Daf Yomi Bava Metzia Daf 78 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good [Music] morning I see the guest with the tals the part oh he's not a guest he's a k shom i see somebody with the towels going whatever okay ah old yesterday [Music] today we need a dear rabis thank you so much for enhancing my learning with your Shear I had gotten it into my head that perhaps it wasn't giving the gamar enough respect to be doing exercise while studying thanks for the clarification best regards David goric PS a whole Shear Burns about 500 calories you know I'm sure there'll be there'll be people that'll say that it's not bovic to me I I don't see a greater C to T than learning Tyra in every situation besides where it's also to learn you're going to be doing exercise he might as well be learning you're going going to be driving you might as well be learning I'm not saying to watch while you're driving but see thinking learning if you're in the restroom and you can't learn okay that's something else but covered I don't know I didn't askov askov um it would be nice if people started sending in pictures of themselves doing exercise walking in the street learning I actually put it in my Amazon basket I forgot to buy it and I just bought something from Amazon it takes 30 days to get here one of the biggest reasons I think that kly is making from Mar to America is Amazon Prime this Amazon Prime you order and 25 minutes later it shows up your door and you run to the box with the biggest Sim possible like what's in here oh it's that thing I just s it's like you don't know if it's that thing or the thing you ordered two days ago it's like it's unbelievable it's like every time it's a new surprise that's one of the biggest um I think our uh what is it called um no our Nan Nan living in so we don't have it so no seriously I pressed send 30 days from now it's coming 30 days a small item that in America takes less than an hour 30 days anticipation no no no and they don't deliver it the same way and they climb up the stairs and a guy comes out of a car doesn't have an Amazon truck no it's not sick not sick but he says and I think it's going to be 30 days how about 30 days two months I have no idea where I was going with this what what happened so I put in my I I finally found something that I could put my iPhone over here and watch a Shear while I'm walking and you know hands off cuz I was walking like this in the street it wasn't that's also a little strange you know so yeah okay anyway my name what yeah yeah yeah yeah video video video my name is Isaac Weinberger one day I'm doing it my name is Isaac Weinberger I recently joined y it's a wonder share why am I writing to you see well you should know I'm you should just know that I'm 11 years old I'm 11y old kid and I really want to go to the shabbaton in America we're already talking shabbaton here is there any way that I can go to the shabbaton thank you Isaac weberg yeah 100% so there is you tell tati to if you want I can give you his number Bo I thought this was beautiful yesterday we were learning about giving a deposit and uh does is deposit you get your deposit back here's a WhatsApp from perfect this would never happen in America just in here it goes Shalom I want to cancel my my appointment that I have tomorrow so the guy says good afternoon uh you need at least three days to cancel we don't and otherwise we don't give you back to the posit so can I change it to another date sure what date do you want I want it 4 days days from now 12:00 he says okay great Thursday he says great now can I now can I cancel hi rebelli can you believe I'm your talid and you are my R and yet we've never met a generation like never before you have a Rob and a tal he says that never met learned at least 10 I also learned the great the South Africa meny's father but teacher beats your sorry meny with simple Clarity in gamar with diagrams inim my love and learning is drastically improved both in quality and quantity why do I say Quantity because I go over your room on YouTube again and again since I travel out TOA has dropped to almost zero since I travel out B toyra has dropped almost zero talid laser you know and finally I am truly Blown Away by the dedication of all those mdy members who are on a daily basis who are there on a daily basis to make sure things run smoothly even on the hardest days you have spoken many times about dedications of byad as Mar amongst many others who are always different the whether is giving up work hours even family times such as their PES oh I've Remy there's a should I send it to you now I wanted to show this video I it's on YouTube this is crazy I'm doing this now but the cover the year uh can we show this right in the beginning of she I'll tell you when but it's on YouTube I don't know if you can download I'm not very good at downloading from YouTube all right so it says like this and I would have done something from here but also I'm not so good at it whether the she is given in RBS Chicago New York wherever you might it might be but I have to point out another amazing member who never ever takes a single day off and that is Yosef Bak whether the she is given to RBS Chicago New York or wherever it might be whatever time it might be Y is always there to make sure the recording goes out as soon as possible so nobody loses any moments in learning all those who were at the shab witness his amazing dedication first when is during the highlight of the entire weekend the actual SE y stay behind in the she room to edit the video and make sure that it went out on time but today's editing truly blew me away even though that he with his family on what you might consider personal time he's not only editing the videos but even spending extra time to put special touches on it to make it as entertaining and enjoyable as possible especially love the part we were discussing how workers so ysf sent me this email he's aware of it I'm not it's not a dig to ysf um ysf is on vacation Miami and I'm going to show you the picture here he is this is ysf on the plane learning this ysf bumping into nitsan hison at the barbecue place in Miami however we just recently hired a new editor so that ysep could go on vacation because he hasn't taken a vacation in probably four years so he's now coming in arel he's my barber's brother gingi's brother and he's doing a tremendous work so this editing that he's talking about although Yosef does this editing this is the new guy so he was able to fool and I looked up he sent me the um you could see he did a great job when we're talking about David haer's son so he went back to the video of his son and he did like one of these circles around him like he lit him up and you see the kid walking getting coffee coming back he did a whole it was very nice very nice edit when I spoke about uh the uh employees saying that their parents whatever died so he made it dark and music of a sad La get oh here he says over here I especially love the part where you were discussing how workers have many deaths in the family in background changed to black and white with sad music in the background maybe for the next fundrais we can send out a promo video like that and try to Cal people I mean move people to give more to the campaign it's precisely these types of little touches that makes the shear so enjoyable to watch and the reason why it keeps growing our goal is and as yose mentioned to me today the goal is to put out the video even quicker so that they could each one takes a half let's say edits half and then we could get it out there quicker so that America has it early in the morning not like today it comes out a little bit later TI to all the dedicated team members of MD especially it's captain reell and welcome arel B another great addition to the editing team and uh a part why why we went and did the whole charity thing just to make it easier we had people like Gary that were here and didn't take a break for four years and we're able to get other people like a Remy who's up there now to fill in and and give people breaks uh the for the sa and Speedy return of all the hostages Dave you want to come here a second here come I'll show you yeah just come see look the the screen here so you see what I'm talking about here I want to show them straight on I'll read this thing Emily and Andrew fukes come this way this way come this way what are you doing there's no there's no there's no cord here say Dave another guy that does the SH behind the scenes and does all the Hebrew sh without pay without crying but here take take a look at this thing right over here you're allow to go behind me I let you go try to move it I just want to you know what it is okay fine great he fixed it so Emily and Andrew from his family who suffered a heart attack yesterday in should have we're holding we had a story here in our coo a guy gave a lot of money to our coo and I I'll correct myself I said that the COO took 1,800 test on D I made a mistake was, 1500 D I don't want to you know I'm not a person that exaggerates at all can I get my money back please [Laughter] now how much did you donate Robert how much say how much yeah well how much money you want back let's go no yeah so a guy donated to the co a few th000 shek per a that they should take this money and purchase toys for the kids for kanaka take them to the toy store and buy toys that's what he said one guy listen my kids I don't want to spoil them this that I bought myself I don't know what a hat like what do you the guy said you should buy toys what are you doing you're GH back forth is he not is he is it wasn't it wasn't that St but yes or no do we have to be mck but the guy said toys and toys don't don't do something else another very interesting sh a guy a wealthy guy had somebody and gave him $110,000 for son's the guy went took the $110,000 and made a daughter's not a son is that okay maybe I want I don't know it's a bigger Mitzvah whatever it is I gave it for this what are you doing for that so we'll see a little bit we're not passing but it's something to think about we're holding by six lines from the bottom a person owes a 100 to his friend and he went and he paid a z at a time there's hundred Z he paid one Z every day you have that video all right let's show it why not that part is not so this guy is pushing a wheelbarrow full of pennies into the Department of Motor Vehicles to pay a bill bro Nick Stafford took revenge on his local DMV by paying auto sales tax with five wheelbarrows of pennies how much was the total tax $2,987 45 that's great the staff at the DMV office in Lebanon Virginia had to count each penny by hand and there were 298,000 where do you even get all those pennies got the Pennies from the bank they came rolled in the paper rolls so instead of just taking the pennies and rolls to the DMV I paid 11 people 11 people he to come in with hammers and break up the penny rolls then there was the price of the wheelbarrows he needed to carry 1,600 lb of pennies total cost $2,000 this ended up $2,000 on $2,900 it absolutely worth every penny of it worth every penny a down there but I think I proved my point and that that interet itself is [Music] priceless okay so this something similar it's everybody's like dream it's similar you owe you owe you owe this bill and you're paying in pennies you're paying in a dollar a day is that is that okay or not it's not the same it's a different it's it's good enough for the for the T the point is that a penny is a payment and you want to pay in a penny at a time it's a penny at a time what what's the guy's Tina the guy's Tina is when you give me a dollar at a time so I go to the vending machine and I buy a chocolate you give me a a nice amount now I have something to invest with you made me use it you maybe that's not a great says says he can have though it's you paid it back you have a great against I said the reason why I show this video is cuz I got it from three different people so like you have to show this and I actually showed the picture of the guy in one she not the whole video okay there's a person who sold a now could be could be wine and it could be a donkey says to that his father always says how do you know which one it is it depends what kind of kick you get from it wow so did I ruin it huh thanks the Americans okay get it the point over here is that we're talking about a donkey because it's a donkey you can't divide you can't you can't make a sh he doesn't want Aus you can't give him just half of him so if it was one it would be easier to split up so Rashi says it's a d he bought it for hundred and he forgot to pay $1 so that's the that's the that we learned yesterday when the guy is very persistent and he keeps on knocking on your door keeps on calling you up sending you text messages that means he doesn't want the sale to be until you pay 100% but it's only 1% of the of the purchase let's say is that enough $1 like a 100 like if he's persistent persistent about paying back that $1 No [Music] Deal not true when when a person chases somebody for such a small amount of money you don't say it's not a deal there are times when people chase you for a different reason sometimes they chase you CU they don't they want every penny some they chase you because they want to make sure you're not backing out when you sell them a lemon of a property he keeps on coming knocking your door not because he wants the money he wants to make sure you're not going to retract you can see when you when that happens you you need to run so when there's like one one dollar left come on come on give me the dollar no what do you mean give me the dollar I'm I'm giving you I he wants to make sure that the deal is a deal so that you don't give him back that property says she the guy has a small tiny little field a 10 by 10 nobody wants a 10 by 10 field he's going to start slepping your tractor for 10 by 10 field he needs to raise $100 quickly has a wedding to make he needs the money desperately he couldn't find the buyer so he sold his other field that's a 20 20 by 10 that is easier to find a buyer but he doesn't need 200 all he needs is 100 and he's driving the guy crazy where when are you going to pay me the whole thing that's if the guy doesn't give him all the money then you have the of when a guy's persistent there's no sale sometimes you have a field you could sell it just you're a little lazy all you need to do is put in a little more effort it reminded me of oh by the way I have to go back to this picture because there's something important that I noticed yesterday in she um yeah look over here he threw that in to lier from Toronto on your engagement okay okay when I was learning it actually when I was giving the sh yesterday it hit me a guy come came over to me once and he said uh I tried many times to bring people to the shear and I was never successful you think to yourself well did it 1,400 times you can't even do it once so the answer is is out of his way he makes himself M puts up signs himself offers to Lear with people whatever it is follows up with them does it are you or notash says you got butash says over here not going be persist keep on going knocking on the door so this guy you know what it's not worth trying that hard I'll I'll try and if it doesn't go I'll sell my more expensive property and then it's the same story just he was a little lazy in the story then he goes and he keeps on knocking this is one of these questions that doesn't have an answer it's a take you question why is the that he doesn't care about this field why would he sell if you have an apartment that you love this is where you go this is where you go for shabas you can't you never going to get rid of it so you're going to work really hard to sell your cheaper property why are you putting your your your nice apartment on the market cuz you don't care about it that's theot ah you don't care about it so it's like also the reason why you knock on the door is not to make sure that he pays you every penny the reason why you're knocking on the door is to make sure he doesn't run away from you the deal is the deal yes or no I don't know says mishna that if you hire somebody to make a barbecue and he doesn't want to do it for you so you collide him and tell him I'll pay you double if there's a loss you can't find somebody else you can lie you can be M him or if there's a loss what's a loss here we'll show you this just to remind the let's say you have the flax in the water and if it stays a couple more hours it gets ruined he promised he's going to show up and it didn't show up you could hire workers instead of them how much comes out of his pocket says Rashi interesting other arguing him she says if you already started paying the guy then you can take that money that you owe him and give it towards another employee you can't just take if you made up with him $100 you can't just take $100 and and it has to come out of his pocket so to speak but it says in the bright it's 40 or 50 times or 10 times when do you take a lot of money out of the guy when the guy comes to to the job side and brings all his tools that was the that was the norm they would show up drop off the tools and come back the next day and start work and then he decides to leave the job site and he left you all the tools some showed him say that's goofa he was like showing you okay you can take my tools but the point is there's tools oh now I have more more what to play with and I I I hire another guy say listen you want to do this job take you see all these tools is that enough for you yes okay take them answered in recognition of myself and the from MD those who we mentioned today in the morning the new guy ariel the Ys Ai No Gary wherever he is where is that guy still vacation okay every guy that was Ina knows exactly what we're talking about you rent that car and the guy says do not go off-roading don't do uh wheelies not what are they called the circles the donuts and burnouts and the first thing you do you block away you put it into neutral and then you slam the bread get there before you know it no tires no engine smoking he tells you un condition you go on the mountain you don't gole in the valley like you know don't go up to Alps with it if anybody did those what are they called The V I forgot how to say it in English the V tracks the Z tracks the when uh backtrack how's it called when a a road goes like this switch back thank you s switchbacks up the Alps the hardest driving possible you're on the edge of the mountain and you're putting in in gear oh for an American with gear o oops stops mom on the thing okay anyway don't do that you're going to burn out the clutch you know I let you drive on the highway now the highway the other guy says Don't drive on the highway you're going to do 120 I need you to drive slower up mountains whatever each guy in their own thing but he made a deal with you he said I'm renting you this vehicle this donkey this car on condition you only use it over here and not over there and you didn't listen to him even though you went the same amount of miles [Music] kilometers says you went a different amount it doesn't matter it's not the point is you didn't listen to the guy if you rented a donkey now notice I'm pointing this out because this is's question it doesn't say anything about oh it died from overheating it died from EX exhaustion and die from this it doesn't say anything it just says you didn't listen to the guy and it died now we're going to have a new part of the mishna and the mishna starts giving us conditions same thing as the rer right you rented a donkey to go up the mountain you put it in the valley it happens to be that the guy said you can go up the mountain and up the mountain there's a great chance that it will fall yeah the paths are narrow and he said you could take it up the mountain and you went in the valley wider if it slipped now in the valley it it could slip a lot easier on a mountain yeah I'll show you I I can prove it here oh this all you need to see should we show you again was gmak the gmak part is that he gets up as if nothing happened if that was a human being that'll be like a middle Shiva at this point it's crazy guy gets up keeps on walking okay that's on a that's on a mountain so the guy said you can take it up a mountain and I I I I'll take that risk that'll fall down the mountain and you took it to the big you took to the valley and did that in the valley to find s part of the charity C that's right we need more people it h it happens to be it happens to be no just we were talking about this yesterday happens to be this video serious and if the donkey overheated the engine overheated here we got to pick Yoshi made a picture approve by AI okay so the the engine overheated in other words it overheated why because it's in a valley there's no air so it over here because he told you don't bring it over there I know the engine of this donkey I know it's going to die what's the name of that uh Donnie you know the guy's name the guy lives in inti he does mortgages I forgot his name uh American no seagull seagull Adam seagull Adam seagull told me they had a German Shepherd that was running around like a MOG outside so he brought him in and he said the animals don't know how to regulate their body temperature so if they overheat so dog comes in looks at him died on the spot ask him he told me this might is a German trap ran around too much in the heat it didn't know how to regulate its temperature died so this ISS this issues he knows his donkey could overheat doesn't it overworks it dies he told you he warned you don't bring him there so you see what the mission is doing here now the mission is talking about did he allow you to go on the mountain didn't allow you how did he die did he slip did he overheat in the ra doesn't talk about this at all it just say straight out he told you not to go to the mountain you went to the mountain you're finished you have to pay over here makes if he went to the the the valley and he slipped in the valley it's okay cuz he was going to slip in the mountain anyway and if he overheated in the valley it's not okay because that's where it's hot the mission is the question is why they made a deal you're only going to take this animal in the valley on the mountain I don't allow you he's not good he he'll miss step he'll fall down so if he didn't listen to him and that's his concern happened his concern didn't happen and he died from a different thing po if because he had to work hard to get up to the mountain he rented a donkey and the donkey became atile blind not 100% blind but like a little bit so that and Rashi says later on AAR that becomes blind here's a little bit of a blind guy that becomes blind could still carry stuff you could it's not great to drive on mountains CU it could fall off but it could do workio this is an agario nario is basically what happened uh on October 8th the Israeli Army came in and started taking people's trucks away so we need this truck we need this ambulance they went to to hatala they took their ambulances it's called in Israel that's what the the that's what the king would do he liked your donkey his guys needed his his soldiers had to go from point A to point B they take your donkey halfway through the donkey is not working well ran out of gas get off the donkey leave it there and keep on going with another donkey rash says that on B we'll see now if these things happen while you're [Music] renting so then he says the owner says to the renter that's your masle what happened why why did why it blind why did the the government come you have you're not you're not very lucky so stick to it that's your donkey but if something happens to it it died or it broke then the renter has to replace it so that's today what's going on with the the the is going to say even that it might be two different M what why is it that in the r if you don't listen to the renter no questions asked I don't care how it died it just died whether it's because it slipped or overheated we don't care and all of a sudden the we started making distinctions well if it slipped you poter over or it depends if it's in the the owner of the donkey says the ear wasn't good you went up on the Alps very very thin ear you died I don't care slip not slip it die from lack of oxygen sometimes because there's no Crosswinds in the valley so also very poor ear and that's why he died so we don't ask any questions that's what he's tining exhausted so that's why the renter has to pay for everything he was negligent there was either was a place with different snakes or we could say it's more like this thing over here I told you not to go over here so you are you were negligent and then it happens to be a snake came and bit him and killed him so okay no you could say it's just two different cases and the sa it wasn't bit by a snake the Ra was bit by a snake oh you're saying why why you say you're saying if the rati I told you have to go there because I know it's going to die and it died from something else so the saer noer no but he's asking but he's asking if he if if in a place that shouldn't be your Potter why what do you say I hear it's such a simple casha that it's going to be like the other one no no that one according to these he's asking according to that say there's a lot of snakes there then you don't have a according to that say there's no there are no snakes just happens to be he got killed by a [Music] snake this is this goes according toor thator says nro this is very important to when a person says you can rent my car but only you could use it yeah what it happened to me show happened to me we're not going to talk about exactly who we're when he's probably not listening this year I hope I let my car to somebody and it came back binged up so he says I didn't do it but it turns out he admitted to somebody else that he let somebody else drive my car so it's probably that guy Nick you're golin that should be a GU you could drive my car I didn't say you could let somebody else but okay over here by not following instructions the guy says do not take it on the mountain and You Take It on the Mountain you automatically become a golin and the Gin is on all even if you were negligent by by the fact that you didn't listen now what the is going to do here is the is going to bring three rib mayors of course it's not the first one it's not the second one the last one which remor says that if you don't listen you're GH of he says three similar things in we all know about the just because you probably don't remember this one I'm not going to show the whole thing the Frack thing right I I tell you to do one thing you do you do something else this is the that says the guy's aov he didn't listen he took my Frack he made it red GH of so pay for the material I gave you white wool whatever it is white wool and I told you dye my white wool to make it a black Frack you made it a red Frack give me my white wool back GH of real quickly I said the story before but we have a little bit of a to the story REM these rebi but this yeah I'll show you that you're wrong I'll prove to you I have a picture okay okay he says and I say let's see who's right told today is the I'm giving the she in my Olive colored Frack so the whole yiva came to see what's going on after she says rebi you said olive color and you're wearing black Frack he said what you never saw black olive before that's the story and says it's not true and I'll show you that it's true here we go giving a [Laughter] [Music] [Laughter] FR okay fine right probably you say it's okay what about the one that he that they did they're not looking for General n you guys know that one okay fine next says okay this is not important to our we say quickly re says that if he made it he improved the Frack more than what it cost him to improve let's say the Mater the the dye and the wood for the fire and all that stuff cost $10 but now the Frack is worth 25 all you need to do is pay him for the material for the $10 anyways the the the dire guy he gets the less of the two if the expenses are more than what it's worth so you give whatever it's worth why because according to is not a GH according to it's a GH so perhaps this is the remain that says when you change something you become a GH say when I take somebody's frack and I change it from black to Red from white to Red whatever I do I did a to change but over here in the donkey I didn't change anything I took him up a mountain nothing changed in the correct turning the D sponsored by Eric Adelman of bigger cup Consulting and by and Paul for bring into our lives mayor newed mayor collecting money for PM so I don't know if you ever wondered this in America is one day and P is two days is two days is different there's two days pum and there's only one day y so why CU went around asking the Americans he says how many days do you want y they said what do you do on y they said you eat a lot oh eat BOS we want two days what do you do on Pur give one day one day they came to the yies what do you what do you do on y you eat a lot you have to buy meat oh no no it's expensive do okay I can hear we'll take two though you collect money for is that your original it's that bad good EXC oh what original how you doing where you from London you to say silver so Yi soble I have a friend you'll see em that name years years I haven't seen him but okay he lives in somewhere huh maybe he's my friend no he grew up so when you collect money it's for and we take the money different but we're not so exact okay they they buy a little bit more a little bit what's this money for the money is for sud take the the C you take the the meat whatever is left over goes to and this is what we want right here huh yeah general and this is actually and that's why we want this I give you money for the to buy meat do not buyel it's a have to make a special tonight this is the that says you're not all to change I tell you to do X don't do y I tell you to buy meat you're not all to buy shoelaces I tell you don't go up the mountain don't go up the mountain and if not you're G of the way I understand it it's not 100% like that I don't think anybody says exactly like this but maybe a little bit to understand the when I give you money and I say buy meat with it and you buy something else with it so I never gave you the money you never had it's my money I told you you could do this with my money and if you don't do this with my money so it was never Yours by Donkey perhaps maybe this is thear I gave you the donkey it's yours you're ready you're ready on the road for two days now in Middle you did something you weren't supposed to do but doesn't retroactively take away the fact that it was your donke the whole time something like that to that point says don't tell don't tell I said that he probably not going be Mas okay this is the final one I give her money to buy a jacket don't buy a hat don't change around I told you to buy X buy X don't buy a different thing don't buy shoes instead of pants what's the reason because you're not listening to the so over here also the reason why you're on the donkey because he did not listen to the renter he told you don't bring it on the mountain you brought it in the mountain they're going to people are going to they heard you said and show in front of everybody I'm buying a new suit for and not a single guy walks into the show with a new suit this guy's wearing new shoes this guy but so you're a liar you told everybody buying suits so people going to say he's a liar he said in front of everybody's going to buy this guy a new suit and look at him look at he still has the same tears the same everythingi bought the other thing you didn't buy this if that's the so then you should say the reason why you shouldn't change from a hat to a jacket from a jacket to hat or from a to Talus is because people the rich guy that's not what it says it says because the rich guy told you X and you did y you didn't listen to the not because people going to think the is a liar it's because you Chang it and from here you see this idea that if a person tells you I'm giving you money on condition that you make a for your son and you make it for your daughter you're you're a gaslin so people say no so you could beik and this so ask your local Rabbi one interesting SP I saw with the Son and the daughter that when a person gives money to marry off the son he's really being the money to the son I'm paying for your through the father you're like the for the son so the father doesn't have the right to divert to a daughter you as somebody who married of a kid you don't believe that okay I hear it's really me comes out of my pocket got it explain like this picture it became blind blind dish it could still see a little bit it could still do work says rash AOS did have okay my says you say I says okay it means worms in its feet how so now that we mentioned this word of of Z so the guy said is Mo something like this could be worms moths same thing he had a dream that the king's stuff is is getting uh you know eaten up by the moths so they try to test him is the guy lying what was it eating is it eating the the Silvery the the ones that are made out of fla like like uh red red wool like he said it was the flax you're talking to the king off with your head you don't deserve to live he said the right thing and they let him live they impounded the car they'll come back they'll give it back to [Music] you when it comes back okay sole bad luck but when it doesn't come back then the renter has to give him another donkey so like I explained before the rash goes out of his way to explain that they could take your donkey and take it for 25 miles when it gets tired they just drop it grab somebody else they see a better donkey a stronger one they grab that one now you follow them what you're supposed to do is just follow it's the king's guys you don't have a choice you follow and you take your donkey back so if it's in the same direction you were going that it's your it was your masle that's your problem it's in the opposite direction then he can't he can't use this idea of and he has to give him another donkey the donkey became or became blind so the renter says here that I'm not I'm not providing you anything else it's your that went crazy but if it died or the king took it we just said that it doesn't have over here it says if the king takes it you have to give another one so made a distinction between a donkey that's going to come back or donkey that's lost forever so I could that's how I that's I'm going to TI up the steer over here the one that I have to give another donkey because it's never coming back the one I don't have to give another donkey because it's going to it's just impounded for a few days he'll come back soon that didn't make this distinction how is he going to explain the contradiction also made a distinction don't don't forget made a distinction whether it's going in the same direction that he was going or in the opposite direction so if it's going the opposite direction he has to provide him another D going in the same direction he doesn't it's your but it can't be why yeah we have that says oh if it was going the same way it's only that makes the distinction of back forth with Direction but so what's the obvious answer he yeah I make the distinction he makes the dis wow I said the same exact thing as great [Music] the the everything from beginning to end is there a few words missing then you understand it's all if you rented a donkey and got blind or became and it could still take the packages the owner says that's the donkey you're stuck with it but if it died or the king took it then you have to give him a new one wait a minute that's so P you don't have to give him a new one if the king takes it but it makes it makes a difference when you were going north and the King was going south the king's guys are going south they're going the opposite direction then I have to give you another donkey if you're going there anyway why because it's your if it's in the same direction then the renter doesn't have to provide a new one not he has to give him another one rabai have a wonderful day