Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 41 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Applause] [Music] good morning R Bo we will uh go short on these here's somebody Spotify he's the top two fan and Spotify in general there's 15,000 minutes on Spotify and I uploaded 2,000 have us as their top 10 on Spotify because there a lot of people watch on Spotify you think it's only YouTube only old no there's other places I don't know if this yeah Spotify has video this Rai is Mitzvah of mikar the son ofar who gave us a ter goldo he's the owner of ATA which happens to be one of my favorite pictures of mdy shows about 1500 people at that sheer so I don't know if he wants the whole world to know about his Mitzvah what time it is and where but okay I need to announce the people who have given a dollar a day that was in Brooklyn ter golden Brooklyn Bar Park Gregory kav gives a dollar a day Sam Glock Micha Nan Natan cenim doz or doz a riser is a dollar day now I do want to tell the about all all the people who since the beginning of Kaneka gave also other amounts sh Kon 8 a month Moi landi I no I see him somewhere else Mo oh that's different than mo mo landi 18 Leo 30 is not a mistake $840 a month it's unbelievable the Miller boys 36 Lawrence Reese 36 AB R 30 y Adler 36 Israel fredman 18 Dr Mark burkson 30 Manel gerich five Hesh Earth 36 AR fish 36 Salomon Simon Jacob is that your gr where is he he's not here Simon Jacob maybe Michael K Shiner 30 Jess Norris 4 Mandy 101 which is huge and even Huger is ruing Harrison a ,000 a month verified Mo platnik and it's not he actually yeah gives a lotd I think he's from Florida $36 from M platnik you don't only have to do a dollar day you could do other amounts there's other ways $100 a day or a month what is this for a year 100 bucks take $100 wow he's inspired inspired thank you so much says Alex Gilden for continuing to set the stand for I have to admit the new intro music to the she is so catchy that's your song I find myself humming it all day long I would like to sign up for a dollar a day but I would be switching up from $20 monthly who do I speak to to change the donation amount Alex gild sponsor for the unity the month another sponsor of the [Music] month all those for the son oh I I I have to go back to that picture it's funny I just realized now the shimmy is in the middle and he writes over there on his name AKA y Schwarz and BR is the son on okay next Eric and jacn land young and suffer should have on the occasion of his 62 yard side happy birthday to my nephew who with courage and with only hashem's help was able to escape after being captured from the clutches of the evil terrorist was internally grateful for's kindness to him and his family I think that might be yeah art of the month is sponsored by that come from supporting Li yesterday there's a person in the room who is this person who sponsors the art of the month and I didn't even know who he was and only after daving was made aware he's uh a very quiet person he's not part he doesn't live in and so you and then we were talking afterward about the 3D he said I want to step it up to help out with the 3D so uh just a a side riddle there's a famous on the tour and called two PR does anybody know where the name comes from I believe this is where it comes from anybody anybody oh very good two people knew gal the famous although I think he means to beish not to let go but we're going to see that the very famous gar today we're holding four lines from the bottom of we learned yesterday a bull who who C who kills someone so the owner has to payer and says in the but a bu that had relations with the human being don't what's the cas if through the relations he killed this woman Mal what's the difference if a if a bull kills a human being with its horn it's killing if it whatever crush the human being it's killing so what's what's the difference you're going to tell me that there was a and there's no this only when you kill a person not if you have relations with a person talking about that there was a but no but they brought the woman to and because of this bull they killed the woman because she was she had relation with an animal thing that he since he caused her death yeah indirect way and it was wasn't his fault but yet an animal killed a human being in a way there's no top that means 40 da into Bama it also means that 40 days ago we're in the hotel in Connecticut I still feel most of us the the dedicated people to MD says that there was both a and here and he ask me what's the difference there's a huge difference says listen to this and it comes out of as we learned what does Karen mean Karen means that a that a bull wanted to cause damage on purpose it's a better to cause damage over here this is more like Shen Shen means that the animal wants to enjoy himself he wants to eat and causes damage says ra unbelievable since the animal's trying to enjoy himself then he's not theer only goes on not on so we have a situation where an animal crushed a baby in the domain of the N because we learned just a little you're only meaning it has to be in the property of the one that was damaged so we're talking about a animal went into somebody's property and crushed the human being to death from doesn't say his answer so you do pay there's no a sh reg and carrot and everybody anal that kills is according to ra because you need to be and this animal was just walking around regling it it was moving it had no idea there's even a baby there so you from According to the bull that's trained to fight in the cisum against human beings against animals he's not and that was a huge that we learned yesterday an animal that kills human being not necessarily is a trait for the you think oh is done with this animal you can't bring as a carbon we learned yesterday it's not it's not a problem this animal was forced to do what it had to do and therefore not and it's as a as a says we have a number of here let's take a look at all these and the person died you must kill the bull it's not just a bull we said it's every animal and you don't eat the meat we're going to see that you know of benefit even from the skin not only the meat what does that mean he's clean and going to see five maybe not all today and done already three times here's the that tells us you have to the witnesses have to be in front of the owner and he was negligent that's now we're talking about the Parish of you pay money does the do we evaluate the person that died or the person that caused the damage the this is to redeem himself and if the bull killed a small child a girl or a boy says if a Bull killed a human being if only pays the time doesn't have to pay both the bull both the and the M the bull they die now let me ask you a question if the who kills a person must die how in the world did he kill three people how did he get to be a m ran huh he ran away and then what he killed again came back and away very good excellent that's one of the eight in thear there's eight and that's one of the ones that sticks new anybody can come up with seven more that doesn't help that's not a m for for because we'll see okay that's another the gar knocks it off all in a row all in a row does that work does that work has to be three different days we said you have to it depends are you that's exactly okay so these kind of thing now imagine you're you have to say think break your how do you come up with eight here eight different also applies if he kills a young child no difference how old a person is you kill the bull there's a difference now if you kill here here's the there's one price for All slaves we don't start evaluating the the guy that owns the bull we don't evaluate the slave he could be the top slave he could be a 95y old slave that's two days to live the doctor said that's it even if he's worth one shek p it's also it's also within that idea whether doesn't matter how much he's worth as the once you kill this bull on the first time that he kills how do you ever get to be a so look at this real quickly so here the eight only four out of the eight stay so one is we'll say about real quickly one shot is that they thought they saw he's about to kill a human being and it the the guy got out of it who almost and almost the understood is enough to make him a more you saw he wants to kill the guy just jumped up he found a string and he's able to get out of it seek means that he actually hit three human beings but they didn't die in the spot their intensive care and eventually they died so he's able to get the three or like Jonathan welcome back Jonathan welcome back welcome back snow not a welcome back he's a guest but so was trying to say this that he killed three animals and since he's a m for Animals M for this can I see in my chart please oh or [Music] three says that's not enough this doesn't make or he killed three people that W weren't going to live anyways out or the the the ones with the X's are no good they're Havas now this is what what you guys were saying that he ran away he killed ran away killed ran away so there and each and each time there was a this one I'm not going to explain who's M meaning there's three we're going to have to see it inside it's a little bit uh in not intense it's just a case there was there was witnesses that said that the ax killed then witnesses witnesses came and said so those Witnesses are gone the first Witnesses but then a third pair of witnesses came and said that the second guys that said it are liars and therefore all the testimony comes into play and you kill and then there the final one is M Bal is that they witnessed to the owner your Bull killed somebody we don't know which bull there's 20 Bulls there afterwards they figured it out but they warned the guy and that's enough for the guy for the bull to die says here we go they said they we witnessed that this bull wanted to kill a human being just people stepped in or whatever it was and they got him out of there I had a little bit of a video maybe yse will put it in for the shear sobody sent me I think it's appropriate even though it's in Pakistan you see an old guy with a walker real video walking down the street and a bull looks at him looks looks looks and all of a sudden from got him good guy goes flying up in the there and lands you don't exactly see the hole you just see the guy's feet a little bit moving so it's it's okay I think the show so this R there was a guy that came to the r and said a a he said I was he said I was almost in a car accident I was like this close to the it like in the last second I got out of it do I have to make a gol so the r told him you go up to the be and you can say the and they you walk back [Music] because is only for somebody that was in a Sak and was saved and not for somebody that was saved from a Sak again go is only for somebody that was in a Sak in a car accident flipping over and he was saved from the car accident but not from somebody that was saved from the Sakana that didn't get into it okay or like the famous this is the famous myo where a guy made a huge huge sud huge and everybody comes and this and they ask the guy why you making such a sud said because my wife she hung up my pants to dry outside no because I was in my pants half hour before she did it that was a okay he almost killed a human being almost is not doesn't count you're not you're not from almost so number two is that there was a real s in other words he critically injured these people but they didn't die so if they're not dead then you can't testify again but then at the end they all they all died he killed three animals and you don't do ska for killing animals but he's a that count just because he's we said a person has different masle he knows how to get away from it so just because you're able to kill a stationary animal cow grazing in the in the grass it doesn't mean that he's able to kill a human being that's walking down the street maybe the is he killed three Idol worshippers so it's interesting some say that a Jew has different masle it's or I don't know maybe they looked different they act different just because they're able to kill doesn't mean they're able to kill so this is very very interesting because we always learn that you kill a human being even if the guy only has one minute to live in terms of the killing a person if he's a he killed a person that's already dead there's a type there's a person that let's say has a a hole in his heart the doctor says he only has a month to live less than 12 months he's a just because he's able to kill people that are very sick or whatever does that mean that he's he's able to kill regular people oh we got to show this he killed and he ran away to the meadow to the swamp oh now it's working wow the new the new switchboard is working you just see the the fine he did this over and over rash rash over here says it's two times killing the third time you have to pay oh so this is very important if I could get there oh these guys are the guys these are the okay so what happened was on the first day a set of came and said that the sh killed another Shar on the second day this based on Rashi on the second day another another set came and said the Shar killed it same set then come a set of AD say so we believe the second set set that the first set was with them on vacation somewhere else it's impossible that they witness what they witnessed and therefore their their their testimony that they W they testified against the bull is flawed and there is no the the bull remains as if he never gour any other person ever zero zero happened okay then on the third day come a set of Adam and say that the bull gourd and say so get rid of them they're called right the ones that are false are Z andab said this is what happens this is very important right over here a third set of AD come and testify that the ones who said that you were with us sonication they're Liars so they're T testimony goes out the original testimony that the bull gored three times comes in there three checks and he becomes a m right then and [Music] there yeah but we want to say that there's three real we what's a case that he's a real M that it happened three times there three testimonies so basically those three testimonies they were thrown out and they were put back in ask what's the point of bringing Witnesses if it's to say that we saw a pattern in this bull and here it is it happened on Sunday it happened on Monday happen on okay so you accomplish what you need to accomplish we had the already if the fact that the Tor says you have to you have to say testimony about the owner it's to to tell the owner watch your bull so you didn't gain anything you told him to watch watches Bull in one shot you told him three times in one minute cuz all three original Witnesses became Witnesses in one minute when the third group of witnesses the third pair of witnesses come and testify that all the the are false then they all fly out the window in one testimony and all the original pairs they become reinstated in one minute and that's not enough time for the guy to watch his animal you have to give him three opportunities you have to tell him on Sunday your animal's bad he he failed a Monday failed three strikes that's not you can't do three strikes in one shot a retroactive three stri strikes don't work why not you're putting witness is you warn the first time but it was false what you warned him then was bad it wasn't good now making it good but he didn't know he wasn't careful on Sunday there's a pair of ad that said you're your your bull is a bad guy then the the Adam came and said he's not a bad guy so he went to sleep he stopped watching him based on the testimony of those aam he didn't watch now on Tuesday you're saying that oh those guys that said that IM they're false okay you reinstated but he didn't have a chance to be to watch his bull properly now no so then then it doesn't work this case doesn't work it's not a real mood not a real mood it's already 8:00 but if it's to make the guy watch his bull I didn't know that he's a bad bull no the third pair is testifying that he was there it's not he he can't say I didn't know you did know and there was witnesses that that said it killed but we got rid of those Witnesses but you can't play this game that you didn't know that your bull is a bad guy you were standing there the entire time every single time but it's interesting because you're you're taking two things it's not enough that you know if I could prove that you knew that your bull gored three times that's not enough to make you a mood you need that that that the witnesses saw it three times over here the witnesses came into effect retroactive that's good enough if you combine it with the fact that you knew so it's like you know what I'm saying you're dancing here in sort of it's interesting bar we're talk they testified against the owner but not against the bull the guy owns a ranch he owns thousands of bulls what is he supposed to do you have you have this this bull somewhere they're warning listen you have a bad guy in there now you have to step it up and he didn't so at then when they pointed out the bull that bull becomes a m right away we learned in the Mna whether it's a or you have to kill the animal this if you learn K with us it's word for word in K three quarters of now word for word here we go it's likea sh told me that basically sh is only 50% of what we really have it's it's there's a lot of repetition I don't have to ask the Bells says it says in the that you have to kill the animal so what happens when you throw a when you when you Stone an animal that's not so it's a it's also to eat have to repeat itself and say don't eat the flesh is to teach you that if you did properly the right everything after the said it you have to put it to death you're still not allowed to eat it asking how do you know I can't benefit can't sell to I don't know what use it as soap use the the hide we'll see in a second time what do you see from clean like a person says the guy cleaned out they wiped him out wiped him out he has nothing left in other words this is nothing nothing he's cleaned out and he can't benefit from it who told you that they did it after perhaps it's what are you gon to do with these words if you Stone him then you're not allow to have all like says because when the Torah tells us by you should go give it to God over there but any other time the T says don't eat that means you're not have enough from it either you sell it to go you give it to a so how do you know that even after that's okay you're right if we're going to learn from the the words over here we're not learning this from the word we're learning it from right if you're going to Stone it that means you can't eat it so if you're going to tell me that the word comes to teach us they not to benefit from it that's not how you say in Hebrew ores don't benefit cuz eating I already told you can't eat it from s so then why does the use word the word don't eat when it's not trying to tell you don't eat the t is trying to tell you don't benefit so there's other words for benefit whatever the word is why do you need the extra two words even though made it says very interesting back in the day they used to use a very very sharp Stone to do so maybe when you do with a stone so it's like stoning an animal sort of you're using a stone to kill it then it's have offer everything because you treated it like so but maybe if you used knife it's look what the Torah says over here doesn't say anything about a knife do say anything about a stone it's all good the Turning of The Da sponsored by my holy nephew B mayor Ben Zev David the son of Jen Robert and Jen early and also another sponsor turning for the same I do want to remind we're doing a push on Kana today we'll focus on the monthlies any denomination monthlies uh it adds up tremendous amount that helps us do all our programming and everything Els oh I just want to point this out real quickly that when the go from using a stone like used a stone for and they also used to a knife when did they stop so the prea the prea the preer brings and brings this also he says I couldn't find the pre's Mish but the pre says in the Mish that when fought with goas very good when he fought with goas and he threw the stone at goas so the stone asked the metal that it to let it penetrate Gia's head and the the metal made room and from that day on clol stopped using stones to give cover to the metal and started using uh knives for and mil now as St to connect to Kan very interesting that goas f forward on his head why so that won't have to walk that many feet he's a very large human being so let him walk a couple extra feet why what's the big deal so the answer is because anytime that does a nest that's completely not necessary like in that time so was young and strong could have walked another 10 feet when does that he shows his love to that person or to the Kel and the same thing we found he sold didn't have to sell him to to those with with perfume but he did was unnecessary Nest but the show hey I'm with you I'm Kan also Kana we we're permitted to light the with t oil so this Nest it was unnecessary Nest unnecessary Nest shows the love of and we learn if you I found this this is so interesting because in that brings this I went to and here it was the rudimentary I I didn't even use the right font I was doing everything myself over there the box is not even full I didn't know what I was doing but okay it worked then this is a magel the M says the different things that you sh with a Magle is a sickle the the top right corner mag here's there's a stone on the left side here here it is now that we know both what we do it comes to say not to benefit from the here because the Torah says look what it says sorry it's meat doesn't talk about the hide so I think hide maybe is M welcome back also I forgot to mention your name Le so see from that also includes the come on we learned before different how do they know this s the word s what's in addition to the meat the doesn't learn every time I say this I have to say that a big huge our neighborhood RAB p and he wrote a two large volumes that all the s in the T every time it says s he gives you the what could you add you have to fear there is no there only there's only one so what else can you add to that he said I'm I'm done I'm not ding any that proves that all my ESS are false what about all the just like I got to say these so too I get for being truthful and saying I'm I'm done so first of all this this is the name of the saer D and P but you see from here very interesting you get he says Ah it's false it's you can't D us he gets for ding falsely cuz that's what T is and it's it's a it's a it's a good for people do a lot of people say I do da and I don't remember anything I don't retain anything if you're if you're learning falsely and it counts so certainly it counts if you're learning the right thing just you don't remember it huh yeah exactly yeah yeah on the same on the same that you have to fear in other words because of because so by the way it says in this week's Parish by it says he tells his brother same thing and perhaps what he meant is I fear you also because you tell me I don't know maybe as should we go V we have to go V we have to hold on there's a there's a boo boo here we started very very late because of the new if you look up there there's a I think it was $10,000 that that box over there with all the new wires brand new they put it together and Dave and Gary work very hard it's going to go smooth from here but says amazing that if you have a the doesn't pay half of the what what are you saying of course you can't pay for why where do you get the money for the T from itself so you Stone the T and then what it's dead it's about so you can't take it and pay with it so of course doesn't pay so he says this is how you view me what do you think I'm stupid they say in English Hebrew they say you know who I am my grandfather a lot of people told me this my grandfather was a bigin you think I'm look at me you ever heard that L big so I don't what you're saying yeah okay anyway I guess this used to be very what do you think I didn't think about what you said okay finish I guess we'll have to stop here but I'll just I'll explain it we'll just say it stay a few lines hold on [Music] hold on let me just finish this line what happened was this animal is not is not the animal was a and maybe you should pay ker but you don't have to kill the animal why because you don't have real a you need a in order to kill the animal but you would have to pay to to to do chuva and that will start we we'll continue tomorrow go back a little bit have a wonderful [Music] day and we'll do after [Music] chakas