Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 84 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good [Music] morning once in a while you get a real real good email and this one I received at least a week ago maybe two weeks ago asking that I should read it today it was uh an emotional email dear rabie Stans I have a story for my father Moz was an avid fan of yes and listen to them every day here's a picture of him I remember him very very clearly I to have my parents live with me so every dayas I heard good morning I actually heard it multiple times a day each time my father loged to hear the r review the D we live in woodmar and my father's so excited to meet the RO at SCH at SCH by rabag and each time there was a SE in bar Park in Flatbush my father was nter on at the age of 76 six after battling leukemia each day I sat with him in the hospital trying to engage him in some conversation get him to smile at random thoughts or story of his Grand great great grandchildren even putting on da for him when he was no longer able to listen for himself my daughter is witnessed to the events which I'm about to relay over one day when he's not responsive to anyone or anything I started putting on the recording my daughter told him zi we're putting on relli good morning rabai and my father continued ah we looked at each other in this belief my father had not spoken a word all week cannot distinguish who is with him but is knew the da which played such an important role in his life and somehow pushed through with the word ah which we heard every day how I miss hearing those words my father's birthday is and I would like to sponsor the day of learning his of his if possible I'd also appreciate the story being read so that anyone out there who just starting the D will fully understand the impact learning has to the as it did to my father should also know that as a result of my father's learning two of my sons took on learning the da and it continues Z Goldstein it's a beautiful email Bo said today's tuat I want to show you something beautiful in Middle of Gaza and Kan yunas in a house of a probably a terrorist once upon a time I don't know if we have volume there still issue with the volume but the point is that uh they celebrated and the they made a Tish Tu Tish in Middle ofun all right um it's a whole thing he's shooing here he's talking to the have little stuff on the wall that they do okay put he puts on his status all the time to get people to come back to the D so somebody came back and says that day I did yesterday's da was amazing to start again he restarted B mentioned about going three days without learning yesterday I thought about myself thanks for the status iron K dear I started a while ago with 8 minute but forgot about it for a while and only had joined the she for the first time starting my life around uh for the first time in my life starting around uh to be ironic I made it my New Year's resolution to learn more I learn every day now as I commute from New Jersey to the Bronx and back every day watching the English year and sometimes theit as for have the time but because my Commuter so long I can catch up if I miss a day for the first time ever I'm learning every day by choice it makes me more active and happy in my in a way I never was now you say this all the time but I want you to know how important it is that you continue to repeat it because it gives me so no doubt it does to others when you say there are just people out there who want to learn but only need that little push all I can think of is that if this was true for me there must be at least a million more YouTube subscribers out there for you the point says it is always there I needed another push I feel lucky that my friend had shared mdy with me I'm a new person because of this of his push also when you say things like you should do a seeum even if you're not 100% sure you really deserve to these are things we also need to hear because they are all things that make learning TI even more exciting you have such accessibility that someone like me who never appreciate and learning is intense and a tradition as beautiful as a d Unthinkable and I'm so grateful this happened to me Unthinkable and I'm grateful I'm so grateful this happened to me I decided to make this simple but permanent changed to to my WhatsApp status just one person learns more because of it maybe riosa if you don't mind putting in that status I think I forgot to put it in here thank you RI for your incredible share and everyone who makes it all happen keep it up because you are saving liveson kbal West Orange New Jersey yii de re I tried all day and finally got someone to sign up for the next M but he's a bit of an amarit and here's a picture you got this guy to sign up and finally our organization endorses from chaplain into the US military talking about other part defense met you many times most recently at the first annual MD exza in Connecticut pictured our army chaplain D edert from Lakewood and iron Cohen from Waterberry Connecticut training to be majors in South Carolina and of course there you are in the background as a keep up with the da recently they were deployed in Kuwait Iraq Poland you get to travel with them everywhere with blessings respectively RAB fjd yes International Dean US Department of Defense military chapy endorser beautiful we learned to in Kuwait not only in Gaza it's gal the of the mon sponsored by Anonymous from Lakewood last day huh that would be great to go to give AER everybody goes to we gotta go the last day for teaching I just heard I have to speak to my very very good friend LS colum I didn't have a chance to speak to him I heard it late at night and it was already too late to speak to him his son was in the unit that lost the 21 and he just walked out of the building and his life was saved but he had to go back in grab all his friends that were no longer with us so they're all very very shooking up you know lisis Cole sponsored the space mer etc etc okay um in memory of from an in Manchester who joined the she at the beginning our fathers C GR on his 25th yard side pre-depression orphan to decorated World War II veteran to family patriarch together with his wife toid he raised Generations by example by his children grandchilden great grandchildren who follow mdy by Goldstein the beautiful Emil joking up the picture remember him here remember okay shom Rand I don't know where he is he fell off the face of the Earth shom Rand here he is ra having major surgery in memory of my father the day of his 12th in the art of the mon Anonymous for the for easy child birth for his daughter and a healthy baby Bo say here we are he's on the H Morty rby in the where is he somewhere I don't know is there volume today oh Morty for okay we got to go look at this said take a look at this it's a little deceiving 90% of the time when you have a like this it means stor in a today means that it's very easy a lot of words very little rash but there's a a whole bunch ofas if a person with a hole in his heart a literal hole in his heart the doctor say he can't live for more than a year he's a trally a tra and he kills a human being he's a killer does he get Misa or not could you testify that you saw that he killed somebody and therefore is he yes or no and of course no is going like this of course he's is that what you think to yourself you're wrong what he's a guy no but for a different reason because he's not a person that you could do you can't you need it it's not a no but I I caught your hand in the corner of my eye I saw you go like he's going to die anyway it's not a free pass he's gonna he's goingon to get good question but it's not a it's not a let let argue with thear what do you ARG you know what split up split up I want I need I need kamansi sitting between you guys having a he's going like this AR you argu for him you against you all okay so we're we're middle of a suya everybody everybody uh knows this this is just something you could ask a little kid in there if somebody pokes out somebody's else eyes out do you take his eyes out obviously not we don't do an eye for an eye but the Tor says I for an I so we know that that's not the case but how do we know that so in other words what is where do you see it in the T we know because from day one since M came off of SII people cause damage to their friends unfortunately there's hands missing legs cut off we never cut off anybody's arm or leg how do we know so yesterday we brought two sources and discussed why we need two but here's just and then just like a you pay money so to a human being then we had another possibil we had a nice try all the way at the end and we didn't go through it that how a it's not some eyes are worth more than others and the said you see that also by sometimes you kill a person that's has more value than you less value than you so it's not exactly instead of okay so the and now we're going to try another eight times some of them are a little better than others some of them are completely pushed off different sources perhaps in the to that you could see this in the to we know again we have a we know that this is was given from generation to generation from that we don't take an eye for an eye but where do you see it in the another source perhaps we're holding like six lines from the top of and we're gonna have to put on the like speed up a little bit okay so put your finger in and let's go for a ride I say it means monetary compensation not eye for an eye maybe it means the ey the real eye I'll prove it to you because what if a person is already blind so how you going to punish him you have a guy that has an Ute and he's going to cut off somebody's foot how are you going to punish him he's crippled already and he caused another person to be crippled how could you do an eye for an eye a leg for a leg so what are you gonna say he should pay in that case okay everybody gets an eye for an eye but this guy that doesn't have eyes to begin with he should pay cash that's impossible everybody gets the same punishment one one ruling for the whole that's not a great R and therefore must be it's cash not a KN for says in other words saying you're right there is one punishment and the punishment is an eye for an eye if a person doesn't have eyes he goes Scot free why because there's no other punishment there's one punishment for all of Cl Israel an eye for an eye there's not one punishment in ey for an eye and the other guy gets cash it's one punishment if you don't have eyes you don't have eyes so you go Scout free and I'll prove it to you so that's the case that we discussed here's a TR beautiful tra the guy has a hole in his heart from a bullet tra the doctor say he's not going to live He's not going to survive more than a year this traa guy went ahead and this aam you see the aam on the bottom they K they say he killed him come another two and say you guys are liars you're with us on a crew somewhere so what's the is that the guy in red since the guy in red cannot be put to death their their is not good why because they cannot be musam you can't you cannot kill the two aam even if they're Liars why because they wanted to kill a Traer and a trafer doesn't die you can't put him to death since you can't put the red guy to death so there is not a type of that could that that's in the par of you can't say put them to death oh so sometimes you can't do it sometimes you could so you see what yeah correct I'm saying it's a type of it's the type of a I just brought the whole case of yeah even by itself you're just saying things that the would say he'll be back soon a guy that has a hole in his heart or any sort of TR saus is missing I don't know what that killed a regular person might have you can't do anything to them so therefore you don't have it's not it's not one rule oh so you see sometimes if a person it's impossible to kill him you don't kill him you kill everybody else in where you could do you do the the punish that's not a great R the let's try another one again what is the source in where do you see it hinted in the T that it's not an eye for an eye it's really money you pay if you poke somebody's eye out let's go to the what it's a good thing I started off to share like that maybe you'll remember it but you see you can learn from he's doing nowar is right it's amazing that's how it is what oh that's all I want to hear sometimes we just don't understand it but it's always right whoa I don't know what happened there the seven went to the wrong place okay you see all the way in the bottom in the famous so we had here he corroborated this in you say right means money he gave a nice check a gooda so says the it says the says it means money says that can't be I'll prove it to you from that in that same the few words before that in green over is also in Cena what it's talking about one guy gave another guy a bunch of cash and and caus him damage through the cash like what what's going on here obviously know in this case doesn't mean money no maybe does they had lookest we'll zoom in into test these are all the same right the same bunch of a person causes damage to his friend what he wanted to do that's what we'll do back to him and then it says it says you see the red red says can so why does it have to repeat itself in because it's extra in this particular case means money so so then why do you need the green words the extra three words all the way at the end of I get it to tell me he's talking about cash but what's the already says that in I did this is I think I have to ask the the the ask and the beler it seems a little bit different than usual usually we use this kind of the reason why the mishna said these extra words is to match the ra to say that words in a p are matching to have a flow that's interesting okay I don't remember me personally again it could be I could be we learned it three days ago and I don't remember I'm just saying maybe rememb such a concept matching words things should flow in a it's I think it's interesting another one another try the famous we just spoke about it h that the T says that if you try to if you lie if we find that you're lying you testified and you're a liar you were actually with somebody else at the same time that you testified you testified on Sunday at 12:00 you saw somebody kill someone and then two other Witnesses said no you on a cruise ship on Sunday 12:00 what happens to the person that lied they kill him Cas also came what you want to cause damage to the other you want it to cost him $100 you're going to pay $100 if you're a liar you wanted to take his life we're going to take your life so in that par says y here y y with the comments not Y what what do you usually give when you go to store you're giving cash from hand to hand that gives you back change that's a thing that goes from here here's a little hint in the you pay cash not eye for an eye so so how do you the next words reg what he he gave you don't give cash with the foot so then why did say reg Bal by the way so all these Dres not all but they're very similar to each other Concepts that we already had that's where we could fly through them we just had this idea a second ago right before in the whole thing famous you should do to him like he wanted to do to his friend this this false witness if you hold that it means literally chop off his hand it already says whatever he wanted to do money cash hand life everything what he wanted to do that's what you did to him so why does it have to specify is com to tell us this hint that you pay cash you don't take a real hand so oh same thing as we said before we have nothing to learn from it but it flows well with everything else another another source I gotta tell you the story uh it's a it's a story from from the meaning before the May 1500 years ago I don't know how long ago something like that no 1,200 years ago he's from the the big and he writes this story he says that uh very interesting story there's a extremely wealthy individual that had two sons and he died and he left over a tremendous inheritance including the inheritance was a sa written by Ezra and both of the boys really wanted the sa they they were willing to give up all the money in the yusha and take each one so they made a raffle they made a girl and one of the boys won one of the sons won the what you know this one no no no okay coming up with solutions for them like yeah why they just cut which way this way or this way so so one one of the kids won the raffle he got the sa to he's extremely happy there's a guy in the neighborhood that so was going on he says what these M he was a mmer he wasar he says these guy this guy gave up millions of of gold in this for for makes no sense he went in middle of the night took out thees and says in the he took the instead of you should worship he cut out the and he put in the AL that what e means should go means to worship he ruined he he changed the meaning of the word in aparis anyways they get to that par everybody's reading from the they get over there in and all of a this the son was extremely he he couldn't believe it he's like how's it possible Ezra wrote Al instead of this this not this not even Ezra and he he lost it he had a he lost all the money and now he lost his he he very depressed anyways his his father came to him in a dream and told him don't worry about it this is Ezra saer so and so did it and in fact Ezra saer himself is going to come in and repair the sa this is this not a like a story written by so he says but [Laughter] go nice he said me very nice okay no but again it could be like me wrote the story about the like we we didn't see him right okay fine so the bottom line is the father said go to that the sh where this guy uh took out the and you'll find the over there so he went there and he found a human eyeball under the table as the guy lost his eye the guy that took it because of the that he took out anyway we're talking about I had to tell you the story because there's no other stories today says so the says like this an ey for ey a soul for a soul but that means if a person takes that eye he loses an eye person takes a person's life he loses his life but it doesn't make any sense that a person should lose his eye and his NE and his body at the same time but he says it means literally take the guy's eye out but what you do sometimes possible you not get guy's eye out he dies on the spot from shock from blood loss I don't know what but the to wouldn't tell you that the T says just as I How Could You assure me that every time you take a person's eye out he's not going to lose his life so obviously the T didn't mean a literal lie it means cash that's what he says what do you mean maybe send to a doctor and the doctor sees whether or not he could withstand such a thing and if in fact the doctor said it's okay sign them off and then the guy loses his life he might okay no no at least he got to he got to he got to go like and we have a it says by malus do you got to assess each individual the guy's 95 years old you're going to give him 39 malus he'll probably die after one malus two malus the doctor has to give him a a test a fit test so what if the doctor you know was not in the mood looked at him didn't even take his blood pressure nothing and sign them off and then they start giving him malus and the guy dies Potter the the B is Potter it's not their fault they they got us he the guy was signed off so over here also the guy was signed off that we could remove his eye remove his eye and he died no no that's not a that didn't mean that okay so now we have to move on to another here's the we're going to talk about this later maybe tomorrow that a burn for a burn a wound for a wound that what that when a person even though we said that you have to pay for the arm the arm is valued in the slave market $100,000 you pay $100,000 but in addition to that you also have to pay s the pain if it means that you that you have to do exactly what they do to you what you did to the other person so they you remove this guy's arm they're going to remove your arm have why should the guy that caused the damage have to pay for pain he's getting paid what is he getting paid he's getting paid pain the to says do to him what he did to the other guy so he made the other guy lose arm you make him lose arm that guy has pain you have pain you're paying through your pain says the but sometimes it's not equal pain that's not a great R so obviously it can't be literal it means money so no I could also say it's literal the people that are very very sensitive to pain they have 100 pain from a missing arm lanic and the guy that did the damage he's a you know he's a tough guy he never takes a pain medication he's he likes pain doesn't bother him what uh I hear I hear but let me just explain this the guy that his arm was removed initially he has 100 pain the guy that removed his arm has 50 pain so then the Torah is not saying the tah the Tor is not uh the Tor say you have to pay for pain you didn't pay for pain you only paid 50 not 100 pain so the difference between the 50 and the 100 that you paying cash you're asking it's not I hear no no this is and everything fine what's your name from Lauren not the guy that's Bitz where's that guy I haven't seen that guy and I didn't see you at his b okay sh what do you [Music] say yeah but the gamar said before what he's asking thear said before you can't mix two types you can't mix death and money this and money money seems like a different type of taking off money or taking off arm cuses person okay right here okay we'll have to we'll have to think about it he's saying it it fills in that pain okay again famous RAB it's a double what's this double again same we had a secondo so it's easy it's to say that even though you're paying for the arm you have to pay for medical bills and if you mean it means that you got to take off the guy's arm just like this guy needs to be healed by a doctor the the guy that caused the initial damage he's also going to the doctor so that's his payment that he has to go to doctors and pay for his own doctors one guyy is 95 years old so it takes him a very very long time to heal so she has to go to many many doctors that cost a lot a lot of money this guy went to doctor once so he only paid for one doctor bill the the the the guy that he caused the damage to had to pay for 10 doctor bills you have to pay nine doctor bills the difference so just a regular here we go here's where you see in the to that you pay money and not the uh actual limb why because it says by by us but also says by but we all know that by a bow it's money why you learning this from yeah we're holding by the wide lines already five lines down sorry so I skipped learn from a human being just like a human being we take his life so if you took somebody's limb we should take your limb the life of the had this yesterday it's better to go from and don't learn damages from Death it's better to learn from another human being not from an animal it out okay so in fact we do learn right here's the just to go back for a second we're not we're going to take out the bottom we're going to insert this this is by a person is a woman has to pay 50 so does use the word over there and it's a human being it's a woman and it's damages okay so you see that it's money and not [Music] literal comes famous we discussed him yesterday right was it means literal a literal lie as show me one case in the history of Judaism that they ever took somebody's eye that they ever took somebody's finger they ever took we know it's not it's impossible so what are you saying doesn't hold like that no no no of course he didn't mean literal it just means you don't bring him to the slave market so if you don't bring him the slave markeet and evaluating based on a slave based on a free human being by the way if you try to go on uh Ai and try to create a image with with a slave it doesn't even exist it's gone there's no there's no such thing slave it's AER can't even talk about it can't even depict it so I think I tried it just didn't work for me maybe I said the wrong thing okay so this is a tremendous think about it a 20-year-old pilot in the the Air Force he knocked out a 95 year old man's eye the 95y old man could only see 3 feet in front of him six cataract surgeries I don't know the whole thing can barely see that's it the pilot has the best eyes so when the pilot knocks out the old man's eye how much does he have to pay him $100,000 for old man's eye or 10 million dollars for Pilot's eye which one is it you never think this but thear says it goes based on the guy that causes the damage it's based on the pilot not on the guy that's damaged you don't pay him it's a that's what is trying to say we had it right says yeah but that's not that that's the ER that's like a one that's a one it's a very specific thing each you can't say every so you tell me all males in the world are exactly the same Michael Jordan and this guy are work the same it doesn't work like that some human beings are worth more they're physically stronger larger bigger they're going to live longer ask any accountant ask any insurance company different human beings have different that actually the the what you're talking about is a very it's a specific list every baby's worth this every woman is worth that every man is worth that that's you can't you can't base people like that and how you going to evaluate an arm that's a whole human being how you going to terrible story there's a donkey the kid was playing with the donkey put his hand in the donkey's mouth and the donkey bit down gone SOA wasn't exactly sure what happened he thought that it means the donkey's driver whatever he thought so he says okay you got to give here all the five things they have to do have to pay for for for medical bills for all the pain for The Bu says T so it must be that this kid is old already it's not a two-year-old or a one-year-old talking about a kid that gets embarrassed that could be embarrassed [Music] okay what about the five I wasn't talking about the obvious obvious is the damage in addition to the damage everybody pays damage I'm talking about in addition to the damage it's it's only a donkey it's not true when your animal causes damage you don't pay the five things you only pay one damage you're right go evaluate you have to evaluate based on a slave you can't just okay evaluate him you're right take him to the slave market and go ahead here we have a picture take him to the slave market and figure out how much he's worth compared to Slaves the reason why we have this pictures for the next line the father says not my son my son is not going to go to slave market start measuring himself up compared to other slaves no not my son you could gain $100,000 for the arm not not not my son you're rooting it for the kid don't worry about it I'll pay my son whatever damage it is I'll take care of it my son will not go through that torture of going to a slave market okay I'll tell you but you see over here you parents cannot take away from the kids without good reason if you do you have to pay them yeah whatever the case is you think about the case but just because he's your kid he's not your possession so you can't say oh I don't want my kid to to benefit this and this it's not good for him too bad on you maybe he wants $20,000 $100,000 and if yeah you have to pay for it I will tell you a dollar there was a bull that chopped off a kid head treat him like a slave figure out how much his hand is worth we're in Iraq we're in B you can't do this yeah well not much caniz we just don't have the best then to to we don't have anybody that has here in bble that could do this no what I want you to do is evaluate his arm and then if this kid goes one day and grabs something from the guy that caus him the damage we won't take it away from him but we have to know how much it is now if you don't look in the art scroll there's a trick here it says let's say just if you read it in Hebrew what would that mean to you that a an axe cause damage to a human being says rash know it's the opposite but other means the human being caused damage to the axe so here just uh it's a little confusing for me at least the when the the B it's very simple when the when the sh was damaged you see the human being on the right gave a punch to the Shar or one sh hit another sh when flying up then we could take care of this in B but when the damage was CA a human being here on the right the guy gets tossed into the air both times it's a human being that got damaged either by a bull or by another then we don't take care of this in bubble sorry that cause damage to a human being as what's the difference between a human being that gets damag and an animal gets damage because no good in B that has have real not uh you know some guy took a test I'm not I'm not no I'm not making fun my son-in-law got from Rab burit in the Jerusalem call it's a very big thing they work years on it but it's not the we're talkinging about for the generation to generation that they don't have this so for the same reason so how can you deal with Bulls so what if if a bull damag another bull but there's Noz sponsored by Greg ha success and safe return of our and hostages for of we're doing the the work of of the we're doing sent the people to take care of it you're not going to stop loans in people need to borrow money so you got to do some sort of B even though they don't have authority so too they don't even though they don't have authority they have Authority for bulls that damage human beings and Bulls all the mother okay so let them do it for for for human beings that were damaged comes up with another when we know what we're dealing with how much money we're talking about then thez and could deal with it otherwise thez doesn't deal with it I don't know how much bull is worth go to the marketplace for for axin oh so you go to the marketplace and figure out how much damage you cause the bull so go to the slave market and figure out how much a human being is worth say same something that's exact the double payment the four and five are exact amounts let deal with it when it comes to that's we're not going to deal with it even in B but never less when a human being hurts another human being a car accident whatever it is it's monetary loss Letz Do their jobz and take care of something that is very common but that a human being hurts another human being says somebody will walk over another guy and punch him in the face very rear as this is even you saying and that look at this one andash says what's in this case and the is saying it's a very common thing that what that the the damage that's caused that she lost her and this and and Rashi says that busha is not aass how do I know bu is not AAS there's not a monetary loss here but what we said that it's all dependent on the person that caused it how great he is and the person that got it how great he is so you see that it's a monetary thing you're right when it comes to we do deal with this in B think about it is 200 when somebody embarrasses somebody else you give him double auba you could live off auba for a whole year it's a lot of money 400 Z took for in B so yeah thez in B deals with we don't hold like [Music] that what should I do should I should I take care of a case that that that somebody's claiming that he was very embarrassed you want to you want to deal with but it's not a real K like we said but it's like a in terms of we don't deal with it in b okay so let's take those two theor and put them together for there's two there's two what's the word I'm looking for two conditions thank you two conditions first of all has to be very common second of all there has to be a monetary loss and that will explain everything if it only has one out the two we don't deal with it in in other words human being that hits another human being this is obviously a very big monetary loss but since it's missing the other component it's not common since not common we don't do it deal with it even though it's common you can't say I lost money from it my face turned red but I didn't lose any money therefore I also don't deal with it in B when one a it's another axe we deal with it in says that we don't deal with it and we have to understand if a bull hit a human being why you talking about that case what's more common human being hitting a human being or a bull hitting a human being rash says a human being hitting another human being is more common therefore say the more common case b even though it's much more common we still don't deal with it in B so talking about a bull the damage is another bull nevertheless we don't deal with it in so why why do you say rather that we do deal with it so this is the that we have to remember is monetary damage or is it aass huh what do we say remember that's how we pass it is we go with the half of of a is considered a therefore when we're dealing with a in B we can't deal with it because it's a canas but when it's a m when it already gour somebody three times we do deal with it as how do you ever get to a situation where a bull is a m every time that he Gore somebody a and we don't deal with the time we don't deal withas so you'll never get the situation of a bull being a three time offender a very very rare case where there was a terrible bulling in and they went to bz three times he killed three human beings and then they shipped him off to B says the the only time meat that comes bulls that come from or vice versa are in vacuum packs they the slice up ready to eat you don't ship a whole giant Bull from one country to another country says you're right and we said if it's very rear we don't deal with it from they came they used to visit and they came they visited bble and they saw what happened and they said okay he's a says that had they happen to see a bull gore three times extremely rare we don't deal with it in B if it's very rare as we learned when it comes to uh a damage that's caused by an animal that the animal enjoys he benefits he eats or I got to show you this video because just to remind you because this is what Raji talks about here in our when a when a when a bull is scratching his back so Sayes Rashi maybe scratch his back on another bull that's how he call the damage to the bull cuz he was itching and he scratched his bag and he threw him off a cliff and he killed him so that's Shen because he was enjoying himself when he did it Ken is when he tries to hurt another bull he's trying to enjoy himself how do you have regal regal means he's just walking normally down the street and he pushed the the bull off a bridge in that case they considered a in and you deal with it says the what's you burnt your friend with a with a hot iron or with a nail says if a person causes damage to somebody else on his fingernail you don't see it but it hurts a lot who's the T that says you have to pay for this and it goes according to check out this P it makes no sense what's going on here the P starts over with the word burn towards says the word says re the word is in the beginning okay very good yeah I see that makes no sense why would say that the word is in the beginning of the when it's not what's going on here says no the word alone would mean where it doesn't have a wound it's just a burn without a wound and the Torah says no at the end if it has a wound then you pay for this for the burn if not not the opposite means with so then why have to repeat itself says says the gor our goes like which is a pel PL rebi who wrote the mishna wrote the mishna according to the one that argues on him not according to according to what that even when there's no visible damage it was just a lot of pain you pay for that re holds he don't pay for it do and is gonna ask tomorrow that it makes no sense it should be the opposite have a wonderful day