want, all the more so I can take. The bus was late. My ice cream melted. So, you need to pay me. >> Come, we'll teach you a few things. Oh my god. Wow. What's up? All right, our voice. Have a wonderful day in auten. Thank you for calling. Merry close of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.