Daf Yomi Bava Metzia Daf 44 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning because Live's not here we're gonna leave the S you you want to take it y why um welcome to all the guests what's your name felin yeah oh is here TC wow what's your first name y from TC wow it's not easy she to get into probably the hardest one no this is a picture of Rabbi leader and Rabbi Glock I think let's let's read the email is on a on a flight you see this on a plane here we go thank you for coming to the US I know it's a big for you and your family should know that your presence a big even though you're here to fundraise LOL I came out to the live sham Bor this past Thursday and I have a few observations observations to share should I say to Shear everyone was comfortable with one another everyone was greeting one another as if this cousin the only difference was that no one was wondering if we were later from this side of that side the question was asked so when did you start learning the da with rebelli this might be the wrong email but okay I'm saying it I don't know if it has to do with that picture your stars clearly managing the crowd is not easy handled well I was watching everyone's was greeted this sh was really really does change lives whoever says otherwise is fooling themselves let's talk about the last point there are a few ways that the the she has changed my life my colleague and I have been working together for nearly 10 years since we both started learning with this most of our inperson conversations now include a reference Tod y everywhere I go I meet people are part of DD y families recently a few weeks ago traveling Oh it is the same one he came over to ask if we could dive on the plane within 30 seconds a Jewish geography came out that he's mdy regular at the Hub my friend was waving me over to meet the guy also learns with mdy kid sir we bonded over how it change our lives in different ways see the attached photo he said I'm the guy on the right side of the table at the live share and filling every morning come out every morning where did you sit right over here every leader what a pledge to meet leader when we finished bakama I saved the seal and made it at my Pur sud with my family and friends galdi it was an amazing it was amazing especially after all the glasses of wine that preceded it and impactful my wife and children I called my reab in Via video and he sh to last story I was leaving the live stream in bar Park last week I went down to get my coat and there's another year there doing the same I asked him when did you start learning the D of the rebell he said about a year ago I Contin when did you start learning that he said 42 years ago first my wife got me the taste from Ellie pron Ellie title B then she got me this thing called an iPad and I was ker here's a he's been learning the die 42 years he's still finding SE inir his name is Mayor wickler doctor I believe what an inspireing you anyway I've gone past my timer thank you for staying with me for me it's day 232 stay with you as well here's the 42 more years and then some Edison New Jersey here's the picture again leader and R Glock I think on the left and the guy in the middle I'm not sure RI y see in the crew good luck your fundraising campaign here in the US we couldn't get to the shear last Thursday and my son zachi is a fanatical about not missing a d a day of da it's not about the D it's about the Y he's a future in-law he has a future in-law as he has become a master negotiat for more minutes of screen time to catch up ah he has a future in law he has a future in law cuz he's a massive negotiator wow I almost got myself in trouble there cuz he looks pretty young over there imagine a surprise when I when on the way home from soccer practice as they tried to get to 6:45 Min my wife spotted a group of men crossing the street she said I have a feeling it's an important Rabbi as she passed wave to you she encouraged my really shy son zachi Davis to take a picture of you someone who also inspires him to do the D thank you for interrupting your important call my wife said it must have been your wife right and taking a great picture I sincerely sincerely with a karata to Carlos vard and Zaki Davis and a few of the recent owners from today thank you for bringing the da to life every day and making it addictive Joel Merin $500 from Baltimore this morning is 7 hours ago I guess it says like this this person donated come out $4,000 12,000 plus 2,000 first he put his name on 2,000 then he did Anonymous on the 12,000 shekel I don't know if that was on purpose we'll pretend it wasn't praised thousand saying in other words what he's try to say here is that you can learn even from the worst person in the world even from Hit therefore what do we have to learn from Hitler if one can destroy 6 million lives one can save six million lives every day emails flow in saying and do I Chang my life and do I save my life and I certainly change my life for the better may this campaign bring thousands of say do I change my life and thank you bur I don't know where you are exactly maybe I do oh where that's you so you Anonymous for the 12,000 shek did you do that on purpose not anymore there's no Anonymous in mdy I said that he knows that wow it's a beautiful donation borrow Burger could you come over here are you able to come get over wow I have to learn this day I know I know say in person I hope not to forget your name you drive at least 20 minutes from no alone little more yeah beautiful $4,000 donation beautiful on the last day the week was more even bigger the what the week what week last week last week oh wow really the the wheat oh the wheat the wheat that he gave me that was a bigger donation than this why because you got it from your kids it me more it's a shame I threw it out in the garbage I put it away in the kitchen it's nice and safe thank you the weat I thought you said the weat okay I got it now thank you very [Music] much B Burger Bar how do you remember that name BB just called BB sh that that area I don't view that much so what's your name you you're not a you're not new I saw you that also from alone wow you should come every dayski $100 dedicated to rebell dedicated to rebelli who unites at least those with ADHD through in honor of reell and the he has in our family extended family those two people actually where is he that's you you donated $100 you took it out of your mother's well beautiful oh that's your dad right behind it's that whole area look at them okay we have a brand new per to begin so we got to get going here the is sponsored by Anonymous for the safe and Speedy return of all the hostages before Ros business and in all my Endeavors the last day say we all love this person not going to say what it is exactly aring for the month for the art Anonymous of the easy child birth his daughter and a healthy baby we're holding all the way on the top huh nobody's waving because Li is already Mis they're waving okay how many people are on Zoom these days 50 very nice I want to tell the like this every year for the past 25 years besides Corona I've been in my sh's hotel in Chicago so that means ever since I moved to we fly to America for PES that was one of the deals I made with my wife to move to that I would go to Chicago for PES and Chicago for the summer that being said PES in itself is a very difficult time to do the D especially PES there's a lot of excuses a lot of family time and trips so I want to forar the it's not going to be easy but that's what the D is about and if you fall behind happens to some people don't fall off the bandwagon if you get annoyed at the fact that I'm giving sh from hotel room that's how it is sometimes it's not always from the B some a little harder sometimes it's in a Bas in Chicago sometimes it's in a hotel room or hotel conference room they're not easy she room for me because there's no audience and I'm talking to a camera and it's a darker lit room but we keep on going for some reason I come back to this stroll and there's like three four people missing for good we lose like they just fall off completely so I'm warning don't be one of those people and if you fall a little bit and get annoyed a little bit and you find the better Shear just come back afterwards there's a lot of people that just fall and the so is you pick up and just continue we're going to be starting the very famous the middle of p p it's going to be fun it's going to be um it's more of a business peric and it's not that not that difficult they say I don't remember it they say it's not that I don't remember it being that hard it has like a name oh it's tyal so don't fall let's do this top and we know that if I have a question for Shen if you have a lot of fruit that you're supposed to bring up 10% of your fruit you bring up to your slime to eat but you don't want to bring up so much fruit so you trade it in for silver coins don't worry it will be coming trust me and I'll tell you why later we have to show it every time even though Jonathan's fans gives me a hard time we show it every time because are people believe it or not in this room that still don't know what it is how do I know because when I tested the just two weeks ago people that were in the shear for for years forgot what Trum Meer is they forgot different things we show it over and over it doesn't matter with all but you're bringing you switch the fruit into silver coins my question to you is could you take those silver coins and all of a sudden you realize you have a pale of silver coins and now you want to trade it in take the silver and transfer the gusa from the silver into gold instead of bringing 500 pound of silver you'll bring one pound of gold huh it is why way you're wrong but thank you for trying you weren't listening well ah you weren't here last night he was obviously it's not the same kind of Mag I didn't give sh yesterday in Hebrew so says the gamar we said in we said right it wasn't the chart the mishna says that according to B you in your mind as long as you think and Rashi says it means you say it there are those who explain you don't really need to say it R means you could think it but it's better if you say it like we understand what you meant by saying it could you says did get this from here's the right maybe we should say it together there's no talking about [Music] okay what's means to speak even if you speak it out you didn't do it you didn't touch the guy's thing you thought about it that's enough to be over on you don't have to be you need to be what do you do about the fact that says do you have to touch it it's a problem as long as you think about it no you need to lift it you need to steal it you can't think about stealing somebody's bike you have to steal the guy's bike I don't know if you noticed like I'm I'm noticing here I talk about Stolen Bikes CU I have a lot of Trauma from a child I lived in farak and my bike got stolen so many times and my mother found the guy and the guy beat her up it's all I have Trauma from it can't ignore my says I'll call on anything from the mouth that we're talking we're not talking about stealing we're talking about a Sher stealing that's a little different if he thought about using the item that he's watching a just he said he's going to do it he's what about my where the stalemate I have a you have a what do we [Music] do yeah they're very close to each other one is he didn't extend his hand he didn't it says that he used it he he touched it I'll explain to you what it means I would think so here's another exception to the the rule we know over here it tells us that there is a when it comes to how do I know that if I told my slave I told my agent go ahead and I'm watching this barrel of wine I want you to go take a cup of wine so if my agent takes a cup of wine from there I become throughout the Torah if I tell my agent go steal that guy's bike go steal his car he's not me why everybody listen you can't listen to me but it comes to it's an exception to the rule I remember this because I will be asking you this what are the two places in the that there's yesterday we had one and today we have the said and this is uh whoever was in the shear yesterday knows that to me it's always it's an amazing thing like you hear these they through on the according toas because he held okay says the you never heard the they should shouldn't listen to me I told to kill the babies [Applause] [Music] what says what says this during the say that don't be laughing like when the guy says that's what he meant okay yeah say say something more down to earth to the kids the frogs was disgusting this I don't know in the stomach something it says that if you tip the barrel and you take a r of wine from it and then it breaks then you only have to take that you only you're only responsible for one rev but if you lift up the barrel it's different than tipping right because tipping it's still on the ground you didn't lift it you just tipped it if you lift it up then it becomes yours that's only because it broke afterwards so you're not responsible for breakage but if you took it out a cup of wine I'll give you a great example you'll completely understand this if I open up a bottle of coke and I take one cup of coke out of it what's going to happen to the rest of the bottle it's going to go flat that's what happens here with the wine if you take one cup of wine out of this that's it your your arrow is what caused it to spoil why cuz right now it's not a full Barrel when it's full it keeps its freshness when there's ear in it that's it goes v i was a caterer tell when I was a caterer the they brought they said no we don't need your barura white wine we have our own is a weird kind of thing they pour the thing and then the K drinks at the she's what happened was the father of the decided he's going to save the wine from this's bris the same wine and they brought it to the what it's a common thing he says by yeah you keep it but there's a there's a limit how long this stuff lasts for usually doesn't last for 22 years especially when you open it okay somebody asked somebody asked why is that you you rebi you remember everything R had a tremendous memory and why can't I remember and he said I wish I I wish I heard this years ago he said you know why because when you open up a barrel of wine says you take out one cup so it fills up with ear and it spoils the whole thing if you if you learn the whole day but you watch a little bit of YouTube at the end of the day you stick in that little it ruins everything it explains a lot for me at least I don't remember anything okay can fill your head with if you lifted up the barrel of wine took it doesn't mean that you actually removed the cup of wine you lifted it up because you wanted to take out a cup of wine officially not even though you just lift it up to take the wine that's it you're a g of on the whole Barrel that was one of the when we spoke about yesterday and the day before do you need to remove some of the wine in order to be over not a r from here that you don't need to remove why because it's as if you did remove why is it as if you did remove you want all the wine in there as we explained before it's better for you you don't want the wine to go bad so it's as if you removed that one cup that you wanted to and you put it back in there you did remove it as if you remove moved it why because you want the whole thing so you become a sh on the whole thing what if you lift up a wallet because you want to take out one bill one one coin out of it m do you say it's the same thing as a barrel of wine where you want to take out one cup is because wine watches wine you need all of the wine so that the wine doesn't spoil but one coin has nothing to do with the rest you can take out one coin perhaps when you watch something that's very large usually you don't you you don't lose a very large object I will tell you that in my Mish we do lose very large jobs my father came home my father's and he came home he told my mom that the car was stolen he went to Yeshiva with the car it's gone kids are they filed the report the whole thing cops came to the house remember the whole thing four or five days later my mother is going she goes to the bank she's walking to the bank and the car is right in front of the bank turns out my father parked the car in front of the bank he went to the bank then walked to Yeshiva and forgot that he left it in front of the bank so sometimes an our M large items get lost as large but in the the is saying that a large wallet is easier to my father once invited for for sh so we're sitting by the sudo we're like after kid knocking the door and in walks a whole family my mother's like oh she had no idea now as is she would only prepare you know like exactly each person got under plate a certain amount of food was very so like you know that was the time that I asked if we could have more dessert and like why are you pinching me under the table that kind of thing yeah so everybody had to like give the GU it was a whole yeah that's what happens when you live with says okay I don't know if if a whole wallet is a wallet is is different than a barrel of wine or not take we're going to miss we're gonna miss and now we're starting H H gold the golden rule of get ready AI the golden rule is whoever holds the gold rules ah so if you hold if you you rule it's a it's a it's a business peric so does a I didn't make this up myself no there's a a guy wanted to buy mat a PES now you know the a PES after is a is very very expensive if regular mat is expensive so Matas that are very rare and there's very few of them especially and it's it's better to to eat to make your your on to eat so people buy two matzas it cost I don't know hundreds of dollars a pound matz whatever you want to call so a guy goes to the matah bakery and he asked the guy if he could buy these matzas yeah $200 $100 a m okay he takes it he lifts it up he says you know but I don't have money here's 50 bucks I'm going to run home and get my money by the time he gets back the gab from the re already came in he's looking for Mattis and the the owner of the bakery sees who he's dealing with the GU says I need it for the for the ,000 a mat no problem th he pays he pays the price takes the matzas and leaves he comes the guy comes back with the money he says oh I'm sorry I don't have any mat I just gave it to the Reit so he runs outside tells the G listen it's my I paid I made a I made a k I went like this says no no no so the guy calls up the and he tells the you should know you should know that you're you're you're not with the why because there is I'm saying this doesn't say really but it has to be just like has to be has to be yours has to be yours so who's the AL like who's the like but he didn't pay the full prize he just he just lifted it so I'm going to show you a video here stop this what he gave him a little bit of down payment but down payment is not let me ask you something let me so Remi Remi did you learn this D yet ah let me ask you so let me ask you only you if I give money to somebody does the thing become mine oh you have to do a k on it so the money that he gave is nothing to us nothing the only thing that counts here is he did yeah so the answer is that uh the guy that did a 100% it's his however we have to ask another question and this I saw in a saer I'm not even making this up but you can think of about this yourself what is that cu want that's another question what does hem want you to do so it's very possible that he would want you to be to the Reb in terms of you're 100% right why because he's making all thing and he's fighting I saw you're right they both should be you're right but let he's not he's being he's being stubborn he's being stubborn the Reb doesn't want to give it back now the guy no I'm saying in that case that doesn't want you're right but then what but then what I'm asking him then what he doesn't want it right now he doesn't want it you're right that he should and he shouldn't have taken it and the store owner shouldn't have sold it to him and this doesn't happen by the way in B Park mat Bakery the goes himself no this is different no cuz over there they don't sell to the highest bidder all right so the bottom line is that show the video here's the video let me show you the video in case you didn't see it you're new to the shear oh I love Robbie Jacobs here Robie job come here come here Jacobs come quickly because I love the way you're looking here this is amazing look at his face he's not even looking at the goat he's looking at the you enjoyed it yeah was good okay you learned something from it yes what did you learn how to do a k yeah but you knew that before not exactly not exactly all right beautiful you're big bu this guy's a he's a you're talking about he's a he knows his stuff okay so you have to do a k says let me so let's just show I need to show you a couple of things here first it's very very important all all we're talking about here is there's one thing that's money and then the other thing is the merchandise what's merchandise and what's money the only way to make a Kenyon is by lifting up a goat lifting up something or M pulling it huh okay you've been there you've been listening he came special to say goodbye to me because he's not going to be here on Sunday people are saying already very good I'll be back sooner than you think oo depends how many days you have to stay in Miami it's a whole NE no I have I have take it's back it's just a few days after P few days few weeks whatever okay so here goes say it's very interesting money does not acquire anything acquires so if I go if I lift up something it becomes mine so now let's take a look you have gold and you have silver the both coins which one is the money and which one is the merchandise that's the question here that's what the mission is talking about one of them is merchandise one of them is money they both can't be money I'm not buying I could do AIP I could switch a car for an apple but if I'm using money so what the mission is going to tell us really is that the gold is the merchandise and the silver is the money in other words if I lift the gold then I acquired it I just owe somebody money I will have to pay him silver coins but by me lifting if if I purchase a car from you by me driving it away whatever the Kenyon of however I acquire a car that's how it becomes mine not by me giving you a check not by me paying you I owe you money I could be kind of the car if I lift it up if I'm strong I go lift up the car it becomes mine then the $110,000 I have to give you that's a different story I'll pay you tomorrow I'll pay you in two years I'll never pay you but it became mine check this out the this is a a little bit of a video I don't know if he's wearing his yamaka today I'm not sure what's going on here okay there's there's gold and the silver by this guy lifting up the gold he just acquired the gold and he became the silver but it was vice versa if he lifted up the silver if the seller lifted up the money money doesn't acquire so the other guy did not acquire the gold by by the by the seller lifting up the silver by Me by if I own a supermarket and I take your $100 from you you did not acquire the grape juice and the Matas that's not how it works the only way you acquire Matas is by lifting up the matah the money I'll come I'll go home get my money and bring it back to you but I acquire matah by lifting it up so all the Miss is saying is when I have gold and silver coins the mission understands that the gold is the merchandise the gold is the matah think about it gold it's very valuable the mats is very valuable the silver is just a coin and therefore when I make a Kenyon in the gold I lift it up the gold like this guy let's see it again when he lifts up the gold that's it the king happen the silver is on the table you could take it you don't take it but but that has nothing to do with the Kenyon I acquired the gold I acquired the money comes later but the what happened the K happened in the gold let's see the next one I don't know if it's as clear I didn't understand that the first time I saw it they put down when the seller take oh now I do understand when the seller takes the I don't know what happened over there but when the seller takes the silver oh yeah very good very good now I understand you're right men's right eeve the seller is the guy with the turbine so even though the seller lifted up the the the the other guy's coins right the guy put down the silver coins here not this one this one the skinny guy puts down the silver coins the seller picks up the silver coins no happen nothing happened he could even take the gold away he takes it puts in his pocket he could take it back why because just because the guy in the turban lifted up the silver you don't make a k with money there's no K with money so very good you help me out [Music] here not going into that the the copper is the merchandise and therefore if you lift up the merchandise the other guy owes you the money but if you do if you lift up the money C doesn't mean money means silver but if you lift up the silver which is money it doesn't Acquire The Copper which is considered today the merchandise here Mo rice AO all the old Israeli money bad stuff you can't do anything with it today according to T it's a little whatever so the merchandise is the m what that's rubbed out the U the the good money is money so you don't acquire anything with money you have to make a Ken on it is something like this if you want to see exactly how they make pennies in America they take these uh reels aim just means the blanks it has no no on it whatsoever it doesn't have a depiction the what to call slugs slugs meaning nothing nothing to them not blanks nothing printed on it I see my that that's with the hole in the middle that's something else they didn't have phones in those days I don't think yeah with the string yeah all these sh yeah okay in this case theim the blank is the merchandise because it's not money so when you acquire the blanks that's you could do a kenon on it but on money you can't do a on money oh so the metalin is considered the merchandise right they once you make a K on the merchandise on the the guy owes you money money you make a K on money nothing happens what oh man yeah yeah yeah okay it's good thing you didn't do he's not here huh I have to tell him to stop with these jokes is without what part of everybody has a different AA just ignore okay getting it off oh I forgot this is very [Laughter] important met it's getting worse then then they're going to say they're going to say it's a [Laughter] cult metalin metalin Works obviously you can make that's a regular um okay if he did a Kenyon on the fruit but he didn't give him money he did a Kion on the mat he didn't give him the money you cannot take it back if he gave him money but he didn't pull he didn't do on the you can take it back but they said this is the famous Mish all all it's called is in Mish two words but over here the Mish says it out the one who took Revenge man took revenge on the by the way once you mentioned how comeo wasn't wiped out was so the one that took revenge of the is going to take revenge on a person who doesn't stick to his word why does it say the one who took revenge of the MIT or the one who took revenge of H why does it say d so there two that I know the says that there's no in the time of the but you have to use common sense when you treat your fellow you have to use logic common sense and if you go against human behavior the norm in human society against logic so yes according to the you only gave money and I could grab it back from you I could take it back but you know what that's not how Society works that's maybe what he's saying that's not the minut society works you give the money the deal's over the says it says that prom is not going to be another M says I know he says you're going to bring carbonis will'll be take make sure there's no Mal he says and what about in a time that there's no carbonis so he says oh listen to this somebody came over he said oh remember because of you I say carban in our days was no carbas you could say caranas say says the whole reason why we don't have a a mble today is because we say things with our mouth so M our words have a lot of power words have a lot of power you have to treat it as such if you take back your word take revenge like that's it [Music] says let's say the the seller he has the money he received the money so he could take it back he could reneg the deal not the buyer Whoever has the money in his hand he's the one that wins says the re the famous the author of The Mish he was telling his son that's exactly what it says in our Mna when it comes to to to gold and silver gold is the merchandise silver is the money listen to this funny L rebi he calls his own father rebi rebi so there's a whole here says you see from here that you have to call your rebi a re you have to call him even if he's your father you have to call him rebi and the Shak says that it's D rebi who from the time of until rebi you didn't have re was the wealthiest in the generation also the greatest God you didn't have this so such a person that God's CL calls him rebi that was his name his nickname was Reb his name his name wasn't re Huda his name was rebi so such a person you have to call rebi it's not a r that you have to call every single rebi a re back upon he calls his own father rebi he tells his father when when you were younger you said the exact reverse the gold is the coin the the gold is the currency not the silver him later on we'll see that rebi shim was not happy and he he never took it back he didn't like the fact that his father changed opinions later on life and I'm just thinking to myself now out loud my father when he was younger he told me that I can't open up cans canas explain to me why on chavas chavas can't open cansas S on Chavis he held that you're making a CLE a whole thing say I don't open cans and shs now my brother does and my sons do like why cuz Z does like where he told me he can't no he took it back too bad father in my head you can't that's it you can't ABA I'm sorry yeah you change your sheet this later in life that's your thing I shouldn't say this edit please edit seriously who knows he doesn't watch he's going to know in 10 seconds that I said that there's other things he does anyways I I hear what is saying listen you told us when you were younger that's it I'm going with this I don't know what happened later on I'll do say myself what was re what was re thinking listen gold is much more expensive than silver so therefore the silver is considered the merchandise and once you make once you acquire once you make a Kyon slightly slightly uh confusing but the bottom line is when you make when you acquire the fruit you the other guy is the money the pap D Yesa before the war he said that we got to move here a great he said thaton learning Eon is gold and learning BOS is silver it's it's more common it's more for the for the and he said when rebi was older he thought that Ian was more important later on when he got older he realized that for the I was just sticking in another Reit I think the explained it that yes it might be more more expensive more it's the better way to do it but at the end of the day for the when you have a general population and it's hard for them to do so the better thing would be silver anyway him it says like this later on life and that's what he wrote the mishna the silver coins are very popular that's how you do business have a think about it try to buy a pack of potato chips with a $100 bill forget about a $100 bill how about a $25,000 bill because yeah $100 is $25,000 100 100 gold according to the gar is 25 times the amount of silver so $100 is 25 so go go try to pass around the $2,500 Bill nobody's going to get it's not something that that really works unless you're buying big stuff real quickly it's only so it's going to go quickly in honor official in honor of the sponsoring for the daily learning and by the brothers the our grandfathers I'm gon to scrug with this name the entire month it makes much more sense that the silver is the merchandise the gold is the currency it says in our that the copper is the merchandise if you're telling me that silver is the merchandise now it makes more sense that copper is the merchandise even though when it comes to compared to to silver gold theab sorry silver is considered the merchandise compared to to gold but compared to Copper that's what the m is telling us you should know silver is is considered currency that the copper is the fruit and the silver is the fruit compared to the gold what if you telling me that silver is considered currency now when it comes to gold and silver you're telling me that silver is the currency and even though gold is much more important so when it comes between silver and copper and silver is more expensive than copper it's more popular in the stores certainly why does the M even have to tell us that the that silver is considered currency compared to Copper it's I do need it so certain places that they use this copper it's more popular in certain places pennies that are C are more popular than other currencies in certain places maybe it should be considered currency no around the world universally silver is currency compared to Copper you should know also held not like in the mishna tells us that gold is fruit it's merchandise no gold is currency so we all know I I couldn't find a good chart it was very very late in the day but r r was R's nephew okay the famous story that he they uh father and mother were they shared the same or the opposite Rab's father and mother were's brother and sister okay so as you see in this chart so ra borrowed money from his cousin a girl it wasn't St the daughter of it was his cousin so he borrowed gold from his cousin and it went up in price he went what should I do how do I pay this back it went up in price is it ribus talking about my father a lot of things in in in our house my father used to use language from the gar this is one of them I didn't know what he's talking about yeah you tell me okay you get used to it like it becomes part of the I don't know what it means but yeah it's Migra it means it doesn't make sense or something I don't know I paid him for for your I paid the okay good means it means means good it weigh weigh a lot in other words pay him the don't worry about it you don't have to worry about uh Rivers if you're telling me that gold is currency okay so I borrowed 100 bucks you give back $100 I don't care goes up in price down in price the only thing that went down in price is the silver compared to the gold but I'm giving you currency but if you telling me that gold is merchandise so we remember right so means that you're not permitted to do as follows if you borrow a bowl of Wheat and it cost back when you borrowed it was $20 it's not permitted to give back a bowl of wheat you can't give a saw you can't borrow a saw and then pay back a saw why because it could go up in price it could go down in price it's ribus if it goes up in price barley wheat there's a market right now today there's it's on the stock exchange how much is barly how much is wheat if you bought it at 20 and then you return it when it's worth 30 so you you returned rivis so how in the world could he take from his cousin a a bar of gold and then return a bar of gold that's sub gold is also on the stock market the only way you could say that's m is if gold is currency what oh cuz you went to the this month so there is an exception to the rule if when you borrow the wheat you have your own weat you borrowed it but it's locked up in a in a closet I don't have the key I'm waiting for the key to come so I'm permitted to borrow based on that wheat that I have in my closet now how much could you borrow the exact amount that you have in the closet unlimited unlimited why because I could go to a thousand different people and borrow one let's say I have one one bag of weed in my in my closet I could borrow from a thousand different people a thousand bags of wheat based on that one bag of wheat so may I could borrow unlimited so there is no concept of Saw B if I have so ra who borrowed gold from his cousin he had a little bit of gold at home how much not the whole amount a small amount so if he had a small amount there's no problem of sa we're going to see a lot more of that in fine had it what else did you say Jonathan yes we just said fix price fixed price that's okay but it went up in price over here went up in price it's not small small change oh and if you if you convert it to the doll you convert to the current currency so it's worth 20 bucks you con the item to I'm back oh at the time of the you convert it okay I'm gonna need your help during but I'm going to be America he had gold it's as if he says I'm just waiting for my son to open up the safe I need the key this T of holds that gold is Cardy it's not the merchandise like the M says the you remember the first M this 4800 says this 4800 in one dinner of Z one that you woman with is one of eight of the is made out of silver do I care look at to know if the pr is has the value did lose value it's not a PR then I can't with it one the silver was one out of 24 of silver coin just to know whether or not you took a six more than you were supposed to and then the whole sale is cancelled dinner one dinner of silver so over here the gar says that gold is has a value 25 times the value of silver okay gold is more valuable 25 times more than silver so I looked it up yesterday gold today is 83 times the value what I looked it up yesterday I said it just went up you saw I'm serious I looked it up yesterday 83 it said 83 times the value of silver as you got to see this how's it possible that gold is 25 times silver in our days gold is only 12 times how's it possible that in the time of the T was 25 times the answer is look at our days it's 83 times and goes into the whole chat that it really isn't 25 times it's just they call something else it's 12 times okay we got to go V there there's people waiting here okay so I need to know how much how much uhum in in silver to give for the pin if I give a thing I have to give change or [Music] not if you're telling me that that gold is currency and everything else fluctuates based on that but the the currency stays the way it is it's fixed great if you tell me like the M that gold is actually merchandise you're going to tell me that you do Ain based on something that that fluctuates in price something that he has to add to the coins and Co has change doesn't make any sense you see from here that gold we view it as cury not as merchandise not like Mish not awesome like rebi when he was a Youngster not awesome unfortunately I don't know we have to we have to keep on going this is in case you don't know what m is in years 1 124 five you have to take 10% of whatever you have left over from your produce after you give it to Trum myus you have to bring it to Yus now the the fruit is too heavy so you take money out of your pocket and you see it has that color you transfer the purple gusa from the fruit into the money and the fruit becomes you could eat the fruit the question is could you take that money that silver and transfer that it's too heavy for you it's getting heavier and heavier you transfer that into gold do not transfer silver into gold you can't say you could could you transfer from the silver to the gold that silver is the currency think about it quick question could I take silver the silver that I have here my my hand and transfer into Fruit I want to I feel like slepping apples up to not silver could I do that no the Tet says it goes One Way Fruit to money that's it if gold is fruit the and I have no right to transfer silver to fruit the Torah says it goes from from fruit to Silver not the opposite so I cannot take silver and transfer it into Fruit gold is fruit so that's the whole Su what is gold is gold fruit or is gold currency is fruit it doesn't go that route no the opposite the silver is the fruit and the gold is the currency I could go from fruit to money to currency so I can go from silver to gold but fruit to Gold what if I don't feel like taking silver to the of course I could take gold to the agreed that I could transfer fruit to Silver but silver is not silver is considered fruit so how could I transfer fruit to fruit how can I take my my apples and transfer it to silver coins you just told me Silver is fruit and I can't go from from fruit to fruit I can only go from fruit to money the answer is because compared to fruit silver is money so too compared to fruit gold is money you're right gold is fruit but gold is also money compared to other stuff when it's you have silver and gold gold is fruit when we have fruit and gold fruit is money I mean gold is money gold is money guys paying attention compar the fruit it's considered currency should we what are we going to do uh uh it's already we never finish so late have a wonderful day aabab shabis at [Music] 9:30