Daf Yomi Bava Metzia Daf 14 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning rap the whole o wants to welcome back to the boo he just got up when did you get up oh I sent people to the MAV yesterday seriously I thought you getting up this point wow okay it's first day back right into it is welcome back we shouldn't know for any from any more yesterday I said the story of it's just cheers and there other for the future tremendous news the person who jumped in first the group that jumped in First Montreal had to get together yesterday you're not going to believe this Badness it was a tremendous for me monreal is a small place we don't hear from them that much but they decided they want to do the first ever kickoff for this campaign that we're doing approximately 20 people showed up and they set a goal to raise $100,000 I think so very that's very [Applause] nice there's always that guy there's always that guy when they raise $100,000 in Israel it's Israeli dollars no it's Amer we go with American dollars B they'll do more than that but it's a great it's a big for us because now we know if Montreal could do it then Toronto is going to have to do double than that and London is going to have to do triple than that do Harris um here this is yane from Yanke Pizza he donated the whole thing he's part of the shear he came to the shabbaton shom goldon is the one that ran the whole thing so thank you I showed this picture yesterday of's grandson showing it again today because B this week the cover of the isra the Hebrew Mish is going to be about mdy bem will bring more people to T it's a beautiful I I have to say it's probably the nicest best article ever written about mdy yeah I loved it very very Talent very young how old is he he's 25 years old and this is already like his fifth cover in a row or something something czy very very talented guy hi rebell while back in Manchester for a few days I bumped into a wire and my cousin Benny gson he's inviting his grandparents to the by the B tonight while I was saying hello to mine regard Jesse Sounders Saunders director of the Jewish weekly we miss you and Ma to Ben the is in the background the second guy y's on the left tonight at tonight's Manchester another tonight or maybe it's the same one yeah maybe this is Benny's this is one of your favorite is Joseph from Schwarz learning the gar learning not wasting time at a dear belly and the mdy family a year ago as my little brother choking up your talid this is's brother I missed the guy a year ago as my little brother lay in a coma from which he would not recover I realized that sitting in t neck there's there was exactly one thing I could do for him later that night I texted to his account that would try to make up the D for him I went back to noer 41 on YouTube and started learning I surprised how much I enjoyed this year and realized how much I had been missing the charts made the suus easier to understand the admirations were done with wonderful humor and there's a special camaraderie here the camarad is no small thing earlier this year when we were learning for B I took upon myself seven where is he that here no on a hunch I looked back at the list of people who learned foravi when he got sick and I saw that Robert ear had learned 15 D for AI how many D do we do together like 5,000 I think it was huh sh who else is a guest there you're not a guest are you not anymore sh guest wow the guest is back the most kids are back you fly to America more than Navi shalom welcome back we missed you so I never met that ear but what an important and Powerful connection I cor ramble on about the friends I've made with wonderful people ysf bak and Mark ashkanazi and I've reconnected with friends from Yeshiva but I most want to say thank you rebelli for bringing us to this amazing sh and thank you for everyone who have been wonderful friends and amazingly supportive may all together ab's brother y'all see Mand bound it's unbelievable so so he got another guy that fell for it got into the da and this is his da anniversary he's doing the D exactly a year unbelievable I mean just it always reminds me that we're not here forever and nobody knows when and what he was maybe you could call him the he the life of the party is always there always had a good joke had a funny background shooing on those when you went on Zoom you always heard his voice and suddenly in his early 40s boom all over got we got we never know by Anonymous for the safe and Speedy return of all the hostages the par of this is the last day ma last day let's say to my sonon ma to myself Ellie and the entire Mish and the birth of sopia r should bring everything's backwards I guess that I say it every day and I don't remember anymore but it's backwards I'm confused by Iron framan it should be to reell I don't know this is the it says and then it says b with with a S I don't know what to do here I'm confused let's do it all the ways first is a bass okay let's start from the beginning these are names these are basses and the Art of the month spons Anonymous for the for needs a child birth his daughter and healthy baby I'll just explain to that real quickly I don't want to dwell on this every day but I'll have to we did 5,200 ah first of all we have a guest here go around here we have a seat for you I don't know if we have two seats no you can't where are you going to get to this seat you have to go re Hound but there's a seat over here you know what one of you sit here one of you sit here I don't want to confuse anybody B we just read a whole thing about you I mean Robert sorry sorry sorry sorry that wasn't good okay what you always come just a little late um so I just explain I wanted to explain before I'll explain now I don't want to dwell on it what it is people take upon themselves a page they say okay I'm going to try to raise if if it was 20 people and $100,000 I try to raise $5,000 you know it AES out to $5,000 each here sit down over here this seat right here what's your name midd you related to this guy wow what a you're also related that's your uncle yeah he's like the star of the shear you know that right when he comes he's usually in the Army he's usually giving out knives to the which is more important than learning da right no it's not supposed say no let's do it again man he's busy giving out helmets the it's unbelievable thing isn't that more important than the da no it's no way he's confused I confus let's ask your father what's more important to give out stuff more important than the D that's right I love you man hey let's go get out of here go out thank you nothing is more important than the D don't get out of here there go Mi what's more important than the D what so how come you don't come to the dve and you stay in the the the the army bases let me tell you a story that I haven't said in a long time we had a guy here by the name of sh elat I was coming up the stairs and he's going down the stairs I said SCH what are you doing he goes I have to collect money to AR Kipper I said no you don't have to collect money you have to learn the da da is more important than no but I said get back in here so kid sir he comes back in and so he didn't come back right away I started the year and I said what happened and all of a sudden he walked in and we made a whole thing out of it and he said he did the what happened was that during this she people heard about it and they gave him thousands of dollars people they said you know he came back to thousand doll and then he tells me what happened was instead of him going he sent his son and he gave his son all the address he says nobody was home his son raised zero had he gone he would have raised zero he came to the D he made thousands of dollars so what do you see from here all the K have their helmets they're all going to have uh body armor and all the flashlights and the knives everything will be fine as long as you come to the D you can do it afterwards what we will we did we weren't here we the group in Montreal raised $100,000 how they they didn't raise they set a goal each person takes a page it says your name on it and you say how much you want to raise and then you go and you reach out to your friends in a non in a very easy way just send some text message to stad and most people either throw it into the garbage or they respond if they like you and like that they er raise the goal whatever our goal is going to be a million two million who knows 10 million H all [Music] right we are holding in Middle we have like five minutes here that we have to tidy things up finish up the sugya and we're going to move on to other sugas very interesting stuff today but we're holding in Middle we had like this A Guy Walks down the street and I could ask you the question because it's nette today you walk down the street there used to be something called a check remembers it's one of these it's a piece of paper you sign your name when you're in the grocery store there's always that woman that holds up the line she pulls out a big checkbook she very slowly how much a dollar 25 one you know whatever we're not gonna talk about that part you find a check on the street it has a signature it has an amount it has a name on top what do you do with it what do you do with the check what would you do if you found the check it says who the check was written by it says who the check is to this in the store signature amount what do you do sh so something similar you find the document on the street it says ruim a million dollars what do you do so the Mish tells us that if it's connected to real estate you don't give it back if it says in thear that if he doesn't pay the there's there's a lean on real estate you don't give it back is of the opinion that so it goes like this right as soon as the witnesses sign that's when the lean occurs that's when it starts so why don't you give thear back explained that we're concerned about a we're concerned learn that the L borrows money then he's a good guy he gives back the money gets back Hisar then under the table they do a stick he gives thear back to the malva or in this case you found thear and you give it back to the malva so the goes to the says pay me back which he already did and it's not a real loan so the says I don't have money however I sold real estate that was attached to this loan let's go get the piece of real estate from the guy real estate is worth $10 million so the go and they grab the real estate from the unsuspecting buyer and they split it they make a deal it's a big lie because the lawy already paid the loan now they're just taking extra for themselves great that's why you don't give back a document that's why you don't get back AAR Shu as we learned yesterday is of the opinion we're not concerned that people are going to do no this is not a thing it's too farfetched to worry about G him doing these things no not concerned that's why you don't give it back all of a sudden cuz you're going to give it back no so what's the problem why can't I give back the document the problem is because we're talking about unlike the other Mand that we learned until now that Thea we're talking about a case that the admits that there was aone holds that the L does not admit it alone there's no loan it's already paid off whatever no loan anymore so they have no business giving back a document that he denies okay so now that we know that let's go back to the next chart this is not so confused we're not going to do all the parts of the chart but yesterday we learned BR in the BR it talks about if you find what do you do if you want to see it inside it's the the top line over there it has even though everybody admits to it even though the admits to it do you guys see a problem even if the admits to it don't give it back so first of all we're talking about the admits to it and says we're talking about the doesn't admit that was his whole explanation if he wants to go with a and he wants to hold like a he must say that the doesn't admit to the loan and over here the say she doesn't let's keep on going so we're holding like three lines from the top this Bry is very problematic to it's going to be two questions on first of all like the question we asked yesterday H has to say if he wants everything to go well he has to say that the BR that the Miss is talking about when Thea doesn't admit to the loan and the BR that he doesn't admit another problem are you know why because we're learning a lot and they're also gal because if you're if your head is spinning right now we're starting a brown in two minutes to remind the you go you go on the and they ask you what's yesterday nobody knew what it was right today we know the top words on means that somebody wrote and said you could take my belongings starting right now even though you didn't give me a loan give me a loan later line of credit whatever you want to call it so he says if you find one of these stas you could give it back and we're not concerned that somebody repaid it why RAB say why what's the always I'm not concerned that somebody repaid it why because how did you find such AAR if he repaid it what's the first thing you do when you repay a loan rip it up like the gal from somebody sitting here in the shear I don't know if he wants me to say it's him but his brother-in-law I said this a few times smack his brother-in-law once uh gave somebody somebody owed him money in the diamond industry and he gave AAR or something and he paid it back a whole M so the guy came to him with thear and said here over there it goes by Shake hand there's a lot of trust this guy was a liar and he wanted to collect twice with the same with the same Shar even though he knew very well that it was paid off so this guy's brother says oh oh yeah there's AAR let me see thear so he gave him thear he says okay he ripped it up he tore it up that's the first thing you do if you pay back you rip up itar so why why is that a problem so if you look at this just look at this uh chart for a second it says on the bottom right corner sh right next to him for per we're not concerned that it was paid off what does the Bry say top right corner Bryce so there's a problem red and green there's a contradiction and the BR says we're concerned that people pay things off and says we're not concerned if you find AAR even though the admits that it's a good star don't give it back why you see it says especially if the says I don't admit that this is a good in other words I already get I already paid it off so that's the end of the so have two contradictions we have two problems with great so what do we do with the check at at the end of the day today what do we do with a check so they say again I'm not a r I'm just throwing things out that I saw if you find the check that's a regular check with the signatures the names the whole thing you don't give it back you don't give it back you don't give it to anyone and certainly you don't deposit it for yourself why not because it's not your money the money the guy that has the if you want to go like deep into the the guy that is the owner of this account it's his money as on this money you have no right to take it out of his account obviously if you find a check without a signature what do you do give it back to the owner of the check now sometimes people leave the amount open it's open check they don't write the amount in and in this case the writer of the check admits he wrote this check and left it open could you give it back to the one it's written to do we have to be concerned maybe the one that was it was written to pass it off to another person so the answer is nobody passes off a open check to anyone because the guy you give it to might fill in a crazy amount he trusted you he didn't trust anybody else so you could give it back to the guy that was written to but not to anyone else says the we're talking about again you find the in the street do you give it back yes or no and it says in the mishna that what if the doesn't have again means that there's an attachment of real estate to thear if you don't pay you could the the Malou of the lender could go after your real estate and if you don't have real estate anymore because after the time that you took the loan you sold your real estate you could go and take the real estate at out of the purchasers resour if there's no if there's no real estate attached don't give it back either why not according to you don't give it back why this is a new mus we might have mentioned it once what does this mean if you were to read these words don't look in the art scroll I see you peeking it seems like the opposite it seems like the fact that there is a lean of real estate in thear it's a mistake that theer made and the fact is these words mean the exact opposite the fact that it's not in thear means that the CER forgot that every in other words every Star should have a lean and a connection to real estate and when you don't have that lean you hear Donnie when you don't have that lean it's a mistake dannie was up the whole night in the in the giving out stuff to the you hear this what's what does it mean I know so what does it [Laughter] mean means that when you have a star in front of us and it doesn't mention real estate don't worry about it there plenty of real estate attached to it the CER forgot to put it in and therefore Whoever has thear the Mal can go after real estate again it's not going to be fear he's going to go after real estate that that he's not deserving of because the loan happened later thear was written earlier there's a lot of issues when this real estate attached really say there's a concept called here these three things these three things the CER must ask permission from the one writing thear should I put it in you guy taking a loan should I put it in the in thear what are these three things first of all sh we know sh means that there's a connection to real estate so that's it right here we have a a question it says you have to ask and if you don't ask or you don't you don't get permission you don't put a she you don't put a lean into thear so if you don't see the lean in the star it's not a mistake it's because he asked permission and he didn't get permission so there are star that don't have a connection to real estate what are you telling me the is saying it the other thing is what if you made improvements you bought a field from someone that took a loan so first of all I want to know is my field guaranteed I'll get my money back second of all what if I build a house on this field what if I plant trees and the lender takes my field away from me are you going to reimburse me for my improvements in the in the land I have to ask permission write that in there yes I'm going to take responsibility so so ask me it doesn't happen automatic shefer and also when if they take my field away from me the one I just bought from you because you owe money and you didn't pay and they took my field away can I get your best field I want your in this I don't want just any field I don't want to I want in Manhattan downtown I don't want in Missouri okay so says you have to ask permission you want to tell me whether holds you have to ask permission or not whether it's automatic thing that the sh goes into the star whether you put it in or not can't be that what said when we're talking about a loan nobody gives a loan a loan you don't gain anything it's a pure Mitzvah I give you a loan and that's it I don't get I don't get anything out of it if I get a little bit more than ribus it's saer so at least at Le the least you can do is back it up with some real estate so automatically there's a real estate lean whether the cyer put it in or not if he didn't put it in you should know it's a mistake on the C's part but the second part that says that I have to ask the should I put in there on a sale on a regular sale why there are people that buy land for one day to this very day I happened to be there I never really purchased anything there I went to see what it looks like there's something called a tax sale in the United States I'm sure it's all over the world that is people that don't pay their property taxes in Israel it's called Arona whatever it is let's say it adds up to a lot of money and the guy is ignoring you so what they do is they sell your taxes at auction and I know some very successful people in Chicago that this is what they do all day they go to these auctions and basically the starting bid is the amount of the taxes so let's say you have a house that's worth a million dollar and the taxes are $30,000 you didn't pay you live in monly tremendous the taxes are very high right Viv the taxes $35,000 a year easy okay who some people can't afford $35,000 extra dollars on top of your $100,000 tuition so you don't pay you get lazy you don't pay comes a guy so they sell it they say who wants to give the the cities $35,000 the guy says I'll give $36,000 it's a bid a war this guy say I'll give 40,000 geter you give whatever you give you buy the taxes then the owner gets it's a notification that his taxes were sold now sometimes he doesn't get it sometimes he's in sometimes he's deceased I don't know the guy's lifter who knows the guy that buys the taxes he starts raking up they start charging 12% interest whatever the amount is on their money and gets more more and more all of a sudden the guy gets a bill of 60 $70,000 now he for sure doesn't know what to do and the guy could take his house okay that's how it works now what if the guy gets a shock he can't believe it he didn't get the mail all of a sudden he he finds out in the newspaper that somebody bought his taxes so the first thing he does he runs down to the city and he pays the 35 now it's already 45,000 he pays it and he takes his house back what is that called that's called the guy bought a house for one day the guy at the tax sale that bought the house he knows that he might not have this house he buys 20 30 of these in one shot this is what they do some of them he gets lucky and he gets the keep some of them the guy pays him the extra taxes and he makes a couple of bucks some of them them he finds out later are worthless he bought in downtown Chicago the house some I told you this m a guy was trying to convince me they want to pay me $1,000 to buy his house to take his house from him that's how little it was worth in downtown Chicago and not downtown you know South okay something called over here also I know that you took out a big loan I know you can't afford it I know you might not pay it but you know what I like your penous in the center of so I'm going to make it I'm going to make you a deal I'm buying your penth house right now instead of $10 million I'm buying it for $50,000 why because it's very possible you're not going to pay your loan and they're going to foreclose on my pent house and they're going to take it away but right now I need a for I'm I'm asking to do this I'm buying it for a few days now later on they come to take it away okay it's a risk I took I might get to keep it I might not says so so therefore in that case not every time is there not every time I get my money back I I take a risk I'm asking to take a risk I'm not paying that much anyways I take a risk there are people like that there's a story this person by the name of he bought you know the the the top floor the attic from his sister also Ti from she obviously didn't tell him the whole the whole story comes the the person that lent her money and grabs the attic away from the brother also now they go to bz he's taking his sister to B he needs to know listen is she even if he's not upset at her he just wants to know she or not is she going to get for this I have to save my sister yesterday we had the the the son that tried to kick his father out of the nursing home put him in the nursing take all the stuff joh story today in the a sister did it to a brother when you wrote the document the sale document did she write in there that she's taking responsibility and she's it's it's does a lean on on property he said no like the famous joke what do you say at a birthday party of a person who just turned 120 have a nice day so that's what he told him have a nice day it was the shortest ever is there uh does it say in there that there's a no byebye see you later go fight it out with your sister we can't help you out I know my stuff I went I mean I know my stuff you you said wait a minute so what do you mean she didn't write it in there it was a mistake the didn't write it in there so what's the answer say that's a sale is on alone so here you see the distinction between aone document that you say again there is no when it comes to selling because there are people that don't put in a guarantee because they're willing to take the risk it's okay here's the story hold on let me see if I have a better one oh here we go this one okay you have Ru and he owns the field the Mala gave him 100 bucks Ruben goes sells the field to shim okay comes the malva and says Ruben pay me I don't have 100 bucks what does the malva do shim improved it gal the malva takes the field now who does the malva and shim the malva takes the field from shim could ruin get involved there in the court case that's the question again yeah you see what happened Ruan owns a field he's he takes a loan out Ruben goes sells the field so Ruben is very involved there he sells the field to shim but who steals the who takes it legally away from shim the malva the malva he didn't get paid by Ruben he goes and he takes the field away from shim could ruin go to court and try to prove to the malva you didn't give me alone you didn't me alone why do you take it away from shim or it's a it's something that's only between the Malin and shim the answer is what's the answer he could get involved why not what what no no that's already too deep money at oh that's right his money's at stake ruin has a big thing here number one his money's at stake what else is that stake reput his reputation he doesn't want somebody to be upset at him so simple here the sticks in the word there is a guarantee real estate lean and the Mal comes and takes the field away from the buyer go fight the Malin Court can't tell him back who are you I don't know who you are I only deal with the buyer tells him if you take it out of him if you take it out of the buyer he's going to come back to me and I am responsible to pay him back because some say even if there's no warranty guarantee real estate connection here I don't feel like going into sh and seeing shim look other Direction I made I made a deal with him I sold him a property and they took the property away from him it's me he's going to be upset not you so even though there's no I'm involved there very much and therefore I could go and go against you in court some ask why can't Ruben go to court on behalf of shim anyways he's he's he's a lawyer he's shim's lawyer no so maybe doesn't know about it okay interesting that the usus how is in English grievance Tinus is in English yeah okay can have Tinus you mean every non Jew knows what Tinus is 100% 100% you take this 100% and use it in a lot of other things that said trust me it's 100% trust meus is in English when the M says over there points out that you can't be you're not permitted to be upset at somebody because you feel like it okay if somebody didn't invite you to his bris you don't have the the right to be upset we get Breakers at people you did this to me there's something called he did something against he took something from you there somebody didn't lend you money I think he talks about not lending money you don't have the right to be upset at him he didn't L your money if he doesn't pay you back then you have tyus then tyus interesting talking aboutus that same person that told me the first M which I messed up says a another I'm not saying this just I thought it was funny somebody came to to his father-in-law for loone he said can I have $20,000 he said no he says why not he says cuz I rather you be upset at me then later on i' be upset at you I know if it's this that but in you looked at the guy says this guy's never paying me so you know what you be upset at me now I don't want to be upset at you tyus I don't want to be upset Asin here we go very very simple ruin sells a field to to a buyer comes a guy you know how it goes especially in certain different places there's always that guy that that makes a whole what are you selling it's mine it used to be mine I don't have the right documents to prove it but the whole thing rumors rumors you didn't take any responsibility so depends if he didn't make a which the is going to explain very simple not a threeyear kak walks up and down the the the the border of the field whatever he does over there he could take it back why could he take it back he didn't do a kazak now Rashi says he didn't give any money no money exchanged here T says there is money there is a Kenyan okay Rashi we go with Rashi there's no money no I'm taking it back why I don't even need to deal with all these neighbors that are making rumors this that nothing sh huh not what yeah I give it I give my feeli back there is no deal but once he did a on the field even though he didn't give any money cannot take it back why there's a sack with a bunch of kns I you had one here yesterday oh there's a sack with a bunch of knots I guess here the knots it it shows that the sack is is very strong and that's where the the saying comes from a cat in the sack yeah em this is where it comes from not joking look it up there's a what's his name here this is kak this is a cat I just I like this guy's face he like he's surprised the guy on the left okay anyway so the you bought a property without without a guarantee so it's your loss if there's if you you made a kak here now there's rumors it's your problem there's brings a person was going out with this woman and she told them that her father's and this and that so they got engaged and they said okay they're they set a date for the wedding then he finds out that first of all she has a shra whatever that means doesn't go into details he says this this it's possible to have a shra even though you're p a shra doesn't only work for whatever she has a sh second of all her father is actually married to that she was talking about married to he wants to know if he's allowed to break the he made a he's GNA he's going to get married huh no no no not her mother not her mother the the father later he's not a he's he right now he's in jail for he's married to gu so he wants to bring a ride from gar that it says over here that even if you do make a deal you say I'm going to buy this property once you have you have all sorts of things then you can back out of the deal besides he says the rush says that when a when a person gets engaged thinking that the father is and she's and this and that so it's like getting engaged right it's getting engaged doesn't talk about the r say and over here she broke the f [Music] even if we're talking about oh sorry what does mean sometimes means Walking On the Border like stomping down the ground over here Rashi says that he he he lifted up the Border he made a certain border you showed this is the Border you don't have to be the three years you have to do some sort of Misa either I don't know what the word is tamping down maybe there's a word tamping like uh they have a tamper like one of these tools that goes like this is it called tamping it's a square with a pole they go like this you guys don't know you never that's much better turning the Innovations in honor of my uncle prman and the Turning of the D sponsored by n t of Baltimore Maryland in honor of fish thanks to them 137 people learned 16166 over 727 th000 minutes of to with MD you want to take that on how much they I don't know we'll find out right now we know about manol one one by one where are we oh no what happened there a guy sold a field even even says the with an even with a guarantee I'm not giving you a new field I'm not giving you your money back you know why so what if the guy made a big stink did he take it away from you no when he takes it away from you when all these big talkers that they oh used to be mine and my father father used to live when they come when they're able to kick you out of the field then come to me and let's we'll speak then you show me a document showing that they took it away from you I'll pay you cash I don't care about all these rumors and all these fact that that's that's something that's your problem now a person steals a field I know of a story Mish somebody I know very well I told you this story I'll say it again this guy very very smart guy he did a deal a real estate deal with a very successful real estate person a guy in the business he took him to a building of his and he sold him the building now how did the guy know was his building because there's a huge sign on the side of the building that said his name on it so obviously there a big sign what happened the guy went in that morning put up the sign took him toward the the property and then took off the sign when the guy found out everything went n and the guy he had to end up paying back every cent the whole thing but there's something called selling I said also here Ines somebody rented apartment for a very long time and his trick was he figured he'll get the guy off his head for three years and meanwhile he sold apartment the owner of the apartment comes to his apartment sees another family living there they said what are you doing what are you what are you doing here we bought it no you didn't buy it it's my apartment get out it happens somebody was sitting here last night when I said the story he said his parents bought an apartment from somebody during the the yipper war and it turned out the guy already sold it to somebody else he lied to them he took all their money they got on a plane went back to America never lived inel again because they lost all their money on a house that was sold uh alah they come here and their apartment was sold to somebody else a lie the guy took all their money it happens I know someone did happened to them in Nat yeah yeah it happens Russians moved in I know somebody had sold his the apartment three times three to three different people before gets registered 100% they go and they sell it quickly what it happened to [Music] you somebody presented them as the landlord yeah somebody presented them as a landlord and you gave him $20,000 it wasn't even his people only were doing him a and letting him live there the people only doing a letting him live there I'm just repeating so people know what you're saying in case they don't hear yeah all the bills on his name and he came to us when we were you know 30 years old and he said look I own the place and I'm to deal with you and it to you you gave him a deposit that was it I remember you told me the story yeah B kid sir it happens today and it happen theor talks about it so this is what happens say check this out if you see this guy you'll understand why here check out his face this is the type of guy you want to steal from anyway he owns a field comes this guy check out what he does to him unbelievable kicks him out of there then the golin he says oh it's my field look I'm here he sells it to somebody okay he sells the field this guy why did he buy a field to do this he put up a house he put He put he he improved the field the must pay for the house for the improvements of course he has to pay for the property has to give him back what the purchase price but he also has to paying for the house and for the trees and for everything else for the fence the whole thing just a quick question we have a let's say no fix moves into this rental that he that he bought from a guy and he improves the rental he improves it he puts in air conditioning here there you have to put an air condition the whole thing does a renovation who pays for the renovation so typically speaking the the owner would have to unfortunately pay for the renovation over here we're talking about the golin why does the Goslin have to pay for the renovation ask Rashi the the the the buyer put up a house on the property not owned by him not owned by the Goslin so whoever the original owner is he should pay for the house at least not the whole house at least for his expenses whatever the is if I walk into your field and I plant the tree you pay me for expenses says Rashi because it was already improved beforehand when the guy owned it and it went down by itself in value and then the buyer improved it back to where it was to begin with so the buyer didn't gain anything he has nothing to pay the only thing that the buyer could do is go after the ghav okay the okay listen listen what happened a guy a guy no no no I'll explain to you the guy owns an apartment the guy owns an apartment he had air conditioning in there he was painted everything was good somebody comes steals the apartment from him after 20 years air conditioner is worthless the paint needs to be repainted so the guy that the G of sells it to now the guy puts in a new air conditioner Paints the walls now we're asking that the original owner should pay for the air conditioning the answer is no when you stole it from me it had air conditioning I I had it with air so you already had air conditioning I don't I'm not paying anybody for anything the GH of what then he does you're right rashi's answering that's talking about that he already had the and went down after stolen he had went down went up so the the one that was stolen from is saying I'm not paying anybody anything I had it at a good place my a my apartment was air conditioned it had good paint you stole it after a while the paint went away deteriorated and there's no air conditioning the new guy put in the air condition B so the GH of should pay for that not but you have to say that okay says the you don't take money from the GH of for the improvements oh why not we're going to see in a second to understand why doesn't the ghav have to pay for improvements what if he said the ghav when he sells the fake land that's not his he says I I take it it's if you put any improvements I'll pay for it is because he never specified but if he did specify the G would have to pay for improvements in the air conditioner that perhaps it looks it looks like ribus why when the ghav doesn't own the field think about it the ghav doesn't own the field he sells he doesn't own the apartment he a apartment that's not his he takes money for it what is that money the money is aone the guy gave him money not for a purchase cuz it's not his he can't purchase it he gave him money for no reason that's called a loan the GH of of now he got $100,000 for the apartment he has to give back the $100,000 the guy that that he he lied to he ripped him off but now if he tell me he has to pay $110,000 $110,000 for the air conditioning in the painting so it looks like ribus he got $100,000 and he's giving back $10 it looks like rivit but it's not rivit therefore the GH of gets off the hook I know it's hurtful but that's how it is so what do you do what do you do in this case do you pay is this the reason that said that you don't get the improvements because it looks like ribus or perhaps because it's wasn't mentioned yes no yes no I don't know I don't I'm confused is very indecisive you didn't know what that is says in the name of and he explains even though he said I will pay for the improvements what do you see from here if he doesn't own the property it's going to look like interest is and this by the way let's see if remembers when you have this is between ra do you have to pay the improvements or not who do we passing like ra or when it comes to M this we're going to passing like ra nevertheless the next few minutes we're going to try to understand just uh so we're on the same page here when a person owes his wife what is it called a child support child support and alimony but it's talking about also Child Support also but Alon she cannot take from sold real estate okay why because nobody could buy real estate because everybody has a wife nobody knows if they're getting divorced nobody knows how many how long they're going to be divorced or widowed and how much money is going to come out of my real estate that I purchase from anybody so you can never buy real estate if a guy has a loan there's a $10,000 loan I know it's C at 10,000 where com to come and take $1,000 out of my property butus it could be it could be 80 years I don't know so no cap there's also you can't take AIS which I don't know what it is yet was going to see in the gar and which I don't know yet what it means we're going to see in the is talking about our that we're talking about here what improvements the air conditioners so it says like this you don't take it out of take you don't take it from sold real estate says you do take it if he owns real estate right now you take it from his real estate it says what's the middle one the purple I I did explain it our question over here you buy something from a ghav and you improve that you put air conditioners and it says M that you have to the ghav has to pay him back from unsold real estate you're right sold real estate not unsold real estate that the GH of has he has to take and pay for the air conditioners no it's a on we're not talking about the case of aov we're talking about this case take a look it's came out the same thing but look at this a guy borrowed money the guy that borrowed money sold the field the guy that bought the field improve the field comes the guy that lent the money and takes the field away now the guy that bought the the field wants his improvements back from the borrower he wants his initial purchase price plus all the improvements he wants 130 instead of 100 and there's no problem with ribus here because it was a legit sale the the Ruan the lus sold the field to the buyer when do you have a problem with ribus when I lend you money and you give me back more than I lent you by the GH of the the purchase lent the GH of money he never purchased it because he can't buy anything from a GH of so the money he gave the GH of was was a loan and then the GH of goes back and gives back more money for the improvements that's ribus but over here there's a sale and I want money for my improvements that's not ribus says the Gar so you're talking about no no we're not talking about a GH of hour case so we have no Riot to hour case of a ghav we're talking about a different case of a loan SOA just means the two words before for the saer it's one line right you don't take from sold real estate from sorry not this one wrong wrong chart here we go this is the r the sa let me just go over here okay we said in one line you don't take from sold real estate is the is okay not it's not so confusing you don't take for fruit that was taken let's say you owe me money and I take your house from you the house do I take the furniture in the house no I take the house if I take your field do I take the fruit that are on the tree no the fruit that are finished on the tree they don't belong to me the real estate belongs to me you don't take the fruit let me ask you something else if you steal a field from me and I come and I I get my strength back and I take the field back do I take the field back with the fruit that you planted here or without with because it's my field you planted out my field so the ghav does take AIS so therefore Thea is talking about a ghav not a not a if that's the case it's going to be like this both of these cases the r and the sa are both talking about a ghav so how do you tell me that the sa the middle one is talking about has to be uniform not true not uniform at all the oh what just happened that was funny ran away the malva ran away the r is talking about a gaslin and the and the sa is talking about a malva two different stories what's this middle case you improve the it says we are talking about and it says this is our question the improvements from aov that sells this field do you pay it or not it says over here you do have to pay the improvements where from like if it's just simple a gun of go has to give back the field and the one that was NS out the one that the field was stol from has to take the field back that's impossible a Goin can never recoup anything must say it's talking about our story The he stole a field he sold it to somebody else our story that somebody else went and then made improvements so you see from here that the ni the one that I'm sorry the one that bought the field does have to pay for improvements once you're fixing up this then you can't ask any questions froma that's fixed up you you answered that it's talking about that he sold it to somebody else then tell me that's talking about I think we should go another minute here because otherwise it's the middle of the story um no okay we'll stop over here raai have a wonderful day m