Daf Yomi Bava Metzia Daf 95 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good [Music] morning welcome welcome first of all what is that RAB 4K himself all the way from don't tell me it's not M where is it Pon pona you got it Remy you know how to do it let me show you oh here now a little Zoom let's do a zoom in s zusa s who's the guy next to you right before you who's that guy next to you yeah that's Riv oh nak have a seat I was getting nervous say it's a very very special day today today a Remy Cohen is making a bris and in mdy style let me show you something very interesting a picture Mish taken like two minutes ago here he is in the booth Manning oh it could have been two minutes ago cuz I'm not even sitting there minutes okay okay is it after shak's wearing his shirt you can see his shirt over here so yeah it's today and here is AI in the booth not with his wife with the brand new baby we don't know he's here working and Manning the booth so and just there's a sneak peek to what the booth looks like up there it's a beautiful piece m a lot of equipment a lot of and basically a is the one that did most oh and I see A's father is up there with him the sandic himself so I don't know if you're able to zoom in on yourself is there such a thing let's see is there such a thing you know you can't zoom in on yourself only zoom in on other people all right in of and where's your father he's there somewhere a beautiful so I do want to announce talking about some guys from England Remy and his father on June 24th right no is June June 24th myself and some of the from MD including Noam fix and Ai kamansi and maybe even people like Mark askanazi maybe even the r who knows but I know for sure I have book tickets no has his tickets booked and so does AI kamasi we're going to be in manchest for a now if the is two days shy of the first of all the last day is only a quarter of so if you're one and a quarter a mud behind maybe I'm making a come celebrate the SE with me in Manchester and the following day on the 25th we're gonna have a c in London maybe a kamansi no I'm you'll make the C no I'm GNA make a a day early believe a day early so we're doing a little trip to England starting off last time we started off in London and end up in Manchester now we're doing reverse Manchester then London and with that Rai don't worry about where we're holding because we have very very short D coming up including very short andab say we are holding like 12 lines from the bottom 14 lines from the bottom oh we have to do some sponsors that that is true the of the day Joe Sharp Jo in honor of the MD for enabling our learning and our support of mdy there is such a thing called MD you see that is anonymous for Save and speed return of all the hostages may this be in the Merit of of Baltimore mother who is in critical condition after having her fifth child Bo say have her in mind yob shus shus who's that the one that comes to the Hebrew sh today is the art tonight ah it's really for tonight okay so say it anyway it doesn't hurt to say it twice is also here one comes to the Hebrew one comes to the English Jonathan B Jonathan Berg is sponsoring were holding 14 lights from the bottom let's take a look at the P for a second we know that a is the worst of the worst in terms of payment he has to pay for everything there's only one exception to the rule if it dies as he's working it the car conks out in middle of the Highway by the way I just I'm thinking to myself now loud I I probably told you this once or twice but I borrowed my uncle's car a Chevy it happened to be he got it pretty new and uh he lent it to me and I was on the West Side Highway I believe going back from Manhattan to New York in rush hour traffic and the car ConEd out in middle of the M like the Middle Lane and there's nowhere nothing you can do all you get is curses and and and oh Jew in middle of Rush Hour the car just boom is the feeling of yeah I restarted and then it went all the way home but that one like just the pad the the so anyways if that happens if your car dies while you're working that's one exception to the rule of if we look at the POS it says it broke a leg the cow broke a leg a tire fell off a MCE or completely died theic only discusses two things what's missing if we take a look at for instance what's missing from sh it says the same thing mace that it says by n broken bone says by n doesn't say by n is if it was captured the army of another country comes in and captures doesn't say stolen captured so we're missing something today basically is a DA of of understanding how different things happen why you have different [Music] different I understand the word broken and death not the word the concept it says those two things how do I know the idea that on a very very big O they come in with the tanks with everything they take away your stuff there's no police there's no complaining to the authorities there's nothing you're never going to see that thing again and you had nothing to do you don't have you don't have your own tank you don't have anything to fight it a be why perhaps say oh if those two things if it breaks and it dies also if it's something you could think about it's that you're not thinking about you never thought that another country while while you're borrowing somebody's car they're going to come and say oh what is it called and he just D comes and takes your car a different a different country a different never thought about that interesting sh you borrow somebody's car borrow somebody's car and you have an accident police show up uh Insurance you look in the the glove box no insurance you call the guy up he says I forgot to tell you it lapsed it lapsed Insurance laps now you're you're for everything but you thought that there Insurance a normal person has insurance no what's the you say Au anybody agree with that you'd like to what do you say you agree oh it's illegal insurance so if you stick in a fancy yes word yeah not word okay I don't know about that okay so I I I believe you're right that's what the PO say that it's something to this point it's it didn't occur to you it didn't occur it's it's like why why should I think there's no insurance you let me the car every normal person like he said it's illegal to drive without insurance I took a car that's in right because lend you a car with Adin then it's going to hurt him that's what you think but he did he that's what you think why would he do that he will hurt himself right okay okay so this is good far no no one said very good so again how do we know we're looking for how do you know that if it was captured your you borrowed it so the bottom line is we're going learn it from here it says the same exact thing as but it also adds the third word not to forget you know we could I don't want to go through all the there's so many it starts at and goes all the way through down dollar or so it starts with continues to goes to one after another boom boom boom and that's basically you're learning one from the other pretty soon we're going to say we learn from which is a little bit further away it's too parous away but we're learning one from the other it's not such a big deal to learn one pos it doesn't even say the that we said the other day on Friday we're talking about it how know that this talking it's one so we can learn things from from each other we could do a which is a Little Bit Stronger Just Like have three things and that's the one we're looking for includes being captured is Potter in these things right Potter it's he's only what so how you going to learn three things or the third thing that's poter to telling that he's it's very nice it says in the but it's the opposite you're learning that who is Potter it's not fair we're going to learn from a different not from a but so let's take a look again at the same what should it say it should say I asked the Israelis last night or I shouldn't say Israelis but the Hebrew speaking what would happen in in modern day Hebrew if it said does it mean both that it broke a leg and died or it's one of the other so the Americans say the opposite of the Israelis M American Israelis I go with Israelis personally 14 doesn't count the the you know the when I play ball they always said ah you probably learned how to play in a no I only start when I was 15 16 something felt I never learned that anyway so I have a whole word that's extra because it could have said a v now it happens to be that maybe it's not extra maybe I really need to split the broken bone and the death because maybe it means both V it's both what' you guys say it's either or it's together I don't know they all said okay I don't remember what they said anymore anyway but we have what it could be so it doesn't matter you can pick whatever you say it's going to be someone it's not extra the word is not there to to teach us a captured animal I needed for the basic simple meaning of the P that you don't need both things broken bone and die when is the the P is talking about B together that it broke and it died I need to break it up so says listen that's great according to nobody thinks nobody in this room is going to think that the iser to curse a parent is when you when you curse both parents it says in the together both from the simple of the means you need both you need to curse both how do I know it's one or the other like we know today I wanted to change it and I forgot okay here's the now you can understand it but just by looking at it it says there's a that goes together with the father and at the end of the it says the word is next to the is two words away so you see from here that's why the P repeated itself to teach you that if you curse a father by himself or curse a mother by your you're over you don't need both but without the special Li I would say you need both why because the V is comes the I need the to break it it's not extra if the simple meaning of here this is what Yoshi did I just took it out I took out your Al Yoshi sorryi says it's connected the two anytime you have two things in aost and there's a there you need everything so I need I need broken bone and death and by by CL I need father and mother unless you come with a special word and says which literally means either either or but says no when I have two things in a with a V it doesn't matter it's broken automatically so I don't need a special word to say either so that special word either the word I is completely extra I'm going to learn with that word I to me I just made a Simon in my head and I put it here the AL of is one like to me if I want to remember at least for today don't ask me tomorrow the two things in the are one they're connected okay fine no you can go both ways it can mean either or it can mean together now you look at this over here according to means both of them together it's one anytime you have two things in AAR it automatically becomes one one you have to plow B over there so then why in the world does the say say to show you that you don't without the word y it would mean either or and there would be is to plow with with a with a bull any bull one Buller onear use a use a cow you use a goat to plow I don't know figure it out use the tractor you cannot use one or the other so the the the only reason why it'ser we know that one is M it's only when you put two different types together because the Torah goes out of its way it says the word without the word just because it says it doesn't mean together not like that it's one it's actually two it's one or this the word is extra the had no reason to stick in the word even though there's two words and there's a and usually I say that when there's two words two concepts in one it means you need both the concepts together I would need a and a m in order to be by it's a simple logic what's the difference if an animal dies off completely 100% or an animal dies 50% when the says that an animal that dies 100% the soil is of 100% so us common sense and if an animal dies 50% you should be 50% if an animal loses it leg a leg why I need the T to tell me you for this for this for this if it dies 100% you 100 see it dies 50 you 50 so the fact that the T adds it's completely extra so sh and I are completely extra at least the Le even the is extra the whole is is not not necessary what I learned from the word and that's what I was searching for all the way in the beginning how do I know that a captured Animal by is from the extra word I could learn the idea of broken from death death is very broken certainly part broken so I don't need I don't need the word and from that so the typically I need the word I to break things up not in this case it's Common Sense oh it's Common Sense the word o is extra you're asking why the T does it like that that's what I don't know you want to take out this whole G skip I'm going to think about it for three seconds but that's about it it should say like it says by the word no Oh you mean it says it's you're saying according to this that the word is completely not necessary and to teach us even it's not really to teach us it's just saying that it it's we learn because we learn from the question is you saying that it's through the O we don't need the here okay good just be more direct I hear the once told B he goes over to B says let me ask you something if the Mal came to you and told you that he's going to take your today at 5:30 in the afternoon would you allow would you be allowed to commit suicide at 5:00 you know that he's coming 5:30 half hour early so said of course not he says why not says cuz I'm I'm taking my life I have hour before it was supposed to happen so for that half hour you're you're you're committing suicide it's a so he said oh so if so if you wake up somebody wakes you up at 8:00 for shakas you mosy around in bed until 8:30 so he just killed a half hour of your life you're on that half hour of your life that's what he told him so I said I I was saying as a mush I said um sit in bed and instead of getting up you watch you no no no didn't speak about YouTube speak like okay fine what's the difference if you die completely you die half an hour it's a half hour death it's still still now we're going back to it says in the even if it's broken or dies you have to pay now how do you know that a has to pay for is something that's that's spoken about by so says maybe just do a simple for broken death so certainly or also once it dies it dies you're not going to revive it this is unbelievable you borrow somebody's car and the guy comes at night and steals your car so you tell the guy you tell the owner listen who's stolen go go figure it out yourself go go into the The Villages the nearby Villages see if you can find your car you do it not me you the only reason you don't say that by death cuz there nothing can do but where there's something possible tell the owner go find it so I don't know the simple concept of but here it's this is very very simple simple logic let's just learn from is not as responsible as you you the borrower are responsible for everything you are getting a favor from somebody borrow somebody's car without paying you should be much more on the line and we know is and when it dies you the borrower when it dies you're so certainly you should be when it dies nevertheless but he is responsible for which is somewhat of so certainly somebodys who responsible when it dies which is unbelievable it just died it dropped dead you have to pay for the whole thing so certainly if somebody comes and steals it there's no answer whatsoever the is explain what I thought the answer could be it's the famous story but it's K to say it over I said yesterday and a very big Bish that was in the sh he said he never heard it theer was once approached by one of his b was approach by one of the B who went off the D the guy became a Mas says the RO I have some questions about hash I don't understand C certain things so he said let me stop you right there you are a Bala you went off the D because you'rea so you don't have questions you have answers and there's no answer to an answer ex you have excuses but there's no ter for ter you say ter is an excuse okay huh yeah right he's saying what could be here the famous picture let's say this guy's a and he comes and he says I had a o if he says it was stolen he has to pay if he says it was loss he has to pay he comes up with a trick he says it wasn't stolen a guy held me up at gunpoint that's different than stolen that's a so he swears he makes a and he doesn't have to pay then come and say you're a liar it never happened we live right next to you you never had a hold up you said it was 12:00 I was playing ball outside it never happened whatever they say okay they they're able to prove that he's a liar it's in his house here the animal's in the house he has to pay kful he has to pay double and a a borrower never pays double so what's worse somebody pays double or somebody a can ever pay double why because no matter what he says he always has to pay the principle he says it was stolen you has to pay principal lost principal gunpoint principal it it dropped dead you have to pay everything Le let's say I borrow somebody's car and I take that guy that I borrowed in my car I give him my ride and I get into an accident I have to pay every you have to pay pay pay there's no there's no way out of it so but a sh pays double so isn't that worse than you're trying to tell me is is less responsible than a no is more responsible than he has to pay double nevertheless since this whole thing comes through swore and that's why P says it's stronger the whole comes because of his not because that he's playing the double because rash over doesn't say that Rashi says at the end of the day you have to come on to to a whole case of sh it's very rare it's much it's much more common that a pays the Caren all the time that's worse than paying once in a blue moon when he and then he has toay okay your whole question was what if he was held up at gunpoint he at gunpoint he has to pay double not true if he's held up a gun point he doesn't pay double why because we had in k a guy that uses a gun is he a g of or a golin is he scared of people or not scared of people says he's actually a wimp he's scared of people why he needs a gun the only reason why he's he's holding you up with a gun is because he's scared of you if he has F16 then he then then he's a big shot okay but that's a wh so he's not he's not a gazin he's a ghav and sorry he's not a ghav he's a gaslin and if he's a gaslin guy that comes at night he's a gin he doesn't pay C gin never pays C only got pays G doesn't pay who okay what about it yeah he would be poter we're talking about sh here sh we're talking about talking talking about who claims and according to this doesn't pay no GH pays G pay God doesn't pay so so you're right you're right he's not afraid he's not afraid the other yeah so we just established that a has to pay for how we learn from doesn't say but we learn from how do you know this idea that we were talking about the other day of B again what's B when I borrow something from someone and as I'm borrowing with before I borrow it or through the borrowing the owner of the object is working for me he's working for me he's bringing me a cup of coffee we're going to see Z that says he has to be working with that object itself okay which we don't pass like if he's he's with me I'm poter but how do I know that a a who has would be po if while if while he borrowed it the the the owner of the object was working for him he brought him a cup of coffee and then it was stolen typically why cuz I just learned learn it out from but in this case it would be says but it doesn't say you see what what's going on here here let's see inside here here's the about and it says in that the the of only talks about but it says only in these two things is the of if it broken bone or it dies it doesn't say anything about because that's exactly if you look at the it's beautiful I know that also even though it doesn't say in the how do I I know I could take those two concepts of and bring them down to that you're partner in those two things I learned them from the and is actually poter in those two things by and how do I know that those two things by from it only says you see what's going on over here it only see it says the and it says and Potter from from but the says that's only by but perhaps he would be it almost doesn't make sense I'm learning the whole idea of and yet maybe you should be even though I know that whole idea and the answer to that is very simple I'm learning the concept of from I take the concept I bring it by and then say okay the whole list by is but by yes the concept is written by sh but let's take the list of it doesn't have okay but now I do know as well but it's not is in the that there is a even though it died oh and let's remember this because we're going to use it a little bit later on is it difference something that happened by mistake it it died you didn't kill it it died it broke a bone that's Mish but is not you can't say it's it's May but it's not oh let's learn out hold on let's go let's go we're goingon to learn that if this if it was stolen and the owner was working with him then he's Potter like we see by now the say well time out don't forget how do you even know the concept of I learned the whole idea from now how do I know this how do what's the LI what kind of liit are you learning one from the other the is the simplest one and very easy to break just like I find by there's a concept of so there a concept by the right before he said a second ago that only when there do I have the of you don't have to pay but if it's it's not here I'm going to learn the upper one from the lower one because there's a v in the beginning of the POS of on the bottom so it's a continuation not only the one right before but even this and just like so I learned the upper one from the bottom one I learned the idea of not from a not because oh just like I see so so two I have no no no it's a real Li a real Li you can't break so easy it's a v there's a v here now I can't go that way I just learned from but I'm not going to be able to learn what if it was stolen from a borrower and it was B and the the owner of the the was working gave him a coffee maybe he should be why cuz I can't learn I can't flip the arrow that way I can't learn why because it's very different is when it dies and when it dies I can't learn how but let's go back how do I know that a is even when it's stolen and lost the very very simple look at this so if I'm going to learn from it has to be word for word I can't make sh worse off than where I'm learning it from again top if it was [Music] stolen but if the guy was serving coffee he's poter how do I know I learn it from the top from so if he was giving him coffee he should be I can't be worse than the guy above me from from the place I'm learning means stop it could only be as much as not worse than I could maybe make as as not worse than so it has to be one for one just if anybody wants this as a concept that means when I learn one thing if I learn a from B then it could only be as bad as B not worse than b doesn't care about this whole it could worse not worse it could be worse what do you do the same V here but the only thing that changed here is that I added an arrow I'm going to learn it goes both ways since since is a continuation of the so it's the continuations I'm going to learn one from the other it goes both directions again I'm GNA learn I'm learning the IDE of from from how do I know from and how do I know that if it was lost and stolen from it goes both directions now beautiful SH now if you anybody was to see The Unbelievable first video made like this in MD I'm not showing the whole video I just want to show you this part I was very impressed yph asked me how long did I have to wait for the wind to blow it over I that a guy that edits videos ask me such a question and the answer the answer is on now that uh yeah whatever the answer is that it I there's no wind so I had I pulled it with a string fishing string smack I got him I got him anyway look at how it landed all right so um what is that what I just showed you there is what it's a I'm putting the cup at the edge and then wind came and blew it over what if there was B what if the owner was with me he gave me that coffee as he lent me the cup whatever the thing is he was there at the time do I have the het of Balo even if I was negligent and I put the cup at the by the way I have to give a gra to my son y he's the one that videoed the whole thing and once once I'm mention yo I want to tell you a big thing that he taught me I I was foring him he says ask me anything okay so ask him what's coming with ra he told me right away asked him a few other questions I said I was a little shocked that he cuz he doesn't like to look inside he looks at the screen a lot and this and that so I'm like okay so I asked him I said school also you know the stuff like that he goes no so I said what's he goes cuz you have pictures and diagrams so I get it I said yeah but calling with the rav I didn't have any pictures he said a big he said because you have pictures throughout so even the stuff that you don't have pictures I get I didn't know that that is all right it works he paying attention you never know when the next picture comes so even the things that don't have pictures go in that's what you said what's you with the sponsors let me ask you come here you screaming out sponsors the last half hour what sponsor for what what this is let me let's do this only one person can screen sponsors it's not you okay you also have you screen sponsors yesterday this guy no sponsors okay forget the sponsors okay it's distracting sponsor sponsors you want to cut out sponsor okay that's the only the the owner was there's a no questions during share nothing certainly not scream out sponsors this something rash says there's a concept in called okay here smim what does that mean when I have one par next to another par I can learn here par number two I can learn things to number three like we just discussing the thing is can I learn from par number three all the way to par number one we know goes first then can I learn concept from one to the other can I learn the idea of from all the way to let's say yeah yeah but correct or on the bottom all the way to the top says it doesn't go all the way to the wasn't because it doesn't reach it can only go up one par not two and that concept of negligence was never said by where where is it said it's said by he's negligent how do I know negligence by and it doesn't say but it's it's obvious if the least the one that has the least severity negligence certainly say that there's a concept of but negligence negligence we don't have when it's when when it says the of is all the way by and we learn from only those things that we went backwards top bottom this way that way but the word which was only mentioned not mentioned not not like that but the idea of of of is only mentioned by it's out of the question we we're not we're not learning to it it's too far away from it's to pares away what if you want to look like this there's another thing that did this idea of is all in the bottom you learn from or all the way up we could learn from which is also the idea of you borrowed a cow and you borrowed you asked the owner to work with you at the same exact time the same idea but instead of borrowing the owner you rent him you ask him you give him $10 to work for you to bring you a cup of coffee you borrow the owner you asked him to work for free and then and you rented the animal at the same exact time sorry or you rented him in other words the guy was already working for you died that's a concept that's the idea of it doesn't say anything about so ACC says that this idea doesn't mention what do you mean it doesn't even say everybody agrees is only who gets to scream out sponsor spor okay but only one person please we're not we don't even mention so it does include it just doesn't mention it just like it doesn't mention sponsor thanks for the for the bigger cup Consulting that's a cup not the cups that they saw on the floor before quick and M wife was in G birth what are we trying to see first of all is there b by a renter renter rent a car from you and you gave me a cup of coffee as I'm renting at the same exact second here I rented I rented a car and I asked you here for10 more dollars could you please drive me to this place I borrowed the car and I rented the owner or I rented the car and I borrow the owner all these things it says they're doing he's doing something in a different place this goes according to now it doesn't mention it what's missing here it's what's missing is the maybe it's missing also but it does it does mention why because since it mentions and according to look at this this goes according to and is of the opinion that are one of the same right we had this the other day a few times he had it what is a renter he has so when I talk about renting the owner renting the cow renting the cow I'm talking about as well so it's mentioned [Music] idea of is from you're telling me anything that's in I don't mention so it does mention doesn't mention so would be so we just have to switch over to the right it's not it's that and are one of the same I do have a source that is just like here it says because they're one and the same once I say the same app and if you if you don't like the fact that it goes according to Mayor so I'll just push this button over here and and it it goes okay so it's it's rebut that says like before you said it the whole thing goes like okay I'll keep it like okay so now we have a we have a tremendous actually in and is gonna say it's not true the whole the whole head there of is when the owner is working with that item not that he goes to get you a cup of coffee which is a completely different item if I borrow your car he's in the car with me doing something he's driving me if I borrowed the drill he's drilling for me it has to be that object that he lent you to have the he of B he's behind it leading it but not a cup of coffee and another or stipulation in the right just understand the concept the concept of b as I'm renting as I'm borrowing your car you went and you got me a cup of coffee but it's over after 10 seconds it's over now I have the car for four weeks and during those four weeks I smash it I break it it's stolen it's lost all the bad stuff happened to during the four weeks I'm I have B of for the first second as I get the keys from you as I get the keys as the said it has to be simultaneously or you know what you were working with me you were getting me a cup of coffee and they said as you getting me a cup of coffee said can I have your car yes okay so you're working for me and I got the car but it was over by the time of my major accident you wen't working for me anymore say the only time you poter you can come in no you come in come in doesn't understand the only time he pot he says if you're there from beginning to end if he's there during the accident gets rid of that so you see from here has to be the entire here this whole this a there's a concept of of borrowing and then V borrowing Ma you see the ation there was an accident he says the whole thing from beginning from all the way he has to be there I don't like this says yeah we had all these words so it basically means there's a with him at the time of borrowing here it says he's doing work somewhere else does mean what's he's doing something else he's getting me a cup of coffee so now we're trying to poke a hole in the first the first they said is that it has to be within the same thing you borrow a car in the car don't give me a coffee coffee has nothing to do with the car you have to be driving my car for me but over here it says what does mean doesn't it mean that he's doing a job somewhere else coffee no no no means that same place so why is it called like this picture right over here he's he's not on top of the of the bull he's 10 feet ahead he's preparing the the dirt for the Kish but it's the same it's helping the Kisha he just happens to be a few feet ahead the is going to ask what's the difference few feet bead a few feet behind it's one just say it like that but the sa says that he's on top of the B so that would mean have doesn't it mean that that he's literally in a different place that what you borrowed it the the the the the bull and then you borrow the owner that does not account for why because he started working for you after you borrowed it right it wasn't simultan even if he's sitting on top of the animal in that case so how how could you tell me that means that it's literally there when it says in the sa that he's on top of him obviously anything not on top of him is in a different place completely no no no it means they're both they're both plowing each one has a beautiful even though he's not sitting on top of him he's 5T ahead he's not on top he's ahead still tells us even though he's on top of he's still and we'll just do two more lines if there one the one is talking about a different place one is talking about right here it makes sense but talking about the same plowing what difference is one foot ahead or he's on top it's m much the same thing so obviously when it says means a completely different and that's a on I guess we could stop right over here unfortunately rabai have a wonderful day should